KES
ravinder singh · 15 Apr 2004
Guru pyari sadh sangat jee
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh ||
Please give ur views on the importance of KES and Why guru sahib asked us to keep the KES as such.
and why do we cut Nails if we need to be sabat soorat.
Bhul chuk di khima ...
DAS moorakh hai ... chhamaa karna ...
[%sig%]
Re: KES
singhsation · 18 Apr 2004
Then why doesn't it hurt when people cut their hair? If cutting the living part of the nail hurts, then shouldn't cutting the living part of hair hurt too? No offense meant, but the logic is flawed. Further rationalization can be made as to the distinctions between hair and nails but, in my opinion, such distinctions would still fall short of any scientific conclusiveness on why we cut nails and not hair.
I don't see why we need a scientific explanation for keeping kes - Guru ji commanded us to keep our kes and that is the bottom line. If scientific reasons existed, would it add greater weight to Guru ji's word? Does Guru ji now need science to convince his Sikhs to follow his commands? If science contradicts the practicality of Guru ji's hukums, does that mean we should reject those hukums? Of course not.
I've mentioned this elsewhere, but when you use science to back up your faith, that same science can be used to tear down the arguments you make and thus cast a shadow over your faith.
-daas
p.s. I don't mean to single out your comments but only use them as an example of arguments to avoid - using science to back up your faith is a huge trap that is easy to fall into when arguing with someone who is questioning your faith or belief system.
Waheguru wrote:
> Hair is living, It changes colour from the root, when hair
> dies, its falls out. Nails hence are living too, where they
> die, they grow off the living nail and become the tip, which is
> cut. Nails cant naturally fall off. If u cut the living part of
> your nail, you will feel the pain.
[%sig%]
Re: KES
singhsation · 19 Apr 2004
Mkhalsa -
Have a read through my post again - I think you've completely missed the point. Either that, or you just read the first line and responded without reading the rest of what I wrote. So before you go on to tell me my logic is flawed, it would be a smart idea to understand the point of the post and the context in which I wrote what I did.
If someone is going to use scientific reasoning to try and explain the difference between cutting hair and nails, then you cannot throw in "spiritual awareness" as a variable to consider.
This is one of the reasons I'm not a big fan of relying on science to prove our beliefs - our beliefs are what they are and scientific backing of our beliefs is of only secondary importance.
daas
Re: KES
Mohan Singh · 19 Apr 2004
I read that there are other organisms which have appendages which dont have nerves but are still living.
Personally I do not need to justify keeping Kesh to myself but when others ask I say it is Gods Hukam.
Waheguru Ji Ki Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: KES
Guldeep Singh · 19 Apr 2004
Singhsation Ji ...very well said
>>our beliefs are what they are and scientific backing of our beliefs is of only secondary importance.<<
Guru Angad Dev ji's message when he was Bhai Lehna Ji was simple. Follow the Guru's Hukam Period. When Guru Nanak Sahib ji threw the bowl in the mud. Bhai Lehna Ji didn't ask why but just did what the Guru asked and retrieved it.
Where there is Love and Faith science and explanations take a back seat.
Bhul Chuk Maaf
Re: KES
jumunjeeeeeeeeee!!!!!!!!!!!!!! · 21 Apr 2004
I've noticed that my concentration is an iota better when my kes is up in a joora than when its all over the place.