Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Interesting Question

Interesting Question

Singh · 14 Apr 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fetah Gurbani makes it clear that there is only One Amrit which I believe is essentially naam. The Khanda Da Phul is another form of the same Amrit with the Gurbani absorbed into it, as there exists only one Amrit and no second. My question is seeing that there is only one type of Amrit if someone has already achieved it do they still need to take Khanda Pahul Da Amrit, as they have already shucked the one and same Amrit?? I believe the Bhagats and other people who reched God before both charan and khanda pahul da Amrit enjoyed the same Amrit in the form of naam, hence they did not need to take birth again or what ever to take khanda pahul da Amrit. What’s your views.

Re: Interesting Question

??? · 14 Apr 2004

It is important to disinguish "rites of passage" and internal alchemy, for want of better terms, but Amrit Naam and Khanda da Paul are intimately linked yet not to be confused with each other. The problem to your question is essentially the English translations which makes matters too literal, to understand the issue focus more on the original texts -sorry I can't help futher, I myself have much work to do in this field. As per the Bhagats, you raise some interesting points, however just so you know, there are 2 groups who do oppose the view you expressed, one is composed of a growing number of Reformist Sikhs (of which the AKJ, SGPC are good examples) over the past 50 -100 years -some from these movements have rewritten history believed to be contaminated and shown amongst other things that the Bhagats were Sikhs of Guru Nanak and would have taken charan amrit. The other camp relies on more "puratan" literature, the key one here being Pracheen Panth Parkash, where Rattan Singh Bhangoo indicates some of the Bhagats being reincarnated as the Punj Pyare. Sorry to confuse matters further, however this should prove helpful in assessing various sources should you continue to look further into this matter and help you eventually come to a conclusion.

Re: Interesting Question

Singhnee · 14 Apr 2004

Waheguru jee kaa khalsa! Waheguru jee kee fateh!! >>>>>My question is seeing that there is only one type of Amrit if someone has already achieved it do they still need to take Khanda Pahul Da Amrit, as they have already shucked the one and same Amrit?? >>>>>> There is no question about one Amrit but there is also one METHOD to give amrit. If someone has not get Amrit according to that Gurmat method then he/she needs to take amrit again. All bhagats got charan paahul and naam dee daat from Dhan siri Guru Nanak Dev jee. There is no other way to go to Sachkhand. "Nanak ke ghar keval, Naam" (Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee)

Re: Interesting Question

curious · 14 Apr 2004

There is in fact a story of a Gursikh in Guru Gobind Singh jee's time who did not take khande-ke-pahul he was a very "paunchia" or "uchee avastha" Gursikh and he never took khande-ke-pahul but one day Guru jee met him and asked him why, and he said that he'd already had God's darshan and what was the need? and Guru jee said, "do you consider yourself a Sikh of the Guru" and the Sikh said, "yes" and Guru jee said, "in that case you must take khande-ke-pahul" It was during Guru Gobind Singh jee's time - it is in one of the Janamsakhis or the Sri Suraj Prakash Granth ... if somebody has the exact name please give it . . .

Re: Interesting Question

Singh · 15 Apr 2004

Waheguru jee kaa khalsa! Waheguru jee kee fateh ??? I don’t think there is any dispute that Gurbani shows that there is only ONE AMRIT and no second. With or without translating into english we can still see that Gurbani makes it clear that there is ONE AMRIT and No SECOND, hence as far as I am concerned this is fact as per Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Which leaves the question unanswered. Singhne Please back your comments with relevant Gurbani. Like I said Gurbani makes it clear Amrit is essentially naam, and Khanda Pahul is this same Amrit just in a different form. In your view it appears that people who had taken Charan Pahul Amrit also had to take it again as it was in another method? Also how did the bhagats before Guru Nanak get Amrit? I find it hard to believe that Khabir, Farid etc who were on the level to be one with God and have their bani in Guru Granth Sahib Ji had to take rebirth again. curious I appreciate your story, as it makes sense to be a Sikh no matter what you have to follow the procedures laid down by the Guru, but this does not answer my original question. Also some people particularly on this site don’t entirely trust Suraj Prakash Granth, the same for Panth Parkash for that matter. What do people think about people reaching God before Guru Ji’s time? Gurbani makes it clear that without the Guru no one has or can obtain God. However what do people think of people obtaining God before Guru Ji’s time by following Gurmat. Guru and Gurmat is the same, as without Guru’s updesh and wisdom there would be not Guru (teacher). Therefor people before Guru Ji’s time (and non sikhs today) who followed Gurmat like the Bhagats were never without the Guru as they were following Gurmat which is essentially the Guru.

Re: Interesting Question

Karmheen · 15 Apr 2004

>>>>>Please back your comments with relevant Gurbani. Like I said Gurbani makes it clear Amrit is essentially naam, and Khanda Pahul is this same Amrit just in a different form. In your view it appears that people who had taken Charan Pahul Amrit also had to take it again as it was in another method? Also how did the bhagats before Guru Nanak get Amrit? I find it hard to believe that Khabir, Farid etc who were on the level to be one with God and have their bani in Guru Granth Sahib Ji had to take rebirth again.<<<< Dhe did use bani when she said "Nanak ke ghar keval, Naam" and as mentioned before, although Naam and Amrit are interconnected, they are not the same thing. The point of getting amrit is to get Naam. The people who took charan pahul did not have to take it again because that was the Gurmat method of giving amrit before Guru Gobind SIngh Ji gave this right to the panj pyarey. As for your last point, it has also already been mentioned in this thread, and this was also discussed on this board before as well, you can search for it, that the bhagats in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, eg. Bhagat Kabir Ji, Bhagat Farid Ji, were indeed the SIkhs of Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji. THere are some people who beleive that it is better to be politically correct and cater to everyones needs by saying that they were not that they were muslim and such, but this is not true. >>>What do people think about people reaching God before Guru Ji’s time? Gurbani makes it clear that without the Guru no one has or can obtain God. However what do people think of people obtaining God before Guru Ji’s time by following Gurmat. Guru and Gurmat is the same, as without Guru’s updesh and wisdom there would be not Guru (teacher). Therefor people before Guru Ji’s time (and non sikhs today) who followed Gurmat like the Bhagats were never without the Guru as they were following Gurmat which is essentially the Guru. <<<< How can you follow gurmat when you do not know what the guru's updesh is? How can a non-sikh jap naam when he has no idea what that special naam is? WHat was the use of Sri Guru Gobind SIngh ji himself recieiving amrit from the panj piyarey if there was no use in it? Gurmat can only be recieved from the satguru Sri guru Nanak Dev Ji, so how can non sikhs be following gurmat? that just does not make sense.

Re: Interesting Question

Singh · 16 Apr 2004

Karmheen Please clarify how this relates to the topic and stresses how someone who has naam Amrit needs to take Khanda Pahul, when they are both the same. "Nanak ke ghar keval, Naam" I see where your coming from with people not knowing about Gurmat before Guru Ji’s time but the fact is that the bhagats existed before Guru Nanak’s time and obviously knew about naam, humbleness etc and other aspects of Gurmat. Also I’ve met people who to a large degree are following Gurmat without knowing it, ie remembering God and doing deeds. Lets not forget Gurbani clearly states this to be the highest of acts/religion. What’s interesting is according to the sakhi posted by curious the person had already obtained the ultimate in sikhi (God’s darshan) without taking Amrit. If this sakhi is true it appears to that to reach God Amrit is not required, but Amrit is only required to be a Sikh? What do you think about the below quote from Guru Granth Sahib Ji concerning people who lived long before Guru Ji’ time: Page 435 AASAA, FOURTH MEHL: In the Golden Age of Sat Yuga, everyone embodied contentment and meditation; religion stood upon four feet. With mind and body, they sang of the Lord, and attained supreme peace. In their hearts was the spiritual wisdom of the Lord's Glorious Virtues. Their wealth was the spiritual wisdom of the Lord's Glorious Virtues; the Lord was their success, and to live as Gurmukh was their glory. Inwardly and outwardly, they saw only the One Lord God; for them there was no other second. They centered their consciousness lovingly on the Lord, Har, Har. The Lord's Name was their companion, and in the Court of the Lord, they obtained honor. In the Golden Age of Sat Yuga, everyone embodied contentment and meditation; religion stood upon four feet. || 1 || This clearly shows people living as Gurmukh before Guru Ji’s time, therfore to be a Gurmukh they must have known about Guru Ji’s updesh/teachings.

Re: Interesting Question

Singh · 16 Apr 2004

i posted a reply to this with Gurbani, but it seems to have got lossed in Cyber space.

Re: Interesting Question

Karmheen · 16 Apr 2004

>>>>Please clarify how this relates to the topic and stresses how someone who has naam Amrit needs to take Khanda Pahul, when they are both the same. "Nanak ke ghar keval, Naam" <<<<< The Naam that you need to jap in order to get amrit is only in Sri Guru Nank Dev Ji's ghar. So you have to take amrit, which is now changed by Sri Guru Gobind SIngh Ji to khanda batey dii Pahul, but was previously Charan Pahul. If you don't have NAam, how are you to get amrit from it? >>>>I see where your coming from with people not knowing about Gurmat before Guru Ji’s time but the fact is that the bhagats existed before Guru Nanak’s time and obviously knew about naam, humbleness etc and other aspects of Gurmat. Also I’ve met people who to a large degree are following Gurmat without knowing it, ie remembering God and doing deeds. Lets not forget Gurbani clearly states this to be the highest of acts/religion. <<<<< Are you talking about the bhagats thats bani is in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji? Becuase all of those bhagat were SIkhs of Sri GUru Nanak Dev Ji, so they had recieved Naam from Guru Ji, through whichever method guru ji used then to give Naam. Bani says time again and again that Naam japna is the highest act of religion/living. But how can you jap Naam if you don't have NAam? People can be following principles of Gurmat, but until they get Naam from the Punj Pyarey through shaking amrit, they are not listening to what bani is saying, which is to Jap Naam. >>>>>What do you think about the below quote from Guru Granth Sahib Ji concerning people who lived long before Guru Ji’ time:<<<<< I tried finding that shabad from the ang that you gave, but it is not on ang 435. Although you have the raag right, on that ang I fould Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji's chant. Until I can find the real bani, I cant tell you what I think of the english translation. But in bani it does say that : Kuljug udariaa, Gurdev|| and Satjug Duapar Treta Bhaniiae, Kuljug utmo juga mahe|| [%sig%]

Re: Interesting Question

daas · 16 Apr 2004

amrit (sweet taste) is actually made in your body naturally through meditating on God, there are different stages. you need a Guru of some sort for you to pass through to God, we need to get Deekeea (baptised) for a true way to live our lives.

Re: Interesting Question

Singh · 19 Apr 2004

Karmheen You are right the ang references is actually Ang 445 AASAA, FOURTH MEHL. I didn't think the admin was going to put up my last post, hence the post being lost in cyber space comment. Anyway “If you don't have NAam, how are you to get amrit from it?” Yes Gurbani makes it clear that Neem can only be received from the Guru. But Naam is not a technique like what you are referring to. The Gurmantre is what the 5 pyarai give, it’s a mantre and way not Naam. Its clear that Gurmucks existed even in the first Jug as per my quote from Gurbani which you can now double check. For them to have been Gurmucks surely they must have been doing the first basic principle of Gurmat ie Naam Jap. “Are you talking about the bhagats thats bani is in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji? Becuase all of those bhagat were SIkhs of Sri GUru Nanak Dev Ji, so they had recieved Naam from Guru Ji” The Bhagats in Guru Granth Sahib Ji existed before Guru Nanak’s time, so how did they receive charan or khanda da Amrit. They were certainly following Gurmat but existed before Guru Ji’s time. Could they not have had Amrit in the form of Naam which meant they didn’t require charan or khanda da Amrit as Guru Ji says Nanak Amrit Ek Hai, Doosar Amrit Naahi. Also the sakhi posted by "curious" reveals the old Sikh having Naam as without it he could not have met God, but he did not take AMrit at that stage. “But how can you jap Naam if you don't have NAam? People can be following principles of Gurmat, but until they get Naam from the Punj Pyarey through shaking amrit, they are not listening to what bani is saying, which is to Jap Naam.” I don’t know what you are going on about here, as the Bhagats make countless references to Naam and Naam Jap and they existed before Guru Ji’s time, and don’t think they took Amrit from the 5 Pyarai. Naam is mentioned in one form or another through out the Bhagti movement. Even Suf’is did Simeran with the 90 or whatever different names used for God in their tradition. The concept of Naam is eternal and I don’t think it begun just when Guru Ji came into being or in 1699. Do you really think the deep and eternal Naam which Guru Ji preaches about in Sikhi so much is just a thing which is received by anyone who goes through the procedure of Khada Pahul da Amrit. Sorry but Bani reveals Naam as much more than something which can be simply obtained by going through a procedure, a large majority of people who have taken Amrit from the Jatha or where ever do not have NAAM, they only know what the Gurmantre is.

Re: Interesting Question

ns · 19 Apr 2004

Veryu good question by singh, it 'll be impossible to get a clear answer, this was up to our Guru Sahiban.My only suggestion is that we all know paul is necessary to be khalsa, thereforefor go for it and become the son of our true Guru.This is suggestion stems from the line in SGGS "Gur ki karnee kahee thaavooo"

Re: Interesting Question

jumunjeeeeeeeeee!!!!!!!!!!!!!! · 20 Apr 2004

all i know is that we need a guru to become one with god. Perhaps that's the missing piece? a string(s) of gurus from way back, all one with god, initiating disciples? Vaheeguroooooo!!!!!!

Re: Interesting Question

Singh · 20 Apr 2004

Gurbani makes it clear that in Kaljug (now) Guru Nanaks message (sikhi) is the key to meet God. I don't think that means just taking Amrit as some people try to kid themselves, but taking AMrit and living according to Gurmat as a whole. People who live according to Gurmat without Amrit are probably half way already there. People who just take Amrit are not completly there, but someone who does both is a lucky soul.

Re: Interesting Question

karmheen · 20 Apr 2004

>Yes Gurbani makes it clear that Neem can only be received from the Guru. But Naam is not a technique like what you are referring to. The Gurmantre is what the 5 pyarai give, it’s a mantre and way not Naam. Its clear that Gurmucks existed even in the first Jug as per my quote from Gurbani which you can now double check. For them to have been Gurmucks surely they must have been doing the first basic principle of Gurmat ie Naam Jap. < The gurmanter and naam are the same thing, as can be seen from Jail Chitteyaa of Bhai SAhib Bhai Randheer SIngh ji, when he discovers, after much confusion that the naam that gurbani tells us to jaap all of the time is actually Vaheguru. >The Bhagats in Guru Granth Sahib Ji existed before Guru Nanak’s time, so how did they receive charan or khanda da Amrit. They were certainly following Gurmat but existed before Guru Ji’s time. Could they not have had Amrit in the form of Naam which meant they didn’t require charan or khanda da Amrit as Guru Ji says Nanak Amrit Ek Hai, Doosar Amrit Naahi.< It has been proven by Giani Gurdit SIngh that the bhagats were all actually in existence during the time of guru ji, and were their sikhs. I agree that the concept of naam did not begin with guru ji, but every other person that claimed to have the real gurmantar did not have the true, eternal naam, that is only with satguru ji, and we, in order to prove that we deserve this naam, have to give our heads to guru ji through the amrit ceremony, and make that deal with guru ji that for our head, please give us naam, and if guru ji accepts our head, than he gives us naam. I dont know what the shabad means, but when you read the whole shabad, and you get to the kaljug part, it is only there that guru ji mentions meeting the true guru and getting naam which got guru ji to meet Vaheguru. The kaljug shabad is the only shabad that mentions meeting God, or the lord, so whatever naam they did have during Satjug, it did not compare to the naam that satguru ji gives his sikhs in kaljug, which is the aukhad "medecine" of all sins and dukhs that can help you meet Vaheguru. And it is when you meet Vaheguru that you get mukti from this cycle of life and death, so you get amar, and essentially that is what amrit is, the elexir of eternal life, so this eternal life is obtained only through the satguru, sri guru Nanak Dev ji. If I translated anything wrong, because I know close to nothing about Gurbani arths, may GUru ji please forgive me. >Do you really think the deep and eternal Naam which Guru Ji preaches about in Sikhi so much is just a thing which is received by anyone who goes through the procedure of Khada Pahul da Amrit. Sorry but Bani reveals Naam as much more than something which can be simply obtained by going through a procedure, a large majority of people who have taken Amrit from the Jatha or where ever do not have NAAM, they only know what the Gurmantre is.< I think this is exactly the problem with so many people today. THey insult the significance of the amrit sanchar ceremony by calling it a mere procedure. THe truth is that it a connection between the two worlds when the panj pyaarey are giving amrit, and no words can describe this ceremony justly. I personally think it is pure blashemy to call this just a "procedure". ANd not anyone can go through it, people have been rejected if the panj dont feel they're ready.

Re: Interesting Question

Singh · 22 Apr 2004

karmheen “the naam that gurbani tells us to jaap all of the time is actually Vaheguru.” Its funny that you think Naam is a the mantre, and Waheguru the mantre is Naam. The Mantre is the means to Naam not Naam alone. Its like saying an Amrdhari is a Khalsa just because of that, while in reality Amrit is the way to become a Khalsa. The Mantre Waheguru leads to Naam, but just becouse someone knows the Gurmantre does not mean they have the jewel of Naam. “It has been proven by Giani Gurdit SIngh that the bhagats were all actually in existence during the time of guru ji, and were their sikhs. “ I think your very mistaken. I have never heard of Bhagat Farid, Namdev etc ever meeting Guru Ji in thier liftime let alone taking Amrit from them. Did all the Bhagats in Guru Granth Sahib Ji meet Guru Ji or only some? BTW Bhagat Prahlard is mentioned in numerous places in Gurbani but he existed in a totally different Jug. Gurbani makes it clear how he was a Bhagat so how did he get so close to God when he existed before Guru Nanak and khanda da Amrit?? Tell me did Bhagat Prahlad not have “the true, eternal naam”, as Gurbani may disagree. Infact Gurbani makes it clear that there have been Bhagats through out the ages (before Guru Nanaks time) so how did they get Amrit and meet God? Some of them we may not even know about. Har Jug Jug Bhagat Apaiya Paij Rakhda Aiya Ram Rajai. “I dont know what the shabad means” The shabad is for you to see in black and white, it shows Gumucks existing before Guru Nanaks time. It shows how people lived as Gurmuck before and guess what the shabad even says “The Lord's Name was their companion”. Accept it. Rather than calling my comments blashemy why don’t you answere the question rather than going off topic ???? Do you really think that everyone who has taken Amrit has Naam as per what Gurbani reveals

Re: Interesting Question

uk Singh · 22 Apr 2004

I have heard that the panj piyare were also incarnates of the Bhagats, although have no factual evidence as proof. the bhagats who arrivied on this duniya way before Nanak must have reached sachkhand otherwise their thoughts would not have been entered in the Guru Granth Sahib. Guru Nanak Sahib Ji writes: bin satgur kinai na paa-i-o bin satgur kinai na paa-i-aa. does this mean that if one of these Bhagats believed in a Guru before Sikhi they could have obtained Vaheguru? If they believed in a spiritual teacher with full and complete devotion as well as Vaheguru, then maybe they reached the ultimate goal..