Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

cloning

cloning

sarbloh · 08 Apr 2004

Is cloning ethical? Is it playing the role of god? Or is our research of cloning and making it successful all part of gods will?

Re: cloning

Mkhalsa · 08 Apr 2004

Yeah, how does sikhi feel about this? If a singh needed a new liver, would it be unethical to clone a new one? what if you son died, can u clone a new one? These are interesting questions...

Re: cloning

Mkhalsa · 08 Apr 2004

also, there are people who already clone their pets, when the pet dies, they just make a new one, is this wrong?

Re: cloning

DKaur · 08 Apr 2004

Talking about cloning, I need to do a paper on cloning. Does anyone have any information on cloning? These are good questions that i can use for my paper, but does anyone have a solid answer?

Re: cloning

gk · 08 Apr 2004

i disagree with cloning, its like we're playing God. If a singh was sick, he should have full bharosa in god's will (whether it's him getting better or being pulled out of this life...) i think by all this new technology we're only setting ourselves up for our own destruction one day.

Re: cloning

illiterate · 08 Apr 2004

Replacing a dead son etc with a cloned one sounds so very wrong. It might be okay to clone for organs and such, but cloning entire human beings doesn't seem right at all.

Re: cloning

UK Singh · 09 Apr 2004

As long as genetic research is confined to treatment of diseases, I do not see any problem with it. After all, if "hukam" meant that we do not treat diseases by any means, the science of medicine would have been forbidden in Sikhism. It is not, rather it enjoys a place of honour. The question of cloning has to be split into two different questions : 1. Cloning for harvesting of organs / tissue - medical treatment. Questionable depending upon definition of life. When does life begin according to Sikhism ? 2. For other purposes - IMO, not acceptable. It is possible cloning may lead to genetic discrimination similar to caste system & even justify its ongoing perpetuation to preserve a particular genetic pool.

Re: cloning

g · 09 Apr 2004

its not playing god, if god gave us the tech to do it... then it was meant to be, theres just a certain responsibility that comes with it... like we shouldnt clone humans and animals... but organs would be fine if somone looses an arm they can make a new arm for them... there is nuthing wrong with that.

Re: cloning

Singhstah · 10 Apr 2004

the liver cloning isnt wrong cause its for health, but cloning a person is completley wrong, if they were meant to die, they were meant to die, plus i don't think the clone would have an atma because the person who died's atma will have already gone into the next life or Sachkhand or watever. [%sig%]

Re: cloning

Mkhalsa · 10 Apr 2004

The way that the law (and science) technically see a clone is as a twin brother/sister of the person being cloned. How could they not have an atmaa? Everything has a soul. But it probably would be someone elses soul who was meant to be born into that situation..

Re: cloning

kaur · 11 Apr 2004

I don't think people quite understand the concept of cloning. Yes, biotechnology has figured out how to clone organisms, but not organs. I don't think you can't clone a liver (unless there has been some drastic discovery in the past few months) usually human/mammalian transplants are used. You can clone liver cells, or grow them from mesenchymal stem cells. Also if an organism is cloned, how can it not have an atma? It is still its own person, it just has the identical genetic make-up of what the donor DNA was composed of. I personally despise the idea of human cloning. I see each individual having their own genetic make-up for a reason. Each person is built unique. Because of this unique nature, there is a great diversity in the world, this is amazing when it comes to diseases etc. because if everyone was exactly the same, one strain of virus/bacteria could wipe out the planet, but because of this diverse nature this does not happen. Each person has their own level of resistance and so forth. Some people have been shown to genetically be more prone to certain illnesses, some less. I believe Guru Sahib made humans the way they are for a reason, trying to selectively clone humans based on physical characteristics (eg. models) or whatever else is straight up wrong. I am not anti-research with cloned stem cells, but cloning for other purposes is stupid. [%sig%]

Re: cloning

Mkhalsa · 12 Apr 2004

Cloning an organ is entirely possible. What they plan on doing (I don't think its been done yet) is to selectively edit the dna of the embryo so as to stunt the growth of the head and other organs. Basically just grow a circulatory system and the organ(s) needed. Seems kind of wrong when you think about whats involved..