Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

the best for all...?

the best for all...?

Searching · 04 Apr 2004

wjkk wjkf. Sangat ji, jus a quick question: God is said to do the best for all rite, but sumwhere along the line the best thing for one person will effect sum1 else badly so will that not be wrong?? This sounds like im being offensive but i dnt mean to be, i jus dnt undastand how the best thing for 1 person will be ok for all. The way i see it, when sum1 gets summat or does summat good then its nice for them rite but then sumwhere sum1 else has lost out. is this more to do with ones karam, so if there wer 2 people then 1 would receive the fruit of their good and bad actions so its not really bout Guru Ji doing this its all in ones preordained will. thats jus my manmukh mentality so can ne1 explain this plz. Bhul chuk marf karni. wjkk wjkf.

Re: the best for all...?

the singh next door · 26 May 2004

?

Re: the best for all...?

answer · 26 May 2004

=)

Re: the best for all...?

singh · 26 May 2004

sarbat da balla :) God's storehouses never run out. God's will is infinite, God is all knowing. God can do what's best for all and make it work out. our puny limited intellects cannot comprehend this. hope this is somewhere in the ballpark.........

Re: the best for all...?

Manjot Singh Khalsa · 27 May 2004

I think what they are asking is, is gurmat philosophy meant to help the greater good or the individual? lets say theres a child with a highly contagious disease and hes been quarantined off, to save this child, you need to bring him out to give him medicine which would immediately effect an entire population and potentially kill millions. which is it? save the child or save millions?

Re: the best for all...?

10 · 27 May 2004

There is a sakhi that might help to better explain how everything happens for the good of all. It has been a long time since I last heard it, so forgive me in advance for any errors, I will try my best to write what I remember and translate it from punjabi to english. There was a king in the past and he had a servant who was very close to him and used to accompany the king whereever he went. The servant was a very religious person; whenever something would happen the servant would say that it happened by God's will for a good reason. One day, the king had his arm chopped off and was in a lot of despair. The servant, like he always would, made the comment that it happened for a good reason. The king became very angry at these remarks and replied that the next thing the servant would do, if the king got killed, would be to say that it happened for a good reason. The king then fired the servant and asked him if that also happened for a good reason. The servant again said that he was fired for a good reason. A bit later on, the king was on a hunting trip in the jungle. He would normally be accompanied by the servant. While hunting, the king was captured by some people who were looking to sacrifice a human for their god. THe king tried to explain that he was a king and could offer them some rewards for them to release him. They told the king that they were unconcerned with what the king was and all they needed was a human for the sacrifice. When they took the king and got him ready to kill, they noticed that the king had a part of one of his arms chopped off. They considered that to be sacreligious as he was missing a part of his body. They then released the king as they had no other use in keeping him. The king then realised that what his servant was saying was true. If the king did not have his arm chopped off, he would have been killed to be offered as a sacrifice. The king thought that what he had done in firing the servant was wrong, so he decided that he would appologize and bring the servant back. When the king met the servant he explained everything that happened. He told him that there was still one thing he didn't understand. He asked the servant what good came out of his being fired. The servant told the king, that if he wasn't fired, he would have accompanied him on his hunting trip and those people would have took the servant in the king's place to offer as a sacrifice to their god. So, you can see that everything that happens, does happen for the good of everyone. Even though, with our limitted thinking, we cannot realize it immediately, but over time we can see that this is true.