Can a Sikh go
Can we · 02 Apr 2004
Can a sikh go to a hindu temple for some ones wedding or go to a church for a wedding. I think we should not go, but I am no sikh so I ask the sanget.
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
Can we · 02 Apr 2004
Can a sikh go to a hindu temple for some ones wedding or go to a church for a wedding. I think we should not go, but I am no sikh so I ask the sanget.??? · 02 Apr 2004
I have on many occasions been to place of worship belonging to another tradition as a "guest" either to a Wedding, Funeral or Birthday etc.] I personally see no harm in doing so, I make it clear to my hosts that I have certain practices as part of my faith that are not open to negotiation, just as they do and if we can both be understanding of these. For instance, I will not remove my Dastaar under any circumstances -whereas, Christians often remove their hats/headcovering during certain services. Likewise, I am vegetarian and teetotal and aspects such as Murti Pooja, drinking of wine etc are not part of our maryada. In most instances, they have been fully understanding and I've experienced no issues whatsoever, in fact to be honest, I recall good experiences during visits I've personally had from my Jewish, Shia Muslim, Christian and Hindu hosts. In particular, I have found the Muslims and Jews to be most welcoming and offering most courtesy, showing utmost respect for the Dastaar. All in all, in my personal experience, it's simply a matter of laying your cards down in a "respectful" manner and thereafter its pretty enjoyable. Remember, Guru HarGobind Sahib built a Mosque for his muslim troops and followers, clearly he wouldn't have taken part in the Namaaz per se, but Guru Sahib has always taught us to have an element of mutual respect for another's right to practice their faith and yet be steadfast in your own. Hope this helps... ...interestingly, I'd be interested to know why you think we shouldn't go?learner · 02 Apr 2004
i completely agree with er... mr/ms ??? ! i've also been to various places of religious worship of other faiths, and every time i have been treated better than i've ever been treated in every gurdwara i've been to! i also have found jews and muslims (both shia and sunni) to be the most welcoming, going out of their way to provide non-kosher/halal food for me. i wish to make a special mention of the shia's though. when i recently went to a shia imam barga with a couple of other singhs for ashura many of the shias came up to us and hugged us, one of them with tears streaming down his face telling us how beautiful we looked with our dastars and flowing beards. we were the first to be served food and treated like royal guests. i also have no problem with joining in with religious traditions of other faiths... after all we are all worshipping the same akaal purkh, whether we say vaheguru, allah or raam. i took part in the matam for ashura with the shia's and found it a very spiritual and emotional experience. it is quite sad though when u think that if three or four muslim guys turned up at a gurdwara nine times out of ten rather than being treated cordially and welcomed they would be eyed with suspicion. i think we should do a lot more to encourage people of other faiths (or of no faith) to learn about sikhi. any other thoughts on the matter? has anyone ever had any bad experiences in other places of worship? & just to repeat ???'s question, why do u think sikhs shouldn't go?... · 02 Apr 2004
I think it is okay for a Sikh to attend a mosque or mandir or church, but as long as they do not worship the other faiths prophets and do not take part in singing their praises or in any services i.e, Weddings etc. and also do not matha teik to any statues or paintings. Weddings of other faiths are wrong to attend because it is done against Gurmat maryada. It is also wrong for Gursikhs to attend a so called sikh wedding were the guy is not keshdhari and the girl, and which does not also follow the Gurmat maryada. Sorry if I have offended anyone, but this is what I believe to be true. Bhul Chak Maaf jee!! Daas. [%sig%]gursikhoooo sunoooo · 03 Apr 2004
its not wrong, its a part about learning of other cultures.. when u learn of other things.. then only can you see how lucky u are to be sikh -:)Singh1699 · 03 Apr 2004
To Learner >>i took part in the matam for ashura with the shia's and found it a very spiritual and emotional experience.<< Isn't maatam a form of mourning for the grandsons of mohammed killed by a muslim leader and done by Shias which in extreme cases takes the form of beating themselves with chains or beating their breasts ? Which part of matam did you take part in and how was it a 'spiritual and emotional experience' for you ? can you answer in the light of how Gurbani tells a Sikh to accept everything as Waheguru's doing. Tera Bhana Meetha Lagay.no one · 03 Apr 2004
If you have to go to a friend/family member's wedding or whatever at a mosque/mandir or whatever, I think its ok, as long as you don't BOW to the murtis or whatever else...