Re: keertan
Jatha Singh · 26 Mar 2004
Every tune is some raag or the other. You don't have to do aaaa eeeeee oooooo to do kirtan in Raag. One can do simple raag and still qualify as Hari Kirtan.
Sangatee kirtan was started by Siri Guru Arjun Dev jee himself. So who are we to question sangatee kirtan that jatha does?
Re: keertan
Balpreet Singh · 26 Mar 2004
I agree that keertan should firstly done with love, etc and that's what is most important. At the same time, I also feel we shouldn't make too many excuses. Raag Vidya is something that is important and is being lost. Indeed, it would be best if a shabad is sung in the raag it was written in. There's no avoiding this reality.
Re: keertan
charansharan · 27 Mar 2004
The way that I take Raag Vidiya is the way that I take Shaster Vidiya
We should essentially learn it and understand it from the traditional Indian perspective
but only Shaster Vidiya is not the Sikh martial tradition
and what I mean by that is the Sikh martial tradition includes wrestling, stick-fighting, hand-to-hand / face-to-face combat, different techniques of warfare, a whole different mentality of chardee kalaa, a whole background philosophy and attitude, PLUS DEFINATELY shaster vidiya,
in the same way - raag keertan is one part of the Sikh keertan tradition
that is my humble opinion
Therefore when you are in a REAL FIGHT - you may not be able to do your panthra and you may not be able to do some of the exact vaars that you learned in gatka /shaster vidiya class. You will do what it takes from the strength of all your body to bring the opponent under your control.
Gurmukhs primarily defeat their opponent with the weopon of humility and pyaar. This is our biggest weopon. And keertan is a way to exercise this weapon. When we are doing keertan we are bringing under control our strongest opponents... kaam, krodh, lobh, moh, ahankaar. This is also the way we do naam simran.
For this reason I think a Gursikh needs an equal amount of ORGANIZED, "sit down and do it" swaas swaas naam abhyaas, and ORGANIZED, "sit down and do it" dhunee simran.
And therefore I also think doing keertan you should do what your heart says but also try to learn a few things about raag keertan (I hope someday satguru jee gives me this baksheesh)
At the same time I think learning raag would be good for me, and learning tabla would be good for me. But when I'm out there fighting my kaam, krodh, lobh, moh, ahankaar - the most effective tool will not be the raag or the taal, it will be the pyaar.
That is my humble perspective that there are some times when rules don't apply and only PYAAR applies.
This is in my humble opinion the case of raag keertan.
bhul chuk maaf karnaa jee
daas
Re: keertan
Rupinder Singh · 29 Mar 2004
WaheGuru Jee ka khalsa
WaheGuru Jee ke Fateh,
Guru Shabad and Gurmat Sangeet are very close and intertwined with each other. The example of this is well in front of us, In Saheb Sri Guru Granth Saheb Jee Maharaj majorty of bani starts with the mention of raag and taal. Puratan Keertani use to give alot of emphasis on Gurmat Classical Keertan. Ragi's of 19th and early 20th century eg: Bhai Heera Singh, Munsha Singh, Jawala Singh etc. are well known. I have heard from one of the "Bajurg" Some of these ragi's will do an hour or 2 of naam abhais before going to darbar saheb and do keertan. These were the people who kept strict Keertan Maryada. No Chanhal tunes but Gurmat reetan that were sung by Guru Shaeb himself and his sikhs. It is famous that bhai Heera Singh jee (did Keertan sewa for 70 years in harminder Sahib)strongly opposed the invent of harmonium to Harminder Sahib. He wanted to keep the original string intruments that were used by Guru Saheb and his keertani.
We are fortunate enough that the very reetan that were sung by Saheb Guru Arjan Dev Jee Maharaj and Saheb Guru Gobind Singh jee are still among us. We just need to put an effort to learn this Gurmat Keertan rehat. Once friend of my was listening to shabad from Bhai Santa Singh(Puratan Ragi about 1950-60's). The reet was puratan Gurmat reet and the shabad was describing "Birha" of sepration from WaheGuru, the reet itself had so much beerha in it that a Goora guy listned to it and without understanding a word of Gurbani understood that deep feeling of seperation is being describe here. Unfornately, new tunes have a bhangra beet on it, while shabad is explaining the pain of seperation.
Another story- Bhai Avtar Singh(Perponent of Gurmat Sangeet)mentioned this to daas. Once in Vancouver, every morning they would do Asa-di-war in same very way that was sung hundreds of years ago in Guru Darbars and they would sing all the puratan reetan. A Gori Sikh Bibi with limited undertanding of Gurmukhi would come and and listen to keertan without knowing that this is puratan keertan style. One day she told Bhai Avtar Singh jee when she listens to these reetan feels like she is sitting in Darbar of Saheb Guru Arjan Dev jee Maharaj in Harminder Sahib hundreds of year back.
A sikh does not exist without the Gurmat rehat. But when it comes to Gurmat keertan rehat we get all wishi washy and have all the excuses. The proper keertan rehat was set in Guru darbar, and was followed for hundreds of years till recently.
1) Shaan; where the very raag the keertan was to be sung will be played briefly on the string instruments.
2) A reet which would be in the same raag as the Bani while be sung. This reet will in be "Wada Taal" - Chartaal(12 beats), Jhaptaal(10 beats), Dhamar (14 beats) etc. will be sung.
3) A reet in a simpler taal will be sung with some katha, if the raagi wishes so.
4.) The keertan will end with the Pauri of the same raag that the last shabad was sung in.
Music is a strong tool and can greatly help us when we use it in the way it used in Puratan Guru Darbar.
Rest Guru Knows
WaheGuru Jee Ka khalsa
WaheGuru Jee Kee Fateh
keertan
punjabi kuri · 16 Aug 2005
most ragi's in the time of today compose kirtan in filmi tunes. the guru granth sahib is written in rag's therefore keertan should be sung in rag's. on the other hand i agree that keertan should be done with love.
Re: keertan
ASengh aka "boongawala" · 20 Aug 2005
I've began to like raag after listening to Harjinder Singh Lalli at the Sanjha Smagam, guess its not all about "aahhhhhhh, saaaaaa, maaaaaaa, niiii."