Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

keertan

keertan

Worried · 26 Mar 2004

We should try and use proper Raags more in Keertan. Like alot of Keertanees have alot of devotion and there is alot of Russ in his words the Raags are really dodgy sounding, definately not puratan and sound like nursey tunes or Hindi film tunes, Only a few Keertanees try do to proper Raag, I know its hard but the Jatha should try and keep things how the Guru did it. Also we could try using traditional instruments like sairangi etc in keertan maybe, not sure how that would work though. I dunno, if you listen to the old keertan tapes they sound really differnet to the new keertan the Jatha does, and it feels like its moving away a bit. What are your views on this Waheguru Ji Ki Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: keertan

mmmh! · 26 Mar 2004

the jatha use the Sata and Balwand story to back basic kirtan and lines such as 'koi gavay raagi naadhee bedi boh bhaant kar, nahee har har bhejai ram raje' to defend this style. ragis just say that people are not interested in raag style kirtan... eg Bhai Nirmal Singh is well trained, yet he performs on the main, Bolywood tunes as does, Sri Nagar Wale, Anoop Singh an you know the rest.. raag kirtan is fast becoming extinct as there are simply not enough practitioners and it does not sell nearly as well as "ex-hazoori" material....which as you know is churned out in a Fordism manner.. the problem is that it all sounds the SAME! With a Vaja, you simply cannot reach the notes of stringed/plucked/wind instruments.

Re: keertan

Jatha Singh · 26 Mar 2004

Every tune is some raag or the other. You don't have to do aaaa eeeeee oooooo to do kirtan in Raag. One can do simple raag and still qualify as Hari Kirtan. Sangatee kirtan was started by Siri Guru Arjun Dev jee himself. So who are we to question sangatee kirtan that jatha does?

Re: keertan

s!nghn! · 26 Mar 2004

People tend to think that doing keertan in raag means that the shabad must be done only in teen-taal and include all the "aaaa eeeeee oooooo" (as it was so eloquently put in an earlier post). But every tune is indeed in one raag or another, whether the keertani even realizes it or not. I see your point about "proper" raags (I assume you mean singing in the same raag as the shabad is composed in). But it's complicated. I mean, sometimes you just want to do a shabad, regardless of what time of day it is. But if we stick to the "pakaa raag" routine, then we can only do certain shabads only at certain times of the day, or even only in the right season, as prescribed by the raag. That means we'll only get to hear Basant for a few months each year! That'd be tragic!! Moreover, Gurbani is only composed in 31 raags. This means we will never get the chance to hear the other thousands of raags that exist. The raags used most often in Jatha today, in my opinion, are Malkauns and Darbaari -- both of which are excluded from Sri Guru Granth Sahib and both of which are to be sung at late night and in a particular season (ie. Malkauns = technically a raag of Winter). I'd rather hear these raags being sung with pyaar at any random time/season, rather than hearing only one of the 31 raags and having it mechanically sung at the prescribed time. Overall, it's pretty confining for those who like to do whatever shabad they feel like doing, depending on their mood/avasthaa, and in a tune that they like and feel. I think keertani who have knowledge and training of raags and tend to avoid doing them, do so not due to others' preferences, but just because they themselves don't feel like doing raags all the time. I personally would rather have people doing keertan genuinely from the heart rather than just according to the time.

Re: keertan

Balpreet Singh · 26 Mar 2004

I agree that keertan should firstly done with love, etc and that's what is most important. At the same time, I also feel we shouldn't make too many excuses. Raag Vidya is something that is important and is being lost. Indeed, it would be best if a shabad is sung in the raag it was written in. There's no avoiding this reality.

Re: keertan

charansharan · 27 Mar 2004

The way that I take Raag Vidiya is the way that I take Shaster Vidiya We should essentially learn it and understand it from the traditional Indian perspective but only Shaster Vidiya is not the Sikh martial tradition and what I mean by that is the Sikh martial tradition includes wrestling, stick-fighting, hand-to-hand / face-to-face combat, different techniques of warfare, a whole different mentality of chardee kalaa, a whole background philosophy and attitude, PLUS DEFINATELY shaster vidiya, in the same way - raag keertan is one part of the Sikh keertan tradition that is my humble opinion Therefore when you are in a REAL FIGHT - you may not be able to do your panthra and you may not be able to do some of the exact vaars that you learned in gatka /shaster vidiya class. You will do what it takes from the strength of all your body to bring the opponent under your control. Gurmukhs primarily defeat their opponent with the weopon of humility and pyaar. This is our biggest weopon. And keertan is a way to exercise this weapon. When we are doing keertan we are bringing under control our strongest opponents... kaam, krodh, lobh, moh, ahankaar. This is also the way we do naam simran. For this reason I think a Gursikh needs an equal amount of ORGANIZED, "sit down and do it" swaas swaas naam abhyaas, and ORGANIZED, "sit down and do it" dhunee simran. And therefore I also think doing keertan you should do what your heart says but also try to learn a few things about raag keertan (I hope someday satguru jee gives me this baksheesh) At the same time I think learning raag would be good for me, and learning tabla would be good for me. But when I'm out there fighting my kaam, krodh, lobh, moh, ahankaar - the most effective tool will not be the raag or the taal, it will be the pyaar. That is my humble perspective that there are some times when rules don't apply and only PYAAR applies. This is in my humble opinion the case of raag keertan. bhul chuk maaf karnaa jee daas

Re: keertan

Worried · 27 Mar 2004

thanks for your replies generally i dont mind if sairangi etc arent used but for example bhai manjit singh does really nice keertan but hte tunes he uses arent even half puratan, they sound like nursery tunes or filmy tunes. at least we should try and keep the raag similar-ish to what they had in the gurus times, otherwise soon enough we will be using synthesisers and western instruments :O WJKK WJKF

Re: keertan

Rupinder Singh · 29 Mar 2004

WaheGuru Jee ka khalsa WaheGuru Jee ke Fateh, Guru Shabad and Gurmat Sangeet are very close and intertwined with each other. The example of this is well in front of us, In Saheb Sri Guru Granth Saheb Jee Maharaj majorty of bani starts with the mention of raag and taal. Puratan Keertani use to give alot of emphasis on Gurmat Classical Keertan. Ragi's of 19th and early 20th century eg: Bhai Heera Singh, Munsha Singh, Jawala Singh etc. are well known. I have heard from one of the "Bajurg" Some of these ragi's will do an hour or 2 of naam abhais before going to darbar saheb and do keertan. These were the people who kept strict Keertan Maryada. No Chanhal tunes but Gurmat reetan that were sung by Guru Shaeb himself and his sikhs. It is famous that bhai Heera Singh jee (did Keertan sewa for 70 years in harminder Sahib)strongly opposed the invent of harmonium to Harminder Sahib. He wanted to keep the original string intruments that were used by Guru Saheb and his keertani. We are fortunate enough that the very reetan that were sung by Saheb Guru Arjan Dev Jee Maharaj and Saheb Guru Gobind Singh jee are still among us. We just need to put an effort to learn this Gurmat Keertan rehat. Once friend of my was listening to shabad from Bhai Santa Singh(Puratan Ragi about 1950-60's). The reet was puratan Gurmat reet and the shabad was describing "Birha" of sepration from WaheGuru, the reet itself had so much beerha in it that a Goora guy listned to it and without understanding a word of Gurbani understood that deep feeling of seperation is being describe here. Unfornately, new tunes have a bhangra beet on it, while shabad is explaining the pain of seperation. Another story- Bhai Avtar Singh(Perponent of Gurmat Sangeet)mentioned this to daas. Once in Vancouver, every morning they would do Asa-di-war in same very way that was sung hundreds of years ago in Guru Darbars and they would sing all the puratan reetan. A Gori Sikh Bibi with limited undertanding of Gurmukhi would come and and listen to keertan without knowing that this is puratan keertan style. One day she told Bhai Avtar Singh jee when she listens to these reetan feels like she is sitting in Darbar of Saheb Guru Arjan Dev jee Maharaj in Harminder Sahib hundreds of year back. A sikh does not exist without the Gurmat rehat. But when it comes to Gurmat keertan rehat we get all wishi washy and have all the excuses. The proper keertan rehat was set in Guru darbar, and was followed for hundreds of years till recently. 1) Shaan; where the very raag the keertan was to be sung will be played briefly on the string instruments. 2) A reet which would be in the same raag as the Bani while be sung. This reet will in be "Wada Taal" - Chartaal(12 beats), Jhaptaal(10 beats), Dhamar (14 beats) etc. will be sung. 3) A reet in a simpler taal will be sung with some katha, if the raagi wishes so. 4.) The keertan will end with the Pauri of the same raag that the last shabad was sung in. Music is a strong tool and can greatly help us when we use it in the way it used in Puratan Guru Darbar. Rest Guru Knows WaheGuru Jee Ka khalsa WaheGuru Jee Kee Fateh

Re: keertan

s!nghn! · 07 Apr 2004

Something which has been increasingly annoying me lately is that when people do keertan in raags, I've noticed that hardly anyone sings along with the keertani. Why is that?? When a keertani starts singing in raag, the sangat falls immediately silent. It's sort of discouraging and would easily turn people away from raags.

Re: keertan

UK Singh · 07 Apr 2004

Guru Gobind Singh Sahibs favourite instrument was a Taus (created by Guru Gobind Singh), Guru Hargobind Sahib promoted the Sarangi. Not a Vaja/Chimtey. The majority of the Gurbani is written in raag format for a reason. Our lack of commitment has surely prevented the uptake of this vidya which is fast becoming lost or being taught solely by Namdharis. Almost all Raagis fail to mention the title of the raag ie The beginning of the raag (the key) needs to be mentioned in order to get the full ras/understanding. Without the title how can we understand the raag in its entirety. <<<<<<<<<<>>>>>>>>> Guru Granth Sahib Ji mainly focuses on mind and emotion. A persons state of mind fluctuates throughout the day. One minute we can be joyous and the next angry or sad. In the same way we cannot pigeon hole raags to be read at particular times of the day. For instance the Shabad 'Lakh Khushian Patshaheean, Je Satgur Nadar Karey' is read on happy occasions, but at no fixed time! However, most Raagis read this incorrectly as they do not start from the Rahau line. There is a mood, and a mood within that mood…something is added in and creates another mood. Guru Arjan Dev Ji started a trend of fusion of music. The trend given by the Fifth Guru…was that South and North Indian music were mixed together. Also, he mixed two, (and three) moods together -aka misharat raagas.

Re: keertan

??? · 08 Apr 2004

These discussions always makes me laugh, so hard!!! We have the standard, so the raags are all "aaa-eee-ooo" and no one can sing along! This is amazing coming from a Sikh! The compositions of the Guru's (yes, they composed Raags as well as Shabds) are disrespected like this -wonderful! The Sing-Along routine is somewhat of a recent innovation, typically from what I have gathered, it would be done during nagar kirtans/parbhat pheris, in the Darbar, one listens to the Raags -I have seen some Gursikh Keertanias perform Kirtan in Raag amongst a typical reinsbhai sangat, who all felt the need to join in and all one could hear was literally "aaa-eee-ooo" all over the place, out of tune and time! There is a time to sing along and a time to listen and experience (re-read JapJi Sahib and one can deduce this for themselves). I opened up by saying this makes me laugh so hard, because we have "Gursikhs" staunchly proclaiming that matters such as Sarablohi Bibek and Keski or Chatka and Sukha (depending on your slant) are part of our Maryada -whether these are or not, is a different debate, but these matters are generally supported through sources other than the SGGS, yet Raags are part of the Guru's written Hukam -why indeed do we get all -wihsy-washy- about them? As per the timing and seasons aspect, I suggest further reading into "Gurmat Sangeet Maryada" will help explain these further and alleviate your doubts -for this is uniquely Sikh and different from Hindustani Sangeet.

Re: keertan

Mkhalsa · 08 Apr 2004

The raag supporters have said that guru sahib himself mixed raags. For reason, to get different moods and different feeling. I think gursikhs are correct in mixing raags, but there is a need for learning more raag "maryada."

Re: keertan

s!nghn! · 08 Apr 2004

While I've come across as sounding fairly anti-raag here, I assure you I am quite the opposite. A few weeks before this discussion even began here, I had resolved to do keertan only in pakkay raags and wanted everyone else to follow suit. In my last post, my sing-along point was that everyone SHOULD sing along and I can't see why people don't sing with raags when they sing along to everything else. I wasn't saying that since they don't sing, we should all stop doing raags. As far as I understand, Jatha keertan is sangatee-keertan, so whether the keertani is doing a pakka raag or not, I believe the entire sangat should indeed sing along. Please let me know where I can read up on Gurmat sangeet maryada. I have only a mostly Hindustani background I think and I don't know much in terms of the Gurmat aspect. My post about times/seasons was what I had learned from my teacher who was very strict about times and seasons as I once learned the hard way. Boy oh boy, did I ever learn my lesson! But I'm all for the "aaa-eee-ooo" in keertan, trust me, and I didn't mean to degrade the importance of raag. You're absolutely right that we shouldn't get wishy-washy about raags.

Re: keertan

uk singh · 09 Apr 2004

http://www.gurmatsangeetproject.com

Re: keertan

s!nghn! · 12 Apr 2004

Thank you so much for that link, "uk singh" jee!

keertan

punjabi kuri · 16 Aug 2005

most ragi's in the time of today compose kirtan in filmi tunes. the guru granth sahib is written in rag's therefore keertan should be sung in rag's. on the other hand i agree that keertan should be done with love.

Re: keertan

ASengh · 16 Aug 2005

YEH.. "I agree!" Lets go and tell Bhai Jeevan Singh to stop doing keertan the way he does and to pick up the taus, sarangi or sitar and start going "aahhhhhhh, saaaaaa, maaaaaaa, niiii!"

Re: keertan

s!nghn! · 16 Aug 2005

Doing keertan in raag does not mean doing "aahhhhhhh, saaaaaa, maaaaaaa, niiii". Doing keertan on traditional stringed instruments too does not mean doing "aahhhhhhh, saaaaaa, maaaaaaa, niiii"

Re: keertan

Dyal Singh · 16 Aug 2005

Why is it that when there is a discussion on raags, some people have to make a point of demeaning raag kirtan, and those that sing it by going on about "aaa-eee-ooo"? Its called "alaap"! Whether you agree with alaap or not, don't demean Gurmat Sangeet in an attempt to prove your point. Alaap is done in raag kirtan, as well as with simple tunes, but doesn't have to be. Raag's and tunes are not dependant on alaap. Keertanya's within the whole Panth do alaap. Sure, some may do it to show there knowledge, but there are others who do it because it is a genuine expression of what they are feeling inside. Another form of alaap is taking a line from Gurbani, and reciting it at half speed, or double speed (or mixing both methods) on the "sur" of the raag / tune being sung.

Re: keertan

ASengh aka "boongawala" · 20 Aug 2005

I've began to like raag after listening to Harjinder Singh Lalli at the Sanjha Smagam, guess its not all about "aahhhhhhh, saaaaaa, maaaaaaa, niiii."

Re: keertan

Lionking · 21 Aug 2005

Author: ASengh Date: 08-16-05 03:57 YEH.. "I agree!" Lets go and tell Bhai Jeevan Singh to stop doing keertan the way he does and to pick up the taus, sarangi or sitar and start going "aahhhhhhh, saaaaaa, maaaaaaa, niiii!" ________________ No lets go and tell Guru Gobind SIngh and And Guru Granth Sahib ji it was wrong tha they invented these Intrsuments and wrong GUrbani in Raag. To mee that comment sounds exactly like the sant samaj people saying, but our Baba ji said so. No doubt BHai Jeevan Singh ji does loads of Paath SImran, and I'm nto critisizing his love and devotion - but Gurmat Sangeet is Gurmat Sangeet, and there was a reason why the Grus decided to invent the instruments and write GURBANI in Raags (or most of it) __________________ Author: ASengh aka "boongawala" Date: 08-20-05 12:38 I've began to like raag after listening to Harjinder Singh Lalli at the Sanjha Smagam, guess its not all about "aahhhhhhh, saaaaaa, maaaaaaa, niiii." ____________________ Harjinder Singh b-ham is DEFNETLY A BIG INSPIRATION for me as well. Myself wasn't too fond of raag before, but listening to him is such an inspiration !!!! You can lsiten to the London SIkhi Week 2005 of the Kingston Kirtan at www.dhurkibani.com - Media -Audio Section Such an inspiration!!! Big time recommended for everyone!!! I want tooo learn Taus nowwwww :D

Re: keertan

khalsa · 21 Aug 2005

ref: raag yes gurbani is composed in raags but guru ji also used the favourite tunes of their time ( which people of those day liked to listen ) to convey the gurbani's message to the general public. you can see guru ji instructions about this in " SGGS" e.g. assa di var "tundey asrajja ki dhun per gaunni" llalla behlemma ki dhum uper gaunni etc the purpose was to get masses attention towarda gurbani. u r point to sing shabbad in rags is not important. why don't raggi sings asa di var to the tune called in the "SGGS" because they do not know that tune. [%sig%]