Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sant Attar Singh and Naam Simran

Sant Attar Singh and Naam Simran

simba · 26 Mar 2004

Sant Attar Singh's biography by Sant Teja Singh Ji Maharaj is very good book and it is a must read for Gursikhs. It has an entire section devoted to naam simran. I'll try to give a rough translation and briefly summarize it to the best of my abilities. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Sant Attar Singh use to always stress the importance of japping naam. Guru Ram Das has given us a hukam to jap naam. (ang 305) gur satgur kaa jo sikh akhaa-ay so bhalkay uth har naam Dhi-aavai. One who calls himself a Sikh of the Guru, the True Guru, shall rise in the early morning hours and meditate on the Lord's Name. udam karay bhalkay parbhaatee isnaan karay amrit sar naavai. Upon arising early in the morning, he is to bathe, and cleanse himself in the pool of nectar. updays guroo har har jap jaapai sabh kilvikh paap dokh leh jaavai. Following the Instructions of the Guru, he is to chant the Name of the Lord, Har, Har. All sins, misdeeds and negativity shall be erased. fir charhai divas gurbaanee gaavai bahdi-aa uth-di-aa har naam Dhi-aavai. Then, at the rising of the sun, he is to sing Gurbani; whether sitting down or standing up, he is to meditate on the Lord's Name. jo saas giraas Dhi-aa-ay mayraa har har so gursikh guroo man bhaavai. One who meditates on my Lord, Har, Har, with every breath and every morsel of food - that GurSikh becomes pleasing to the Guru's Mind. jis no da-i-aal hovai mayraa su-aamee tis gursikh guroo updays sunaavai. That person, unto whom my Lord and Master is kind and compassionate - upon that GurSikh, the Guru's Teachings are bestowed. jan naanak Dhoorh mangai tis gursikh kee jo aap japai avrah naam japaavai. ||2|| Servant Nanak begs for the dust of the feet of that GurSikh, who himself chants the Naam, and inspires others to chant it. ||2|| Naam is very important. Japji sahib says: mooth paleethee kaparr hoe || When the clothes are soiled and stained by urine, dhae saaboon leeai ouhu dhhoe || soap can wash them clean. bhareeai math paapaa kai sa(n)g || But when the intellect is stained and polluted by sin, ouhu dhhopai naavai kai ra(n)g || it can only be cleansed by the Love of the Name. Naam shouldnt' be done for others to hear. Waheguru is within us at all times. Naam is done to wash away our sins. This is why Guru Ji has given us Naam. Bhai Gurdas ji says: vaahiguroo guroo ma(n)thr hai jap houmai(n) khoee|| His Guru-manta is Vahiguru, whose recitation erases egotism. Some people say that Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji has many names, (ie. raam, hari, gobind, satnam, allah, etc.),so how do we know what gurmantar is. Sant ji points to this shabad: (ang 1403). sat saach saree nivaas aad purakh sadaa tuhee vaahiguroo vaahiguroo vaahiguroo vaahi jee-o. ||3||8|| You are forever True, the Home of Excellence, the Primal Supreme Being. Waahay Guru, Waahay Guru, Waahay Guru, Waahay Jee-o. ||3||8|| Also, Guru Arjan dev ji says: (ang 376) vaymuhtaajaa vayparvaahu. The Lord is absolutely independent, and totally care-free; naanak daas kahhu gur vaahu. ||4||21|| O servant Nanak, chant His Glorious Praises. ||4||21|| Guru Gobind Singh Ji has also written in Sarbloh Granth that Waheguru is the true mantar. Raam means that God is within everybody. Hari means that God defeats sin. All these names can dwell inside you ('hirday vich vasaouday hun'). But when a Sikh, in full love and devotion, says waheguru (you are great), then in this Sikh, naam will dwell (es day hirday wich aa wasda ha athay ek khaas rang wich) in a special way. (ang 563) thoo acharaj kudharath thaeree bisamaa ||1|| rehaao || You are wonderful! Your creative potency is amazing! ||1||Pause|| So in conclusion Waheguru gurmantar is the most powerful. In saying Waheguru, all of Gods wonderful characteristics are included (as compared to one or two as in Raam and hari). If Waheguru is said in full love and devotion then first all of that persons sins are washed away (mal dhoor hundy ha), then you feel more and more love for Waheguru, and then that persons love for Waheguru increases so much that that person sees waheguru everywhere and in everything. (ang 846) barahm deesai barahm sunee-ai ayk ayk vakhaanee-ai. I see God, hear God, and speak of the One and only God. aatam pasaaraa karanhaaraa parabh binaa nahee jaanee-ai. The soul is the Creator of the expanse of creation. Without God, I know no other at all. The methods of reciting naam (naam japan dee jugath) have been passed down from Gursikh to Gursikh. But this daas has only seen it written in two places. In Sau Sakhi its says that Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj tells Mata Jeetho Ji that the tip of the tounge (jeeb di teesy), with force (jOr naal), should touch the roof of the mouth (thaloo naal), and at all times keep saying Waheguru Waheguru. Shaheed Bhai Mani Singh, the one who sat and listened to the recitation of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji by Sri Guru Gobind Singh himself, in Bhai Gurdas Ji's 'yarwee waar' in 'sheeha thay gajan dee sakhee', has written that when our breath goes in we should say 'Wahe' and when our breath goes out we should say 'guru'. So from these two sources, and from talking with maha purkhs, I have learned that there are three ways of japping naam: (1) very very slowly moving the lips and tongue say waheguru together with each breath. (2) the tip of the tounge (jeeb di teesy), with force (jor naal), should touch the roof of the mouth (thaloo naal), and (holy holy) very very slowly keep saying Waheguru. (3) with every inward breath say 'wahe' and with every outward breath say 'guru'. (4) ajapaa jaap. This come naturally and can't be explained. Our consciousness and shabad become one. And then: our dhhaarai jo a(n)thar naam || One who enshrines the Naam within the heart, sarab mai paekhai bhagavaan || who sees the Lord God in all, nimakh nimakh t(h)aakur namasakaarai || who, each and every moment, bows in reverence to the Lord Master naanak ouhu aparas sagal nisathaarai ||1|| - O Nanak, such a one is the true 'touch-nothing Saint', who emancipates everyone. ||1|| But of all ways to jap naam the most important thing to remember is that 'naam hajoori wich japaya jaway'. (ang 274) gond mehlaa 5. Gond, Fifth Mehl: gur kee moorat man meh Dhi-aan. Meditate on the image of the Guru within your mind; gur kai sabad mantar man maan. let your mind accept the Word of the Guru's Shabad, and His Mantra. gur kay charan ridai lai Dhaara-o. Enshrine the Guru's feet within your heart. gur paarbarahm sadaa namaskaara-o. ||1|| Bow in humility forever before the Guru, the Supreme Lord God. ||1|| mat ko bharam bhulai sansaar. Let no one wander in doubt in the world. gur bin ko-ay na utras paar. ||1|| rahaa-o. Without the Guru, no one can cross over. ||1||Pause|| bhoolay ka-o gur maarag paa-i-aa. The Guru shows the Path to those who have wandered off. avar ti-aag har bhagtee laa-i-aa. He leads them to renounce others, and attaches them to devotional worship of the Lord. janam maran kee taraas mitaa-ee. He obliterates the fear of birth and death. gur pooray kee bay-ant vadaa-ee. ||2|| The glorious greatness of the Perfect Guru is endless. ||2|| gur parsaad ooraDh kamal bigaas. By Guru's Grace, the inverted heart-lotus blossoms forth, anDhkaar meh bha-i-aa pargaas. and the Light shines forth in the darkness. jin kee-aa so gur tay jaani-aa. Through the Guru, know the One who created you. gur kirpaa tay mugaDh man maani-aa. ||3|| By the Guru's Mercy, the foolish mind comes to believe. ||3|| gur kartaa gur karnai jog. The Guru is the Creator; the Guru has the power to do everything. gur parmaysar hai bhee hog. The Guru is the Transcendent Lord; He is, and always shall be. kaho naanak parabh ihai janaa-ee. Says Nanak, God has inspired me to know this. bin gur mukat na paa-ee-ai bhaa-ee. ||4||5||7|| Without the Guru, liberation is not obtained, O Siblings of Destiny. ||4||5||7|| At all times consider shabad as your guru, and consider our Gurus from Guru Nanak Dev Ji to Guru Gobind Singh Ji as 'pooran gur avthaar'. Keeping this in mind one should: (ang 286) oot(h)ath bait(h)ath sovath naam || While standing up, sitting down and sleeping, the Naam, kahu naanak jan kai sadh kaam ||6|| says Nanak, is forever the occupation of God's humble servant. ||6|| In all times good and bad keep saying 'Dhan Guru Nanak, Dhan Guru Nanak'. A very important point should be made here, that for the first two to four years one should say waheguru with the tongue (methods one and two).: (ang 1362) rasnaa japai na naam til til kar katee-ai. The tongue which does not chant the Naam ought to be cut out, bit by bit. And after this (method 3) will be easy to do. Amrit Vela and before one goes to sleep people should try to do it with the breath. While one is out walking around try doing it with your tongue (helps keep concentration), and then eventually you will be able to do it all times with just your breath.: (ang 319) jinaa saas giraas na visrai har naamaaN man mant. Those who do not forget the Lord, with each breath and morsel of food, whose minds are filled with the Mantra of the Lord's Name Dhan se say-ee naankaa pooran so-ee sant. ||1|| - they alone are blessed; O Nanak, they are the perfect Saints. ||1| (ang 305) jo saas giraas Dhi-aa-ay mayraa har har so gursikh guroo man bhaavai. One who meditates on my Lord, Har, Har, with every breath and every morsel of food - that GurSikh becomes pleasing to the Guru's Mind. A Gursikh needs the sangat of other Gursikhs. Some Gursikhs have done bhagti from previous lives and hence their swas giraas starts naturally. Others have been destined to start abhyaas in their present life and hence must start at the first rung of the ladder. When people start japping naam, they have three main complaints. (1) they feel sleepy, (2) their body feels tired from sitting with their legs crossed (3) and the mind starts wandering. The solution to feeling sleepy is to take a bath in cold water. And if you still feel sleepy splash cold water into your eyes. And if you still feel sleepy, then stand up and for alittle while walk around while japping naam before you sit down again. The solution to feeling tired is to consider your body as your horse. If your body gives you trouble then tell it that enough is enough. You've controlled me for too long and now I must control you. With alittle bit of effort (himmat), then in a few days you won't have this problem. When one first starts the mind wanders constantly, but with time it will become easier to concentrate. The solution to stop your mind from wandering is to think of Guru Nanak-Guru Gobind Singh, hold their feet, and say 'hay sachay pathshah. mada han, chunga han, thayra han'. Bless me. Please allow my mind to stay forever at your feet. Also one should read Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib Ji's bani (salok) and remember the sacrifice that Guru Sahib made for us. And in this vairaag remember Guru Ji. One tear from this vairaag wipes away lifetimes of sin. Also, stay in saad sangat and do sewa. (ang 6) man jeetai jag jeet conquer your own mind, and conquer the world. (ang 74) nihtay panj ju-aan mai gur thaapee ditee kand jee-o. ||18|| I have thrown the five challengers to the ground, and the Guru has patted me on the back. ||18|| The devotee who trusts his faith, shares his earnings, japs naam, and does sewa, his mind is filled with love for Waheguru. With simran and kirtan, and always remembering these 4 things in your consciousness, your soul wakes up and we see Waheguru in everything. (1) (ang 1245) ghaal khaa-ay kichh hathahu day-ay. One who works for what he eats, and gives some of what he has naanak raahu pachhaaneh say-ay. ||1|| - O Nanak, he knows the Path. ||1|| (2) (ang 470) mithat neevee naankaa gun chang-aa-ee-aa tat. Sweetness and humility, O Nanak, are the essence of virtue and goodness. (3) (ang 1378) fareedaa jay too akal lateef kaalay likh na laykh. Fareed, if you have a keen understanding, then do not write black marks against anyone else. aapnarhay gireevaan meh sir neeNvaaN kar daykh. ||6|| Look underneath your own collar instead. ||6|| (4) (ang 468) da-i-aa jaanai jee-a kee kichh punn daan karay-i. Showing mercy to other beings, he makes donations to charities. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ This translation isn't doing it any justice, but I think the main point comes across. As for the methods he says there are 3. People on this forum have suggested that this book shows how a group other than the AKJ does Naam DrirH. I disagree. References are only made to Sau Sakhi and Bhai Gurdas Ji's vaars. These may show a connection to naam DrirH but Sant Teja Singh doesn't say anything about Naam Drirh. To say it does is wrong.

Re: Sant Attar Singh and Naam Simran

guRooo · 26 Mar 2004

balpreet singh jee, could you please respond?

Re: Sant Attar Singh and Naam Simran

Balpreet Singh · 26 Mar 2004

Simba, Very good translation seva! The first time I read this, I was blown away. >>>>>> The methods of reciting naam (naam japan dee jugath) have been passed down from Gursikh to Gursikh. But this daas has only seen it written in two places >>>>>> Slight mistranslation here: not "methods" but "method" jugat is a singular term not plural. So "have" is also incorrect, it is "has". Later on yourself in this quote you say "seen IT written" acknowledging that it is singular ie. ONE method. There's also a slight mistranslation/confusion in the part where you describe Bhai Gurdas's 11th vaar and Bhai Mani Singh. Bhai Mani Singh wrote his Bhagat Ratnavali to explain Bhai Gurdas jee's 11th vaar. So the writer and the story are Bhai Mani Singh and Bhagat Ratnavali not Bhai Gurdaas's vaars. In addition to the two sources cited here, I also would like to add a reference from Prem Sumaarag Granth, an older rehitnama: "oupar saas naabh tay "vaah" say layvai, ar talay kaa saas "guru" say chhoDay. Vahiguru daa jap karai." Sant Teja Singh has listed the "methods" of japping naam. I unfortunately don't have the book infront of me but I'm pretty sure he doesnt' refer to the the first 3 as different methods. They are in fact all one method. This is something I discussed earlier, ie. starting from ONE method taught by the punj pyaaray, the Sikh begins to learn new things and it develops itself into ajapaa jaap ie. unconscious simran at all times. I'm not sure what more to say. You claim that naam driR is not mentioned anywhere in the article. IF someone knows what naam is and how to jap naam, then they can clearly recognise that Sant Teja Singh is talking about the same thing. It is crystal clear that this is the naam abhyaas technique taught by the punj pyaaray. The two historical references provided by the article and the third I've cited also refer to the same method. It is a known fact that naam abhyaas technique was taught by Sant Attar Singh jee and is described here in this article and is identical to the one that is found in the Jatha. Again, I'm not sure how this ISN'T proof of this fact. But then again, I understand that this wouldnt' be clear to someone who does not know what naam driR is. Fact is however, that to understand what naam is and how to meditate on it, one MUST go before the punj pyaaray and receive this gift. One can read as many books or articles about the issue and it will not be enough. The punj pyaaray must plant naam within the seeker for it to grow.

Re: Sant Attar Singh and Naam Simran

P.Singh · 26 Mar 2004

Thanks Simba, awesome read. Where can I get this book from? (I live in Canada)

Re: Sant Attar Singh and Naam Simran

simba · 26 Mar 2004

Veer P. Singh, I personally got this book from a friend. The name of the book is: "Jeevan Katha Raaj Jogi Sant Attar Singh Ji Maharaj (Masthuana Wale)" I suggest you first try at your local Gurudwara or any Sacha Sauda store. Baba Iqbal Singh from Baru Sahib comes to Canada every couple of years in order to do fundraising. I'm sure they would have copies. You can also contact them: Dr. Bhai Khem Singh Gill, Chairman Akal Academies (Former Vice-Chancellor, Punjab Agricultural University) 119-D, Kitchlu Nagar, Ludhiana - 141 001 (Tel.: 91-161-470546, Tel./Fax: 91-161-472119, 406434) Email: [address removed] I'm sure they would be more then happy to send you a copy. Akal Academy is a Sikh school. "In these academies modern scientific education combined with the spiritual education based on Guru Nanak's philosophy is imparted with the objective of producing complete men and women (true human beings)." All profits made from this book would go towards Akal Academy. My daswand goes to Akal Academy every year. Akal Academy was started by Sant Teja Singh Ji as per the wishes of Sant Attar Singh Ji.

Re: Sant Attar Singh and Naam Simran

P.Singh · 26 Mar 2004

Balpreet Singh, anyone can do naam simran and anyone will benefit whether your muslim, christian or whatever. Panj Payarey do instill naam within the GurSikh but still anyone can naam jap.

Re: Sant Attar Singh and Naam Simran

simba · 26 Mar 2004

Veer Balpreet Singh, >> Slight mistranslation here: not "methods" but "method" jugat is a singular term not plural. So "have" is also incorrect, it is "has". Later on yourself in this quote you say "seen IT written" acknowledging that it is singular ie. ONE method.<< My Punjabi isn't the best and any errors are mine. Thank you for pointing out my error. >>Sant Teja Singh has listed the "methods" of japping naam. I unfortunately don't have the book infront of me but I'm pretty sure he doesnt' refer to the the first 3 as different methods. They are in fact all one method. This is something I discussed earlier, ie. starting from ONE method taught by the punj pyaaray, the Sikh begins to learn new things and it develops itself into ajapaa jaap ie. unconscious simran at all times.<< Sant Teja Singh Ji says there are three ways. He says: "So pichlee likhth athay maha purkha tho suni jugth tho spasht ha kay naam japan day drishtmaan wich thin threekay hun" It is indeed very "crystal clear" that he is saying there are three methods. Three. I don't think punjabi has changed that much since back then that the word "thin" (three in punjabi) really means "ik" (one). "...naam japan day drishtmaan wich thin threekay hun." I'm not sure what more to say. As for all methods being being done at the same time...How in the world can someone do this? The first method says to say waheguru together in one syllable, without breaking it apart. The third one says to say "wahe" when you breath in and "guru" when you breath out. How can you do both of these at the same time? The first two methods talk about saying it out loud quietly. Whereas the third method talks about saying it only with your breath. How can you say it out loud and not out loud at the same time? In the paragraphs that follow this describe how one who is starting out should start with either of the first two methods and then eventually try the third when he or she is ready. Why would he write this if he was talking about one method. He is talking about THREE different methods. This just shows that you don't have a full understanding of what hes saying yet you use it as a proof on other debates on this forum. You even have Kulbir Singh saying it. If you feel there is one method then by all means thats your opinion and you should stick to using references like Sau Sakhi or whatever to prove your point. Leave Sant Attar Singh out of it. How would you feel if I went around and told people that this guy on the internet named Balpreet Singh doesn't believe in Sarbloh Bibek, Naam DriR, and what not, and use you as proof to tell people not to believe in these things. Is this not wrong. I know you're not purposely doing this but Singh get your facts straight and stop using Sant Attar Singh to prove your point. Catching grammatical errors on Sant Ji's part is not the way to prove your point. Even before you said that Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh never said that there were three ways. In fact he clearly says in this autobiograph, "It was also clear that this mystic Name could be contemplated in many ways: (1) With the tounge. (2) With the breath and mind. (3) With inner consciousness by keeping the pranasakti (vital breath) controlled in the naval. By every method one could attain the highest spiritual state." Is it not "crystal clear" from this that there is more then one way? Are you reading what it says or are you reading what you want to read? You said that a Sikh learns the one method and from this he learns new things (i'm assuming you mean methods when you say things). This quote from Bhai Sahib's autobiography says 'methods'. I haven't read any books by Bhai Sahib but when you say a Sikh learns one method and from that he learns others (or new things as you put it), is that your opinion or does Bhai Sahib say this directly?

Re: Sant Attar Singh and Naam Simran

simba · 26 Mar 2004

I forgot to add that Sant Ji insists that it is very important that 'naam hajoori wich japaya jaway'. My personal opinion is that 'preem' (love) is the true techique. Guru Gobind Singh Ji says "Jin Praem keyo thin he prabh payo" If you don't have love for Waheguru, and you don't develop that relationship with Waheguru, then I don't think any technique can help you attain Sach Khand.

Re: Sant Attar Singh and Naam Simran

Balpreet Singh · 26 Mar 2004

Simba, The article begins with describing how the "method" (singular) for naam abhyaas has been passed down through gursikhs. It then gives historical references describing the method. And then I should believe that Sant jee didnt' believe in this method? Perhaps through your reading, method 1 is different. I dont' think it is. But I know for a fact that 2 and 3 are the same thing. Even the historical examples given show that. I'm not about to sit here and describe naam abhyaas for you or try to do cyber-naam driR, but I repeat: if anyone who has had naam driR reads that article, they know it is the same method. Sant Attar Singh and Bhai Sahib Randheer Singh jee belonged to the same Jatha at one point and believed in the same rehits. That's why Bibis in Sant jee's Jatha all wore keskees. The jatha was Panch Khalsa Divaan. Bhai Sahib Randheer Singh jee in Gurmat Karam Philosophy describes the Gurmat Naam Abhyaas technique and makes it clear that this is wear naam abhyaas starts. This is THE method for naam abhyaas. From this method starting at the tongue, it goes into svaas and from there it moves on to ajapaa jaap. He makes this clear in the book. But you are right, unless naam is done with love, it is impossible to get any spirtual reward. That's the key.

Re: Sant Attar Singh and Naam Simran

uk singh · 26 Mar 2004

Excerpts From Bandginama ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 1st Stage In the initial stage, we should practise Simran by uttering the Divine Name aloud. But if this fails to result in mental concentration, we might resort to the beads of the rosary. Subdued utterance of the Divine Name and listening to its sound helps us to concentrate. At first, the mind does wander and concentration is dicult to attain. In this tug-of-war, irrelevant thoughts are bound to recur, but one need not despair: There is no escape except through Simran. bin Har bhajan nahi chhutkara Guru Arjan - Gauri. This human life is the time to realize God. Gobind milan ki eih teri baria Guru Arjan - Asa. ================== 2nd Stage Repetition of the Name at times, leads to automatic mental Simran: the lips cease to move, and yet mental Simran progresses. This induces mental peace and joy. As we grow spiritually, mental Simran will always, or whenever we so choose, progress unceasingly. The physical aspect of Simran ends, and mental repetition continues from day to day. The external attractions and distractions begin to drop, while mental harmony with Him begins. All the powers of the mind, which were diffused in external objects, begin to be concentrated, through the sweet, soft, mental Simran. The seeker of God perceives a flood of mental peace coursing through his whole being; the mind is at rest, the lips are motionless, and yet mental Simran continues! Those who are regular in the recitation of Gurbani, especially as a mental process, taste this joy now and then. But it is far more useful and more methodical, to get to the stage of mental Simran through the repetition of Nam. It facilitates the progress to higher stages. At this stage, if we accustom ourselves to the practice of Simran with our every breath, it brings much joy. As we inhale, we might mentally utter "Wah", and "Guru" when we exhale. The lips do not move. This is also mental Simran, and we practice Nam with our every breath. This is the second stage of Simran. =========== 3rd Stage The Third stage of Nam is marvellous. Mental Simran promotes concentration, and the gentle sound that mental Simran creates within our being becomes more audible. The sounds of the external world are drowned in the sound of mental Simran within. We hear nothing but the music of Simran within. The music is pitched in such a high key that even while travelling in a railway train, moving at full speed, to the man practicing mental Simran, the rattle of the wheels is inaudible. The spiritual stage gradually continues to advance to such an extent that we consider even the recitation of mental Simran as super uous. Then the physical process of Simran ceases, but the mind is in union with God, in a state of poise. Now, both the physical and mental stress of Simran cease, and the mind is perfectly at rest. This is called the Sahej stage, whose peace and bliss defy description.

Re: Sant Attar Singh and Naam Simran

simba · 27 Mar 2004

Balpreet Singh, This is ridiculous. Is it too much to ask of you to get a copy of this book and read this chapter for youself? If you want to twist around what the section says and make it sound like hes talking about Naam DriR, then thats your prerogative. But until you read it please stop telling people that hes talking about Naam DriR. If you continue to do so its akin to lying and your avasta will no doubt be affected. In the future if someone comes to you and physically shows you this book and says "what are you talking about? it talks about three different methods, not one," you're gonna have nothing to say and your credibility will decrease and you'll look like a liar. I know using a name like Sant Attar Singh adds to its credibility, but its wrong to put words into other people mouths. Singh, I'm not trying to debate the fact that Naam DriR is a bad method or something. I don't even know what it is. If its similar to one or two of the methods described by Sant Ji then thats good for you. Methods two and three are taken straight out of the references that he talks about. My whole point is that hes not saying theres ONLY one method. As for it being a known fact that Sant Attar Singh Ji taught Naam DriR and that Bhai Sahib and him were in the same Jatha, well this is just AKJ propaganda. This is just a ridiculous assumption and i'm not even going to debate it with you.

Re: Sant Attar Singh and Naam Simran

Singh · 27 Mar 2004

After reading these articles, I have to agree with Balpreet Singh. You probably have to have Naam Drir to fully appreciate what's being said. But to me, it seems pretty clear: Sant Attar Singh is talking about swas giras simran, which some of us call naam drir. You probably have to carefully read the article in punjabee and know what naam drir is exactly. Good job for providing this article. Thanks!!

Re: Sant Attar Singh and Naam Simran

Balpreet Singh · 28 Mar 2004

Simba, I have read the original in Punjabi. I used to have a scanned version of it too. I don't intend to carry this discussion on with you anymore. I will repeat my point once again: Sant jee writes that that THE method has been passed on and goes to give historical references of THE method. He doesn't refer to different methods. Indeed, it seems he probably did write "three methods". But I'm telling you that the second and third are indeed the SAME THING. I'm not going to go on and on about it any more. If someone has naam driR, they know what I'm saying is true. As for Sant Attar Singh and Bhai Sahib being in the same Jatha: it's a historical FACT. They knew each other and worked together in Panch Khalsa. This is nothing to debate. Just do your own research. It boils down to this: I know there is a gurmat method to jap naam. This method has been passed down from Guru Sahib's time. If you don't agree, then so be it. When japping naam, how do you do it? What do you focus on? All these are questions that arise when there is no method taught. Anyways, all I say is jap naam and read baaNee. Guru Sahib will do kirpaa on whoever does this.

Re: Sant Attar Singh and Naam Simran

RS · 28 Mar 2004

Simba said, 'As for it being a known fact that Sant Attar Singh Ji taught Naam DriR and that Bhai Sahib and him were in the same Jatha, well this is just AKJ propaganda. This is just a ridiculous assumption and i'm not even going to debate it with you.' Ahh, so that's what this is all about. I was wondering why this veer sounded so angry. He's one of those people who's always involved in these jatha fights and trying to disprove one jatha or another. No need to get too upset Simba Jee. Sant Attar Singh Ji and Bhai Saahib Randheer Singh Jee were in fact both associated with the Panch Khalsa Divaan. And if Sant Jee mentions 'a' method that's been passed down and gives references for that particular method and it happens that this method he describes (or two methods as you say) is the same as naam drir, then what is there left to argue about? The other method (the first out of three you say) obviously isn't the one he gives the historical references for. These references are only given for and describe svas giras simran (naam drir). So then what's your point? You seem to be trying to find tiny little points, try to paint them into major inconsistencies and then use these in your hate mongering of a certain jatha. Get over it man. Hate mongering and wasting your time to simply try and create false doubts (and not doing a very good job of it, I might add), can't be really good for you. Instead of writing such krodh filled posts (especially about stuff that you admit you really don't know much about ie, naam drir), which don't really do anything but throw up smoke screens, do some simran. It'll do you some good. I can't end without saying that Svas Giras is the gurmat method of japping naam. Those references you posted really drove this point home for me. Also, those who do regular abhyaas of it know what I'm talking about. I used to have doubts about it as well and figured I could do without. I used to sit there trying to do simran, sometimes for what seemed like hours. Sure, it must have had some effect. I don't doubt that. But I had no idea what I should be focusing on or about... well, about anything, actually. Eventually I got Naam drir and started with that. Svas Giras. Amazing. And thanks for the references.

Re: Sant Attar Singh and Naam Simran

P.Singh · 28 Mar 2004

Balpreet Singh, If I create a Sikhi website and tell people to chant Vahiguru, you think this is against gurmat?

Re: Sant Attar Singh and Naam Simran

kaur · 28 Mar 2004

I too have read this book. I think "Simba" jee has created some confusion in translating this piece. From my understanding it is pretty clear that the first three methods or "tthin tareekay" are all a part of the same process. Because it is a complicated 'thing' to describe (how to jap naam), it has been broken up into three parts, the fourth being a level reached by those who follow "the process" containing the three parts (I wouldn't know of this fourth level). Like others have stated on this message board, unless you are fortunate to have had Naam DriR it is impossible for you to understand what the process is and what methods are involved in this overall "process". All you will have are questions...questions that come up all too often such as what do I focus on? How? What? When? Where etc etc. These questions are diminished when you are blessed with Naam DriR by the Panj Pyaray. ------ (1) very very slowly moving the lips and tongue say waheguru together with each breath. (2) the tip of the tounge (jeeb di teesy), with force (jor naal), should touch the roof of the mouth (thaloo naal), and (holy holy) very very slowly keep saying Waheguru. (3) with every inward breath say 'wahe' and with every outward breath say 'guru' ------ This is taken directly from your first post. I don't know maybe it's because I have had Naam DriR that it is impossible to separate these into three different methods. They are all a part of one "technique". The first listed method describes the speed at which you are to move your lips tongue and breath in general. The second goes into more detail of HOW to move your tongue, and again makes mention of the speed to do this. The third goes into the specifics of HOW your breath should be controlled with "wahe" and "guru". So where is the confusion? How can you state that these are three different "methods" or "techniques". "Simba" jee you also state the following in one of your posts: "The first two methods talk about saying it out loud quietly. Whereas the third method talks about saying it only with your breath. How can you say it out loud and not out loud at the same time?" This point here is a clear indication that you have not received Naam DriR. One who has been blessed with Naam DriR will see how this IS possible. You then go on to say: "This just shows that you don't have a full understanding of what hes saying yet you use it as a proof on other debates on this forum. You even have Kulbir Singh saying it. " Wow. it seems like you have a very lucid understanding of how to jap Naam. This shows particularly when you question every tareekaa mentioned. You question every little thing about the translation...examples: "As for all methods being being done at the same time...How in the world can someone do this?..." and.. "How can you say it out loud and not out loud at the same time?" So what makes you think that Veer Kulbir Singh jee and Veer Balpreet Singh jee are using this as a proof without having a full understanding? Just from this one thread I can tell you straight up that they have more understanding about it than you yourself have showed. If you are going to try and prove a point, atleast try and hide your questions (especially about the one method you are trying to argue as being separate) so the readers will believe you have a good grasp of the topic at hand.

Re: Sant Attar Singh and Naam Simran

kaur ! · 29 Mar 2004

P.Singh, I think what Balpreet Singh is trying to say is that you could tell people to chant Vahiguru... But, since you're not Punj Pyareh (Guru) and therefore unable to implant naam within the seeker it wouldn't matter much... The Naam simran wouldn't be as effective.....?

Re: Sant Attar Singh and Naam Simran

Singh · 29 Mar 2004

Next time theres an amrit sinchaar people should get naam drirr and all these questions will go away... If anybody ever sits during amrit vela and wonders what to do...where to focus....how to jaap gurmanter....mind is wandering.....then the amrit sinchaar you went to the panj didnt teach you how to jaap naam. In actuality panj never let a seeker go without first making sure that they learned how to jaap naam properly. Even if they have to spend extra time with the person, nobody leaves confused.

Re: Sant Attar Singh and Naam Simran

Jarnail Singh "Gyani "Arshi" · 23 May 2005

[gurbani] <>vwihgurU jI kI Piqh ][/gurbani] I am not an expert in this field..but here my two cents worth. I have the BOOK at the centre of this storm...and it is pretty clear to me as well that the..TREEKA is ONE....there are just THREE STEPS...towards the ONE GOAL. A naam abhiyasee has to begin somewhere...1....then progress to 2 and merge into 3...Swaas Grass..Naam Abhiyaas through every rom of his body.. End of discussion as far as my "personal naam abhiyaas" goes.... any more and i must leave it to the experts.. [gurbani] <>vwihgurU jI kI Piqh ][/gurbani]

Re: Sant Attar Singh and Naam Simran

Abhiyaas.Blogspot.Com · 23 May 2005

This thread is excellent! Daas hopes no one spoils it by bringing Jathebandiaa or anything else into it. "A Gursikh needs the sangat of other Gursikhs. Some Gursikhs have done bhagti from previous lives and hence their swas giraas starts naturally. Others have been destined to start abhyaas in their present life and hence must start at the first rung of the ladder. " -This is true, without the Sangat we are nothing, we cannot make it without the Saadh Sangat. Bhai Rama Singh Ji used to say that there are very basically 2 ways to do simran: One is just repeating Vaheguru with the mouth. This way gives the person exceptional mental powers (Riddhia Siddhia), but it takes longer for the person to reach the true objective, which is Darshan of Vaheguru. The second method is Swaas Swaas Simran (with each breath). This sort of Simran is taught to you by the Panj Piare, nobody else alone has the authority to teach it. However, if one has done Simran in previous lives or if Akaal Purakh showers his blessings on us, then we come to do Swaas Swaas Simran ourselves. "When people start japping naam, they have three main complaints. (1) they feel sleepy, (2) their body feels tired from sitting with their legs crossed (3) and the mind starts wandering." This is very true. The two things that Abhiyaas can do to you is either make you lazy or make you extremely energetic. The lazy avastha is very bad, because all you want to do is sit down and Jap Naam and do nothing else, and this way we do nothing else and our deh (Body) becomes very lazy. If we don't do something about this lazy avastha, then we will get so lazy that we won't want to Jap Naam eventually. As for the Mind wandering, this is just normal. When we start Japping Naam we always experience this, however, we must not loose hope because that is the whole aim of Simran - to conquer the mind. " I have learned that there are three ways of japping naam: (1) very very slowly moving the lips and tongue say waheguru together with each breath. (2) the tip of the tounge (jeeb di teesy), with force (jor naal), should touch the roof of the mouth (thaloo naal), and (holy holy) very very slowly keep saying Waheguru. (3) with every inward breath say 'wahe' and with every outward breath say 'guru'. (4) ajapaa jaap. This come naturally and can't be explained. Our consciousness and shabad become one." There are many many stages you will go through when japping Naam, and you will spontenously be revieled different methods by Vaheguru himself. But yes, the above points are correct.