Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

REHITNAMA: BIBEK BIBEK BIBEK

REHITNAMA: BIBEK BIBEK BIBEK

Rashminder Singh · 25 Mar 2004

THIS IS A VERY COMMON QUESTION ASKED BY EVERYONE ALMOST EVERYDAY "WHY ARE BIBEKI'S SO PROUDY" "THEY HATE OTHER PEOPLE WHO ARE NOT REHITVANT GURSIKHS" "THEY DONT EAT FROM HANDS OF NON GURSIKH" BLA BLA BLA............ THEN I THOUGHT EVEN THOUGH I AM NOT BIBEKI WHY NOT DO SEARCH ON OLD REHITNAMAAS AND I FOUND THESE LINES, HOPE IT ANSWERS EVERY QUESTION IN DIFFERENT MINDS LIKE ME.......... _________________________________________________________ kurreemaar masa(n)dh jo meenae kaa prasaadh leae j ein kae haathh kaa janam gavaavehi baadha|| Do not eat food made by those who are excommunicated from the Panth The life of those who take from their hands will go avail. Rehatnama Bhai Desa Singh ________________________________________________________ choraa jaaraa ra(n)ddeeaa kuttaneeaa dheebaan || vaedheenaa kee dhosathee vaedheenaa kaa khaan || sifathee saar n jaananee sadhaa vasai saithaan || Thieves, adulterers, prostitutes and pimps, make friendships with the unrighteous, and eat with the unrighteous. They do not know the value of the Lord's Praises, and Satan is always with them. Page 790 Guru Nanak Dev Jee Salok _________________________________________________________ lagae dhivaan mool n jaavai rehith binaa prasaadh brathaavai || Sinful are those who show disrespect while in the Divaan; sinful are those who distribute food or Parshaad in the Gurdwara without living a life according to the code of conduct. Rehatnama Bhai Nand Laal Jee __________________________________________________________ rehath binaa thanakhaahee jaano || rehath binaa jarrh bhooth bakhaano || Without strict discipline they are punishable. Without strict discipline they are like ghosts. Rehatnama Bhai Desa Singh __________________________________________________________ rehath binaa jag mo bharamaaee || rehath binaa nar narakae jaaee || Without discipline the whole world remains deluded. Without discipline they will go to hell. _________________________________________________________ namar subhaav n kabehoo(n) thiaagae || dhurajan dhaekh dhoor thae bhaagae || He never abandons humility. He forever avoids crossing paths with faithless cynics. Rehatnama Bhai Desa Singh _________________________________________________________ kabeer saakath sa(n)g n keejeeai dhoorehi jaaeeai bhaag || baasan kaaro paraseeai tho kashh laagai dhaag ||131|| Kabeer, do not associate with the faithless cynics; run far away from them. If you touch a vessel stained with soot, some of the soot will stick to you. ||131||. Page 1371 Bhagat Kabeer Jee __________________________________________________________ sa(n)niaasee bairaagee jaevai aar oudhaasee yogee thaevai ja(n)gam vaamee avar j koee thaa(n) kaa joot(h)aa kabee n laeee || Hermits, renouncers, Udhasis and Yogis; Celibates and other sects and faiths; never eat from the same plate. Rehatnama Bhai Nand Laal Jee __________________________________________________________ meenaa aar masa(n)dheeaa monaa kurree jo maar hoe sikh varathan karehi a(n)th karaegaa khuaar ||6|| Meenaas, Masandhs, those with haircuts and those who kill their daughters; If a Sikh associates with them, he will not be united with the Lord and will suffer at the time of death.. Thankhaanama Bhai Nand Laal Jee _________________________________________________________ jhoot(h)ai kee rae jhoot(h) pareeth shhuttakee rae man shhuttakee rae saakath sa(n)g n shhuttakee rae ||1|| rehaao || Turn away, O my mind, turn away. Turn away from the faithless cynic. False is the love of the false one; break the ties, O my mind, and your ties shall be broken. Break your ties with the faithless cynic. ||1||Pause|| Page 535 Guru Arjan Dev Jee Raag Dev Gandhaaree ________________________________________________________ jae kurehitheeeae jag dharasaavath paahul peee kukaram kamaavath || thin so(n) varathan naahi(n) milaavai rehi niralaep param sukh paavai || Those who after taking Amrit but commit a cardinal sin; Their company should be avoided (until they retake Amrit) to maintain the Guru's blessings. Rehatnama Bhai Desa Singh _______________________________________________________ BHUL CHUK MAAF DAASAN DAAS RASHMINDER SINGH

Re: REHITNAMA: BIBEK BIBEK BIBEK

simba · 26 Mar 2004

These quotes tell me not to hang out with faithless cynics, kurheiti's, prostitutes, pimps, and just bad people in general. A lot of Bibeki Sikhs don't even talk to other Gursikhs. Explain that. Many only eat from other Gursikhs who they think are hardcore rehitvaan. I say show me a perfect Sikh.

Re: REHITNAMA: BIBEK BIBEK BIBEK

Mkhalsa · 26 Mar 2004

>>A lot of Bibeki Sikhs don't even talk to other Gursikhs. Explain that. <<< who does that?! i know some who choose not to hang out with hypocrites and fakes, but I dont think theres singhs that decide not to do sangat with other singhs, thats ridiculous.

Re: REHITNAMA: BIBEK BIBEK BIBEK

Rashminder Singh · 26 Mar 2004

I UNDERSTAND VEER JI WHAT YOU ARE SAYING AND LET ME TELL U AGAIN, EVEN I AM NOT BIBEKI SINGH....... IF WE STUDY ALL THOSE REHITNAMAAS AND TRY TO UNDERSTAND THEM CAREFULLY WE CAN SEE THAT THOSE REHITNAMAAS ALSO TALKS ABOUT SO CALLED HARDCORE REHITVANTS. FOR EXAMPLE: rehath binaa thanakhaahee jaano || rehath binaa jarrh bhooth bakhaano || Without strict discipline they are punishable. Without strict discipline they are like ghosts. Rehatnama Bhai Desa Singh HERE STRICT DISCIPLINE MEANS SO CALLED HARDCORE REHITVANTS AND IT SAYS WHO IS NOT STRICT IN REHIT ARE LIKE GHOSTS.... NOW WOULD ANY HARCORE REHITVANT LIKE TO EAT FOOD FROM GHOSTS........... REMINDING YOU AGAIN...NOTHING ARE MY WORDS, I AM JUST TRYING TO GIVE YOUR ANSWER. NOW LETS READ THIS......... lagae dhivaan mool n jaavai rehith binaa prasaadh brathaavai || Sinful are those who show disrespect while in the Divaan; sinful are those who distribute food or Parshaad in the Gurdwara without living a life according to the code of conduct. Rehatnama Bhai Nand Laal Jee HERE REHITNAMA TALKS ABOUT PERSON WHO DOESNT KEEP REHIT AND DONT FORGET IT BASICALLY MEANS STRICT REHIT BECAUSE I THINK THERE IS NO COMPENSATION IN REHIT, ONE CAN NOT SAY I READ 2 NITNEM BANI'S OUT OF 5.... I ALSO KEEP REHIT COZ I TOOK AMRIT.. REMEMBER AMRIT IS NOT A JUST A WATER TO DRINK, IT IS COMMITMENTS TO KEEP STRICT DISCIPLINE VEER JI LET ME CLEAR ONE THING, I MY SELF IS NOT STRICT IN REHIT AND ON PERSONAL LEVEL ITS LIKE A SLAP ON MY FACE............ I JUST DID RESEARCH COZ I WANTED TO KNOW DOES REHITNAMAAS SAY SOMETHING RELATED TO THIS AND YEH I WOULD SAY IT MAKES SENSE TO ME NOW......... SO MANY PEOPLE HAVE MISUNDERSTANDING N MISCONCEPTIONS BOUT BIBEKI SINGHS.. AND LET ME TELL AS U SAID THEY DONT TALK TO OTHER GURSIKHS, I COMPLETELY DISAGREE. ONLY THING IS THEY AVOID EATING FOOD COOKED BY THEM. FEW MONTHS AGO I WENT BACK TO INDIA AND ONE BIBEKI SINGNEES FRON AKJ VISITED OUR HOME AND I EXPERIENCED THAT SHE WAS OVER STRICT IN WHAT TO EAT AND WHAT NOT TO EAT..... EVEN MY PARENTS WERE MAKING COMMENTS ON HER BEHAVIOUR, THEN IT CAME TO MY MIND THAT IS IT EASY FOR THEM TO DO THIS... AND ANSWER WAS NOPE ITS A BIG SACRIFICE FOR KEEPING GURU JI'S REHIT. guroo kaa sikh hovai so aisee rehith dhee khojanaa karai jaeharree rehith saahib khushee aavai The Sikh of the Guru should study Rehat and discipline and they should adopt those principles that please the Guru. Rehatnama Bhai Chaupaa Singh Jee VEER JI BHUL CHUK MAAF GURFATEH JI

Re: REHITNAMA: BIBEK BIBEK BIBEK

simba · 26 Mar 2004

Well Said Rashminder Singh What is rehit? What is the true rehit? These are questions that great Sikhs of the past (i.e. compilation of SGPC rehit maryada) have had a hard time figuring out. I personally don't see unity on this issue because no group of jatha would be willing to compromise where they feel they are one hundred and fifty percent right. Each group thinks their Baba, Sant, or Bhai Sahib was the best sikh to ever live since Baba Deep Singh. I totally agree that Gursikhs shouldn't eat from the house of bad people. But none of these rehitnamas say anything about not eating from God fearing, good people. Do they? >>rehath binaa thanakhaahee jaano || rehath binaa jarrh bhooth bakhaano || Without strict discipline they are punishable. Without strict discipline they are like ghosts. Rehatnama Bhai Desa Singh<< Where in this rehitnama does it talk about "strict" rehit. It just says rehit. Again rehit is open to interpretation. To me the word rehit describes someone who at all times keeps Waheguru in his/her mind. A Gurmukh. A person whose daily actions reflect the fear of God. This is a million times harder to do then eating out of certain metals or taking cold baths. To worship Waheguru the first thing we need is discipline. To control our minds from doing manmukh things. This is what I interpret this rehitnama to mean. >>lagae dhivaan mool n jaavai rehith binaa prasaadh brathaavai || Sinful are those who show disrespect while in the Divaan; sinful are those who distribute food or Parshaad in the Gurdwara without living a life according to the code of conduct. Rehatnama Bhai Nand Laal Jee<< Is this rehatnama not talking about hypocrits? We all know these people. They have more Akhand Paths then anyone else. But they don't listen one bit. They socialize. To them its a get together. An opportunity to network. When out in public they treat people like they're their personal shoe shiners but when they're in a Gurudwara they act all humble. This rehitnama talks about these people and how its a sin to be like this. It says nothing about eating their persaad. The very fact that this rehitnama talks about people like this being in a Gurudwara and distributing food shows how some Gurudwara's who don't even allow non rehitvaan Sikhs to do any seva is wrong. I know Sri Harmander Sahib only has Gursikhs cook langar. To me this is a good way to ensure that bad people (as discussed above) aren't cooking the langar. Personally, I would feel bad not accepting food from someone who I know is good person. Someone who works honestly. Whose food is the product of honest, hard work. We're supposed to see Waheguru in everyone. I think these people are pleasing to Waheguru. Who am I to discriminate? What makes me so pure? We are not supposed to hurt anyones feelings. This is a hukam from Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj. I would feel like crying if I had to turn down good peoples food. I don't consider food that i'm eating contaminated if a non-amritari touched my food or the plate I was eating in. Theres no magical conduction involved. To me this is pakhand. I know people do these things because they think its hukam. I respect them for that. But Guru Sahib has shown, and told us to not do things blindly and to question things they feel are wrong. I could be wrong. May Waheguru correct me if my opinion is wrong.

Re: REHITNAMA: BIBEK BIBEK BIBEK

.. · 26 Mar 2004

>>rehath binaa thanakhaahee jaano || rehath binaa jarrh bhooth bakhaano || Without strict discipline they are punishable. Without strict discipline they are like ghosts.<< What??? I thought Sikhi is about love!! Strict discipline, isn't that the stuff brahmins do >>rehath binaa jag mo bharamaaee || rehath binaa nar narakae jaaee || Without discipline the whole world remains deluded. Without discipline they will go to hell.<< They will go to hell? I thought Sikhi doesn't believe in hell? That sounds more like Islam or Christianity. >>Meenaas, Masandhs, those with haircuts and those who kill their daughters; If a Sikh associates with them, he will not be united with the Lord and will suffer at the time of death..<< If a Sikh associates with monas, they'll suffer at death? WHY? What about Sants that helped monas become Gurmukhs? What about when Bhai Rama Singh Ji was a mona? Who brought him into Sikhi? Obviously he had to get sangat of Gurmukhs somehow! Baba Jarnail Singh Ji also associated with monas in that he helped them. If Sikhs dont associate with monas, how will the panth ever grow? How will Sikhs do parchaar to people of other faiths? It has to start somewhere, a Sikh cannot cut off all contact with Mone!

Re: REHITNAMA: BIBEK BIBEK BIBEK

Kulbir Singh · 26 Mar 2004

Someone wrote that he has found many bibeki Singhs conceited or arrogant because they don’t talk to ordinary people. It is quite possible that there could be some Singhs (when I write Singhs I mean both men and women) may not like to talk to ordinary people or avoid hanging out with them but let me assure you that most of the bibeki singhs are not like that. If you had a bad experience, with one or two singhs that does not mean all bibekis are like that. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee writes that bibeki Singhs keep strict rehit of not eating food from non-devotees but from their heart, they always stay extremely humble. They consider themselves dust of feet of everyone. People have different natures and temperaments. Some by nature are introvert while others are extroverts. If an introvert person adopts the strict rehit of Khalsa, he is not going to become gregarious all of sudden. The outside rehit is adopted to preserve the treasure of Naam-Amrit inside the body. The outer rehit is not supposed to change one’s basic disposition. It is Naam and Gurbani that change one’s mind and intelligence. What outer rehit does is aid in doing naam abhyaas and then helps in preserving it within oneself. A lot of gursikhs do naam bhagtee but most of them fail to preserve the nectar of Naam within them and this mostly happens because of their lose rehit. It is extremely naïve of some Gursikhs to think that one’s arrogance or superciliousness is a result of one's strict rehit. We should realise that people who take up rehit come from varied levels of spirituality. When they keep rehit and become full Khalsay, we should not expect all Singhs to be of same level of spirituality. As one progresses in rehit, one attains qualities of gursikhs. Bibek is an important and a mandatory rehit of Khalsa but bibek alone cannot elevate one’s spiritual state, though it does play an important role in doing Naam Abhyaas. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: REHITNAMA: BIBEK BIBEK BIBEK

singhsation · 26 Mar 2004

Kulbir Singh - You will find many chardi-kala vale Sikhs who do not agree that bibek as you are calling it is mandatory. Following from that, it is also unlikely that they will agree that eating strictly and only from sarbloh has an impact on simran/naam abhyaas - I certainly don't believe that is true but will speak more on this after I have kept bibek for a year or so - It can't be any harder than the discipline I keep already. If it is a mandatory rehit, I have yet to see anything that verifies it is a mandatory rehit. All I have seen are interpretations, fraught with the problems associated with interpretations. daas Singh

Re: REHITNAMA: BIBEK BIBEK BIBEK

Kulbir Singh · 26 Mar 2004

----------- You will find many chardi-kala vale Sikhs who do not agree that bibek as you are calling it is mandatory. ----------- I don’t know what “chardi kala” singh oppose Bibek that has been ordained in Gurbani. Gurbani clearly asks gursikhs to not mingle with manmukhs and to do friendships with only Gurmukhs: MANMUKH SIYON KAR DOSTI, SUKH KE PUCHHEH MITT|| GURMUKH SIYON KAR DOSTI, SATGUR SIYON LAAYE CHITT|| This shabad makes it all clear. Siri Guru jee clearly states that “if you befriend a manmukh, don’t ask for happiness and on the other hand if you befriend a Gurmukh, your mann (mind) will concentrate on the true Guru”. If our Guru Sahibaan restricted us from having friendships with manmukhs, how could they have allowed socialising with them and eating from them? After all, there must have been a reason why we should not befriend manmukhs. The same reason applies to not eating from them. SAAKAT SANG NA KEEJIYE, DUREH JAAYEEYE BHAAG|| “Never stay in the company of a saakat i.e. a manmukh. Seeing a manmukh approaching you, run away from far away, before he comes near you”. Our Guru Sahibaan even stop us from being in their company. How can it be prudent for us to eat from manmukhs in the light of this? SANTAN KA DAANA ROOKH, SO SARB NIDHAAN|| GREH SAAKAT CHHATEEH PARKAAR, TEY BIKHOO SAMAAN|| “The simple food of Gursikhs is nectarous. The 36 kinds of delicious servings of a manmukh are like poison.” Singhstation jeeo, what do the pseudo-chardi kala Singhs that you are talking about have to say about all these pankitees? It is a one thing that these “Chardi Kala” Singhs don’t keep bibek because of some difficulty but no true Sikh can oppose this rehit and I have never heard any Gursikhs living in the fear and love of Guru, rejecting Bibek or Sarbloh. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: REHITNAMA: BIBEK BIBEK BIBEK

singh · 26 Mar 2004

Kulbir Singh wrote: > ----------- > You will find many chardi-kala vale Sikhs who do not agree that > bibek as you are calling it is mandatory. > ----------- > > I don’t know what “chardi kala” singh oppose > Bibek that has been ordained in Gurbani. Gurbani clearly asks > gursikhs to not mingle with manmukhs and to do friendships with > only Gurmukhs: > > MANMUKH SIYON KAR DOSTI, SUKH KE PUCHHEH MITT|| > GURMUKH SIYON KAR DOSTI, SATGUR SIYON LAAYE CHITT|| > > This shabad makes it all clear. Siri Guru jee clearly states > that “if you befriend a manmukh, don’t ask for > happiness and on the other hand if you befriend a Gurmukh, your > mann (mind) will concentrate on the true Guru”. Yes ,it makes it clear that gursikhs should not spend time with manmukhs. What does this pankiti have to do with eating only and restrictively out of sarbloh? Nothing. Moreover, how is this pankiti even relevant to what i wrote? Please point out exactly where I have said it is acceptable to befriend manmukhs. > If our Guru Sahibaan restricted us from having friendships with > manmukhs, how could they have allowed socialising with them and > eating from them? After all, there must have been a reason why > we should not befriend manmukhs. The same reason applies to not > eating from them. Again, you are pointing to one particular aspect of the 'rehit' and one which I really don't find that complicated or controversial. But of course, if you're implying that gursikhs who don't eat out of sarbloh are manmukhs then I DO have a problem with that. > SAAKAT SANG NA KEEJIYE, DUREH JAAYEEYE BHAAG|| > > “Never stay in the company of a saakat i.e. a manmukh. > Seeing a manmukh approaching you, run away from far away, > before he comes near you”. > > Our Guru Sahibaan even stop us from being in their company. How > can it be prudent for us to eat from manmukhs in the light of > this? Same point as the one you made before - as long as your definition of manmukhs isn't the one I stated above, there is no argument from me - how could there be? This is gurbani - it is Guru ji's hukum to us - only the most wretched would dare try levelling their own intelligence (read stupidity) against gurbani. You're preaching to the converted - I would die rather than "kinthu pranthu" my Guru's Bani. > SANTAN KA DAANA ROOKH, SO SARB NIDHAAN|| > GREH SAAKAT CHHATEEH PARKAAR, TEY BIKHOO SAMAAN|| > > “The simple food of Gursikhs is nectarous. The 36 kinds > of delicious servings of a manmukh are like poison.” > > Singhstation jeeo, what do the pseudo-chardi kala Singhs that > you are talking about have to say about all these pankitees? It > is a one thing that these “Chardi Kala” Singhs > don’t keep bibek because of some difficulty but no true > Sikh can oppose this rehit and I have never heard any Gursikhs > living in the fear and love of Guru, rejecting Bibek or > Sarbloh. Pseudo-chardi kala Singhs? That is clever and enlightening - Insulting people you do not know...speaks volumes about your mindset. What do these Singhs have to say about these Pankitis - the same thing I've already said - they would no more oppose these pankitis than they would japji sahib, sukhmani sahib or ragmala - only moorakhs would "kinthu pranthu" gurbani. Now that you've posted gurbani that no gursikh could ever have any objection to, please post gurbani which says you must reject food from gursikhs who present food in non-sarbloh materials. Then show me gurbani that states gursikhs must only eat from sarbloh. Before you go on and tell me that these hukums are found elsewhere - remember that it was you who chose to use gurbani for your argument not me. More importantly, I don't want to turn this forum into an exchange of "pseudo"-witty insults, it would be a great disservice to the administrators who are upkeeping this forum, and to forum members, especially young and impressionable sikhs. However, if that is your wish - Guru ji's kirpa, I've never backed down from a fight in my life and I sure am not about to run away from an internet-personality. daas

Re: REHITNAMA: BIBEK BIBEK BIBEK

Kulbir Singh · 26 Mar 2004

Singh, ------------ Yes ,it makes it clear that gursikhs should not spend time with manmukhs. What does this pankiti have to do with eating only and restrictively out of sarbloh? Nothing. ------------ I thought we were discussing Bibek under this thread. I had earlier written that Bibek is mandatory rehit of Khalsa and in response to this, Singhstation had raised his doubts about this. In response to his post I wrote about bibek. Why are you getting all upset at me for not writing about Sarbloh? I was writing in response to Singhstation and he did not mention sarbloh in his last email. ---------- Pseudo-chardi kala Singhs? That is clever and enlightening - Insulting people you do not know...speaks volumes about your mindset. --------- Singhstation wrote as follows: “You will find many chardi-kala vale Sikhs who do not agree that bibek as you are calling it is mandatory.” In response to this I wrote that if there so called chardi kala Singhs who oppose or don’t agree with bibek, then they are Pseudo-Chardi-Kala Singhs. What is wrong with this? I still stand by this and believe that a Sikh who does not believe or keep rehit of Guru Sahib is not chardi kala. ------------ What do these Singhs have to say about these Pankitis - the same thing I've already said - they would no more oppose these pankitis than they would japji sahib, sukhmani sahib or ragmala - only moorakhs would "kinthu pranthu" gurbani. ----------- In response to your childish response that only Moorakhs (stupids) question Raagmala, I can easily say that only “Moorakhs” believe in Raagmala, but I am going to refrain from saying so. Don’t want to condescend to such a low level. I don’t believe in Raagmala but I also don’t believe that the innocent Sikhs who are unaware of the reality of Raagmala and end up reading Raagmala are “Moorakhs”. ---------- However, if that is your wish - Guru ji's kirpa, I've never backed down from a fight in my life and I sure am not about to run away from an internet-personality. --------- Okay I believe that you would not back off from fighting. Vaah Dhan Gursikhi!! Such people as you, who don’t shy away from fight are so rare in this Kalyug. Thanks for letting us know that you are such a warrior who never backs down from a fight. I will keep this in mind, when remonstrating with you. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: REHITNAMA: BIBEK BIBEK BIBEK

uk singh · 26 Mar 2004

Singho - Please refer to the quotes from Simba's post: (2) (ang 470) mithat neevee naankaa gun chang-aa-ee-aa tat. Sweetness and humility, O Nanak, are the essence of virtue and goodness. (3) (ang 1378) fareedaa jay too akal lateef kaalay likh na laykh. Fareed, if you have a keen understanding, then do not write black marks against anyone else. aapnarhay gireevaan meh sir neeNvaaN kar daykh. ||6|| Look underneath your own collar instead. ||6|| ========= Kulbir Singh Ji - As you are now engaged here you stated in one of your other replies on the Ishnaan thread that: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee has written in Gurmat Bibek that a Sikh can do paath like this or if drying hair, so long as he or she is not holding a pothi or gutka, and is doing paath from memory. Can you please tell me where I can get hold of this..? Thanks

Re: REHITNAMA: BIBEK BIBEK BIBEK

Balpreet Singh · 26 Mar 2004

I'm not sure what's being proven here. Gurbani clearly says not to go near a manmukh.....so we shouldn't go near, but we can eat the food they make and serve? What sense does that make? As for Gurbani for Sarbloh: what will we say when someone asks for Gurbani to prove that we need a Kangha? In the same way, Sarbloh is a rehit. I've repeated ad nauseam that the article in the Gurmat section on Sarbloh and Bibek has all the quotes re. the importance of sarbloh. If you still are not convinced, then so be it. If you have concrete proof that sarbloh bibek is manmat or not necessary (besides saying X mahapurakh dont' do it) then please do share. If not, then do as you please and I shall do as I see fit. I am convinced that Sarbloh is a rehit. I havn't seen any evidence it is not. If you can't believe this, then so be it. We have so many other commonalities as Sikhs of the Guru to share, why focus so much on the differences? I guess we'll have to agree to disagree and move on. If we all did this, imagine how much more love we'd have in the Panth today rather than be trying to destroy each other.

Re: REHITNAMA: BIBEK BIBEK BIBEK

Nutter · 26 Mar 2004

If we all did this, imagine how much more love we'd have in the Panth today rather than be trying to destroy each other. dont you find that AKJ sites are constantly trying to prove that Keski is a Kakaar and Ragmala is not bani and yadi, yadi yah! the same goes for other Jatha/Sant related sites...al trying to push forward a particular rehit.....this seems to be a no win situation. Why not concentrate on saving the non-bibekis/manmukhs rather than put them down.. remember "aap japo, avarahi naam japaavoh" spelling might be incorrect..sorry!

Re: REHITNAMA: BIBEK BIBEK BIBEK

Kulbir Singh · 26 Mar 2004

-------- Why not concentrate on saving the non-bibekis/manmukhs rather than put them down.. ---------- I agree that we should not put down manmukhs. The way to concentrate on saving non-bibekis is to tell them about bibek. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: REHITNAMA: BIBEK BIBEK BIBEK

Nutter · 26 Mar 2004

"I agree that we should not put down manmukhs. The way to concentrate on saving non-bibekis is to tell them about bibek." the way to save manmuks in the inital stages is to teach them the basics ie Naamp Japo Kirat Koro Vand Chako..

Re: REHITNAMA: BIBEK BIBEK BIBEK

Kulbir Singh · 26 Mar 2004

--------- the way to save manmuks in the inital stages is to teach them the basics ie Naamp Japo Kirat Koro Vand Chako.. --------- Nutter, you wrote that we should teach them the basics and I am saying that without Rehit no one can japp Naam. We know that at amrit sinchaar one gets Naam from Punj Pyaaray. One of the precondition for getting Naam from Punj Pyaaray is that the seeker wear all kakaars, promise to abstain from bajjar kurahits and keep other rehit. Rehit comes before Naam. Without promising to keep rehit, one cannot get Naam. From the above it is clear that Rehit precedes Naam. Since Bibek is part of rehit, so in order to tell someone to japp naam, one must first tell them to keep Bibek. Amen. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: REHITNAMA: BIBEK BIBEK BIBEK

singh · 27 Mar 2004

Singh - Singhsation = same person By your talking about bibek, I thought you were including the sarbloh protocol. My apologies for the misinterpretation - many people, including sarblohi singhs, seem to use the terms interchangeably. That said, I still should have clarified what you meant by bibek before posting anything. In response to your childish response that only Moorakhs > (stupids) question Raagmala, I can easily say that only > “Moorakhs” believe in Raagmala, but I am going to > refrain from saying so. Don’t want to condescend to such > a low level. I don’t believe in Raagmala but I also > don’t believe that the innocent Sikhs who are unaware of > the reality of Raagmala and end up reading Raagmala are > “Moorakhs” Not touching this subject (shudder). Okay I believe that you would not back off from fighting. Vaah > Dhan Gursikhi!! Such people as you, who don’t shy away > from fight are so rare in this Kalyug. Thanks for letting us > know that you are such a warrior who never backs down from a > fight. I will keep this in mind, when remonstrating with you. > > Daas, > Kulbir Singh "Vaah dhan Gursikhi" indeed. This coming from the person who initiated the insults and patronizing comments. And, for that matter, a person who persists in using insults and patronizing comments though I've asked a number of times to stop with these kind of comments as they create a negative impression on young minds. "Vaah dhan Gursikhi" indeed. - daas

Re: REHITNAMA: BIBEK BIBEK BIBEK

Kulbir Singh · 27 Mar 2004

--------- "Vaah dhan Gursikhi" indeed. This coming from the person who initiated the insults and patronizing comments. And, for that matter, a person who persists in using insults and patronizing comments though I've asked a number of times to stop with these kind of comments as they create a negative impression on young minds. "Vaah dhan Gursikhi" indeed. ---------- It was a pleasure debating with you. When I wrote my sarcastic comments that you quoted in the last paragraph of your last post, I was amused. You wrote that you are going to try out the rehit of Bibek for one year. If you do so, please don't try it out but believe in it being rehit of Guru Sahib and keep this rehit with shardha. Please apprise us of the results. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: REHITNAMA: BIBEK BIBEK BIBEK

warrior*princess · 27 Mar 2004

We should all be looking to be bibeki, there is no need to argue over it. Veer jee started a very good thread..i don't understand why someone everytime has to start a debate. If we want to adopt the lifestyle of a GurSikh, then being bibeki is a requirement.

Re: REHITNAMA: BIBEK BIBEK BIBEK

singh · 27 Mar 2004

Dear Kulbir Singh - That was my intention from the very beginning - my posting questions here and arguing on this forum was a means to an end - namely getting myself geared to keep sarbloh bibek. (Debate, in my humble opinion, is the best way to learn.) Guru ji's kirpa, I will adopt sarbloh bibek and strictly adhere to it for at least one year - that is my goal. For the the time period that I am going to adopt it, I intend to treat it as Guru ji's hukum. That doesn't mean that I fervently believe it to be a mandatory requirement but that I think there is 'something' important to it. I want to 'walk in the shoes', so to speak, and find out for myself, experience it for myself. A year from now (starting May), I hope to be able to share my experience with the forum. Waheguru ji ka Khalsa, Waheguru ji ki Fateh! daas

Re: REHITNAMA: BIBEK BIBEK BIBEK

.... · 27 Mar 2004

"Singh" Veerji, good luck!! trust me you will start to see why singhs and singhnees keep Sarbloh Rehit, it does change ones Avastha. But as Kulbir Singh Veerji stated "If you do so, please don't try it out but believe in it being rehit of Guru Sahib and keep this rehit with shardha." Yes do believe in it while you are trying. Good luck once again. Guru Sahib kirpaa kaaran. I know it made a huge difference in my life and mindset when I first started, and now I can never give it up.

Re: REHITNAMA: BIBEK BIBEK BIBEK

Rashminder Singh · 28 Mar 2004

veer singhsation ji......... i am happy to see that u r not a political type of person and trying to learn more about gursikhi. well done veer ji if u really think bibek can help u in spirtually plss go for it and dont take it personally for a particular jatha or so.............. may be go to some panj pyaare who tells u about its rehit and go for it bhul chuk maaf ji

Re: REHITNAMA: BIBEK BIBEK BIBEK

>>><<< · 29 Mar 2004

BEBIK IS REHIT.....END OF STORY!!!!!!!!!!!