Re: Naam Drirh
Balpreet Singh · 24 Mar 2004
I'm really really sick of this argument. This all started from a section in McLeod's book on the Sikhs which talks about the AKJ. I recall it mentioning that the Jatha amrit sinchaar has the punj pyaaray "vigorously" repeating naam and this "revolves around" the candidate. People have taken this to mean that the punj pyaaray start walking around the initiate. Does that make any sense? They would leave the bata and start walking around the new singh? That's totally ridiculous.
I can guarantee this has never happened in an amrit sinchaar organised by Jatha. Never. The punj pyaaray indeed do naam driR by putting their hands on the new initiate's head, but do not do any revolving or walking, etc.
As for the reference from Bhai Mani Singh, it comes in Bhagat Ratnavali.
Re: Naam Drirh
Balpreet Singh · 24 Mar 2004
"umm",
Yes, teaching how to do naam abhyaas to someone is indeed a very big mistake. But as far as I know, this thread hasn't said anything about what gurmantar is, how it is meditated upon or any other detail of gurmantar.
Perhaps you found it objectionable that I mentioned that the punj pyaaray place their hands on the head of new initiate. If that's objectionable, then it is equally objectionable to describe how the amrit bata is prepared, how it is given in the hands to drink, in the eyes and in the kesh.
The secret of an amirt sinchaar is the naam that is given. That should defnitely remain a secret. The rest of the process can be described and is no secret.
Re: Naam Drirh
singhsation · 24 Mar 2004
????
There are no secret mantras in Sikhi and I'm curious as to what this secret naam is that is given.
How does keeping naam a secret benefit anyone? I'm sorry, but this strikes me as wrong.
For those wanting to know the "secret", here, I'll tell you:
Gurmantar = Waheguru
Mool Mantar = the first pauri of Japji Sahib.
Do simran by repeating Waheguru. Repeat Waheguru with every breath you take. Make it the first word you say when you wake, and the last word when you sleep. With every breath...."waheguru, waheguru, waheguru....." It won't happen at first and your mind will wander but don't stop fighting, a Sikh never stops fighting. Keep at it, and with Guru ji's kirpa, the waheguru jaap will become automatic.
many will advocate different ways of saying 'waheguru' and what to say when you breath in and breath out and where on your body your breath should be pausing, the throat, the stomach etc.
there may definitely be something to all of this, but you don't have to know any of this to start - at worst case scenario, your beginning may be more unsteady than someone who has the above training but the end result will be the same. don't worry at all about it - just start doing simran and Guru ji will show you the way - you don't need to rely on anyone else. put your bharosa in Guru ji and everything will be made known to you.
Wake up at amrit-vela, do ishnaan, and then do simran by repeating Waheguru. Many Sikhs have found that if they do simran before doing punj bania, their minds don't wander as much when doing the punj bania. Try it.
That is it - no secrets.
Simran, naam are the most beautiful and powerful things in the world. The most evil man in the world can become better with naam. How can anyone justify keeping such secrets?
bhul chuk maaf karni - I don't know why but this 'secret naam' stuff just made me very sad.
your daas
Re: Naam Drirh
Kulbir Singh · 24 Mar 2004
Singhstation and "...",
There is no doubt that gurmanter or Naam of Gurughar is an open secret. At the same time, no one person has authority to give naam to a seeker seeking Vaheguru. This authority now rests with the Punj Pyaaray and they alone can give Naam to seekers seeking Vaheguru.
If there is a seeker of Vaheguru, longing to meet Vaheguru, he or she should go to Punj Pyaaray to get Naam. If a single person gives him Naam as many so called fake sants do, it does not help the seeker and affects the fake sant very adversely. Some innocent and ignorant gursikhs give naam to other people without realising how adversely it affects them spiritually.
If any person had the right to give or tell naam to seekers, then what is the point in taking amrit? The whole purpose of amrit-chhak is to get Naam from Punj Pyaaray.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Naam Drirh
singhsation · 24 Mar 2004
Kulbir Singh -
I'll have to look into the statement that only the Panj Piare are allowed to advise others about Gurmantar and Moolmantar - you may be right, but this is one of the few times I've heard this argument, and the first time as relating to Sikhs. The last time was from some sadhu's chela who said the naam he was given has to be kept secret. You may be right but when I took amrit, the Panj Piare never told us that we had to keep anything secret. However, that was a long time ago and maybe I've forgotten - I'll look into it.
That said, I think even those who are not amritdhari can only benefit from simran and path, and it seems almost counter-intuitive that putting one on the path towards Guru ji could be detrimental. However, this is something I will have to check as currently I don't have much knowledge on this 'rule' (for lack of a better word) and am only giving my opinion.
To become a Sikh is something more, of course, and requires Amrit.
yours, daas.