Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Talking to Girls at all?

Talking to Girls at all?

..? · 24 Mar 2004

I know some Singhs talk to the opposite gender without much problem and then theres others who dont do it at all. What is the right approach? Is it ok to have friends or people who're close even though they're girls? or for girls, boys?

Re: Talking to Girls at all?

... · 24 Mar 2004

We're not in a religion which says we should segregate the genders. It is absolutely fine to talk with any one you please.

Re: Talking to Girls at all?

answer · 24 Mar 2004

If you see them as your sister and your mindset is fine, then what's the problem? As long as you keep the topics clean and remember that your not anything more than brother/sister, what's the harm?

Re: Talking to Girls at all?

Singh · 24 Mar 2004

I spoke with a Singh about this topic recently and told me about when he asked another Singh why he didnt' talk to girls. The question was, "Why can't you just talk to them like you would talk to your sister? We should have pure minds..." The Singh replied, "I have confidence in myself that I will be able to have a pure mind and see the other person as my sister. The problem is that I have no control over what effect I may have on her and perhaps she may not be able to have full control over her mind and so because of this, I avoid speaking to girls". Fact is that our minds are always swinging and it's very possible our mind may swing the wrong direction and we may say/do something we regret. So the safe route is to avoid interaction. On the other hand, I remember hearing this younger Singh describe how he went to the pharamacy and the pharmacist was a woman and he avoided looking at her face and kept looking down at the counter as though he was staring at the bottle in his hand etc. This is going much too far and falls into the area of "pakhand". I agree with avoiding unnecessary interaction, but going so far as refusing to even look at a person of the opposite gender is going overboard. It's all about finding a good balance that lets you live in the world and also keeps you safe.

Re: Talking to Girls at all?

.. · 24 Mar 2004

Sometimes it's beneficial to have friends (sisters/brothers) of the opposite gender, simply because you can get more support in Sikhi and I think girls and boys can support each others' sikhi in different ways. Some girls really need to be told (BY THEIR BROTHERS!!!!!!!!!) that they look perfectly fine and beautiful with hair on their bodies/faces and with their keskis, rumals, or whatever else. Girls often need support like this. Sometimes boys may need support or help with other problems, and some bhanjees are very understanding and compassionate (as are many bhajis) so I think they can help each other out. As long as everyone keeps it 100% sure that the Khalsa is a family of brothers and sisters, fighting together as one force. The more you say "girls can only talk to girls, boys can only talk to boys", the more girls and boys will start to wonder about why the opposite gender is so bad, and this might lead to them wanting to talk to the opposite gender for different reasons, leading to "crushes" and what not. Plus in today's society, some Gursikhs hang out with non-Gursikhs who have boyfriends/girlfriends or even just other friends of the opposite gender. If Gursikhs boys and girls can say "yeah well I talk to boys too, but they're my brothers, and they really care about me and help me out when i need help." This way, if they have brothers and sisters to talk to, they might not feel the need to go out and get boyfriends or girlfriends like their other friends are doing. The sister and brother relationship should always be emphasized though, so that bad feelings don't start or anything.

Re: Talking to Girls at all?

Singh · 24 Mar 2004

sure there problems can arise when you talk to the opposit sex but if you just dont do it... all you are doing is hideing from your problems, I thought we where supposed to conqour them? I think its the cowards way to hide from you problems, you could take it to the extreme that muslims do... they hide thier women in viels because they think they will have feelings of kaam if they see their faces, the problem will only get worse when you hide from problems... imagine what happens to them when they do see someones face... they probally do feel alot of kaam... as where somone see's womens faces all the time they dont have kaam but wutever

Re: Talking to Girls at all?

s!nghn! · 24 Mar 2004

Most of us have a lot of confidence in ourselves. We think we'd never screw up. We think that we're such great mahapurakhs that there's no way we could mess up a brother-sister relationship. Well, the fact of the matter is that just about all of us are idiots. We need to face the facts -- it's a LOT easier to screw up than we think. As stated above, even if you yourself truly are infallible and there's no chance of you ever screwing up, you can't guarantee that the other person is on the same level. As for the question of "hiding" from problems rather than "conquering" them, why set yourself up for such a tough test when we fail much easier tests everyday? It's better to not invite the opportunity for problems to arise rather than to set yourself up and take the risk of messing up and living with remorse. But no one here is advocating that no male ever speak to any female under any circumstance. We should just avoid unnecessary closeness. It really is best.

Re: Talking to Girls at all?

waheguroooooji · 25 Mar 2004

speak to them if you have to, but avoid it all costs...its simple. people just make excuses to justify why they want to talk to opposite gender. if shes not your immediate family member (sis/cousin) or someoen very close to the family, then dont talk to them. it seems like 'pind' morals of not letting our daughters flirt with guys are down the drain. i see so many amritdhari girls flirting these days, be it on msn or in person. facing our fears is one thing, but avoiding is the best remedy. if a girl walks by you, dont look at her. Our senses take in and process everything we see. If we avoid them, our mind will not wander. Why do we dream waht we dream about? its becuase we think about what occurs during the day. If we think about gurbani during the day....gurbani will be on our thoughts. the more we talk with our GURU instead of people, the better we will be. i really hope people would stop justifying talking to members of hte other gender. if you wnat to talk to them, go ahead, but dont use sikhi as your back up for it. soory if i was harsh, but we need to get back to reality. we have been living in western society so long that we have had our thinking process change along the way B C M fateh.......

Re: Talking to Girls at all?

Renu · 25 Mar 2004

I agree with waheguru ji. We should all look forward to reading gurbani because it does help us. We should not justify things. I myself have been talking to singhs on msn. Just my unfortunality, I keep thinking about this one singh, even though I do not talk to him anymore. If I had not talked to him earlier, I would not have had this problem. I talk to other singhs too, but there was just one singh that stood out. I realize now that it was wrong for me to fall for him.

Re: Talking to Girls at all?

..! · 25 Mar 2004

I don't talk to girls unless I have to. Truthfully, I don't talk to anyone else if I don't have to. But I think what you have to avoid are the bhootneeyas, like ones that have no self respect.

Re: Talking to Girls at all?

Singh · 25 Mar 2004

yeh well imagine this you havent talked to girls all your life.. so your shy and dont know how to act around them... somehow you get in a bad situation and are just overwelmed by your feelings because you are not used to it... who do you think would act stupider the one who is overwhelmed by his feelings (kaam) or one who is used to being around/talking to girls...

Re: Talking to Girls at all?

Another Singh · 25 Mar 2004

So guys who hang around with girls a lot aren't overwhelmed with feelings of kaam?? hmmmm... interesting. I wonder how you would explain the fact that 99% of people in North America have premarital sex and close to 90% of those vowing to remain abstinent until marriage end up having pre-maritial sex as well. Kaam is a massive force in the lives of most people and none of us are immune. I don't think anybody is saying completely boycott the other gender. It's basically about common sense. Avoid situations that can lead to trouble. I personally think personal, private conversations with members of the other gender are generally uncalled for. All this stuff about being brothers and sisters.. it's good, but face reality. How many of you talk the same way to bibia that you're close to as you do with guys? Do you feel the same way when you talk to girls as to guys or do you get more enjoyment out of it? Would you talk to these same girls in person in front of older singhs (for example, their parents or other gursikhs) the same way as you do in private or over the net? I know so many singhs and singhniaa who have messed up. Once you break this vase that is your jeevan, it's hard to put back together.

Re: Talking to Girls at all?

s · 26 Mar 2004

TO: Another Singh - I'm not sure whether your stats are correct but I totally agree with the sentiment. To: everyone in general. It would perhaps be ideal if guys and girls didn't talk at all and avoided contact but I don't think that is feasible for many people. It might be do-able in high school and in undergrad (as long as you don't get involved in any extracurricalar societies - aka University Sikhs Socieities, Amnesty International, Young Liberals, Student Council etc.) But as you move into the workplace and even some professional/graduate programs, you WILL be in communication with the opposite sex. Depending on the type of work you do, you may be in constant communication with members of the opposite sex. Avoidance works to a certain degree, but I think the key is being aware of the potential danger at all times. In my personal opinion, avoidance leads to shyness and akwardness and that can be a huge hindrance in many aspects of life. I don't have any concrete answer, but I don't think the answer is as black and white as some are making it out to be. your daas.

Re: Talking to Girls at all?

jack dem · 26 Mar 2004

I say dont' even talk to girls, why bother. I think went through all of high school talking to a girl maybe 4 times, and that was when they asked me for some help. Otherwise I never talked, eventually I matured and I do talk with some people. I think Singhs should never talk to women, its kalyug, were not as strong as puratan singhs and that society has changed. Everyone is so into kaam.

Re: Talking to Girls at all?

What i dont get · 26 Mar 2004

girls, girls.. girls. i cant talk to girls cuz im a coward.. i cant talk to girls cuz i mite get kaam i can't talk to girls FOR SHOW friggen, if you feel like ur getting kaam then seriousy dont talk to them avoide them as much as possiblE, but telling people yo i dont talk to girls, thats stupid too, its like keep it to yourself buddy, no one wants to know... or do they? thats the real question.. I dont give...guyz need to start thinking more..esp. about these kind of things.. IT DOESN'T make them more manlier by not talking to girls.. stop being so chauvanistic your not better than girls are you? no your not. So get A LIFE . girls dont wanna talk to boys.. so stay away

Re: Talking to Girls at all?

A Very Old Man with Wings · 26 Mar 2004

I have a question for bhai jack dem. You have only talked to a girl for times. Interesting indeed? Have you not made use of instant messaging services? I am sure you have. I am also sure you have talked to some girls via instant messaging? Is this false information? Is it not true? You do not talk to girls anymore, but your past still reflects on you does it not? If it does not, please tell us how you overcame these things. I am sure you are not and will not be a singh full of kaam, but I would like to know how you can stay away from it and have prevented it. When you talked to girls maybe 4 times, how did you feel? Sorry bhai, but not everybody is like you. Therefore, we want to know how you felt, what you experienced, and what you overcame. Thankyou ji sava lakh shukrea. If you can please describe to us that would be great. I think it would also be vice versa for females. They are definitely equivelant to us. Therefore, we should respect them. If we don't talk to them, it might seem like we're hating. But I'm sure they feel the same way. So it should be a mutual understanding. Bhai Jack Dem Ji, I am looking forward to your post. Vaheguroo ji ka khalsa Vaheguroo ji ki fateh ! Satnaam Vaheguru

Re: Talking to Girls at all?

G · 26 Mar 2004

I agree with - What I dont get -

Re: Talking to Girls at all?

Jack dem · 27 Mar 2004

Just go to gurdwara everyday, and you won't feel like kaam. I watched this program on aids as a kid, and I never looked back ever since.

Re: Talking to Girls at all?

JACK DEM · 27 Mar 2004

I live in Quebec, there aren't that many Punjabi gals to chat with. But we have a small population in Laval. Once I got out of high school, I did start talking with girls, otherwise I went through all of high school not tlaking to them. 2 reasons why, one is I find most teenager girls to be filled with kaam [non-siksh], and that I didnt' really care for love, hard it is to believe.

Re: Talking to Girls at all?

Mannpreet · 29 May 2005

OK, let's fastforward to what this topic is really about: As I have already posted on: http://www.indianest.com/boloji/viewtopic.php?t=146&postdays=0&postorder=asc&start=15 BOTTOM LINE: PREMARITAL SEX IS BAD, POST-MARITAL IS FINE. PERIOD. _____________________________________________________________ I have already explained the MANY PROBLEMS that result from PREMARITAL SEX: 1)SEXUALLY TRANSMITTED DISEASES: AIDS : a serious killer, hello! also syphilis, gonorhea, and genital lice and insects! digusting! but if you guys like that sort of thing then I can't help you... 2)UNWANTED PREGNANCY: (NOTE: condoms are only 97% effective, so there is ALWAYS a 3% risk of the aforementioned problems, therefore abstinence is the BEST 100% safe guaranteed policy UNTIL marriage b/c that the future spouse is someone you really trust and they can't leave you easily after you've married them so they can't use you as a sex object -the women REALLY need to wake up to this b/c guys often do use women for fun although the woman are now also using out of revenge.) This will only result in bastard children with no father whom everyone will always ridicule- is this what you want?, remember that you have the power to create a whole new human being- that's a huge responsibility- so you should be careful of you bring such a person into the world and under what circumstances. That's why you should wait till marriage. 3) BROKEN FAMILIES: where the father impregnates the woman and then leaves her with the kid because there is no legal agreement that the man is bound to so he can simply use the woman for sex and then run off to go wild with another so there is the additional problem of women being disrespected and used as sex objects, so I don't know WHY on earth women nowadays are SO stupid and go ahead and have premarital sex! And what's worse : 4) DESTROYED MARRIAGES AND HIGHER DIVORCE RATES: you can even check statistics on the higher divroce rates in countries such as here in the west in which premarital sex is or serial monogamy is very common, if you don't believe me. Why? you may ask. Well, b/c the sexually promiscuous man and woman have already formed their first deep emotional connection with their very first sex partner so the bond with the future spouse becomes useless, and CAN NEVER and WILL NEVER gain the same level of closness! The marriage will just be an unwanted burden in most cases 4) PERMANENT UNRESOLVABLE PSYCHOLOGICAL GUILT: As a result of premarital intercourse, many couples are troubled by one or both of the partners by feeling unfaithful to their present spouse by having had premarital sex prior to marriage, and this ruins the trust within the marriage so its bound to fail. 5) A MESSAGE FOR THE WOMEN ESPECIALLY: b/c women cannot separate love and purely physical sex as easily as men, AND because women have to bear the result of sex: pregnancy, promiscuous women face even greater problems by having premarital sex as they will encounter intimacy problems on top of having to worry about worrying about raising a child on her own. Everyone knows that the a woman WILL NEVER forget her first love, and that includes her very first sexual partner b/c of the emotional bond established there- same is true of some men. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- In closing, I'm only 22 but still I CANNOT BELIEVE THAT THE MEN AND WOMEN THAT EVERYONE WAS SO PROUD OF AS BEING TRUSTWORTHY AND NOBLE, ARE NOW GOING AROUND AND HAVING SO-CALLED "MODERN" PREMARITAL SEX ! WHEN YOU GET MARRIED TO YOUR SPOUSE, HOW ARE YOU GOING TO KNOW FOR SURE THAT HE/SHE IS A VIRGIN OR NOT? YOU CAN'T TRUST ANYONE ANYMORE! ITS TERRIBLE! ITS A CRISIS! WHAT'S WRONG WITH YOU PEOPLE? WHAT'S THIS "MODERN" GARBAGE OF THE GIRLS TRYING TO SHOW THEIR BUTT CLEAVAGE WITH HIP HUGGERS AND LOW RISE JEANS, DON'T YOU KNOW YOUR OWN NOBLE INDIAN ROOTS? SO ARE YOU A SLAVE TO SOCIETY THAT JUST B/C ALL THE GIRLS AROUND YOU ARE DRESSING LIKE TRASH, YOU HAVE TO DO THE SAME THING? DON'T YOU HAVE A BRAIN OF YOUR OWN?? IF EVERYONE JUMPED OFF A CLIFF, WOULD YOU DO THE SAME JUST TO "FIT IN"? -WELL, GUESS WHAT, THAT'S EXACTLY WHAT'S HAPPENING! WHAT'RE YOU TRYING TO PROVE?? DON'T YOU KNOW THAT THERE WAS A REASON THE WOMEN ALWAYS WORE LONG LOOSE CLOTHES- SO THAT SHE WOULD BE RESPECTED! AND NOW THEY'RE DRESSING TRASHY, I MEAN, YOU DON'T SEE MEN REVEALING AS MUCH OF THEIR BODIES. WHAT IS THIS WORLD COMING TO? WE USED TO HAVE SUCH A STRONG NOBLE CULTURE! WHAT IS HAPPENING TO IT? THIS REALLY MUST THEN BE THE KALYUG: THE AGE OF DARKNESS AND BLINDESS, THIS IS AN EMERGING GLOBAL PROBLEM AS THE WORLD "MODERNIZES"- WHATEVER THAT MEANS, AND WE NEED TO DO SOMETHING ABOUT IT.

Re: Talking to Girls at all?

Mr. Sandhu · 30 May 2005

I think there should be definite limits and boundaries as to the conversations between the boys and girls -just like in Punjab in the good old days where discipline and morality were followed strictly. In this kalyug, I think what people should realize is that boys and girls being intimate prior to marriage is JUST as bad a breach as eating halaal meat. It is utter foolishness to conveniently follow a few rules of our religion on one hand, and then totally disregard the sacred sancitity of our marital codes of conduct on the other. You see these boys and girls- one day they'll have a cigarette in one hand, a bottle of gin in the other, they'll go to bars, they'll date around freely, they'll kiss on the cheeks, on the lips, grope each other, and then? Then they'll come home, throw the cigarette and bottle away, quickly chew some gum to rid themselves of the alcohol/cigarette scent, and the next day? The girls will change from club clothing to politely wearing full sarees and cover their heads, the boys will have a ramaal on their heads, and then these same people will go to the Nagar Kirtan chanting Vaheguru as if they've suddenly become saints. What kind of nonsense is this? Another thing is this spreading interracial dating, I see muslim, hindu and our girls hanging around men of other races more. Now suddenly, we're not good enough anymore. If this continues, then you can say goodbye to culture and identity. I really get sick of seeing all this garbage around me 24 hours 7 days a week, you know sometimes I ask Vaheguru why I have to witness and endure the insanity of this Kalyug. Then I think, maybe its a test to see how strong our morals really are, how far we can really follow our religion when everyone around us is becoming polluted with kaam, karodh, lobh, moh and hankaar, all in the name of being "modern"- when all that modern really means today is to lower your standards, throw away your humanity, and live like an animal. Because when everyone around you acts moral, its very easy to do so. But even if it is a test of our character, we are failing miserably...

Re: Talking to Girls at all?

jss · 30 May 2005

here's my take on it... if guys were to avoid girls and girls were to avoid guys,, then they wouldn't learn how to interact with each other...and when they are adults in the workforce, they'll have trouble interacting and understanding each other... fact remains that in grishti life, we all have to deal with one another...it's impossible to avoid contact with girls or guys..and it doesn't make sense in sikhi to say..."i'm not talking to a girl"... HOWEVER, this doesn't give free reign to go ahead and do what we please....we need to keep everything in balance....and the balance needs to be there so we dont' get caught up in feelings of kaam by being close to members of teh opposite sex and so we don't get caught up in feelings of kaam (because WONDERING about the opposite sex).... for me personally, i talk to my sisters all the time....HOWEVER, what i try to do is not get myself into a one-to-one situation...i mean...talking and interacting in a group is a safe way of maintaining positive relations with people, yet avoiding the stupidness that likes to acompany us in our teen years...it's not a hard fast rule...but it's something i try to do...obviuosly sometimes it can't be avoided...

Re: Talking to Girls at all?

.............. · 30 May 2005

well said mannpreet. your post is blunt but makes sense.

Re: Talking to Girls at all?

Waheguru, Waheguru · 30 May 2005

just talk to girls as you would infront of guru sahib and treat them as your sisters at all times. Simply ignoring them will only cause problems when it comes to marriage or when your forced into a situation like work.

Re: Talking to Girls at all?

someone · 31 May 2005

i think that there is no harm in talking to the opposite gender as long as it is appropriate.... think as the other person as your brother or sister....then think would i talk to my (real)sister/brother like this and if 'yes' then why not talk.....sometimes you have to.... just don't make it a habit....ie....don't talk about nonsense....gossip..

Re: Talking to Girls at all?

fgf · 31 May 2005

jss, i think the way people speak in this society is MUCH different from India, where there is shame. Here you can joke around and in a sense flirt with girls, and its supposedly done as brothers and sisters. to be honest, if you are really in tune with sikhi and want to be a better sikh, its best to avoid kaam or any type of emotional attachment. those who disagree are just fooling themselves.

Re: Talking to Girls at all?

kp · 31 May 2005

whats more disturbing is the fact girls/guys go guy to guy and change partenrs so quickly and easily thereafter.