Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Indian? British indian? what are we :s

Indian? British indian? what are we :s

Ethnic Background?????? · 20 May 2006

fateh jee, im a amrithari and recently, well since i have been in to sikhi i have been filling out forms for jobs or jus any random forms, a quetsion the majority of the forms ask is : "what is your ethnic background"? Well the options that are usually given are either indian, british indian, asian, british asian or Other. where do sikhs fit in to this ? :s to we tick the other box? indian? this clearly shows sikhs are not recognised, but what do put down?

Re: Indian? British indian? what are we :s

J.A.T.T · 21 May 2006

LOL Sorry but I find this question to be funny. Anyway, if you are born in the UK, then tick the "british indian" or "british asian" box.....Or better yet, just tick the "other" option box if you don’t feel comfortable of classifying yourself as “British Indian” or “British Asian”. I am not from England (I am from Canada), but if I was in your position then I will either classify myself as a Punjabi (Canadian Punjabi) or Other or even Asian. But I will never classify myself as an Indian. [%sig%]

Re: Indian? British indian? what are we :s

ME · 21 May 2006

British Sikh is what you are bhai Saahib. Tick the "other" box and if they provide you with space write in, Britsh Sikh. If your nationality is British and you are a Sikh. These are the reasons as to why Sikhs are asking for separate monitoring, as we don't want to be labelled British indian... unless of course you are.

Re: Indian? British indian? what are we :s

ethnic · 22 May 2006

Someone told me once that 'Sikhi' is also recognised as a seperate ethinicity in UK... so yea, tick other and put British Sikh i suppose

Re: Indian? British indian? what are we :s

kirtan lover · 22 May 2006

JATT.. what so funny... British Sikh... always use other and state sikh. As in UK Sikh is separate identity.. as per Census studies.

Re: Indian? British indian? what are we :s

Kulz · 22 May 2006

Hi What a load of rubbish, what country are your parents or grand parents from? The question you need to ask you’re self. I consider my self as an Indian because the state Punjab is in the country India or Pakistan. So you are either an Indian or without a country. You cannot call your self British Sikh as Sikh is recognised as a religion. In the US you have many people who have become Sikhs; they don’t call them self’s as American Sikhs, its just American. We are part of India we are Indian and Punjabi, so that should answer you query. Good bye

Re: Indian? British indian? what are we :s

Bhudysut · 22 May 2006

Vahiguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Vahiguru Ji Ki Fateh I just want to point out that Dass know's some very gupt Sikh's who are working hard to have the term Sikh listed (as a seperate entry) at the next census in the UK. As British law already recognises Sikh's as a distinct race, you can (by definition), put down Sikh as your ethnicity. I currently do this already on all of my documents. I hope this helps. Akaal Sahai Singh

Re: Indian? British indian? what are we :s

PTE SINGH · 22 May 2006

The question asks your ethnicity not your religion. Your ethnic origin will always be Indian regardless of your political or religious affiliation. Ethnicity has nothing to do with religion. One can change their religion but not their ethnic build up. To answer otherwise would be falsifying your form. Sikhs are only regarded as a race in the UK in the same way that Jews are, because most Sikhs and Jews come from a single race of people, this will inevitably change as the religion grow. [%sig%]

Re: Indian? British indian? what are we :s

uk wala · 22 May 2006

In a local census we recieved in the 'background' section options were: Indian Pakistani Sikh Chinese Other Dil khush hogiya knowing that I didnt have to associate myself with India. [%sig%]

Re: Indian? British indian? what are we :s

Yuk · 22 May 2006

I would never call myself British Asian. Asian is a common grouping and completely inappropriate.

Re: Indian? British indian? what are we :s

J.A.T.T · 22 May 2006

Indian is not ethnicity, but a nationality! LOL Anyway, I find the question to be funny because it's just such an easy question to answer. Just use your common sense mang! [%sig%]

Re: Indian? British indian? what are we :s

JS · 23 May 2006

British Law has defined Sikh as an ethnic group( Mandala Case 1983). In a recent survey in the UK it was found that there were huge differences between Sikhs , Hindus and Muslims of Indian origin. It would help that forms that check for ethnicity had Sikh on them so that resources in education and ,jobs (5Ks are inissue in some jobs) can be considered. A Gujrati Brahmin has nothing in common with a Sikh of Punjabi background.

Re: Indian? British indian? what are we :s

facts · 23 May 2006

sikh = religion indian/british/canadian = nationality ethnicity = JATT [%sig%]

Re: Indian? British indian? what are we :s

Manvir Singh Khalsa · 23 May 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh. Sikhs are considered a ETHNIC and RACIAL group in the UK (like the Jews) according to the British Law. So I suggest that on a form you tick "OTHER" and write down "SIKH". Some counties and councils in UK have implemented changes and updated the forms to include the option of ticking "SIKH" for ethnicity/racial group, for example Slough and certain areas in Midlands. You can approach your local council to update the forms, and they will most likely do so (if there are enough Sikhs in you area) as this will also help with Ethnic monitoring and ensuring the Sikh community's needs are being fulfilled. So this helpful for the Sikhs so we know how we are getting along and can get funding and projects to be set up for specific things highlighted by ethnic monitoring (e.g. health, education etc) and it helps the government to understand the Sikh community's needs and measure our progress. In regards to NATIONALITY. Whichever country you have CITIZENSHIP to, that is your NATIONALITY. So if you have a BRITISH PASSPORT then your nationality is BRITISH. If you have an INDIAN PASSPORT then your nationality is INDIAN. Bhul chuk Maaf. Daas, Manvir Singh

Re: Indian? British indian? what are we :s

..... · 23 May 2006

for ethnicity, i tick other...then write "Sikh" im a British Sikh :-)