Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

a mistake made me

a mistake made me

Searcher · 30 Dec 2003

fateh, my cuzin just came over to my house, and he brought with him a package of pot of gold chocolates, it was the blue box ones, it said truffle, my cuzin said they have no alcohol i took one, and ate half of it, it tasted very sweet, and then i looked at the back of the box, and it said sorbitol, so im just like hmm what could that be, i checked on dictionary.com, and found it was alchohol, truffles i knew them to be alcholish, btu now i have just made a mistake well im not really intoxicated but a bad mistake has been commited for that reason i just do ardaas to guru sahib for forgiveness, i think that is okay?? wjkk wjkf

Re: a mistake made me

chemist · 30 Dec 2003

sorbitol is a sweetning agent so u dont need to worry

Re: a mistake made me

Singhstah · 30 Dec 2003

Waheguroo ji ka khalsa waheguroo ji ki fateh I think it will ne alright if you do an ardaas, but you should always ccheck for yourself.

Re: a mistake made me

Mkhalsa · 30 Dec 2003

sorbitol is not drinking alcohol. so its not sharab. If you were to drink it, you wouldnt get drunk but very sick and probably die. so i dont know if it could be counted as such.

Re: a mistake made me

PESH!!!!!!!! · 30 Dec 2003

In this case, you havent done it knowingly. But still PESH is required. Its a kureth, The panj will guide you.

Re: a mistake made me

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 31 Dec 2003

jee its not liek u picked up a bottle and drank it, its juss a mistake that u did'nt meen 2 do.

Re: a mistake made me

Searcher · 31 Dec 2003

do i really require pesh? if guru ji knows that i kinda did it by accident, then why do i need pesh i niever literaly picked up a bottle of wine, my intention is to never consume alchol in any way..

Re: a mistake made me

. · 31 Dec 2003

it was an accident ji, i dont think u have to go to the punj if Guru Jee knows it was an accident... If you do ardaas, your Guru will forgive u, as long as u didnt mean it and the ardaas comes from the heart.

Re: a mistake made me

kakaree · 31 Dec 2003

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh I have been thinking on this issue recently. Seems to me that when restriction was given it was first for tobacco. Now it includes intoxicants- alchohol. Was the intent was to prevent drunkeness? It seems likely. Alchohol is used for its preservative properties not only in alcholic beverages but in some medicines, tinctures and flavorings. Take vanilla for instance, 35% alchohol, a 1/2 tsp or teaspoon means 35% of that amount spread over an entire recipie. If it is in something that is cooked or baked the alchohol completely evaporates. In any case 1/3-1/6th tsp of alchohol could hardly intoxicate anyone, and in fact though it smells great is exptremely bitter. But since it can now be purcased in powdered form we can use instead this at home. Onetime when we were traveling through the south western states. One of the girls had been into a grocery store. She told us an Indian man (native american) had asked her to buy hair spray. So she went back inside and bought for him. By the time she had told us and we were wondering about it, we were again approached and asked to buy hairspray. We declined. This happened several more times. When we stopped for gas, we asked the attendant why we were being approached to buy hair spray. The answer was for the alchohol content. The contents were sprayed into water and drunk by desperate alchoholics. Such people will drink cough sryup and anything they can get their hands on with alchohol in it- for the intoxicant. Alchoholism is a very terrible disease ruining the lives of not only the alchoholic, but often their families. Our guru gave us practical wisdom. Lets not turn it into something impractical or ritualize it beyond its intent. It is insulting to guru and undermines good and common sense, debasing the precept of the foundation upon which rehit stands. But let's take this one step further. It's also probably good common sense NOT to eat too many chocolates ;)

Re: a mistake made me

Kulbir Singh · 31 Dec 2003

Whether the candy you ate had alcohol or not is beyond the question. The reality is that by eating from outside, i.e. food cooked by manmukhs, you have violated the rehit of Khalsa. Bibek is an important rehit and should not be violated. A person who eats from people who smoke, cannot be a bhagat. It is just not possible. The factories where they make candies and chocolates are not suitable for Gursikhs. The people who work there smoke, eat meat and also drink. Eating food cooked by them is not right for a Gursikh. Please read Gurmat Bibek book, by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee. Bhai Sahib has made it clear that eating from the hands of non-devotees is very wrong. He has quoted many Gurbani pankitiyaan to prove this point. Bhai Sahib himself kept bibek and Sarbloh against all odds. He stayed in jail from 16 years but kept his bibek. To keep his bibek he had to stay hungry for up to 40 days on one occasion. Our elder veers like Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee made so many sacrifices to keep this rehit. Why are we getting so lax? Why are we getting so lazy and careless about keeping rehit? Not keeping rehit is one of the reasons why Panth is not in chardi kala at this time. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: a mistake made me

Sarabjit Singh · 31 Dec 2003

Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa Vaheguru ji ki Fateh, Veerjio, I have a question for you. If Guru Gobind Singh can eat the food prepared by his cook, Gangu, then what prevents us from eating food prepared by non-SIkhs as long as its clean and hygienic?

Re: a mistake made me

rehit important cos · 31 Dec 2003

JAB EH GAHE BIPRAN KI REET MEIN NA KAROON INN KI PARTEET

Re: a mistake made me

. · 31 Dec 2003

>>Not keeping rehit is one of the reasons why Panth is not in chardi kala at this time. << yes, but that's more related to not keeping the actual important rehat like -not doing simran -not doing amrit vela -not doing selfless seva -not doing joreya dhee seva -NOT HAVING PANTHIC EKHTA AND CREATING YER OWN REHAT -not giving up punjabi/indian culture & brahminism, etc. etc. -not seeing everyone as equal -having ego problems -not embodying the concept of universal love. -seeing other people as lower than you (be it children, woman, 'manmukhs', non sikhs, 'moneh', etc..) -having problems with other sikh groups (fighting within the panth) it has very little to do with where people eat from, i mean, read the guru granth sahib jee... it says everyone is equal.. we should try to focus on that thought first. my cousin kept bibeki and he still did stupid manmukhi stuff on the side.. it seems like a ritual.. look at the more important stuff !! (simran sangat seva pyaar --> sikhi)

Re: a mistake made me

kakaree · 31 Dec 2003

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh Respectfully difficulties of panth is the focus on differences or singularities rather than oneness. How can there be chardi kalaa then there is disagreement. pointing of fingers. a feeling of being better than another?When one sees not the distinghishing marks but the similarities of ONE light, one spark of the divine in everyeye of the creators creation, whatever the station of life, Then and, likely then only, will there be charii kalaa.

Re: a mistake made me

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 31 Dec 2003

yah sarbjit singh brings up an ultra super point it becomes discrimination

Re: a mistake made me

simba · 31 Dec 2003

Kulbir Singh said "A person who eats from people who smoke, cannot be a bhagat. It is just not possible." I am interested in how you came to this conclusion. I assume you formulated this after reading Bhai Sahib's book. As i do not know punjabi well enough to read Bhai Sahib's book with a good understanding, i would appreciate it if you could point out the "Gurbani pankitiyaan" that prove this.

Re: a mistake made me

Searcher · 01 Jan 2004

I do not keep sarbloh bibek. and i don't think i can rite now either. my mother is not amritdhari she makes all the food.

Re: a mistake made me

Kulbir Singh · 01 Jan 2004

SarbjitSingh wrote: ------------ I have a question for you. If Guru Gobind Singh can eat the food prepared by his cook, Gangu, then what prevents us from eating food prepared by non-SIkhs as long as its clean and hygienic? ------------ Please realize that Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee did not have a separate kitchen or cooks to cook food for himself. Siri Guru jee was the complete embodiment of humility. He could have never done this. He used to eat langar prepared by his beloved Sikhs. There is no question of him eating from the hands of Gangu Brahmin. The question is that if Gangu was not the cook of Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee, then why do they call him Gangu Rasoyeeya. The answer is that firstly he was normally known as Gangu Brahmin but some people used to call him “Rasoyee” (kitchen). He had a perpetual bad temper and used to get irritated over trivial matters. In Punjabi such person is said to be “Garam Subhaa vaalaa” meaning hot-natured. Since kitchen is always hot due to cooking of food on stove, they started calling him rasoyee. From rasoyee, it became “Rasoyiya”. Don’t even think that Siri Guru jee had a separate kitchen or cook. He used to eat from normal Guru ka Langar. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: a mistake made me

Kulbir Singh · 01 Jan 2004

Unknown writer wrote: ------- it has very little to do with where people eat from, i mean, read the guru granth sahib jee... it says everyone is equal.. we should try to focus on that thought first. -------- Guru Sahib writes that everyone has the same light of Vaheguru in them. Guru Sahib talks about a different spiritual state here. If we take this logic, then we should be able to eat tobacco too because after all, tobacco too is not without the light of Vaheguru jee. So, the presence of light of Vaheguru in all does not mean that we should eat from the hands of Manmukhs. What would you say about the Gurbani Panktiyaan that ask us to stay away from the sangat of Manmukhs? ------ my cousin kept bibeki and he still did stupid manmukhi stuff on the side.. it seems like a ritual.. ------ As for your cousin, who kept bibek and did not do simran and baani, I agree with you. We must keep baani and simran going along with rehit. But bear in mind that the outer rehit comes before simran. Unless we keep punj kakaars, give up 4 cardinal evils, give daswandh and keep bibek, our simran and baani does not get accepted by Guru Sahib. If necessary we will provide Gurbani quotes to backup our claim that unless we keep rehit and obey other hukams of Guru Sahib, our simran and kirtan does not get accepted by Siri Guru jee. The outer rehit is something that we cannot refuse. We must keep it to stay in Sikhi. Does a Sikh have the option to not do ishnaan and compensate with more baani? The answer is no. Same holds true for giving up 4 kurahits. Can a Gursikh compensate for not giving up smoking or meat by doing more paath or simran? The answer again is no. How about Daswandh? Can a Gursikh not give daswandh and do more simran to compensate for this? The answer is again no. We should use exactly the same logic for Bibek. Ones who don’t keep bibek i.e. not eating from the hands of non-devotees cannot get full benefit of Baani. According to baani, they cannot have Vaheguru residing in their hearts. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: a mistake made me

Kulbir Singh · 01 Jan 2004

------ I assume you formulated this after reading Bhai Sahib's book. As i do not know punjabi well enough to read Bhai Sahib's book with a good understanding, i would appreciate it if you could point out the "Gurbani pankitiyaan" that prove this. ------- SANTAN KA DAANA ROOKHA, SO SARB NIDHAAN|| GREH SAAKAT CHHATEEH PARKAAR, SO BIKHOO SAMAAN|| (The simple food of Gursikhs is like nectar. The 36 kinds of delicious dishes of non-devotees are like poison) This pankiti clearly proves that we are to avoid the “poisonous” food of non-devotees. VEDEENA KEE DOSTI, VEDEENA KA KHAAN|| SIFTEE SAAR NA JANANEE, SADA VASAI SHAITAAN|| (Friendship with non-devotees and eating from non-devotees, causes evil to reside in one’s mind. Such person can never know the nectarous naam of Vaheguru” Please read Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee’s Gurmat Bibek and if you cannot understand it, ask your parents or friends for meanings. But do try to read it yourself. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: a mistake made me

Searcher · 01 Jan 2004

gurfateh, Okay.. aren't some foods machine generatad..ie.. chocolate, chips, pop, anything of that sort????????? other things: not all gurdwara sahibs have amritdharis making langar, so guru ka langar should be prepared by amritdharis, atleast thats what is done in india we live in canada, and in canada its not always amritdhari preparing langars, its those who do khandpaths, anybody, anyone, even if they are not amrithdari, so the question is: if non amritdharis cook langar, we should not eat it? But if its guru ka langar and its encouraged to eat guru ka langar, then we cant eat it?????????

Re: a mistake made me

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 01 Jan 2004

now if u wanna be a true "bibeki" u gotta get ur own fasasl as the attah is proseessed by non-amritdharis normally goraye smoking n' stuff including the water and stuff butter milk............. how and where will the line be drawn?

Re: a mistake made me

s · 01 Jan 2004

its not intentional.. mistake happens.. no worries.. just do ardaas

Re: a mistake made me

Hara Kiri · 02 Jan 2004

u shud still get peshed, many people think of peshi as something extreme, but it better to answer to punj payaray than dharam raaj. i think most people will agree to that, and also raw items are considered pure, so water, milk etc. is ok.

Re: a mistake made me

Kulbir Singh · 02 Jan 2004

It looks like you guys have not been reading all the messages on this forum. The same arguments keep popping up and it does not make sense debating the same thing every week. Maybe the admins should have FAQs about rehit and answer all the questions once and for all. ------ now if u wanna be a true "bibeki" u gotta get ur own fasasl as the attah is proseessed by non-amritdharis normally goraye smoking n' stuff ------ Ghabroo jee, please realize that if you are a true seeker of Vaheguru, then you should not comment on something you are not sure of. Do you think, Singhs like Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee, Bhai Fauja Singh jee were ill-informed when they kept the Sarblohi Bibeki rehit? I suggest that you read Gurmat literature on Bibek and then form your opinion. Why should we have to grow our own fasal to keep bibek? This question of yours, proves that you are not fully aware of what bibek is. Bibek is not about raw-materials or ingredients used for cooking. It is about cooking food. Bibek means eating food "COOKED" by amritdharis. It does not apply on "GROWING" basic food like grains or flour etc. It applies to cooking and money used for buying ingredients for cooked food. You can confirm with all panthic organizations who keep bibek for more details. AKJ is not the only one who keeps this rehit. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: a mistake made me

Searcher · 02 Jan 2004

1. All i can say is that it wasn't my intention to consume alcohol. 2. First of all, my cuzin (whos also amritdhari) ate the same chocolates, also his mother(who is also amritdhari) said take teh chocolates and finsih them, so he said to me "they have no alcohol" cuz ont he box it said it didnt, hes only in grade 6.. so i took one, bit half, and it tasted sweet, i looked at the ingredients of the box and it said. 0.8 g sorbitol i think for the whole box, so i wanted to know what sorbitol was, and i checked on dictionary.com, and it said sweet crystaline alcohol , and i was like i consumed alchohol! we throwed the box away.. i just went mental after that, not because of the physical after effects of the chocolate, but because of the mental effects that went to me, like i consumed alcohol bla bla bla.. but i cooled down later, the point is it wasn't intentional, so i dont feel like i should get pesh for it. hara kiri said:: Author: Hara Kiri Date: 01-01-04 20:57 u shud still get peshed, many people think of peshi as something extreme, but it better to answer to punj payaray than dharam raaj. i think most people will agree to that, and also raw items are considered pure, so water, milk etc. is ok. ---but i have already done ardaas, god watches all our actions, and chitar gupt record them, so i guess its all good, and in the end, we have to answer to god anyways,--- rite now, i just went to look for the definition of sorbitol it says that sorbitol is: A white, sweetish, crystalline alcohol, C6H8(OH)6, found in various berries and fruits or prepared synthetically and used as a flavoring agent, a sugar substitute for people with diabetes, and a moisturizer in cosmetics and other products. *okay now sorbitols found in various fruits and berries???? to what extreme can we take this..????????? bibekis are allowed to eat fruits, but even some fruits have alchol?????? btw this is the defintion of a truffle Any of various chocolate confections, especially one made of a mixture including chopped nuts, rolled into balls and covered with cocoa powder. kulbir singh said: i have disobeyed the rehit of the khalsa... >>>>>>>> Whether the candy you ate had alcohol or not is beyond the question. The reality is that by eating from outside, i.e. food cooked by manmukhs, you have violated the rehit of Khalsa. Bibek is an important rehit and should not be violated. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> teek ah..i understand that bibek is important for khalsa rehit, but i also understand that naam rehit is more important for gursikhs of today the most important things: sewa, simran, bani, bana, maybe we shud focus on those more, because ourmind can only become clean we have naam.. wjkk wjkf bhul chuk de kima

Re: a mistake made me

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 02 Jan 2004

well thank u i have now learnt kulbir vir ji does'nt change my view on it, but 2 each his own eh?

Re: a mistake made me

Singh · 02 Jan 2004

Kulbir Singh "Singhs like Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee, Bhai Fauja Singh jee were ill-informed when they kept the Sarblohi Bibeki rehit? " Yes but Bhai Rama Singh never kept Sarbloh bibek and he was also a Sikh of extremly high calibre. Another point which should be added to this discussion is that Guru Nanak ate from Bhai Lalo when he went to his home. Bhai Lalo was full of humbleness and Guru Ji ate his food, although he was not an Amridhari. I have never heard of Guru Nanak going to his humble home and first giving him Charan Pahul Da AMRIT and then eating his food. The quotes from Guru Granth Sahib Ji also depend on interpretation, for example SANTAN KA DAANA ROOKHA, SO SARB NIDHAAN|| GREH SAAKAT CHHATEEH PARKAAR, SO BIKHOO SAMAAN|| You say (The simple food of Gursikhs is like nectar. The 36 kinds of delicious dishes of non-devotees are like poison) For me Guru Ji is showing how the simple food of Saints although is simple is superior then beautiful foods of people who are bad. Therefor Guru Ji is not saying we can only eat from Amrdhari’s here at all in my opinion. Guru Ji is pointing out how Saintly people may have less wealth and quality food, but still what little they have is superior to great delicacies enjoyed by sinful people. This quote can easily be applied to Bhai Lalo who Guru Nanak ate from although his food was plain, where as food enjoyed by bad people in some cases Amridhari’s like Badal is worse although in worldly terms a better.

Re: a mistake made me

charandaasi · 04 Jan 2004

Were the 4 sahibzadas sarbloh bibeki? If so, then how did they drink milk from Moti Mehra who risked his life to feed them?

Re: a mistake made me

Kulbir Singh · 04 Jan 2004

-------- Were the 4 sahibzadas sarbloh bibeki? If so, then how did they drink milk from Moti Mehra who risked his life to feed them? ------ All we know is that even ordinary Singhs of Guru Gobind Singh jee can give their life for the rehit of Khalsa including Bibek and Sarbloh. Brahmgiyani Saahibzaadas certainly would have kept their rehit. They were so strict about maryada that they even refused to say "Salaam" and said Fateh in the court of Vazeer Khan. The story of Moti Mehra is not found in the old historical texts like Pracheen Panth Prakaash or Gur Shobha Granth by Sainapat. It is probably a creation of modern Dhaadees who needed some masala to the story of the Sahibzaadas. I don't think such stories are based on truth. Even if Moti Mehra's story is true, how do we know that he gave them cooked food? Maybe he gave them fruits or other uncooked food like nuts that Singhs are allowed to consume. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee in jail survived for years on fruit alone. Tomorrow some one can claim that Bhai Sahib used to get fed by the British food in jail. Should we believe such false stories? Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: a mistake made me

Jagroop Singh · 04 Jan 2004

Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh! Sadh Sangat Jio, Can a Gursikh tell me wheteher sorbitol is in fact alcohol or not. Yesterday i ate a Muesli bar and realised that it has Sorbitol in it. Should i not be consuming sorbitol because it IS alcohol? Thanks. Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh!

Re: a mistake made me

Kirpan · 05 Jan 2004

man.. sorbitols in fruits too, fruits such as berries..