Sikhs are a Nation NOT a Religion!!!
Jagroop Singh · 27 Dec 2003
Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh! Sadh Sangat Jio, Please find pasted the opinions of a prominent 'Panthic' Sikh Activist and close friend, Jagdeesh Singh. His points make excellent reading, pushing the need for 'Ethnic Recognition' for Sikhs. The UK Sikhs are striving to get seperate ethnic recognition...hopefully the Sangat out there realises the importance of this (especially with the current France scenario) and is trying to do the same... If not, please consider and action this important initiative. Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh! -------------------------------------------------------------------- "Sikh Gurus never meant us to be a religion. They meant us to be a full-fledged people, a nation, a PANTH - defined and driven by a comprehensive ethical human culture" NATIONHOOD NOT RELIGION! Dear fellow Sikhs across the globe: I take this opportunity to briefly and respectfully share with you my potent concerns over the continued use and imposition of the term 'religion' and 'religious' on the Sikhs and their matters. Please read and consider the following substantive points and questions. These invite careful thought and a response to key fundamental points. 1. Firstly, the term 'religion' is a vague, stigmatized and legally UNDEFINED term! Both European, United Nations, British and other territorial laws refer to 'religion'; but leave it undefined (certainly in European and British law). Even the recent European Union Directive establishing equali rights on grounds of sexual orientation, religion and philosophical thought; fails to define the critical point of what is 'religion'. This begs the question, what makes a group or community a 'religion'? What are the qualifying factors? Perhaps, our wise Sikhs could comment on this fundamental point? In contrast, British law explicitly and comprehensively defines what an 'ETHNIC' group is. Indeed, this was done in 1983, in direct response to a landmark Sikh legal case (Mandla v Dowell Lee, 1983, House of Lords), to decide the question of whether Sikhs were merely a 'religious' group or a much wider and comprehensive social and cultural entity - ETHNIC. It was decided, on merits of their common language, history, sociology, social customs (including 'religious' and beyond)territorial commonality, community feeling, etc; that Sikhs were "more than just a religion". It was decided that they were a full-fledged ETHNIC community, and should be treated as such under public and private law! 2. Why do Sikhs have a fixation with the term 'religion'? Where is this term used in Sikh history or Sikh historic or scriptural literature (e.g. rehatnamas, hukamnamas, gurbani)? In case someone thinks 'dharam' means 'religion', they are sorely mistaken! Dharam is a much more fuller, substantive and wholesome term than 'religion'. 'Dharam' means a totalised and holistic lifestyle of righteous living (code of ethical conduct, philosophy of life, etc). It was used in this sense by the Sikh Founding Fathers (the 'Gurus'). For example: "(Guru Nanak) gave a new code of conduct, as the high way of spiritual life. Thus, Guru Nanak restored to DHARMA, its lost feet. He blended all classes and creeds into one social order: the SIKHS. In this, he gave the lowliest social equality with the kings; and taught humility and dignified living to the world." Bhai Gurdaas, Var 1, 24 Sikh writers continue to confuse and misinterpret 'religion' and 'Dharam' as the same things (much like the term 'Khaalsa' meaning the 'pure'). 'Dharam' is higher than the confines of institutionalised 'religion' (e.g. Catholicism, Protestantism). It is about human society and its wholescale ethical functionality. The authentic Khaalsa culture, society and people is a dharamic nation and civilisation. The Sikh Gurus never meant us to be a religion. They meant us to be a full-fledged people, a nation, a PANTH - defined and driven by a comprehensive ethical human culture ('a network of ideas, values and customs which define the behaviour of a society'). 3. The term religion was first brought to the Sikhs by the British colonialists, in the 19th century during their conquest of Panjaab. British officialdom began to describe the Sikhs as a 'religion'. The British used various disjointed and half-baked descriptions about the Sikhs - their lifestyle, their ethics and collective community. For example, the 'Khalsa' was frequently described as a 'military sect'. The Darbar Sahib was described as a 'temple of worship'. Indeed, even today, the term 'temple' and 'place of worship' is routinely applied to gurdwaras. Moreover, the learned Sikhs have absorbed and imbibed these misdescriptions; and frequently use them themselves, pliantly. The Gurdwara is neither a 'temple' nor a place of 'worship' (a English term for formal religious 'prayer' etc). In sum total, the Sikhs have blindly and pliantly accepted terminology superimposed by a conquering power! (highly reflective of the current subdued and pliant 'Sikh' mental character?, in contrast with the pre-1849 staunch Panjaabi - Sikhs who were annihilated by the invading British, much like the Scottish highland stalwarts). 4. The term 'religion' comes with a great deal of negative and institutionalised baggage. The religious establishment throughout Europe, over previous centuries, and indeed, the current time; has been involved in great social and political controversies and scandals, and sanctioned aggressive wars by the prevaling imperialistic states. Religion is associated with institutional control, formalisms, ritual, tight and oppressive authority and officialdom. This is certainly not the substance of the Khaalsa philosophy, lifestyle or movement or peoplehood! Indeed, the exact opposite. 5. Religious groups do not have rights in international law! The nearest thing to religious rights, is the right to freedom of thought and expression and freedom of 'religion', etc, as defined in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Religious groups do not have any COLLECTIVE rights as a collective community, unlike ethnic-national groups, in international law. There is no legal basis for self-determination for a 'religious minority' or a 'religious community'. The Sikhs presenting themselves as a 'persecuted religious minority' in India, diverts massively and most fundamentally, from the correct principles of the Sikh case - a nation undemocratically and oppressively colonialised and subjugated by a state (INDIA). It makes no intellectual sense for a 'religious' community to seek autonomy, self-determination or self-rule, merely because of their different style of worship, different prayers, different centres of worship. That is like, buddhists demanding territorial and political separation from christians. In contrast, a nation - a people who have a collective way of life and a collective society of their own, and seek to function and develop as a collective human unit - has much more comprehensive and overarching basis for self-existence and independent existence. A nation wishes to function as a full-fledged comprehensive society - social, political, civic and legislative; based on its cultural, social and spiritial substance and values - customs, heritage, codes, norms. This is why the Khaalsa civilisation decidely qualifies as a nation more than as a mere 'religion', much less a 'religious minority'! The reduction of Sikhs to a 'religious' group, as against a ethnic group, is driven by the duplicitous and oppressive desire to deny the Sikhs their legal rights as a distinct and full-fledged people. Being a 'religion' gives Sikhs no legal strength or basis. Indeed, discussions by the Sikh Commonwealth (London) with western governments' representatives and in the United Nations (New York) about Sikh nationhood were often complicated and impeded by Indian pre-information, that Sikhs were only a 'religious' group. 6. Sikhs says they are a 'nation', and claim national rights. How do they reconcile this with their constant and repititive self-description as a 'religious' group, seeking 'religious rights and freedoms'? INVITATION FOR COMMENTS & FEEDBACK I hope that, we as a people can look to evaluating these these important and searching fundamental questions? We cannot chop and change from being 'religious' one moment to 'ethnic' and 'national' another moment. Consistency, is necessary in intellectual argument and certainly in law - domestic and international. At the moment, the erratic chopping and changing, indicates a lack of clear thought and comprehension of the critical substance of the global issues facing the Sikh people both as a migrant population (in France, Britain, USA, Europe, etc) and as a non-state nation. There is nothing worse and more self-destructive than a confused mind. I would hope that the above earnest comments, will nurture healthy debate and discussion. Open responses from Sikh organisations, like United Sikhs, British Sikh Federation and other leading Sikh bodies, are much welcomed. I would also advise Sikhs in France to present their issues of the dastaar ('turban'), as an issue of ethnic equality - the right to practise a distinct and progressive ethnic way of life. The 5ks - their ethical significance/symbolism and practical usage in day to day life - forms an integral part of the ETHNICITY of the Sikh people. Entrapping this into the swamp of 'religion' will create unnecessary complications, and further undermine the status of the Sikh people as a people. Jagdeesh Singh Sikh Commonwealth (London, England) Sikh Community Action Network (Slough, England)