Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

LADIVAAR FONT??

LADIVAAR FONT??

sevadaar 1203491241208 · 29 Apr 2003

VAAHEGUROOJEEKAAKHAALSAA!!! VAAHEGUROOJEEKEEFATHEH !!! sadh sangat jeeo, The Guru saahibaan created Gurmukhi script after seeing that the common people had difficulty in obtaining access to education of Sanskrit and they wanted to eliminate the bureaucracy, heirarchy and hypocricy in the religious institutions, so they developed standardized practices like Gurmukhi, and Langar, which emphasized equal access to outer blessed food and inner blessed food. dhan dhan maharaaj satguroo sri guru nanak sahib went as far as iraq, mecca, medina, turkey, and tibet - throughout the mountains and deserts - and preached sikhi wearing the costume and speaking the language of the locals, never sacrificing his rehit along the way. therefore, does it not make sense for us to have guru granth sahib accessible to all - and printed in pad-chedd so that all people can read it easily? the argument that pad-chedd has some mis-printed words will only last as long as people don't fix those mis-printed words. once the mis-printed words are properly printed, pad-chedd will just be ladivaar with spaces. other than that, there is no difference. it's still the writings of guru granth sahib. it's still the guroo. BANEE GUROO, GUROO HAI BAANEE. if i said it like that, or like this BAANEEGUROOGUROOHAIBAANEE, or if i said it like this, the point is the same. and if it isn't - we should make it the same, by putting spaces where they need and taking them out where they shouldn't be. But we shouldn't just keep ladivaar because it's "traditional" -- since when is Sikhi traditional? sanskrit was the "puratan" traditional heritage / historical language of the time, when the guroo sahibaan taught sikhi. but they did not look at that - they looked at the needs of the sangat. if it's easier and makes more sense - and less mistakes are made - with pad-chedd, then what's wrong with it? ----> just asking <------- bhul chuk maaf karo VAAHEGUROOJEEKAAKHAALSAA!!! VAAHEGUROOJEEKEEFATHEH !!

Re: LADIVAAR FONT??

Roopkaur Khalsa · 30 Apr 2003

Vaheguru ji ka khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fateh >>>>the argument that pad-chedd has some mis-printed words will only last as long as people don't fix those mis-printed words. <<<<< The only problem with this is that there are so many different interpretations of where the spaces should be and what the proper grammer is that it is almost impossible for everyone to agree on the exact same spaces in bani. >>>therefore, does it not make sense for us to have guru granth sahib accessible to all - and printed in pad-chedd so that all people can read it easily? <<<< It is because of this argument that so much dhill has come into sikhi, because people want it to be acceptable to as much people as possible. However, if the bani was written in pad shed, then why would people make the effort to actually understand the bani and derive its full benefits by comprehending every word. If it is already split up, then a person just reads it the way it is without actually analyzing it, and therefore does not derive the full ras out of it. >>it's still the writings of guru granth sahib. it's still the guroo.<<< Since we were given the bani in the larivar roop by sri guru gobind singh ji as our present guru, Sri guru granth sahib ji, how can the alterations made to it by man be considered the equivalent of what guru ji bestowed on us? >>>>But we shouldn't just keep ladivaar because it's "traditional" -- since when is Sikhi traditional?<<<<< The whole point of sikhi is based on tradition. Guru jis rehit is followed based on tradition. That is the whole essence of sikhi, to follow the tradtions, or rehit, that was set forth by our guru jis and puratan singhs of the past. >>>>sanskrit was the "puratan" traditional heritage / historical language of the time, when the guroo sahibaan taught sikhi. but they did not look at that - they looked at the needs of the sangat.<<<< Although they did look at the needs of the sangat, the reason why guru ji wrote bani in gurmukhi and not sanskrit is becasue that was the bhana of vaheguru ji, and that is how sikhi was meant to be. There is bani in sankrit as well, its jsut written in the gurmukhhi language, hence there is more need to get santhiya, so we may know how to pronounce words that appear from other languages as well as where to put the spaces properly. >>>if it's easier and makes more sense - and less mistakes are made - with pad-chedd, then what's wrong with it?<<<<< Actually I think that more mistakes are made with pad shed becuase no one stops to analyze the meanings of the words and the grammer of bani, they jsut read the words the way they are split up, even if they might be split up wrong. Bhul Chuk Maaf Vaheguru ji ka khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fateh ~RoopKaur Khalsa~

Re: LADIVAAR FONT??

Singhnee · 30 Apr 2003

Waheguru jee kaa khalsa!! Waheguru jee kee fateh!! Sevadaar jee please read the Gurmat section of this site and there is a topic on padcched sroop. I hope that will help you understand the significance of LaRidaar sroop of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. Waheguru jee kaa khalsa!! Waheguru jee kee fateh!!

Re: LADIVAAR FONT??

Daas · 30 Apr 2003

Very intersting views, heres something that has cropped up, say if the pathi is making x amount of mistakes while doing path from a larivar bir, isn't that wrong ? just the same for a padched bir. fair enough we can do ardas afterwards and ask for forgiveness but its still wrong !!! there is a sakhi where guru ji asked his gursikhs to slap a sikh who was doing the path incorrect so that he may realise that he needs to pay more attention when doing path. Then there is the whole argument about what right do we have to padched a lardiar bir, it is a valid argument but then on the flip side what right do we have to do path of larivar bir, aren't we with our limited intelligence deciding where the pauses occur, how to urcharan certain words, if we took it to enth degree then one who does path of larivar is using his own math to pad ched the bani to that they can do the path, but how do we know it correct, Veer kulbir singh ji has posted many emails regarding the difference in certain lines, but there are many lines which pratan jatha singhs don't agree on and they are from Bhai Sahib era, each one has their own sujee and will do path according to their own research and baksish from guru ji. Who is right and who is wrong only guru ji knows. All this happens in his bana. The questiong of dil nowadays cannot be justified by the existence of a padched bir, in the early 1900s there was a lot more dil then there is now and it took the singh sabha movement to get sikhi back on tracks, and it was larivar bir then, the dil is because we call ourselve sikhs but really haven't understood the message at all, we interrupt things for our own purpose and make up rules and then call them tat gurmat, when really only guru ji knows what Tat Gurmat is and our task is to try and understand and follow not to enforce and dictate. This not an email pointing the finger at anyone in particular but the panth as a whole. We have become so disected as a panth, I wonder what Guru Gobind Singh Ji would have made of all this ??? Bhul CHuk Maf Karna Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh or VahguruJiKaKhalsa VaheguruJiKiFateh,

Re: LADIVAAR FONT??

Kulbir Singh · 30 Apr 2003

Daas wrote: > Very intersting views, heres something that has cropped up, > say if the pathi is making x amount of mistakes while doing > path from a larivar bir, isn't that wrong ? Dear Daas jee, when the paathi reads wrongly from the real saroop of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee i.e. from laridaar saroop, those mistakes are considered to be of a mortal being i.e. the paathi. We all know that our Guru is perfect and as such cannot contain the wrong split of words. If there is a wrong split of words in a padd-chhed saroop, then that means that the mistake is in Guru Sahib but if the paathi reads wrongly from a laridaar saroop, then the mistake is of the paathi. > just the same for a > padched bir. fair enough we can do ardas afterwards and ask > for forgiveness but its still wrong !!! Daas jee, we are mortal beings and are bound to make mistakes. These innocent mistakes cannot be equated with the blunder of ripping apart Gurbani against the wishes of our Guru Sahibaan. Guru Sahib is all-knowing and if he wanted, he would have done the pad-chhed himself. I am surprised that today the Sikhs are questioning the wisdom of Guru Sahib. > Then there is the whole argument about what right do we have > to padched a lardiar bir, it is a valid argument but then on > the flip side what right do we have to do path of larivar bir, What kind of argument is this that "what right do we have to do path of larivar bir" ? This right of doing paath from laridaar saroop has been given to every Sikh by Guru Sahib himself. > aren't we with our limited intelligence deciding where the > pauses occur, how to urcharan certain words, if we took it to > enth degree then one who does path of larivar is using his own > math to pad ched the bani to that they can do the path, but how > do we know it correct, Veer kulbir singh ji has posted many > emails regarding the difference in certain lines, but there are > many lines which pratan jatha singhs don't agree on and they > are from Bhai Sahib era, each one has their own sujee and will > do path according to their own research and baksish from guru > ji. > Who is right and who is wrong only guru ji knows. All this > happens in his bana. Veer Daas jeeo, this is precisely the reason why we should not do the padd-chhed of saroops. How do we know that we are doing the correct padd-chhed? While doing paath, if we do wrong padd-chhed then it would be our mistake but we don't have any right to change the doing of Guru Sahib. We should live in the bhaana of Guru Sahib. I think that this is a very important issue of today. In fact this is the most imporant issue. The issue is of our Guru. It is imperative that we fix this mistake and do parkaash and paath only of laridaar saroop. My veers and bhains who are reading this forum can make a difference if they insist on having only laridaar saroop during kirtan, anand karaj, amrit sinchaar or akhand paath sahib. Hundreds of veers and bhains visit this site and if they all take this stand, then that day is not far when the real saroop of Guru Granth Sahib jee will be installed back on the throne of Guruship. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: LADIVAAR FONT??

Harbhajan Singh · 30 Apr 2003

Waheguru Jee Kaa Khalsa, Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh Dear Sangat Jeeo, The first point i want to make and it is the most important. Is that each and every one of us must read and more IMPORTANTLY understand Gurbani. If you read Gurbani you will understand Guru Jees Message. After understanding the message then you will be on the road to meeting the Guru. The Laridaar issue is most complex and both sides have EQUALLY GOOD POINTS. In my mind reading Paath from any Bir is the most important point. Many of today’s youth don't have the love in reading paath as the elders did. First we must encourage the youth to read paath. The best way in doing that is to read from padched, once they are proficient in reading from that then we must encourage them to read from Laridaar. Not make statements as some people do about laridaar, they know what statements they made and it isn’t right for a Sikh of Sri Guru Nanak Dev Jee to utter any words against the Padched Bir. Remember the power is in the Bani and nothing else. I think it's probably the first time i'm going to disagree with Dass Kulbir Singh Jee but this is not the main issue. This is one which can be discussed but the main issue of the day is first and foremost to do Parchaar of Sri Guru Nanak Dev Jees - Sri Guru Gobind Singh Jee's message. We as the Jatha have been too enclosed from the general sangat and if we make this a major issue we will be more isolated. As Jatha we must be in the forefront in doing Parchaar to the Sikh youth and the rest of Mankind as a whole. 'then that day is not far when the real saroop of Guru Granth Sahib jee will be installed back on the throne of Guruship'. All Sri Guru Granth Sahibs are Guru Jee and nothing less. If we have these thoughts in our mind then we will lose faith in Guru Jee and it will come to a stage when Gursikhs dont even do Mutha Tek to the Bir if it isnt Laridaar. I don’t care how Spirtually high the Gursikh may be but he is making a mistake in not doing mautha tek. I've met in my life Gursikhs and Sants who dive down to the earth to do Mutha Tek to the Guru Granth Sahib whatever Bir it may be. That's probably because they see something we don't which is more spiritual and beyond our human understanding of just the style of writing. Please bear in mind Laridaar writing or joined up writing is just the way they wrote in that age. I have seen European Texts (majority of them Bibles and government texts) from the same age as the Guru's Jees time which is Laridaar. The most important style and attractive style of writing was laridaar in that age. However I have also seen writing which is attributed to the 6th and 10th Guru Sahibain which is in Padched. Let’s be grown up about this and make sure our values are not diluted and that Jatha stands united. If some Singhs can read from Laridaar then I bow down to them as they have done effort in achieiving that. Please bear in mind my stand is that Gursikhs should read Bani and appreciate the treasure Guru Shaib has bestowed on us. Harbhajan Singh Waheguru Jee Kaa Khalsa, Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh

Re: LADIVAAR FONT??

rsingh · 30 Apr 2003

'However I have also seen writing which is attributed to the 6th and 10th Guru Sahibain which is in Padched.' This shows that the guru's could write pad ched as well, but chose to make the Guru Granth Saahib Lareevaar. The main point I'm seeing in favour of Pad Ched is that it is spiritually the same as Lareevar but with the benefit that it is simpler to read. So basically, everything else being equal, the Pad Ched is superior due to its greater readability. The problem is that Guru Gobind Singh Jee gave the gur gaddee to the Lareevar saroop. Banee was always the guru, but the physical throne was given to this saroop, just as it was previously given to human saroops. By now replacing the lareevar given by Guru Gobind Singh Jee with a pad ched saroop, we have basically decided, using our own matt, that we will improve our guru. Guru Gobind Singh Jee maybe didn't have the foresight to see the difficulty we would have with lareevaar, so we will correct guru saahib's mistake and improve our guru. That's basically what we seem to be saying. If we have a hard time reading lareevar, we should then make the time and effort to learn. We can even use gutkas or pothees in pad ched. However, we don't just change the physical form of our guru (the Guru Granth Saahib) to fit our own needs and agenda. The gur gaddee was passed on by Guru Gobind Singh Jee and we have no right to make any alterations to it. As Sikhs, we accept what our Guru Saahib gives us. If we can change the saroop of our guru to make life easier, why can't we change everything else in sikhee as well? Also, if we were around at the time the guru's had a human saroop, would we try improving them too? Would we have decided that Guru Amar Daas Jee was too old looking, so let's do some plastic surgery to improve the situation. The jot, the banee inside would still be the same. We'd just be taking care of the outside, according to our great matt. Maybe I wouldn't be able to understand punjabee very well, so instead of improving myself and learning, I would just tell Guru Saahib, "Hey, go take some English classes so I can understand you better. If you follow my advice, you'll be a better, more accessible guru." If padched is acceptable, will a saroop with punctuation added in (bindees, etc) also be okay? What if someone changes the order of the banees? The same banee will be there, just in different order. Will that be the same thing? Other faiths and cultures preserve their ancient texts and try to learn them in their original form. People even preserve the writings of ordinary authors in their original form, out of respect. We lazy sikhs have gone and changed the form of our own Guru Saahib. This is quite sad.

Re: LADIVAAR FONT??

Singh · 01 May 2003

I agree with Harbhajan Singh Ji's main point that it is the reading and understanding of gurbani which is the more important thing. Another point for me is that speaking for myself, I matha tekh to Guru Granth Sahib because of the messages and updesh contained within and not to the individual pages or words themselves whether or not they are seperated. There was a time when I would matha tekh to Guru Granth Sahib as an individual thing or object, make extravagant rumalay and put harr on the bir. I now think that was just idolizing and 'dressing up' the bir on my part. I think those now saying that matha tekhing to or doing patt from padd ched bir is not the same thing as larivaar bir are themselves, whether conscoiusly or not, treating the larivaar bir as an object in itself. As to the statement about 'lazy sikhs' not learning to read larivaar, it should be recalled that Guru Nanak travelled afar in taking his message to the people in a way they could understand and not waiting for them to come to him. For my part I think Guru Nanak would be more pleased with those trying to make our Shabad Guru more accessible so that more people can obtain laha. Just my thoughts. Sorry if I upset anyone, thats not my intention

Re: LADIVAAR FONT??

Daas · 01 May 2003

Well its good to see some interesting views of both sides fo the discussion, one point that has stuck in my mind for some time is, Did guru ji give the guruship to the saroop or the shabad, if it is the laridar saroop which is what the views is in the above messages, then it stands to reason the only bir that can be accepted as Guru is the one that Guru Gobind Singh Ji passed the guruship on to, how can we accept copies, printed copies, they weren't given the gurgaddi we're they ? which copy is more authentic hand written ones, printed ones ??? many of the hand written ones contain hundreds of mistakes, does this not make them the same as padched ones with mistakes in ??? Then there is the question AKJ believe that ragmala is not bani and in most birs ragmala is there, how can the Guru be poora then ??? Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh ji wrote a great many books, but why is all the bani in these books in padched ? surely if AKJ wanted to keep the larivar issue at the fore front they would have remedied this and made sure the books we're printed with larivar bani ???? Personally when I go to the gurudwara I cannot in my mind think about which bir is prakashed and wheter or not I should math tek, be it laridar or padched I will bow to both as they both contain bani, and bani guru, guru hai bani, vich bani amrit sarea. Also having been in AKJ all my life the question that dil is prevalent more now cus of the bir is nonsensical mainly, AKJ INDIA definitely have larivar saroop at all programs and look at the situation there, AKJ has become the laughing stock of the panth there, recently there we're not 1 not 2 but 3 different AKJs going to the SGPC to request a place to do a smagam for the 1978 shaeeds, luckily they saw sense and managed to do one smagam together, hopefully this will bring back ekta there after many years of division in AKJ. The main point for larivar seems to be we humans had no right to change the bir !! which is a fair point, but then where we're all the chardi kala gursikhs of those times who are still alive now, why didn't they sacrifice their lives to stop pad ched ??? why do we now create dubta amongst sangat who have little or no clue about this issue, you will probably say more reason to alert them and get this back to the forefront but then as Harbhajan singh says look at the state of sikhi worldwide, surely parchar needs to be done where ever we can ???? "If padched is acceptable, will a saroop with punctuation added in (bindees, etc) also be okay? What if someone changes the order of the banees? The same banee will be there, just in different order. Will that be the same thing?" this was tried a while ago by Teja singh bhasoria, they we're off the view point that bhagat bani had no place in Guru Granth Sahib and tried to remove it but Panth stood stread fast and expelled him from the panth, now the panth could have sood stead fast on this issue but why didn't they ????? Anyways I'm sure Veer Kulbir singh ji will answer questions that I have, and I thank him in advance because I always find his posts enlightning :) Bhul Chuk Maf Karna Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh.

Re: LADIVAAR FONT??

Sukhdev Singh · 01 May 2003

VahegurooJeeKaaKhalsa VahegurooJeeKeeFateh I'm not going to extend this debate. I think most people know the facts on this issue & most of them have been raised above. Everyone will come to their own conclusion according to their maat & karam. However I would like to mention that the majority of those advocating that there is no difference between the birs are the ones that don't do Paat from either Laridaar Sanchia or Siri Guru Granths Sahib's Laridaar Saroop. Therefore it is hard for me to contemplate on how they can ever come to this conclusion. You can only come to a conclusion after experiencing/doing something not before. Merely by reading about or viewing something you can not arrive at a conclusion.I too was of the same opinion a few years ago. But it was not until I started reading Bani in the laridaar format that I realised that there was a difference. This difference should be apparent to a Naam abayassi rehat vala GurSikh.For what little I have experienced in Gursikhi is that there is more to Gursikhi than merely what ones eye's can see, read about or understand. That is only a small percentage of Gursikhi. That majority is about things you can not see, can not read about or even come close to understanding. So I will urge all my Gursikh veers & Bhenji's to please start reading from the Laridaar format of Banee before knocking those who are trying to highlight this neglect in the Panth. Bhula Chuckan Dee Maaf VahegurooJeeKaaKhalsa VahegurooJeeKeeFateh P.S It would be nice if people could use their real names instead of trying to hide especially if you are advocating a view. I could understand if you were withholding your name if you were asking a question or seeking advice for someone that was trying to learn & might feel ashamed. This would reduce the amount of arguing for argument's sake.(wishful thinking i suppose)

Re: LADIVAAR FONT??

Kulbir Singh · 01 May 2003

Veer Harbhajan Singh jeeo, You have written an emotional posting but you have not answered any points raised by this daas (myself) and other points in favour of laridaar saroop and against padd-chhed saroop. >>>>>>> Many of today’s youth don't have the love in reading paath as the elders did. First we must encourage the youth to read paath. The best way in doing that is to read from padched, once they are proficient in reading from that then we must encourage them to read from Laridaar. >>>>>> I may agree that maybe it is good to teach our kids and youth from padd-chhed first and then prompt them to read from laridaar saroop. But then why is there need to have a padd-chhed saroop. You can have padd-chhed gutkaas and pothis from where you can train the youth to read baani and then let them read from the laridaar saroop. Why was the need to install a parallel saroop with laridaar and original saroop? Have we not created a disunity in the panth by having the parkaash of padd-chhed saroop. Now after creating the disunity in the panth by installing the padd-chhed saroop the supporters of pad-chhed are asking the devoted Sikhs who want to stay in bhaana of Guru Sahib by accepting the doing of Guru Sahib i.e. laridaar saroop, to accept the padd-chhed saroop. I ask you veer jeeo, how fair is it to ask the gursikhs who want to stay in the bhaana of Guru Sahib by accepting the doing of Guru Sahib, to accept a man-made saroop i.e. the padd-chhed saroop? Who has caused the disunity here? The ones who introduced padd-chhed and propogate it or the ones who want to stay in bhaana of Guru Sahib and accept only laridaar saroop? When was the Sarbat Khalsa called to make this decision to rip apart baani in thousands of pieces? When was it decided by panth to accept this man-made saroop of Guru Granth Sahib? If there was no sarbat khalsa and no other panthik gathering where such important decision was made, then what right do we have to change the form of Guru Granth Sahib jee? Please answer the above raised questions. >>>>>>>> Not make statements as some people do about laridaar, they know what statements they made and it isn’t right for a Sikh of Sri Guru Nanak Dev Jee to utter any words against the Padched Bir. Remember the power is in the Bani and nothing else. >>>>> Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee in his books have openly called the padd-chhed of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee a “manmatt”. I totally concur with Bhai Sahib on this. Gurmat is what Guru Sahib does and manmat what a mortal being does. Laridaar is the creation of Guru Sahib while Pad-chhed is the creation of a human. >>>>>>>> Nanak Dev Jees - Sri Guru Gobind Singh Jee's message. We as the Jatha have been too enclosed from the general sangat and if we make this a major issue we will be more isolated. >>>>>>>>>>> I don’t think we should worry about the consequences of following rehit. If following rehit means that we will be isolated, then so be it. This world is a temporary place and what we should worry about is the next world, where we are going to live forever. >>>>>> All Sri Guru Granth Sahibs are Guru Jee and nothing less. >>>>>>> Guru Granth Sahib jee written in Gurmukhi is Siri Guru Granth Sahib. Guru Granth Sahib jee written in French or English cannot be considered to be our Guru. Same way Guru Granth Sahib jee i written in Punjabi (Padd-chhed) is not Guru. Punjabi is padd-chhed whereas Gurmukhi is laridaar. I again appeal to my Gursikh bhains and veers that we must recognize the true Guru i.e. Laridaar saroop of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. No Sarbat Khalsa or a panthik gathering has ordained the use of Pad-chhed saroop. Padd-chhed saroop is a creation of a human and as such is full of baani wrongly written. Laridaar saroop is the work of Vaheguru himself. The devoted Singhs belonging to AKJ always do all sewa in the hazoori of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee Laridaar saroop. Taksali singhs too recognize the laridaar saroop. They do parkaash of only laridaar saroop in Mehta Chowk – their headquarters. They give santhiya only from laridaar baani. Let us not be left behind. This padd-chhed saroop is being advocated by non-rehitvaan so called modern Sikh scholars. Let us follow the gursikhs and mahapurakhs who have all supported the laridaar saroop. It is our responsibility like Makhan Shaah Lubhaana, who recognized the true Guru out of 22 fake Gurus in Baba Bakaala. Today too we need a Makhand Shaah Lubhaana to show the sangat the true Guru. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: LADIVAAR FONT??

Harbhajan Singh · 01 May 2003

Waheguru Jee Kaa Khalsa, Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh Veer Bhai Kulbir Singh Jee, I will answer any of your questions with my limited intelligence. Firstly I was amused in a friendly way when you stated that I haven't answered any question raised by Pro Laridaar Gursikhs. If you read my post again I have stated 'Please bear in mind my stand is that Gursikhs should read Bani and appreciate the treasure Guru Sahib has bestowed on us.' I have made a common sense approach to the issue. Sri Guru Granth Sahib for reasons I won’t go into was changed to a Pad Ched writing. I’m not for and against anything as I see Sri Guru Granth Sahib as Guru Jee whether in Padched or Laridaar. Simple reasoning I thought, sorry if it confused anybody. I will try to answer Bhai Kulbir Singh Jee's questions but he has probably and admirably answered them himself. >'Why was the need to install a parallel saroop with laridaar and original saroop? Have we not created a disunity in the panth by having the parkaash of padd-chhed saroop.' Disunity of the Panth happened after Sri Guru Gobind Singh Jee left for his eternal abode. This has been noted by several reputable historians when Banda Singh Bahadur was in charge of the Panth and after his martyrdom the panth was spilt with the Tat Khalsa or Khalsa on one side and the followers of Banda Singh Bahadur called the Bandai Khalsa. Hope im right about the names of the two khalsa's. If im wrong then forgive me. Ever since then there has been disunity until the present day. The Disunity wasn't caused by Pad-ched printing it was done by the majority of those who called themselves Sikhs not following the Teaching's of Guru Jee. I think there was no need to Pad-ched the writing but if it has been done, and im playing Devil's advocate here again isn't everything done in His will (don't take this too seriously). >'Now after creating the disunity in the panth by installing the padd-chhed saroop the supporters of pad-chhed are asking the devoted Sikhs who want to stay in bhaana of Guru Sahib by accepting the doing of Guru Sahib i.e. laridaar saroop, to accept the padd-chhed saroop. I ask you veer jeeo, how fair is it to ask the gursikhs who want to stay in the bhaana of Guru Sahib by accepting the doing of Guru Sahib, to accept a man-made saroop i.e. the padd-chhed saroop? Who has caused the disunity here? The ones who introduced padd-chhed and propogate it or the ones who want to stay in bhaana of Guru Sahib and accept only laridaar saroop? When was the Sarbat Khalsa called to make this decision to rip apart baani in thousands of pieces? When was it decided by panth to accept this man-made saroop of Guru Granth Sahib? If there was no sarbat khalsa and no other panthik gathering where such important decision was made, then what right do we have to change the form of Guru Granth Sahib jee? ' Sikhs should accept Sri Guru Granth Sahib as Guru no matter what. I like the response you gave about Guru Jee being translated in French, English and even bindia were mentioned. Sri Guru Nanak Dev Jee travelled vast distances and spoke numerous languages; he probably spoke Chinese dialects, Arabic, Turkish, probably even Italian. He probably uttered bani in numerous languages so others could understand the divine message. But the translation wasn't the Issue the pad-ched and Laridaar is the issue. So I still state I am not enlightened enough to make comment of Guru Sahib. I consider Guru Granth Sahib Jee as the eternal Guru (Not the form of writing). No Gursikh should be made to accept anything. Especially Gursikhs who believe in Laridaar. I don't believe in raag malaa and never will. I have had many discussion with pro Raag malaa singhs over the past 10-15 years and still come away being anti and probably confused them aswell. If there was a big promotion for Laridaar and the Panth was split 50/50 and it was a major thing in the panth then I would be right behind you Kulbir Singh Jee, probably about half a mile down the road with my sojee. However being interested in Panthic affairs since 84' I haven’t seen a big push for Laridaar Bir, but I have seen a huge decrease in Sikh Parchaar. If there was as I said I would support you. However the point you've made about Metha Chowk might be incorrect as I've heard different from one of the senior members of the Sant samaj. I might be wrong in that case forgive me. I just want to reply to a statement made rsingh about changing the physical form of Guru Jee. Sri Guru Gobind Singh Jee gave the Gurgadi to the bir which was in his presence. So therefore the only Sri Guru Granth sahib is that Bir and all the others are copies. NO, they aren't as Guru Jee in his divine wisdom gave Gurgadi to Gurbani as the everlasting Guru. So physical appearance isn’t as important as the Jot as when Sri Guru Nanak Dev Jee transfered his Jot to Sri Guru Angad Dev Jee he did so because to relay the message that he recieved from Akal Purakh was going to take more time than the Human Body could stand. When the 10th Nanak Sri Guru Gobind Singh Jee knew that the message was complete and it was time to return to Akal Purakh he transferred the Jot into the Bani so it would be everlasting. I would like to make my last point as my fingers are hurting now. I do also concur with you that Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh did write padched of Bani was incorrect or padched of Guru Granth Sahib was manmatt. We must make sure that all bani in Bhai Sahib's books are Laridaar, don't you agree? Im only playing the fool but you must now as I haven't read as much as yourself Bhai Kulbir Singh was Bhai Sahib alive when they started printing his books? If so im sure Bhai Sahib would have demanded that the bani was to be printed in Laridaar. I don’t normally reply to message boards as I don’t like to dissect others comments. I also believe in that what ever has been stated for and against Laridaar Bir isn’t a subject that should cause division in the Jatha. I’ve seen numerous times when views are made strongly and forcibly but I think we must make sure that when we explain our arguments like Bhai Kulbir Singh Jee and Dass have it is easily understood by the Sangat. Sangat must look at the views posted and then decide for themselves. I probably made alot of mistakes. Hopefully someone will point them out and I will endevour to correct them ;) Dass Harbhajan Singh Waheguru Jee Kaa Khalsa, Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh

Re: LADIVAAR FONT??

Jugraj Singh · 01 May 2003

Waheguru Jee Kaa Khalsa, Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh >>>>>>I have made a common sense approach to the issue. Sri Guru Granth Sahib for reasons I won’t go into was changed to a Pad Ched writing. >>>>>> It was changed by who and with what authority? Who are we to change guru sahib's saroop. >>>>>> I’m not for and against anything as I see Sri Guru Granth Sahib as Guru Jee whether in Padched or Laridaar. Simple reasoning I thought, sorry if it confused anybody. >>>>>> So veerji let me ask you this. You see both larivaar saroop and pad ched saroop as guru ji ... consider this. Guru sahib gave the gurgaddi to the larivaar saroop. So the larivaar saroop is guru. How can the pad ched saroop also be guru. You say that bani is guru. Well veerji if i were to recite paath all day long would you then consider me guru. Or if I made you a cd of guru granth sahib ji would you then consider the cd your guru and matha tek to the cd. The saroop is of obvious signifance and hope the point is clear. >>>>>>> The Disunity wasn't caused by Pad-ched printing it was done by the majority of those who called themselves Sikhs not following the Teaching's of Guru Jee. I think there was no need to Pad-ched the writing but if it has been done, and im playing Devil's advocate here again isn't everything done in His will (don't take this too seriously). >>>>>>> I agree disunity is caused when people do not follow guru sahib's hukam. Guru sahib gave gurgaddi to larivaar saroop so are you not disobeying hukam by also accepting the pad-ched saroop as guru. And don't use the bani is the same argument because it was just dealt with earlier. Yes everything happens in god's will. so I take it that we've no business trying to fight against people like Kala AFghana and Nirankari's etc. who disrespect guru sahib. >>>>>Sikhs should accept Sri Guru Granth Sahib as Guru no matter what. I like the response you gave about Guru Jee being translated in French, English and even bindia were mentioned. Sri Guru Nanak Dev Jee travelled vast distances and spoke numerous languages; he probably spoke Chinese dialects, Arabic, Turkish, probably even Italian. He probably uttered bani in numerous languages so others could understand the divine message. But the translation wasn't the Issue the pad-ched and Laridaar is the issue. So I still state I am not enlightened enough to make comment of Guru Sahib. >>>>> If you read an english tranlation you are not reading gurbani. Gurbani is only in the form of guru granth sahib. >>>>> I consider Guru Granth Sahib Jee as the eternal Guru (Not the form of writing) >>>>> Your statement is contradictory. How can you consider guru granth sahib ji your guru and also pad ched saroop your guru at the same time. The divine light is only in the larivaar saroop. The same way that the guru-joti was only in guru gobind singh ji and not every person who did paath. >>>>No Gursikh should be made to accept anything. Especially Gursikhs who believe in Laridaar. I don't believe in raag malaa and never will. I have had many discussion with pro Raag malaa singhs over the past 10-15 years and still come away being anti and probably confused them aswell. >>>> This is good news you don't believe in rag mala. Due to your prachar people might start believing in Pad-Ched saroop as guru. Do you want to be held accountable for this??? >>>>If there was a big promotion for Laridaar and the Panth was split 50/50 and it was a major thing in the panth then I would be right behind you Kulbir Singh Jee, probably about half a mile down the road with my sojee. >>>> Singhs take a stand when they see anti-gurmat things happening, they don't wait. >>>>However being interested in Panthic affairs since 84' I haven’t seen a big push for Laridaar Bir, but I have seen a huge decrease in Sikh Parchaar. >>>> What does prachar have to do with laridaar saroop? And just because their wasn't a push doesn't mean their shouldn't be. >>>>I just want to reply to a statement made rsingh about changing the physical form of Guru Jee. Sri Guru Gobind Singh Jee gave the Gurgadi to the bir which was in his presence. So therefore the only Sri Guru Granth sahib is that Bir and all the others are copies. NO, they aren't as Guru Jee in his divine wisdom gave Gurgadi to Gurbani as the everlasting Guru. So physical appearance isn’t as important as the Jot as when Sri Guru Nanak Dev Jee transfered his Jot to Sri Guru Angad Dev Jee he did so because to relay the message that he recieved from Akal Purakh was going to take more time than the Human Body could stand. When the 10th Nanak Sri Guru Gobind Singh Jee knew that the message was complete and it was time to return to Akal Purakh he transferred the Jot into the Bani so it would be everlasting. >>>> Okay let me get this straight. Did guru sahib not have singhs make copies of granth sahib ji in his own time? He did. All the copies were Larivaar. And all the copies were called the Granth SAhib. So when he gave the gurgaddi he gave it to the guru Granth sahib ji. so let me ask you this once again. If someone was to memorize the whole guru granth sahib then would they be guru? according to your logic yes. >>>>I do also concur with you that Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh did write padched of Bani was incorrect or padched of Guru Granth Sahib was manmatt. We must make sure that all bani in Bhai Sahib's books are Laridaar, don't you agree? >>>> ? all gutka's are not larivaar and they are fine. To conclude. We through our own minds have made a mistake. It was even decided by the shromani committee that pad ched printing is wrong. Now Singhs who instead of standing up for what guru gobind singh ji declared and the saroop he gave gurgaddi to are actually refuting it????? We the sons/daughters of guru gobind are taking a stand everytime we chose a side of an issue...even on a message board. And WE WILL BE HELD ACCOUNTABLE. SO I DO A BENTI TO ALL SINGHS PLEASE DO NOT LET YOUR OWN MAT GET IN THE WAY OF GURU SAHIB'S HUKAM.

Re: LADIVAAR FONT??

Daas · 02 May 2003

"We the sons/daughters of guru gobind are taking a stand everytime we chose a side of an issue...even on a message board. And WE WILL BE HELD ACCOUNTABLE. SO I DO A BENTI TO ALL SINGHS PLEASE DO NOT LET YOUR OWN MAT GET IN THE WAY OF GURU SAHIB'S HUKAM." and what is Guru Jis Hukam, Bani Guru, Guru Hai Bani, Vich Bani Amrit Sarea. where does it say, that the guru is only in larivar ??? where did Guru ji write this ? the bani is the guru not the saroop, the saroop is satkar jog and deserves all the respect one can give. Cus if he we are admanant that Guru Ji is in the larivar saroop then there can only be one bir which can be called Satguru and that is the bir guru ji gave gurgaddi too. Why accept gutka then ? they too should be in larivar !! if the saroop can only be larivar then there should be no gutkea with padched, why do those who 100% support laridar accept gutkea then ??? shouldn't we rely on guru jis kirpa then when it comes to trying learn the path from laridar. There we're a number of quesiton asked in my previous email which still remained unanswered I hope someone does as I found this thread very useful, Sukhdev Singh requests that we should use real names, but what use is this, this is a forum to learn from, not to point out "this person has this view or she has this view", and on other forums where I have used my name you tend to get pump shump from other writers who like what you write which indirectly will only enflate your houmai, not everyone suffers from that though :)

Re: LADIVAAR FONT??

"hum saadhh junaa kaa keerraa" · 02 May 2003

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Very Interesting posts on this subject, and i must say that we are very eager to bring Guru Sahib down to our level, but cannot put in the effort to rise upto Guru Sahib. It is fact that a Gurmata was passed some time back stating that no printing of Pad Chaad bir is permitted within the Panth.... so why do we still go against this Gurmata?? If we are going against Gurmata's then is it not obvious that what we are doing is wrong? Harbhajan Singh is adamant that the introduction of Pad Chaad has not caused 'disunity' or 'dhill' within the Panth.... i would strongly disagree with this, nowadays Akhand Paaths are being done in their millions every year, any person with little or even no knowledge of Gurbani or rehit is doing 'akhand paaths' sant sumaaj hold 50-100 'akhand paaths' at one time, its turned into a business, and why is this? Why was this not happening when it was only Larhidhaar Bir? Are we not doing Biadbee to Guru Sahib by holding 50-100 'akhand paaths' at one time? I agree that Biadbee was happening when only Larhidhaar was enthroned, but the introduction of paad chad was not the solution to it nor did it help in anyway. 'Dass' mentioned 'bani guru, guru hai bani, vich bani amrit sarea' we all agree, that Bani is Guru etc but when we talk about Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee we also realise that the 'GurJot' will only reside within Laridhaar... why do we have 'Chanani Sahib' and do 'Choor' over Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee and not over Gutka's ?? Or over Sanchi's?? We realise that there is a great difference when the whole bani is in one 'jhild' (in larhidhar) as in Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee then only can the 'GurJot' be present, hence we do 'choor sahib' and have 'chanani sahib' over Guru Sahib. A pathi is doing Patth from a chad chaad bir and comes across the thuk "baareh jojun shhuthru chulai thhaa dhaehee girujh nai khaaee" someone in the sangat corrects him with the right thuk "baareh jojun shhuthru chulai thhaa dhaehee girujhun khaaee" and the paathi says 'how can *i* be wrong, i am reading what is written here' so he has made the judgement that his Guru is wrong and that he is right....... so who are we pointing the finger at? the paathi or our Guru?? are we saying that our Guru is wrong now? (i believe that this thuk has been changed to the correct format now) we could say the same for mistakes in Larhidhaar Birs but those mistakes are not intentional, in Padd chaad we have chosen to make those mistakes using our own 'mutt' ... if the paathi was reading from laridhaar he could not have turned around and said my Guru is wrong here not me., Guru is never wrong. Bhai Ram Singh Jee has written a very good book on this subject, i would advise everyone to read it. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!

Re: LADIVAAR FONT??

sevadaar 1203491241208 · 02 May 2003

VaaheGuroojeekaakhaalsaa VaaheGuroojeekeefatheh the Gursikhs have spoken. I take all my comments back and apologize for causing an argument. I humbly request all gurmukh pyare to leave this conversation alone. The situation is clear: Satguroo Gobind Singh Sahib gave gurgadhee to the ladivaar / laridaar (is that a difference of dialects or is one of them wrong?) suroop of the baanee Guroo, Satguroo Granth Sahib Jee Maharaaj. All panthic sevadaars should read from this suroop as it is the parthhak puroon guroo suroop. Gutkas, amrit keertans, etc. may be in either but Guroo Sahib cannot be changed. bhul chuk maaf karo, daas mayree khalon maujaray gursikh handaantday

Re: LADIVAAR FONT??

Admin · 02 May 2003

Dear Sewadaar jee, you have shown a real big heart and displayed Gurmat by not sticking to your mann's mat and listening to Gurmat arguments and making up your mind in the favour of Laridaar Saroop of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. May Guru Sahib bless you with his eternal Gursikhi. Dhan are you for recognizing Sach. We are closing this debate now as nothing new is being posted to this. Soon we will be posting a new article on the importance of the laridaar saroop of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. It is our mission to make the Sikh Sangat aware of the real saroop - laridaar saroop and that doing parkash of padd-chhed saroop is wrong.

Re: LADIVAAR FONT??

kaur00 · 02 May 2003

wjkk wjkf can i add a point from the youth point of view? i read all the posts and pretty much all of them said that pad-ched saroop should exist so the youth can learn from it and then go on to read from lareewar. I strongly disagree with this point. I do sehaj path regularly nowadays and when i started reading my dad did not let me read from a sainchee or a pad-ched bir. He felt that if i started reading from a pad-ched saroop i would never progress and read from lareewar as the argument would be 'whats the difference? bani is bani, separated or not".... so instead of letting me take the easy way out he spent an hour of his time after rehras and made me read from the lareewar saroop while he corrected any mistakes i made. even now if i cannot figure out how to break up the pangtee when i do path he lets me use a sanchee but i cant read from it. overall i think it was a good decision on his part becuz if he had let me take the easier way out then i may not have been where i am now. (this post isnt to criticise anything anybody has said, but just to let the veerjis who had the needs of the youth in mind know what the youth really needs.. and thats akhand pathee singhs to devote time to the future singhs and singhnian and teach them bani from the lareewar saroop, in its original form!) bhul chuk maaf! wjkk wjkf

Re: LADIVAAR FONT??

Davinder Singh · 02 May 2003

VaheguruJIKaKhalsa VaheguruKiKiFateh! One day i asked Bhai Sahib Jeevan Singh why do you think the Panth is so broken up on many issues, and among themselves. Bhai Sahib said that the biggest pap that has been committed within the Panth is creating the pad-ched saroop, by doing this we are broken. VaheguruJiKaKhalsa VaheguruJiKiFateh!

Re: LADIVAAR FONT??

Master Jaswant Singh · 05 May 2003

WaheguruJIKaKhalsa WaheguruKiKiFateh! Ladiwar is from Guru, Padched from Man Man is always bhoolanhar There are 100's of mistakes in Padched. No intellectual can boast of correct Padched words. So it sin, even printing the Padched Swroop. FIRST word of Bani, i.e. Satnaam, cannot be decided by SARABSAMTI, to be written as Sat Naam or Satnaam, separately or otherwise. So how one can proceed further in the bani. No congregation, of panth, can decide about this word unanimously. So how possible to decide about 1430 pages? So say no to Padched. Jaswant Singh Amritsar

Re: LADIVAAR FONT??

Kulbir Singh · 05 May 2003

Bhai Sahib Jaswant Singh jeeo, I am so excited after reading your post on this forum. I and other singhs were just thinking of doing benti to you and other India Singhs to post on this forum so that the youth in Canada, America, UK and other countries can learn from the puraatan Singhs like you. I feel greatly indebted to Guru Sahib for doing kirpa on us and inspiring you to write on this forum. Please continue to post on this forum. I request you Bhai Sahib jeeo, to post more detailed posting covering Laridaar saroop on this site. If you wish, you can email us in Punjabi or fax us in Punjabi and we will translate your writings in English to post on our website. Please Bhai Sahib jeeo, do kirpa on us and continue to guide us to the Gurmat path. Just in case, the sangat on this forum does not know, Bhai Sahib Jaswant Singh jee is a puraatan Singh of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee’s times. He lives in Siri Amritsar Sahib and has done great sewa of panth by preaching Gurmat. He has written books and published laridaar Gutkaas. He is a great supporter of Laridaar Saroop of Guru Sahib. We are blessed to have his input on this forum. Please read what Bhai Sahib has written and ponder upon your current thinking of supporting the wrong practice of padd-chhed saroop. Bhai Sahib writes in his posting above that the panth so far has not even decided on the second word i.e. "Satnaam". Some say it should be "Ik oankaarsat Naam", others say it should be "Ik Oankaar Satnaam". The great scholars of panth are stuck on this one and there is no way we can reach on conclusion. Who are we to tear apart Gurbani. Please please Khalsa jeeo wake up. Stop the insult of our Guru Sahib. Stop this torture. Bhai Sahib Jaswant Singh jeeo, please write more detailed analysis of why we should not have padd-chhed saroop. We are looking forward to hearing from you on this subject. Daas, Kulbir Singh Toronto, Canada.

Re: LADIVAAR FONT??

anxiously awaiting! · 05 May 2003

Wow, we are so fortunate to have Bhai Jaswant Singh Jee posting here! I humbly request Bhai Sahib Jee to post more as well, especially about their life and experiences with Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Jee.

Re: LADIVAAR FONT??

Meharban singh · 13 May 2003

Dear Bhai Sahib Kulbir Singh Ji WaheguruJIKaKhalsa WaheguruKiKiFateh! I have gone through the message on this forum and also your e-mail to me. Pita Jee is away to Rajasansi (in Amritsar) for A Sehaj Path Programmme. Your messages will be conveyed to him. Thanks for your encouragement on this activity. I think you have gone through his essay on this topic " Sacho Guru Gavacho Rai ". If not, I will manage to send it to you. My regards for the sangat be conveyed, please. M Singh

Re: LADIVAAR FONT??

Jaswant Singh · 30 May 2003

****ADMIN NOTE: This is a posting by Bhai Sahib Master Jaswant Singh jee. This is a good comparison. In brackets is description about Padd-chhed and without brackets is about Laridaar form.****************** SRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI in two formats makes difference LARI-DAAR form ( joined words ) (PAD-CHHED form( words separated )) That is God-given (It is given by man) Formal Guru-ship was given to that form(Guru-ship was not given to this form) Every hand written copy of S. G. G. S. is in this form (Printing in this form started around 1950 AD) In accordance with PANTHIC resolutions (Rebellion against PANTHIC resolutions) Formal PANTHIC resolutions were made to never allow printing of PAD-CHHED form (No formal PANTHIC resolution was made while starting printing of this form) Oneness of the text is there (Different PAD-CHHED words in the text by different publishers / institutions and by same institution in different reprints) There is no possibility of errors in the text if the LAG MATARS are taken care of (Possibility of hundreds of permanent errors getting inserted in the text, due to man) One who recites; searches and seeks company of learned GURSIKHS for help (One feels self – sufficient for reading) Feeling of respect as PARTAKH GURU is stronger in the sikh (Such feeling becomes much diluted. GURU GRANTH for many becomes GRANTH only) Makes the reader humble (Leads to arrogance) Produces or creates love and reverence for BANI and GURUS in the sikhs (Becomes reason for source of business, trade, bargaining etc.) Concentration while reading is desired (Concentration of mind not necessary) Compulsorily and thus automatically concentration is generated while reading (Mind is more free to go astray.) Makes us think & understand (Thinking not required for the reciter) Learned PATHIs are required (Layman with little knowledge of Gurumukhi script is apt to recite) Practice, perseverance and dedication is required for a PATHI singh to become AKHAND PATHI (In many instances; PATHI singhs with little respect of Maryada, earn livelihood through AKHAND PATH business) Keeps a disciple SANMUKH (Can make us BEMUKH. Refusal to recite from LARI-DAAR form is to be a BEMUKH)

Re: LADIVAAR FONT??

Master Jaswant Singh · 08 Jun 2003

Dear Bhai Sahib Kulbir Singh Ji Waheguru JI Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh! One more comparison can be drawn between the two forms. The words “Path Karna” ( Doing the path ) seem to be suitable only when doing it from “Lari-daar” Sri Guru Granth Sahib. In case of “Pad-Chhed” form, “Path Parna” ( Reading the Bani ) is more suitable. There is lot of difference between Karna (doing ) and Parna ( reading ). Simple reading is not as fruitful. The resolutions of Chief Khalsa Diwan and S. G. P. C., disapproving “the separating of the words” are given below. C. K. D. resolution no. 2682 dated Jan 21, 1945, “Neither the Parkash (the exposition ) of Pad-Chhed Bir nor the Akhand Path from this Bir is desirable. The printing of this form, whole Bani into one copy in separated words, is improper and harmful for the sikh nation ( Panth ). The matter regarding the Akhand Path from this Bir along with the suggestions of the members was discussed. The copy of the decision be sent to S.G.P.C. and news papers.” S.G.P.C. Religious Committee Gurmata no. 7 dated Jan 1,1950, “ It was decided by the committee that no person or organization should print the Pad-Chhed Bir. Nor its Parkash is desired.” Bhul Chuk Maaf Karna Ji Jaswant Singh

Re: LADIVAAR FONT??

Kulbir Singh · 09 Jun 2003

Bhai Sahib Master Jaswant Singh jeeo, Kot kot dhanvaad hai, ghareebaan noo nivaajan daa!! We are very grateful to you for writing up on Laridaar saroop. You made a very good point by pointing out the difference between “paath karna” and “paath paRnaa”. In the light of the resolutions by Chief Khalsa Diwan and SGPC, why is panth not doing anything about padd-chhed saroop? Master jeeo, could you please explain what strategies we can use to install the true saroop of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee in the mainstream Gurdwaras? What is there that can be done? Is there any organization that is working on this project? Please guide us on what we can do to make a difference. Please write if you have spoken to the officials in SGPC or if you have spoken to the jathedar of Akal Takhat about this. What is their response to this? What other organization is willing to help? I think we should form a coalition of like-minded organizations and bring this issue in the forefront. SAACHO GURU GAVAACHO RE!! We need a Makhan Shah Lubhaana today. Ghareeb nivaaz, Sachay Paatshah, Satguru jeeo, kirpa karo!!! Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: LADIVAAR FONT??

Manjit Singh · 10 Jun 2003

If someone still has a doubt in mind about Larhidaar Saroop, I can see only few reasons for that 1. One's bad karma 2. One is related to such a jathebandi which cannot correct itself and so is its followers. 3. Someone is moorakh even more than me.

Re: LADIVAAR FONT??

Jarnail Singh · 15 Jun 2003

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh. I have been learning and teaching Gurbani Paath for over 45 years now. IMHO everybody wants to become an "instant" pathi.....I beleive this disease is due to us eating instant noodles, instant pizzas, instant this and instant that. Can you imagine..people come to you with absolutely no knowledge even of Punjabi Alphabet.... and within three months want to be able to do Akhand paath. Just because they are able to "recognise" A B C in the Punjabi Kaida and they can string the alphabets to form words and they "see" these same alphabets in the Guru Granth Sahib Ji and they think...AH, Gurbani is not THAT DIFFICULT after all............ The Padchhed Birs are there for us to LEARN and PRACTISE...JUST like a LEARNERS LICENSE. After years of learning and practise if we feel adequate then we should do Paath on a Laridaar Saroop and if we can go beyond "first gear" ........well and good. BUT if the "engine" keeps "dying" on us then we should know we are NOT THAT GOOD A PATHI and go back to some more practise. But in todays superfast rat race world who has the time to practise......sadly any tom singh dick singh and harry singh who can barely recognise the Gurmukhi letters, calls himself a qualified paathi.....and some EVEN INSIST they are GOOD......or even BETTER than others. This is because we have lost the BHAEH and BHAU...first there MUST be BHAEH (FEAR) of GURU in our heart then follows BHAU (LOVE) of GURU....If there is NO Bhaeh (fear) and people just treat SGGS as a mere book. which Cannot "retaliate" even if you read everything wrong.......then LOVE will NOT FOLLOW. My late dad Gyani darbara Singh learnt Gurbani Paath from Gurbchan Singh Bhinderawaleh and the daily routine was just one page 25 times......and any mistake would solicit a SLOTAR ( big stick) on the head or back.....now a days people take a "postal lesson in Gurmukhi followed by a postal lesson in 25 pages of SGGS and after going through them they are qualified patthis. D.I.Y. lessons in Gurbani paath are offerred by well known Sikh organsiations which should know better.