Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Bhai Chaman Lal

Bhai Chaman Lal

Jinder · 25 Dec 2003

Is Bhai Chaman Lal a part of the RSS, I heard Jatehdar Bhai Ranjit Singh say that? What do you guys think?

Re: Bhai Chaman Lal

Trying to be a Gursikh · 25 Dec 2003

He's now a Singh. Some of his new tapes has pictures of him in khalsa roop

Re: Bhai Chaman Lal

? · 25 Dec 2003

hasnt he taken amrit for the last few years now?

Re: Bhai Chaman Lal

hhh · 27 Dec 2003

dont know not sure but he came to vancouver like 2 years ago i suppose his kirtan is awesome though dude

Re: Bhai Chaman Lal

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 27 Dec 2003

bhai sahib is the kirtani who was/is a hindu rite? with juss mucha and ramaal on head? his kirtan wuz wikkid

Re: Bhai Chaman Lal

hhh · 27 Dec 2003

yeah that was him but now he is a gursikh

Re: Bhai Chaman Lal

hm · 28 Dec 2003

the "rss" tag is now being overused , its crazy how it jus jumps out of nowehere and attaches onto someones character when rumours spread. one cud accuse the common giannis of being "rss" when their singing shabads in hindi film tunes see how far it can get. bani has made an amritdhari sikh out of this guy, and we r here listening to rumours he is "rss"? thats absurd unless there is ground for such accusations, is there any? his background? can a man woman help what their born? i know a daughter of a gianni who became a muslim and now runs a bookstore on islamic literature is she an "akali sgpc sikh" agent coming to destroy islam? it seems anyone can play on the "rss" tag as a political stunt to pull down another sikh. according to cynthia mahmoods book fighting for faith and nation same thing happened to the jhajaru movement one sikh didnt agree with the next, then all of a sudden their accused of being an "indian agent". judging people like that leads to consequences and damages the person in different ways.

Re: Bhai Chaman Lal

sikh · 29 Dec 2003

imagine how a sikh would feel in the olden days if rumours were spread of their being "moghul agent" after taking amrit? to what extent would that person be hurt? especially since such a entity was out to destroy sikhi? some people call the singh sabha movement "british agents", how hurtful is that? certain sikhs sacrificed their whole lives for that cause , didnt get married, went to free gurdwaras cameback as cripples from mahant heavyhandedness. Today certain people spread they were "british agents". Sant jarnail singh was accused of many things one of them having connections with ISI, this lead to further rumours. how does this all start? From where do these rumours start?

Re: Bhai Chaman Lal

panesar · 30 Dec 2003

as long as dirty politics are played in religion to attack one sikh or the next we wont be getting far for that is breeding a chalaki religio political culture within the confines of the sanctity of religion and anti unity. Like it or not Guru Sahib will punish. everything in sikhi that seems slightly out of shape cant be revolving around rss every instance. Chaman Singh might have done kirtan as a mona to start with, does that mean every single mona on stage doing kirtan is rss? whos fault is it the committees or the masses who dont know? how was bhai rama singh treated? then why should bhai chaman singh be labelled rss? is there even an apology that it might have been a mistake speculating? if not what does that show? is there any supportive evidence of claims? if not then why are these claims not taken back?

Re: Bhai Chaman Lal

ashamed · 31 Dec 2003

its pretty obvious the rumours in that case have been started to make a fellow amritdhari a son of Guru Gobind Singh look like dirt, leading to implications on all those who start, spread, believe in political propaganda, this life isnt going to last forever we have to answer to guru sahib and nindia isnt a small game where you get away on brownie points.