Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Guru Nanak Dev Ji on a SHIP?

Guru Nanak Dev Ji on a SHIP?

daas · 04 May 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh When the Great SatGuru Nanak Dev Ji Maharaj travelled on their voyages (udhasis) to other countries such as Iran, Iraq, Saudi Arabia, Sri Lanka, China to do Parchar......it is written in history that they travelled in a SHIP. I have a few questions in regards to this: When Guru Ji & Bhai Mardana went in the ship, who's ship was it? Who drove the ship? If it was somebody else's ship, was that person a GurSikh? When the ship arrived in other coutries, did Guru Ji have any problems arriving & entering the country? How long did it take in the ship? I was just thinking about this and was curious. I would appreciate it if somebody could enlighten me please. thank you, bhul chuk maaf karna Jee

Re: Guru Nanak Dev Ji on a SHIP?

daas · 05 May 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh does anybody know anything about this?

Re: Guru Nanak Dev Ji on a SHIP?

----- · 05 May 2006

Guru Nanak Dev ji did not travel on a ship when they went for the udhaasi's....he didnt need any mode of transportation...remember he was God himself....they oceans made room for him while he walked.......I dont know where you got the ship thing from?.....but I was told he went on foot all thew way!

Re: Guru Nanak Dev Ji on a SHIP?

daas · 07 May 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh thank you for your reply. I could be wrong, but I know Guru Ji met a lot of people on their journeys. The reason why I mentioned the ship is according to a picture I saw about Guru Ji's travels. I will ask admin to post it here so you can see it for yourself.

Re: Guru Nanak Dev Ji on a SHIP?

satnam · 07 May 2006

Guru Nanak Dev jee went to all Udasi's by walking. You can read Bhai Bala jee's Janam sakhi which is considered authentic by all sikh organizations.

Re: Guru Nanak Dev Ji on a SHIP?

Mehtab Singh · 08 May 2006

I heard that all Gurujee did was ask Mardana to close his eyes, and when he would open them after a few seconds, they would be where they intended to go. Distance didn't matter at all.

Re: Guru Nanak Dev Ji on a SHIP?

Trigger · 08 May 2006

oceans made way for him?? did you see this happen?

Re: Guru Nanak Dev Ji on a SHIP?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 08 May 2006

why would Mardana need to "close" his eyes... cant Guru ji do it with his eyes open... Sounds like childish magician trick..close your eyes...now open your eyes..barcadbra open sesame..!!! Clap Clap Clap Bhai bala didnt even EXIST...how could his janam sakhi be authentic ??..when he himself is not authentic ?? Guru Nanak Was Narayan aap kaladhaar jagat mehn parvario...a Honest to Godness KIRTEE, Householder, Farmer, Shopkeeper, Feeder of the Poor...and He WALKED on His two God given FEET..to spread His Message of Divine Love.. THe "SHIP" is the House of NANAK...that saves us Klayugee Jeeves.from sinking in this Ocean of MAYA....Saddeh Guraan ne JAHAZ Baniyaah....Waheguru NAAM JAHAAZ HAI..jo charreh so utreh paar

Re: Guru Nanak Dev Ji on a SHIP?

----- · 08 May 2006

"oceans made way for him?? did you see this happen" No but I have heard this.....I wish I could have seen it but im not that fortunate!.......plus this is based on every individuals sharda....and the amount of sharda towards guru ji...if u dont beleive in it, dont!......

Re: Guru Nanak Dev Ji on a SHIP?

A Singh · 09 May 2006

"drove a ship" I didn't realise you 'drove' a ship...what next, they 'sailed' a car?

Re: Guru Nanak Dev Ji on a SHIP?

----- · 09 May 2006

Dear Jarnail Singh Arshi ji "Bhai bala didnt even EXIST...how could his janam sakhi be authentic ??..when he himself is not authentic" Bhai Bala ji did exist......there are so many sakhis in which we hear Bhai Mardana, Bhai Bala and Guru Nanak himself...all three of them went to places to help us kuljugi jeev......please dont delete his presence from our sikh history.......

Re: Guru Nanak Dev Ji on a SHIP?

a singh · 09 May 2006

guru nanak dev ji IS god and can do whatever he pleases.

Re: Guru Nanak Dev Ji on a SHIP?

A.S.Khalsa · 09 May 2006

VJKK VJFF 'Daas' Ji, I hope this is usefull my brother, Brothetrs and sisters yes it is true that Siri Guru Nanak Dev Ji travelled on a ship. This is stated in the 'Janam Sakhis' of the gurus(these are biographys about the gurus lives written in the times of the gurus - in Guru Nanak Dev Ji's case the biography was told by Bhai Bala who was Guru Nanak Dev Ji's childhood and lifelong friend , the next Guru - Guru Angad Dev Ji was very pleased with this accurate biography of the almighty Guru Ji.) This extract is taken from an AMAZING book targeted at the youth of western countries written in English - ' The Gursikh Legacy' By Harjinder Singh Lallie. It is worth getting a copy to read Sangat Ji, it truely is addictive and unique. ''In 1518, the Guru embarked on the Final journey towards the west. He dressed himself as a muslim Pilgrim, a Haji, with him he carried a staff and a mat for the call of prayer. Bhai Mardana Ji (Guru Ji's companion and best friend) The two trvelled on a ship to the Arabian States and theron the two walked to the great cities of Arabia. They arrived in the Holy city of Mecca by which time it was night.........'' While Guru Nanak stayed at Mecca near the Holy Ka'ba, many Holy Pirs, Kazis etc came to visit him including the head of faith, Makhdum Rukan Din... as well as other famous Holy Muslim Men who asked the Guru to stay longer but the time was decided when to leave. The head of faith was impressed by Guru Nanak Dev Ji and asked for a sign of remeberance and the Guru left behind his sandles. The Muslim Holy man prized this more then his life. When Rukan Din moved to Hindustan he brought these with him, and can still be found in the museum of the Pir, also known as the museum of Uch Sharif. Guru Ji was dressed as a muslim - just as all people on the pilgrimage are. They did not recieve any difficulties in terms of getting into countries including Mecca as who would question a Holy man dressed appropriatley with the full knowledge of other religions. As for who was driving and on the boat were other muslims who were on the pilgimage too. Forgive me for any mistakes Brothers and Sisters, I am a fool who makes countless mistakes... I hope than Vaheguru blesses you all...and me! VJKK VJFF

Re: Guru Nanak Dev Ji on a SHIP?

singhstar · 09 May 2006

Jarnail Singh Arshi Very well said, there was no Bhai Bala. Bala was probably included by some fanatical Brahmin back in the day Older Sakhis dont even mention Bhalla. Also how could Guru Nanak Ji be God !!

Re: Guru Nanak Dev Ji on a SHIP?

A.S.Khalsa · 09 May 2006

VJKK VJFF I have found another book that is based on the janam sakhis of the gurus- and yes Bhai Bala Ji DID exist and can be seen in ancient paintins in Harmandir Sahib (Golden Temple) sitting with Guru Nanak Dev Ji and Bhai Mardana. The other Gurus were completely aware of the sakhis written by Bhai Bala and did not oppose or argue against it - infact the task set of writing it was set by Guru Angad Dev Ji- the 2nd Guru. '' The Guru went west to Hinglaj. Here he met a group of pilgrims on their way to Mecca. He joined them and crossed the Arabian Sea with them. Guru Nanak was dressed in Blue robes, a colour that is sacred to the muslims and carried everything that a Muslim Pilgrim carried: a staff, a prayer mat, the Holy book, and a pot for his morning wash. The boat brought them to Jeddah and the pilgrims traveled with a caravan towards Mecca. Soon they were joined by many others........'' Extract from a book called '' The Lives and Teachings of the Sikh Gurus'' by Harish Dhillon. I hope this was usefull relating this topic. Please forgive me for any offence or mistakes. God bless you all.... VJKK VJFF

Re: Guru Nanak Dev Ji on a SHIP?

daas · 09 May 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Dear A.S. Khalsa Jee, thank you so much for your post and information. It does help, I was just curious about Guru Maharaj Jee's udhasis. I just hope the Sangat can stay in Chardi Kala and not get into any controversial issues on this thread. Nanak Kee Ardaas Suneejai || Keval Naam Ridhei Meh Deejai ||

Re: Guru Nanak Dev Ji on a SHIP?

The Khalsa Fauj · 09 May 2006

Sharda has a limit too. Bhekhi sharda has no use. Guru Sahib Ji says, Aaklee Sahib Saivee-aye Wisdom is very important. As for Bala, he is a fake character. He isn't even mentioned in Bhai Gurdas's Vars. If he was this important, he would have been mentioned. Bhai Bala Janamsakhi is actually written by Hurbhagat Nirunjanee-aa and gang. These are the same people who added stuff like mira bhai shabad, raag maala, jit dur mohamdaa, etc. etc. into Guru Granthh Sahib Ji. Hurbhagat was directly responsible for getting Bhai Taru Singh arrested.

Re: Guru Nanak Dev Ji on a SHIP?

The Khalsa Fauj · 09 May 2006

As for SatGuru Nanak Ji's travels, Guru Nanak Ji walked towards Middle East and Rome if Guru Ji went there and on the way back, Guru Ji came in a ship. With stories like ocean gave way, we are not going to spread Sikhi anywhere to outsiders. It is only useful when on kids. Same goes for Mardana meet ukhaa bhain Naankee baloundee hai. Parsaada shakan chulee-aye. These kinds of stories bring nothing but kunn russ. Munn Russ is the main thing, which comes from recitation of Gurbani. Naam Juppo by reading Gurbani.

Re: Guru Nanak Dev Ji on a SHIP?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "arshi" · 10 May 2006

if BHAI BALA JI was that important..how come he is not even mentioned once by BHAI GURDASS Ji..who mentions Bhai mardana ... On the Mecca trip ONLY TWO are mentioned..Baba nanak and Baba Mardana !!! WHY exclude (or forget ??) the THIRD member of this TRINITY ?? The Bala janmasakhi is a SPURIOUS "distortion of sikh hsitory" written by the MEHRBAN GROUP to discredit Guru nanak and his Line to the Betterment of the RIVAL Mehrban Group ( these were the sons of GURUS who didnt get Gurgadee)..to this day this Group has possession of Kartar Pur Bir compiled by GURU ARJUN JI. Ancient paintings are NO indicator of truth..these paintings that show bala..also show Guru nanak ji WEARING A TOPI !!! Several paintings on Darbar Sahib walls show DEVIS and Devtas... etc etc... Several paintings also show Moolmantar to be up to Hosee bhi sach...and under that Eh sewa Ranjit singh ne karvaee ( LOgically IF we take EVERYTHING WRITTEN as PROOF of moolmantar length..then the sewa ranjit singh ne karvaee should also be part of Moolmantar ) Bala is a FIGMENT of imagination...

Re: Guru Nanak Dev Ji on a SHIP?

a singh · 10 May 2006

Also how could Guru Nanak Ji be God !! ^^ dunno......umm maybe coz he was god ...........

Re: Guru Nanak Dev Ji on a SHIP?

singh · 10 May 2006

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Author: satnam Date: 05-07-06 08:51 Guru Nanak Dev jee went to all Udasi's by walking. You can read Bhai Bala jee's Janam sakhi which is considered authentic by all sikh organizations. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Have you READ "Bhai Bala's Janam Sakhi"??? Bhai Bala and his Janam Sakhi came in public limelight in 1950s. A Sikh author in Delhi published the book. At the LAST PAGE of the book he wrote "this is not true." A full month was dedicated on Panjab Radio going through Bhai Bala Janam Sakhi and showing how it actually INSULTED Guru Nanak Dev Sahib Jee. Have you read the ENTIRE Bhai Bala Janam Sakhi? Did you conveniently skip over the part where it was written that BHAI BALA "revealed and recited ANAND SAHIB" (when it was GURU AMAR DAAS JEE). Did you conveniently skip over the part where it says that Guru Nanak Dev Jee "HAD TO BE RE-BORN" because of his "SINS" from his PAST LIFE. One's tongue burns just commenting on the writings!!! Is Bhai Bala ALL-KNOWING???? Does Bhai Bala not recognise that GURU NANAK DEV SAHIB JEE came to EARTH to REDEEM the WORL OF SIN through sharing the SHABD GURU (just read Bhai Gurdaas jee's vaars). * Where are Bhai Bala Jee's ANCESTORY?? * There are land records from Rai Bullar's time of all villagers, including Guru Nanak Sahib Jee and Baba Mardana Jee. But NO mention of Bhai Bala jee!!! * Bhai Bala Jee's Janam Sakhi is flawed with contradictions and insulting remarks about the Gurus (obviously written by Hindus who felt hurt that Guru Nanak Sahib Jee travelled with a "Muslim" and wished to undermine the Guru Sahibs) Rab sumat bakshe.

Re: Guru Nanak Dev Ji on a SHIP?

A.S.Khalsa · 10 May 2006

VJKK VJKF I am glad to say that yes Bhai Bala Ji did exist and the task of writing the janam sakhis was given to him by our 2nd Guru. This sakhi was looked over by people who knew Guru Nanak Dev Ji such as Baba Budha Ji, Guru Angad Dev JI etc...when the sakhis were passed down to the other Gurus im sure if they never heard of Bhai Bala Ji they would have said "Sangat Ji, whos this Bala fellow!'' Bhai Bala Ji's name is mentioned in sikhi through out the time of the Gurus many times. He can be seen on paints in the Harmander Sahib (Golden Temple) sitting with Guru Nanak Dev Ji, waving a fan over them while Bhai Mardana Ji plays the Rabab. NEVER UNDERESTIMATE Guru Nanak Dev Ji. No1 truley knows his TRUE GREATNESS and SHAKTI appart from the Holy company of Saints. We shall all find out exactly what Guru Nanak Dev Ji was when we leave this earth...maybe those of you who doublt who Guru Ji realy was can ask them when they are sitting up high on their immortal throne in Sach Khand...again dnt doubt them... it will be ur loss. Brothers and Sisters forgive a fool like myself for my mistakes, im still learning and Hope that Guru Nanak Dev Ji blesses you all... VJKK VJKF

Re: Guru Nanak Dev Ji on a SHIP?

Harminder Singh · 10 May 2006

Waheguru ji ka khalsa, Waheguru ji ki fateh bhai bala's name isn't in bhai gurdas ji's vaaran. The bala janamsakhi is supposed to have been written by the mina's. They also have pictures at the front trying to show their own lineage in one of the older versions they have in sikh collections right now. It is something to look into

Re: Guru Nanak Dev Ji on a SHIP?

singh · 10 May 2006

Bhai Gurdaas Jee says: [gurbani]iek bwbw Akwl rUp dUjw rbwbI mrdwnw][/gurbani] ek baabaa akaal roop doojaa rabaabee mardaanaa There was the Baba (Satguru Sri Guru Nanak Sahib Ji) in image (roop) of Akaal Purakh (the Timeless), and with him he had his companion Bhai Mardana Ji, the rebeck player. NO MENTION OF BHAI BALA!

Re: Guru Nanak Dev Ji on a SHIP?

singh · 10 May 2006

I heard in katha that the Guru walked. He also walked over the oceans. It's a big feat to walk for that distance, but for even a Sikh of the Guru to walk over water is no big thing if he has Naam Kamaai. Possible he took a ship for some voyages as well, don't know.

Re: Guru Nanak Dev Ji on a SHIP?

singhstar · 12 May 2006

there are several sakhis of Guru Nanak Ji in th British Library incl that of Bhai Bala Janam Sakhi among others. There also is a very early Sakhi, would be ood to know if that mentions Bhai Bala ???