Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

AKJ Question

AKJ Question

.. · 22 Dec 2003

Whats the point of AKJ, why be part of a group, when you can be part of the Khalsa. All these differenent groups are just like the caste system so whats the point, we as Gursikh should not be part of any group and just be part of the Khalsa. So please tell me why have AKJ and other groups. When we have the Khalsa.

Re: AKJ Question

domalla premee · 23 Dec 2003

Waheguruji ka Khalsa Waheguruji ki fateh Let us refocus a minute and look through the Guru's lens. Those people who have understood the Hukam at the time of amrit remember that you have become a Guru Ka Sikh above all and not a 'jatha's' Sikh. This is the understanding that is given to each candidate who takes amrit that they are part of the Khalsa Panth above and foremost. 'Akhand Kertanee Jatha' is just a nickname that stuck years ago to describe Gursikhs who loved to do continuous keertan for hours on end. There was another nickname called 'Bairamee Jatha' (jatha that does not sleep). For those of you looking and making judgements from the outside in this is God's honest truth. Please readjust your perceptions. These are just working Gursikhs plain and simple who gather together to perform keertan in their spare time, without the desire for profit and simply for the love of the Guru. Just because the name is repeated hundreds or thousands of times does not make it a group separate from the Khalsa Panth. There are some differences within the Panth itself about many things. Yet all these entities are part of the Panth. What is the deal?? The caste system segregates people into occupations and social status and is purely evil and forbidden by Sikh teachings. It degrades other human beings. There is not even the ground for comparison. Gursikhs are all equal in the eyes of the Gurus. The caste barriers dissappear unless someone is not personally following Gurujee's teachings. Gursikhs according to rehet maryada are told to remain among Gursikhs and I think maintaining a Gursikhi jeewan is the main motivator behind this and not to discriminate. The Khalsa Panth is an equal opportunity blessed fraternity and sisterhood with no parrallell anywhere. Panth Khalsa da dass

Re: AKJ Question

.. · 23 Dec 2003

Why do AKJ do keetha in the style they do, because thats not the way keetha should be done. It should be done with katha and keetha so you understand the bani. How can you understand bani if you just do WaheGuroo. So whats the point of the SGGS ?

Re: AKJ Question

nineteen 84 · 23 Dec 2003

the question is, why have the LABEL of an akj singh? why do we insist on telling people we are part of Taksal, or part of AKJ, or part oh whoever. we should rid ourselves of that totally. Jathas are to guide us, and bring us together in sikhi, not seperate us.

Re: AKJ Question

Trying to be Gursikh · 23 Dec 2003

I must admit this branding of jathas is really concerning me. I want to chak amrit this vasakhi and sometimes start getting so confused on which jatha to join. I sometimes lose the plot, maybe I am not ready for it....

Re: AKJ Question

Jugraj Singh · 23 Dec 2003

I once heard a gursikh explain the jathay bandi's this way. An army is made of different regiments/branches. The same way Akal Purakh's army (Khalsa) is made of different jatha bandi's. If you were ask a soldier what he did for a living. He would say I'm a marine, or i'm in the airforce or that I'm in the army. Hardly anyone would say that I work for the department of national defence. Same goes for the jathay bandi's. Their rehits differ for many reasons. But the goal of all jathay bandi's is the same. It's just that over time a lot of jathay have got dhil in their rehit etc. and have lost the technique for swas giras simran etc. If we are honest with ourselves we all know the reasons for the dhil in the rehit, it's easier not to keep rehit. Das, Jugraj Singh

Re: AKJ Question

Dogma · 24 Dec 2003

Jugraj Singh... I WHOLEHEARTEDLY agree with your point of different jathebandis being like branches on a tree. But I think the problem with that analogy is that in order for the "tree" to GROW and prosper then the branches have to work together. I think that many of the jathebandis are not tolerant of one another in ANY way. That's when then the JATHA bashing starts... So what do you suggest we do to keep our SIKHI tree strong?

Re: AKJ Question

Trying to be Gursikh · 24 Dec 2003

What about the creation of ego by having different jathas, i.e AKJ rehat is better than Taksal rehat. Nanaksar kirtan is better than AKJ kirtan. Have we not created 'jatha brand' affiliations over the last 10 years or so. My father told me that 30 years ago, it was just the khalsa panth. People took amrit from Bhai Randhir Singh's Jatha or from RaraSahib jatha or any other jatha, at the end of the day there was no discrimination. It was thought of as one. Everyone interacted with each other. Today it is all jatha driven, to the point interaction between GurSikhs is being jepordised. I know we make out that there is only one panth, but do you really think in practice it is really happening like that. Just something to think about. Just my observation

Re: AKJ Question

kookar ram ko · 25 Dec 2003

What are Kathees?

Re: AKJ Question

Jugraj Singh · 25 Dec 2003

I guess the panth is made up of individuals. Even within our "nuclear sangat" (people you hang out with the most) we have issues of trust and faith. Our ego's hold us back and the maal that has collected on our maan's over lifetimes makes it more difficult to do so. I guess we can be responsible for ourselves and do as much paath and simran as possible. If we do sewa of guru sahib then how can we not grow stronger as a panth. I think people spend a lot of time on discussins about various sikhi issues. vichar is good to a certain extent but without bani and naam to initiate and bring about changes what good are dicsussions. I will share my personal opinion. A lot of people know they are lacking certain rehit's etc. A lot of Singhs recognize the need for a dastaar for both men and women but because they feel that their jatha will increase in quantity they allow for dhil in rehit and do amrit sanchars without dastaars. This is wrong and I believe that they are seriously hurting Guru Sahib. In any case things like this mess up the panth. You get differences in rehit because some people belive in quantity over quality of sikhs. Some people blindly follow people they belive to be brahmgiani's. Even if the "brahmgiani" does things against gurmat they don't analyze the situation for themselves. A lot of our leaders are idiots. I remember some jathedar of akal takht had his interview published on sikhe.com and he flat out said dastaar for bibi's is not needed. Who the gave him the authority to override Guru Gobind Singh ji? We don't try to make a relationship with guru sahib. We continue to look for someone to do that for us. A sant etc. and this way we give these "sants" undue power and respect. They gain influence and start rehits according to their own maat rather then guru's. A lot of people will say that puratan rehit's aren't Sikhi. They'll say things like Sarbloh and Keski are lies. They will make baseless claims without thinking the situation through. All those people should ask themselves this question. What has hurt the panth more? If Singhs eat out of sarbloh does it not make the panth tighter... do we not become a close knit family. What hurts the panth more believing in keski as a kakkar or not? Which of these is more likely encouraged by anti-panthic organizations to destroy Sikhi and undermine our uniqueness our identity. A lot of the rehit that Singhs keep is designed to knit the panth closer together. Example sarbloh and bibek. Even things like taking a stand on the larivaar issue is a big deal. We all know that we should have larivaar saroop da parkash (because guru sahib did it that way) but we continue to support the padh-ched saroop. Things like this create a division in the panth and people who want to follow guru sahib's hukam are labeled fundamentalists. It is our own weakness/laziness/lack of faith that hurts the panth. If we want panthic unity we have to start with ourselves and try to get kamai of Guru sahib's hukams. Sikhi is about quality. We must analyze our own jeevens and determine wether we are living the lives that guru sahib wants/intended for us to live. Guru sahib already sacrificed everything and will give his Khalsa anything ... we just have to be HIS Sikhs rather then following our own mat. Remeber it has always been said, "Raj Karega Khalsa". Das, Jugraj Singh

Re: AKJ Question

hayar · 25 Dec 2003

my mates dad took amrit from bhai randhir singh's jatha in ludhiana and sed the same thing, back then they jus took amrit it was no way like it is today it wasnt a group and bhai sahib was very very widely respected as one of the most spiritual robhi sakht singhs in that century.

Re: AKJ Question

uk singh · 25 Dec 2003

>A lot of our leaders are idiots. I remember some jathedar of akal takht had his interview published on sikhe.com and he flat out said dastaar for bibi's is not needed. Who the gave him the authority to override Guru Gobind Singh ji?>> the same goes for Jathebandhis... My mate has Talvinder Singh Babbar on tape saying that we should all follow one maryada which was established in 1945....who do we believe? All answers are found by doing bhagti...we just argue too much over b/s.. All Jathebandhis are egocentric....they have cemented their beliefs in different views....and none is willing to budge as THEY are OBVIOUSLY right.. Because of our egoes, Singhs cannot get on with other Singhs they are like oil and water. Why should this be the case..??? We do not need external forces like the rss/arya samajists to destroy Sikhi....we are managing fine by ourselves...we are a laughing stock! the amount of inter-jathebandhi nindiya is off the scale! problems arise when we try and push rehat onto others... if someone has take pahul at Akal Takht, Taksaal so what? is this not real amrit?

Re: AKJ Question

Singh · 25 Dec 2003

The Khalsa Panth has always had smaller seva groupings, even during the very early days with the various Misls. Akhand Kirtani Jatha is the backbone of the Khalsa Panth. If Jatha did not exist, where would we find such a collection of Naam-Abhiaasee & Rehatvaan Gurmukhs? It is a pleasure to be with the Sangat of these Gurmukhs - otherwise where would we find true Saadh Sangat as ordered by our Guru Ji? This is not to say that Gurmukh are only in Jatha, but that Jatha is an abvious collection of such prime examples of Gurmukhs that can be easily located anywhere in the world. From my experience, all Gurmukhs who enjoy singing Vaheguru's praises attend Jatha programs, whether they are "Jatha" or not is not important. Jatha Singhs do not consider themselves different by calling themselves Jatha Singhs, but its just a way of identifying these Gursikhs. Jatha does not seek to create any differences. Jatha simply promotes the message of Gurmat. This is the reason why Jatha has grown in just a few decades to be the largest Jathaibandee in the Panth today, without question. The strength of the Jatha is in the Naam Abiaasee lifestyles and the Kirpa of Guru Granth Sahib Jee. Nowhere else have I seen such loyalty to the words of our Guru in today's age. May the Jatha further prosper as a beautiful flower in the garden of Guru Ji.

Re: AKJ Question

Jugraj Singh · 26 Dec 2003

Uk Singh, valid points about the confusion. perhaps we should take the initiative and do the research for ourselves and ofcourse do a lot of ardaas for bibek budhi. Even if we choose certain issues to unite on we can achieve a lot. I honestly can't think of anyway to justify the parkash of larivaar saroop. Perhaps we should all begin with taking a stand on such basic issues. Having something in common to strive for brings people together like nothing else. Jatha singhs are known for doing parkash of larivaar saroop but the sad truth is that many jatha singhs also have parkash of pad ched saroop in their own homes. I believe (correct me if I'm wrong) their was a akhand keertan samagam where pad ched saroop was parkash. This was a while back in Toronto. Also, a lot of Jatha Singhs are now openly saying "it's good to keep khand/peen da bibek but it's not necessary". ???? explain that one? bhai sahib must have been a fool staying hungry for all those days when it wasn't really necessary. das, Jugraj Singh

Re: AKJ Question

warrior*princess · 26 Dec 2003

There is GREAT importance where true reht is kept and passed on, by Guru jee, at amrit sanchaar and where it is followed. So yes it does matter where you take amrit, jee. Guru Gobind Singh jee said there is only Khalsa. Khalsa can only exist under the true reht, i.e. those who live in accordance to it, and nothing else.

Re: AKJ Question

happy new year · 26 Dec 2003

i think its pointless argueing over issues like dat. if people really wanna be strict, then why dont they do things for humanity? poor? seva for elderly the needy? surely thats what early day sikhs did, and bhai sahib himself is a prime example of that by reforming the lowest sections of society towards gurmat was he not? whats gonna make u a better sikh? doin things for yourself or for others? how long will you sit there and wait till you see signs of your own progress/ while doin things that help others and sharing with humanity helps u progress too and helps you see God inside them. god bless folks.

Re: AKJ Question

happy new year · 26 Dec 2003

and i dont mean charity, i mean sincerely giving out of your heart for others and working to help society whether they are amritdhari or not whilst doing naaam and living a greest jivan.

Re: AKJ Question

happy new year · 26 Dec 2003

btw what is the literal term of khalsa? does one achieve the state of khalsa after taking amrit alone?

Re: AKJ Question

. · 26 Dec 2003

i think akj back then was just rensbhais and kirtan in bhai sahibs time very simple, but today although it has that side, its also has a political dimension to, not miri piri sense, but political socially as a group member. This can be an encouragement for some and a hinder to spiritual progress for others. kirtan always rocks.

Re: AKJ Question

dust of the sangat 11111 · 27 Dec 2003

Gurfateh Ji, what is a keetha singh?

Re: AKJ Question

Calendar · 27 Dec 2003

Above all, everyone will say they are a sikh or a part of the khalsa, before they will say they are akj or taksali.

Re: AKJ Question

Chetan pro0akj · 27 Dec 2003

GKhalsa Ji, the caste system is evil akj is just a jatha, i am sure the gursikhs in akj will say they are khalsa above saying they are akj.

Re: AKJ Question

harkeerat singh · 27 Dec 2003

please argument na start karo

Re: AKJ Question

yep · 28 Dec 2003

akj is one of the very few jathabandis that upholds maryada much respect.

Re: AKJ Question

Wonderful Broadcast · 29 Dec 2003

Akj does awesome kirtan it rocks. Its a jatha, who cares, their gursikhs!!!! wow...