Live Broadcasts, video cameras, isit spiritually beneficial ?
Tanned Singh · 22 Dec 2003
VaheguruJiKaKhalsaVaheguruJiKiFateh
over the weekend there was a Rahensbai kirtan at Coventry (awesome program) lots of sangat.
I was just wondering - the main reason for such programs is for Gurbani Kirtan and for sangata to join together and sing the divine hymns From Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, without any distraction, pause ..............
so my question is - should a Program be organised to revolve around the live broadcast or should the program be run and organised in a way that the sangat that ARE AT THE GURDWARA benefit the most and not be distracted from the main aspect of the program ?
The raehinsbai was great allot of sevadaars did great work hiring a new sound system that was ace ! the kirtan was broadcasted live for sangata around the globe to listen/watch the program BUT is it worth the sangat who attends the program/smagam loosing concentration or being interrupted by videoing, live broadcasts ??
during the rehensbai 3 Huge lights where put on facing the sangat at all angles (by huge lights I mean the kind you have in your garden - flood lights). which was really irritating and hot, when the guru pyaraei who put the lights up where asked what they where for, they said ''the live broadcast was too dark''.
90% of the Gursikhs sitting in front of the lights where really irritated.
Don't get me wrong the seva done was a great seva but maybe when we have a good idea we shouldn't get tooo into the idea so that it ruins it for the gursikhs who have made an effort to come to the program ?
is it not distracting to have video cameras and live broadcast lights always in your face ?
do we really need live broadcasts ? the video quality isn't great, most of the time it goes on the blink or the sound doesn't work and all we seem to hear in return is how Veer Fullana Singh ji was shaking his head so hard and how the tabla was popped :s
why not just record it and put it online within the next few days, qualities better no need to waste money and time setting up all the equipment ? and why the need for so many video cameras do we not know how to share anymore ? Kirtan doesn't belong to us but to everyone, so why make a video and keep it locked away. couldn't one person record it and make copies ?
I guess the main thing I would wish to know is -
was it worth all the huge lights and distracting allot of the sangat with 7-8 fancy PC's and slim monitors for a live broadcast ? wouldn't it be allot more worthwhile for everyone to sit and not worry about the rest of the things at that point in time and enjoy the Kirtan and let others enjoy it too ?
No offence intended, bhula chuga maaf karnia
'Tanned' Singh
VaheguruJiKaKhalsaVaheguruJiKiFateh
Re: Live Broadcasts, video cameras, isit spiritually beneficial ?
Hardeep Singh · 22 Dec 2003
Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa
Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh!
I was one of the people who was watching the live broadcast. I know what i was watching was nothing compared to actually being at the ransabai, but i think i did benefit from it.
In regards to the broadcast being too dark. I think the problem could have been solved much easier by adjusting a few of the settings in the camera itself instead of adding so much lighting. I'm pretty sure most current cameras themselves would have been able to solve the problem, and if not, a small light near where the Kirtania were would have been just fine as well, not 3 flood lights on all the sangat.
I agree with Tanned Singh that the sangat at the ransabai should not be affected by the live broadcast.
Hardeep Singh
Re: Live Broadcasts, video cameras, isit spiritually beneficial ?
Comdex 2003 held at Coventry · 22 Dec 2003
Totally agree.
I find Reansabais are becoming increasingly a tech show. The broadcast could have been done with just 2pcs max (i.e. california). I think the sangat witnessed a new deffinition to overkill. And the lights were a distraction, rather than having 10 lamps all over the place why not just have one good one, or perhaps use a bulb with better lighing effects so that it does not blind the sangat.
Especially for the younger kids, its already difficult to get them to concentrate on the Kirtan but when they start to gather round the equipment instead of their Guru, well this is not a good thing.
My only point is that this lazyness of the Sevadars in their space race to get the Kirtan recorded and online ASAP by doing all the tasks on the fly during the Reansabai; was a distraction to the Sangat, obviously i doubt it would have made much difference if there was 2 pcs or 10 but the point was that there was no effort to discresion and alot of tasks could have been done later.
I think for next time the Sevadars need to strike a balance between enjoying kirtan and providing a service to the sangat.
Vaaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa, Vaaheguroo Jee Kee Fateh!
Re: Live Broadcasts, video cameras, isit spiritually beneficial ?
W!N Sevadar · 23 Dec 2003
Waheguroo jee ka khalsa waheguroo jee kee fateh!!
We somewhat agree. Distraction is not good. This was the first in UK and I think the sevadars need to get used to it. The first few broadcasts Waheguroo! Network did caused a lot of distraction and we felt very guilty about it. BUT now we have minimized it to where we arent interrupting and we do not use lights. I think once the UK sevadars get the hang of it, it will be a lot less of a distraction.
You know what though? I felt like I was there! I felt like I was sitting right there. We turned out the lights and watched the whole rainsbaee, and it was amazing. For me, the broadcast was worth it. I loved it.
We should aim to minimize the distractions. We can do the broadcast now with one PC and we aim to get everything done beforehand as not to distract keertanis. Also, problems of it cutting out have been minimized with experience and the UK broadcast only cut out a few times because their wires were loose.
I think it should continue as long as we keep distraction to a minimum. During Waheguroo! Network live broadcasts, nobody has complained about any distractions, and if somebody did, we would immediately fix the problem or get out of the way. So if anyone does have any concerns, speak up at the program, I am sure the sevadars will listen.
Re: Live Broadcasts, video cameras, isit spiritually beneficial ?
Hardeep Singh · 23 Dec 2003
singh,
This isnt about complaining, but about constructive criticism from concerned sangat.
It was appreciated by myself and others that the broadcast was done. However people on this thread have been pointing out ways to improve it.
If it was the professional video guy who had the lights, maybe they should reconsider having a professional do it.
Hardeep Singh
Re: Live Broadcasts, video cameras, isit spiritually beneficial ?
singheee laad · 23 Dec 2003
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Wahe guru Ji Ki Fateh,
Daas was one of the sewadaars trying to help with the live broadcast.
First of all i would like to apologise if any distraction or discomfort was caused to the sangat.
just to clarify a few points the lights were brought by a member of the sangat who was filimg the keertan, he had 3 cameras and we asked to borrow a light as the feedback from net was that the video was way too dark. The lighting in general in the durbar hall was very poor. Another 9 cameras were also brought by other mebers of the sangat wich i think also adds to the distraction.
Only 2 pcs were used for the broadcast, one more laptop was used for sikhi to the max and one more laptop for monitoring msn/messagboards etc.
The main lights were switched off by a member of the sangat, but immediatly we were told by a committe member that the lights should be switched back on for Health and safety reasons.
Suffice to say that this is our first live broadcast and we have learnt many things and we will continue to learn, its through feedback such as this, that we can improve the service with minimal impact to the local sangat.
Apologies again for our many mistakes.
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: Live Broadcasts, video cameras, isit spiritually beneficial ?
Tanned Singh · 23 Dec 2003
VaheguruJiKakhalsaVaheguruJiKiFateh
for some reason discussions always seem to go in opposite diretcions from what they started off as.
The reason for the first message was not to slate the sevadaars or live broadcasts. but to ask is it the sangat in the hall who have come to the program and are sitting trying to concentrate.
we can say that if we had our eyse closed then we wouldnt have realised anything happening around us, but thats not always the case by closing your eyse you cant stop the bright light completely it still causes some irritation.....
Yes everyone has different levels to which they can enjoy certain things.
i was once told a story about how in Bhai sahib Bhai Randhir singh ji's time there was times when bhai sahib would hit his Karei together when he would enjoy the kirtan, but another singh would loose concentration even if he heard slight movement or talking.
everyone is differnet but i think 90% of ppl agree that the lights were too bright, not just the camera ones but the final light that was put up by the gumukh pyara sevadaar was the brightest.
a singh sitting near daas asked the sevadaar if they needed it and said it was hot and bright, i heard the reply ''close your eyes'' :s
well anyways.the lights where bright, the proffesional camrea man, was it needed ? with didigtal cameras you dont need all those lights maybe they wernt so proffesional (no offence).
and its not that the equipment was in the way of anyone but allot of youth spend there time staring at it (even though they should be trying to concentrate).
we can all say that we should ''close our eyes'' or look towards the sikhi to the max screen and not at the pc's, but it does have an effect on ppl around little children run around seeing what all the pc's are for and they distract ppl.................but again this isnt the issue the issue was the big brigth lights, and huge amounts of equipment.
do we really need the live broadcasts to be really bright, someone earlier has said that we shouldnt complain, but when someone online complained it was too dark the sevadaars added more lights ?
what is the fascination to see the keertan shouldnt we be listening ?? why not have audio broadcasts an have the sikhi to the max changing on the screen live ??
if the sevadaars had actually listened to the sangat that was there instead of the sangat who wanted brightter picture couldnt it have been made better for both the sangata, online and live sangat ?
bhula chuga maaf
daas
Tanned Singh
vahegurujikakhalsavahegurujikifateh
Re: Live Broadcasts, video cameras, isit spiritually beneficial ?
make a big deal singh · 23 Dec 2003
VAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA VAHEGURU JI KI FATEH
Veer/Bhain Jee,
Maybe you didn't read the last post before yours, but the Sevadar has said they have taken your points on board and will be looking into improving it for the next live broadcast this was just the start of many to come and no duobt there would have been some issues to deal with hence on the orginal email advertising the broadcast, it was wirtten please bare with us for this is our first attempt.
We did try all other ways to improve the video quailty but it wasn't as simple as tweeking the video card or whatever, we wouldn't have had the lights up for no reason if it was just tweeking a few settings.
Maybe this is your first international Rhainsabi... but every international Rhainsabi that i can recall has had some sort of extra lighting.
also Ajit Singh has mentioned that there wasn't HUGE amounts of euipment, bare minimum euipment was used, 1 pc and 2 laptops which was probably taking up the space of 2 people and totally to one side.
for the future we will try not to use any lighting where we dont need it, but the feedback we have had from sangta around the world would suggest that it is worth while doing such broadcasts.
We could really go on forever saying what is a distraction in the darbar hall during Rhainsabi..... but points have been noted and will be corected for next time, there is nothing anti-gurmat in live broadcats, something that might not be a fascination to you, could be very inspriing for others to be able to do darshan of Gursikhs sitting 1000's of miles away... and if the likes of Bhai Jarnail Singh Jee can give 'asees' and say keep up the good work, i don't see there being a problem.
I think this is turning into a point-less debate, your points have been noted.
VAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA VAHEGURU JI KI FATEH
Re: Live Broadcasts, video cameras, isit spiritually beneficial ?
jaat kamini · 24 Dec 2003
dhun mehi dhiaan dhiaan mehi jaaniaa gurumukh akuth kehaanee
I think we dont need the video BECAUSE its a distraction to the dhun................Sikhi is about Dhun..........Anhad naad...........not about watching...........its about listening and feeling on your inside...............rather than watching
Re: Live Broadcasts, video cameras, isit spiritually beneficial ?
Sarbloh Singh... · 24 Dec 2003
i dont think watching the keertani doing keertan is more important than listenign to the keertan and guru jee's bani, with live broadcasts all people tend to do is look at whos attended the smagam and loose concentration on the bani/keertan...i think that audio live broadcast is enough..
bhul chuk maaf
gurfateh
Re: Live Broadcasts, video cameras, isit spiritually beneficial ?
kookar ram ko · 25 Dec 2003
How do you download sikhi to the max? ive tried so much but it just wont work
Re: Live Broadcasts, video cameras, isit spiritually beneficial ?
uk singhnee · 25 Dec 2003
bhai rama singh ji came back from a smagam in new york to the uk and requested a singh that he should get the video films of the kirtan smagam posted to bhai sahib in the uk so he could do the sangats darshan when he was back in uk, bhai rama singh ji also would take photos of gursikhs so he could do their darshan and would show us youth, some of us are just good at putting everything down, if someone if doing something from which people are attracted to sangat and kirtan please do not discourage them, just learn from the jeevan of bhai rama singh ji, especially the uk sangat who have done so much sangat of bhai sahib should know better but they seem to be the worse at putting everyone else down, who knows maybe from seeing so much sangat on the videos someone might even come join in the sangat next time. i myself came more interested into kirtan smagams when bhai rama singh jee showed me a video of a kirtan in vancouver i was just so amazed with how much sangat was into the kirtan, maybe if i had never seen that video i would never have later done sangat of such great gursikhs that i meet at the kirtans now
Re: Live Broadcasts, video cameras, isit spiritually beneficial ?
Tanned Singh · 25 Dec 2003
vahegurujikakhalsawahegurujikifateh
Broadcasts are a good thing (to a certain extent) and they shouldnt be stopped. i agree that audio is allot better than video but Video is also good. the main reason to start this discusiion was that.........to make the broadcast better we tend to go overboard and make the smagam revolve around the broadcast, yes they are good for gursikhs who dont have sangat in there areas and so on, but this discussion was started only to let the sevadaars know that the sangat at the program should come before gursikhs watching on live broadcast. and that they should not be ignored when making decisions to make the broadcast look better. but it is very good work and please continue just take more advice.
and its very good to know that Bhai jarnail singh ji gave there asees and lets hope that this great seva isnt being done to get compliments.
and daas is deeply sorry if it seems that i have made a big deal out of this, just like yourselves have done the broadcast seva for the first time, this is the first time i have attempted to write on message borads, please forgive me if i sounded against broadcasts or offended anyone during this discussion.
Daas is not against broadcasts, just against the smagam being revolved around them instead of broadcasts being revolved around smagams.
vahegurujikakhalsavahegurujikifateh
Re: Live Broadcasts, video cameras, isit spiritually beneficial ?
warrior*princess · 26 Dec 2003
Keep up the seva pyario jee! - there are gursikhs out there who do not even have ransbaees happening in their area...so these broadcasts are great sevaa.
Also the Ransbaee was awesome as ever and very inspiring. Great Keertan! Can't wait til the next one!
Re: Live Broadcasts, video cameras, isit spiritually beneficial ?
bechara singh-wannabee · 26 Dec 2003
i share some of the views of the sangat who was in the darbar hall at the time. many people could not see the sikhi to the max screen due to the large bright lights.
i can really appreciate the value of the live broadcast for those who are too far away (there's always a "chaao" to see sangat from far away), or for those who, because of family or health situations cannot attend.
however, one thing which i think many find uncomfortable (in live or recorded) is when the camera does a face-by-face lingering. many people find this disturbing, esp those who are getting into sikhi or those who want to keep a low profile so as not to get hankaar.
my benti is to all people making video recordings at any keertan prgrams, to (a) keep the pooran satkar of our guru sahib, and (b) to respect the privacy of the sangat (who have no choice as to wether they are filmed or not). i dont want to make this into a big point, but i just think its common courtesy.
also, a benti to the parbhandaks. if they feel there is an over-intrusive cameraman/woman, then it is your responsibility to have a polite word. please do so.
finally, a brotherly pat on the back to the sewadaars doing the live broadcast! keep up the good work, and please do take on board the constructive comments (singh's dont whinge, but they aren't shy to speak out - respect it and be grateful for it!).
looking forward to smethwich (birmingham) on 10th january.... :)