GIRLS AS PANJ PIARE
? KAUR · 01 May 2006
can girls become panj piare if no why not? (Admin Note: This topic has been discussed many times. Please do a search of this forum.) [%sig%]
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
? KAUR · 01 May 2006
can girls become panj piare if no why not? (Admin Note: This topic has been discussed many times. Please do a search of this forum.) [%sig%]. · 02 May 2006
in an akjuk amritsanchar in germany bib ekbal kaur did panj pyaare di seva with bahi raghbir singh, bahi sohan singh, bhai jarnail singh and another of the jatha singhsBhupinder Singh "daas" · 02 May 2006
VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VahegurujeeKeeFateh Yes they can Bibi Sahib Jeeo. Only someone against the truth would disagree, as Vaheguru Jee's above this inequailty and so that is why the Keski was made as the kakaar. Sat Sri Akaal VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VahegurujeeKeeFateho · 02 May 2006
no----- · 02 May 2006
Because when Guru ji asked for heads of 5 individuals.....No women got up to sacrifice their heads only 5 men, the punj pyare!....hence the tradition carriers on......LK · 02 May 2006
Yes. Khalsa is without gender. There is no restriction made by Guru ji that only men are allowed to be part of Panj. As Admin jee says, this has been discussed previously.singh · 02 May 2006
khalsa is not literally without gender..Singhs are boys Kaurs are girls..Singhs have long dari's Kaurs do not, Singhs can wear cholay girls should not.http://sikhissues.blogspot.com · 02 May 2006
Dont worry about the hindus! Alot of bibia are higher the the singhs out there.MOW · 02 May 2006
i asked this question to bibi kirpal kaur who was the adopted daughter of bhai randhir singh. she said that in generally the answer was NO the panj should be singhs as they were in the original amritsanchar. however in absolutely exceptional circumstances where 5 jeevan wale singhs cannot be found it is acceptable for a singhni to take their place. i think this is the general stance of akj uk, india etc. as well as most other jatha's although some say no women are allowed at allA · 03 May 2006
no they can't. heallow O, i agree. tanksE · 03 May 2006
it was preordained that panj pyare were to be 5 singhs, god has not practiced inequality, just as it wasnt inequality to make all 10 guru's male females have not been disadvantaged by this, its just one of the roles singhnees are not supposed to play i have contacted several bibia and singhs from bhai sahibs time, some new him very well all have said singhs make up panj one bibi who knew bhai sahib very well and spent much time with him told me this ; there were many bibia in bhai sahibs time who were ranggle sajjan, even though there were such gurmukh singhnia present at the time they did not do panj seva. there is a difference between a singh and a singhnee, and dont say there isnt, if there isnt can a singh get pregnant? can a singh marry a singh? can a singh breast feed? bhai mokham singh, bhai tharam singh, bhai sahib singh, bhai himmat singh bhai daya singh - panj singh were preordained. ANOTHER bibi I questioned on the area spoke to BABU MAL SINGH when the bibi asked if singhia should be put in panj, babu ji said NO, panj pyare should 5 panj singh. babu ji then said in exceptional circumstances if there arent 5 singhs who can be found, then and only then may a singhnee take a singhs role in the panj. babu mal singh was a true gurmukh, bhai sahib said to him " we are one", like bhai sahib he got jeevan mukht, and meet god while still alive. singhnia in panj is not normal practice, nor has it ever been normal practice, all of the singhs/singhnees from bhai sahibs i have questioned, never once saw a bibi in the panj pyare. equality doesnt mean a mother can play a fathers role, and father a mothers role, this is the western view of equality, one which is false, and results in 50% of marriages ending up in divorce.E · 03 May 2006
yes mr mow, i have also been told this it was preordained that panj pyare were to be 5 singhs, god has not practiced inequality, just as it wasnt inequality to make all 10 guru's male females have not been disadvantaged by this, its just one of the roles singhnees are not supposed to play i have contacted several bibia and singhs from bhai sahibs time, some new him very well all have said singhs make up panj. one bibi who knew bhai sahib very well and spent much time with him told me this ; there were many bibia in bhai sahibs time who were ranggle sajjan, even though there were such gurmukh singhnia present at the time they did not do panj seva. there is a difference between a singh and a singhnee, and dont say there isnt, if there isnt can a singh get pregnant? can a singh marry a singh? can a singh breast feed? bhai mokham singh, bhai tharam singh, bhai sahib singh, bhai himmat singh bhai daya singh - panj singh were preordained. ANOTHER bibi I questioned on the area spoke to BABU MAL SINGH when the bibi asked if singhia should be put in panj, babu ji said NO, panj pyare should 5 panj singh. babu ji then said in exceptional circumstances if there arent 5 singhs who can be found, then and only then may a singhnee take a singhs role in the panj. babu mal singh was a true gurmukh, bhai sahib said to him " we are one", like bhai sahib he got jeevan mukht, and meet god while still alive. singhnia in panj is not normal practice, nor has it ever been normal practice, all of the singhs/singhnees from bhai sahibs i have questioned, never once saw a bibi in the panj pyare. equality doesnt mean a mother can play a fathers role, and father a mothers role, this is the western view of equality, one which is false, and results in 50% of marriages ending up in divorce.Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 03 May 2006
They can, and you will witness three females in the panj that will establish Khalsa Raj.LK · 03 May 2006
Bhupinder Singh - how do you know? Knowledged obtained through Ridyta Sidhiya beign revealed now eh?Rrs · 03 May 2006
There is a lot of hearsay about who said what. Either they can or they can't do sevaa. Don't make exceptions for special cases. If amrit is amrit in the special case where bibia can do seva, then what's the difference in normal circumstances? Yes, physically women and men are different. But how does this relate to their atmaa and their sikhi? In terms of Gursikhi, is there anything that a male can achieve that a female can't? Nope. The first panj were males.. but nowhere did Guru Sahib make this into a general rule. Nowhere. The failure of any women to get up at that time doesn't translate into denying women forever. The panj that stood up didn't stand up to represent their gender. They offered themselves to their Guru, not the male gender. And remember, there were thousands of men who ran away. So should there be a section of males who we also ban from doing seva? And of course, many women since that day have given their head to their guru.' · 03 May 2006
DHAN DHAN SIRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE ਆਸਾ ॥ aasaa. Asa. ਰੋਜਾ ਧਰੈ ਮਨਾਵੈ ਅਲਹੁ ਸੁਆਦਤਿ ਜੀਅ ਸੰਘਾਰੈ ॥ rojaa Dharai manaavai alhu su-aadat jee-a sanghaarai. Thou Keepest fast to pleases God and slayeth beings for thy relish. ਆਪਾ ਦੇਖਿ ਅਵਰ ਨਹੀ ਦੇਖੈ ਕਾਹੇ ਕਉ ਝਖ ਮਾਰੈ ॥੧॥ aapaa daykh avar nahee daykhai kaahay ka-o jhakh maarai. ||1|| Thou seest thy own interest and seest not the interest of others. What for pratest though? ਕਾਜੀ ਸਾਹਿਬੁ ਏਕੁ ਤੋਹੀ ਮਹਿ ਤੇਰਾ ਸੋਚਿ ਬਿਚਾਰਿ ਨ ਦੇਖੈ ॥ kaajee saahib ayk tohee meh tayraa soch bichaar na daykhai. O Qazi thy one Lord is within thee, but thou beholdest Him not by thought and reflection. ਖਬਰਿ ਨ ਕਰਹਿ ਦੀਨ ਕੇ ਬਉਰੇ ਤਾ ਤੇ ਜਨਮੁ ਅਲੇਖੈ ॥੧॥ ਰਹਾਉ ॥ khabar na karahi deen kay ba-uray taa tay janam alaykhai. ||1|| rahaa-o. Mad after religion, thou takest no notice of Him, wherefore thy life is of no account. Pause. ਸਾਚੁ ਕਤੇਬ ਬਖਾਨੈ ਅਲਹੁ ਨਾਰਿ ਪੁਰਖੁ ਨਹੀ ਕੋਈ ॥ saach katayb bakhaanai alhu naar purakh nahee ko-ee. Thy Muslim book tells thee that God is true, and that He is neither male or female. ਪਢੇ ਗੁਨੇ ਨਾਹੀ ਕਛੁ ਬਉਰੇ ਜਉ ਦਿਲ ਮਹਿ ਖਬਰਿ ਨ ਹੋਈ ॥੨॥ padhay gunay naahee kachh ba-uray ja-o dil meh khabar na ho-ee. ||2|| Thou gainest nothing by reading and reflecting, O mad man, if thou obtainest not understanding in thy mind. ਅਲਹੁ ਗੈਬੁ ਸਗਲ ਘਟ ਭੀਤਰਿ ਹਿਰਦੈ ਲੇਹੁ ਬਿਚਾਰੀ ॥ alhu gaib sagal ghat bheetar hirdai layho bichaaree. The Lord concealed in every heart. Reflect thou in this in thy mind. ਹਿੰਦੂ ਤੁਰਕ ਦੁਹੂੰ ਮਹਿ ਏਕੈ ਕਹੈ ਕਬੀਰ ਪੁਕਾਰੀ ॥੩॥੭॥੨੯॥ hindoo turak duhoo-aN meh aikai kahai kabeer pukaaree. ||3||7||29|| The same Lord is within both Hindus and Muslims and this proclaims Kabir loudly. www.srigranth.orgSingh · 03 May 2006
"in an akjuk amritsanchar in germany bib ekbal kaur did panj pyaare di seva with bahi raghbir singh, bahi sohan singh, bhai jarnail singh and another of the jatha singhs" Awesome!!! Who is bibi ekbal kaur?anon · 03 May 2006
bibiya are different in men, in the same way they shudnt be allowed to sit on maharajs tabiya, since they bleed uncontrolably, and with this how can strict bibek perai be maintained? In addition to this bhai sahib states that when sittin on tabiya u shud only be wearing full kachera not pyjama, n bibya cnt do this. In the same respect we have to recognise there is a difference. [%sig%]E · 03 May 2006
"Don't make exceptions for special cases" when an amrit sanchar is to be carried out water should be collected from a natural running source by an amritdharee bottles of water handled by smokers should not be used if possible to avoid. BUT if bottled water is the only thing available, it will have to do, will it not? ---------------------------------------------------------------- rs - "Yes, physically women and men are different" ---------------------------------------------------------------- ok you acknowledge there is a physical difference, panj have a certain physical form, hence if a singh has a little toe missing he cannot be in panj even if he is a bram gyiani physical form of panj is that of 5 singhs. bhupinder singh das - you are sexist why should there be 3 singhnees in panj???? only 2 singhs?????? thats sexist, thats inequality..........not fair!!!. · 03 May 2006
"singh" Girls should not wear cholay?? Who made up that rule?o · 04 May 2006
only guru ji can establish khalsa raaj and if there is a panj pyareh with 3 singhnees in can this really be called panj pyare or is it doh pyare? and why dont u keep ur visions to yourself, haumai is a big disease you knowT · 04 May 2006
WHY CANT BIBIA WER CHOLEH...................A · 04 May 2006
Oh come on 'girls' apply some common sense.. being one of the panj piare you have to be able to represent a PURE Clean image.. now men may not be able to understand why girls can not represent 'the panj' but we girls know that it makes perfect sense for the position to go to that of males.. but there are no restrcitions on females doing sewa in the amrit sanchaar. A man ahs his place where as a women has hers.. i done mean this in a sexist way.. but we sure have our differences as man and women. I sure wiould love to be a wife of one of the panj pyaareguroooo · 04 May 2006
i agree with rs i dont see a problem with women being in panj sikhi doesnt not preach discrimination against sexessingh · 04 May 2006
bhai randhir singh also says for women if they change into a fresh pair of pyjame then they may sit on tabiya (and it is common sense that they would not do this at that time of the month)E · 04 May 2006
singh sed- in an akjuk amritsanchar in germany bib ekbal kaur did panj pyaare di seva with bahi raghbir singh, bahi sohan singh, bhai jarnail singh and another of the jatha singhs" Awesome!!! Who is bibi ekbal kaur? ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- this did not happen in akj of old, i have spoken to many who spent time with bhai sahib, and with singhs who went to rensvais in bhai sahibs time, none have ever witnessed bibia in panj, though there were bibia at the highest spiritual state (bram gyian) other practices have also changed, (eg) akjuk dont always use a lareedar saroop of siri guru granth sahib jiSingh · 04 May 2006
Taksal and Nanankar are sexist for not letting bibia do keertan in sangat. This is manmat thinking, "Bhamanism" End of the day, when the amrit is being made, the punj are trasfering their kamai into the amrit. A women can have same avasta as men!Pushpinder singh · 04 May 2006
its is not about right or equlity its about the very basic theme of Khalsa philosophy... When you have darshan of Guru Sahib(u do path of Sri guru Granth Sahib ji) you will see that always Akal Purakh has been depicted as male and HE blesses the human being depicted as female Panj pyaras also depict that concept so we can't play with the Practical theater of Guru Ji ..... tradition are not for debating upon they are for disscussing about and understanding their meaning..... its not discrimination... one more thing Bibi Ji.. it has been for centuries that Man considered himself superior than women ..BUT.. here through this mrayada Guru Ji tell man that only AKAL PURAKH is male and Man is no superiror than women and both sexes are blessed with AMRIT by 5 Pyaras in same Darbar and the same way One more thing i must mention about women carrying Palki of Guru Sahib: Guru Ji always considered women to be his mothers and sisters and in Punjab mother and sister do not carry Palki of their son or brother.... mother, sister and daughter are not even aloowed to carry shoes of their father or brother (they do dress up their bro or son if he is a child) .. it is for the respect women enjoy... this does not originate from pujabi society but from Khalsa society..... BiBi ji you are princess as per Guru Ji so please accept the honour besowed upon u by Guru Ji .. Lets follow Maryada rather than questioning it.. May guru Ji bless us with knowledge of hidden secrets and symbolic language of Khalsa Rehat Maryadasanjo · 04 May 2006
Author: anon Date: 05-03-06 14:31 bibiya are different in men, in the same way they shudnt be allowed to sit on maharajs tabiya, since they bleed uncontrolably, and with this how can strict bibek perai be maintained? In addition to this bhai sahib states that when sittin on tabiya u shud only be wearing full kachera not pyjama, n bibya cnt do this. In the same respect we have to recognise there is a difference. <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< why cant bibiya where full kachera? whats the difference between a singhni bleeding and a singh sweating? perhaps we should stop the singhs who sweat alot from sitting with maharaj. like someone stated above if bibia can be accepted in "exceptional" circumstances then why not in normal circumstances. what if there are plenty of singhs available but only 4 of them are chardi kala n what if a singhni present is more chardi kala than the remaining singhs. does she get the final spot in the panj? or does one of the remaining singhs get it tho they may not be anywhere near the level of the singhni? at a amrit sanchar the panj pyareh as far as ino represent guru ji, cannot a singhni represent guru ji, aslong the person has khalsa roop then i reckon its fine. i.e tyar bar tyar keski tari strict rehit wali bibi. guru gobind singh ji says khalsa is his roop, not just the singhs, the WHOLE khalsa. i think when it comes to amrit sanchars it shoudlnt matter, wen it comes to nagar kirtans n stuff then its just a show for vaisakhi so myb they should be all men, because thats jsut history, but in a amrit sanchar aslong as the bibi is chardi kala n is capable of planting naam within the abhlakee there aint a problem. akj emphasise that the panj have to be tyar bar tyar gursikhs at amrit sanchars, so if you wona take amrit u gota choice, (hypothetical situation): 5 dodgy singhs or 5 chardi kala bibia. so does the gender really matter?LK · 04 May 2006
E, you accuse Bhupinder SIngh of being sexist for saying 3 Singhnees and 2 singhs, yet you say 5 singhs and 0 singhnees, implying your a bigger sexist than him...Truth · 04 May 2006
bibia can wear choleys as long they wear a pajami along with it....but just a choley is not suitable for a singhni. · 04 May 2006
"Author: Singh Date: 05-03-06 14:11 "in an akjuk amritsanchar in germany bib ekbal kaur did panj pyaare di seva with bahi raghbir singh, bahi sohan singh, bhai jarnail singh and another of the jatha singhs" Awesome!!! Who is bibi ekbal kaur?" yeh i agree its great.bibi ekbal kaur is no longer living, but clearly akjuk panj pyaare have no objection to this :-) yeh women have diferent roles.but id much prefer my panj pyaara to be a bibi if there was a choice between a bibi who ahd more kamai and a singh who has less guruji dusnt practice discriminationrs · 04 May 2006
Woman not allowed on tabia and not wearing cholays is just garbage and not worth responding too. Also, women don't bleed everywhere. It is kept under control. There are a lot of people who believe that they can't do seva during this time, but this is brahminvaad. You don't become impure during this time of the month. Our guru's taught against this. E, exceptions for water and for who can do seva are completely different situations. As far as not being able to do seva with a missing toe goes, this is about being sabat surat. You have to be whole physically. But it doesn't matter what the gender is. No where in gurbani has guru saahib indicated that women can't reach the same spiritual levels as men and nowhere did Guru Gobind SIngh Jee restrict the seva of panj to any gender. Nor is this mentioned in any rehitnamay. I've in fact heard from some singhs that there was a bibi who did seva at an amrit sanchar during Bhai Randheer SIngh Jee's time in the jatha. Some older singhs in India mentioned this. I will have to find out more about this. Pushpinder Singh, your points make no sense. Bibia can't carry the palki because they are princesses? Why can they then where a kirpan and fight? If we are all females and god the male, then what difference is there between a man and a women doing seva? Any seva? If we are all considered females? And you will have to agree that the reference of god as male does not mean that physically god has a male form. So then we are all his females and there is nothing left to debate. Anon, bhai Sahib writes nothing about bibia not being able to do paat seva or sit on tabia. Please don't insinuate anything like that. Bibia did keertan and paat seva back then.E · 04 May 2006
LK i was being sarcastic, just using logic you 'pro bibia in panj' use. so would you make exceptions for the bibi in the panj and allow her to wear pajame? because it would be a bit po other wise and what do you think of physical contact between singhs and singhnees like touching hands? you dont want either the singh or singhnee having a po thought while doing the amrit sanchar now do you? ------------------------------------------------ guru ji doesnt practice discrimination? so a non amritdharee can do panj seva? NO they cant, is this discrimination? a singh who has a toe missing cannot do seva in panj, is this discrimination against handicapped? ----------------------------------------------- god made all 10 guru's male, is this inequality? god made 5 singhs panj pyare in 1699, is this inequality? in anand karaj the singh walks in front, is this discrimination? ------------------------------------------------ as the god preordained panj to be 5 singhs, panj should always be 5 singhs, to call this discrimination is to call gods actions discriminative. panjpyare have a certain physical form, that of 5 singhs, this is the truth, and must not be changed by people who've been influenced by the wests idea of equality, which we all know is false... · 04 May 2006
E, there is no rule that says women must wear a pujami. This is punjabi thinking and is common practice, but there is no rule on this in sikhi. Stop turning your punjabi thinking into rules for sikhi. anyone doing seva in punj would hopefully be above having 'po' thoughts at that time. if the punj start having such thoughts merely through touch, then how will they give amrit to female ablakhees? as has been pointed out, missing a toe is totally different than being a female. what is a women missing that makes her not sabat surat and incapable of doing punj seva? the guru's were male as were the original punj. no debate on this. but there was no condition set for future panj. just like the guru khalsa panth is not all male. if we go by your thinking, then the guru khalsa panth should be all male, as it represents the guru. this is obviously not the case.what? · 04 May 2006
Only People of Indian descent can be Punj. It was pre-ordained by god that the original panj piaray were all of Indian Descent, so this means that no whites, chinese, blacks or any other racial/ethnic group can ever do this seva. This is pre-ordained by god. Only brown males. From India. That's it. Ask Veer E to explain if you have any questions.singh · 04 May 2006
what is a kaur missing? no offense, but for one, I would say the manly beard reminiscient of that of a Lion! Thats what!.. · 04 May 2006
oh for god sakes E, ud think that if they were chosen to bin the panj pyaare that they would have the ability to control their po...atleast in a n amrit sanchar. if theres no alternative fifth pnaj pyaara then is aid a aomen should be the 5th rather than not having an amrit sanchar oh yeh and i heard from people that new singhs from bhai sahib randhir singhs times that there was a bibi in one of the amritsanchar acting as one of the panj and "what?" what a good questionns · 05 May 2006
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh Admin Jeeo, What is the purpose of this thread by reading above can you not see the lines being drawn in between akj/akj india/taksaal/nanaksar...do you like this sort of parchar that divides the youth clearly. Why do you allow such post through, are they making us more aware of anything new??E · 05 May 2006
so its ok for bibia to show their legs? right ok, all puratan singhs ive spoken to dont agree with bibia showing their legs. what if the bibi is pregnant? 6 pyare? why is that all the people ive spoken to from bhai sahibs time say theyve never seen bibia in panj, believe me theyre were bram gyiani bibia around at the time why is it that not one bibi was present in the panj which was first formed in 1699? why do you complicate things, when khalsa was first formed panj pyare = 5 singhs SO panj pyare = 5 singhs why? because thats how god ordained it. theres a fundamental physical difference between a singh and singhnee, what difference is there between a singh in india and one in england except they live in different places, what a silly argument. '..' - no condition for the future panj? so we can just change how amrit sanchars are done according to our own mat? MANMAT.E · 05 May 2006
sanjo - like someone stated above if bibia can be accepted in "exceptional" circumstances then why not in normal circumstances that someone is babu mal singh sanjo - guru gobind singh ji says khalsa is his roop, not just the singhs, the WHOLE khalsa. yes, but being khalsa doesnt automatically give you right to do panj seva, eg, a bramgyiani singh with altered physical form cannot be in panj. yes a singh without a finger isnt the same as a singhnee, but the point is form is very important, and just being khalsa doesnt mean you can be in panj.ummm.. · 05 May 2006
wake up and smell the coffee, look at what you are saying, there is no gender for a gurmukh, techinally we are all female souls waiting to be united with our lord husband. stop talking dribble and think outside the box, it is the body which beholds the jyot, this is a vessel nothing more nothing less, remember their are sould in this world who are beyond the whole colour, gender, age, prejudices that we have bought into sikhi, guru ji made it so simple but our stupid matt has tried to complicate it. Its quite simple, colour, gender, don't matter, its the spirtual avastha and jeevan qualities that matter. Prob find that women are more truthful and just than most men who proclaim they are worthy of this maahaaan sevaa...PTE SINGH · 05 May 2006
The Panj Pyare that we generally allow today are in most cases not fit enough to carry that mantle, which is why the question of women in the Panj Pyare comes up. The Panj Pyare should be all that is perfection in the embodiment of man. They should be the best among all men of the sangat, in mind body and spirit. In the old traditions these men would not only be the wisest and most honourable but the strongest and amongst the best fighters. This would automatically filter the women out, who though can match and excel men in every other sphere, are unable to match us physically and forcefully. In the same way that elite forces around the world allow women to apply, they still have to measure to the same physical and fighting standards, which generally they cannot and will not manage. If we stopped having unfit and fat blokes who could not tell the blade end of a sword from the hilt, we would no longer have to be sexist and could use the argument of practicality and suitability for why women are not used as Panj Pyare. The Panj Pyare should be the five best people. Who have PROVED themselves worthy, regardless of age, sex, caste or colour. Its time to raise the standards. [%sig%]O · 05 May 2006
indian desent doesnt affect the form of the panj pyareh gender, missing limb doessanjo · 05 May 2006
if the singhni is chardi kala enough to plant naam within you then it shouldnt be a problem. 5 dogdy singhs giving amrit or 5 chardi kala singhnis, what would you choose?Jaskeerth-Gyan Singh Khalsa · 05 May 2006
See the post below. The last post is by Daas and should clear up the whole debate. If it doesnt then add a reply. http://www.sikhsangat.com/index.php?showtopic=17913&st=0&p=158836&#entry158836K S Dhillon Uk Wala · 05 May 2006
In my humble opinion they should be allowed. lets not put too much importance on the physical, and overlook the actual truth, that it makes no diffreence if the person ordaining amrit is a male or a female, but there jeevan? lets not get bogged down on ceremony's and ritual, for our beloved Guru's did not want this from mankind. IMHO. [%sig%]rs · 05 May 2006
E, the condition is a sabat surat khalsa. And there is a physical difference between a chinese sikh and a punjabi sikh. The problem with bibia wearing a chola without a pajami is cultural, not religious. You may not have found a singh who saw a bibi in the panj back then. But that doesn't mean it didn't happen. Some older singhs say it did happen on one or two occasions. I will confirm and get back on this. However, Singhs like bhai Jeevan singh (also from back then) have no problem with bibia in the panj.Singh · 05 May 2006
Jaskeerth-Gyan Singh, Your argument supplied on the link is flawed as Desa Singh Rehatnama contains many questionable lines which go against Gurmat. For example, the consumption of opium/bhang is condoned, and only 2 Bania are mentioned for Nitnem. It is also stated alcohol is acceptable before battle. Furthermore as you consider yourself a "Taksali Singh", it is unsuprising you have this view since the Taksal Rehat Maryada states that a wife must treat her husband as if he is God. With these types of views I am not sure how valid the stance of Taksal thus is on this issue.E · 05 May 2006
you wont find someone with more weight in their words then babu mal singh. do you think babu mal singhs views are sexist? how about the bibi who bhai sahib took as his daughter which mow mentioned? if 1 bibi went in the panj on one occasion in bhai sahibs time dont you think this is strange, seeing how many gurmukh bibia were presesnt at the time? truth cannot be changed, panj were 5 singhs, and have been ever since youre manmat is twisting the truth there is NOT a fundamental difference between two normal males, both are male and have basic male structure. changing sikhi has been a problem since dasm patsah left manmat such as eating meat being allowed, kesh as kakkar, and now changing the form of the 5 pyare from singhs to singhnees. suppose it is kaljug, shouldnt be surprised if i had to trust someone you or babu mal singh and the other bibi's who had affiliations with bhai sahib i have to disagree with you, evidence is firmly against your views.Satnam · 05 May 2006
Truth is that all Souls are Females and only God is male. Female Soul has to love male god to re unite with God. God has given some souls male body and some female body. But when we die we are only souls which are female. Since Panj Pyare were female souls in Male body, so we should accept and make Male( bodies) as Panj Pyare. Bottom line is that we all are same and we should respect Guru Jee's Maryada.rs · 05 May 2006
E, it's not like you directly talked with Baoo Mal Singh Jee. It's hearsay. Enough people tell different and contradictory things that Bhai Randheer Singh said. Give a direct quote, otherwise, it's hearsay. Also, no matter what the spiritual jeevan of Baoo Mal Singh Jee (and it was great, no doubt), we don't base our rehit on any individual but on what our guru's stated and taught. They didn't ban bibia from panj seva. That's the bottom line. Your whole point is that the original were males, so it must continue like this. Why? Unless Guru Sahib indicated that it must be like this, which they didn't. If you can provide any evidence that this was indicated by Guru Sahib, then your point carries weight. Incidentally, if you want to get into personalities (ie, Bhaoo Mal Singh Jee), Bhai Sahib Randheer Singh Jee had a stance on most significant issues. For example, they clearly and very strongly give their stance on meat and keski as kakaar. As well as on Raagmala, lareedhar and how many banees should be done for nitnem. Just as all of these issues were addressed in the Sikh Rehit Marayda (SGPC), so was the bibia in panj. The marayda says it is acceptable for bibia to be in the punj. Yet Bhai Sahib never writes against this, as he does about the other topics. You'd think changing the marayda of the punj would be a pretty significant issue and Bhai Sahib would have said something about it, as he did about all the other issues. Once again, a sabat surat khalsa can do seva, male or female. The fundamental difference in structure that you talk about is all related to the reproductive system. How does that influence anything in the amrit sanchaar or make a bibia non-sabat surat? It doesn't. Just as we don't base selection on background caste, race or nationality, we don't base it on gender either. Sabat surat khalsa. That's it.girl in blue · 05 May 2006
This is ridiculous, I can't believe I'm reading this. There is absolutely no logic involved in this, women can be in the punj pyare as can children and people of old age. It's how tyaar bar tyaar a person is that counts, not the gender or age or build. They should khalsa that keep the most rehit and have an ucha sucha jeevan. If there are females/children and elderly that fit this description more than a male, then they win! You should all go ! And make sure it's ! People that are close minded, ignorant and say only men should be in the punj are either . Everyone who wastes time on this argument is .Admin · 09 May 2006
To all those that continue to post on this thread, please read the last post. This thread is closed. E, you have made this same point several times (in different words) and others have made their own points many times over. Allowing your post will not contribute anything new to this thread. It will only prompt others to respond and continue the cycle. Unless you have something new to add, this thread will remain closed.E · 10 May 2006
TO ADMIN - this is a NEWPOINT you cannot change the form of the panj, just as you cannot change the form of siri guru granth sahib ji from lareedar to pad chedd.rs · 10 May 2006
Admin, please let this response up. It's only fair that people can respond to his new point. That's a good one E. The form hasn't been changed. Five Khalsas. Just as age and race don't determine the form, neither does gender. In your mind, race and age might not matter. But that's your mind. You've arbitrarily decided where to draw the line. Lareedhar and padched are a totally different issue. Changing this requires necessarily deciding on certain meanings of gurbanee over others. It requires passing off your interpretation of Gurbani as the absolute one. This can't be done to Dhur Kee banee. However, panj are selected anew for every amrit sinchaar. A women can give her sirr to her guru, she can be a tyar bar tyar khalsa, she can have jot prakash within her and she can definitely do sevaa in panj. This is in no way changing the form. If it is, then we can also start bringing in height and weight restrictions, beard length (I've actually heard of this being done), colour and anything else related to form. To you gender may the only deciding factor in form, but that is simply your view. The form for punj is simple: Five tyar bar tyar, physically whole (sabat surat) Khalsas. Just as size of the letters or angs or colour of the ink or number of lines per ang don't change the essential 'form' of a lareedhar saroop, race, height, gender, etc, don't change the essential form of the panj. Instead of coming up with your own manmat reasons based on your own logic, just provide me with some actual proof that Guru Saahib anywhere indicated that women couldn't do this type of seva or that the physical gender of a person in any way changes whether akal will reside within them. The concept of panj starts with Panch Parvaan Panch pardhaan and gursikh women can definitely fit this bill. Until you can provide some solid evidence that women can't be in the panj, I'll go with the panthic decision that they can.E · 11 May 2006
fact - form of 5 singhs is fundamentally different from that of 5 singhnees fact - a singh is a singh a singhnee is a singhnee fact - it is wrong to change how amrit sanchar is done fact - putting singhnees in panj is changing form panj have. fact - body of guru granth sahib ji has a form (lareedar unbroken gurbani) this musn't be changed. fact - handwriting or slight variations in ink do not fundamentally change the form. fact - height weight doesnt fundamentally change the form of a singh, a tall singh is still a singh, a singhnee is not a singh. fact - panj pyare were 5 singhs, and now still are. fact - sggs ji was origianlly lareedar, and now should still be. fact - i have never heard of more than one singhnee in the panj, it only happens when 5 singhs are not present. fact - you should be providing evidence that singhnees can be in panj rather than me providing evidence that they cant because, you are the one that is trying to change how amrit sanchars are done. i am merely defending the way the amrit sanchars were conducted in dasm patsah's time, you are tryng to change it. fact - yes a women can give her head and take amrit, but in original selection no women stepped forward to give her head , this was preordained. explain you keep going on about sabat surat, why is this so important? why cant a bram gyiani singh who has altered form not be in panj? how can you say men and women have the same form?. · 11 May 2006
difference in gender is as big as difference in form, roop, as missing an ang is.E · 11 May 2006
yes changing sggsji from lareedar to pad chedd can change meanings, but it would still be wrong to put spaces in the right places eg a bram gyiani maybe able to fully understand where to put spaces but it would be manmat to do so.Common Sense · 11 May 2006
Admin, are you only allowing post that agree with a certain viewpoint, or poststhat can be easily refuted? Isn't it a valid point that Desmesh Pitaa Guru Gobind Singh ji Maharaj bestowed the surname "KAUR" to women and "Singh" to men. Singh means lion and KAUR mean PRINCESS (not LIONESS or SINGHNI). Why are we blatantly preaching against our Guru Ji's WORD? MEN AND WOMEN HAVE EQUAL RIGHTS but to say that they aren't DIFFERENT is utterly absurd.EE · 11 May 2006
Fact: The guru panth allows bibia to do panj seva. Read the rehit marayda. another fact, more than one bibia have done seva at a time, maybe not in akj, but in other amrit sanharsrs · 11 May 2006
Nice bunch of facts you've presented there, E. Unfortunately, not all of those qualify as facts. Many of them are your opinions. Such as what qualifies as a fundamental difference in form. It's your opinion. Not a fact. You're right that a singhnee can't be a singh. But she can be a Khalsa. And that is a hard fact. 5 Khalsas are what you need for an amrit sinchaar. The basic fact is that a male or female can both be Khalsa. The soul of both is described as female. There is nothing about the male body which the guru has ordained as being special compared to the female. This is your thinking. The first five were male, but we don't believe in original sin. Your argument is like the Christians: Eve gave in to temptation, therefore all females forevermore must carry the burden of this sin. This has been addressed many times in various threads. The original five didn't stand up as only representatives of males. There weren't two teams, male and female. Only Sikhs. Your lareedhar point has no bearing. Simply because what you consider to be minor and major changes in form are your opinions. You haven't shown why the gender difference counts for so much more in terms of panj seva. I also don't agree with your contention that at most only one bibi at a time did seva, and then only because there weren't enough singhs. Prove this. Show me where only one bibi did seva and that there weren't enough singhs around. If singhs can travel thousands of miles for keertans and smagams, I don't think there would be difficulty in gathering enough singhs. Also, did these amrit sanchaars with bibia still count as amrit? If the original form is broken, is that acceptable? If it's such a big deal, then how can you say that one bibi in emergency cases is okay? Why not just postpone until enough singhs are available? As for proving that women can do seva, it is proven. Nothing has been shown to say that they can't. You claim that you're simply defending the way amrit sinchaars were conducted during Dasam Patshaas time, but the FACT is that other than the very first one, you really don't know anything about any amrit sinchaar from that period. So stop making things up.rs · 11 May 2006
E, changing gurbanee to Padched changes the Gurbanee. It's the Guru's banee and we can't change it. We also can't change the marayda for Amrit Sinchaars. You're absolutely right on that. However, there is no original marayda from Guru Gobind Singh Jee that prohibits bibia from doing panj seva. You're imposing this. Not the Guru. Having females or males does not go against gurmat. It doesn't change the essential form of the panj piaare. Unless of course you ascribe the male form as the essential form of the panj piaray. Which the guru didn't do.