Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Pasta

Pasta

?? · 27 Apr 2006

can bibekis eat pasta if its been cooked by aritdharis and even the sauce is by amritdharis?

Re: Pasta

... · 27 Apr 2006

If they pasta is MADE by amritdharis (not just bought and boiled) then it's fine. The bought and boiled pasta is made by the factory not by the amritdhari so it really shouldn't be used.

Re: Pasta

Gandalf · 27 Apr 2006

waht if the tomatoes and wheat were not grown by amritdharees...

Re: Pasta

. · 27 Apr 2006

OM gandalf, I think that's a pretty obvious answer. I mean its not like tamaoties are labled with "made by amritdhari" . I think we are talking about cooking it by our own hands.

Re: Pasta

... · 27 Apr 2006

Gandalf, you've had this question answered like 20 times in the past. Raw materials can be grown by whoever. It has to be cooked and prepared by amritdharis. Just read the article in the Gurmat section.

Re: Pasta

singh · 27 Apr 2006

i think gandalf has a point... also...you guys may want to clerify for "??" that its not just any amritdhari who can prepare the food for a bibeki...it has to be only bebekis so essentially, pasta noodles made by a bibeki, cooked by a bikeki are acceptable...not any other

Re: Pasta

... · 27 Apr 2006

wrong. The first level of bibek is to eat only from other amritdharis. Such a person is considered bibeki even if the amritdharis he eats from do not keep bibek. The tomato/wheat argument has NO point. It's already been said that the raw ingredients are COOKED.

Re: Pasta

ks · 27 Apr 2006

pasta is cooked too. What makes it different, physically/chemically? really, get to the core of the matter. Does a "bibek" food have a different physical structure than a "nonbibek" food? how can you claim that wheat/tomatoes are okay, when they were handled by a nonbibeki? Those tomatoes aren't jumping onto the food shelves, let alone trucks, by themselves? How is that handling any different for food that goes through a mechanized pasta making factory, or from a mechanized milk plant? face it, there is no rule other than the ones that are made up by "..." and his cohorts. if you want to be a real bibeki, grow/develop *everything* yourself, and then you'll have people's respect. Until then you're just choosing what's convenient (accepting milk and preground flour as bibek).

Re: Pasta

... · 27 Apr 2006

ks, if you are ignorant what can I do? Pasta is made from a dough that has been cooked and made into pasta. It's not a raw material. Do you know what a raw material is? It's a basic ingredient that can be physically altered (crushed, dried) but is not cooked. Salt, sugar, flour, vegetables, fruit are all then raw materials. Same with oils. A non-raw material would be Pasta Sauce or Ketchup or Yogurt. Even those these things may get subsequently cooked again, they are still prepared by cooking. It's not that complicated but if people want to be willfully blind and ignorant, there is no logic that can convince them.

Re: Pasta

singh · 27 Apr 2006

If the tomatoes are handled by non-bibekis and non-amirtdarys, what makes it different from the processed foods that are made by machines and made by non-amritdaris? Those tomatoes are picked and planted and delviered by non-amritdaris (most likely) so how does the raw material differ from the processed? (I've asked this once or twice before and people say "this has already been proven" so if nobody wants to answer, could i get a link to another post that answers this question?)

Re: Pasta

Harmeet Singh · 27 Apr 2006

vjkk, vjkf salt is not a total raw material as it is processed a lot before it gets to a container...sugar is not a raw material..the sugar cane is from where sugar comes from...flour isn't a raw material..the wheat that the flour came from is. *I'm not on anyone's side..just clearing up the fact of what's a raw material* bhul chuk maph karnee jee :) vjkk, vjkf

Re: Pasta

... · 27 Apr 2006

Harmeet Singh, the sugar and salt and flour aren't cooked, just physically altered. It's a raw material. As for tomatoes: wash them. Problem solved. Once it is cooked in sarbloh while reciting bani, it becomes bibeki. Natural products, regardless of who handles them, can be used. The answer is very simple: cooked=not bibeki. Uncooked=bibeki.

Re: Pasta

singh · 28 Apr 2006

. . . jio im fairly certian cane juice is heated in the process of making sugar...so how do you define 'cooked' i would imagine if heat is applied to a 'raw material' for any reason, it becomes cook... would you like to clerify?

Re: Pasta

unreal · 28 Apr 2006

maaf karna ji, I'm not picking sides here, but, with all due respect, your argument is not very strong. Diffrentiating between "cooking" and "altering" is a rather weak rationalization. The milk that we all drink is handled by non-amritdharis as is the flour we use and any number of other products. Many of the processes these other foods go through, in being refined, could easily be called "cooking". Again, this diffrentiation is very weak! For example, milk goes through a process called pasteurization which involves heating the milk - isn't this cooking? Of course it is but bibekis still drink milk from the supermarket? Why? This is a clear violation of bibek. Salt and sugar are both products that are handled and processed/refined by non-amritdharis - what is the difference in their handling of the salt and sugar and their heating of the salt and sugar? If non-amritdharies handle the salt and sugar extensively and use 100 steps to refine the salt and sugar but don't heat it, it remains bibek? If they use 100 steps but apply a few degrees of heat, it becomes non-bibek? This doesn't make sense. What if one of the steps in refining the salt and sugar involved heat? Again, this difference between refining/processing and cooking is an artificial one being used to justify why some food products are acceptable and other are not. No one is doubting the power of gurbani/simran - could not one take a machine-made cookie, and put it a sarbloh batah, heat it up a little, and thus make it bibeki? Is not the power of gurbani/simran not enough to do this? Of course it is. But this example just highlights the flimsy and, dare I say, manufactured difference between "cooked" and refined/processed products. The answer seems straight-forward: Living in the society we live in, those keeping bibek make compromises when it comes to any number of food products - the only way to avoid such compromises is to use only those foods and food products that amritdharis produce themselves and do not allow others to touch. These compromises are understandable. Moreover, despite these compromises, I respect the discipline of those keeping bibek as it is not an easy thing to do. However, I request that those keeping this discipline not put forward these weak rationalizations and justifications as it hurts the legitimate reasons that DO exist for keeping bibek ie. reducing the chance of eating egg, meat products etc. ... wrote: > Harmeet Singh, the sugar and salt and flour aren't cooked, just > physically altered. It's a raw material. > > As for tomatoes: wash them. Problem solved. Once it is > cooked in sarbloh while reciting bani, it becomes bibeki. > Natural products, regardless of who handles them, can be used. > > > The answer is very simple: cooked=not bibeki. > Uncooked=bibeki.

Re: Pasta

ks · 28 Apr 2006

wow, "..." thinks sugar is raw product. Do you know how sugar is made? Besides being "cooked", many chemicals are used to make it sellable (to bleach, refine, and homogenize) in the western world. The same applies to flour. Nothing short of growing and processing *everything* yourself is "pure." it goes back to my original statement: if you want to be a real bibeki, grow/develop *everything* yourself, and then you'll have people's respect. Until then you're just choosing what's convenient (accepting milk and preground flour as bibek). even then, is fertilizer/pesticide for plants bibek? Because that surely alters the "natural" condition. How about gmo plants? Because almost every fruit/vegetable you buy in a western grocery store will be gmo on some level (organic doesn't always mean non-gmo). How many would consider seedless grapes to be bibek? Newsflash: that's a gmo too!

Re: Pasta

Gandalf · 28 Apr 2006

Why is the preparing more important than the growing?

Re: Pasta

some1 · 28 Apr 2006

is'nt cooking a type of physicaly altering things? ks is not ignorant u r...believing bibek has spiritual advantages. haha.

Re: Pasta

some1 · 28 Apr 2006

whats ur definition of cooking? applying heat? ma theres no such thing as bibek..its a gimick... everything is cooked ppl please help ur own sikhi...don't bring this stuff into it plz...benthi and admin let it up..u did'nt let my last one up..this is total comunisim on ur behalf...if i were 2 go pro bibek it would be up in a heart beat. but u know it makes absolutely no sense...its brahminvaad 2 the MAXIMUM.

Re: Pasta

some1 · 28 Apr 2006

yah and milk for petes sake is obviously cooked!!! pasteruzation??? its joot 2? did u knwo that? hmmm...

Re: Pasta

SINGH · 28 Apr 2006

Funny how people who don't keep bibek try to define this rehit. If you haven't kept bibek rehit (which involves your entire lifestyle, not just food), then you really have no idea about what you're talking about. Keep ridiculing and belittling. You have no clue what you're talking about. It's that simple. Firstly, what you ingest definitely has more than a physical effect on you. Think about how amrit is prepared. And degh. As far as rules for bibek go.... you want items that are in as simple a form as you can get them. Sugar, flour and raw fruits and vegetables fit this bill. Is sugar completely 'raw'? Nope. Would sugar prepared by singhs be more bibek? Definitely. But using sugar is definitely not the same as eating a store bought cookie. I still have to put the sugar through many processes before eating it. You go as basic as you can. And of course, different singhs will have slightly different standards. The more 'bibek' that you can keep, the better. Is store bought milk bibek? Most bibeky singhs will say no. Is it a compromise? Yes. A dhil. But because I make one dhil doesn't mean that I open the floodgates and let everything go. You do your best. Some singhs don't take store bought milk. More power to them. Why isn't growing the food as important as cooking it? Just because it isn't. Food bibek is concerned with purchasing (honest money) and cooking. Not growing. Nobody 'grew' the food. They put a seed in the ground. Then took care of the product. It's a much less intrusive process than cooking. Things in the wild will grow by themselves. As far as I know, they won't cook themselves. Obtaining food grown by a gursikh would be great. But not necessary for bibek rehit. Once again, it's about levels of bibek. Difficult to define an absolute bibek. You go as far bibek as you can. In thinking, acting, speaking, doing, eating, whatever. Sangats of singhs will decide for themselves what is minimally acceptable to them. Not some internet geeks. I don't do simran 24/7. I wish I did. I strive for this and hope for this. Gurbanee tells me to reach for this. But I don't yet do this. So, then are the few moments of paat and simran that I do useless? Should I give them up since I don't do it 24/7? Of course not. What a stupid thing to think. You do your best and keep striving for more. Add more and more paat until you reach that level. Same with bibek. So I drink milk. And use sugar. So should I completely abandon the rehit? Start eating pasta and anything else that is 'processed'? Of course not. Keep moving forward. Not backwards. You don't use one dhil to justify another. In the end, I know what bibek has done for me. The effects it can have. Those that don't.... oh well. Your karms, my karms.

Re: Pasta

singh · 28 Apr 2006

if u hav sugar and u recite bani while putting it into ur food, tis the same as reciting bani before eating a store bought cookie

Re: Pasta

some1 · 28 Apr 2006

justify it go ahead dood. u know that this is not the sikhs way..ritiualism...etc. bibek=discrimination.

Re: Pasta

,,,, · 29 Apr 2006

loll wahs bebiki????

Re: Pasta

singh · 29 Apr 2006

'SINGH' ji, its not that people like myself (and i admit i am not a bibeki by any standard) ae trying to speak for bibekis or 'punch holes' in the logic. i think we are trying to understand the dietary aspect of it. it just seems (and correct me if im wrong-but i dont think i am) that there are not clear rules...you make exceptions where you 'have to' and you dont at other times. it is totally subjective when you choose to make exceptions and when you dont and it is almost like a person can do whatever so long as it is prepared in its FINAL stage by an amritdhari. YOU (no you personally per se, but you as in bibekis) stated that cooked food is not ok, etc. when people point out the problems with this rule, b/c WE (non-food bibekis) when we try to implement this system will not/can not follow the rule b/c it makes little to no sense. again, there is no attack here...just a discussion on logic and reality. it seems in reality that there is no rule for bibek. everyone just interprets it to meaning what they want or can accomodate. the milk example is great - one dhil does not lead to another...but unfortunately that logic can be used for justifying so many types of 'dhil.' "i am making ONE compromise - but it does not make me less [insert descriptive here (gursikh/good/rehatvan/etc)] b/c it will not necessarily lead to another" hopefully you will see - not the best logic - and not an easy one for us students who want to follow it, to follow. bhul chuk muaf fateh

Re: Pasta

sanjo · 29 Apr 2006

"SINGH" is correct, i aint bibeki but i still agree that we cant judge bibekis if we havent tryed it ourselves. some of u guys could try it for a week and love it who knows, so really this arguement is going to lead nowhere. to me having so much discipline over what you eat is good, what you eat affects your cognition. " Gursikh di roti beti di saanjh Gursikh naal. The Gursikhs have to share food and establish marital relationships with Gursikhs only " <<< (from gurmat section of this site) this rehit is mentioned in every amrit sanchar aparently, irrespective of jatha. we amritdharis cant eat jhoot why? obviously guru ji is trying to tell us something. yet no amritdhari questions this hukam we accept it n dont eat jhoot. sometimes we are too quick to judge, especially if we feel we cant kepe these rehits ourselves. das does this himself out of ankhar. fact of the matter is until a bibeki can walk down the street and be respected by everyone and until that bibeki can respect everyone else then we arent doing very well as a panth. same goes for jathebandis etc. so if people are against bibek just keep it on the low, kepe your opinion to yourself, coming on a forum n trying to catch people out in their beliefs is not gd especially if a person believes he is serving his guru with pyar. lets face it to make sacrifices like bibek etc requires determination n pyar n a huge amount of discipline. slandering others beliefs leads to your own haumai simple as. all chardi kala gursikhs who didnt kepe bibek, got close to guru ji through kirpa, we cannot all be blessed alot of us have to earn this and keep such rehits. if ur anti bibeki and the call for battle comes u may line up on the frontline with a bibeki, are u not going to sacrifice your all for your fellow brothers or sisters? are u going to say "oh ur a bibeki n i thinks its brahministic so dnt bother fighting alongside me"? sme goes for any bibekis who myt think they myt be better that everyone else, (though i dnt knw of anyone like this) its just all i see is people trying to knock others beliefs or tryin to catch em out, i used to do it, it feeds your ego, none of us are going to move towards guru ji if we carry doing this whether we are bibeki or not. bhull chukk maaf

Re: Pasta

Singhstah · 30 Apr 2006

Id like to pose a question to all the haters: DO YOU THINK THAT BHAI SAHIB RANDHIR SINGH JI WAS STUPID AND JUST MADE IT UP OUR OF NOWHERE????? bhai sahib is someone that we have complte proof of being bibeki, he almost died in jail because he refused to give up his bibek rehit then, this was at one time on top of regular beatings, do you really think he did all of this for no reason? was he "backward" as you put it. Haters get over it BIBEK IS REHIT AND BIBEK RULES BIBEK IS THE FUTURE

Re: Pasta

ks · 02 May 2006

what randhir singh did or did not do is irrelevant. Is he your Guru?

Re: Pasta

singh · 02 May 2006

Singhstah you have some backwards thinking, you say bahi sahib did this as if nothing he could do was wrong. I am a huge an of bhai sahib, but i dont agree with your post. Sure bhai sahib was bibeki but that doesnt autoamtically make it right, he wasn't a guru, who shouldnt base ur rehit on what bhai sahib did, isntead what our guru's did

Re: Pasta

Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 03 May 2006

VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VahegurujeekeeFateh Yeah Bhai Sahib 'singh' Jeeo, as Guru Gobind Singh Jee did follow this rehit of Sarbloh Bebek, then why don't you. Also, what Bhai Sahib 'Singhstah' Jeeo is saying that since Bhai sahib randhir singh jee reached saachkhand in his life so quickly then wouldn't he have knowledge and the experience on how to reach there that fast. Hence, Sarbloh bebek, bani and lots of Naam japp, also including every other rehit too. If Guru Gobind Singh Jee Followed the rehit then why don't you? the children of your father. Please him. Impress him so that he may let you enter saachkhand and wed Vaheguru Jee. Sat Sri Akaal VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VahegurujeekeeFateh

Re: Pasta

w/ever · 03 May 2006

Singstah ji actually to everyone do you even know meaning of bibek?? please go and read about abek/bibek by Dhan Dhan Sri Guroo Gobind Singh ji Maharaaj then come back!

Re: Pasta

LK · 03 May 2006

Some extremely important questions about Bibek have been raised, including abuot sugar and salt. Hopefully, someone who follows bibek can answer the above mentioend questions.

Re: Pasta

Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 03 May 2006

VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFateh bibi Sahib 'w/ever' Jeeo, Of course Bhai Sahib Singhstah knows what Bebek is, and he's right the future of Khalsa Raj in punjab will have a firm belief in Sarbloh Bebek. And the ones that don't believe in it, DON'T!! But don't go around putting down you fathers teaching/rehit. OK!! Sat Sri Akaal VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFateh

Re: Pasta

singh · 04 May 2006

Bhupinder singh jeeo, i understand taht guru ji kept the rehit (thats even if he did, but i wont get into that now), but what singstah said was bhai sahib did this so why shouldnt we? and he clearly said bhai sahib made this up "DO YOU THINK THAT BHAI SAHIB RANDHIR SINGH JI WAS STUPID AND JUST MADE IT UP OUR OF NOWHERE?????" All I'm trying to say is stop basing your rehit around what bhai sahib did, that means I believe that sant jarnail singh reached sachkhand, so that automatically means I should believev in raag mala? No, i belive in it because i studied it and believe thats what my guru ji wanted, not thats what my "sant" wanted. If you want to keep bibek, study it and see the benefits, do do it just because bhai sahib did it, he is not our guru

Re: Pasta

w/ever · 04 May 2006

lol gosh i seem to be putting my foot in it recently! maaph karna i guess i should not have used the '!' at the end of my previous post ok my point was, or rather i should have wrote, that some people take the bibek thing out of context without fully understanding what it is; i.e. it's not just about eating from sarbhloh, eating food prepared by Amritdharis; it includes a whole bunch of other things don't get me wrong i am fully for those who use sarbloh utensils etc, good on them. my point simply was to understand the concepts of abek/bibek, to read what Guru ji writes and THEN perhaps to not loosely just throw around the word bibek with a connection to the useage of sarbhloh, or the preparation of food by Gursikhs only or to the useage of only raw materials in cooking etc everyday in Ardaas we recite "Sikha nu Sikhi daan, kesh daan, rehat daan, bibek daan..." and then you get some people saying "ok then so what exactly is bibek" and a lot of people are like "yeah its about eating from sarbloh pandeh and eating from Amritdharis etc etc" and yes, YES it IS about that BUT at the same time it's NOT just that alone!! read about abek/bibek about the "two brothers" (within us) and maybe you can understand what i am on about but of course knowing me i have got it entirely incorrect so please bhul chuk maaph

Re: Pasta

LK · 04 May 2006

Bhupinder, how do you know W/ever is a bibi? You remind me off Daas Soora.... Singh you shoudn't be revealing so much of your ridhya sidhya.

Re: Pasta

... · 04 May 2006

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ke fateh ....i think that we shouldnt discriminate against BEBEKI Singhs/singhnias.IF we dont keep bebek ourselves then how can we even say for one instance that bebek isnt imoportant.at the end of the day we all need to practice what we preach (bhul chuk maaf if this offends anyone).. if you think bebeks stupid or not imortant then try it for your self and see the efffects it has on us. Talking from expirience bebek has done alot for me..when i first kept bebek i didnt do amrit vela i didnt expirience any thingi realised that bebek isnt important without amrit vela, then i tryied everyday then i felt somthing then ididnt want to stop so im still doing it now. so just try it if you think it not imporant. i hope no one thinks that im speaking out of haumai but i thought that it was relevent to say this accepting that i was once an anti bebeki. waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: Pasta

singh · 04 May 2006

Author: ks Date: 05-02-06 16:41 what randhir singh did or did not do is irrelevant. Is he your Guru? BHAI SAHIB RANDHIR SINGH JI !

Re: Pasta

ns · 06 May 2006

Admins.....Another thread going nowhere , come on wake up

Re: Pasta

Singhstah · 06 May 2006

LOL, i did not say that bhai randhir singh ji made it up, i meant "do u think he made it up" or did Guroo Sahib Ji tell him this rehit? I did not say Bhai Randhir singh ji is my guroo, my Guroo is Sri Guroo Granth Sahib Ji Mahraj and Sri Guroo Granth Sahib Ji Mahraj alone. The reason I used bhai sahib as an example is because, even though Guroo Sahib kept this rehit, there is, as far as i know, no actual recorded proof, and all u lot seem to want is proof. However we do have proof that Bhai Randhir Singh Ji kept this rehit, and im sure that we all agree bhai sahib reached sachkhand, so i dont think he wud lie about the need for bibek. Dhan Dhan Sri Guroo Granth Sahib Ji Mahraj, my ONE and ONLY Guroo!! and Dhan Guroo Dhan Guroo Pyaare!!

Re: Pasta

daas · 06 May 2006

"DO YOU THINK THAT BHAI SAHIB RANDHIR SINGH JI WAS STUPID AND JUST MADE IT UP OUR OF NOWHERE?????" U might find it didnt come around through bhai sahib ji - sarbloh marayada has always been common amongst nihang singhs in india.

Re: Pasta

a singh · 06 May 2006

Author: LK Date: 05-04-06 12:17 Bhupinder, how do you know W/ever is a bibi? You remind me off Daas Soora.... Singh you shoudn't be revealing so much of your ridhya sidhya ^^ it is daas soora. also w/ever mentioned she was a bibi in another post ^_^

Re: Pasta

singh · 06 May 2006

"and im sure that we all agree bhai sahib reached sachkhand, so i dont think he wud lie about the need for bibek. " Im sure we alll agree that sant jarnail singh reached sach khand, but most the ppl on this thread don't believe in raag mala, the point that bhai sahib kept bibek and he reached sach khand meaning we should is not a good one, otherwise all ppl that believe thiis and believe that sant ji reached sach kahnd should believe in raag mala

Re: Pasta

S Singh · 06 May 2006

I dont normally contribute actively to these boards however the length of this topic leads to belief that this topic is one of varied opinions and one where no mutual agreement can possibly be reached. However I do feel that if one keeps bibek, they must also keep bibek rehni behni and sehni not just kehni, and therefore must avoid differntiating themselves from other Amritdhari's. Those who do not keep bibek rehit, please do not get disheartened as all amritdhari Gursikhs have taken amrit from the same bata and no "one" persons amrit is stronger than anothers. We should all aim to keep our rehit up to the best we can, try to move forward day by day but try to keep it gupt - bibek daat is something which should instill nimrata not be used as a houmai boost. As for my interpretation of what bani tells us about food on the whole I think this salok summarises everything very nicely if read in the correct context. salok ma 1 || pehilaa suchaa aap hoe suchai bait(h)aa aae || First, purifying himself, the Brahmin comes and sits in his purified enclosure. suchae agai rakhioun koe n bhittiou jaae || The pure foods, which no one else has touched, are placed before him. suchaa hoe kai jaeviaa lagaa parran salok || Being purified, he takes his food, and begins to read his sacred verses. kuhathhee jaaee sattiaa kis eaehu lagaa dhokh || But it is then thrown into a filthy place - whose fault is this? a(n)n dhaevathaa paanee dhaevathaa baisa(n)thar dhaevathaa loon pa(n)javaa paaeiaa ghirath || The corn is sacred, the water is sacred; the fire and salt are sacred as well; when the fifth thing, the ghee, is added, thaa hoaa paak pavith || then the food becomes pure and sanctified. paapee sio than gaddiaa thhukaa peeaa thith || Coming into contact with the sinful human body, the food becomes so impure that is is spat upon. jith mukh naam n oocharehi bin naavai ras khaahi || That mouth which does not chant the Naam, and without the Name eats tasty foods naanak eaevai jaaneeai thith mukh thhukaa paahi ||1|| - O Nanak, know this: such a mouth is to be spat upon. ||1|| *NB the food only becomes pavitar when the ghee is added (does this mean when cooked possibly?) Maybe this is why the cooking aspect is so vital and the preparation of food.... i dont know....??????? Obviously we all need food to sustain our health and to remain healthy but the key point here is..... without bani... without naam.... without putting in the effort to gain the true wealth... these efforts are all futile. Lets try and concentrate on the truth and not forget that rehit is a discipline, a walkway towards Guru sahib, but what use is that walkway we are building if we dont begin to walk!! Please do ardaas so I too can begin to walk - hehehehehehe