Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

punishing dushts

punishing dushts

raj_karega_khalsa · 20 Apr 2006

VaahigurooJeeKaaKhaalsaa! VaahigurooJeeKeeFathe!! Khaalsaa Jee, i was talking to my sister about the gursikhs who punished ribeiro and she brought up a point which i couldnt answer very well.... we both agreed that its more than ok to punish a dusht whos in the act of commiting crimes and theres no other way to stop him...but wen hes retired and not hurting ppl anymore like ribeiro and dawyer, wuts the need to kill him?? Bhull Chuk Maph Karnee VaahigurooJeeKaaKhaalsaa! VaahigurooJeeKeeFathe!!

Re: punishing dushts

... · 20 Apr 2006

General Vaidya who was killed by Sukha/Jinda was retired. Ribeiro was in Romania as an Indian diplomat ie. agent of the Indian Government. People who commit crimes like these are dangerous and need to be put out of commission. Just because they're not doing anything at the moment doesn't mean they won't hurt people again in the future. KP Gill may be retired but they still call for his help in Nagaland, Assam, Kashmir for advice.

Re: punishing dushts

singh · 20 Apr 2006

sometimes revenge is just.

Re: punishing dushts

davinder · 22 Apr 2006

Khalsa Fateh I have been pondering for quite sum time as to how sikhs are to hand out punishments e.g. if sum1 has killed another wat is the sikh way to deal with this crime, do we lock them up, trust them to reform and let them go, kill them, injure them. what is our justice system? WGJKK WGJKF!!

Re: punishing dushts

some1 · 22 Apr 2006

For that pug that your father wears..thats why its right to kill dushts even when retired.

Re: punishing dushts

raj_karega_khalsa · 22 Apr 2006

hmm...but like, ppl like ribeiro arent hurting any innocent ppl nemore...hes stopped. If he was stilll doin zulam on innocent ppl i would definately agree that he needs to be stopped. But now that he isnt hrtin no1, why punish him???? Bhull Chuk Maph Karnee

Re: punishing dushts

.. · 22 Apr 2006

I think the real justification has already been given by some1: for the pug on our father's head and our own heads.

Re: punishing dushts

LK · 23 Apr 2006

When was reibero killed? Are there any news items about this (i must be living on some toher planet for not having heard this :S)

Re: punishing dushts

raj_karega_khalsa · 24 Apr 2006

Ribeiro's not dead....some singhs did try to punish him but i believe he just ended up in a wheelchair...read the jagwinder singh jee's dead thread for more info... Bhull Chukk Mapph