Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Boy's KaRa taken off with Wire-Cutters!!

Boy's KaRa taken off with Wire-Cutters!!

singh · 18 Apr 2006

http://www.manchesteronline.co.uk/men/news/s/210/210936_goalie_in_sikh_bracelet_row.html Goalie in Sikh bracelet row Don Frame [i]OFF: Sonny and the bracelet.[/i] A YOUNG Sikh footballer had to have his religious bracelet removed with wire-cutters before the referee would allow the game to go ahead. Sonny Singh, 18, who plays in goal for West Didsbury and Chorlton FC, was told by match official Les Lever that it could be a danger on the pitch. Sonny argued that it was an important symbol of his religion and hadn't been off his wrist for seven years. Advertisement your story continues below He also pointed out that it would be covered by his goalkeeper's gloves anyway. Sonny covered the bracelet with masking tape but the referee was unmoved and team-mates finally had to make a phone call to get someone to bring a set of wire-cutters to clip the metal band off. West Didsbury are now making a complaint about the referee's behaviour to officials of the Altrincham Youth League. Sonny, who has been with the club for eight months and played many games without any problem with his bracelet, said: "I was disgusted, and now I feel absolutely gutted that I agreed to do what he asked." [i]RULE: Ref Les Lever.[/i] 'Astounded' The bracelet, known as a kara, is a symbolic steel bracelet worn as a symbol of commitment to truthfulness, strength and unity. "I told him again and again what it meant, but he insisted it could be dangerous," said Sonny. "It put me in an impossible situation. I couldn't let the team down by refusing. "Lots of professional players wear items of jewellery on the pitch including ear-rings that are taped over." Danny Iredale, the manager of Sonny's team, said: "I was just astounded at what the ref was asking him to do. "The daft thing was that Sonny's gloves would have covered the bracelet anyway." Mr Lever did not want to discuss the incident. Altrincham League secretary Fred Taylor said: "We will have to wait for an official complaint to be made by the club and then we would need to hear the facts from both sides." Amrik Singh, a lay preacher and leading member of the Sikh community in Manchester said: "I'm shocked that something like could be allowed to happen. It is an important symbol of our religion and the bracelet would normally remain on the wrist for many years when someone reaches adulthood." ----------------------------------------------------------------------------- It sad that the boy allowed someone to cut his KaRa with wire-cutters. If someone is ignorant of the Sikh articles of Faith (i.e. 5 Kakkaars) and acts "ILLEGALLY" by asking someone to remove the Kakkaar, then as Sikhs we MUST STAND OUR GROUND. If we give in then we are doing a DIS-SERVICE t o the whole PANTH as people will say, "If he can take it off, then why can't you?"

Re: Boy's KaRa taken off with Wire-Cutters!!

G Singh · 18 Apr 2006

Waste of space Singh! He could have stopped them!

Re: Boy's KaRa taken off with Wire-Cutters!!

guruji's_student · 18 Apr 2006

waheguru thats so bad!! ppl wud rather have arms removed rather than theuir kakkar!! and ... FOR FOOTBAL!! .. sikhi comes first least he relasided his mistake!! ... waheguru ... gr8 ppl gna think its ok now waheguru

Re: Boy's KaRa taken off with Wire-Cutters!!

a singh · 18 Apr 2006

not judging here but is he even a real singh? Hes wearing a patka..forget a bout the kaRa for a sec but i think he forgot his crown in the changing rooms...

Re: Boy's KaRa taken off with Wire-Cutters!!

PTE SINGH · 18 Apr 2006

The boys fault 100%, should have refused to play on this occasion untill the refree was reprimanded [%sig%]

Re: Boy's KaRa taken off with Wire-Cutters!!

OJ Simpson · 18 Apr 2006

This is sad. How the heck is a Kara going to hurt or injure someone? that referee should take off his watch off as well which he is wearing in that picture because that might hurt or injure someone as well. Also what i wanna know is why did that Singh just let them cut his Kara off?

Re: Boy's KaRa taken off with Wire-Cutters!!

guruji's_student · 18 Apr 2006

I think we need to be in contact with this so called " singh" ... does he not knwo the relevance of a KAKKAR!! MAY WAHEGURU JI DO KIRPA ON EVERYONE WAHEGURU

Re: Boy's KaRa taken off with Wire-Cutters!!

LK · 18 Apr 2006

Name of Ref sounds French. lol

Re: Boy's KaRa taken off with Wire-Cutters!!

1978 · 18 Apr 2006

Author: a singh Date: 04-18-06 08:32 not judging here but is he even a real singh? Hes wearing a patka..forget a bout the kaRa for a sec but i think he forgot his crown in the changing rooms... of course your not judging. thats complete ekta your displaying. come to think of it, maybe those bibian in guru sahib's time who weren't wearing keskia but did give up their lives and the lives of their children for us weren't real singhnia. they must have forgotten their crowns while they were busy getting abused.

Re: Boy's KaRa taken off with Wire-Cutters!!

S Singh · 18 Apr 2006

Unless he has taken Amrit he should have no problem removing his kara. To many kids at our school used to play the old "its my religion" line when asked to remove kara. They were the same kids who did not think twice about drinking bacardi & smoking.

Re: Boy's KaRa taken off with Wire-Cutters!!

singh · 19 Apr 2006

I don't think insulting this guys sikhi is going to help out at all, insulting him will just push him futher away from sikhi, you people who were insulting him need to think of what this guy is probably thinking if he read this post

Re: Boy's KaRa taken off with Wire-Cutters!!

S Singh · 19 Apr 2006

>I don't think insulting this guys sikhi is going to help out at all, insulting him will just push him futher away from sikhi, you people who were insulting him need to think of what this guy is probably thinking if he read this post singh he may read the posts and think, yes these guys are right I have not taken Amrit and I do not wear all the panj kakkar so it was wrong of me to make a big fuss. I should take amrit and become a proper Singh of Guru Gobind Singh Ji.

Re: Boy's KaRa taken off with Wire-Cutters!!

singh · 19 Apr 2006

i dont think saying hes not a real singh and saying hes not a real singh because he wears a patka will make him say "yea these guys are right" maybe if you guys come from a kinder stand point then he probably will think that, but saying hes not a real singh is just gonna make him dislike amirtdary singhs, or whoever posted those things, maybe if we try to make him understand the improtance of the kara he would realize what he shouldve done, maybe he is just doesnt know a lot about sikhi, all i know is that calling him a fake singh isn't helping anyone

Re: Boy's KaRa taken off with Wire-Cutters!!

Robert Langdon · 19 Apr 2006

All daas can say is, that if his kara and sikhi meant alot to him then he would not have let them remove his kara let alone cut it with wire cutters. He would have walked off the pitch. Seems football means more to him than his Kara and Sikhi. Well... many are saying football is becoming a religon.

Re: Boy's KaRa taken off with Wire-Cutters!!

S Singh · 19 Apr 2006

Rob Langdon makes a very valid point. Loot at our brothers in France they have not removed their dastaar to go to school but in this case this guy has allowed for his kara to be cut off so he can play in a football match.

Re: Boy's KaRa taken off with Wire-Cutters!!

Singh · 20 Apr 2006

so you guys dont take off your kirpans when you fly on planes? you can drive across the country...hell, you can even take a ship across the atlantic this guy had a whole team who was non sikh and counting on him to play on top of which....a kara is a weapon....it can do damage if you hit somone with it.....even by accident and to see all these guys on here calling themselves sikhs while sending insults towards this kid....hilarious

Re: Boy's KaRa taken off with Wire-Cutters!!

aks · 20 Apr 2006

i think it's good that he stuck up 4 himself but why the sudden change of mind. first his arguing 2 take it off n then he goes n takes it off wahs the point.

Re: Boy's KaRa taken off with Wire-Cutters!!

S Singh · 20 Apr 2006

>>Sonny covered the bracelet with masking tape but the referee was unmoved and team-mates finally had to make a phone call to get someone to bring a set of wire-cutters to clip the metal band off. Did he tape the kara to his arm ? If so then would hari not be pulled off when he removed the tape ? Or is that ok ?

Re: Boy's KaRa taken off with Wire-Cutters!!

hmmmm · 21 Apr 2006

>>>some one had to bring a set of wire'cutters to clip the metal band off<<< Wire-cutters???!!! He must've been wearing the super thin bendable type of KaRa. YOu would need MUCH more than that to get a Sarbloh Kara off!

Re: Boy's KaRa taken off with Wire-Cutters!!

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 22 Apr 2006

What an idiot "couldn't let the team down"... not a proper Singh anyway- otherwise he would have sacrificed his silly game of football for his kara, NOT the other way around.