Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Chicken or the egg

Chicken or the egg

Gandalf · 10 Apr 2006

What comes first: Outward Sikhi (i.e. wearing bana, sarbloh, bibek, who you talk to, who you eat with, etc, etc) or Spirituality (i.e. love for guru, love for all other humans)... The feel that I am starting to get from many ppl is that they believe in the physical and visual aspects of sikhi thinking that it will impact their spirituality (what we can't see)....i guess its easier to measure the physical aspects than it is to measure the spiritual aspects... I agree that you can't have one without the other, its just I think that many ppl put too much emphasis on the physical.... Any ideas on what I have said....

Re: Chicken or the egg

anon · 10 Apr 2006

i agree

Re: Chicken or the egg

makhan · 10 Apr 2006

Sadly it is true that a big majority of Sikhs observe outward appearance and pay too much attention to banna and other rituals even in sikhi there are no rituals but many jathebandis have created their own. They call it "rayheit" and quote "rayheit payree muj ko sikh payara nahei" but they do not understand the true rayheit of guru ji before the rayheitnamei were written. "Jin patt ander bahar guddar Te bhalle sansar."(From gurubani).

Re: Chicken or the egg

... · 10 Apr 2006

If you have love for Sikhi then you'll show it. They aren't mutually exclusive. By far, those who have the outters have more of the inner as well as opposed to those who don't have any outter rehit. Inner rehit doesn't stay inside, it comes out and manifests itself in outter rehit as well. But at the same time, if someone is doing just outter, it won't be for long because they can't sustain it and it is just pakhand.

Re: Chicken or the egg

Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 10 Apr 2006

VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFateh If anyone wants Vaheguru Jee's Darshan you have to be pure on external and internal spiritually, as without both we can never attain it or we have to go through the hard way. What comes first is our guru Jee, and that is why some eat only from amritdaris hands and not a manmukh's hand, as this is the only way they can attain Vaheguru Jee's darshan. The people who have eat from a manmukh's hand and have had Vaheguru Jee's darshan had to go through the hard way to achieve it. So what comes first? By maintaining purity on the external body is what Guru Jee wants, as the external is what helps one with the internal, but if one doesn't work on their internal spirituallity than that person is indulging in duality. This goes both ways; the internal and the external have to be pure. Bana is meant to be spiritual but it has been placed in a materialistic form so that it may be worn on the human body. The kakaars and naam are the two things that go with us, as the naam is what absorbs these kakaars and makes them one with the soul. There's a number of dresses and colours the naam forms on the soul. Similarly gurbani doesn't go with us but it helps our spirituallity. So what comes first? How can anyone have love for all humans if they haven't japped an immense amount of naam, as this is completely impossible - don't we still have all the demons running wild inside of the body. Kindness, humilty and love is obtained by japping naam, but before we get to this stage we still have to show kindness to humans but if it's going to sacrifice our bebek, then sorry, guru Jee comes first. Naam is the giver and we are the receivers, not we're the givers and naam the receiver. What has been stated here means more than one thing, as it states the ultimate truth, which is what gurbani states. So what comes first? Sat Sri Akaal VaheguruJeeKaakhalsa VaheguruJeekeeFateh

Re: Chicken or the egg

Confused Khalsa · 11 Apr 2006

[gurbani] jIAhu inrml bwhrhu inrml ] bwhrhu q inrml jIAhu inrml siqgur qy krxI kmwxI ] [/gurbani] Inwardly pure, and outwardly pure. Those who are outwardly pure and also pure within, through the Guru, perform good deeds. We need both. The bana and outwardly rehits and the inwardly bani, seva, humility and compassion. [%sig%]

Re: Chicken or the egg

amarjeet singh · 11 Apr 2006

u need outward sikhi to help ur inward sikhi. jioh nirmal bahroh nirmal bahroh ta nirmal jioh nirmal satgur te karni kamaani koor kee soi pahuchai nahi mansa sach samani janam ratan jinee khatiaa bhale se vanjaare kahai nanak jin man nirmal sadaa reheh gur naale bibek and bana and hu u talk to are important, they either help or hinder your naam jap. gurbani specifically says to avoid sangat of manmukhs so i think it is clear that it will have a spiritual effect.

Re: Chicken or the egg

MANKIND · 11 Apr 2006

we are damm..controlled..Hum aadmi ek dammi. The Damm - breath that has enterted us is OURS..CASH in HAND. The damm breath thta went out is GONE FOREVER... the one damm thta has yet to tneter us is NOT OURS...maybe we will get it maybe we wont. so what is reality..just the ONE DAMM we have NOW..is the chance to wash millions of paaps..and join in Waheguru.. One DAMM can wash kror paaps..a kror damms apent parotting waheguru !!may not wash a single paap..is reality a lot of people spend their entire life..thinking about the dammas gone past...others spend their time wishing about the dammas they havent got (future) and may not get at all . a very few spend the one damm they have as cash in hand to buy Naam....so that if the NEXT DAMM never comes..and they DIE..they have cash in hand to buy a ticket....to waheguru REMEMBER..ONE DAMM....no more no less.......

Re: Chicken or the egg

so nice · 11 Apr 2006

<> THats so beautifully put.It has just improved my Naam abhiyaas wahgurooooooooooooooooooo

Re: Chicken or the egg

singh · 13 Apr 2006

you gotta work on your inner sikhi, then eventually your outta sikhi will start improving, you will automaiclly start wanted to wear the bana once you start getting into bani, good post gandalf samra

Re: Chicken or the egg

Boongawala · 14 Apr 2006

We should be tugging away in naam 24/7 anyway. Naam is our inner purifier. There is nothing else that can purify us from inside except naam. This naam should be japped all the time this is the only way we will be "jeeo nirmal." Having said that rehit is equaly important. External rehit which is kakars, ishnaan etc. These are the things that help us with 24/7 naam abhiyaas. When an abhilkaakhi goes infront of the panj piyare, he/she must present themselves with the 5 kakars and they should be wearing a bana. They should have made preperations before the Amrit sinchaar, example growing hair, not doing any bujjer kurehits. Before the Amrit Sinchaar the abhilaakhi works on his outer being and not so much his inner. This is because it is only after he/she takes Amrit they get the naam to clean the inner-self. Having said that some abhilaakhis wake up Amritvela, sit through Akhaad Paath, do nitnem. These are all forms of cleaning one's inner self. They are related to naam. Naam is the screw, rehit and gurbani is the screw driver. It is only though naam we get humility, seva, good thinking. But rehit is needed to jaap that naam. Both go hand by hand. Vahiguroo ji ka Khalsa Vahiguroo ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: Chicken or the egg

singh · 14 Apr 2006

too many young wannabees dressed up as nihang warriors at the gurdwara these days who dont even know basics when it comes to bani. Total opposite of what gurus wanted when trying to reform the religions of their time.

Re: Chicken or the egg

. · 14 Apr 2006

sant sipahi not sipahi sant saint then soldier

Re: Chicken or the egg

SINGH · 15 Apr 2006

Do you really have a choice? When you shuk amrit, you're given rehit. Your guru gives you naam after you give your guru your head. Following the guru's hukams on rehit is part of the deal. You start keeping rehit and working on your spirituality together. For a gursikh, there is no difference. You jaap naam and baanee to show love for your master and you follow your guru's ways on 'external' rehit out of love for your guru. These things go together. Like a horse and carriage. Can't have one without the other.