Forum
Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
Niranjan Singh · 10 Apr 2006
Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
Sunday 9th of April 2006
Panthic Weekly News Bureau
Amritsar Sahib, Punjab (KP) - In a stinging attack on the growing cancer of “Babaism, Deraism, and Santism”, the executive committee of the Akhand Kirtani Jatha, called upon the Panth to keep the current influence of Brahmin dera culture in check, and challenged the current Sikh leadership, particularly the SGPC and the Takhat Jathedars to initiate a major overhaul in how this critical issue is being handled.
In a statement, released by Bhai Surat Singh, Jathedar of Akhand Kirtani Jatha (AKJ) India, he condemned the indiscriminate use of the word “Sant” and labeled the dera culture as a disease that is challenging the authority of Guru Granth Sahib Ji. The statement was signed by the 11 member committee of the AKJ. “Along with blessing us with religious knowledge, our Guru Sahibans, trumpeted the bugle so we can extricate ourselves from the slavery of Bipparvadi rituals and their theology of subjugation.”, it stated.
It further stated: “Instead of the worship of entities, personalities, stones, deities, idols, cremation grounds, graves and tombs, our Gurus directed us to worship only the Almighty God and Shabad Guru, but sadly those who call themselves part of this Sikh Panth are stuck in the web of graves and tombs, fake Gurus, and sant babas.”
The statement then detailed a suggested plan and series of steps to help maintain the respect of Guru Granth Sahib Ji and help eradicate the Sikh community from the dera disease. They include:
1) SGPC should allot 1% of their Rs500 million budget to counter the dera/gurudom influence in the Sikh community.
2) Creation of a special task (security) force, that would always be ready to uphold the respect of Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Retired Sikh officers, soldiers and Nihang Singhs should be recruited for this seva.
3) A list should be created of all gurudoms, and deras, and all property and assets of these deras be compiled.
4) A similar list should be created of all Gurdwara Sahibs under the SGPC’s authority.
5) These lists should be presented to Sri Akal Takhat Sahib where all properties and assets of these derawadi babas should be openly divulged to the Khalsa Panth afterwhich a panel of Sikh lawyers should then take legal action to reclaim these back to the trust of the Sikh community.
6) Strict legal action should be taken against those who disrespect the Saroops of Guru Ganth Sahib Ji. This should be written in state law and enforced rigorously.
7) Stop the misue of the word “Sant”, as a first step; disallow it use for living individuals.
8) Socially and politically boycott those who associate, patronize and solicit dehdharrees, gurudoms, and derawadis for votes.
9) In keeping proper respect of Guru Granth Sahib Ji, all sales of Guru Sahib Ji’s Saroops should be immediately stopped.
A representative of the Khalsa Alliance, applauded Akhand Kirtani Jatha’s efforts, and requested the SGPC to follow up on the proposal set forth by the Jatha. “The continuing disrespect of the sacred saroops of Guru Granth Sahib Ji, and the growing influence of Brahminvaad in Sikh homes, is proof that Sikhs are no longer masters of their own destiny. Sikhs do not believe in superstitions, nor do they worship worthless deities and charlatans. These distractions (baba and deras) are the invention of the various Hinduvata forces and of the Indian intelligence apparatus and have nothing to do with Sikhi. Sikhi promotes religious independence, and equality, not blind rituals and social bigotry.”, the Alliance representative acknowledged.
Editors can be reached at: [address removed]
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
k.s. dhillon UK wala · 10 Apr 2006
Gurfateh,
this request is sure to fall on deaf ears. Our so-called jathedhar, Vedanti, continues to frequet these dhera's at the request of these sant/baba's. In the past six months, we have documented evidence that vedanit has been to mann pf pehowa's main dhera, three times.
Just an update...mann of pehowa is currently in new york, at the new york dhera, makhan shah lubana gurdwara. The NY gurdwara's have joined together, to request he be sent back, ASAP, and that he not be allowed to go do his so-called parchar/kirtan at any other gurdwara. (press release to be issued tomorrow.)
he will be in NY for two weeks. Lets see what uor NY brothers are willing to do re. this disease.
A huge amount of respect to the AKJ for taking such a firm 'PUBLIC' stand against this cancer within.
Gurfateh.
Kulbir singh dhillon UK wala.
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
Chachaa Jee · 10 Apr 2006
Tell me what good will releasing a statement going do?
Didn't SGPC, Release a hukum that Chatar and Jeevan can't print saroops, didn't they release a hukum saying no to pad-ched saroops????
All of this stuff is still going on, what goos is the statement if they don't take any practical action on it??? Seems like a PR stunt to me......................
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
singh · 10 Apr 2006
"Seems like a PR stunt to me......................"
do you even know who bhai surat singh ji is? and you have the nerve to say he is doing a PR stunt?
people blow a fuse when baba takhur singhs bachan on sant jis shaheedi is questioned but people have no problem saying that gurmukhs of the highest calibre are doing PR stunts because they are setting up proposals to groups like SGPC...
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
S Singh · 10 Apr 2006
Does Canada not have an extradition treaty with the USA. You would have thought the abused bibian in Canada would be ready to seek justice against the pehowe pervert.
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
..... · 10 Apr 2006
How about action against SGPC for creating a Rehat Maryada that only calls for doing 3 banis in the morning Nitnem instead of complete 5 baniya. A whole and well meaning generation of Sikhs actually believes its Guru's. What could be a bigger crime than this. Doesn't it bother anyone.
How about SGPC sanctions, eating meat when there is ample proof that it is not okay to eat meat.
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
manish kaur · 10 Apr 2006
who are the akhand kirtn jatha to do this. its been 30 years and the akj have'nt even got an asthan yet, there achgeivment is very little, compared to dehras, babas etc. you lot should think about what these dehras etc have done for the panth
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
MANKIND · 10 Apr 2006
Dhurr wich Tatoo...thats what we are so good at......
setting aside the real subject..we brought in manna su..what the NYorkers are going to do...another questioned why the bibian in canada are not up to mark. another got so angry at his mentor allegedly called PR Stunt and dragged in thakur singh and his taksalis....a third questioned why 3 banis..meat etc..
when the DUST settles... the Tatoo will have disappeared..and we will have Vedanti having dinner with Daljeeta in Chicago...naother Jathedar will be at dhanwants dera..and so on and Badal will be having a havan in ashutosh dera while dhumma will be having a havan at his dera...
everything back to good old square ONE...and the Derawadees+Sants+badals+anti-Sikh Press goluck looters...etc etc etc all UNITED as before..
BTW..ALL the 11 "signatures" in the press release are written by the SAME HANDWRITING.( One person signed for all)
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
Harmeet Singh · 10 Apr 2006
vjkk, vjkf
manish kaur pyare jee,
what have these dera's done for the panth?
what achievements have these deras made?
please answer my 2 simple questions :)
vjkk, vjkf
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
... · 10 Apr 2006
Dear Arshi Gyani Jee/Mankind/whatever you wish to call yourself this week,
The names on the paper are not "signatures" they're the names of the 11 members of the Committee.
What do you think your insightful "revelation" would mean? Did you think it would show that the press release was a fake? I'm not sure what your point was?
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
Gurdaspuria · 10 Apr 2006
Waheguru jee ka Khalsa
Waheguru jee kee Fateh
To eliminate Sant, Sadh and Babahism from Sikhism is foremost task.
We must declare Knowledge war on this. This war to be fought on many fronts:
A True Sikh must commend this AKJ's action, this is one of the front, we need to fight.
One of the major front is to educate Sikh masses about these terms as used in Gurbani for Sant, Sadh, Baba, Sateguru to dispell this illusion.
Documentary films must be prepared in simple term why one should not ne called Sant, Sadh, Baba or Sateguru.
Repeated articles in nNews papers totally based on Gurbani and puratan history must be published.
Why people fall in the trap of these fake Sant Babas: Drugs, politics, ignorance, quick fix for thier issues, recommendation, lack of faith in Gurmat and Naam etc. Root cause must be understood and addressed.
Here is my 2 cent on the subject.
Following Summary of a reseach document on the topic addressing sant sadh, baba and satguru:
It is extremely difficult to understand the meaning of sant and sadh alone. Since Sant and sadh words are also written for Satguru, God and for Gursikhs. Firstly we need to undersand what is Satguru? then word sant and sadh will be very easy to understand.
According to the Gurbani in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, Satguru is the intermediate link between the devotee and God. With Gods grace, the devotee follows the Gurmat path, and honestly puts more effort in meditating on Gods name. The path towards God opens up, the devotee?s sins are erased, and the devotee becomes free from the cycle of birth and death. Without the Satguru, no one has ever reached God, nor will anyone ever do so. God has placed self (God) into Satguru, and the spirit can be seen by the devotee through meditating on God?s name.
The Gurbani tells us numerous characteristics of the Satguru: Satguru is complete, is spiritual, exists forever, has been existing forever, is free from the cycle of birth and death, is divine knowledge (Satguru ke Bani), is divine word (the Sabad/Gurmanter), is divine spirit (Jot), is residing in everybody, is the intermediate link between the devotee and God, and is the vehicle/channel to meet God, etc.
The Gurbani has addressed Satguru using many names. Some of these names are: beloved, friend, companion, Sadh, Sant, etc. If the definition of Satguru is not completely understood as per Gurbani, this can lead to the worshipping of earthly ?saints.? Understanding this principle is very important. Only this understanding can stop this spreading of dehdhari (bodily) Satgurus, Sadhs or Sants who are preaching their own holiness and misleading people. In the Gurus era, no one ever called each other Sadh or Sant. Instead they simply called each other Bhai (Brother/Sister).
In some places in Gurbani, the term Sadh or Sant is also used to refer to God. Occasionally it is also used to refer to the people who follow the path of Satguru, the ultimate saint. In some places in Gurbani, these earthly Sadhs or Sants are called thugs (thieves), who mislead innocent people into rituals and away from the path of Satguru.
The Gurbani, like a mother, cradles us, holds our hand, warns us from the wrong path, teaches us Gurmat, and re-enforces the importance of meditating on God?s name. It also tells us to be a Sikh of Satguru, to be humble, and to meditate on Gods name with great love and devotion.
If we carefully read Gurbani, we can easily find the direction given by our Gurus and Bhagats in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji: Be humble, it is better to be called Gursikh, Bhai, or Bhain rather than Sadh or Sant. If we think ourselves superior to the rest of the mankind then it is extremely difficult to establish or keep a close relationship with God
This write up is based on numerous quotations from Gurbani so that the true character of Real Satguru-Sadh-Sant can be understood to dispel ignorance about terms.
Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa
Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
Singh · 11 Apr 2006
Author: manish kaur
Date: 04-10-06 18:23
who are the akhand kirtn jatha to do this. its been 30 years and the akj have'nt even got an asthan yet, there achgeivment is very little, compared to dehras, babas etc. you lot should think about what these dehras etc have done for the panth
Akhand Keertanee Jatha has done more for the Panth in the short period of time it has been around then groups who have been around for hundreds of years. There are Akhand Keertanee Jatha Singhs in countries all over the world from Australia, India, Europe, Canada all the way to California. From what I know (I may be incorrect) Akhand Keertane Jatha is the largest organisation of Amritdharis in the world. Other than massive Practise and Parchar of Naam Bani (the highest action) Akhand Keertanee Jatha has done huge Kurbani for the Panth whenever the time has come to take up arms whilst the so called Sants did nothing.
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
MANKIND · 11 Apr 2006
Author: ...
Date: 04-10-06 19:33
Dear Arshi Gyani Jee/Mankind/whatever you wish to call yourself this week,
The names on the paper are not "signatures" they're the names of the 11 members of the Committee.
What do you think your insightful "revelation" would mean? Did you think it would show that the press release was a fake? I'm not sure what your point was?
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
pehlaan aapnee peehree haeth sota fero "author:..." jio.what type of "name" is "author:..." ?? By what standard are you questioning others ??
BTW i am flattered to be gyani...basically i am just what they call athveein pass....
my point is..a Press release scanned as Original..should be "really original..with proper signatures..not just names...any special reason the 11 couldnt sign on the spot..or later before the statement is released..vedanti has been known to "sign' other jathedar's signatures..and doing it right the first time makes sure no such situations arise..just my point of view...
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
a singh · 11 Apr 2006
daas would just like to say that alot of ppl seem to be complaining and wanting to make a change...but the question is have any of you actually made it anywhere? Are you at the avasta of a sant etc...If you are then by all means carry on but if not then please make it your self then preach to others.
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
... · 11 Apr 2006
Dear Gurdaspuria,
"A True Sikh must commend this AKJ's action, this is one of the front, we need to fight."
Although I respect AKJ and their Seva within the Panth, the Babas and Dera also contribute to the Panth as well. Since I do not agree with the AKJ action, does that make me a False Sikh?
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
Harpartap Singh · 11 Apr 2006
There are some real good points made by AKJ India. Also, it doesn't seem to be a PR stunt because was not AKJ one of the jathebandji's which demonstrated outside Chattar Sinh Jeevan Sinh a few weeks ago?
Seems like they're actually doing something rather than just talking :o)
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
uk singh · 11 Apr 2006
It would have been a good idea for Bhai Surat Singh to contact other Jathebandhis to strengthen the statement.
I'm sure that even DDT cannot deny that it is not a good idea to promote the 'Sant' label - especially these days.
Despite their many shortcomings it is good to see that the Nihang Jathebandhies have not jumped on the sant/dera bandwagon.
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
singh123 · 11 Apr 2006
if it wasnt for sant mahapursh alot of things would be very different in sikhi today
they've kept us in check
who the hell are we to even try and say we'll keep them in check
keep nimrata within and respect such great souls
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
The Truth will always shine!!! · 11 Apr 2006
I really dont understand the concept behind the AKJ, the continually go on about how people shouldnt use Sant and how we should get rid of all Babas/dhera/jathas.........but what seems to bamboozle me and im sure many others too is that this organisation has achieved nothing over the past 20-30 years....
....when people mention AKJ people think ohhhh its those guys who always cause conflict within our panth.......what is the problem...so what if people refer to others as Sant.........if the Sant is preaching and making people join Guru Ji's Panth then what is all the fuss about.......???
it always seems to be the AKJ who bring this same issue up, above someone mentioned what have these babas done........!!!!!!
.....Well quite frankly what have you guys done apart from cause conflict and organise simran where the gurdwara starts to shake......with your continuos interruption of shabads with Simran..........!!!!
I tell you what Sants have done,,,,,.........:
Who Collected donations to build many Gurdwaras.......Sants!!!
Who fought for the truth when is was mostly needed....Sants!!!
Who is and has encouraged the majority to take Amrit......Sants!!
Who doesnt bring up the same issue bla bla bla conflict....Sants!
SO WHY THE HELL IS WE ONLY DO NINDIYA OF WHOM......SANTS!!
The Akj talk about Ekta by getting rid of Dhera/babas....well to be honest im sure there is a huge call for ekta between your own jatha before you can even try to criticise others........one jatha in akj believe this and the other belive that.............get it right between yourselves first guys!!!
In my opinion the real reason the akj keep abusing the same issue..is very very simple.......the notion of JEALOUSY.......Goes a verrrrryy long way.....These guys cant accept that Sants are making the difference in bringing people to Sikhi not akj....................PERIOD
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
THE FACTS · 11 Apr 2006
I think "Manish kaur" and "Mr Truth will always shine" take the biscuit as the worst posts written so far.
So starting with Manish kaurs posts, lets look at some facts.
1. You said AKJ has not even got an aasthan. AKJ do not build deras which are later used as personal ATM machines by the sants or their sons and mates. AKJ has built many Gurdwaras around the Panth, but calls them Singh Sabha Gurdwaras. These are given to the Panth, for the benefit of the sangat, and not used as personal business deras.
2. It was sangat of AKJ UK who built the Shaheed Singhnia Gurdwara In Pakistan where Mir Mannu killed Gursikh kids and hung them around their mothers necks.
3. It is AKJ families who built or do seva in many Gurdwaras in UK, which are run under Singh sabha name.
4. It is AKJ families in Slough who have donated more than £50,000 from their dasvand for the Sikh school.
5. The businessmen, who originally built the Sikh School in Southall approached Bhai Rama Singh first to be its patron. Bhai sahib refused because he did not want the attention. So that it why they got Amar Singh Nanaksaria, who loved the attention, and then later had cases for fraud and corruption in USA.
6. In the 80`s, Giani Amolak singh asked AKJ Uk to take over Havelock Road, but the Singh refused, because their interest was Naam and seva. They knew the politics of Southall would ruin AKJ.
7. It is AKJ UK who gave dasvand, did parchaar, and helped do Amrit sanchaars, whihc have built gurdwaras throughout Europe.
8. It is AKJ who still send thousands to Shaheed parivaars, in a movemnt that so many have forgotten, and familes that so many have forgotten.
9. It was AKJ Uk that did programmes in pakistan, when no one dared to go, because they would be labelled by governments.
This is the point. AKJ could have built huge deras. But instead it choose Naam, Bani, Niskaam Seva, and helping fund a Khalistan Movement for 2 decades. Yes, the Singhs in Vancouver who built the Khalsa schools have links to AKJ, and so do many Gurdwaras in Pakistan, Panjab, and south India.
The difference is AKJ gave everything to the Panth, and does not build deras as personal ATM machines and courtcases based on corruption. AKJ is respected in the Panth because it is not a dera, rather a Panthik Jathebandie.
Sikhism is about giving, and not taking!
To "Mr Truth will alway shine."
AKJ has never been against real bhagti wale Gursikhs like Baba Harnam singh RampurKhera, Baba Kartaar Singh Bindranwale and Baba Jarnail singh. In fact they have always had close links and did seva together.
AKJ like many other Panthik groups recognise no Sikh of the times of the Gurus were called "sant", instead they were all called "Bhai". This is not an AKJ invention, but historical fact.
AKJ is in fact much quieter on this issue. If you read literature by SGPC, Sikh Missionary, Sant Sipahi, and many other reject the whole concept of Gurudoom and Santdoom. They articles are far stronger.
It is AKJ, who are rehitvaan Gursikh. You say theu are the ones who are causing problems. Lets analyse this. If is White chola sants, not AKJ who do the following:
-It is the white clothes sants who rape young girls like Dhanwant singh,
- it sants who do illegal occupations on the lands of the poor to build their deras.
- It is those who get young girls to matta tek to them, while they twisting their mostuaches wearing fancy clothes.
- It is those who have multi-million dollar courtcases, as does nanksarisa, whether both parties have been proven as drunks.
- It is those who have been caught in cheap motels with women, while procaliming on stages to be celebates.
- It is white chola sants who disappeared during the 80`s, but suddenly reappeared in the last decade.
- It is white chola sants who have Punjab police officers providing them from protection. The same officers who have been pictured and witnessed torturing to death sikh youth in interrogation centers.
You tell me who is doing a dis-service to Sikhism and Panth. Is it those who have rehit, or those who dress up in white and do kurehits.
If a person has real bhagti, it is a mohar on his forehead, and everyone can see it. No one criticizes them. People only criticize the fakes!
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
Rashpal Singh · 11 Apr 2006
This is to 'The Truth will always shine!!!'
The reason we havent got Ekta in the panth is simply because of people like you.
I dont think Akhand Keertani Jatha have anything to be jealous of at all, infact maybe other people are jealous of them. They have always done parchar of what we call GURMAT. They have always served the Khalsa Panth, and will continue to do so.
You said:
'Who Collected donations to build many Gurdwaras.......Sants!!!
Who fought for the truth when is was mostly needed....Sants!!!
Who is and has encouraged the majority to take Amrit......Sants!!
Who doesnt bring up the same issue bla bla bla conflict....Sants!'
You claim all this, but name me any 'sant' that has done all the above with good intentions?
I dont know of any 'Sants' who protected the Sikh kaum during the post-84 period. Where were the Sants in 1978 when nirankaris were doing beadbi of Guru Granth Sahib Ji?
You said:
'.....Well quite frankly what have you guys done apart from cause conflict and organise simran where the gurdwara starts to shake......with your continuos interruption of shabads with Simran..........!!!!'
You claim that AKJ do nindya of Sants, but don't you think what you have said above is nindya?
I can say with full conviction that AKJ has more Sants in it than you can shake a stick at but the fact is that no one is labelled 'SANT', everyone is Bhai Sahib or Bibi ji. A true sant will never call himself a Sant, or let anyone else call them it.
AKJ has taken a good step against these Dere wale Babe and fake saadhs.
This is what Gurbani has to say about your Manns, ranjits, daljits:
gj swFy qY qY DoqIAw iqhry pwiein qg ]
gaj saadtae thai thai dhhotheeaa thiharae paaein thag ||
They wear loin cloths, three and a half yards long, and triple-wound sacred threads.
glI ijn@w jpmwlIAw loty hiQ inbg ]
galee jinhaa japamaaleeaa lottae hathh nibag ||
They have rosaries around their necks, and they carry glittering jugs in their hands.
Eie hir ky sMq n AwKIAih bwnwris ky Tg ]1]
oue har kae sa(n)th n aakheeahi baanaaras kae t(h)ag ||1||
They are not called Saints of the Lord - they are thugs of Benares. ||1||
AYsy sMq n mo kau Bwvih ]
aisae sa(n)th n mo ko bhaavehi ||
Such 'saints' are not pleasing to me
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
..... · 11 Apr 2006
Whats is wrong with PR stunt is that AKJ is using a broad brush to paint every Sant/Mahapurakh as frauds or fakes. While many people have made it there business to collect maya and 'apni ustat aap karaani' in the name/guise of Sants. There are and always have been true Sants whoes Kamai we can't even measure or comprehend, who achieved partakh darshans of Guru Sahiban. A Few names like Sant Attar Singh ji Mastuane wale, Baba Nand Singh ji, Baba Isher singh ji, Sant Jawala Singh ji, Baba Karam Singhji Hoti Mardan and many others, these are true Sants of Sikh Panth did not care about maya whose only goal was/is to do Parchar of Panth and preached utmost supermacy,respect and sewa of Siri Guru Granth Sahib ji. Nindak of True Sants would be subject to what 13th Ashtpadi of Sukhmani Sahib says.
Than question is how do we judge who is true Sant or not. My humble opinion, we can't, only Guru and Nirankar is the judge of that. All fakes and frauds would be accountable to Guru and dearly pay for their misdeeds, how they pay for their deeds, only Guru would be the judge of that. Jhootth/haume will fall by itself...it does not human assistance to tip it to ground.
AKJ or any other Jathebandi can't be the Certification board for true Sant or not. This much haume is not good.
Bhul chukh di maafi je kuch vadh ghat keh dita hove.
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
singh · 11 Apr 2006
"a singh" you said "Are you at the avasta of a sant etc..."
in response no i am not the avastha of a sant but to be quite frank anyone who has kept sangat of bhai surat singh pooranji knows he has more avastha and naam kamai than all these sants running around in panjab. most people complaining have never met bhai surat singh so i dont think they are in a position to comment.
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
a singh · 11 Apr 2006
veer ji this was not my point. i am merely saying we are always complaining about such and such sant...yet when we look at our own avasta we are not in any position to do prachaar..i was not aiming my comments at any a b c bhai sahib.
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
singh · 11 Apr 2006
"i am merely saying we are always complaining about such and such sant..."
in this case bhai surat singh pooranji is "complaining" about "such and such sant" and he has every right to do so. and he has more naam kamai than all these fake white chola wearing sants in india put together so i dont think YOU are in a position to say anything
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
..... · 11 Apr 2006
singh veerji wrote"
"he has more naam kamai than all these fake white chola wearing sants in india put together"
Only Waheguru would have access to anyone's Naam Kamai account. It seems you have inside information on this data. Its like saying my dad is stonger ( who in reallity might be Kangri bhalwan) that yours ....or my Baba (Bhai Saheb) is holier than your baba....this is childish.
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
singhji · 11 Apr 2006
There is no doubt in my mind Bhai Surat Singh 'pooranji' is a Sant himself, anyone who has spent time with him will realize this. However, he recognizes this huge problem of Santism were any guy puts on chola and becomes sant. Man if you see what some of these sant deras it will make you sick to ur stomach seriously. So, please dont bash this genuine attempt at trying to fix a huge problem.
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
... · 11 Apr 2006
How do you know who has more Naam Kamai? What gives you the skills to measure peoples Naam Kamai?
People of Sant Baba X Singh will say that he has more Naam Kamai than Bhai Y Singh and vice-versa. Simply saying X has more Kamai than Y or Y has more Kamai than X means nothing.
There are many fake "Sants" out there, who come nowhere near the examples of Sant Attar Singh, Sant Jawala Singh, Sant Nand Singh, (both) Sant Isher Singh(s), Sant Gurbachan Singh, Sant Harnaam Singh, Sant Jarnail Singh, etc, etc. Yet there are many Jeevan-wale, even today, with the Sant title.
Also, there are many fake "Bhais" out there, who stand nowhere near the examples of Bhai Taru Singh, Bhai Mani Singh, Baba Deep Singh, Bhai Sati Das Bhai Mati Das, Bhai Dayala, Bhai Randhir Singh, etc, etc. These fake Bhais will also mislead and take advantage of the Sangat and this happens whatever Jathebandi they are from. Yet there are many Jeevan-wale, even today, with the Bhai title.
The point is you can NOT simply paint everyone with the same broad brush.
Have we become so shallow that we are simply judging people with the pre-fix in front of their name?
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
..... · 11 Apr 2006
Those who ( 5 membari committee, 7 memberi committee, 11 memebri committee etc) every so often blow this 'Panth Khatre vich....' Bigul and release press statements, ultimatums, hukamnamas so cheaply to meet there political ends or satisfy their own egos and hunger for publicity have gotten it totally wrong.
Khalsa Panth di saajna was done Kalgidhar Patshah Guru Gobind Singh ji and no fake 'Sants' or fake 'Bhai Sahabs' can ever damage it. Fake and Mithya will always self destruct...These periodical campaigns are nothing more than Publicity Stunt.
Guru Teg Bahadur ji did not have to worry about 22 fake Gurus. Truth always prevails. So if we think anyone is Fake 'Sant' or Fake 'bhai' do not worry. There paaps will destroy them. 'Papi ke marne ko Paap mahabali hai..." Fakes will come and go....True Sants/Mahapurakhs/Bhai Sahebs will always shine till eternity
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
MANKIND · 11 Apr 2006
Guru Teg Bahadur ji did not have to worry about 22 fake Gurus. Truth always prevails. So if we think anyone is Fake 'Sant' or Fake 'bhai' do not worry. There paaps will destroy them. 'Papi ke marne ko Paap mahabali hai..." Fakes will come and go....True Sants/Mahapurakhs/Bhai Sahebs will always shine till eternity
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Of course Guru Teg bahadur Ji didnt worry...but His sikhs like Makhan shah lobanna worried like hell.... NOW Guru Garanth ji doesnt worry..we need to...exactly like makhan shah lobanna to "find" the true Guru....hidden by these fake sants...
Didnt Guru gobind Singh ji BURN the fake MAHANTS ?? why do you think Guru ji did that ?/ Was Guru Ji "worried"...why didnt Guru ji also say what you have said above...dont worry man.....everything will be A-OK..no fake can damage my Panth !! Guur Ji BURNED the fakes alive.. thats what we also got to do..man.. it is FALSE t say fake will self destruct..Guru Ji didnt wait for the mahants to self destruct ?? WHY ??
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
Sikh in the West · 11 Apr 2006
I think its great that the AKJ is doing this. We need more people to stand their ground. I think people think its okay for these sant, babae and brahamgiani to sexually assult women or get donations for themselves. Alot of people out there keep on saying that these women are not doing anything well only these women know what they have done. There are alot more women out there that have been assaulted but the difference is these women are educated and in the western world...not a typical east indian lady who's going to brush everything underneath the carpet and forget about it. If this does not stop now it will never stop...its our generation that has to put a stop to it before anymore people get hurt, people that say these women are lying.what if it were their sister or mother it had happened to. Well the truth will unveil itself in the time to come, All i'm saying is these fake sants need to be exposed.
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
seva · 12 Apr 2006
funny how the pro-sant people can only names real sants from the past, but not a current one.
The press release is about the current lot in punjab. There are 19,000 pinds in punjab. There is almost a sant per pind, some have more than one. You honestly saying there are 19000 mahapurshes in Punjab. If so, why so much patitpuna?
Why from these thousands, can you not name one proper current sant?
Now do you realise where the press release is coming from?
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
amarjeet singh · 12 Apr 2006
u saying pooran ji is doing a publicity stunt eh????
what stupidly stupid thing to say
poor souls
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
Dass · 12 Apr 2006
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa
Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Panji Manish Kaur, please let me know what the baba's / Sants / Dhera's have done?
Yes there have been great Mahapurush's who have done Sikhi prachaar from the heart and totally in accordance with Siri Guru Gobinds Singh Sahibs Rehet.
As for the Kalyugi Sants like Phewo wala and Dhadariwala what have they done? Please do not put forward the case of they have baptized or conducted Amrit Sanchars and bought thousands into the fold of Khalsa. Because in Guru Sahibs house quanitity does not matter QUALITY does.
Bhul Chuk Maaf
Guru Fateh Parvaan
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa
Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
......... · 12 Apr 2006
There are some fake sants and there are some good babas for whom the word "sant" is just a professional word like we have dhadi or keertaniye etc.(Though i feel its better to not use this word)
Baba ranjit singh ji dhadrianwale explained this in his divan.
I initially liked dhadrianvale and then after seeing the tapes i stopped listening to him but i have again started to hear after his apology.I feel he is doing something very good for the panth.Infact watching his few recent cd's,i will just say woooooooooooooooooooooooowwwwwwwww.
I feel akj is very panthic but I also feel labelling all these sants in one category is not the best move for the panth.
I feel the only way to remove sant problem is by starting parchar at grass roots,settling up of schools and academies etc.
Otherwise,the kalyug people will keep on begging at the doors of these sants when wordly problems come.
I have witnessed there are lots and lots of women especially in villages who feel that by worshippin the sant or even sleeping with him,she will cross over wordly ocean.Now what to do of these kind of "sikhs".
If we ban all these sants,these type of people will run to people like radha svamis or ashutosh etc.We need to make sure that we preserve the future generations of these kind of people.WE need to set up SCHOOLS.Yes SCHOOLS.Why no one opening it.Why akj not thinking about it.Are we dead?
For gods sake,start opening SIKH schools in Punjab and the sant problem will die a gradual death.
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
HARINDER SINGH · 12 Apr 2006
GURU PYARI SANGAT JI PEOPLE ONLY REALISE AFTERWARDS..........
Above no doubtely people have mention how great the Sants Mahapurks were!!....But heres a story that has huge relevance to today!!!! Whichever way you aim to interpret it............
When Sant Baba Isher Singh Ji Rara Sahib Wale began doing Kirtan and touring many parts of the world, people just like now became jealous and weary of the Chardi Kala!!! People began to think about various ways in which Baba Ji could be taken down or even ashamed....
First Sant Baba Isher Singh Ji use to visit Sant Baba Attar Singh Ji Reru Sahib Wale...after meeting them and doing their Sangat for many years Baba Ji became enlightened onto this Path of Sikhi.......After some time Baba Ji moved to a place called Rara... Its was here they first started doing kirtan with Sant Baba Kishan Singh Ji...Some years after Sant Baba Attar Singh Ji left for Sachkhand and the chelas from Reru Sahib realised the Chardi Kala of Sant Baba Isher Singh Ji and very became weary of this............
We talk about fakes, but yet have no proof for some.....
Anyway....Five Amritdhari Singhs form Reru Sahib had Ishann, did Panj Bania Da Path and went into Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji's Hazuri......They then did Ardaas and guess what it stated....The Ardaas was based soley upon: "this new Isher Singh is not in the Samprda of Reru Sahib,,,furthermore this new Isher Singh should not be listened to as he is a FAKE."...........!!!!!!!
Sangat Ji this issue hit the Sangat like hot cakes, People were ranting and raving a bit like now and some people believed what was said, stating Sant Baba Isher Singh Ji was a fake and not part of the Reru Sahib Samprda....this kind of left people confused faithless.....(Baba Ji kept quiet and continuned on the path of TRUTH)
FURTHERMORE,
When a few years had gone by people began to once again see the Chardi Kala from Baba Ji. The Nindaks who had stated such things, had shut up and realised the truth....Sant Baba Isher Singh Ji was not a fake............
Then in another attempt to STAIN Baba Ji, people planned another tactic which they thought would certainly effect Baba Ji.
(Today we talk about the Baseless unproved allegations against Sants, from people who have betrayed SIKHI by cutting Guru Ji's Beloved Kesh and used the other Jathas such as the AKJ as a tool to come forward and speak)
But getting back to the point Sangat Ji, the new tactic was absolutely disgraceful and pathetic....the people instead of publishing false articles like now, they sent a woman into Baba Ji's room one night alongside other Sangat... the plan involved the woman remaining in the room with the Sangat, and once they all got up to leave the woman would hide in the room........
..........so this all happened and the sangat left, Baba Ji went into Samadhi and the Singhs from Rara Sahib closed the door.............In the middle of the night the woman climbed onto Baba Ji's bed and started touching Baba Ji.....Baba Ji being such a Mahan Mahapurak, threw the woman and shouted for her to leave the room immediatly (Nothing else happened)......
........But guess what............The word got out and just as today the whole party of nindaks pumped the word all over the world. Many people began asking Baba Ji what had happened and why he had done such a thing???
But nothing had happened, so Baba Ji never replied to all the at the time hype.....
.......Just as the situation is today,, Afer a few years Baba Ji once again came in the eyes of people for STILL BEING IN CHARDI KALA....but people remained who couldnt accept the fact and insisted Baba Ji was a fake!!!!
After some time, the entire world realised.........Many things had happened and Baba Ji was still in Chardi Kala....Baba Ji continued all tours to Kenya and UK....
...furthermore some years after Baba Ji had still encouraged many to join the Khalsa Panth and do Sewa for the rewards in Sikhi.
The mentioned issues are just some of the bad things which took place in the Life of Sant Baba Isher Singh Ji Rara Sahib Wale.......In 1975 when Baba Ji left for Sachkhand people cried and cried...they couldnt belived how they had wasted thier entire lives doing Nindiya of such a Mahan Sant.
ONLY THEN I.E AFTERWARDS DID PEOPLE REALISE, But Sangat Ji today if you look around, Sant Baba Isher Singh Ji is remembered as a great Mahapurak within our Sikh History....Nobody rememebers the false stains, why because the people making them were FALSE instead........
For even more history, this stuff happened in our Beloved Guru Ji's time too..People called Dhan Guru Nanak Dev Ji a Ghost a fake.......People still say Dhan Guru Gobind Singh Ji allowed his father to be Shaheed so he could become the next Guru.....for 22 years after Dhan Guru Har Krishan Ji, people never accepted Dhan Guru Tegh Bahadar Sahib as the next Guru Ji.
BUT TODAY ALL OUR GURU'S ARE REMEMBERED NOT JUST IN ARDAAS BUT EVERYWHERE FOR THE AMAZINGLY GREAT THINGS THEY DID ON THIS EARTH.
So my point Sangat Ji, is not to make this into a tennis ball topic but to ackowledge the fact that it is only afterwards people realise the TRUTH...
As many people have stated only time will tell....Just like it did in the past and just like it will in the future!
There are many GREAT people out there, whom all have qualities of being Great Parcharaks and furthering Guru Ji's Sikhi
The Sewa being done by some of the Sants/Bhai Sahibs/Ragis/Dhaddis/Jathas/etc....etc is great and for us all...Lets acknowldge this fact and stop criticising for once!
Bhull Chuk Maaf
Harinder Singh
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
DASS · 12 Apr 2006
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Guru Granth Sahib Ji is the mahima of Naam, Akal Purakh, Sants, Bhgats, Braham Gyanis and Sadh, if you take these entities out then what else will remain in there, this activity is totally against Shri Guru Granth Sahib Ji and not in accordance with Gurbani. This activity is totally against Khalsa Panth and not in anyway in favour of the Khalsa Panth, Khalsa means a Sant, Khalsa is a Sant and this activity will means a blot on the face of the Khalsa. Akhand Kirtani Jatha has taken a move against the Khalsa panth and should be bycotted with full force against this anti - Khalsa activity. I wonder if AKJ knows the meaning of Akhand Kirtan.
Sevak
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
..... · 12 Apr 2006
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Didnt Guru gobind Singh ji BURN the fake MAHANTS ?? why do you think Guru ji did that ?/ Was Guru Ji "worried"...why didnt Guru ji also say what you have said above...dont worry man.....everything will be A-OK..no fake can damage my Panth !! Guur Ji BURNED the fakes alive.. thats what we also got to do..man.. it is FALSE t say fake will self destruct..Guru Ji didnt wait for the mahants to self destruct ?? WHY ??
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
You just verifying my point....Guru Saheb will be judge of that and he can exact whatever punishment is due to Fakes.....We do not need dharnas, rallies, gheraos, press releases...Guru Gobind Singh ji is not gone anywhere, he was always with Panth....he will always....if something pains us, we should do ardaas before Guru and he will take care of fakes/masands burn them to alive, Fry them alive...Bhai Jeevan Singh ji always says 'Birthi Kade no Hovai Jun ki ardas'.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
MANKIND · 12 Apr 2006
Author: .....
Date: 04-12-06 10:49
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Didnt Guru gobind Singh ji BURN the fake MAHANTS ?? why do you think Guru ji did that ?/ Was Guru Ji "worried"...why didnt Guru ji also say what you have said above...dont worry man.....everything will be A-OK..no fake can damage my Panth !! Guur Ji BURNED the fakes alive.. thats what we also got to do..man.. it is FALSE t say fake will self destruct..Guru Ji didnt wait for the mahants to self destruct ?? WHY ??
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
You just verifying my point....Guru Saheb will be judge of that and he can exact whatever punishment is due to Fakes.....We do not need dharnas, rallies, gheraos, press releases...Guru Gobind Singh ji is not gone anywhere, he was always with Panth....he will always....if something pains us, we should do ardaas before Guru and he will take care of fakes/masands burn them to alive, Fry them alive...Bhai Jeevan Singh ji always says 'Birthi Kade no Hovai Jun ki ardas'.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
BUT NOW GURU JI...is Guru "KHALSA PANTH" on which Guruship was bestowed by Waho Waho Gobind Singh AApe GUR-CHELA...in 1699. SO hoping for Guru Gobind Singh ji to materialsie in the flesh..is falsifying the Khalsa panth FACT.
The Guru Khalsa panth in the Tabiah of Guru garnth ji's Gurbani must decide who the False Santsderawadees/mahapurash/etc etc are and FINISH them OFF ( not kill them as Dhumma threatened to do to someone!!) but fiisnh them off through EDUCATIOn of the khalsa ji of their FAKENESS and HOLLOWNESS.
IF JSBhinderaallh ahd worked like you and just did ardass..Birtha kadeh na hovee jan ki ardass.." and then Sat down with Folded Hands waiting for Guru Gobind Singh Ji to come out...????? DO ARDASS..YES certainly..BUT then we got to Take Action too.
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
DASS · 12 Apr 2006
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
So does it mean that so called AKJ folks have become Gurus themselves and they are looking at burning the mahants, I thought these AKJ people are against anybody being called a Sant or a Braham Gyani, so now they are pronouncing themselves as Gurus and want to burn the mahants - if that is true and if they have become Satgurus then they have the authority to do so, but if they are not satguru then who has given them the right to do so, it is very hard to understand AKJ philosophy - it is surely their own philosophy and not Gurmat by any chance. God bless them with the Gurmat.
Sevak
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
Sukha Singh · 12 Apr 2006
Press Release
New York Sikh Sangat takes Hard Stance against Mann Singh Pehovawale
New York - Gurdwara Committees and Panthic Jathedbandi's of the Tri State area held a meeting at the Sikh Cultural Society Gurdwara where problems facing the Sikh community and panth were discussed, including the upcoming New York tour by Mann Singh Pehova wale. All Jathebandhi's and committees took special notice about Mann Singhs upcoming tour and made note of his previous tours, where Mann Singh has been known to give the wrong meanings and use gurbani out of context in such a way that it is inappropriate to discuss in front of our mothers, sisters, and daughters.
The pending crimes reported by the various press in India, and in North America, regarding the inappropriate meetings between Mann Singh and young women were also looked at and discussed. It was noted that Panthic Jathedar of Akaal Takhat Bhai Ranjeet Singh hade made and collected video statements which were then released to the media. In these videos the girls revealed the nature and extent of the crimes of sexual harassment by Mann Singh, to various Panthic bodies, yet no action has yet been taken, by these leaders. Many of Mann Singh’s close associates have also been active in shedding light on the disgraceful acts committed by him. The relevance of Mann Singh’s close association with and honoring of corrupt leaders and the smooth operation of his dera’s was also discussed. Other pending issues were also brought up and resolved.
It was concluded that at every program by Mann Singh, from his arrival at the airport would be attended by Sangat wishing to enlighten others of his actions. The proposal to make and distribute pamphlets outlining the activities of Mann Singh was also taken into consideration.
The collective majority of attendees pressed for action on another issue. They wished for Mann Singh’s presence at Mukhan Shaah Lubhaana Gurudwara, the only committee still wishing to support his programs, should be discussed with the respective committee and a humble request be made to cancel the planned program. Worldwide media coverage and attention given to the activities of Mann Singh has still not resulted in a statement or even acknowledgement from Mann Singh, and this should suffice in the boycott of all his programs from all Gurudwaras. Those who fell victim to his actions should be helped in all ways possible and it should be the duty of all Sikhs to use the highest means of support in encountering the injustice they faced. An eleven member committee was formed in regards to this.
Upon reaching these conclusions, the committee of Mukhan Shaah Lubhaana Gurudwara was contacted and they assured sevadaars that Mann Singh’s programs would take place only at the Gurudwara itself, and nowhere outside. They expressed regret that they had not been contacted earlier as they would have made arrangements to cancel his programs. Senior leader of Gurudwara Mukhan Shaah Lubhaana, Master Mohinder Singh proposed the idea that the Sikh community should sit down and find a proper and permanent solution to this problem so that future fake Baba’s are not allowed entrance into any Gurudwara. He simultaneously putt a certain amount of blame on the Sangat for giving such inapt individuals such credibility and merit in so little time, with no prior knowledge and forgetting all maryada and respect for Sri Guru Granth Sahib. Master Ji said he gives Sangat full support and applauds their efforts in regards to this issue.
Sardar Rajinder Singh & the eleven member committee may be reached at (917) 892-2401
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
Sukha Singh · 12 Apr 2006
Boycott of Pehova Wale
Not to long ago, Baba Mann Singh Pehova wale, did 1313 Akhand Pahts for the Chardi Kalaa of the Khalsa Panth. It seems like the effect of those Akhand Pahts has already begun to take shape as Mann Singh has recently been boycotted and barred from holding diwans on stages in Dubai where the Sangat rejected his presence and similarly now Mann Singh has been boycotted from the various stages in New York in the tri state area.
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
European Sikh · 12 Apr 2006
Author: MANKIND
Guru Nanak fed saints and said that is Sacha Sauda.
slandering is going against the teachings of first guru.
<<<<<<<<<<<<<<
ALL "SANTS" are more than welcome to come eat in Guru nanak Ji's Guru Ka Langgar....its still SACHA SAUDA....
But todays SANTS..call themselves "DERA SACHA SAUDA"..and ENTICE the innocent Sikhs of the same GURU NANAK....into a web of evil.
They are NO "sacha sauda"..not dhanwanta, not manna su, not daljeeta su...the SIMPLE Daal Roti of Guru nanak ji's Sacha Sauda is a no no to them..they want and demand 36 parkaar they Bhojans....and serving girls of 36 nationalities...
Excellent post Mankind and also very so true.
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
Dass of DASS · 13 Apr 2006
Mr Dass has written 2 very stupid points.
You say AKJ have made themselves into Gurus. Then you say AKJ should be banned from the Panth. These statements show your low intelligence level.
AKJ believes in Shabad Guru. It is respected part of the Panth. It perserves the respect given to Gursikhs and seeks to rid the Panth of rapists and molesters in the guise of Gursikh bana. This is the duty of every sikh. If sikhs in the Panth are rising against dodgy sants, then it will stop bad sants. What has any real sants got to worry about? If Guru Nanak can speak against tyrants like Babur, why cannot his Sikhs speak against rapists anmd molestors?
Why do you seek to defend rapists?
Do you not have a mother, sister or daughter?
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
k.s. dhillon UK wala · 13 Apr 2006
Statement from Chardi kala singhs in Dubai....
Fateh Ji,
This in response to your request to writeup the complete episode of the visit of Maan Singh Bheve wala to Dubai.
You are in receipt of eye witness report of Maan Singh,s visit to Dubai in 1993 & 1995. It is clear in the report that Maan Singh,s interactions with the sikh sangat was "HAKARY" & "BADMASHY" type. He also knew that, he is least welcome in Dubai, given the circumstances under which he left Dubai in 1995.
We under the banner of "Khalsa Panchayat UAE Dubai" are the watchdogs for "Gurmat Parchar". We are also not member of any Gurdwara Management Committee.
It was brought to our notice that Maan Singh is again coming to Dubai & his first program is in a new Gurdwara ( We never heard about it) under construction in Um Al Quain about 60 km from Dubai. On 10th March we had a meeting with the management of that Gurdwara & briefed them about his previous deeds. They were surprised to read his deeds in the news items & books we showed to them. The announcement for Maan Singh's program was not made in the Gurdwara & was canceled.
On 17th March he arrived at Dubai airport and it's report was sent by E-Mail to you. I was manhandled at the time of taking video. On 10th March his program for 17th March was announced in Sonapur Gurdwara in Dubai. This had to be canceled because of our initiative to educate sikh sangat out side the Gurdwara through leaflets. This had a very positive effect and non other Gurdwaras allotted time to him. His departure was on 25th and only Friday of 24th required full vigilant on all the Gurdwaras. Our men were in all the Gurdwaras & the material for distribution was ready in case he is given time unannounced. It never happened & he left Dubai without giving any program in any of Gurdwara during his stay between 17th to 25th March in Dubai.
Thanks & Best Regards.
Prabhjit Singh
(Khalsa Panchayt UAE Dubai)
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
k.s. dhillon UK wala · 13 Apr 2006
Statement from Dubai whilst mann pehowa was still there. Why are so many members of our sanghat willing to tell the truth to the sanghat, yet mann of pehowa has a foolish child speaking for him?
how long will the panth be blinded to the true mann of pehowa?
We all should now recognise the our current jathedhar, Vedanti is supporting the wrong camp, once more. First it was dhanwant, now mann of pehowa....
Mann of pehowa is now saying that his ten day trip to Dubai was for a visit, no kirtan was planned....the lies keep on coming.
Read sanjh savera article today with the true story of one of our sisters, and the sexual assult that mann of pehowa forced upon her.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dear Kulbir Singh Ji,
Wahe Guru Ji Ka Khalsa;
Wahe Guru JI Ki Fateh parvan hove ji.
Mr. Tarsem Singh Khalsa s/o Mr. Joginder Singh came to Dubai on
employment visa in Jan. 1991. He was working in M/S Ribtex Garment
Factory, P.O.Box 4006 Sharjah U.A.E. He was arrested from Sharjah
Gurdwara in March 1995 and remained in Jail for 15 days and after
court case he was deported to India on 4th June 1995.Attatched is a
copy of Tarsem Singh's cancelled Visa.He again came on employment visa
of M/S System Construction Co. P.O.Box 26368 Dubai U.A.E. in 1998. He
is in my office and giving the first hand information on the deeds of
Maan Singh Bheve wala(the so called Saadh)during his last 2 visits to
Dubai in 1993 and 1995.He states as under :
"The present main Gurudwara of Al Awir was at Al Rashidiya location in
Dubai in 1993. Maan Singh Bheve Wala had come to Dubai and
made 'Purchaar' for 'Amrit Chakko' in a number of Gurudwaras in UAE.
At Rashidiya Gurudwara about 300 people attended the ceremony
for 'Amrit Paan' organized by Maan Singh and his co-personnel who came
with him from India.I was one of them.
A week after there was a lot of unrest in the Sikh sangat that after
the Amrit Parchaar, the Panj Pyaaras including Maan Singh Bheve wala
had sent
Amrit from the baata in glass for the wife of Mr.AmreekSingh.When the
Singhnis from the Amrit Sanchaar saw the Gaathra with Kirpaan on
Amreek Singh's wife, they questioned her how she was wearing these
when she was not present at the Amrit Sanchaar. To which she replied
that she was given the Amrit by parcel in a glass sent by Panj
Pyaaras. This spread like wild fire and Singhs from Singh Sabha UAE
protested strongly to Maan Singh Bheve waala. On the next Kirtan
Darbaar of Sant Singh Bheve waala Mr Fakeer Singh informed the Sangat
about this incident and asked that the Singhs who participated as Panj
Pyaaras should apologize to the Sangat for this deed.To this Maan
Singh Bheve wala with his followers left the Gurudwara in anger.Later
it was decided that Maan Singh Bheve wala will never be allowed to
perform Amrit Sanchaar in UAE.
In 1995, he again came to UAE for Parchaar.He was told clearly by the
Singh Sabha UAE at that time that he can do only Parchaar for Amrit
but he
will not be allowed to perform the ceremony.To this he declared in the
Sangat that some people have asked me not to perform Amrit ceremony.
He banged his fist on the Harmonium many times and said No one could
stop him from performing the ceremony.Upon this Mr.Santokh Singh and
Mr.Lashkar Singh( the then Secretary of Singh Sabha UAE)challenged him
to do so and then see the consequences.Maan Singh said that if they
did not allow him into the Gurudwaras then he would hire a hall in
hotel
and perform the ceremony there..in the presence of Guru Granth
Sahib.Things became very tense and came to the knowledge of Police.
Matters got worst and it became a problem of Law and Order.He was not
given times in the Gurudwaras in Dubai but another Gurudwara in Ajman
(now closed)about 50km from Dubai had given him time for Friday weekly
congrigation. Maan Singh came to know that the Police and CID is after
him so he did not turn up at the Gurudwara and flew back to India the
same night.The Sharjah Police was tracking him and so they raided the
Sharjah Gurudwara with the impression that he might have turned up
here. On Friday the 17th of March,1995 the Sharjah Police raided the
Gurudwara situated in the premises of Gurmail Singh's workshop and
arrested 25 people including me.Since i was at the Tabya of Guru
Granth Sahib the police told me that they also wanted The Book to be
taken to the Police Station.I asked for time from the Police to do
Sukh Aasan, which the Police allowed and after the ardaas the Police
took the Swaroop in the blanket. A few names amongst those who were
arrested are: Nirwair Singh of Bin Laden Co.,Balbir Singh of Conmix
Co.,Jaswinder Singh Fagwara, Bhajan Singh of Jalandher and Santokh
Singh. We all were also deported to India and lost our jobs and
service benifits.
In the jail, the police asked us to call people who are running this
gurudwara to release you from the jail. We called all the commitee
members but no one showed up in support of us.They charged us of doing
illegal practises and were deported under the country law.I am a poor
man and was earning handsome salary from my job in 1995 adn was
supporting my family very conviniently. I lost my job, all my service
benifits and had a very tought ime in India. Being jobless in India I
got another offer in Dubai but at half the salary with a lot more work
compared to my last comfortable job."
This is the extent to which the behaviour of Maan Singh has affected
someone's life including Tarsem Singh who has narratted the above
incidents.
Thanks and Best Regards
Prabhjit Singh
Khalsa Panchaayat,Dubai,UAE
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
Bootha · 13 Apr 2006
Dass of DASS,
Thats right yaar, judge, jury and executioner ! For your information nothing has been proven against any of the persons you rant about, and boy will there have been efforts to get them behind bars.
So called AKJ's and their coharts will have made every effort to get them behind bars, but you know what, nothing has happened, after all these years of false accusations, nothing.................. why?
don't give me the ' they have friend is high places' that doesn't wash, you lot who spew so much vitriol will have made all efforts to get them convicted but the evidence is not there, just heresay and false accusations.
AKJ does so much good for the panth, but it lets it self down by its members getting on their high horses and big heads.
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
S Singh · 13 Apr 2006
Bootha
Plenty of things have been proven about the motel wala baba of chicago, child raping dhanwant, rapist jagera, amar the fraudster.
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 13 Apr 2006
Author: S Singh
Date: 04-13-06 13:11
Bootha
Plenty of things have been proven about the motel wala baba of chicago, child raping dhanwant, rapist jagera, amar the fraudster.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Singh Jio...Guru Ji declares in His Divine Gurbani....aandeh eh na akhiyean..
Call NOT those "BLIND"...who have NO EYES ( what the world calls Blind People)..Call THOSE BLIND..that HAVE a Perfectly good pair of eyes and 22/20 Vision.. BUT DO NOT "SEE"....
The First group can go to a hospital..see a good eye specialiast..laser surgery etc etc and maybe get their vision restored...BUT the SECOND VARIETY....are a totally different kind of "patient"... whcih hsopital or eye doctor ahs a cure for theri perfect vision ?? None...only GURU JI's KIRPA can help them..
Jarnail Singh
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
ashamed of nanaksar · 14 Apr 2006
An IHRO Investigation Report
Gang rape and Torture in Nanaksar Gurdwara (Thath) in Ludhiana
The International Human Rights Organisation (IHRO) has found media reports to be correct and proved to the effect that one Sukhwinder Kaur (23), mother of two kids, of Kaithal (Haryana), was gang raped and tortured for three days by injecting sedatives and showing pornography inside the Gurdwara building of the local Nananksar Gurdwara (Thath), at Ferozepur Road, by a group of its preachers, led by Satnam Singh alias Satta.
For this shocking incident, the management, including the Head of the sect Baba Bhajan Singh, is responsible because of mismanagement and negligence to keep an eye on such unscrupulous elements that had brought bad name to the Sikhs in general and the Nanaksar sect in particular. And for that, Baba Bhajan Singh should appear before Akal Takht to seek atonement for the sin that had been committed inside the Gurdwara building and to ensure the Sikh Panth that such incidents would not be repeated in future.
A three-member team of the IHRO, comprising its chairperson D S Gill, secretary-general Mohinder Singh Grewal and secretary Ms Inderjeet Kaur, documented the report on the incident after visiting the spot and meeting PSEB employees, the Thath In charge Baba Jagir Singh, the victim Sukhwinder Kaur, the police officials and many others. Jagpal Singh Grewal assisted the team.
The role of the Punjab State Electricity Board (PSEB) employees, the police and the public that had recovered or helped recover the woman victim from the clutches of the "preachers" on June 1 and apprehended some of the criminals in the garb of granthis and ragis of the Sikh faith, is appreciable. The main culprits are still absconding and the police is on their trail.
The rape victim, Sukhwinder wife of Balwinder Singh, told the IHRO team that she had left home a few days ago and come to her aunt in Gobindgarh after an altercation with her husband, Balwinder Singh, who used to mistreat her. She came here in search of some job and wanted to stay one night at the said Gurdwara on May 30, 2002, where she was repeatedly raped by Satnam Singh Satta, Dalip Singh (Gardner), Tejinder Singh alias Raja, Gurvinder Singh, Tarsem Singh, Gurdip Singh, Gurmukh Singh and Parminder Singh.
She added: "Mali Dalip Singh and Satnam Singh asked me, on that evening, to stay inside the room as some women were already living. When I entered the room and asked about the women, as there was none. When I tried to leave the room Satta closed the door and the Mali tried to grab hold of me. But I repulsed the attempt. On this, Satta slapped me. They tied my hands and mouth with cloth (Patkas), injected some sedative and switched on the TV set for showing me a blue movie. Satta first rapaciously molested and raped me. Next to him was Mali Dalip Singh. Gurvinder Singh joined them. After that, I became unconscious. Next day, on May 31, Tejinder, Gurmukh, Parminder, Gurdip and Tarsem also joined them in their torturous act of raping and molestation, after tranquillizing me again."
"On June 1, when I woke up, there was no one in the room. So I got up and opened a window. Some people were sitting or walking around in that adjoining area. I waved my hands as a signal but none of them noticed me. I did not make any noise out of fear. In the meantime, Gurdip and Tarsem knocked at the door, which I had bolted from inside. I immediately closed the window and opened the door. I told them that I wanted to take a bath. So, they went away and allowed me to close the door. I again went to the window and started signalling in order to get noticed."
Lakhwinder Singh, a Junior Engineer in the PSEB showed the IHRO team a couple of windows of the Nanaksar dera that opened into the compound of their office. He said, "Assistant Lineman Mohan Lal noticed a young woman at about 9:30 AM standing in one of these windows who was signalling him to come nearer. He became suspicious and called his colleagues. So, Ajit Singh, Bhupinder Singh, Aim Lal, Joginder Lal, Gurmit Singh and he himself joined Mohan Lal."
When they went near the window she told them that she was being forcibly kept there asked for help to rescue her. They advised her to keep quite and close the window so that the accused may not be warned. Then they made a call to the police control room. After waiting for some time, they went to the Sarabha Nagar Police Station. ASI Surjit Singh and Head Constable Sucha Singh came to the spot along with them. In the meantime, the control room party had also arrived.
The policemen first talked with her through the window and then entered the dera from the main gate and recovered her from the first floor room. A coloured television, a video CD player, some blue movies, injections and syringes etc were also recovered from the room.
On the other hand, the in-charge of the Thath, Baba Jagir Singh, who is confined to bed due to leg- fracture, denied any prior knowledge of the episode but did condemn the incident, stressing that the culprits should be brought to book. "We have nothing to do with these rapists," he told the visiting IHRO team.
But Satnam Satta and Tejinder Raja did whatever they liked in the Dera. Other sewadars could not check them, out of fear. Moreover, Thath Head Baba Jagir Singh also could not do the needful due to his ineffective administration, criminal and assaulting behaviour of the duo and his intention of remaining the dera head, according some inmates of the Thath.
There is every possibility of such like events happening in the past as the gang leader Satta was expelled twice by the Baba due to his bad character activities. It is also intriguing why the late sect leader Baba Kundan Singh reinstated Satta third time. Even, devotees visiting the Thath do not ruled out such things happening there.
The IHRO calls upon all Sikh organisations, especially the Deradars, to create a mechanism to check and steer clear of such sexual abuses in religious places so that the faith of the devotees may not suffer due to such debauched elements. The Sant Samaj should come out with the truth and start a movement to stop this menace from their deras.
(D S Gill)
Chairperson
International Human Rights Organisation (IHRO) is a NGO, with national focus and overseas lobby network. It agitates both in India and internationally.
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
a singh · 15 Apr 2006
Author: Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi"
Date: 04-13-06 23:19
Author: S Singh
Date: 04-13-06 13:11
Bootha
Plenty of things have been proven about the motel wala baba of chicago, child raping dhanwant, rapist jagera, amar the fraudster.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Singh Jio...Guru Ji declares in His Divine Gurbani....aandeh eh na akhiyean..
Call NOT those "BLIND"...who have NO EYES ( what the world calls Blind People)..Call THOSE BLIND..that HAVE a Perfectly good pair of eyes and 22/20 Vision.. BUT DO NOT "SEE"....
The First group can go to a hospital..see a good eye specialiast..laser surgery etc etc and maybe get their vision restored...BUT the SECOND VARIETY....are a totally different kind of "patient"... whcih hsopital or eye doctor ahs a cure for theri perfect vision ?? None...only GURU JI's KIRPA can help them..
Jarnail Singh
___________________________________________________________
sorry whats that..when u refer to "them" shouldnt u refer to "us" or "your self" ...why? I think u need to realise that those who dont see brahamjyot ARE BLIND...those that havent passed the trikuti..or had dibdrist..are BLIND..
gurbani is NOT for thrigun...but for chauth paad..hence why all the ppl who learn gurbani from schools given wrong meanings..as they are thrigun and NOT chauth paad.
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 15 Apr 2006
a singh ji,
tuhada chauth padd tuhanuu mubarak hoveh ji....panjeven padd te kadon charr rahe hon ?? maybe you are too high up to see what the "padd walleh babas are really doing so far down below...
Dass taan pahleh padd te hee hai ji. ..and everything is so clear down here.....sorry.
Jarnail singh
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
a singh · 16 Apr 2006
aww playing the humility card? i love that. No i wasnt saying i am so high up and no i am not sticking up for every a b c baba...but hey if ur only in tamogun...u really cant judge others. As everyone knws that without going chautha paad u havent "saved" ur self so u shouldnt be preaching to others like u knw how everything works.
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 16 Apr 2006
NO Singh Ji..I never play any card..humility or otherwise...i just say what i feel..no preaching or sermonising either....its just what i feel.period. some like it..some hate it..others ignore it..but i continue to say what i feel.....
Yes I know you dont support every abc baba....no sane person can... imagine supporting manna pehowa dhanwants bhaniara..et al...YET they do have their DIE HARD supporters....mann was recently called to NY and Dubai....but came back with his tail between his legs..thnaks to others who have seen thru him...
Since everyone agrees thta the "majority" of these Sants babahs are up to no good..and a very tiny minority of them are good...why not persuade ALL to drop the sant title..disband sant samaj...and thus KILL the bad ones at one stroke....as long as ALL insist on beigncallaed Sant Baba Ji..the evil ones will continue to hide among the crowd...as the report on NANAKSAR shows.. last week all these BIG WIGS sants were attending sgpc'Akal takhat meeting with BADAL....and today they are on the Front Page of aPunjabi Newspapaer sucking up to Amarinder !!! So much for DHARAM !! They are even Worse than POLITICIANS..at least BADAL is always BADAL..and Amarinder is always Amarinder...not jumping about like Baba Dadoos !!
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
singh 2 · 17 Apr 2006
You know what this site is just full of people of who want to put others down..im just coming into sikhi and i just feel sad at the way you people would call each other gursikhs and think that these are the actions of gursikhs.. i hop dont offend anyone by this.. but when did god die and make you god??? i just feel its really wrong how were always trying to keep picking problems with the same people again and again.. please lets all just grow up together
Marajah will always serve justice.. so if youve been telling lies about anyone on these threads... may god have mercy on ur sole..cuz youve had it!
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
k · 17 Apr 2006
I totally agree.
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 18 Apr 2006
me too....totally..agree..that is.
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
cali sikh · 18 Apr 2006
I agree as well, but since your just coming into sikhi would you not rather be warned about these people...yes there is negativty...but for a good cause....i sure wish someone had warned me about the pehowa wala...its not about picking on every sikh and every good soul or Baba jee from the past, but the new babae are the ones that are the ones that we should be staying away from and just be following the SGGS.
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
European Sikh · 18 Apr 2006
Sangat Boycotts Pseudo-Baba Pehova (Mann singh)
Sunday 16th of April 2006
Panthic Weekly News Bureau
New York, USA (KP) - Several Panthic organizations and Gurdwara Sahib committees throughout the globe pressed for strict and immediate action to be taken against pseudo-Baba Mann “Singh” Pehova wala given his reputation for sexual assault and his other scandalous behaviors.
In recent months, Pehova wala has attempted to hold programs in different Gurdwara Sahibs throughout the world where the local sangats were unaware of his reputation for sexual harassment. A Canadian newspaper reported that a notarized affidavit was submitted by a Sikh Bibi that stated that on his last North American tour, Baba Pehova wala attempted to molest her after following her into a restroom. Explicit details of that encounter were posted on the newspaper's website.
Last month Pehova wala tried to hold a program in Dubai (UAE) however thanks to the diligence and immediate action taken by Khalsa Panchayat UAE Dubai he wasn’t allowed to hold a program at any of the Gurdwara Sahibs. Mann “Singh” was accused of having inappropriate interactions with the sangat on his past visits to Dubai back in 1993 and 1995. Upon his arrival in Dubai last month, several of the sevadars of the Khalsa Panchayat were assaulted by Pehova wala’s associates when they tried to expose him to the sangat by distributing leaflets with information about his past actions. Despite these attacks, the sevadars were successful in their initiative to stop Pehova wala from holding any programs during his stay in Dubai from the 17th to the 25th of March.
At a recent meeting held at the Sikh Cultural Society Gurdwara in New York, Gurdwara Committees and Panthic Jathebandis from throughout the Tri-State area stood united in a boycott against Pehova wala given his upcoming New York tour. The representatives at the meeting took note of Mann “Singh’s” previous tours where he intentionally tried to manipulate the meanings of Gurbani and spoke in a very obscene manner to the sangat and in the presence of Guru Granth Sahib Ji. The pending crimes reported by the various press in South Asia, and in North America, regarding the inappropriate meetings between Mann “Singh” and young women were also looked at and discussed. It was noted that former Jathedar of Akaal Takhat Sahib, Singh Sahib Bhai Ranjit Singh Ji had made and collected video statements which were then released to the media. In these videos the young women revealed the nature and extent of the crimes of sexual harassment by Mann “Singh”, to various Panthic bodies, however thus far action has not been taken against him. Many of Mann “Singh’s” close associates have also been active in shedding light on the disgraceful acts committed by him. The relevance of Pehova wala’s close association with and honoring of corrupt leaders and the objectionable operation of his deras was also discussed.
The collective majority of attendees resolved to take steps to create awareness amongst the sangat of the lewd and offensive behavior of Mann “Singh” through a variety of mediums including the distribution of pamphlets with information about his past actions. Those present also urged the committee of Gurdwara Mukhan Shah Lubhana, the only committee still wishing to support his programs, to cancel the planned program.
Worldwide media coverage and attention given to the activities of Mann “Singh” has still not resulted in a statement or even acknowledgement from Pehova Wala, and this along with other confirmed misdeeds committed by him should suffice in the boycott of all his programs from all Gurudwara Sahibs.
Under the name of Sikhi, people like Pehova wala who set themselves high up on pedestals claiming religious superiority have maligned sacred institutions of the Sikh faith and have abused the term “Baba” luring vulnerable Sikhs who are ignorant of who they really are. An eleven member committee was established to help those Sikh women who were sexually assaulted by Pehova Wala. The committee noted that it was because of people like Mann “Singh” who abuse the name “Baba” for their own interests that countless Sikh men and women have been led astray. Prominent Panthic organizations worldwide have emphasized that the Panth needs to be purged of such anti-Sikh elements and thus all Sikhs are requested to boycott all programs by Pehvo Wala.
Editors can be reached at: [address removed]
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
moorakh · 18 Apr 2006
I agree that there are many moorakh bhekhi Sikhs
However, let me just ask:
If they were called:
or Bhai Piara Singh Bhaneriawala instead of Baba Bhaneriawala
or Bhai Virsa Singh instead of Baba Virsa Singh
or Bhai Mann Singh Pehowawale instead of Sant Mann Singh Pehowawale
or Bhai Fake Sikh 1 instead of Baba
or Bhai Fake Sikh 2 instead of Sant
etc. etc. do you think they would do less harm?
Aren't there just as many so called "Bhai's" who have raped Sikh women, stolen from the panth, done fraudulent things, etc. ?
Aren't there police officers, farmers, army workers, doctors, and people from every background regardless of their title who have stabbed the Sikh panth in the world?
What does the title have to do with it? We are not chasing the title. We are chasing the BAD ACTIONS and we should 'finish' the people who are ruining our panth through their BAD ACTIONS. it is not about titles.
Even many people who use the title "Gyani" before or after their name have done horrible anti-gurmat actions, so is it fair for me to say to Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani stop using the title Gyani, because even whatever course you didn't doesn't qualify you to use it before OR AFTER your name, because you are not a true gyani at the calibre of puran gyani gursikhs from Sikh history. And stop using Arshi because no matter who you got it from, you are not from the Arsh (God's kingdom / heavens), you are just a normal human being. Because nobody is a Gyani but satguru, and nobody is Arshi but Satguru.
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
MANKIND · 19 Apr 2006
no..these goody goodies two shoes would be perfectly allright seeing a newbie fall into the trap of a fake baba than open their eyes...and say something...
you see i dont blame them one bit...they have been forcefed on a one way diet..no ninda..no ninda..even when they see Baba nanak's GURBANI telling..rajeh sheehn mukaddam KUTTEH...their reply is..oh baba nanak hai..aapean human haan...
Secondly their babas have ensured total silence and submission by forcefeeding fake tales like... a cow was running away from abutcher...and a sadhu saw it...so wehn the butcher asked him..have you seen my cow...the sadhu didnt say a word..but POINTED with his arm...and you know what Sangat Ji..in the Next Janam..His ARM was CUT OFF ( by the cow)..boloh satnaam..wekho..kitnee naam kamaii keetee..par sirf UNGGAL karan naala usdee baahn kattee gayee...boloh satnam...dekho kisseh wall bhull ke vee unggal na karnee..baahn kattee javegi...as Kabir would say....khatra khatra warning de ke.....baahn katavean kaon ??
Re: Akhand Kirtani Jatha calls for strict action against Deras and Babas
singh · 20 Apr 2006
Mr moorakh, the difference is them people do not pretend to be whiter than white. But these babas do!
It is these babas who loves their titles and prey on innocents. That is why they are worse than all.
moorakh wrote:
> I agree that there are many moorakh bhekhi Sikhs
> However, let me just ask:
> If they were called:
>
> or Bhai Piara Singh Bhaneriawala instead of Baba Bhaneriawala
> or Bhai Virsa Singh instead of Baba Virsa Singh
> or Bhai Mann Singh Pehowawale instead of Sant Mann Singh
> Pehowawale
> or Bhai Fake Sikh 1 instead of Baba
> or Bhai Fake Sikh 2 instead of Sant
>
> etc. etc. do you think they would do less harm?
>
> Aren't there just as many so called "Bhai's" who have raped
> Sikh women, stolen from the panth, done fraudulent things, etc.
> ?
>
> Aren't there police officers, farmers, army workers, doctors,
> and people from every background regardless of their title who
> have stabbed the Sikh panth in the world?
>
> What does the title have to do with it? We are not chasing the
> title. We are chasing the BAD ACTIONS and we should 'finish'
> the people who are ruining our panth through their BAD ACTIONS.
> it is not about titles.
>
> Even many people who use the title "Gyani" before or after
> their name have done horrible anti-gurmat actions, so is it
> fair for me to say to Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani stop using the
> title Gyani, because even whatever course you didn't doesn't
> qualify you to use it before OR AFTER your name, because you
> are not a true gyani at the calibre of puran gyani gursikhs
> from Sikh history. And stop using Arshi because no matter who
> you got it from, you are not from the Arsh (God's kingdom /
> heavens), you are just a normal human being. Because nobody is
> a Gyani but satguru, and nobody is Arshi but Satguru.