Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

AVTAR SINGH MAKKAR IN UK

AVTAR SINGH MAKKAR IN UK

JEEVAN SINGH · 08 Apr 2006

SGPC HEAD AVTAR SINGH IS IN THE UK FOR A FEW DAYS, HE HAS BROUGHT AMARJIT SINGH CHAWLA AND RAJINDER SINGH MEHTA I APPEAL TO ALL THE YOUTH GET TOGETHER AND PUT Q AND A TO HIM , THIS IS A RARE OPPORTUNITY FOR US TO GET HOLD OF THEM !! PLEASE TAKE THIS SERIOUSLY ! [%sig%]

Re: AVTAR SINGH MAKKAR IN UK

Gurpreet Sumra · 08 Apr 2006

Sikhs should get together and ask these and many other questions to Makkar in front of whole Sangat and he should be forced to respond 1)When he became SGPC head, his statement was published in all leading newspapers that he will not be involved in politics, then why is he now issuing statements in favour of Badal or against Amrinder Singh? 2)What is he doing to get Sikh Rehat Maryada be implemented in every Gurdwara, when it is not being implemented in Darbar Sahib 3)What is his stand against Sant Samaj, Derawaad, and dehdhari Gurudom? 4)Why was he issuing statements against Sarna? What was his motive?Was it not for Badal? Now Vedanti has let him go, so now what does he think about Sarna? Is Sarna again a Sikh or not? 5)What is the most recent development in French turban ban case?When he became head of SGPC on question by a reporter he replied I haven't read that case yet!!! 6)Why is he calling meetings against Spokesman and then using cheap language? Is it on the behest of Badal? If not, then what is the reason? If it is against Gurmat, then provide proof with full details where Spokesman has done anything against Gurmat 6)Why is he sharing stages with Dhumma and company when they dont accept Sikh Rehat Maryada? 7)Why did he attend Sikh Virsa Sammelan, even though he knew there will be anti Sikh jundli present and they even passed their self styled anti sikh resolutions , and what did he do after that? 8)What about Sikh politicaal prisoners, and army deserters in jail? 9)What is being done for 1984 genocide victims? 10)What is the criteria for the selection of Sewadar(jathedar) of Akal takht? 11)Vedanti is not fit as he is Badal's jathedar and he knows very well and majority of Sikhs and Sikh organization speaks against him, then why is he not being removed though Ranjit Singh was just removed like a flash? 12)Is service by Sikh women in Darbar Sahib anti sikh practice? If not then why it is not allowed? [%sig%]

Re: AVTAR SINGH MAKKAR IN UK

LK · 10 Apr 2006

He will be going to Panjab radio, today or tomorrow evening (UK time) www.panjabradio.co.uk shoot him with questions! Gurpreet Sumra, posed some excellent questions that need answerss

Re: AVTAR SINGH MAKKAR IN UK

singh who walked the walk · 10 Apr 2006

he came said fateh and left i belive. didnt wanta answer questions ... hmm

Re: AVTAR SINGH MAKKAR IN UK

LK · 11 Apr 2006

Yeah, I missed the program too, but from what I understand the presenters later on summarized that he said fateh and answered a few questions from the presenters. He requested everyone to stop using 'Makkar' since he has officially removed it.... No calls were taken at all. He was there for a very short time. Too bad. Snagat is requesting him to phone in and have a phone interview, so that sangat can call in and talk to him, like the Prof Darshan Singh vs Dhariya discussion thingy. Let's see what happens...

Re: AVTAR SINGH MAKKAR IN UK

LK · 11 Apr 2006

Yeah. Panjab Radio Managed to get hold if him on the phone. He was on his way to Derby with 'Powar'. He was reluctatant on doing anything on the phone on his way to Derby and said he would answer anything this time tomorrow, so Punjab Radio will be calling him again tomorrow (around 9 am UK Time). He asked those who wanted to ask him questions to write letters to him to his SGPC office lol. Doubt he'll ever answer. It was clear he was trying to escape. Anyway, a recording of the short phone-call has been made and can be listened to below - http://www.pure-panjab.net/Makkar.mp3 Again, please remember to listen and ask questions (after saying Fateh. lol) tommorow on Panjab Radio tomorrow (12 April 2006) around 9 a.m GMT (UK) Time. Be respectful but efficient.

Re: AVTAR SINGH MAKKAR IN UK

Stop the Manmat!! · 11 Apr 2006

Waste of time. He came to Gurdwara Singh Sabha East London and said that NRIs can bypass the ques at Darbar Sahib when they matha tek.

Re: AVTAR SINGH MAKKAR IN UK

JEEVAN SINGH · 11 Apr 2006

MAKKAR MADE CONDITIONS BEFORE HE WENT ON PANJAB / AKASH RADIO, HE SAID NO ONE MUST CALL IN AND NO POLITICAL QUESTIONS MUST BE ASKED !! LOOK AT OUR JATHEDARS THEY CAN'T EVEN TALK TO US AND THEY TALK ABOUT MORE INTERACTION [%sig%]

Re: AVTAR SINGH MAKKAR IN UK

MANKIND · 11 Apr 2006

cant you all get it..he came only for the money..pounds..lols....not answer your silly questions....vedanti has been pulling this same stunt for years..??? still dont get it ?? are we all that dumb ?? all they ant is our pounds and dollars.. give them....empty your pockets....and then shut the hell up. anybody aware that the two idots accompanying makkar are those who swore to defend darbar sahib along with jarnail singh bhinderawallh..but right on cue on june 4th they buried their weapons under manja..and went to longowaal and came out with hands up... read the tatement of dallewaal in punjab today.... UK singhs should do a joot parade of these cowards...instead of putting siropas around their filthy necks

Re: AVTAR SINGH MAKKAR IN UK

. · 12 Apr 2006

Came to Punjab Radio today. Answere petty quesitons like: 'THey didn't allow my car to pass at XYZ place" and "I didn't get parshad when manmohan visited" No real deal questions like "what about the SIKH REHIT MARYADA - who gave u permisison to edit it?" etc

Re: AVTAR SINGH MAKKAR IN UK

Manvir Singh Khalsa · 12 Apr 2006

Dear "." Bhai Sahib, Didn't Giani Amarjit Singh Gulshan (UK), who has written "Sikh Rehit Maryada Darpan" come on Panjab Radio and clarify that the Maryada has NOT been edited or changed by the SGPC. This was a short while after the allegations of change in the SRM were made by Gurcharan Singh Lamba. Giani Ji said the Panthic Scholars made appropriate changes after consulation in the 1940s, which were then approved by Sri Akaal Takht Sahib ji. However, no changes have been in the Maryada in recent years. If this is the case, as Giani Ji says, then I wonder why the SGPC do not issue a press release and clarify their position. Rab Jaane. Daas, Manvir Singh Khalsa

Re: AVTAR SINGH MAKKAR IN UK

LK · 12 Apr 2006

Dear Manvir Singh Jee, I misseed the program by Gyani Amarjit Singh Gulshan. If you have any recording it would be appreciated. SGPC of today have never been good in releasing press releases. When did they inform the sangat about the recent issue of handin over control of construction to UNESCO. Was any press release issued? What I meant to say is that it was disappointing that no major issues were raised about the PANTH, but petty issues like: 'You didn't allow my car to pass beyond XYZ point because it was over that time...' Very petty issues, to a man who should be questions with questions like: What are you doing to prevent the pbulishing of Guru Sahib saroops by private pbulishers? How mcuuh support are you showing to sevadars in London doing seva of not allowing Guru Sahibs saroop to go to banqueting halls (R4G campaign) All of the major issue were left out. Very disappointed, since I tried calling, but lines was jammed.