Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Thinking of taking Amrit this Vaisakhi? Be careful!

Thinking of taking Amrit this Vaisakhi? Be careful!

A Concerned Individual · 07 Apr 2006

VaheguruJiKaKhalsaVaheguruJiKiFateh! With Vaisakhi coming up, I am sure there are many Abhilakees who are getting ready to take Amrit and join the Guru's Panth. However, it is with regret that I also must make a warning to the Sangat and in particular those people who are searching for the gift of Amrit. With various Jathebandia and views in the Panth today, there are various Amrit Sanchars that are being organised and conducted, and the unfortunate truth of the matter is, that the situation in the Kaum today is not the same of that 300 years ago. Many small groups of individuals, attempting to gain power or respect have set up Amrit Sanchars which are quite simply not conducted in accordance with Gurmat. In particular, I would like to mention some of the frankly shocking accounts I have heard of selection for those who are put in the Panj Pyare. The Panj Pyare are meant to be representatives of the original Panj Pyare of 1699 and thus should be Gurmukhs of the absolute highest calibre; if the Panj Pyare are not Jeevan Wale, then the Abhilakees who take Amrit, will also have their spirituality stunted. Having done Veechar with various Gursikhs belonging to many different Jathebandi I have found that often those selected for the Panj are not at all appropriate for it. Whilst groups or dates do not need to be named; last year there were many Manmat Amrit Sanchars conducted. In one, Amrit was distributed to the general Sangat after the Amrit Sanchar, and in another, Sevadars still finishing High School or College were chosen for the Panj, having only taken Amrit a short while ago. In this instance the individual was not even strict in his Nitnem Rehat. In another, the Panj contained an young, unmarried individual who was at the time having a relationship with a girl, and did not keep Amritvela or Bibek Rehat. In that same Panj there was an individual who was seen by an Abhilakee, only days after the Amrit Sanchar, driving his car whilst listening to Bhangra music. These types of stories could continue on and on; the advice I would give to Abhilakees looking to take Amrit is not to be disheartened but do not be naive in their thinking. I would suggest if they are considering taking Amrit, they take it at an Amrit Sanchar organised by a large, well respected Jathebandi where plenty of Jeevan Wale Gursikhs are available for Seva. Organisations such as Akhand Keertanee Jatha and Damdami Taksal often organise Amrit Sanchars and I would advise candidates for Amrit to go here if they wish to be reborn in the Khalsa Panth. VaheguruJiKaKhalsaVaheguruJiKiFateh!

Re: Thinking of taking Amrit this Vaisakhi? Be careful!

... · 07 Apr 2006

A Concerned Individual is right. There are many amritsinchaars these days and most of them aren't according to Guru Sahibs Mariyada. AKJ organised Amritsinchaars however are very gurmat. [%sig%]

Re: Thinking of taking Amrit this Vaisakhi? Be careful!

... · 07 Apr 2006

It's also essential that the amrit sinchaar you go to has Lareedaar Saroop of Sri Guru Granth Sahib parkaash.

Re: Thinking of taking Amrit this Vaisakhi? Be careful!

**** · 07 Apr 2006

There was no Laredaar Saroop but Guru Jee still communicated with me during my Amrit Sanchar?

Re: Thinking of taking Amrit this Vaisakhi? Be careful!

... · 07 Apr 2006

****, I'm not sure if you're asking a question or making a statement. Lareedaar Saroop is Guru Sahib's saroop and should be on the Takhat during the amrit sinchaar. That is maryada.

Re: Thinking of taking Amrit this Vaisakhi? Be careful!

Gandalf · 07 Apr 2006

This raises a question in my mind: Is the amrit you shak tainted if your Punj are tainted...i.e. Would I be less of an Amritdharee (even if I follow everything Guru Jee says to a Tee) if someone who was in my Punj Pyaaray didn't... (My answer: No I wouldn't be less of a Sikh....)

Re: Thinking of taking Amrit this Vaisakhi? Be careful!

... · 07 Apr 2006

Bhai Rama Singh's had some pretty next level spirtual experiences with Guru Granth Sahib in pad-ched. Explain that? He had faith something we lack. We just speak in ego, he had gareebi.

Re: Thinking of taking Amrit this Vaisakhi? Be careful!

Jagdev Singh Rai · 07 Apr 2006

You know what, where's the faith in Guru Maharaj? In my opinion (and it is only my opinion) the Punj on the day represent Guru Ji. If an ablakhi has gone with sharda to Guru Ji then they will get blessed by Guru Ji. Sewa in the Punj is a bakshish from the Akal Purakh. We do not physically choose them, they are chosen by Maharaj because of some kamai somewhere along the line, be it in this life or another. If Guru Ji didn't want the Amrit Sanchars to take place, then I am sure they wouldn't! No one group/jatha has a monopoly on choosing the Punj or carrying out the Amrit Sanchar. They have all been given the sewa by Guru Mahraj. Yes, there are differences. But these differences are part of the Sikh world, and with Maharaj's kirpa they will be resolved!

Re: Thinking of taking Amrit this Vaisakhi? Be careful!

.====. · 07 Apr 2006

I dont like it when AKJ seem to think that they have a monopoly.

Re: Thinking of taking Amrit this Vaisakhi? Be careful!

... · 07 Apr 2006

Author: Kulbir Singh Date: 01-23-06 05:23 It's my humble opinion that our debate should be about asools and not about organizations. Whether AKJ or Jatha Bhindran or some other Jatha, the amrit organized by them would be judged by maryada they keep and not by the organization that does it. Amrit is not amrit just because AKJ organizes it or Jatha Bhindran organizes it. Amrit is amrit if it is prepared with full maryada. If there is an amrit sinchaar organized by AKJ or Jatha Bhindran and they don't keep the most basic amrit maryada, then I don't think such amrit can be classified amrit. First of all there must be the true Saroop of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. Secondly, there must be Punj Pyaray who are tyaar bar Tyaar Gursikhs and the ones who strive to keep full rehit. Thirdly they should follow at least the basic maryada of amrit. Here are some points to ponder upon: 1) If the saroop of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee is not there, can amrit sinchaar be done? I don't think so. 2) If there are only 4 Gursikhs and not 5 Gursikhs to do sewa in Punj Pyaray can such amrit sinchaar be valid? I don't think so. 3) If Sarblohi Baata and Sarblohi Khanda is not there can such amrit sinchaar be valid? I don't think so? 4) Punj Pyaray ask for heads at the time of amrit sinchaar. Before the abhilaakhis can go inside to give head, they must wear full baana including all kakaars and dastaar. If they don't wear kakaars, can their head be accepted or will they even reach that point where their head will be asked? I don't think so. They must wear baana to enter amrit sinchaar mandal. If they don't wear dastaar, can their heads be accepted? No way. this daas is of the firm determination that Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj would never accept a head without the dastaar or without kakaars. It may be acceptable if the Gursikh wears the dastaar but does not consider it a kakaar but accepts it to part of mandatory baana like many Nihungs and Taksalis do but to offer your nanga head without a dastaar and just covered with a thin chunni, is not acceptable. 5) If Punj Pyaray just give you Naam but don't implant it inside you or don't teach you how to japp Naam, how would you japp it? Without method, how do you japp Naam? Where do you focus your dhyaan? So it's best if Punj Pyaray teach how to japp Naam. 6) Punj Pyaray should give amrit and not "Ikk Pyara". In all organizations I have heard of, Punj Pyaray prepare amrit but in most cases, one one pyara imparts amrit to seekers. This is not correct maryada. The whole purpose of receive amrit 5 times in your mouth, 5 times in your eyes and 5 times in your hair is to enable each one of the Punj Pyaray do so. I know in AKJ this maryada is still going on. Some other jathas may have it too and they are dhan if they are maintaining this maryada. But most of them have lost it. If there are small differences in maryada we should ignore them but if a person chhaks amrit with totally non-maryada (e.g. Nanaksari, pakhandi saadh amrit like Kashmira Singh etc) then I think its fair for a rehitvaan Singh to not do roti beti dee saanjh with such person, not out of hatred but out of respect and love for Gurmat Maryada. Such statements like "Amrit prepared by all organizations is same" are nonsense statements. How can amrit prepared by a pakhand like pehowa be amrit? How can amrit prepared by adulturous saadhs be amrit? How can amrit given to women wearing makeup and earrings be amrit? Statements like "the whole Panth does this and majority does that" are naive statements. Are we to keep maryada according to what the majority position is? Majority of the so called Sikh diaspora is patit i.e. they cut their hair. Are we to say that cutting hair is okay? As the matter of fact, it has already been accepted by most people now. How can langar prepared by or served by a patit (a monna, or an adulturous or a tobacco eater) be acceptable to Khalsa of Guru Sahib? Foolish and sometimes malicious are those people who blame Rehitvaan Singhs for refusing such food and for condemning such activities at Gurdwaras. To call such langar as "Guru ka Langar" is nothing short of blasphemy. Langar or degh prepared by adulturers, monnay, tobacco consumers and kutha eaters cannot be classified as "Guru ka Langar". Bhul Chuk dee maafi. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Thinking of taking Amrit this Vaisakhi? Be careful!

... · 07 Apr 2006

I can't comment on what Bhai Rama Singh experienced or didn't experience, but maryada and rehit are principles that cannot be compromised. If someone compromises these principles it is wrong. Period. Laridaar Saroop is the form of Guru Granth Sahib. Pad-Chhed was not given Gurgaddi. All amrit sinchaars should have laridaar saroop during amrit sinchaars otherwise, that amrit sinchaar is missing Guru Sahib's presence.

Re: Thinking of taking Amrit this Vaisakhi? Be careful!

Singh · 07 Apr 2006

It is obviously much better for Lareevar Saroop to be Parkash but I personally still think Jyot of Guru Sahib resides in Padh Chedh Saroop. If a Veer or Bhain doesn't believe that Jyot resides in Padh Chedh, then they will not Matha Tekh to Guru Sahib when they go into the Divan Hall, which I do not think many people will agree with. I would personally still believe the Jyot of Guru Sahib resided in a Saroop even if Padh Chedh occured in all the wrong places as flow of the actual written Gurbani is still the same. I still believe the Jyot of Guru Sahib is in the various old Puratan Saroops even though there are various mistakes and errors.

Re: Thinking of taking Amrit this Vaisakhi? Be careful!

... · 07 Apr 2006

small misprints and scribe-mistakes can be overlooked, but not when the very form of Guru Granth Sahib is changed based on the manmat of some publishers. Pad-chhed should be respected but the Gurgaddi was given to Lareedaar saroop.

Re: Thinking of taking Amrit this Vaisakhi? Be careful!

Jagdev Singh Rai · 07 Apr 2006

Just a question. What should then happen to the thousands of Pad-Ched Saroops out there? Will they be cremated like Birad Saroops are? Everyone talks about LadiVaar Saroops but no one says how we should implement the Saroops back into our Gurdwaras. What happens to all those Pad Ched Saroops? I believe Guru Ji's jot resided in these Saroops too!!

Re: Thinking of taking Amrit this Vaisakhi? Be careful!

... · 07 Apr 2006

I think its pure manmat to say pad-ched hasn't got jot of Guru Sahib in side it. LaReedaar is a style of writing. All the hukamnamas were written in this way. Also other texts were written in this way. What to do we do to laRedaar? We pad-ched it with our minds thats how we read it. Whats the harm if it is already been pad-chedded for us because we havnt got that same Gurbani knowlege they had back then. For God sakes we cant even decide if there should be bindis in Sasas and Jajas how are we going to anything else about Gurbani? Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh's books got published and they had Gurbani in them which had also been pad-chedded. Bhai Sahib accepted will of Vahiguru and let it be. Let me ask who is your Guru? Is your Guru the style of writing? Didi Guru Gobind Singh give gugaddi to a style of writing? No he never gave gurgaddi to a style of writing. Guru Nanak says Pavan aru(n)b satgur mat vela || Shabad Guru Surat dhun chela. The giyaan, the shabad, the surat on the shabad is the Guru. Ones who say laReedaar and only laReedaar is the True guru are spirtualy weak. Period. [%sig%]

Re: Thinking of taking Amrit this Vaisakhi? Be careful!

other ... · 07 Apr 2006

spiritually weak eh? Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh who called pad-chhed maha-manmat was spiritually weak? Baba kartar Singh Bhindranwale who said it was "atee-ant manhaa" or totally forbidden was also spiritually weak? The harm for pad-chhed is that it's done. You don't consider it, it's fed to you. If someone read the pad-chhed, and it's wrong, the person will usually not consider the other versions. Whoever believes that pad-chhed is alright is a victim and believer of Maha Manmat.

Re: Thinking of taking Amrit this Vaisakhi? Be careful!

murakh · 07 Apr 2006

On a side note Please please Can those gursikhs who always say in favour of Ladivar sroop and against pad-ched explain why Guru Nanak Dev Ji favoured panjabi language and gurmukhi script to convey his message to the masses and not Sanskrit? What was wrong with Sanskrit? Then and only then talk about ladivar or pad-ched saroop. I have been reading this argument for a very long time. Please explain. Admin please do not block this post otherwise this is not an open forum.

Re: Thinking of taking Amrit this Vaisakhi? Be careful!

Singh · 07 Apr 2006

We should only do full Matha Tekh to Guru Sahib so if a Veer or Bhain does not see Guru Sahib's Jyot in a Padh Chedh Saroop, they should not Matha Tekh it. I am not sure if you do this personally but I have seen many people who are strong proponents of Lareevar happily do Matha knowingly to Padh Chedh and thus accept it as containing the Jyot of Guru Sahib. To me "ikonkarsatnamkartarpurakh", "ik onkar satnam kartar purakh", and "ikon karsa tnamk artarp urakh", All have the same underlying meaning and form. I treat them all the same, whether they are handwritten, printed, Lareevar, Padh Chedh, etc. The last one may be completely wrong in terms of where the words are split but it is still the same sequence of Gurbani. Did Bhai Sahib and Baba Ji explicitly say that there is no Guru Jyot in Padh Chedh? It is obvious that Padh Chedh is Manmat - just like it is Manmat a scribe accidentaly made mistakes in writing Puratan Saroop - but I don't think Bhai Sahib said that this does not count as Guru Jyot. No one is suggesting Padh Chedh is acceptable, it is a huge Beadbi and I am completely pro-Lareevar; but I think what people are taking issue with is the idea that when they Matha Tekh, they are not Matha Tekhhing to the Guru.

Re: Thinking of taking Amrit this Vaisakhi? Be careful!

other ... · 07 Apr 2006

Why did Guru Sahib not use Sanskrit? Let me reverse that. Why WOULD he use Sanskrit? It's not a divine language, and there would be no reason to use it. If you're equating laridaar and sanskrit saying that both are ancient and not practical, I suggest you inform yourself a little more. If you do pad-chhed differently, the meanings change completely. Lareedaar is not at all hard to read and doesn't involve learning any new skill, just practice.

Re: Thinking of taking Amrit this Vaisakhi? Be careful!

Guroo!! · 07 Apr 2006

Bhai Rama Singh had next level experiences in which ped chad saroop was present. He actually seen the ten guroo's present in the saroop!

Re: Thinking of taking Amrit this Vaisakhi? Be careful!

... · 07 Apr 2006

Well instead of siting on a phorum and saying whatever you want to say, why don't you go to Akaal Takhat and made a stand. The problem is we say Guru Sahib should be laReedaar etc but do we really care about Guru jee? Do we actually stop the manmat things that go on? The answer is no because we just want to sit on our chairs infront of computers and not do nothing for the panth but write essays on phorums. Go do something for the panth.

Re: Thinking of taking Amrit this Vaisakhi? Be careful!

other ... · 07 Apr 2006

Dear Guroo! If pad-chhed saroop is "maha-manmat" according to Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh, what differences does it make if someone had experiences through it? I don't claim that Pad-chhed saroops don't deserve respect. I know people who have had amazing experiences through gutkas, pothis, shasters etc. that doesn't make them Guru. Would it be ok, if I took the bani and re-arranged it by Guru and bhagat? Should that saroop still be parkash? If I can't alter Guru Sahib that way, then why do you thing it's ok to break all the words according to some scholar or publisher's mat? What to do with all the pad-chhed saroops? Leave that up to the Panth together. I dont know nor is that up to me. What are we doing for this issue? Singhs are lobbying Akal Takhat Sahib regarding this issue. But telling the public is an important step. I have heard because of this very effort to inform people, Lareedaar Saroop has been parkaash at Rexdale Gurdwara in Toronto.

Re: Thinking of taking Amrit this Vaisakhi? Be careful!

LK · 07 Apr 2006

Veer jee '...' If a Larridhar saroop has a few spelling mistakes (which is pretty common) Would the Guru be there. Sicne the exact saroop wasn't the same number of angs size of saroop and the spellings isn't EXACTLY the same - would it be acceptable? (I am an advocate for larridhar, just asking for your view on this matter)

Re: Thinking of taking Amrit this Vaisakhi? Be careful!

other ... · 07 Apr 2006

Almost all saroops (and certainly all printed saroops) have some printing errors or others. This isn't a big deal. But when you change the entire form of bani, it's a different story.

Re: Thinking of taking Amrit this Vaisakhi? Be careful!

Guru Ji is Guru Ji · 08 Apr 2006

Waheguru ji ka khalsa,Waheguru ji ki Fatehh! All I would like to share is, if you go inside to give your head... YOU DO NOT think of WHO those Punj are, when there is that deeeeppp desire, yearn for those drops, You see Guru Gobind Singh Ji in the Punj. When you one heartedly focus on Guru Saheb Ji, that sweetness from Baani is not restricted to Guru Saheb Ji's Saroop. Its all about LOVE, AND HOW MUCH LOVE and THIRST YOu have. WAHEGURU!! :'( agree the choice has to be given to those Who have kept Rehit and AmritVela intact. Please do not discourage those who want to take Amrit. Those filled with the deep desire to take Amrit, NO MATTER WHERE YOU TAKE IT FROM... You can recieve what you want. "JIS NO AYAA PREM RAS TISAY HI JARNE" Waheguru ji ka khalsa, Waheguru ji ki Fatehh! [%sig%]

Re: Thinking of taking Amrit this Vaisakhi? Be careful!

LK · 08 Apr 2006

So, change the number of angs on the saroop isn't changeing the form of abni, sice now different hukamnamas appear, thtan those that used to appear in the old saroops without a specific amout of angs in the saroops

Re: Thinking of taking Amrit this Vaisakhi? Be careful!

murakh · 08 Apr 2006

Author: other ... says panjabi and gurmukhi are divine language and script. How and why? If You think they were invented by sikh guru you are wrong. Panjabi language existed before Guru Nanak ji. Baba Farid ji used pure panjabi language and he was born few hundred years before Guru Nanak ji. Kabir ji in "wawaan akhri" used letters of panjabi. Guru Nanak Ji used panjabi because it was the language of the masses and sanskrit was the manopoly of few. Same thing is happening now with this argument of larridar saroop. Guru's message is for all not for few. Where does in SGGS ji mentioned that Gurbani must be written and read in larridar manner. You are saying that larridar saroop contains guru's "YOT" anybody how is unable to read panjabi have no right to have Guru's darshan. Gurbani is divine only because it is narrated in panjabi and gurmukhi. Think again. In macca guru ji did not use panjabi but local language but wil you call that bani divine or not divine.

Re: Thinking of taking Amrit this Vaisakhi? Be careful!

nvtaij · 08 Apr 2006

then does this mean i have made a false promise with my guru? ..i have not taken amrit? i have taken amrit from a fake guru? we are only to bow to our guru...and so i have been going against this principle?? please help...as i am not what i thought i was

Re: Thinking of taking Amrit this Vaisakhi? Be careful!

singh · 08 Apr 2006

wjkk wjkf i wanted to ask for any dates of akj smagams in the next year in delhi oramritsar or anywhere in punjab somehow or even in england. but only next year i would be very thankful 2 u wjkk wjkf

Re: Thinking of taking Amrit this Vaisakhi? Be careful!

A Concerned Individual · 08 Apr 2006

"Those filled with the deep desire to take Amrit, NO MATTER WHERE YOU TAKE IT FROM... You can recieve what you want." Again as I have originally stated, this is true in theory but in practise, I have many people who took Amrit at Manmat Amrit Sanchars fall out of Sikhi, yet generally those who have taken it at Gurmat orientated ones, stay strong in their Rehat and Naam Abhiyaas in the long term.

Re: Thinking of taking Amrit this Vaisakhi? Be careful!

MANKIND · 10 Apr 2006

a GOOD STUDENT will always excel...no matter what school he was registered for.. a Useless student will FAIL..no matter what prestigious school he enrolled in.... Thousands upon thousands of really excellent sikhs were non akj/taksali whatever.... many thousands of akjs/taksalis are good for nothing bhekhis... a good for nothing enrolling in harvard/cambridge will still fail miserbaly..a good student in a public university can become a Nobel Prize winner.... Panj/PAHUL is just the beginning...the result is in the FINISH LINE..the ones crossing the Finish Line COUNT..no one asks where they first started running..... the ones who never reached the finish line..can shout all they want as to which Panj gave them the starting whistle....the Bottom line is they Never FINISHED..or crossed the winning line..