Ramgharia Gurdwaras
Not Ramgharia · 30 Mar 2006
The weird thing is there was an application for a Gurdwara the other day in Surrey for a Ramgharia Gurdwara.
I find it shocking and appalling, people would name a gurdwara after your caste, like name it after a Guru Ji or something, but why name it after your caste.
Will non-ramgharia's be able to partake in langar or going to diwan hall? I mean, its getting to a point when you say to a person, my religion promotes equality among people and you have individuals in our community who do the other thing.
I just find all these gurdwaras are just being built for power or control over a minor fraction of our community, its turning into one big joke. I am all for gurdwaras, but its not so that we can develop our youth, its all just this big ego stroke for the pardan and the guys who make it so they can make money off people. I guess like they say in marketing, find a target market and exploit.
Re: Ramgharia Gurdwaras
Bhagwant Singh Virk · 30 Mar 2006
Khalsa ji
Ramgarhia is not a name of a caste but the name of a misil from a golden period of Sikh history. Just like all other misils it was made of Sikhs from many castes. Therefore to behave as a caste is going against not only Sikh religious principles but also against the historical basis of the misil itself.
To have the name of Ramgarhia Gurdwara just like Baba Deep Singh Gurdwara or other historically figure based Gurdwara names is not wrong as long as it is based upon the principles of Sikhism, and caste plays no part
WJK,WJF
Bhagwant Singh Virk
[%sig%]
Re: Ramgharia Gurdwaras
Harcharan Singh · 31 Mar 2006
Not that it matters, as all the misledars were not entagled in caste - hence members of all occupations being dominant in all misls and being land owners prior to the British land owning rules..
Sardar Jassa Singh Ji has commonly been refered to as Tocca Singh by historians who visited Punjab during the misle period (mid to late 1700s) i.e. Francis Xavier Wendel. Tocca was a common reference made to people from a labour intensive background who used hammers. It is most likely that Sardar Jassa Singh Ji was actually a Lahaar (Blacksmith). although otherhistorians have refered to him as a carpenter.
Sardar Jassa Singh Aluvalia Ji has been refered to as Calaal Singh, calaal refers to inn-keeper/distiller, but obviously Sardar Ji's parvaar left this occupation upon receiveing Guru Ji's darshan, most Sikh Calaals actually found other means of income, which is why Aluvalias are so successful in numnerous business sectors today.
Another Misledar has been called Tchersa Singh (leather worker).
Most of the mahaan shaheheed that were executed in Delhi alongside Banda Singh Bahadur were said to be of so called low caste i.e. choorai, chumaar etc.
All this just goes to show that caste had no relevance in the old days, caste was reinstituted/glorified by the British during various projects i.e. army recruitment, land owndership, various census etc..
They did the same thing all around the world, teh Rwanda genocide of 2 million people no so long ago was a result of caste creation by teh Europeans before they evacuated the congo, and left hand picked light skinned natives in charge.
As for the Gurdwarai, it's very uneducated to blame any one party for the division in Gurdwarai, as all are to blame.
Many Singh Sabhia Gurdwarai did not let non-jatts in management, a trend started in the early to mid 1900's in India which spread around the world.
So called lower castes were discriminated against in this way, hence setting up on their own.
Obviously, 2 rights don't make a wrong, so they are also to blame.
But I have noticed in recent times, as the older guilty generation is dying off, that the more educated younger people are ridding the caste element, it is not long before caste basis will finally be eliminated and Singhs from all types of historical occupations will be invloved in all Gurdwara i.e. Singh Sabha, Ramgharia etc...
Slowly the surnames are disappearing, and the true name given by Dasmai Patshah is taking precsedence again, Singhs are looking as one again in dastaar and banaa, all differences are disappearing, it's only a matter of time before the caste diseased people are vanquished from Guru Ghar forever!
Waheguru
Re: Ramgharia Gurdwaras
blenddacastes · 01 Apr 2006
i have to admit when i go ravidas temple they have a lot of respect when they see singhs as if their graced and humbled by the sight of sikhs. This is the kind of love that all sikhs should strive to have and bring a harmnonious atmosphere to any gurdwara and encourage more.
But ramgharia two sides, on one theres seva being done and less political atmosphere more chilled but i have seen the constituition of ramgharia gurdwaras and i am personally disgusted by the fact non terkhaans cannot join on the political front of seva but the seva that does exist is excellent and i have seen minimal clashes.
I have no knowledge if ravidas lot have the same consituition that bars non chamars.
The reason behind barring and selecting members of certain caste appears to be in counter reaction to singh sabha corryupt politics or in other words percieved jatt domination.
Now what is the point of creating a caste system in black and white inside a gurdwara? Surely ramgharia gurdwara (and ravidasis if they do the same) would really promote sikhism, heal rifts, and bring to the surface true sikh teachings if they actively declare members of all castes welcome and represent everyone. This can be achieved through selective eligable voting ie rehtdhari lokh.
Let us say democracy and elections is ganth. Now whats wrong with the committees selecting even most of their own members and even a few non caste members to just send even a tiny message out that they are reforming their constituition for a start? and perhaps side by side hold kirtan programmes and darbars, workshops jointly as to promote equality and ekta.
It can become a better situation if we all agree we have mistakes and weaknesses and work on building a divine bridge together.
its such a shame that a lot of nice spiritually inclined people end up divided into this stupidity from childhood and thus invisible walls created with the divinity of sikhism on one side and the ugliness of temporary cultural honors and prejudices holding people back.