Re: Debate!!!
Moorakh Mugad Eean · 29 Mar 2006
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Wahegur Ji Ki Fateh!
Alot of medicine doesnt even state what it contains. Many cough and cold medicines contain alcohol, but they dont say so on the bottle...
And who knows where other types of medicine come from and what they contain. Most capsules are made from Gelatin, and it wouldnt surprise me if many other medicines are animal derived.
I think the real question is "where do you want to draw the line?". Which is of course an individual decision.
From what little i know, we arent allowed to indulge in intoxicants. But on a medical basis i dont see what the problem is. For example, morphene is used as a painkiller when one has had surgery. Yet we wouldnt deny that to someone on the grounds that its an intoxicant.
At the same time it would be wrong for someone to take morphene for whatever high they get out of it.
I would say that within the strict context of medical use, it is ok, but anything beyond that is not.
Re: Debate!!!
Moorakh Mugad Eean · 29 Mar 2006
How did this turn into a 1984 debate? It started out being a question about medicine...
Das Soora Ji, i have read many of your posts and respect your opinions, but let us not forget that non of us can say for sure how we will respond when death looks us in the eye.
Non of us were there on that day and non of us can say for sure how we would have responded, i think it is unfair for us to belittle those who were there. It is for Mahraj to judge.
Guru Nanak Dev Ji showed Daya to everyone. Guru Harkrishan Ji showed so much Daya that they took the Dukh of others onto their own shareer. Guru Teg Bahadur Ji gave their life in the Daya they showed to the Hindu kaum. Dhan Dhan Guru Gobind Singh Ji showed daya by forgiving the 40 Mukte. The first of Panj Pyaare was Bhai Daya Singh Ji...
Examples of Daya are endless in the History left to us by our Gurus. So how can we say that Mahraj wouldnt forgive us or XYZ were "So Called" Singhs? These things are for Mahraj to decide.. we have not the capacity to forsee or judge what they will or will not forgive.
Daya Karro Bhaee Sahib...
Re: Debate!!!
........... · 29 Mar 2006
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji kee fateh
i think guru ji has the heart to forgive u but its the way u take it that really matter as someone said alchol is just chemicals mixed together and wut if those same chemicals were mixed in a medicine do we say it had alchol in it its not like to put the alchol u drink in it i understand sikhi is more important than life but talk is cheap how many of us would really chooses to die then to live when death comes to u it hard to say no to anything and then the death angels freak u out but its not like guru ji gonna be like u not my sikh no more u drank medicine to survive guru ji has a big heart to forgive us and to love us if i made any mistakes pleazz forgive me
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji kee fateh
[%sig%]
Re: Debate!!!
dalbir singh shergill · 31 Mar 2006
didnt guru arjan dev ji give alcohol to sick people
i think he did to help ease the pain of the cuts and all
i know it to be true i have seen a drawing of it in one of those calendars
well the whole people being sick even though they were so attached to god
well its all karma from ur past life
like my guru ji from rishikesh got hurt once running
why did he get hurt even though he is so attached to god "bharamgyani"
it is explained that u have karma from past life and that u have to bogh or say that u have live thru that karma whteve it might be like bad or good karma.
even though ur guru can decrease the bad karma to a very small one u still have to bogh it. that is the rule of the akal purka
for example my dad who was in service of the guru - mahant baba ram singh ji
he had to go to delhi with a friend to get money back
so when he was gone leave he came to guru ji
guru ji was explaining at that point that it is more paap for the people who in there right mind yell obsenaties, then it is for a intoxicated person because they arent in the right mind. and he went on explaning that a guru can lessen the bad karma. (meaning make a big paap in to a small one but u still have to go thru it)
so he said that like these 2 (my father and his friend) who are going to delhi wht if they meet so roudy drunk people who yell at them. they should not yell back because it is bigger paap for them. so they leave for delhi
and when they finally get in a train box (this is around 1989) they find them selfs in the midts of drunk high rank military officers
they start yelling obsenaties at them as soon as they see them
they like " get these sikherdo out of here"
this and that, my dad says they did this because at that time there a few bomb blasts somewhere
so they go to one of the entrances of the box and my dad sit on one of the steps. and they take turns like that
at night on one of the stations whlie my dad was sleeping and sitting on one of the steps of the train box both of his feet get caught between station and train
he is barely able to get them out but when he gets them out in like a min there is this huge pool of blood
his foot had a cut where u could see the bone. imagine if it were not for gurus grace wht could have happened. he could have lost both of this feet
so they bring him back to where the officers were sitting and this time they say nothing
and with gurus grace the guy sitting next to him is a doctor.
my dad tell me that when he got of the train the foot hurt so much that he could not walk out of the train station to the rishka.
vaheguru vaheguru
[%sig%]
Re: Debate!!!
dalbir singh shergill · 31 Mar 2006
no it said in under the picture that he served alcohol to ease the pain because so had limbs to be cut off or something like that
Re: Debate!!!
dalbir singh shergill · 31 Mar 2006
or it could have been that he was putting alcohol on the wounds to clean them out