What am I to make of Sikh history books?
Geezer · 28 Mar 2006
Can someone give me some advice. I enjoy reading and am interested in my Sikh roots although I am far from perfect. I have been reading of late to help me gain a better understanding of Sikhism, Sikh history and Panjabi culture in general. I believe in a general level of free speech (not open disrepect though), but I'm finding some of the books contradicting what I was taught about Sikhism and History from my family. I purchased a book by MCleod about the rehat and was really shocked by what it contained especially about the 5 Ks. The issue of vegetarianism is another confusing issue. And I was shocked to hear that some Nihung Singhs have taken opium and marijuana (even my parents confirmed this!) What am I supposed to make of these things? I also listen to dhadhi and katha which helps restore balance. What do you all think of modern scholarship? On the one hand it seems good and on another......not good.....I don't really want to hide myself from anything that is true, even if it is uncomfortable but .......