Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

True meaning of cold Ishnaan

True meaning of cold Ishnaan

akj wannabe · 21 Mar 2006

waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh I just wanted to know what was the meaning of taking a cold shower in amritvela ? Does it say this completely neccesary in any quotes? I have heard from some people that they take a freezing cold shower every morning so they are able to remain fully awake during the hours of amritvela. But when i wake up in the morning, and im really tired, so i decide to take a cold shower, i feel fresh and awake whilst i wash my body and kesh, but then about 5 - 10 minutes later, im fully tired again. Is the meaning of taking a cold Ishnaan really to just wake you up in the mornings? Or is there some other definition.... waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh [%sig%]

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

singh · 21 Mar 2006

use common sense. guru jee wouldn't want you to have a "freezing" ishnaan, then catch a cold, end up sneezing throughout nitnem and coughing throughout naam abhiyaas.

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

Kuljot Singh · 21 Mar 2006

************************************************************ Does it say this completely neccesary in any quotes? ************************************************************ [gurbani]TMfy pwxI jo nih nHwvY ibn jp pVHy pRswd ju KwvY ][/gurbani] Those who do not take their morning bath in cold water and those who eat before their Nitnem infringe the Rehat. Bhai Nand Laal Ji (Rehatnaama) -kuljot singh

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

Gangsta · 21 Mar 2006

"guru jee wouldn't want you to have a "freezing" ishnaan, then catch a cold, end up sneezing throughout nitnem and coughing throughout naam abhiyaas." So we shouldn't have cold ishnaan because we might catch a cold during amrit vela ?

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

amarjeet singh · 21 Mar 2006

no we should have a cold shower not a freezing cold shower

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

Gurpreet Singh · 21 Mar 2006

Seriously, A sikh of Guru Sahib Should use their buddi.... You do whatever that works for you. If you take a warm shower and you aren't tired and you are fully concentrating on your nitnem thats fine. If a cold shower works for you thats fine too. Don't limit yourself to rules....I personally have my moods...sometime a cold shower works sometimes a warm shower works.....all in all its Guru sahibs who makes you do nitnem with concentration not the cold or hot water :). Gurpreet Singh

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

... · 21 Mar 2006

If you're going to use your own mat to decided things like when to take a cold shower or not, then why not use your own mat to decide whether to take a shower at all. Maybe on some days you might not feel the need? If you are ill then I can understand taking a warm shower, but otherwise a cold shower is required. What is the reason for avoiding a cold shower? It's just laziness.

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

Gurpreet Singh · 21 Mar 2006

haha are you for real? its not called using your own mat its called common sense bhai/bhen .... ji, Guru sahib Isn't an evil being sitting on a throne with a big sword waiting for us to slip up so he can chop us...these little things don't mean anything...we should do ardas that he makes us get up at amritvela and take a shower and give us the pleasure of reciting his elahi bani :)

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

Kaur · 21 Mar 2006

>these little things don't mean anything...we should do ardas that he makes us get up at amritvela and take a shower and give us the pleasure of reciting his elahi bani :)< A fortress is built from using little bricks. Likewise, the kamaee of a Sikh is built using the building blocks of Naam, Bani and rehit. It is these little things that add to the big picture. Someone might think it is common sense to no longer keep their kesh or wear a kirpan because apparently we do not need it anymore. I would rather listen to gurmat (cold shower) rather than to my mind, or manmat (i.e. so called common sense)

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

Gurpreet Singh · 21 Mar 2006

You got my words all mixed up Bhainay but its all good..whatever works for u :)...to each their own

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

LK · 21 Mar 2006

Author: Kaur Date: 03-21-06 12:13 >these little things don't mean anything...we should do ardas that he makes us get up at amritvela and take a shower and give us the pleasure of reciting his elahi bani :)< A fortress is built from using little bricks. Likewise, the kamaee of a Sikh is built using the building blocks of Naam, Bani and rehit. It is these little things that add to the big picture. Someone might think it is common sense to no longer keep their kesh or wear a kirpan because apparently we do not need it anymore. I would rather listen to gurmat (cold shower) rather than to my mind, or manmat (i.e. so called common sense) -------------------- 1- I very much doubt that it is authentical, since there wern't even resources in the time to BATHE IN WARM WATER - how can they ask you to have a COLD SHOWER, when hat is the only thing you could have back in the time. The concept of bathing in warm water did not EXIST, since the resource did not exist. 2- It is indeed practicel to bathe in lukewarm water to wake up, but t go to the extent of bathing in ice cold water, (which the Singhs probably didn't even do in the summer, when bathing in Darbar Sahib, or some river!!!!)

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

... · 21 Mar 2006

LK, Well said. If it doesn't fit your beliefs, it MUST be fake. All authorities on Bhai Nand Lal Rehitnama inlcude this injunction as verse 25 of the rehitnama. Furthermore, the injunction for COLD water is repeated in Muktinama verse 9 "If you bathe with cold water in the last watch of the night and share with others what you eat, then, say sGuru Gobind Singh, the angel of death cannot ensnare you". And even beyond that, Prem Sumarag Granth says the same thing about cold water. The common book "Gurdwaras" by Patwant Singh has a picture of a hand written Prem Sumarag Granth which you can go see for yourself which says clearly that a Sikh should bathe with cold water but if for health reasons it is not possible, he may use warm water. So are all three sources non-authentic?

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

Roomie · 21 Mar 2006

Just a question, if i shower with hot water in the morning but i still do my nitnem and simran at amritvelaa...am i going to hell?

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

..... · 21 Mar 2006

LK wrote : "The concept of bathing in warm water did not EXIST, since the resource did not exist" >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> "since resource did not exist" ......hmmmm im pretty sure that humans discovered fire well before our Guru Ji's time

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

... · 21 Mar 2006

Roomie, Yes you are. Ok, seriously for a moment though, if you don't follow the hukam to use cold water, it's likely that even though you're doing amritvela simran and nitnem, you're not getting as much out of it as possible. So if you're doing the rest, why not do this as well? I don't see why there's opposition to cold water? It's healthy and it's a tradition. Why would you NOT want to do this besides just laziness? If you're doing the rest, why not do this little thing as well?

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

ks · 21 Mar 2006

when did bhai nand lal become elevated to Guru status?

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

sk · 21 Mar 2006

Try to live and take Ishnan the body wants. These people AKJ and other Egoist say something and do something else in their life. Nobody will come on your rescue, once you fall sick. The, you will stop taking bath and may stop reciting Gurbani. Eh Ta Kush na kush bolde rehande ne. Enjoy life, enjoy Gurbani. Gud lu Satnam kaur

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

just me :) · 22 Mar 2006

Thank you satnam kaur, you were very helpful!

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

Daas Soora · 22 Mar 2006

VaheguruJeekaaKhalsa vaheguruJeeKeeFateh Well said Bibi Sahib ‘Kaur’ Jeeo. Bhai Sahib ‘singh’ Jeeo I cannot believe you even said. Bhai Sahib ‘LK’ Jeeo don’t always try to be logical about Guru Jee’s Hukam, just learn to obey and love his Hukam, as this rehitnama by Bhai Nand Lal was accepted by Guru Jee, and so if it was accepted by him then we also have no choice but to accept it. Bhai Sahib ‘ks’ Jeeo, Bhai Nand Lal Singh become one with Vaheguru Jee, so why wouldn’t ever Guru jee accept the rehitnama made by him, obviously something like that wouldn’t be accepted from someone like me, a mere human. Bhai Nand Lal Jeeo wasn’t any ordinary being; he was god-like, angelic and had an extreme spiritual wisdom, which is something that every Sikh needs. Bibi Sahib ‘sk’ jeeo these AKJ valae have accepted nearly every Hukam given by Guru Jee, and especially tapoban valae, which have accepted every Hukam. These people have a lot of love for Guru Jee, so please don’t look at the negative side or may I say faults of these people, but the goodness within them. Sangat Jeeo, I've been having a freezing cold shower for a long time now, and I've never ever caught a cold from doing so, but in fact it's helped my concentration at amritvela greatly. By living in these western countries we've made our body weak, lazy and inadaptable to the easiest tasks given by Guru Jee. Make your occupation to serve Guru Jee. Furthermore, Bhai Sahib ‘akj wannabe’you said that you still feel tired at amritvela even though you’ve had a cold shower, this could be, that’s if you do, watch movies/TV or waste your time on the internet, as these tools used by Maya make the mind lazy. Remember that the mind is controlled by the five demons inside of the body, and so by doing these things you’re strengthening the demons, and so they have the ability to take control over your mind and body. It’s either you or the demons that will have the most control over the body, so let it be you. There’s no other reason for why you should be tired at amritvela, and another thing, in the evening you could jap naam for at least an hour to help your concentration at amritvela. Make sure you also go to sleep on time, but not to early and not the late. Forgive me for any mistakes. Daas Soora VaheguruJeeKaakhalsa VaheguruJeeKeefateh

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

SINGH · 22 Mar 2006

LionKing, are you intellectually challenged? The resource for warm ishnaan didn't exist back then? Do you know what 'resource' is required to heat water? A little thing called fire. I believe it's been around for thousands of years. Perhaps you believe that hot water can only come out of a tap. Ever think of how people in villages without running water take warm baths? Think before you try to make smart comments. sk, you've probably never showered with cold water. Which is why you have no clue about getting sick with cold showers. Unless you decide to stay in the shower for an hour and get hypothermia, it isn't going to make you sick. I've sneezed much more often stepping out of a warm shower into the colder air than stepping out of a cold shower. In fact, I don't think I've ever sneezed coming out of a cold shower. It feels quite good.

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

ks · 22 Mar 2006

as "angelic" bhai nand lal was, he does not dictate rehat for me. Only the Guru, Granth and Panth, do that.

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

Daas Soora · 22 Mar 2006

VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFateh Well believe what you like Bhai Sahib 'ks' Jeeo, but all these sants that have gave out these rehits, which are in fact all apart of knowledge that they attained from achieving spiritual wisdom, have japped an immense amount of Naam. These beings become one with Vaheguru Jee, and within everything Vaheguru Jee created is himself, and so Bhai Nand lal Jeeo became apart of all this, so these tips of knowledge are basically from Vaheguru Jee to make it easier for us to reach Saachkhand as well. naanak dhaas eihai sukh maagai mo ko kar sa(n)than kee dhhoorae ||4||5|| Nanak, Your slave, begs for this happiness: let me be the dust of the feet of the Saints. ||4||5|| Gurmukhs are saints and even Guru jee has told us to search for them to purify ourselves; to gain knowledge and understanding is to learn from these saints. Guru Nanak Dev Jee has placed these saints in such a high status that even he says that he wishes to be the dust of these saints. So if he can accept these saints so why can’t we, are we higher then Guru Jee or something that we can’t even understand what he sees in them – is it our ego, laziness, what it is?. sa(n)th sehaaee praem kae ho thin kai laagaa paae || The Saints are the helpers of the Lord's lovers; I fall and touch their feet. These saints are here to help us reach Saachkhand, as stated in the above Gurbani line, as they have experience in doing so, so they pass on their knowledge onto us. You all just want to look for as many excuses as you can. Daas Soora VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFateh

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

ks · 22 Mar 2006

there have been millions of saints throughout the ages. Should we take all the edicts they pronounce as the word of god? my spiritual inspiration comes from the Gurus, not saints. According to their philosophy, taking a cold shower or a warm one is irrelevant. They taught us that the only thing that mattered (spiritually) was honest, authentic, genuine love for god and a similarly driven bairag. Not cold showers. Not bana (yes, temporally this matters in terms of identity, but not spiritually). Not bibek. so, keep searching your sants and mahants for spiritual guidance in the form of worldly acts if you wish to disregard the Gurus message.

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

... · 22 Mar 2006

ks, I'm sure you are a very spiritually bairagi individual who doesn't need to see the example of other Gursikhs who have pleased the Guru. I'm sure you have a spiritually coloured life. I can guarantee you one thing though: someone who disregards Gursikhs, disregards bana, bibek and other rehits can NEVER have a spiritual jeevan. Such a person is an egoist who can talk about spirituality but never experience it.

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

Fateh Singh · 22 Mar 2006

Fateh jio, The idea of cold water doesn't necessarily mean freezing cold, ambient air temp is fine or luke warm. When singhs use to bathe back in teh day they never had showers. The would pour some water over their bodies, soap up, and then wash the soap off. If you are using cold water in this fashion its fine, as your core body temperature doesn't change, as the water hits you and washes off you, your skin returns bak to its normal temperature. IF on the other hadn u shower with freezing water this is very bad for you. you are constantly bombarding your body with water well below your bodies operating temperature and this in turn forces your core body temperature to lower. Although it is only a slight amoutn it causes other reactions in your body. People get hypothermia by swimming in freezing water, we are not far off by showering with it. Theres a big difference to how ishnaan was done bak in the day as compared to how it is done now.

Re:

... · 22 Mar 2006

Fateh Singh, There's nothing wrong with taking "cold" cold showers. Of course I don't mean the kind of cold water that is ice-cold, but "very cold" is fine. You'd have to stay under the water for quite an extended period for it to lower your body temperature. Otherwise, the very benefit of the cold water is that it causes your body to increase circulation to warm against the water. Do a simple search on the internet and you'll see that cold water is really good for you.

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

mehak · 22 Mar 2006

Dear ks for your own life, u have no guarantee, and you are taking the guarantee for others. Let him lead the life, he wants to live. Unnecessary poking the nose. MAAT SAH AWEI KE NA AWEI RAAM - Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji Mehak

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

.. · 23 Mar 2006

!can guarantee you one thing though: someone who disregards Gursikhs, disregards bana, bibek and other rehits can NEVER have a spiritual jeevan." so kabber jee, sheik fareed jee and others neevr had a spiritual jeevan you shouldnt talk about things you dont know fully about your statement is so deterministic...who made you the knower of everything?

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

ks · 23 Mar 2006

'...' should talk less of the jeevan of others, and try to understand that cold showers are nothing more than ritual. A ritual is an action without reason. No one has offered a *reason* for cold showers in this entire thread, other than someone said so. can anyone offer a reason?

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

ks · 23 Mar 2006

mehak, don't you realize how hypocritical you sound?

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

... · 23 Mar 2006

ks, cold water makes you alert and causes blood flow to increase in the entire body making amrit vela more productive. Warm baths are used to put people to sleep. It's a common therapy for insomnia. If the reason isn't clear and you still want to chant "ritual ritual", that's your perogative. I always am amused by people like this. I have yet to meet a Kala-Afghana-ite who is a spiritual Gursikh or even one who has gotten up at amrit vela for the day.

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

ks · 23 Mar 2006

'...' has told me that I can never have a spiritual jeevan, and now he/she accuses me of being a 'kala-afghanite.' That amuses me. Moderators will censor any minor thing, but personal attacks seem to be par for the course. Onto the crux: so you're basically saying that you use cold water showers/baths as a crutch? Because otherwise your simran/nitnem would not be as productive. This is sad. spiritual prowess and concentration should flow from within, not be caused from without. Using your logic, why not do your nitnem outside of the house? The cold will surely help increase your concentration! Or after you exercise! Blood is certainly flowing then. dr sahib, if warm water put people to sleep there wouldn't be market for sleeping pills. @_@

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

... · 23 Mar 2006

ks, I use cold ishnan as a crutch as much as I use kakaars and bathing in general as a crutch. Next you'll be telling us ishnan in general is a "ritual" and who needs it? I'm sure you're at the bairagi avastha where sleep has no effect on you, but most people do feel sleepy at amrit vela getting out of bed. Cold water wakes us normal people up. (it's also a Sikh tradition as was shown with rehitnama references). A lot of people do nitnem outside of the house as well because it's easier to focus as opposed to sitting on the bed when sleep tempts you. Finally, warm baths and hot milk are all natural remedies for insomnia. Some people need pills, but your argument is senseless. Just because some people need pills, means warm baths AREN'T used to treat insomnia as well?

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

SINGH · 23 Mar 2006

ks, You speak about Bhai Nand Laal Singh Jee like he's some guy off of the street. He is one of the most respected gursikhs of Guru Saahib's time. His writings are accepted by the Guru Panth as authentic descriptions of Guru Gobind Singh Jee and Guru Jee's rehit. If this gursikh's writings, who stayed in Guru Gobind Singh Jee's darbar and recorded Guru Gobind Singh Jee's rehits, isn't enough for you, than nothing that anyone here says will be enough. You have no understanding of rituals and gurmat. People like you, who don't see a rational reason for it, call kakkars, amrit sanchaars and even nitnem, rituals. But then you know better than Bhai Nand Laal Singh Jee and the Guru Panth that accepted his writings as authentic and accurate. Who are any of us blind followers to question an enlightened thinker like yourself?

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

ks · 23 Mar 2006

your ishnaan as ritual argument only works if there is no reason behind bathing---but there clearly is, to stay clean. sikh tradition is pointless unless it's a rehat from the Guru. According to tradition we farmed the land. Do you see people running out to raise their spirituality through farming? seriously, give up the insomnia/warm water link, it's not going anywhere. It's a placebo.

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

mehak · 24 Mar 2006

Pyari sangat jee, The temperature of the body differ person to person and place to place, besides there are many environmenal changes, since this system was established. Financial and physical system were different. Tension and IQ were different. Medical research were different earlier. Just to say and apply everything the same for everyone does not carry any weight. KS has given valid reasons. satnam kaur (sk) has also given a nice advice, important is your nitnem, it is not important, how you take bath with cold water, lukewarm, hot etc. Nam japo gursikho, nam japo. Guru bhala kare. MEHAK

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

LK · 24 Mar 2006

----------------------- There's nothing wrong with taking "cold" cold showers. Of course I don't mean the kind of cold water that is ice-cold, but "very cold" is fine. ---------------------- Who determines how cold is "very cold"? What if you only get lukewarm? Are you abandoning the hukam then? -------- Author: ... Date: 03-21-06 14:00 LK, Well said. If it doesn't fit your beliefs, it MUST be fake. All authorities on Bhai Nand Lal Rehitnama inlcude this injunction as verse 25 of the rehitnama. Furthermore, the injunction for COLD water is repeated in Muktinama verse 9 "If you bathe with cold water in the last watch of the night and share with others what you eat, then, say sGuru Gobind Singh, the angel of death cannot ensnare you". And even beyond that, Prem Sumarag Granth says the same thing about cold water. The common book "Gurdwaras" by Patwant Singh has a picture of a hand written Prem Sumarag Granth which you can go see for yourself which says clearly that a Sikh should bathe with cold water but if for health reasons it is not possible, he may use warm water. So are all three sources non-authentic? ----------------------------------------- 1 - As I'm not at home tha moment, I cannot respond to your first two paragraphs, but the fact that there are three soruces (perhaps even moer) doesn't say anything, just like every rehitnama talkign about eating taboos talks about Kutha, and not maas (pretty much 99% of them atleast) - Will you accept that? Will you accept that many many Rehitnamey talk about a forth Kurehit being having sex with a muslim women rather tha, outside and before marriage - will you accept that? The amount of sources saying something, does not mean anything, as far as I'm concerned. As of cold water, if it had any spiritual meaning at all, it would have been written in Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj, the 'khajana' or treasure Spirituality, and about the eternal. This is not done. ------- Author: ..... Date: 03-21-06 14:11 LK wrote : "The concept of bathing in warm water did not EXIST, since the resource did not exist" >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> "since resource did not exist" ......hmmmm im pretty sure that humans discovered fire well before our Guru Ji's time --------- LionKing, are you intellectually challenged? The resource for warm ishnaan didn't exist back then? Do you know what 'resource' is required to heat water? A little thing called fire. I believe it's been around for thousands of years. Perhaps you believe that hot water can only come out of a tap. Ever think of how people in villages without running water take warm baths? Think before you try to make smart comments. ---------- They did have fire, but does this mean they had inside heating? No. Just because they had fire doesn't mean they were like us, i.e. heated water on their "top-modern" stove before showering (atleast some of us =D) Just because they discovered Fire doesn't mean they realised everything they could do with it. Again look into history, and let me know if there was ANYBODY in that time that EVER showered in warm water (whether in Europe, China, Signapore, Canada or whatever). No matter how advanced a people were, they NEVER bathed in hot water - because resources were not there. --------- Bhai Sahib ‘LK’ Jeeo don’t always try to be logical about Guru Jee’s Hukam, just learn to obey and love his Hukam, as this rehitnama by Bhai Nand Lal was accepted by Guru Jee, and so if it was accepted by him then we also have no choice but to accept it. --------- I disagree. Guru Sahib gave us a lesson by turnign down his 'teer' at someones grave. H ewas testing his Khalsa, but his Khalsa used LOGIC, and THOUGH "Hey what is he doing?" and even PUNISHED HIM FOR REVERING THAT GRAVE. THere is no place in Gurbani that the phenomenon of bathing in cold water was accepted. If Guru Ji rejected other materialistic things, I doubt he would adopt this ------------ Bhai Sahib ‘ks’ Jeeo, Bhai Nand Lal Singh become one with Vaheguru Jee, so why wouldn’t ever Guru jee accept the rehitnama made by him, obviously something like that wouldn’t be accepted from someone like me, a mere human. Bhai Nand Lal Jeeo wasn’t any ordinary being; he was god-like, angelic and had an extreme spiritual wisdom, which is something that every Sikh needs. ------------- See, what some people don't realise is that the Rehitnamey we have today are not originals. They are copies of copies of copies of copies. They are NOT the original ones that Bhai Nand Lal Ji wrote. Here read other things the modern rehitnamey include: :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: Do not rob a wayfarer. Do not blow out a lamp [instead of extinguishing it with your fingers]. Do not extinguish fire with water from which you have been drinking. [22, 37a] ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: What is, how to extinguish fire, doing in a rehitnama of the Khalsa? Bahman influence? Most likely. ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: Do not accept a Turk as your master (see ch. 7.13, pp. 219-23). Do not salute a Turk. Avoid meat cooked by Turks. A Khalsa fights against Muslims. A Khalsa slays Muslims. [15, 22a, 29,, 44a, 51, 54] ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: The above quotes are brought from the Tankha Nama attributed to BHai Nand Lal- will you accept it? *********** ks, cold water makes you alert and causes blood flow to increase in the entire body making amrit vela more productive. Warm baths are used to put people to sleep. It's a common therapy for insomnia. If the reason isn't clear and you still want to chant "ritual ritual", that's your perogative. I always am amused by people like this. I have yet to meet a Kala-Afghana-ite who is a spiritual Gursikh or even one who has gotten up at amrit vela for the day. ************ This does not require ice cold *freezing water*.

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

ks · 24 Mar 2006

again, people like SINGH want to extend my thoughts on cold water bathing to other *rehat defined* actions in Sikhi like amrit or nitnem to make me out to be some sort of "kalaafghanite." is it not getting through? There is no rehat, given by the Guru, that requires you to bathe in cold water! and I'm repeating myself, but it's not sinking in so I feel I must: no matter how enlightened bhai nand lal is, he was *not* a Guru. Bhai randir singh was *not* a Guru. Only Gurus give rehat and maryada to Sikhs. Try to open your eyes to this!

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

... · 24 Mar 2006

ks, where did Guru Sahib give rehit? Is it in a Granth you have access to? Bhai Nand Lal writes a conversation he had with Guru Gobind Singh, what more directness are you going to get? But please do tell where you get the direct info on what rehtis Guru Sahib gave to Sikhs...is it not from other Sikhs or do you have some direct source?

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

SINGH · 24 Mar 2006

LK said, 'They did have fire, but does this mean they had inside heating? No. Just because they had fire doesn't mean they were like us, i.e. heated water on their "top-modern" stove before showering (atleast some of us =D) Just because they discovered Fire doesn't mean they realised everything they could do with it. Again look into history, and let me know if there was ANYBODY in that time that EVER showered in warm water (whether in Europe, China, Signapore, Canada or whatever). No matter how advanced a people were, they NEVER bathed in hot water - because resources were not there.' Yes, LK, there were many people throughout history that took warm baths. Which history have you been looking at? Where'd you go to school? Most civilisations discovered warm baths thousands of years ago. The chinese, the romans, even the Natives of North America were using forms of warm bathing. The comment about people a few hundered years ago not realising what they could do with fire is utterly.... stupid. You're trying to say they didn't realise they could heat a bucket of water? Have you ever been to a place where they don't have 'inside heating'? Villages in India and even some places in the west. They still take warm baths. LK, everybody knows there are strange 'rehitnamay' out there. So what? You're now trying to place Bhai Nand Lal Jee's into the same category? Is this some new LK discovery? The rest of the panth even allows keertan of Bhai Saahib's writings. But LK has decided that these writings are fake... based on the fact that some other random rehitnamay might be fakes. That's some truly logical and enlightened thinking. I suppose you don't wear a kirpan or kara either, since these aren't mentioned in Gurbanee. Do you believe in anything that the patshahees not mentioned in Gurbanee did? ks, you don't have to bath every day to stay clean. Especially if you haven't been doing anything strenuous. Every other day would be fine as well. And you don't have to bath in the morning either. But gurmat says we should bath every day, early in the morning. So, ks, could you give us a source for rehit written by Guru Sahib? Where do they tell us what nitnem to do? Or tell us about the kakaars? Do you realise that the Gurus barely penned anything themselves? Others recorded what they said. Bhai Nand Laal Singh Jee wrote down what Guru Saahib recited. But perhaps you want a personally signed document, with a seal from a government official or lawyer, before you'll accept it. If we follow your logic, there will be no rehit and no panth. No Khalsa.

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

ks · 24 Mar 2006

SINGH and '...' are forgetting the other Guru, the Khalsa Panth. What more do I have to say? The rehat maryada was created by the Panth. It contains our collective wisdom wrt Sikhi regarding worldly affairs.

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

Sengh · 24 Mar 2006

cold ishnaan is great fun (except if its completely freezing or its freezing in winter) you jokers who dont like it just havent tried it

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

LK · 25 Mar 2006

Author: SINGH Date: 03-24-06 17:09 LK said, 'They did have fire, but does this mean they had inside heating? No. Just because they had fire doesn't mean they were like us, i.e. heated water on their "top-modern" stove before showering (atleast some of us =D) Just because they discovered Fire doesn't mean they realised everything they could do with it. Again look into history, and let me know if there was ANYBODY in that time that EVER showered in warm water (whether in Europe, China, Signapore, Canada or whatever). No matter how advanced a people were, they NEVER bathed in hot water - because resources were not there.' Yes, LK, there were many people throughout history that took warm baths. Which history have you been looking at? Where'd you go to school? Most civilisations discovered warm baths thousands of years ago. The chinese, the romans, even the Natives of North America were using forms of warm bathing. The comment about people a few hundered years ago not realising what they could do with fire is utterly.... stupid. You're trying to say they didn't realise they could heat a bucket of water? Have you ever been to a place where they don't have 'inside heating'? Villages in India and even some places in the west. They still take warm baths. -------------------------------------------- There's a difference between taking a warm bath in a warm lake, boiling water for eating, and actually BATHING in warm water which has MANUALLY Been heated. Unless you can prove that ANY civilization used to MANUALLY HEAT IT (not the naturally watm water) to get a nice and cozy bath, i refuse to believe you. ---------------------------------- LK, everybody knows there are strange 'rehitnamay' out there. So what? You're now trying to place Bhai Nand Lal Jee's into the same category? Is this some new LK discovery? The rest of the panth even allows keertan of Bhai Saahib's writings. But LK has decided that these writings are fake... based on the fact that some other random rehitnamay might be fakes. That's some truly logical and enlightened thinking. I suppose you don't wear a kirpan or kara either, since these aren't mentioned in Gurbanee. Do you believe in anything that the patshahees not mentioned in Gurbanee did? ------------------------------------- 1- I have clearly provided some Rehitnamas by Bhai Nand Lal Ji. Will you concur the above and take them as Gurmat. Just because a Rehitnama says something (whether it's one by Bhai Dya Singh ji or BHia Nana Lala, they have to be observed very carefully) I have not said thta all rehitnamey are fake, and neither to I suggest that they are. But many are. If you can say that the Rehitnamas I provided in my previous post are Gurmat, I will accept that the taking of a cold bath is compulsary. The above are only two of the dodgy rehitnamey. I gave give u atleast 10 more from Bhai Nand Lal Ji's writings. Am I suggesting tht all of them are false? No, I'm suggesting that a lot of them are. --------------------------- ks, you don't have to bath every day to stay clean. Especially if you haven't been doing anything strenuous. Every other day would be fine as well. And you don't have to bath in the morning either. But gurmat says we should bath every day, early in the morning. ---------------------------- Eh, most human beings, (majority non-sikh) have a bath every morning - does tha make them Sikhs? --------------- So, ks, could you give us a source for rehit written by Guru Sahib? Where do they tell us what nitnem to do? Or tell us about the kakaars? Do you realise that the Gurus barely penned anything themselves? Others recorded what they said. Bhai Nand Laal Singh Jee wrote down what Guru Saahib recited. But perhaps you want a personally signed document, with a seal from a government official or lawyer, before you'll accept it. If we follow your logic, there will be no rehit and no panth. No Khalsa. ------------------- There are several rehitnamas talking about the above mentioned. It's just that our humai and jathebandi din't allow us to believe the the nitnem/kakkars mentioned in the rehitnamas...

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

... · 25 Mar 2006

LK, tell me which rehitnama gives the full list of kakaars and nitnem? At any rate, the approach to rehitnamas is that if there is somethign in them that isn't clearly against Gurmat and is repeated in a number of them, it probably was a rehit. Cold water falls in this category. What are you arguing about? No one is asking you to go and bathe in freezing water, just cold. The benefits have been listed. If you don't want to, then fine. You are one person I've noted who argues for the sake of argument. It's a really horrible habit.

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

SINGH · 25 Mar 2006

LK, I have very little time today to waste on your ignorance, so I'll just paste some text describing warm baths of the past. You seem educated but your intelligence is obviously lacking something if you honestly believe that hot baths are an invention of the 20th century. First, the Romans, over 2000 years ago. "Homer and other Greek writers, tell us the Greeks favored a variety of baths, from hot water tubs to hot-air baths, or laconica. It is believed the people of Laconica, the ancient region of Greece whose capitol was Sparta, conceived the idea." This excerpt is from Marco Polo's writings from the 1200's, describing Chinese baths. "It is true that they have plenty of firewood, too. But the population is so enormous and there are so many bath-houses and baths constantly being heated, that it would be impossible to supply enough firewood, since there is no one who does not visit a bath-house at least 3 times a week and take a bath - in winter every day, if he can manage it. Every man of rank or means has his own bathroom in his house....so these stones, being very plentiful and very cheap, effect a great saving of wood." This last one is about how Muslims grew addicted to hot baths and started the tradition of the hammam during Muhammed's time. (1400 years ago) "Until the hammam caught Muhammed's fancy, the Arabs used only cold water and never bathed in tubs, which was considered as bathing in one's own filth. But when the conquering Arabs encountered Roman and Greek baths in Syria, holy men immediately adopted the pleasure of hot air bathing (perhaps to compensate for the joys of alcohol forbidden by their faith). When the Arabs captured Alexandria in 642, they reportedly heated the Roman baths for six straight months with pergaments and papyri from the fabulous Ptolemaic Library. As many as 700,000 works may have been burned. As the Arabs picked up foreign bathing habits, they were quick to tailor them to their own ways. The hammam gained religious significance and became an annex to the mosque, used to comply with the Islamic laws of hygiene and purification. Physical and intellectual development was deemphasized, and only the massage remained. Once the delight of the warm water sunk in, the cold water bath or shower after sweating no longer appealed to the Arabs." These pieces of text were found using a simple internet search. Before making such stupid and easily refutable claims in the future, do a GOOGLE search. It will save everyone from the hassle of having to deal with such ignorance. Now, was this your main point for rejecting this hukamnaama? Or are you now going to pull something else out of your magic hat?

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

LK · 26 Mar 2006

Author: ... Date: 03-25-06 06:18 LK, tell me which rehitnama gives the full list of kakaars and nitnem? At any rate, the approach to rehitnamas is that if there is somethign in them that isn't clearly against Gurmat and is repeated in a number of them, it probably was a rehit. Cold water falls in this category. What are you arguing about? No one is asking you to go and bathe in freezing water, just cold. The benefits have been listed. If you don't want to, then fine. You are one person I've noted who argues for the sake of argument. It's a really horrible habit. ------------------------------------ 1- Something repeaed in several rehitnamas does not necessarily mean anything. Kutha also falls in this catagory. Will you accept that? I think not. I was mistaken about the hot baths. I apologize, thanks for that text 'SINGH', I've learnt something new :) As for rejecting te rehitnamas (not hukamnama), I have several other issues with it, however since I'm going to be bombarded, and accused for having a habit to argue for the sake of it, and not because I think something Is Gurmat or Manmat, I really see no point. I really don't see a point since no matter how much Gurbani or other reference is provided, some people will not change their opinion no matter what, so I really don't see a point. Apart from that a lot of my posts arn't being allowed on the board when trying to refute someone's points, probably because bias of the admin. Pretty hard to discuss in these circumstances. Bhull Chukk maaf

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

SINGH · 26 Mar 2006

LK, there is no gurbani reference against taking cold baths so I doubt that you can provide one. You also mentioned in a previous post that most humans take a daily bath so 'does tha make them sikhs?' Firstly, most humans (at least in the West) didn't start taking daily baths until the 20th century. It was considered strange and by some, even unhealthy, to bathe daily. A requirement for daily baths was quite unique back during the Guru's time. Secondly.... well there is nothing else really to comment on. Your point wasn't really even a point. You were just trying to be smart. Unfortunately, you failed miserably. You keep talking about kutha. I don't think anybody has any issue with the appearance of this word. The issue is the definition of the word. Is it a synonym for halal or not? '...'s point about determining the validity of hukams from rehitnamay is quite valid and quite widely accepted in the panth. You've challenged this approach but other than your kutha point, haven't provided anything to back your view up. Taking cold baths is a rehit and something that everyone should try. It seems difficult for a while, but a hot bath at amrit vela can't compare with a cold bath. You can scream 'ritual' all you want, but your words are empty and not backed up by gurbani. Unless you've kept this rehit for some time, you're opinions don't really qualify for much. You're trying to be experts on something you really know nothing about. The words of great gursikhs (who recorded the bachans of our gurus on this topic) and the traditions practiced by jeevan vaalay gursikhs through the history of the panth count for a lot more than the kala-inspired rants of some cyber-sikhs.

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

LK · 27 Mar 2006

--------------------------------- Author: SINGH Date: 03-26-06 20:04 LK, there is no gurbani reference against taking cold baths so I doubt that you can provide one. --------------------------------- Neither can I find any saying that Cold baths will help you in your atimac jeevan, is Spiritual life. Now, Gurbani si the treasure of spirituality, and atmic things, so ´how anc why would Gurbani forget to mention this? Am I againt cold baths? No, as a matter of fact I do acknowledge that it is good for you in the sense that it wakes you up. On the other hand I do not see it as a compulsion for a Gursikh to stay at the Charan of the Satguru, to NEED to take a cold bath. -------------------- You also mentioned in a previous post that most humans take a daily bath so 'does tha make them sikhs?' Firstly, most humans (at least in the West) didn't start taking daily baths until the 20th century. It was considered strange and by some, even unhealthy, to bathe daily. A requirement for daily baths was quite unique back during the Guru's time. Secondly.... well there is nothing else really to comment on. Your point wasn't really even a point. You were just trying to be smart. Unfortunately, you failed miserably. --------------------- Right again, however, please re read what '...' jee wrote- ************ --------------------------- ks, you don't have to bath every day to stay clean. Especially if you haven't been doing anything strenuous. Every other day would be fine as well. And you don't have to bath in the morning either. But gurmat says we should bath every day, early in the morning. ---------------------------- Eh, most human beings, (majority non-sikh) have a bath every morning - does tha make them Sikhs? ************** '...' jee was talkiing about not having to take a bath every day to stay clean. I disagree, and most hard-core hygienists (if there is such a thing) would agree, that in order to stay clean, and remove sweat, and other stuff it si fundamental to have a showever everyday to remain clean. We are talking about today 'SINGH' jee, not about a few hundred years ago, how they used to think that you don't have to shower everyday. You have by yourself refuted '...' jee's point about not needing to shower daily to be clean and healthy, since a lot of people died due to not showing daily, before. ---------- You keep talking about kutha. I don't think anybody has any issue with the appearance of this word. The issue is the definition of the word. Is it a synonym for halal or not? ---------- Ask, Bhai Kahn SIngh Nabha, Bhai Vir SIngh, Prof Sahib Singh, Surinder SIngh Kohli. They will tell you ------------------- '...'s point about determining the validity of hukams from rehitnamay is quite valid and quite widely accepted in the panth. You've challenged this approach but other than your kutha point, haven't provided anything to back your view up. -------------------- I can provide 100's of rehitnamas talking about many many hindu rituals, such as Khalsa being there to protect the Brahmins. Khalsa not being allowed to kill black cows. I can provide a rehitnama telling us that the Kachera of the Sikhs comes from Hanuman (Bhai Daya Singh Rehitnama) Kutha was only one of th emany issues I imagened some people would have with the Rehitnamas. The point on determining the validity of a hukam from Rehitnamas CAN NOT be determined on the amount of times it has been writen. In that case you should believe that having Sex outside marriage is NOT the Curehit, but the Kurehit is in havign Sex with a Muslim women (several rehitnamas out there say this) ---------- Taking cold baths is a rehit and something that everyone should try. It seems difficult for a while, but a hot bath at amrit vela can't compare with a cold bath. You can scream 'ritual' all you want, but your words are empty and not backed up by gurbani. Unless you've kept this rehit for some time, you're opinions don't really qualify for much. You're trying to be experts on something you really know nothing about. The words of great gursikhs (who recorded the bachans of our gurus on this topic) and the traditions practiced by jeevan vaalay gursikhs through the history of the panth count for a lot more than the kala-inspired rants of some cyber-sikhs. ------------ 1- I fully concur that having a cold bath is a very good thing, since it makes you active and really makes you wake up in the morning, something warm baths, do not do. 2- I do not believe this to be a rehit, or a must for a Sikh. 3- Whether I have/am practising this (what you call) 'rehit' or not is none of your business, since I don't see any point in bragging around which Rehits I practised/have tried and which I have not. All I will tell you is that I see it benificial to do so, but not mandatory. 4- Unforunatly if it was so simple as "The words of great gursikhs (who recorded the bachans of our gurus on this topic) and the traditions practiced by jeevan vaalay gursikhs through the history of the panth count for a lot more than the kala-inspired rants of some cyber-sikhs." there wouldn't be any controversies would there? Unforunatly these words of Great Gursikhs (indeed, I have no doubt about them being just that), have been modified by a lot of people with the intention of dissolving our kaum into bahmanism, which makes everything a lot more complicated, hence why we've got 'Words of Great Gurmukhs' saying that Hanuman was the one who blessed us with his kachera (I have full reverse for the person who reportedly wrote this, but I sincerely do not believe those words belong to the author, but someone who ahd modified it) As you are probably aware, there are many modification in the rehitnamas, and thus I believe we should use Gurbani as our basis for everything, and if that makes me kala-inspired (yeah right!), then so be it. Bhull chukk maaf

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

SINGH · 27 Mar 2006

LK, you can provide hundereds of rehitnamay, but these won't pass the validity test mentioned by '...'. Your comments on daily bathing still make no sense. Nobody will die of bad hygiene by missing a couple of days a week. Your point about cold showers not being endorsed by gurbanee as a means of increasing atmic jeevan is worthless. Most rehit isn't mentioned in Gurbani. The Guru Khalsa Panth isn't even mentioned in Gurbanee. Nor are our kakkaars. Gurbanee isn't a list of our rehits. You need to understand the double aspect of sikhi, the panth and granth, miri and piri, etc. Nobody disputes that kutha is used in rehitnamay. Once again, the dispute is about the meaning of this term. The individuals mentioned by you will give their opinions (highly regarded opinions in some cases) but this doesn't set the meaning in stone. This then has nothing to do with what the rehitamaa says, or about accepting the rehitnama, but about interpreting the rehitnama, which is something different.

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

LK · 22 Apr 2006

---------------------------- Author: SINGH Date: 03-27-06 16:47 LK, you can provide hundereds of rehitnamay, but these won't pass the validity test mentioned by '...'. Your comments on daily bathing still make no sense. Nobody will die of bad hygiene by missing a couple of days a week. Your point about cold showers not being endorsed by gurbanee as a means of increasing atmic jeevan is worthless. Most rehit isn't mentioned in Gurbani. The Guru Khalsa Panth isn't even mentioned in Gurbanee. Nor are our kakkaars. Gurbanee isn't a list of our rehits. You need to understand the double aspect of sikhi, the panth and granth, miri and piri, etc. Nobody disputes that kutha is used in rehitnamay. Once again, the dispute is about the meaning of this term. The individuals mentioned by you will give their opinions (highly regarded opinions in some cases) but this doesn't set the meaning in stone. This then has nothing to do with what the rehitamaa says, or about accepting the rehitnama, but about interpreting the rehitnama, which is something different. --------------------------------------- 1- Is my approuch of using Gurbani as a reference to every spiritual thing on this planet is worthless? I sincerely believe that anything no mentioned in Gurbani cannot and will not have a spiritual affect. As you mention, most rehits are not in Gurbani. WHy? Because most of them are for PRACTICLE purposes rather than SPIRITUAL. I believe it's chaupa Singh Rehitnama which talks about how a man is to urinate. So now the way or urinating will also have a spiritual efect will it? I'm not saying many rehits do NOT have spritiaul benifit. Wakiing up Amritvele is a Rehit, which is spiritual, BUT it is also mentieond in Gurbani about 'Gursatgur ka jo Sikh Akhay so Palkey uth har Naam Deyay' That is a Spiritual Rehit. Many Rehits are for PRACTICLE purposes, and NOT for spiritual resources...Sometime we need to realise this.Sometimes we shoudl acknowledge that some things are strictly practicle and have no spiritual benifit. Again, I do acknowledge that cold showers can wake you up, but it aint gonna get you any closer to Satyug/Sackhand/liberation. At All. If you sing Shabads while showering in cold water, ti's goign to be as benificial as doing it in warm water. Most people do not dispute the meaning of 'kutha', only those who are hard-core against the defintion 99.9% of the scholars give try to dispute it. There is no dispute whether Kutha means hallal or meat. The dispute is whether maas or Kutha is a Kurehit. The validity test by '...' jee is: ::::::::::::::::::::. At any rate, the approach to rehitnamas is that if there is somethign in them that isn't clearly against Gurmat and is repeated in a number of them, it probably was a rehit. Cold water falls in this category. ::::::::::::::::::::: clearly against Gurmat. Are we united about what is for or against Gurmat? What you call Gurmat is not what Taksalis agree about Gurmat. What Taksalis think about Gurmat is not your view of Gurmat. Someone does toofs, and multiple Akhand Paaths, or reads some bani as a mantra while doing Akhand Path, someone starts yelling their heads off thinking they'll get spiritual benifit. Someone believes that Gurmat is to take bhang, someone thinks singing Dharna is Gurmat to attract followers, someone thinks giving Amrit on Batch to increase the amount of Amrit someone has given to someone is Gurmat. For You Gurmat is very different than what Gurmat is for a Taksali, Akhand Kirtani, SGPC-er, Nanaksariya, Rara Sahib vala. My point: Unless we unite under the banner of the sovreign institution of Akal Thakhat, and do no sit like brethren and discuss these issues, there's not point in talking about what Gurmat is or not. We can discuss and agree or disagree, but what is clearly against or for Gurmat is very different in every Single Jathebandis view. There is very little that is clearly against Gurmat. To Discuss whether kirtan shuold be done in Raag you can sit and discuss till you face goes blue, yet to me, clearly that is Gurmat, Since it is the mat of the Guru, and Sikhs at the time of the Guru did Kirtan in Raag and wrote bani in Raag, and divided Guru Sahib in RAAG, to me that is clearly Gurmat. Yet I'm sure many of my brethren on this phorum will disagree that non-raag hyped up Kirtan is OK. So what is Gurmat? To me Gurmat is in accepting Raag Kirtan, other will due to their opinion disagree. Fair enough. Bhull CHukk Maaf

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

A Singh · 26 Apr 2006

A cold shower provides many benefits – for full details do a search on a 3HO website as I’m fairly sure they’ll list most of it in full together with some weird and wonderful yogic implications. That is one side of the coin. The other, surprisingly enough is not too different to what LK is suggested – yes of course one can “heat” up water but this is hardly going to be the most likely events if one for a moment places themselves in a kutcha mud hut in a 18th century Punjabi village occupied by three generations of relatives. What it does relate to is the notion of using fresh water (which naturally would be cold) and not that which has been lying around in a tub from the previous few days or weeks (and used by other members of the family – as was the case in the Europe prior to the establishment of in house baths). What does this mean for us today – well simple, a daily shower/bath is essential and one should strive to be healthy in body and mind as well as spirit (i.e. hygiene, diet, exercise, paath, simran, seva etc) and also that perhaps we should understand that when texts are written in poetic formats they are unlikely to provide caveats and qualifications to the statement! Also consider the time at which the text was written. As per the implication of the type and temperature of water – well, clearly there are physiological benefits to having a cold shower, however I see no need to get fundamental or hung up on this one minor point and in any event this is not mentioned in the Sikh Rehit Maryada, of course as we have seen on many posts already today people like to discriminate between ‘different’ types of Amritdharis on the basis of their particular ‘brand’, however that is their choice.

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

d · 13 May 2006

ok ks so if ypu only listen for rehits from the gurus then does that mean that you ignore what the panj pyaare tell u do when u take amrit? please enlighten me as daas does not no nything vaheguroo ji ka khalsa vaheguroo ji ki fateh

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

.... · 13 May 2006

some people go so far to justify their own shortcomings......

Re: True meaning of cold Ishnaan

min jeeta · 20 May 2006

I don't have cold showers as I get asthma afterwards.