Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad
praatun singh · 20 Mar 2006
WJKK WJKF
I was wondering what tapoban's views are on Sri Raag Mahala and why tapoban does not beleive in it? And is this proof that it doesnt exist all start from Bhai Sahib Bhai Randeer Singh? or did other singhs bring this up in the past?
WJKK WJKF
Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 21 Mar 2006
This is not a "spelling mistake"... I have come across many youngsters who think Sri Raag Mahalla is "raagmala" ??? One even questioned me..asking i have sat through your First Raol..and I heard you CLEARLY READING SRI RAAG MAHALLA..... for nearly 2 hours..and yet you always declare that YOU dont beleive in Sri Raag mahalla as Gurbani ???
????????????????? surprised..you bet
Jarnail Singh....
Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad
Dhur ki bani aaeee... · 21 Mar 2006
Yes, Bhai Sahib didn't believe in Raag Mala, but IMHO he didnt make an issue of it in the panth because he did have utmost respect for the Akal Takht. Nowdays I see people condemning or promoting Raag mala because 'thier' jathebandi has that view.
I wonder how many people have actually read and understood the 1429 angs that come before Raagmala. Bhai Sahib had great khoj of bani and a lot of kamai? I wonder how many of us have that.
I guess what i'm trying to say is, don't just belive what the next person says, go and do your research, do khoj of bani, and with wahegurus kirpa you will yourself know what the answer is.
peeoo dhaadhae kaa khol ddit(h)aa khajaanaa ||
When I opened it up and gazed upon the treasures of my father and grandfather,
thaa maerai man bhaeiaa nidhhaanaa ||1||
then my mind became very happy. ||1||
[%sig%]
Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad
Rajinder Pal Singh · 21 Mar 2006
Raagmala is not gurbani. It has been well proved long long ago. Any body who has any doubt about it, can read the recently written book by S. Mahinder Singh Josh. The name of book is 'Khast Raag Kin Gaye'.
Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad
sk (Satnam Kaur) · 21 Mar 2006
Dear Rajinder Pal Singh jeo,
Wat Khoj and wat not. Everybody wants to be in the limelight by speaking on the wrong points. That is a negative energy and will not add to the development of the conscious.
Hope you believe in Guru Gobind Singh ji, It was included by Him while he could manage to create 2nd edition of Guru Granth Sahib through Bhai Mani Singh plus the Gurbani of Guru Teg Bahadur. Simply talking hearsey does not look nice. Already so many Jathebandis in Sikhism, at least, do not create conflict in Guru Granth Sahib ji. Meat Khana, aur Sharab Peenee Band Karo, ta Gal samajh ayegi.
Bhul chuk maaf karna, please.
satname kaur
Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad
no way its baani · 21 Mar 2006
benji sk
u need 2 do more research on raag maalaa issue, its been added by a muslim poet who had relation with a prostitue............
Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad
sk (Satnam Kaur) · 22 Mar 2006
Pyari sadh sangat jeo,
Of course, Kavi Santokh Singh and Giani Gyan Singh, were original to many of the points, and what khoj they could do, which is possible now, in the technological world and when many thousands have come out with research by doing Ph.D. and M.Phil. by visiting various places, by reading various granths, by readings various sikh scriptures and by discussing with learned people, besides their own personal experiences and happenings in the life and the society.
And we are simply struck of that, this was done by Mr so and so and this was written by Mr so and so, and we cannot go ahead, with new ideas. This is educated world, earlier it was a different world. People have no much accessibility and there was no printing press and there was no mode of communication and conveyance to reach at fast speed to different places of interest to find and work out on the research side.
If you people are bent upon - Mai Na Manoo - then Bhai sahib jeo, it is upto you. who will bother to read and accept and practize your wordings in the life. People are not going to stop to their destination and you go on speaking your old version, but to yourself only.
Daily, new research,information are coming up, in various magazines and newspapers and discussions are coming up at the TV on various topics. If life with us in Canada is fast, it is much faster in India, just visit and roam for 3 to 4 months and collect the information on the issues, just by sitting in Brampton, it is not going to serve the purpose.
In India, more TV channels are there, which impart more knowledge to the development of conscious, than in our Canada. We have money here, that too upto our extent, whereas in India, people are doing much Naam, Simran and Sewa. Try to broad the outlook. Otherwise, it is upto you.
I would appreciate, if you will kindly write back your age and years of research you have done on the subject and what is your qualifications in Gurmat.
Bhul chuk maaf karna, please.
Satnam kaur
Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad
Khalistan_zindabaad · 22 Mar 2006
it seems some of these singhs think they have greater jeevans than shaheed baba deep singh ji . sant jarnail singh ji etc who believed in raagmala. . . pathetic as always. . .
Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad
JSGyani "Arshi" · 22 Mar 2006
Author: moorukh
Date: 03-22-06 08:19
the posts in this thread totally sum up the state of our panth - people slagging each other off; pulling at each others' legs when trying to climb the ladder of spirituality. if we spent less time doing khoj (theory)<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<
then you are missing out on GURU GOBIND SINGH JI's HUKM...
Jo PRABH ko mil Boch Hai..KHOJ SHABAD meh lai..
KHOJ is VITAL to SIKHI/GURMATT...No BLIND FAITH here...
Jarnail singh
Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad
guruji's_student · 28 Mar 2006
peronsally... to me .... raag malla IS BANI!! ... as when youre doing matha teak to guru ji .. are you onli doing matha teak to only half of guru ji ?
and at akand paats ... everybody reads raag malaa .. as its in guru granth sahib ji
its guru ji .. Never doubt youre guru ji !! .. all hukam
dhan waheguru
DHAN DHAN SRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI
Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad
sk (Satnam kaur) · 28 Mar 2006
Guru piyareo,
Better go to India, and see how much work is being done, on the basis of khoj. Simply challenging me and others will not serve the purpose. ok, you go on saying, that Raag mala is not Bani. Nobody will stop reading SGGS as it is. Please do not creat conflict unwantingly. Already many opinions on different topics. Baki, tuhadee marzi hai, bha ji.
Bhul chuk maaf karna.
SATNAM KAUR
[%sig%]
Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad
darshan kaur · 28 Mar 2006
so raagmala is now half of Guru Ji? you guys get worse and worse!
Live in the real world!
Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad
amarjeet singh · 28 Mar 2006
"and at akand paats ... everybody reads raag malaa "
actually that statement is incorrect
Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad
Niranjan Singh · 28 Mar 2006
>>>>Cus you all know bhai randhir singh ji when he was dying said he made a mistakee!!!
Pro-Ragmala people know more about Bhai Randhir Singh's last moments than anyone in the AKJ or Bhai Sahib's family. That is amazing. Sounds like the trash Dhumma was spreading in California before he took off to Mehta.
How about making up a story about Kavi Santokh Singh's or Giani Gian Singh's last moments ? I am sure that is also in the works.
Perhaps those conjured up the trash about Bhai Randhir Singh can help out.
Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad
JSGyani "Arshi" · 28 Mar 2006
and OMG has also repeated a BLATANT LIE about Bhai Sahib Bhai randhir Singh ji's last dying moments.... This LIE is told even by Brahmginai Sants just to bolster their arguments for raagmaala...cn you beat that..a brahmgiani sant and a lier all in ONE..
Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad
Niranjan Singh · 29 Mar 2006
>>>we will never kno what bhai sahib randder singh said when he passed >>>away, people saying "He DID say this" and people saying "He DIDNT >>>say this" is untrue because we will never know what he truly said
singh, you seem to be giving legitimacy to habitual liars. Bhai Sahib passed away in the early 1960's not in the 1700s so we know what occured, what happened isn't some cloud of mystery to are claiming it to be. Some of those who were there during his final moment are still alive, they can attest that bhai sahib said no such things. The folks making up these fairy tales, mostly jealous taksalis, were not there at all. Who do you beleive ?
Saying we just don't know is a cop out. Truth should not be trampled by koorr for some false "unity". When these people stop making up such trash then maybe this talk of unity can be seriously considered.
Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad
JSGyani "Arshi" · 31 Mar 2006
Author: yo
Date: 03-31-06 13:20
what has sant jarnail singh being in chardi kala havta do with raag malla?
>>>>>>>>>>>>>..
ask "some guy"..above who brought this up...
I agree with you..NONE of the persons listed have anything to do with Raagmala..its just "name dropping" scare tactics... NOT FACTS.
Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad
simple singhani · 02 Apr 2006
NAAM SIMRAN= ANSWERS TO EVERYTHING!!!!!
Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad
Prabhjoyt Singh · 04 Apr 2006
"just me"
The empty pages you talk about in the Kartarpur Bir were left for Guru Tegh Bahadur sahib ji's bani also the Bir at Harmandir Sahib is praatun and that contains Raagmaala. And Niranjan Singh you asked about Giani Gian Singhs last moments well this was the man who took "pheem" and claimed Dasam Patashah Guru Gobind Singh Ji took "pheem" his last moments were he admitted his faults and said it wasnt true that Guru ji too "peem" and he just said it to justify his actions.