Re: what do Bhaats mean in this shabad?
Gurpreet Sumra · 18 Mar 2006
these are the swayas by bhatt who is praising Guru Nanak followed by swayyas in the praise of Guru Angad Dev ji.
Important thing to keep in mind is that bhatts background was influenced by hindu thoughts, but when they understood the Sikh school of thought, then they compared those so called Gods and devi devtas to Guru saabs.What they mean is that now we have Guru Nanak,Angad,Amardas and Ramdas ji we dont need these devtas because now Guru Saab is everything for us.thats why Guru Arjan Dev ji included these swayyas in SGGS.
Using this same argument some people raise questions on the bani of bhatts in SGGS. They raise questions like
1)Guru Saab never praised themselves rather used Nanak nich, vichara but bhatts have said them as god,parmesar why this opposition?
2)Avatars that have been condemned in SGGS why compare Guru Saab to them?
3)God is formless he cant take birth, so why bhatts bani in SGGS?
But the point to understand is that bhatts are saying that now we have got Guru Nanak so now Guru Nanak is our kishan,bishan,brahma and various Gods that people talk about.
Even Guru Arjan Dev ji says about Guru Nanak
"gyan dhyan kich karam naa jana, saar naa jana teri
sab te wada satgur nanak, jin kal raakhi meri"(SGGS,p750)
Guru Ramdasji says about Guru Nanak
"sumund virol sarir hum dekhya ik vastu anoop dikhayi
gur govind govind guru hai nanak bhed naa bhai"(SGGS,p442)
I have churned this ocean what I found is that there is no difference between guru and waheguru.
So bhatts used those thoughts to explain what was prevalent at that time.Even Guru Saab has used kishan,murari, ram etc for waheguru as well as for the characters of Ramayan and Mahabharat.
Guru TeghBahadur saab says
"paanchali ko raaj sabha main raam naam sudh aayi"(SGGS,p1008)
Now paanchali/draupadi as per folklore remembered krishan not Ram, so Guru Saab is trying to say that draupadi remembered lord when she was in trouble.
Now this does not mean that Guru saab is explaining story of Mahabharat because Guru used Ram not kishan here.
Guru Saab is talking about lord waheguru by explaining in terms of stories prevalent at that time.
(some points taken from Prof Inder Singh Ghagga's article)
[%sig%]