Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member
Tribune News Service · 18 Mar 2006
Sikhs part of Hindus: Josh
Varinder Walia
Tribune News Service
Amritsar, March 18
Even as Mr Harcharan Singh Josh, newly appointed member of the National Commission for Minorities (NCM), today kicked off a controversy by describing Sikhs as part and parcel of Hindus, the Jathedar of Akal Takht, Giani Joginder Singh Vedanti, the SGPC President, Mr Avtar Singh, and Mr Tarlochan Singh, former Chairman of the NCM, have deplored his statement.
They said Akal Takht and the SGPC had already acknowledged that the Sikhs enjoyed a ''distinct and separate'' identity and Mr Josh had no right to question the same.
Though Mr Josh had breakfast with Jathedar Vedanti at his residence here today and held a marathon meeting with the SGPC chief, both have announced that they will not hold any more meeting with him (Mr Josh) till he withdrew his controversial statement.
Mr Josh had stated that it was only a turban that distinguished a Sikh from a Hindu. He claimed that the Sikhs came from the same 'Hindu culture' and they should admit this fact gracefully. ''Guru Gobind Singh sacrificed for whom?'' he asked.
He said the Sikhs should not deny the facts that they were baptised to protect the Hindus - their brethren -from the Mughal tyranny.
He, however, advocated for a separate Anand Karaj Act for the Sikhs. He also assured that the NCM would endeavour to bring back the 'blacklisted' Sikh youths who wanted to join the mainstream of the country.
Earlier, the Chief Khalsa Diwan (CKD) honoured Mr Josh on his appointment as member of the NCM. Mr Charnjit Singh Chadha, president of the CKD, and other members of the organisation were present on this occasion.
The SGPC chief said Mr Josh was nominated being member of the Sikh community and hence his "irresponsible statement" amounted to his disqualification. He said Mr Josh's statement showed that he wanted to watch the interests of the majority community instead of the minority.
Peeved at the controversy, Mr Tarlochan Singh, former Chairman of the NCM, said Mr Josh must understand that the Sikhs had a separate religion and identity. He said during his stint as Chairman of the NMC, he had arranged written statements from Mr K. Sudarhsan, RSS chief, and Mr Ashok Singhal, VHP leader, that Sikhs enjoyed a separate identity. He said he had now moved the Lok Sabha to amend Article 25 of the Indian Constitution that equated Sikhs with Hindus.
Mr Josh has had stint as general secretary of the Indian Youth Congress and was considered a confidant of Sanjay, younger son of Ms Indira Gandhi. To a pointed question, Mr Josh admitted his Congress background and said that at one time he cropped differences with Sanjay Gandhi and joined the Congress group led by Mr Swarn Singh, the then Foreign Minister.
Re: Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member
Gurpreet Sumra · 18 Mar 2006
Harcharan Singh Josh, New Chairman of Minority Commission of India who replaced Tarlochan Singh has created furore by saying that Sikhs are Hindus. He further added that everyone knows that Sikhs were created by Guru Gobind Singh ji to protect Hindus, brethren of Sikhs to protect them from Mughal Tyranny. Further, that it’s only a Turban that separates Sikhs from Hindus and Sikhs came from the same Hindu culture.
These irresponsible statements by a person holding such a high post, for sure indicates that he is acting at someone’s behest or he is completely ignorant of who Sikhs are?.
Sikhs are not Hindus, it has clearly been stated by Guru Saab “na hum hindu naa musalmaan”, further Sikhs have nothing in common with Hindus from their birth till death. Hindus have mundan sanskar- Sikhs don’t, Hindus worship stones-sikhs don’t,Hindus have different marriage ceremonies from Sikhs, even at death they have entirely different practices and different scriptures which have different teachings altogether. To top it all Sikhs place of worship Gurdwara is entirely different from Hindu temples. There is not even a single thing that Sikhs have in common with Hindus except for the relation of humanity which Sikhs have in common with every human being on this earth. This humanity was the reason that Guru Tegh Bahadur Saab sacrificed his life to protect helpless people from tyrant rulers of that time and not because those rulers were Muslims. Guru Gobind Singh did not create Sikh to protect Hindus, rather Guru Gobind Singh would have done the same thing to protect innocent Muslims from Narendra Modi in Gujarat,Bal Tacheray in Mumbai and from other Hindu terrorist organizations(VHP,Shiv sena,Bajrang Dal)in Ayodhya. Guru Saab would have done the same thing for innocent Christians in Orissa , tribals in North East and Dalits in Southern part of India.
These statements ,for sure are made to instigate Sikhs though Sikhs don’t want any kind of trouble “hamra jhagra raha na kou, pundit mulla chhade dou”(SGGS,1159).
Regarding Josh, he was the secretary of minority department of AICC(All India Congress Committee), what a department in a party who is responsible for the genocide of minorities. May be the department to work on finding out how to eliminate minorities.
That’s why he got this position.
Tarlochan Singh, former chairman’s Sikhi is now boiling on this statement because he is no more the Chairman, but now he has forgotten that he was the one who made statements that ram comes so many times in Guru Granth Sahib so Sikhs should wear Mukat like Mishra(Badal) and do paath of Ramayan and Havans with chunni around their necks.
Jathedar Vedanti would not speak a word or take any action against this, because Josh babu is doing the same thing what Vedanti wants. He can issue Hukamnama against Joginder Singh of Spokesman because he talks about distinctness of Sikhs and Sikhi but not against Josh. Vedanti should immediately issue a hukamnama to Josh , to ask for forgiveness as he has spoken against Sikh Panth.
Vedanti, wake up and stop issuing hukamnamas to Gurbaksh Singh kala afghana,Joginder Singh who talks about Sikhi and stop helping Sant Baba syndicate by the name of Sant Samaj.
This Sant Baba syndicate, in Virsa sambhal Sammelan passed a self styled resolution that Sikhs should not raise any questions about the authenticity of dasam granth, so that they can impart practical knowledge about it.
Jathedar Vedanti is also known to be very fond of these writings, that’s why he always maintains silence on this issue.
Vedantiji, If you still have some shame left after Sarna brothers episode then issue a hukamnama against Josh and Sant Samaj.
[%sig%]
Re: Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member
Mehtab Singh · 20 Mar 2006
And then they ask us why we need a separate country of our own.
Re: Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member
deadmanwalking · 10 Apr 2006
First of all, Guru Nanak may have said he is not a muslim or hindu, do you guys even know the meaning of that phrase? Some people interrupt things differently. Bhai Bala was a hindu and Mardana was a Muslim. Guru Nanak Dev Ji was for everyone not for one sect hence that is why he had to use the phrase above.
The world Singh did not exist before Guru Gobind Singh Ji. Guru Nanak Dev Ji was born in a Hindu family. We are part of the Hindu sect. I suggest you read the Dasham Granth where Guru Gobind Singh Ji mentions Bharma, Vishnu and Mahesh. If you want I can get the quotation for that as well and write in on the site.
Does it mean that a Namdhari's are not true sikhs just because they do not believe in the Granth Sahib as their living Guru instead believe in 12th Guru Ram Singh Ji? Does it mean that a person who believes in the Guru Granth Sahib as their are not Sikh's? Absoultely not. Again you may interrupt Namdhari's of not being Sikh's and they may interrupt you as being Guruless and not Sikh's.
I suggest you read the Dasham Granth and Guru Nanak Dev Ji's Janak Sakhi.
Sincerely,
Dead man walking
Re: Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member
deadmanwalking · 12 Apr 2006
Okay Veer Ji,
1. If you think you are a true Khalsa then who were the God's before Guru Nanak Dev Ji?
Answer: Sri Ramchander in Treta Yug and Krishan in the Dwaper Yug.
Kulyug which is the present age was Guru Nanak but people who believe in a Guru after Guru Gobind Singh Ji would be the 12th Guru Ram Singh Ji. I am not critisizing anyone here but according to Namdhari beliefs its Satguru Ram Singh Ji's yug who is to bring Satyug. Please note that I am not interfering with your beliefs with Sri Granth Sahib as your Guru so therefore continue to follow your tradition.
2. Who did Guru Teghbadur sacrfice his head for?
Answer: Hindu sect. Again there was no such thing of the word Singh during those times.
4. Guru Gobind Singh Ji's name was Guru Gobind Rai Ji before the prefix of Singh was added. Guru Gobind Rai Ji is a hindu name not a sikh name. Why Did Guru Gobind Singh Ji create the word Singh?
Answer: During the chotic time of the muslim empire the Hindu Sect were afraid of fighting. Guru Gobind Singh Ji had to show them courage so therefore he made them into warriors and the word Singh was used.
3. Why would Guru Gobind Singh Ji mention the names of Lord Bharama, Lord Vishnu and Mahesh (Lord Shiva ji) in his dasham granth?
If you consider yourself true Khalsa then Guru Gobind Singh Ji would have not mentioned the names of the Hindu gods at all.
I suggest you understand the Satyug, Treta Yug, Dwaper Yug and the current age which is the Kulyug. These ages do exist and each incarnation of God came to these yugs.
Also there are many Sikh out there that do not believe in Guru Nanak Dev Ji as an avtar of God. Majority of the Sikh's consider him to be a messenger of God. Again people do not even understand their own Sikh religion. It is better to understand the roots of Sikhism and each of the Yugs how they are correlated to Sikhism.
Wahi Guru Jey Key Fath
Re: Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member
deadmanwalking · 12 Apr 2006
Hey Author,
Do you want to chat on MSN messenger or yahoo messenger about this in greater details? It seems like the administration does not like freedom of speech.
I will give you my msn messenger address: [address removed]
Sincerely,
Dead Man Walking.
Re: Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member
deadmanwalking · 13 Apr 2006
Dear Author Ji,
Why did Guru Gobind Singh Ji write about Bharma, Vishnu and Mahesh in his Dasham Granth Sahib? Guru Sahib would have not written the name of the 3 Gods unless he did not believe that they existed.
Please answer this question and I would love to hear this response?
Sincerely,
Dead Man Walking
Re: Sikhs Are Hindus: Minorities Commission Member
california apna · 13 Apr 2006
Bharma, Vishnu and Mahesh are these god's part of sikhism did the guru's acknowlede their exsistance that they did or do exsist.