Personal Experience of Raag Keertan
Jagjit Singh · 10 Mar 2006
Waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji kefateh
Pyare jio, continuing in the conversation that we are having about raag keertan. I think it would be good to share my personal experience of raag keertan. My experience may be completely opposite to others so everyone please share. Again this is not to put down any style of keertan, because bani is bani and keertan is keertan. There is no competition, it is just about personal preference.
Personally, back in the beginning of 2005, I got really into raag keertan. I have loved listening to keertan for years, but mainly listened to Bhai Harjinder Singh Siri Nagarwale, Bhai Rajinder singh singapore or AKJ keertan. At that time, I was quite convinced by the arguments presented by pro-raag people. I thought it makes sense. So I began resourcing keertan purely in raag.
For months, I listened to only keertan in raags. I found it very soothing. I remember for them months, when I went to rainsbhais and youth keertan darbaars, I did not really get into them, and often came back early, or even stopped going. My mind had got so much into raags that I no longer was tuned to that keertan. Ultimately bani is bani, but my mind was stuck into a mode where I felt keertan should only be in that manner in which my mind had been tuned, i.e. raag.
Hence, I ended up doing less sangat. But personally found that listening to raag keertan very peaceful.
Then one day, I was driving from leeds to slough. In the car, the CD system had a random setting, and keertan started by Bhai Harpreet Singh, with the shabad, "Teera Santan jaacho". It had been six months by now, since I had listened to AKJ style sangatee keertan. I got so much in to bani and simran it was amazing. By the time I had reached Slough, I realised that for the last 6 months of listening to keertan in raag. It was helpful and peaceful. But I had missed the Gurbani Rass that I got from the sangattee style.
I realised that althougth I found peace from that bani. I had missed the Naam. Since I have come into sikhi, the fusion of Naam and bani in sangaatee style keertan has always been the pinacle for me. It had dawned on me, that in them 6 months, I had understood and found sehaj in bani, but I had without realising, sort of subconciously stopped doing simran while listening bani.
So at times the bani I was listening to in raag was talking about naam and the pyaas (thirst) of naam, but I was not even japping it. This made me think. Guru jis hukam is to do simran 8 pahr (at all times). My habit of doing that while listening to bani had left me.
Now, I still listen to raag at times, because I enjoy its clarity of shabad and sehaj. But the sangaatee style is my main diet. It makes us do simran, and trains our minds to do more and more. Many of us spend so many hours listening to keertan, it is such a blessing as Guru jis makes us do simran at the same time.
Gurbani is the food for the soul. No keertan is better or worse than any other. But I hope my mind is trained and drilled to do simran 8 pher, and that is what I strive for. In striving for that, I am glad that as a Gursikh, I have so much access to sangaatee keertan. The combination of Naam and Bani is so powerful, that it works wonders on my mind which wanders and is distracted far too often.
Waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji kefateh
Re: Personal Experience of Raag Keertan
Harcharan Singh · 11 Mar 2006
A raag is not a single tune.
As Raagi ji says, it is an emotion, a mood, an essence.
All the shabads within the said chapter of bani are in a certain mood.
That mood is created by following certain rules.
An infinite number of "tunes" or compositions can be made within the hukmi raag, allowing a composer, a Gursikh, a Raagi, Kirtani...to still express themself uniquely, or there understanding uniquely, but without compromising the essence of the shabad, which is what happens when kirtan is done in non-title raag.
It is not as simple as terminology, there also needs to be musicology, which incorporates understanding of the shabad, the poetry, finding the relevant emotion within (from experience if possible), but ultimatel- having true pyaar for Guru Ji.
When all these elements are united (and even more perfect when we use the perfect accompyment - Guru Ji's saaj - which have been designed for the job, and are the only instruments on the planet capable of executing the kirtan as intended, both emotionally and technically), then we have Guru's Kirtan.
Waheguru
Re: Personal Experience of Raag Keertan
Rajvinder Singh · 12 Mar 2006
Jagit Singh,
Lots of youth get more into the bhangra/filmi tunes of keertan rather than the shabad. I know that when I first listened to AKJ kirtan I thought I was in bliss. But, now I look back and realise that I was just attracted to the catchy film tune that was being done with the shabad.
Music + gurus' shabad = kirtan. Some people get more into the raag music and some people into the bhangra/filmi music. It is not the fault of music. Music has a place in Sikhi and it should be the music Guru Sahib selected rather than our own catchy tunes.
Rajvinder Singh
PS. Sangatee kirtan can be done in raag as-well.
Re: Personal Experience of Raag Keertan
Jagjit Singh · 13 Mar 2006
Waheguru ji kakhalsa, waheguru ji kefateh
Pyare jio, nice to hear from you Gursikh pyaare Bhai Rajvinder Singh. A face from the past. I hope you are well and Chardi kala.
My point is Raag keertan can be done in sangaatee aswell. This is the ideal.
The modern problem with debate on messageboards especially anonymous ones like this, is people find it difficult to have a real Gursikh debate. Hopefully people will learn to improve on this.
Why do pro-raag purists always mention bhangra and filmi tunes? I know some people stereotype certain keertan, but I rarely hear filmy tunes, and if some do, often they are told not to. Even then only people who watch bollywood know what these tunes are.
Pyare jio, speaking as someone who appreciates both raag keertan and sangaatee keertan, I would say that both have there purpose, and should be respected.
For example, if I give a youth a tape of raag keertan and ask them what mood is that shabad in, just from the raag tune. They often struggle to tell me that mood. Only when they can read the heading of the shabad and the raag, do they realise it is this raag and this shabad. Therefore it is in this mood. For me then, that youth has not been taken into that mood by the raag tune, but if another simple tune does induce that mood, then that is fine.
This is pure honesty, which many raag purists find it hard to admit. But instead of acknowledging it, the response is just to comment on filmy/bhangra tunes as a whitewash.
Another little story. When I first met Bhai Jeevan Singh, I asked him to teach me a shabad. He showed me 3 keys. He told me from these 3 keys to do simran, which I did, then he said from the same keys you can do mool mantar, chapuai sahib, asa di vaar, and in fact any bani. I was amazed. Being someone who does not keertan in front of anyone, only the occasional simran, which I also do reluctantly. However in private, guru Maharaj has blessed me to do keertan by myself of many banis, purely because Bhai sahib showed a complete talentless novice 3 keys.
Bani + mind = Gursikhi Everyone should strive to learn raag, but if sikhs around the world are discovering keertan and bani via simple tunes then there is nothing wrong with that. We should encourage all people to interact with bani.
So in conclusion, by all means promote raag. Everyone will benefit from it. But also realise for many people the moods of that bani can also come from other simple tunes that relate that raag. No one tune has a monopoly on any mood. Basically my point is lets not bring extremism into raag promotion.
Waheguru ji kakhalsa, waheguru ji kefateh
Re: Personal Experience of Raag Keertan
Harcharan Singh · 13 Mar 2006
Veer Jagjeet Singh Ji,
”Why do pro-raag purists always mention bhangra and filmi tunes? I know some people stereotype certain keertan, but I rarely hear filmy tunes, and if some do, often they are told not to. Even then only people who watch bollywood know what these tunes are.”
------
Veer Ji no need to make those who simply wish to follow their Guru’s chosen method of Kirtan sound like fanatics, they are more like subservient people.
You say you rarely hear filmy tunes, this implies that if you did you would be able to identify them, which further implies that you watch them. I can shamefully say that I have been brought up in a household where Hindi films were the order of the day, although I haven’t watched any for 10 years, I still recognise them in Gurdwara, and as a result, my focus is spoilt, this should not have to be the case.
This is the same reason that many sangatan and Guru Ghar committee’s prefer filmy kirtani, so that kirtan can be entertaining and Saturday night/ Sunday morning sangat can be happy, business is good as a result (sorry to say this, but it’s a fact – from my personal observations).
In addition, if one is not a film fan, how can they be sure the kirtan they are listening to is not filmy or bhangra kirtan?
Is ignorance really bliss?
If we all made a little effort to learn Nirdaareth Raags of our Guru’s, like we make an effort with banaa, with Gurmukhi, with Dasvandh, With seva…then this problem would not exist.
”Pyare jio, speaking as someone who appreciates both raag keertan and sangaatee keertan, I would say that both have there purpose, and should be respected.
For example, if I give a youth a tape of raag keertan and ask them what mood is that shabad in, just from the raag tune. They often struggle to tell me that mood. Only when they can read the heading of the shabad and the raag, do they realise it is this raag and this shabad. Therefore it is in this mood. For me then, that youth has not been taken into that mood by the raag tune, but if another simple tune does induce that mood, then that is fine.”
-----
No offence, but me and many other Sikhs respect our guru Sahibans hukum 1st and foremost. Nirdaareth Raag has the purpose, the purpose of ensuring that we understand the emotional content of Guru’s words and don’t misconstrue them.
Your test is an over-simplified exercise with not enough variables mentioned. For one how do you know the raag kirtan tape is in raag? Just because the cover says so, have 1st analysed it or learnt the asool of raag. Secondly it may be technically in raag (as most Raagis are), but is the composition and performance “spriritually” – or musicologically in raag?
Lastly, how can a man ever create an emotion where our Guru has apparently failed?
The problem and failure is not with the raag, it’s with the person who has presented the raag. The correction is not to go non-raag, but to find or create yourself the composition and kirtan correctly.
”This is pure honesty, which many raag purists find it hard to admit. But instead of acknowledging it, the response is just to comment on filmy/bhangra tunes as a whitewash.”
------
Veer ji, have you ever asked numerous kirtani where they get their tunes from? May be you should. If they say they compose them, then also ask them, why not compose in Guru Ji’s musical framework, this allows them to be unique and expressive, what is the reason for composing outside or Guru’s framework?
A Kirtan composed in Nirdaareth raag can be as simple or as complex as you want it to be, so the simple kirtan for the simple folk argument does not work. Folk are not so simple. In todays day and age they master many fields and are very successful, speaking more than one language and being experts in numerous areas of life…
Simple or complicated, at least the simple sangat like myself won’t have to sit their worrying about the source of the kirtan music, at least we can fell happy and blessed that we are listening to our Guru’s puritan kirtan…
Another little story. When I first met Bhai Jeevan Singh, I asked him to teach me a shabad. He showed me 3 keys. He told me from these 3 keys to do simran, which I did, then he said from the same keys you can do mool mantar, chapuai sahib, asa di vaar, and in fact any bani. I was amazed. Being someone who does not keertan in front of anyone, only the occasional simran, which I also do reluctantly. However in private, guru Maharaj has blessed me to do keertan by myself of many banis, purely because Bhai sahib showed a complete talentless novice 3 keys.
----
That’s fair enough, but do you think Bhai Sahib’s intention was that you keep playing 3 keys for the rest of your life? Or was it just a short term tip to boost your confidence and give you the opportunity to start doing kirtan straight away?
It takes 7 year old kids a few months to start doing kirtan in raag, be it at a simple level, but they love their Guru, and keep at it and perform to their Guru without any nerves in front of big sangats, because they are doing kirtan for their Guru and not the sangat (not implying other people don’t).
Veer Ji, I am sure you are a successful person in other fields, and may be you have not had access to Guru’s raag education, but don’t give up, resources are now available if you want to learn.
”Bani + mind = Gursikhi Everyone should strive to learn raag, but if sikhs around the world are discovering keertan and bani via simple tunes then there is nothing wrong with that. We should encourage all people to interact with bani.
So in conclusion, by all means promote raag. Everyone will benefit from it. But also realise for many people the moods of that bani can also come from other simple tunes that relate that raag. No one tune has a monopoly on any mood. Basically my point is lets not bring extremism into raag promotion.”
---------
Bhai Sahib, I disagree. People like Daya Singh and his daughter think it is ok to do kirtan to Michael Jackson songs in order to bring kids to baani.
Where do we draw the line, there are currently people who bring bani to us in jazz, hip-hop/gansta rap style, pop, bhangra, Bollywood….
Who is going to decide what is simple or not?
If the sangat is so innocent, then how are they going to know the Kirtan they are singing is not from a Madonna song? How will they feel if they ever find out and see the related video?
Please don’t bring words like extremism into this debate. Kirtan has been done in Nirdaareth raag for over 400 years, only since the British raaj and SGPC control (not blaming anyone in particular LK Ji), has the method of kirtan change.
I have previously posted a number of reasons for this decline, so please see that for more info i.e intro of baja (instrument to which raag cannot be done, as it doesn’t allow microtones – or ghar, as mentioned in bani), intro of mics, amplifiers, speakers, allowing amateur kirtani to perform, loss of raag knowledhe in the mainstream due to oral historical tradition (but not complete loss thankfully), troubles and pressures during British raj, start of all India radio bringing all types of music to peoples homes where only kirtan existed before (huge influence on kirtani – instead of having to learn raag and compose, simply copy a ready made tune, change of sangat attitudes/needs and inception of business minded non-sikh Gurdwara committees to name but a few…
And, finally, you are confusing raag with a tune. Raag is a correct emotional context. An infinite number of “tunes” can be composed within Guru Maharajs Nirdaareth Hukmi raag – but I will always put my Guru 1st, and no matter how great any Gursikh is, will never accept that anyone can create my Guru’s “exact” mood outside of his hukum.
Otherwise why did Guru Ji put the Nirdaareth raag in front of every shabad, why is the whole Sri Guru Granth Sahib compiled in raag format/chapters?
Why have all the Guru’s and Bhagats shabads not been shown chronologically, why have they all been collected and then presented in one chapter – according to the raag???
We cannot keep ignoring these issues, no person has any decent arguments against this fact (I don’t why they try), does this not mean we should explore and find out why Nirdaareth raag was important to our Guru’s, does a clue not lie in Guru de Saaj, which have specifically been designed to render raag to it’s full potential and create the most beautiful kirtan in the world?
I accept it is difficult to change and to especially to change from the culture that has been prevalent amongst various Sikh groups for many decades, and hard to change from the culture that some Sikh role models adopted, but we should always look to our Guru 1st, take good from all, only our guru’s were the perfect beings.
There us nothing wrong with accepting the fact that kirtan has been done with love, devotion and sincerity by real Gursikh over the last decades, but at the same time we should accept the fact that our Guru’s have placed importance on raag – the construction of Bani clearly shows this, and now that we are staring to reclaim the correct use of our Guru’s raag from those who have become famous from it (i.e. many Hindu classical music gharana – from where most raagis/kirtani learn, famous quawi singers, famous musicians, famous playback singers etc, many Indian Historians who claim there culture invented these raags, and there is not even 1 MENTION OF OUR GURU’S contribution, which is the greatest and most comprehensive in Indian musical historians …), we should all try claim our Guru’s kirtan and gifts back.
The only way to change peoples perceptions and put pressure on giani and kirtani to start doing Kirtan as guru intended is by creating the demand – start listening to raag kirtan, is by requesting it from Kirtani when Maharaj is invited to our house (Akhand Paath etc) and most importantly, is to learn it ourselves, so we son’t have to rely on anyone else or question their motives – Guru’s hukum is for us all to do kirtan in our households.
Let’s really try and do it as Mahraj intended, and let’s make use of all his priceless and irreplaceable gifts – Nirdaareth Raag, their saaj and using rahao (stress point) as the chorus – let’s end this “Lakh Kushiyan Patshiyaan” (incorrect rendition of shabad – to satisfy our own needs) era of sangat created kirtan.
Sat Sri Akaal
Harcharan Singh
Re: Personal Experience of Raag Keertan
Rajvinder Singh · 13 Mar 2006
Vahiguru Ji Ka Khalsa
Vahiguru Ji Ki Fateh !
Dear Bhai Jagjit Singh Ji,
I hope you and your family are well. Sorry I didn't say 'Fateh' before, I wrote the post very quickly and didn't expect it would come on the forum as I have posted before and my posts haven't appeared for some reason. I hope we can have a have a Gursikh debate about the topic started by your goodself. I look forward to your responses to the points and questions Bhais 'unreal' and 'Harcharan Singh' have made in their posts.
"My point is Raag keertan can be done in sangaatee aswell. This is the ideal."
Veer Ji, in your posts you have mentioned these as two distinct types of kirtan, eg. in the post "Raag keertan, AKJ sangaatee style and our minds" you have said "Raag keertan will never be as popular as sangaate keertan, because sangatee keertan involves the sangat en mass."
"Why do pro-raag purists always mention bhangra and filmi tunes?"
I mentioned it in my post because I have heard bhangra and film tunes in AKJ rain-sabaee kirtans many, many times. Bhangra tunes are for dancing and are fine for a bhangra/dancing atmosphere. Filmy tunes are fine for romantic scenes in films. Both of these are unacceptable for kirtan, which requires the spiritual, soothing music that Guru Sahib has given us.
"I rarely hear filmy tunes, and if some do, often they are told not to. "
In my experience with the AKJ this is not true. I have heard Bhai Jarnail Singh Ji (AKJ UK Jathedar) say himself that people have complained to him about certain keertani doing filmy tunes. I have never heard of anyone being told not to do them.
"For example, if I give a youth a tape of raag keertan and ask them what mood is that shabad in, just from the raag tune. They often struggle to tell me that mood. Only when they can read the heading of the shabad and the raag, do they realise it is this raag and this shabad. Therefore it is in this mood. For me then, that youth has not been taken into that mood by the raag tune, but if another simple tune does induce that mood, then that is fine.
This is pure honesty, which many raag purists find it hard to admit. But instead of acknowledging it, the response is just to comment on filmy/bhangra tunes as a whitewash. "
What is there to admit here ? How can a simple tune induce the mood better than the raag Guru Sahib has specified ?
"Bani + mind = Gursikhi Everyone should strive to learn raag, but if sikhs around the world are discovering keertan and bani via simple tunes then there is nothing wrong with that. We should encourage all people to interact with bani."
Let me give a couple of examples to answer this. When discovering Sikhi, we all start off by doing paath slowly and make mistakes. But, our GurSikh brothers/sisters correct us and as time goes on we make less and less mistakes until the paath becomes 'shuddh'. Many of us may have discovered Sikhi through simple tunes, but just as in other walks of life, we should keep learning and do things correctly. A lot of GurSikhs got attracted to Sikhi through listening to kachi bani.......but now they have realised that kirtan should be of gurbani only. Should they have stayed where they were or moved on ?
"Basically my point is lets not bring extremism into raag promotion."
Can you please show me where anyone is bringing extremism into raag promotion ?
Regards,
Rajvinder Singh
Re: Personal Experience of Raag Keertan
Harcharan Singh · 13 Mar 2006
Bhai Rajvinder Singh Ji raises a very important point:
Sikhs are students, Guru Ji is the teacher.
When we stop being students - when we stop learning, we stop being Sikhs - no questions.
If someone learns 3 keys, that is the 1st step. Guru's kirtan is the objective, and if we are Sikhs, we can all achieve that objective.
Guru Ji is teaching us in black and white - clearly, how to sing our praises to Waheguru, we should listen to our Guru, and forget about those around us.
Their jeevan and kamai is with them, ours is with us.
Follow our Guru's footsteps where ever you can. With his kirpa, we now have the resources to do this again, please, let's not waste them and let them disappear forever, so that Guru's hukum just becomes a myth for future generations, as some people are trying to make it a myth now....
Re: Personal Experience of Raag Keertan
Harcharan Singh · 14 Mar 2006
If I was in India, I would approach Bhai Balbir Singh Ji in Amritsar.
There are not many people today, who have his level of knowledge and talent.
Re: Personal Experience of Raag Keertan
Jagjit Singh · 14 Mar 2006
waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji kefateh
Pyare jio, veer Harcharan Singh ji and Veer Rajvinder Singh ji, hope you are both well.
I notice Veer Harcharan Singh, you have taken time to go through my post point by point. I am surprised that you gave me such attention. My point of the story of Bhai Jeevan singh was not to say we should stay at 3 keys, but veer ji, how new souls are introduced to bani. It is often via simple tunes. Then we progress from there. We all move on.
You mention about daya singh singh and co ,and this person and that. veer ji, I have said before that I have no interest in filmy tunes. I personally love keertan sang by Jeevan wale Gursikhs who sing it with pyass.
Veer Rajvinder Singh, the extremisim that I mentioned is when some raag purists say all non-raag keertan is manmat, or people need to radical change and raag is the only way. I feel that is extreme, and those who say these things underestimate the power of bani. I am not saying you have said it, but it has ben said on this and many other forums.
Forgive me, both of you if you were expecting to go through your posts with counter arguments. I do not see why, because like I said, I am not against promotion of raag in the proper manner, neither do I have anything against it.
Veer jis, I do ask a question. We talk of hukam. You say raag is hukam. This is a mood, as we all agree. I believe any simple tune which induces that mood is fine, you both say a specific raag tune is hukam. The question is my original post was about another hukam. That hukam is about 24/7 naam abyass inside us. I do not have that, but strive for it. I personally found listening to pure raag keertan during the day in addition to my limited Amrit vela, not as helpful as listening to AKJ keertan during the day in addition to my limited Amrit vela. I explained this in my post.
My humble question to you veer jis, especially you Veer rajvinder singh, as you have probably been blessed with more sangat than das, what has been your personal experience of raag kertan is relation to the Naam that we jaap?
A simple request from one who walks on a path, to another who is probably ahead of him.
waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji kefateh
Re: Personal Experience of Raag Keertan
Harcharan Singh · 15 Mar 2006
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh,
Khalsa Ji Jagjit Singh,
I just have a few points:
As I have said before, there are many young Gursikh infants, who are singing to raag, and picking up Guru's saaj and perfoming kirtan in no time. Age is the way to go, if we introduce children to Nirdaareth Raag at a young age, it becomes second nature to them, if that is all they hear.
But for us to do that with our kids, we need to make an effort ourselves now. We need to be role models, not that we would be learning Guru's kirtan for our kids, we would be learning it as acceptance of a forgotten gift from Maharaj.
Veer Ji you said "No one tune has a monopoly on any mood".
Yes that is right, you are confusing raag with tune, raag is not a tune, it is a spiritual musical framework within which a gursikhs can create infinte melodies, but all will serve Guru's purpose and reflect his words in the tone and emotion they were supposed to be heard. If our Guru’s have given us the tools needed to achieve the right mood, why are we re-inventing the wheel, or more to the point, how can anyone improve in Guru Ji’s work? I say that no man can prove on Guru’s Ji’s work. Other technologies may advance, but the science of naad has declined from our Guru’s time, our developed, perfected and used this art to it’s highest form, it can not be improved on.
It is a simple matter and a simple question, if all the kirtani today are earning livings or doing sevaa of kirtan full time, then why do they not master Guru's Raags? It would not take them long.
If they perform simple tunes, then we need to know where did they derive these tunes from (this is not speaking of anyone in particular), because I personally would not want Guru Ji's Karaah Parshaad served in a joota panda, I would not want the kirtan I am listening to, singing to, to be derived from a bollywood video or Hans Raj Hans.
Let's even leave filmy tunes alone for a second (which is an accepted big problem today, even though some wish not to accept it), if we want simple tunes, and the kirtani is say, not borrowing them, but composing them himself, them what is stopping him from composing a simple tune in Nirdaareth raag? This way he would keep the sangat happy and be obedienient to Guru Ji's wish.
Problem today is that we perform kirtan for the sangat and not for our Guru, hence all these bad habits that are around today, which are derived from the need to please the sangat. Tables are still placed in many Gurdwarai, not to please Waheguru or follow the example of the tradition set by them, but to appease the sangat.
In our Guru’s time, people would have made an effort to learn kirtan, the kirtan would have been done in the most beautiful way, in Guru’s royal court…
My personal experience is this – I used to listen to kirtan (Gurdwara, rehansabai, recorded) and enjoy/like the tabla taal, the “tune”, the speed, the kirtani’s voice, the meaning of the shabd, the kirtani’s banaa the passion etc etc. But it was all separated, and I enjoyed different things from different kirtani.
But when I had my first raag kirtan experience (I was completely ignorant of raag) I was blown away.
I closed my eyes and my soul was touched, the words fitted so perfectly with the music, and the music stressed the Rahao, and made me look at, understand the shabad in a way I had never thought of before.
It bought out a strong feeling in me, which I couldn’t explain, until I did vichaar on the shabd. Later when I learnt of raag and looked up the meaning of the raag, it (the emotion) made perfect sense and complimented the shabd 100%.
It is important to learn something about raag before we try experimenting with any album/cassette that says raag on their, many raagis do not perform strict gurmat sangeet, many have down Indian Classical routes due to their Indian Classical training, hence the long alaaps, use of vocal sargam in the shabd etc… We need to know who is doing puritan raag kirtan and who is not.
If words alone had been enough, Guru Nanak Dev Ji would never have needed Bhai Mardana. If any tune had been enough, Guru Arjun Dev J would not have invented so many new raags and used raag as the skeleton for compiling the Ad Granth Sahib. If any instrument had been enough, our Guru’s would not have designed the most beautiful instruments in the world – created specifically for Nirdaareth Raag Kirtan.
I do ardaas we can all apply the same common sense that has been and is being applied to so many other issues affecting the panth – we should accept and make a huge individual effort to learn about and preserve our Guru’s gifts.
We should be able to sit in a sangat and identify ourselves whether someone is singing in Nirdaareth raag, rather blindly accept what kirtani tell us. We should be able to do this because we should all be kirtani in our own homes at least. We read Ramkali before Anand Sahib Ji every day, we should know what this means, and how it is created. This way the question of whether kirtan is filmy or not will never arise, and those many kirtani, who take advantage of Gursikh sangats who don’t watch films, will be put out of business for good.
I personally find it very difficult to sit down and listen to non-Nirdaareth Raag kirtan now, because of 2 things, one I know inside me the kirtan has not be done according to my Guru’s instructions, and 2 it no longer has any affect on me. My mind and soul need to achieve balance when listing to kirtan, I find Guru’s Raag helps me with this in a huge way.
In the Naam Simran programme in Tooting, London last week, I struggled some what to persuade some of the committee to let the Anand Sahib be done in full, as the normal Langar time would be 40 minutes late, and as a big sangat was going to be there that day, they would not want to listen to 40 minutes of Anand Sahib.
Guru di kirpa, I persuaded them, and the sangat were totally mesmerised. It was the most beautiful and hard hitting Anand Sahib I have ever heard(Bhai Nirmal Singh Ji’s was excellent, but was very technical and 6 paurian), but this was done with so much love, devotion, emotion and in RAMKALI – it was hugely powerful. The sangat loved it, and the management ate their words.
The feeling was a new one for me, I was in tears but felt complete and content at the same time.
I will try and put it on to MP3 and post a link here soon. But the recording will not be anything like being there.
I would request the sangat to try doing the full Anand Sahib, maybe try and do it once a week, in Ramkali and see the effect it has on their athmaa….
Sat Naam
Re: Personal Experience of Raag Keertan
Harcharan Singh · 16 Mar 2006
Chill out ji (I wish people would use their proper names),
Yes, shabad is pardhaan, and raag is the aid, no is denying that. But you have yourseld have acknowledged raag plays a role, that is all I am trying to state.
I think that the panth has been "chilled out" enough over the last 80 years in allowing Guru Ji's priceless kirtan vidya to virtually disappear.
Time to stop chilling.
I don't see anyone telling anyone to take a chill pill when it comes to sarbloh bibek for example. The same principle could be applied there, is the power of bani not strong enough to not let it matter whether we cook and eat out of clay, copper or iron?
Singh Ji,
People are trying to discredit the importance of raag from many angles, but none are going to succeed. Ultimately, bani is all powerful, but our Guru Sahiban put raag before every shabad for a reason.
So instead of changing the arguement to "the power of bani being under-estimated", let's stay on teh topic, and instead question why Guru Ji put the nirdaareth raag before shabad in the "Jagdi Jyot".
SAT Sri Akaal
Re: Personal Experience of Raag Keertan
Rajvinder Singh · 16 Mar 2006
Vahiguru Ji Ka Khalsa
Vahiguru Ji Ki Fateh !
Veer Jagjit Singh Jeeo,
Vahiguru ! I don't think I am ahead of you at all Veer Ji, but I will try and answer your question as you have asked me to. Please do ardas for me so that I can experience what is described below.
Listening to gurbani (whether in paath or keertan) with attention and obedience makes the Sikhs’ mind more gurmukh, lessens the panj vikaar and gives peace and joy. When doing naam jap the Sikh then finds his mind more receptive and more attracted to the jap. Listening to raag keertan which is sung with the correct raag and correct emphasis (rahao line as the chorus) helps attract the mind further to gurbani and also helps the Sikh understand the Gurus’ message better and in the correct context (very important).
The main emphasis should always be on the Gurus’ shabad. If the music becomes the main focus then ultimately the Sikh loses out. But, as I said before, there are many different types of music that can become the main focus in keertan. For some it is classical raag, for some it is filmy tunes, for some (mainly naujawans) it is bhangra, for some it is pop music etc.
Regards,
Rajvinder Singh
Re: Personal Experience of Raag Keertan
Jagjit Singh · 18 Mar 2006
waheguru ji kakhalsa waheguru ji ke fateh
Pyare jio, veer rajvinder Singh and harcharan singh ji. When I read your responses, we have a lot in common. I, too enjoyed the peace and tanquil nature of the bani in raag kertan. It is easier to understand, I think most keertan is not difficult to understand the shabad. For example, Bhai Harjinder Singh Siri Nagarwale is very popular in the Panth. I personally think the main reason behind this, is when he does keertan it is easy to understand every word of the Shabad.
What is interesting is that both of you said you enjoy the Gurbani in Raag. But neither of you mentioned it made you Jaap Naam more. I felt similarly, that enjoyed the bani. However if we look back to my original post, then this is what I said. I said, the bani is enjoyable to listen. But the hukam of that bani is to Naam jaap 24/7. My personal reflection was that I found sangattee keertan easier to jaap naam with, so hence, practically do the hukam of the bani that we are meditating on when listening to keertan.
This is not to say I am right and you are wrong, or you are right and I am wrong. It is just my personal reflection that although Raag is tranquil, I personally think sangaatee keertan also has a good purpose, in the manner in which, it makes the whole sangat sing, and secondly in the manner in which it fuses naam aswell as bani into people.
This is why I find when people say raag is the only way, I find that unneccessary. Everything we do in Gurmat is to take us more towards Naam. Our rehit, bana, bani, nitnem, Amrit vela, daily routine, etc. It is all set up to make us naam jaap more, and concentrate on that. When we leave this earth, we only take one thing, that is our wealth of Naam. Naam is the ultimate reality.
Ideally hopefuly when more youth learn raag keertan, then we will have raag keertan in a sangattee style. But my simple point when saying raag keertan, sangatte keertan and our minds, is that we should not just dismiss sangattee keertan, and make all keertan raag, because sangattee keertan has a purpose. it is also the preference of some aswell. Feel free to promote raag keertan, and lets people make thier choice and their preference, because ultimatley bani is bani.
waheguru ji kakhalsa waheguru ji ke fateh
Re: Personal Experience of Raag Keertan
Rajvinder Singh · 20 Mar 2006
Vahiguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Vahiguru Ji Ki Fateh !
Bhai Jagjit Singh Ji,
I think you need to read my post again. I am a bit concerned that you are putting words into my mouth and trying to make my post sound like what YOU want it to mean. You say that "But neither of you mentioned it made you Jaap Naam more.", but didn't I say ?....."When doing naam jap the Sikh then finds his mind more receptive and more attracted to the jap."
You are saying that raag keertan is devoid of Naam and in some way inferior to AKJ keertan, which I think is highly objectionable and disrespectful to Gurbani. I was hoping that you would refrain from this stance but you seem to be so intent on protecting bhangra/filmy tunes with keertan that you are now claiming Raag keertan does not have Naam !!! Raagis may not do Naam Simran with their keertan the way you believe should happen, but Gurbani does contain Naam.
Is it not the same Gurbani in raag keertan and AKJ keertan ? How can keertan that is done with the music Guru Sahib intended be inferior ? You have said that some pro-raag people do not recognise the 'paras-kala' of gurbani.....are you sure it's not you that doesn't recognise this ?????
You say " I personally think sangaatee keertan also has a good purpose, in the manner in which, it makes the whole sangat sing, and secondly in the manner in which it fuses naam aswell as bani into people.". Does raag keertan not do both of these things ???? You yourself have heard Raag keertan done in sangatee style, but you seem to be in denial and you keep mentioning these as two different types of keertan. How did Gursikhs drink amrit from gurbani before the modern AKJ style came long ? Why did Guru Sahib themselves not use this method of doing kirtan and instead opted for the classical style ? These are questions that need answering, along with the other points/questions that myself and Harcharan Singh have raised. But you keep avoid answering questions and instead take the discussion off on tangents.
Your experience with raag keertan is because of the way YOU approached the music and put it above the bani. This happens with lots of style of music, but you even deny that filmy tunes are used within the AKJ ! Maybe the reason you find AKJ style keertan inspiring is because it is fast, high-tempo and with catchy tunes.
Regards,
Rajvinder Singh
Re: Personal Experience of Raag Keertan
Jagjit Singh · 21 Mar 2006
waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh
Pyare jio, Veer Rajvinder Singh, you seemed to have misinterpreted what I wrote. This whole subject started when on another thread, it was stated by someone that that gurdwaras or groups should change their method of keertan and do raag keertan only because that is the Pure way.
I disagreed with that, because I feel that keertan done in different methods, each have thier purpose.
At no point did I say raag keertanis are deviod of naam, that is your misreading of it. My actual words were
"Ideally hopefuly when more youth learn raag keertan, then we will have raag keertan in a sangattee style. But my simple point when saying raag keertan, sangatte keertan and our minds, is that we should not just dismiss sangattee keertan, and make all keertan raag, because sangattee keertan has a purpose. It is also the preference of some aswell. Feel free to promote raag keertan, and lets people make thier choice and their preference, because ultimatley bani is bani."
There is no competition between the styles of keertan. Of course, people drank Amrit from bani before AKj came along. Why do even think of these things? AKJ style if you call it that, I call it sangattee keertan because it has been around centuries before AKj came along. It has changed and adpated over time. The modern style is very influenced by Mohinder Singh SDO and Bhai Joginder Singh Talwara, and in future it will be influenced by others. In fact, there is no such thing as AKJ keertan, there is only sangatte keertan and in comes in many forms.
No one is threatened by raag keertan. Quite the opposite, it will slowly become adapted into the mainstream.
The reference to naam is just my personal experience, hence the name of the title of the thread. It is no reflection of raagis and their jeevans.
I have never protected filmy tunes, quite the opposite in the past I have spoken to main keertanis about not doing them. But I do think the stereotype that all non-raag keertan is filmy tunes is completely inaccurate. Further I feel that no tune has a monopoly of a mood of a shabad. If we say, the raagis do the music intended by the Guru, I am sure the raag genuis of Sahib Siri Arjan dev ji did not intend his shabads to be constantly interrupted by sa re ga ma alaaps, as raagis display their profieciency. I prefer a shabad not be interrupted, but if it is then Gurmantar is far better than sa re ga, etc. Plus then we would not also have the Gurbani where Guru ji talks about not making raags the "be all and end all of everything."
If a simple tune also reflects that same mood than that is fine. You may disagree, but I believe when a person who is absorbed in naam and sings that shabad, the mood is comes from inside that person, and not from any outside saaj.
Pyare jio, I hope that clears things up. If not, then I am sure we will meet at the weekend at the keertan. The fast temp, catchy tunes mean nothing to me, please do not falsely categorise me in a box. I know pro-raag opinion does push certain stereotypes, but people are far more individualistic than them.
Forgive me if I have upset you, but I do think you have misinterpreted what I said. I just feel the raag purists go too far sometimes, and some of us find their stance that all other keertan is filmy tunes and should be stopped is not accurate, because there is nothing wrong with sangatee keertan as it is also Gurmat.
waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh
Re: Personal Experience of Raag Keertan
Harcharan Singh · 21 Mar 2006
Veer Jagjit Singh Jeeo,
I just wanted to address some points, please do not mind the way in which I respond, I am naturally a very formal person:
"There is no competition between the styles of keertan."
----
I agree, Guru Ji's style will always be the best.
"AKJ style if you call it that, I call it sangattee keertan because it has been around centuries before AKj came along."
----
This is the first time I have heard of either this term "sangatee kirtan".
I disagree completely, Kirtan was done in Guru Ji's style until the British/Harmonium/SGPC/All India Radio/Bollywood/disrepute of saaj in brothels/west/Indian classical gharanai/loss of kirtan vidya due to hard times and reliance on oral history etc influenced it.
AKJ style started post the creation of AKJ and you are right, it has evolved and still is evolving, where as Guru Ji's kirtan does not evolve or become influenced.
"No one is threatened by raag keertan. Quite the opposite, it will slowly become adapted into the mainstream."
----
All the people that have used bajai and sung to filmy/folk tunes all their lives are threatened by it. Those who look upto great Gursikh who may not have sung in Guru's raag, rather than looking up to our Guru's are threatened by it.
You say "will slowly become adapted", let's reflect on this comment in a years time.
Nanaksar UK are already adapting, if you are in UK, try and pop down to Wolverhampton this Sat eve, it will be amazing 3 hours of Nirdaarteh Raag kirtan using some Tanthi saaj...
Now that SGPC have recognised that this is the way to go (I won't question there intentions, i don't care to be honest) and now that Darbaar Sahib will have kirtan as per Guru Ji era again, the world will change, and not slowly.
"Further I feel that no tune has a monopoly of a mood of a shabad. If we say, the raagis do the music intended by the Guru, I am sure the raag genuis of Sahib Siri Arjan dev ji did not intend his shabads to be constantly interrupted by sa re ga ma alaaps, as raagis display their profieciency. I prefer a shabad not be interrupted, but if it is then Gurmantar is far better than sa re ga, etc. Plus then we would not also have the Gurbani where Guru ji talks about not making raags the "be all and end all of everything."
------
I have alreay explained, raag is not a tune, you shouldn't really discuss this issue further until you learnt this basic fact.
And I have explained numerous times, sargams being repeated in kirtan is Indian Classical Music, not Gurmat Sangeet, so please stop confusing the two. Listen to Prof Surinder Singhs album to see how Raag Kirtan should be done.
I am glad you mentioned interuption and said "You prefer for there to be no intereptions" I agree, this includes gurmanter jap whilst doing kirtan. Simran can and should be done seperately. I am sure Akal Takht maryada does not allow any interuption of shabad kirtan.
Gurbani is refering to faiths such as Vedic who treat raag, taal and dance as ways of reaching God, Sikhhi does not. Raag is the ultimate accompyning tool for kirtan, but without shabad it is worthless, that is what Guru ji is refering to, in theri time the Vedic traditions were still very strong, Guru Ji simply ointe out where they were going wrong. People should stop refering to these tuks incorrectly.
"If a simple tune also reflects that same mood than that is fine. You may disagree, but I believe when a person who is absorbed in naam and sings that shabad, the mood is comes from inside that person, and not from any outside saaj.
Pyare jio, I hope that clears things up. If not, then I am sure we will meet at the weekend at the keertan. The fast temp, catchy tunes mean nothing to me, please do not falsely categorise me in a box. I know pro-raag opinion does push certain stereotypes, but people are far more individualistic than them.
Forgive me if I have upset you, but I do think you have misinterpreted what I said. I just feel the raag purists go too far sometimes, and some of us find their stance that all other keertan is filmy tunes and should be stopped is not accurate, because there is nothing wrong with sangatee keertan as it is also Gurmat.
----
Veer Ji - you have avoided many questions we have posed, please now answer these:
1 - Where are todays non-raag tunes derived from? Have you tried to find out or do you beleive ignorence is bliss? How do you know that the tune you are absorbed in isn't from a sleezy bollywood film? Or doesn't it matter?
2 - If the mood was so easy to create, why is the whole Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji created in raag chapters, why have all the Guru's and bhagats bani being grouped under raag, rather than author, subject, time scale etc?
This is not to say mood comes from outside, it dos still come from inside, how do you think raag compositions are created?
3 - Why has Guru Ji put the mood - raag - musical framework of each shabad in the title?
4 - You mention individualistic, I have alreay said to you that millions of compositions can be made within a raag, so what does your comment mean? Is it not the quest for non-gurmat uniqueness the reason that teh panth is so divided today? If people are trying to create a common, gurmat bond between the panth, is that not a good thing?
Waheguru
Re: Personal Experience of Raag Keertan
chill out (amarjeet singh) · 21 Mar 2006
harcharan singh, u really are wasting your time
if u prefer raag thats fine, but to try and say all kirtan not done in raag is wrong, is stupid. to do kirtan in raag would be best, but kirtan not done in raag is not manmat, gurbani sung with prem and concentration is gr8. fullstop. im not going to stage a massive argument with you as you have been doing with other people on this forum. i jus wanted to tell u, if u spent all the tym uve bin writin about raag, doin paath, or kirtan in raag, or even kirtan out of raag, ud find ud b a lot betta off
Re: Personal Experience of Raag Keertan
Rajvinder Singh · 22 Mar 2006
Vahiguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Vahiguru Ji Ki Fateh !
Dear Veer Jagjit Singh Jio,
I interpreted your posts the way I did because of your comments such as the following:
“Now, I still listen to raag at times, because I enjoy its clarity of shabad and sehaj. But the sangaatee style is my main diet. It makes us do simran, and trains our minds to do more and more.”
“What is interesting is that both of you said you enjoy the Gurbani in Raag. But neither of you mentioned it made you Jaap Naam more”
“I said, the bani is enjoyable to listen. But the hukam of that bani is to Naam jaap 24/7.”
How does raag keertan negate any of the above ? If it doesn’t then why say that AKJ keertan has the above benefits but raag keertan doesn’t ? The gurbani is the same, right ? If we accept that raag keertan can be done in sangatee style then surely the only difference between the two styles is the music and the tempo ? How can these make us do more simran in one style and not the other ? That leads me back to my point that AKJ keertan is fast tempo and the catchy tunes are picked purposely to make it more exciting, this is no accident. I know you did not say that Raag keertanis are devoid of Naam but what I said is that you are saying that RAAG KEERTAN is devoid of Naam.
“But I do think the stereotype that all non-raag keertan is filmy tunes is completely inaccurate”
I agree with you here, I have never said that ALL non-raag kirtan is done to bhangra/filmy tunes. The reason I brought this up in this discussion is because we were talking about how music overtakes the shabad in keertan and unfortunately bhangra/filmy tunes are used a lot in AKJ rain-saabaees because they are catchy and have a fast tempo. There are keertanis who although they don’t always do the proper raag for the shabad, don’t use filmy tunes. They sound very close to the raag and do the shabad with sehaj (Bhai Amrik Singh Zakhmi comes to mind here).
In your first post you describe how raag keertan disturbed your focus because you were concentrating more on the music. I acknowledged that this can happen, but also made the point that it can and does happen in AKJ rain-sabaees. It is not just raagis who get caught up more in the music, AKJ keertanis do as-well. Even though you have said that a tune that is close to the mood of the raag is in your view acceptable, in practice this does not happen ! I used to attend rain-sabaees regularly and have seen the keertan turn more and more towards a fast tempo bhangra style. This is especially true of the naujawans; the older Singhs and bibian are normally more sensible. Myself and many other GurSikhs I have spoken to found this disrespectful and off-putting.
Veer Ji, what mood are they trying to portray by doing this style of keertan ? Is it, as you say, a similar mood to the raag that the shabad is in ? Or, is it a bhangra style designed to be as exciting as possible ? The mood they are trying to create is nowhere near the mood of the raag !!! As Bhai ‘SS’ mentioned, Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Ji never did Waheguru Jaap within keertan, and the style of keertan that he did was slow and sehaj (I have read this in an article that came in ‘Soora’).
I can understand why you would get offended at non-raag keertan being called ‘manmat’. I think this word is used a lot in the panth today by people who try to put others down, but ultimately we are all doing manmat. Personally I strongly believe in doing keertan in the correct raag, however I have no problem listening to non-raag keertan and have gained a lot from it since Guru has brought me into Sikhi. This is because of the greatness of Gurbani.
I will try and come to the keertan program @ Southall and speak to you then.
Regards,
Rajvinder Singh
Re: Personal Experience of Raag Keertan
Harcharan Singh · 23 Mar 2006
Wahe-Guru ji ka Khalsa Wahe-Guru ji ki Fateh,
Wow, that got a reaction:
Just Me Ji,
My dream is for all kirtan to once again be done as it was in Guru Ji’s day, yes.
It is not for me “ban” or pursue a “ban”. My preferred method of change is education and experience. This is and will continue to work.
The only problem, as in every single other area of life is that people are resistant to change.
I am not going to get into a conversation about personalities, I do not know these people and it is not for me to judge them. I have made my thoughts on reasons why people do non-rag clear in many previous posts.
Whilst there have been a few recognised cases where “GURU’s” raags have been used in films, this is a common practice as you make out.
This is the precise reason we should be able to understand Guru’s raags and composition, so we can make our own compositions if in doubt.
UK Singh Ji,
Prof Ji is not a professional singer, he only learnt to sing not long before the album was produced, Prof Ji is a composer.
The aim of the album is education – that is why it comes with a book and that is why it provides the full coverage of raags in bani.
The album aims to promote Guru’s Ji’s raag and saaj, which it does perfectly.
Amarjeet Singh Ji,
Thanks for your kind words and support. And you are right, I do use a lot of precious practice time posting here, and am trying hard to cut down. But inspiringly, some people do not think I am wasting time, and have found these very basic level discussions very educational. But thanks again for your kind thoughts.
I will try to stick to promoting Guru’s kirtan only, and not comment on raag, this unfortunately only happens when “OTHER” people try and compare the two and discredit Guru’s kirtan.
Sidhu Ji,
You have misconstrued my post. My problem with the Bajaa is that it is not designed for Guru Mahajrajs Nirdaareth Raag Kirtan, it does not play microtones, does not allow meends and gamaks which are intricate in performing raag.
The other words were simply historic facts, and me trying to show you the source of this sub-standard instrument and source of tanthi saaj. There never was or will ever be any competition.
Your other comparisons are out of context, they are evolutions, the bajaa was a devolution.
Lastly, there is nothing wrong with being knowing Horse Riding, it is actually one of Guru Gobind Singhs Hukum, we never know what tomorrow is going to bring, we shouldn’t be to over reliant on technology.
We should preserve our Guru’s heritage.
1) Shaster vidyaa atae ghorhae di savaari da abhiaas karna
Observer Ji,
LOL, you’ll be surprised how many people are out their who have the same views, anyone who wants to preserve their Guru Sahibaans musical heritage is going to sound similar.
It’s no big secret or hidden agenda why I am spending so much time on Tapoban Sahib, I have huge respect for the many ways in which Singh Sahibs are trying to preserve our Guru’s heritage, and I only wish that they would add this priceless gift to their already important list.
Waheguru
Re: Personal Experience of Raag Keertan
Harcharan Singh · 24 Mar 2006
UK Singh Ji,
The album was made around 5 years ago now I think.
Prof has been singing Kirtan since, his voice is now different...
In complete appropriateness with this topic, I would recommend all my Veeran abd bhenaan in Canada and US to get a personal experience of Nirdaareth Raag Kirtan alongside seeing all our Guru's saaj being used to sing shabad kirtan (and maybe getting a chance to play them yourselves and maybe arrange for yourselves to learn).
You will have the opportunity to do this in the 1st 3 weeks of April.
See the events section for dates and venues:
http://rajacademy.com/
Wahe-Guru