Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Brothers helping on Laavan

Brothers helping on Laavan

singh1234 · 28 Feb 2006

Gurfateh Ji I was asked for my opinions on Gursikh weddings, and in particular why it was wrong for the brothers of the bride to help the bride around when the laavan are being performed. I know this is what happens in 90% of punjabi weddings, but i want the Gursikhi perspective if possible. I am pretty sure it is wrong, but cant explain why. I think Gurughars in India also dont allow this. Could anyone help with this with an explanation as to why it is wrong/why isit ok? Gurfateh Ji

Re: Brothers helping on Laavan

Gurpreet Sumra · 28 Feb 2006

this is wrong.In sikhism both genders have equal status. Those who do it they are knowingly or unknowingly trying to portray that women are inferior then men. Also after anand karaj husband and wife has to spend their life together, so they should do it bythemselves without any assistance from any relative.

Re: Brothers helping on Laavan

SRM · 28 Feb 2006

Unless the girl is disabled, blind or very nervous - then there is NO need or NO requirement for brothers to stand around and help the bride do Parkarma. Sadly its become a fashion that girls need brothers. Not knowing that this started when a girl was disabled or struggled to walk due to nerves or physical disability.

Re: Brothers helping on Laavan

singh one · 28 Feb 2006

Its wrong because only Guru Ji is our support and helper, not any human beings. I think this started back in Punjab when the girl would be wrapped up in so much cloth etc, so that her face could not be seen, and she couldn't really see where she was going, so they helped her...manmat.

Re: Brothers helping on Laavan

Kaur · 28 Feb 2006

Because Singhnis don't need help walking! For punjabis: Back in the day when women used to have a really really big 'ghund' they couldn't see where they were going so the brothers would guide them but its absolutely unneccessary in this day and age.

Re: Brothers helping on Laavan

~l~ · 28 Feb 2006

singhnis can walk by themselves. how about sisters start helping their brother walk around too, just in case he can't make it. lol.

Re: Brothers helping on Laavan

Deaogan · 28 Feb 2006

According to one of bhai sahib bhai Randhir Singh ji's bachans, brothers helping at lavan is wrong, a lot of the weddings that happen today are wrong.

Re: Brothers helping on Laavan

guruji's_Student · 28 Feb 2006

Its almsot saying... that the girls are weak .. as theyre brothers are having to take them around guru ji ? Im not to sure.. but this is wah i think bull chuk maaf

Re: Brothers helping on Laavan

sanjo · 28 Feb 2006

yh tis wrong, i strongly believe its wrong. i read somewhere that a disabled hindu girl was helped round once n then it just caught on to indian society and then sikhi. guru sahib has given women shaster aswel, he is telling us that women r equal to men n that its also a womans duty as a khalsa to defend herself and humanity. she does not require any help from brothers etc cos guru ji expects her to fight for herself if the time comes. i also dont believe in dressing the women and men up in flashy bright red n expensive clothes. the women luk like prostitutes no fence with all that nasty jewllery i.e kokkey, they luk like cattle with those nose rings lol again no fence to anyone. and the men look like wannabe kings in der goldish kurteh pujameh. its funny how the guys think they have to keep abit of a dhari for the wedding but then shave it off by the time the party starts lol. stupid man. i luk at "sikh" weddings these dayz n it reminds me of hindu weddings i c on TV. manz its stupid. what a stupid punjabi culture. these aint real anand karaj! i think there was a thread on here with pics of a proper anand karaj at gurdwara tapoban sahib, luk at that, thats brilliant!

Re: Brothers helping on Laavan

ks · 28 Feb 2006

this hindu custom is present because they would marry off their children at a young age, under ten, and the kids didn't know where to go thus they needed to be guided. to allow such at a Sikh wedding is wrong.

Re: Brothers helping on Laavan

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 28 Feb 2006

More importantly this "action" is INSULTING to GURU JI....and to the Sangat . How can we tolerate a bunch of "brothers and what not" standing around, blocking everyones view of Guru Ji..and taking away the sangat's serenity and peace...all that milling around like around a aaloo gandeh stall in the market is NOT Showing RESPECT to GURU JI. Just look at a Christian wedding..so dignified and calm..everyone in his place..and all.... comapre to our Anad Karaj... a bunch of guys and woemn get up..suround Guru Ji..looking here and there..pulling-pushing the bride/groom along as if they are unable to move..what a farce !! Before this some idiots even used to THROW FLOWERS..and Cut paper bits on the couple...littering the Gurdawraa and destroying the beautiful carpets..these idots didnt even know that they are throwing flowers on humans while the GURU JI is IGNORED ?? RESPECT GURU JI..remain SEATED in the Guru Darbar at all timses except in ARDASS. STOP such manmatt practises... Jarnail Singh.

Re: Brothers helping on Laavan

satnam · 01 Mar 2006

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh Nothing is insulting to Guruji, i beg to differ bhaisahib.......i think we take this insult thing abit too far. Who decides Guruji gets insulted? Do we or does guruji? Why would guruji be insulted? what could constitute an insult to anyone who is imbibed in naam?? On the contrary, guruji would let these people see for themselves what they are doing serves no purpose. Let them do it but sincerely try and educate them.......unfortunately not many of them consciously know exactly what they are doing. my two cents.... satnam singh

Re: Brothers helping on Laavan

Manjit Singh · 01 Mar 2006

True Say Gyaniji. RESPECT GURU JI! People treat GURU JI as a commdidity, "we hired the Gurdwara so we can do what we like! we have given money". People hire flower arrangers, waiters/waitresses, caterers in the Gurdwara. All for the Pakhand. I have seen a beautiful flower arrangement made of a wedding put in front if Guru Mahraj and then taken away by the family as soon as the wedding finished. Brothers helping at laavan gets more and more ridiculas, sometimes 10 brothers/cousin borthers stand, sometimes the brothers interchange between lavaan so everyone gets a chance. The worst form of beadbi in a Gurdwara happens on weddings. And the Gurdwara committees watch whilst the Golak Revenue increases.

Re: Brothers helping on Laavan

singh1234 · 01 Mar 2006

ok....but so far there have been no absolutely clear reasons why this is manmat. theres a few common sense reasons yes, i.e. the girl can walk herself. but there havent been any reasons as per gurmat why someone would not. i was thinking more along the lines of someone providing links to what bhai sahib had to say, or other gursikhs. not a lame attempt by just sayin "no its wrong because girl can walk herself"

Re: Brothers helping on Laavan

RightOn · 01 Mar 2006

it's a hindu ravaj and it crept into Sikhi. If the woman has 2 legs that work properly, then why does she need anyone to help her with Laavan. It's useless so don't do it.

Re: Brothers helping on Laavan

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 01 Mar 2006

Author: satnam Date: 03-01-06 03:52 waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh Nothing is insulting to Guruji, i beg to differ bhaisahib.......i think we take this insult thing abit too far. Who decides Guruji gets insulted? Do we or does guruji? Why would guruji be insulted? what could constitute an insult to anyone who is imbibed in naam?? On the contrary, guruji would let these people see for themselves what they are doing serves no purpose. Let them do it but sincerely try and educate them.......unfortunately not many of them consciously know exactly what they are doing. my two cents.... satnam singh <<<<<<<<<<<<<<, Now its veer ji who is taking things too far !! IF standing around, milling , whispering, guiding "adults"..posing for Video cameras, photos etc in the DARBAR is not an "insult" what is ?? GURU JI is above all this..I AGREE. Remember How Dattu Ji, the angry son of Guru Angad Ji, KICKED GURU AMARDASS JI FROM BEHIND as Guur Ji sat on His Takhat - in Full DARBAAR. Did Guru Ji take that as an "insult" ? NO GURU JI instantly got up and caught hold of Dattu's foot saying..Beteh, my old and hardened back must have hurt your tender foot so badly..please let me massage it for you.... THAT is GURU JI..and we are the Dattus.. BUT Does THAT mean that we will just sit by and let anyone ( say mad enough to climb up on the Palki Sahib and give a KICK to Guru granth Ji Sahib parkashwaan and push the Bir off the palki ??...I agree this is abit extreme...but going by what happened to Guru Amardass Ji in real life..its not far fetched either.. so who will decide if its an INSULT or NOT ?? A line has to be drawn...and this line says..When GURU JI DARBAAR is in session...its an "insult" to GURU JI..to speak loudly, answer your cell phone, walk about aimlessly, cut the line to push your way front to matha tek earlier than those in front....push or shove to take Parshaad first....etc etc....all those actions one normally WOULDNT DARE TO DO if attending say the Darbaar of Queen Elizabeth.or even meeting session with George Bush !! I once attended some ones wedding..and was astonished to see an Elderly grandfather who had his grandson on his shoulder... the small boy was pulling out clumps of his grandaddy's beard, slapping his face, and then pulled his dastaar off his head...BUT all this didnt make one bit of difference to the old man...he just behaved as nothing happened..he held off his boy with one arm..and began to pick up his dastar off the ground and tie it back on his head.....Hum Malleh tun uujal karteh...GURU JI is indeed Naam imbued but we shoudl KNOW our LIMITS... Jarnail Singh

Re: Brothers helping on Laavan

LK · 09 Mar 2006

What is the point? If the bibi says she needs help, then do help here, but since you don't usually wear high heels inside the Guru Durbar (as a matter of fact you don't wea shoes) you don't really need help to walk. Unless she asks for it, there is no reason why she should be pushed around.

Re: Brothers helping on Laavan

gatka player · 09 Mar 2006

satnam ji, i dont think guru ji would TAKE it as an insult but rather its more of an insult TO him