Forum
Mundavani
Mundavani
Sukhdev Singh · 04 Dec 2003
VaheGuruJeeKaaKhalsa
VaheGuruJeeKeeFateh
I’ve just managed to get my hands on the latest book by Gyani Gurdit Singh called Mundavani.
It gives an account of the research covering half a century made by Gyani jee on the subject of ragmala.
The book has photographs of Puratan Birs from Sikh reference library Amritsar, Patiala, Kartapur, Patna Sahib, Damdama Sahib, Nabha, Rawalpindi, Goindwal, Tarn Tarn, Bhai Keh, Bihar, Akal Takth, Hazoor Sahib, Lahore, Kahnghar, Sagri, Deradun, Baranpur, Chandighar.
This book is must read for all.
VaheGuruJeeKaaKhalsa
VaheGuruJeeKeeFateh
Re: Mundavani
Kulbir Singh · 04 Dec 2003
Veer Sukhdev Singh jeeo,
If you have an extra copy, please send one to me in Toronto. I am hoping you got an extra copy from Punjab, for us in Toronto.
I spoke to Giani Gurdit Singh jee last year, when he was very busy working on this book Mundavani. I believe that he has done great service to Panth Khalsa by writing a book about the reality of Raagmala.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Mundavani
Sukhdev Singh · 04 Dec 2003
I knew veer jee you would ask me for a copy.So I brought a spare copy. just email me your postal details & I post it to you.
As for others who require copies of the book, I know that Singh Brothers Amritsar have this book but it was selling fast as they had sold a quater of their stock within 24hrs of recieving the book.
Re: Mundavani
jaspreetkaur · 04 Dec 2003
wjkk wjkf
i had the chance to look throught this book...ohh man the pictures provided of maraj de saroops that do not contain ragmala are enough to convince even the most stubborn person. It's an amazinggg book!
wjkk wjkf
Re: Mundavani
pk · 04 Dec 2003
Will this book be made available in canada anytime soon?
[%sig%]
Re: Mundavani
tohada daas · 05 Dec 2003
veer ji do we have this book in english
plsssssssssss tell me.....................
i am dying to have a look at this book....
i live in australia so if anyone could give this book to amolak singh ji in any samagam would be a gr8 upkaar...
plsss tell me more about this book thanx
gurfateh ji
Re: Mundavani
Jagroop Singh · 05 Dec 2003
Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh
Any chance of an English translation...?
Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh
Re: Mundavani
Singhstah · 11 Dec 2003
Vaheguroo Ji ka khalsa
Vaheguroo Ji ki fateh
Will this book be made available in the UK?
Re: Mundavani
Psingh1984 · 11 Dec 2003
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa
Waheguru Ji ki Fateh
at other times when we give u examples of prathan birs u guys say that they arent authentic but now that u guys have gave a fake list of birs that do not contain ragmala. All of the sudden their authentic. haha u guys are jokes.
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa
Waheguru Ji ki Fateh
Parminder Singh
DDT
holla at my email if you got any questions [address removed]
[%sig%]
Re: Mundavani
Mundavani Singh · 11 Dec 2003
Parminder Singh:
You have shown your pitiable intellect through this email. Have you read this book yet? Have you seen those pictures in the book yet? I am pretty sure you have not because this book came out just a week ago.
To reject something without reading only shows that you have confined yourself to the narrow thinking of whichever organization your belong to. May God have mercy on you so that you give up your Muslim type of thinking.
Please post little bit more thought-provoking post than this. Your last one was pathetic.
Re: Mundavani
Psingh1984 · 11 Dec 2003
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa
Waheguru Ji ki Fateh
Sorry if I offended you but my beliefs towards guru ji's bani are very strong, instead you call me pitiable and refer to me as having a muslim mentality. I thought you so called singhs were panthic and didnt post conversial topics on this message board. I guess the rest of the panth has a muslim mentality as well.
Singhji, I do not need to see those pictures neither do I prejudge. To tell you the truth, I personally dont even like to touch contraversial topics as it is better to stick to guru kian sakhian so that we are motivated to become better sikhs. Instead you prejudged me and basically called me a muslim, where is our pyar. I am sorry if it seemed as I was offensive, but the truth should be put forth. Every other old bir is considered to be unauthentic, but all of the sudden these are reliable.....stop contradicting yourselves. My suggestion to the sangat is to go to India for yourselves and do darshan of all the old saroops that have rag mala. Just a few examples are such as, the small saroop written by 10th guruji at Bhai Dala's home in Damdama Sahib, the big saroop at Har ki Pauree in Golden Temple, and many others old saroops that also have signatures of authenticity at takats. I would also recommend the sangat to view the original list that was given as from my knowledge many of those references are FALSE.
Parminder Singh
AKJ (Now I am a sikh and no longer a muslim...right?)
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa
Waheguru Ji ki Fateh
Re: Mundavani
Tohada Daas_/\_ · 11 Dec 2003
heheheheh thats a good one...... dear DDT'S please read this book b4 saying anything okai...............
gurfateh ji
(plsss let me know guys do we have this book in english?)
Re: Mundavani
Dilbagh Singh Puri · 11 Dec 2003
WGJKK, WGJKF:
I am interested to have this book Even from Amritsar. Please get me the phone number of Singh Brothers. So that I can tell them to send this book to me.
Thanks.
WGJKK, WGJKF:
Re: Mundavani
Tohada Daas_/\_ · 11 Dec 2003
www.singhbrothers.com
official website of singh brothers
thanx
gurfateh jio
Re: Mundavani
Tohada Daas_/\_ · 11 Dec 2003
SINGH BROTHERS
* Bazar Mai Sewan, Near Golden Temple, Amritsar-143 006
* S.C.O. 98,City Center, Amritsar-143 001
Tel:+91-183- 2550739,2545787 Telefax: +91-183-2543965
E-Mail: [address removed]
Re: Mundavani
the singh · 11 Dec 2003
Psingh, don't you understand? He criticized your mentality at prejudging the contents of the book without ever having even seen it. It's not your affiliation or your stance on raag maalaa that is muslim like, but your mentality at condemning something as false without even knowing what it is.
And what contradiction are you going on about? Birs that have been called unauthentic have been shown to be unauthentic. It's not just some kid sitting at home typing up whatever comes into his head (as you seem to be doing about this book), people have actually researched these birs. And usually it's not the bir that's called unauthentic, but certain portions that have been added in. If there are birs with and other birs without raag maalaa, then clearly, only one set can be authentic. Right? It's only a matter of proving which ones are the real ones. The little bir that you've mentioned, do you have any documentation on this? Photographs or anything? Or is it all based on hearsay?
And what's with this us versus them mentality that you have? That's why things never get resolved, because people like you get all irrational and turn it into an us versus them fight instead of taking a look at what's actually being said. You really need to grow up.
Re: Mundavani
Tohada Daas_/\_ · 12 Dec 2003
yeah well said 'the singh',
its a very good effort by akj's, they worked hard on proving that what they say, they mean it....
even though i havent seen the book.............still i say well done, for atleast coming forward with some superb prrofs.
i always explore through all the jathebandees and history etc etc to finalize what i have to follow, unfortunately we all are standing on different platforms but have same destination.
i would be thankful to taksal if they put up the pictures of the old birs online and say thier words as well.
i also request the akj administrator to contact the author of book and ask for authorisation to upload it to internet, so that we all can have a look too.
thanx
deg teg fateh
panth ki jeet
bole sonehaal SATSRIAKAL
gurfateh jio
Re: Mundavani
kooker · 12 Dec 2003
The Mudhavani book was NOT written by the AKJ. It was written by Giani Gurdit Singh of the Kendri Singh Sabha.
Parminder Singh (Psingh1984) stated:
"U GUYS say that they arent authentic but now that U GUYS have gave a fake list of birs that do not contain ragmala. All of the sudden their authentic. haha U GUYS are jokes."
What is up with the U GUYS bit, Psingh1984 ? Are you attributing anything and everything that is anti-RaagMala to the AKJ ? I assume Parminder Singh and others of his intellect also blame the AKJ for the anti-Raagmala verses in Suraj Paraksh ?
PSingh1984 has not even read or even seen Giani Gurdit Singh's book, yet has the audacity to blindly condemn it. This type of obnoxious behaviour is no different than of those self-styled Sanatan Pandits & Nangs who proclaim Mirabai’s verses are part of Dhur-ki-Banee (see reference below).
The site says:
One Shabad (hymn) of Mirabhai is found in the 'Bhai Bhano wali Bir' (version of Adi Guru Durbar), also known as 'Kharri Bir' as Bhai Bhano came from the village Kharra, Punjab. This is a text recognised by Sanatan Sikhs as equal to the Adi Guru Durbar version found in mainstream gurudwaras today, but is not recognised by British Raj-nurtured Tat-Khalsa Singh Sabhia Sikhs and their descendants today, the S.G.P.C.
What does our "Scholar" Parminder Singh think about MiraBai's verses in the 'Kharri Bir" ? Are you free to doubt MiraBai, but nothing after it ?
Re: Mundavani
Mkhalsa · 13 Dec 2003
Why is a link to a NANG site allowed by the moderators?
by linking to them you give them more hits from search engines and legitmacy.. u can quote but please dont allow nang links.. esp since someone might go there and get brainwashed.
Re: Mundavani
Harinder Singh · 16 Dec 2003
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa, Waheguru ji ki Fateh!
I cant seem to find the book on the website - I looked under the authors but there did not appear to be anything called 'Mundavani'. Has anybody got any ideas????
Thanks in advance
Re: Mundavani
Khalsaspirit · 13 Apr 2007
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Khalsa jio,
Check out following link and see but Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh ji say about Mundavani. It is in Gurmukhi. Sorry English translation not available yet.
http://www.khalsaspirit.com/files/Mundavani.pdf
Guru Mehar Karay
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: Mundavani
Hardeep Singh · 14 Apr 2007
Has Gyani Gurdit Singh been excommunicated from the panth? Also are their still photos available of the Guru Granth Sahib birs that don't have raag mala in.
Could someone please upload these photos!
[%sig%]
Re: Mundavani
singh5 · 14 Apr 2007
Gyani Gurdit Singh was never excommunicated, I don't know where you get this idea from. Gyani jee passed away a couple months ago.
Re: Mundavani
Hardeep Singh · 14 Apr 2007
I heard from someone. Is the book available in english and could someone please post the pics?
[%sig%]
Re: Mundavani
Hardeep Singh · 14 Apr 2007
I just found some photes, on gyani jee's website. "Mundavani"
http://www.gianigurditsingh.com/booksmadavani.htm
[%sig%]
Re: Mundavani
CSJ · 14 Apr 2007
People have seen the power of raagmala. Some people can prove anything because they know how to play with words. it does not mean that it is not bani. Whole panth know it is bani whole Saint samaj know it is bani inluded (all bramganees). Who care about some body writting his own thoughts or small group of people who dont belive in it.
We all read bani very carefully so we dont miss even one matra you guys dont even read two angs of GGS JI.
There is one guy saying Japji sahib is incomplete other guy saying jaap sahib is not bani. They know how to play with words they can proove it too. What is diffrence between those guys and the one who write this book.
"PLease put this post on. Thank you"
Personally I will not read such types of books to pollute my mind with it.
[%sig%]
Re: Mundavani
singh5 · 14 Apr 2007
If everyone thought like you CSJ, we'd still have kachi bani like "Jit Dar Lakh Muhammadaan" and "Ratanmala" in Guru Granth Sahib (which were removed). Interestingly, Ragmala is always at the end of these kachi bani compositions. Giani Gian Singh writes that the Panth had decided to remove Ragmala at one point. It is people with blind-faith and those who refuse to look at the facts that are making a mess of the Ragmala issue. Rather than saying "My Baba says so and he's a brahmgyani" why don't you actually try to present your points in some logical fashion?
Rather than jumping straight to insults and saying "you guys" why not be civil?
Re: Mundavani
Prabhjoyt Singh · 15 Apr 2007
which bir was given the Gurgaddi? and does that bir contain raagmala or not ? i think the answer to this question should really end all debate right?
if anyone knows then please do say so.
[%sig%]
Re: Mundavani
Hardeep Singh · 15 Apr 2007
The word Brahmgyani gets used so much!! How do you know if someone is a brahmgyani, do you have the avasta to see their avasta.
Well Said Singh 5
[%sig%]
Re: Mundavani
singh5 · 15 Apr 2007
The original Damdami bir cannot be found. If it could be found, indeed, all questions would be answered.
Re: Mundavani
CSJ · 15 Apr 2007
"The word Brahmgyani gets used so much!! How do you know if someone is a brahmgyani, do you have the avasta to see their avasta."
"My Baba says so and he's a brahmgyani"
First I am not quoting from any particular saint I am talking about in gernal. Above quotes about My Baba says so and he's a brahmgyani. I didnt say that but hear a lot for AKJ that Bhai Randhir Singh JI is brahmgyani he said not to do that, or he did that so we going to do the same. Is,nt it is same as folowing any saint. Dont get me wrong I respect Bhai Randhir Singh ji. To me you use saint word or bhai word doing the same thing. Also it is only AKJ who dont belive in raagmala.
I dont need to tell if I have avasta or not.
Please tell me what alam or hindus get benift by adding ragmala.
What is the damage you think we are having . NO bobdy Means no body have right to add or remove any single word from GGS Ji. Only GGS ji is what we have without any mixup from any body.
We are discusing this not fighting.
If it is not bani how come it have same power.
[%sig%]
Re: Mundavani
singh5 · 15 Apr 2007
The argument against Ragmala is not based on Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh at all. He has only made a very brief mention of the topic in his book. The evidence comes from scholars like Shamsher Singh Ashok or Gurmukhs like Tara Singh Narotam or historians like Kavi Santokh Singh and Giani Gian Singh.
You asked "what alam or hindus get benift by adding ragmala". I think I can best answer that with another question: what benefit did anyone have in adding things like Ratanmala, "Jit dar lakh muhammadan" or the Shabad by Mira Bai? These were all present in many puratan saroops. If you want I can show you pictures. But the thing is, these all came before Ragmala. Ragmala was the last of the kachi banis in old saroops. So if the kachi bani after Mundavani and the Salok were removed, why wasn't Ragmala, which came after those?
And as for "same power" how do you know what power Ragmala has? It is a composition written about the song a dancing girl sings to impress a Brahmin.
Just tell me this much: which Guru Sahib wrote Ragmala?
Re: Mundavani
Khalsaspirit · 15 Apr 2007
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Khalsa jio,
This is for Bhai or bibi "CSJ" jio, if you feel any kachee bani is Gurbani it may be fine with you but when you bring it before panth then prove it. Since this documentary book is before tha panth
there was an open challenge by a Gursikh from United States that if someone can prove this is a Gurbani he/she will be rewarded Rupees 1 lakh in Chandigarh Punjab. So if you have any facts we are suggesting you to go there with any baba of Sant Corporation and win that reward.
It’s been three years since the book is in market no baba of Sant Corporation took that challenge. Even Giani Gurdit Singh ji was called in December 2004 at Sri Akal Takhat Sahib by pressure from this Baba Corporation, Giani Gurdit Singh ji went there but no one could prove against his documentary book.
Bhai or bibi "CSJ" jio we regard your respect for our Guru dhan dhan Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji which every Sikh should have but at the same time if
we trying with our mat that this kahee bani is Gurbani then that will be considered as disrespect. We remember on a different post we told you very clearly on raagmala. Now your
Quote "Also it is only AKJ who don’t belive in raagmala"
We have no idea why you repeated the same. Why don't you do some research before you come here. Throwing anything from top of your mind and speaking loudly which is clear from you wording would not make any difference or prove some thing. Now regarding AKHAND KIRTANI JATHA,
let me remind you again we are not talking on behalf of jatha but as per our experience with jatha thier SINGH/SINGHNIA with Guru Sahib's Kirpa do not throw anything from their mouth without any knowledge of what they are saying. Any way topic is not about jatha for which you can open up another topic. Now to prove that you are 101% wrong in your quote above, following is the list of personalities of Sikh Panth considered as Scholars in panth who do not consider RAAGMALA to be GURBANI.
1. Pandit Tara Singh Nirotam
2. Giani Dit Singh of Singh Sabha Movement
3. Prof. Gurmukh Singh of Singh Sabha
4. Giani Gian Singh
5. Sadhu Gobind Singh Nirmala
6. Pandit Hazara Singh
7. Basant Singh
8. Bhai Kahan Singh
9. Master Mota Singh
10. Giani Sher Singh
11. Baba Teja Singh
12. Master Mehatab Singh
13. Master Tara Singh
14. Giani Nahar Singh
15. Principal Dhram Anant Singh
16. Principal Teja Singh
17. Principal Ganga Singh
18. Prof. Dr. Ganda Singh
19. Sardar Shemsher Singh Ashok
20. Prof. Dr. Sahib Singh
21. Pandit kartar Singh Dakha
22. Bawa Harkishen Singh
23. Prof. kartar Singh
24. Prof. Gurbachan Singh Talib
25. S. Randhir Singh Research Scholar
26. Giani Hira Singh
in last but not least
27. Principal Gurmukh Singh
Now from above list tell us who is from jatha and the answer is none of them so you are ( as we said before )101% wrong in your quote. Now we are wondering what is your resource of research. Or there is no research just hear say.
As from some of your posts you seem like a very concerned Sikh and we can not believe that how you come up with this conclusion. Our benti to your charan is Bhai sahib or bibi jio do not be in the same queue as some others with their eyes shut and ears closed. Be a Guru ka Sikh and be a judge you self. Read Gurbani carefully if you can from Ik onkar to Nanak Naam milay tan Jivan then you will clearly see that what the difference between Gurbani and kachee bani is. And next time when you talk about this subject then be prepared. Do not believe those hear says to conclude on this topic. Even SIKH REHAT MARYADA has to say raagmala is disputed. Why it have to say only for this bani not any other bani of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji and the answer is very clear it is not Gurbani.
Further more Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh ji very briefly talked on this topic. In his article he mentioned the meaning of "Mundavani" and "Mudavani" came in Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji. Please read his article while opening up both shabads in front of you.
Guru Mehar Karay
and defiantly he will guide thru his path.
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Benti to Admin: Admin khalsa jio although the topic is Mudavani either book or shabad of seal but still if some like to twist it to Raagmala then our benti to you do not close the topic let it be open until Guru kirpa naal resolved at least on this forum even if it is not still keep it open.
Re: Mundavani
Prabhjoyt Singh · 16 Apr 2007
singh jio
what about the Damdama bir that is considered by some veers to have been given Gurgadhi is that original or not? does it contain raagmala? ratan mala? JDLM? what about Bhai Mani Singh birs or Baba Deep Singh birs? do they contain raagmala?
[%sig%]
Re: Mundavani
Hardeep Singh · 16 Apr 2007
Bhai Sahib Singh5, when ratanmala was known as gurbani to the panth, who did they think the author was.
Also who did really write ratanmala?
[%sig%]
Re: Mundavani
jassmannn · 16 Apr 2007
I can't believe we are having this debate.
If someone wrote a thesis saying that there was no god, would everyone beleive it, because someone could provie it scientifically.
It has been accepted by the Sikh Panth, and has been included in all editions of the complete Guru Sahib since the guru Gaddi.
Why dispute something, as if we have understood the meaning of all bani. The bani is written in Raag, and the culmination is raag mala.
Re: Mundavani
CSJ · 16 Apr 2007
In the above list I don’t see any name who is big shaheed or who has lots of kammae which sikhs recognize. All of them are writer. All this Prof. etc. they only tell people what ever they doing are wrong. Why in this century people are finding all these things wrong. Why not in Guru Gobind singh ji is time or after gurshikh like Baba deep singh ji, Bahi Mani singh ji or Baba budha ji (who has seen 6 Gurus). Bhai Gurdas ji. it means we know much more then those people. About mera bai and other thing. Guru sahib told us it is khari bir matter closed.
My questions are why now?
1) people think about raag maala.
2) Don’t belelive in shabad (3 letters written by Guru Arjun dev ji and completed 4rth in front of Guru Ramdas JI. They say at that time He was not Guru come on!!!.)
3) Don’t belelive in Hemkunt sahib.
4) Don’t belelive in Dasam Granth sahib.
5) Have questions about Guru mantar.
6) Simran (which is back bone of sikhi).
7) Bhai Bala ji’s was real.
8) How long is mool mantr. The list keep going on.
I think mostly writters or dheras or jathebandis. add to reht or take out something from our sikhi. I think keep it orignal no addition or subtacation.
About you saying I go to some saint I dont need to go to anybody I have greatest of all GGS. I need only his guidance.
About the power of bani Read it few times a day and find out.
I don’t think we will agree on each others facts because our mind are set.
[%sig%]
Re: Mundavani
Gursimran Singh · 16 Apr 2007
There was a raagi Singh, Bhai Jeeta Singh, who stayed with Sant Gurbachan Singh Jee. One day in Lahore the Muslims were having a raag smagam, and because Bhai Jeeta Singh loved raag so much, he decided to go to see it too. Bhai Jeeta Singh went on stage and asked for a couple minutes to do keertan in raag and the Mulsims laughed and said, God didn't give raag to Sikhs, only Muslims were blessed with raag. After hearing this, Bhai Jeeta Singh was hurt and he went back and told Sant Jee the whole ordeal.
Sant Jee told him he wasn't to leave for 40 days. Sant Jee put him in a room and said food will be made and given to you here, and whether it takes you 18 hours a day or 20 hours a day, do sava lakh paat of Raag Mala. After 40 days, then come out. So after those 40 days, that smagam came up again in Lahore. Sant jee told him that they'll give you time on stage this time.
So Bhai Jeeta Singh went back. And the Muslims said he could have a couple minutes. They started giving him a vaja, but Bhai Jeeta Singh said to just put the vaja off to the side. When Bhai Jeeta Singh started doing alaap of Basant Raag, the vaja started playing itself. Noone was playing it. They had only given him a couple minutes, but Bhai Jeeta Singh went for 4 straight hours. Afterwards, the Muslims were shocked and started falling at his feet and saying, no, God did in fact give Sikhs raag.
The power of Raag Mala! The power of Gurbani!
To finish the sakhi, this being a victory for the Sikh Panth, when Bhai Jeeta Singh went back to Sant Jee, Sant Jee said, for being so victorious, you can have anything you want. Whatever you want you'll get it. Bhai Jeeta Singh goes, Sant Jee I have one ichaa, one desire. When the time comes for me to leave my sareer, I want to leave doing keertan in sangat. Sant Jee said then that's how you'll leave.
So when the time came for Bhai Jeeta Singh to go, he was doing keertan in sangat. And when Bhai Sahib would do keertan, he always did with so much love. He would sing raising his hand being so attuned to it. Bhai Jeeta Singh turned his hand towards Guru Granth Sahib Jee, sung, piare, 'Jio Bhaavai Tio Raakh Lai'. Bhai Jeeta Singh left his sareer right then with his hand still in the air.
Re: Mundavani
singh5 · 16 Apr 2007
CSJ,
I don't mean to be insulting, but your points are all born out of lack of research and general ignorance.
The Akal Takhat Sahib decision and Rehit Maryada says clearly that Ragmala may or may not be read and is an issue that has not been resolved. This is actually a step back from the original which said clearly NOT to read Ragmala.
The original Birs are not traceable and so there is no decisive answer to this question by looking at these Birs.
Here are some pictures (low quality but I can provide better ones):
This Saroop was very special because it says in it that it has been compared letter by letter with the Kartarpuri Bir and not to change anything. It ends at Mundavani
[img]http://groups.msn.com/_Secure/0SgC7D9oW!l6o*Q5ALVOQJ51jOezumhD5VR1l8Kdp1q1RMJyMZBryjBuFQ7AcqhiKV4RjovPSPFMvu3kvYjVQDryzKrENSuaTNuGTCu7nHl8Mqps2lpcJTw/Picture029.JPG?dc=4675618826804401697[/img]
[img]http://groups.msn.com/_Secure/0SgD3DdIWA12o*Q5ALVOQJ7yBS3ee3kKQIqH4WmWVIUUqAV2*a*ge82SfLkyp1FtEfvVdbtujlHH4oZlUvEyIYGCmLrlLfdqqXjd9EZgc6aNamJAESAoQDA/Picture030.JPG?dc=4675618826812409425[/img]
This is the Saroop in the Patiala Maharaja's family. This saroop was prepared by copying from the original saroop because it was for the Maharaja and he could afford it:
[img]http://groups.msn.com/_Secure/0SQCJDzYWFi*KHGe5iJAYZ3hqoMz8JKhzTlJjlrPGexTxnTi9hsCuhTmruOBWOK*LAxIyf9UtvVjUxZU21yHO1izYUxgk9dSzEDRH658SdVxjVexEis!0fg/File00111.jpg?dc=4675565952735648653[/img]
[img]http://groups.msn.com/_Secure/0SQDWDzYWFy*KHGe5iJAYZ4imjTKuUwzrQDSTf5ui6k8TbcCGL*AuRltEH0XlppoUxEbBfTLEu3wED5dHvD62tT0WV45IVOXOleUIocSvJ2ROWePVagqZEw/File00120.jpg?dc=4675565952738803068[/img]
Notice that this saroop ends at Mundavani and Salok.
This Saroop is from 1734
[img]http://groups.msn.com/_Secure/0SQApDvkWHWJDt3Cql2AXhxUKDMthIXajPOfOULdf1EpvW8OSvKImYMRcQ8fP2yuuEnIqtDe1SKksnrZdmb1YxtC4yyrUZG7YwayjUQBTgqLpGd*kbjuK3Q/ragmala10.jpg?dc=4675565952582986426[/img]
[img]http://groups.msn.com/_Secure/0SQC8D*oWXWJDt3Cql2AXhyl4w6839ECvIs7ibWXxlckfTG1Slp9M69hZY*cmSPLuw3S6rVib9sQSYHTfKjECEUEZKhCwAjCL80gnyFTgC!UGCIsnh73KlA/ragmala20.jpg?dc=4675565952586390585[/img]
Notice that kachi bani like Ratanmala and Hakikat Rah Mukam come before Ragmala.
This Bir is from 1746:
[img]http://groups.msn.com/_Secure/0RwCSDpgWW0NDt3Cql2AXhwHwEP6ZVw!r0O1TSEWiszuNqvHFjceMkbbf9hT*OEWIM2fiVnvz9AF7bmBuCj2htjJdmPPwGnOu48OrpqrMNQk/ragmala.jpg?dc=4675565952616889625[/img]
[img]http://groups.msn.com/_Secure/0SQAJD*sWnGJDt3Cql2AXh1l7G3401GXy4!s5MhnRq!8YB5p14jHth3hKb8a4nJ2fgI3Rr5!N8GudSeb0s6dsp8BHcf7zIMaehCKkuZzZeVyF2yOSccfHZQ/ragmala21.jpg?dc=4675565952625093013[/img]
Ragmala is here, but before it comes kachi bani like "Hakikat Rah Mukam ..", Ratanmala and Jit Dar Lakh Muhammadan.
This saroop is from 1753:
[img]http://groups.msn.com/_Secure/0SADyDRgXgGYctxlbgC2*AKyAjQbRITGQHb9Gw6w64PKxeRvYhmVBK8fzYnBgPOjr5FMLFYb5JpS355zV9VdpOUQ!A5Jv0QSSmWEXAozhzlhfAAAAynIUAg/mudavani.jpg?dc=4675565952643036432[/img]
[img]http://groups.msn.com/_Secure/0SADJD8gWhFJDt3Cql2AXh!0knOW7wFJWXAmKF1J5TAIbXx3n7Zz6HCHneCcGtbRnImr!VXXziyLw92nQ4Zpl*cvU1lvRPUVEksfhdHDsWl4AAAAAAAAAAA/ragmala0.jpg?dc=4675565952648678746[/img]
Notice that after Mundavani starts the kachi bani like "Salok M: 1 Jit Dar..." and before Ragmala, it also has kachi bani "Hakikat Rah Mukam..." I haven't put the pictures of all the kachi bani but just after Mundavani and before Ragmala. If all this kachi bani could be removed, then why would Ragmala be real if it is the last of the kachi banis?
This saroop is from 1823
[img]http://groups.msn.com/_Secure/0SQD8D*oWXGJDt3Cql2AXhxnxtkwD5tY152CNXyigD!Eh2hWs6Gn!XM7vEzPiCkzhuLVsM!VIA8klac9ZgSyQ!qyddB07SycTABFbz9v6PG7G7MDUhUNvRg/ragmala11.jpg?dc=4675565952683922930[/img]
[img]http://groups.msn.com/_Secure/0SQDMGPwW22JDt3Cql2AXh7oMWgHxhy1D3ylAXxi9hWz562E2J9wE9wwykBlPNvJYSA8SssAtSNKvpZOAbtfZiJ2EJ2TYQoefzOc12APAuCFliN3Fz*c3XQ/ragmala22.jpg?dc=4675565952688749201[/img]
You can see kachi bani like Ratanmala and Hakikat Rah Mukam before Ragmala in these pictures
Re: Mundavani
singh5 · 16 Apr 2007
Gursimran Singh,
lets do the math for your story:
125 000 Ragmala paaths in 40 days means 3125 paaths a day. That means 130 paaths an hour. Which in turn means, for 40 days, without an instant of eating, sleeping, going to the bathroom, Bhai Jeeta Singh was doing 2.17 Ragmala paaths a MINUTE. That's physically impossible. Ragmala paath if you do it quickly takes 3 minutes. So you're saying Bhai Jeeta Singh did more than 2 a minute, 24 hours a day and for 40 days, NON-STOP?
I'll let the readers judge how true this could be.
Re: Mundavani
CSJ · 16 Apr 2007
It is possible to do with surti. I know people in toronto who have done 150 japji sahib paths a day.
[%sig%]
Re: Mundavani
singh5 · 16 Apr 2007
150 paaths a day, if you do one in 5 minutes, is completely possible. It would take 12.5 hours. That's very doable.
How are you going to do 2.17 Ragmalas a minute, 24 hours a day for 40 days?
Re: Mundavani
CSJ · 16 Apr 2007
Please show the pictures of Baba deep singh ji's hand written bir ( 4 of them ) and Bhai mani Singh ji's hand written bir and AAd swaroop at Harminder Sahib. There is a hand written pathi by Bhai mani singh ji with arth in england please them check that one too.
"but your points are all born out of lack of research and general ignorance."
Still answar my quetions in previous post. So you mean what ever people are saying we should belive.
Prof. Darshan singh said once in his academy about waheguru mantar that repeating it wont do any good. Each word of waheguru is taken from each juug is wrong people are saying this to increase the importance of mantr. This is written by Bhai Gurdass ji. Waheguru mantr came only in bhatta de bani only not in guru sahibs bani. and keep on going this topic.
So I rather belive Bhai Gurdass ji than Ex jathedar Prof. Darshan singh.
"NO bobdy Means no body have right to add or remove any single word from GGS Ji"
people are already saying to take batta de bani, sikha de bani and bagta de bani out. we will be left with only 300 angs. It means we know more than guru sahib.
Sikh are demaging sikhi more then any body else.
I think
[%sig%]
Re: Mundavani
CSJ · 16 Apr 2007
With Practice and guru sahibs kirpa. People can do mulmantr mala (108) in 2 minutesor even less
[%sig%]
Re: Mundavani
singh5 · 16 Apr 2007
CSJ,
You're neither arguing anything nor are you listening. You haven't given any proof that Ragmala is bani. This isn't some new issue, Giani Gian Singh and Kavi Santokh Singh both said it is not bani and they were much before our time.
If you can FIND the saroops by Baba Deep Singh, I think all scholars would be very interested. Bhai Joginder Singh Talwara spent years looking and he couldn't find them. Same with Bhai Mani Singh saroops. Scholars all are looking for them, but CSJ, if you know the locations, you'll be a star. People that haven't done any research think it's all very simple and just go look at Baba Deep Singh's saroops. Here's news: they can't be found!
The puratan Saroop at Darbar Sahib was written by Gyani Partap Singh and finished in 1908. Not all that puratan.
You are not arguing or debating with any focus or sense. I have not brought up anything about Gurmantar or Bhatt Bani. I believe in both and reject the philosophy of Prof. Darshan Singh and Kala Afghana, etc. But I dont' accept Ragmala.
Re: Mundavani
Khalsaspirit · 16 Apr 2007
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Khalsa jio,
Bhai Gursimran Singh jio, Bhai or bibi CSJ, please again benti to you bring the facts no right left wording. All these stories of Raagi bhai Jeeta Singh and many others proved to be fake and served no purpose to the issue.
Bhai singh5 jio these pictures are convincing.
Bhai Prabjyot Singh jio, spend some money and time on this book you will get all the answers you might have and the same suggetions to others. In fact this book if for those who have doubts.
Now its up to you whether you want to educate your self by spending some time or want to stick with the myths you have which proved to be wrong.
Again Bhai or bibi CSJ jio why someone did not use the power of ragmala to win rupees 1 lakh.
Guru Mehar Karay
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
[%sig%]
Re: Mundavani
CSJ · 16 Apr 2007
My point is people belive in Prof. Darshan Singh and Kala Afghana. So it is possible who ever started this ragamala issue was same like them with big name and own thoughts. There are lots of followers of these people defeding there points Does it mean they are right because one is ex Jatherdare other is writter.
Why all swaroops these days have ragmaala. If these theory was so write why 95% belive in it
[%sig%]
Re: Mundavani
singh5 · 16 Apr 2007
CSJ
Let me lay it out for you:
This is NOT A NEW ISSUE. Prof. Darshan Singh and Kala AFghana have NOTHING to do with this topic! Please absorb that.
All the saroops today have Ragmala because Akal Takhat has said not to publish any saroop without it until this issue is resolved but it's up to individuals whether to read it or not.
As for "95%" people believing in it: have you taken a census? Even if that figure is true, so what? Just because the majority of Sikhs today are monas does that mean cutting hair is ok?
You started off this debate asking why would anyone add anything? I've shown you all the kachi bani that was added. Now answer your own question. Why were these kachi banis added? If these could be taken out then why is Ragmala so important, especially if it is the last of the kachi banis. If it was directly after Mundavani each time, and kachi bani added after, then I might agree that it is real, but it is always after kachi bani.
Admin Note: No further post will be approved unless it brings up some constructive points, is factual and adds to an intellectual discussion.
Re: Mundavani
Gursimran Singh · 16 Apr 2007
Singh5,
I think you may be forgetting the fact that our history is filled with amazing sakhis that cannot be explained by science and/or reason (i.e. Dhan Dhan Baba Deep Singh Jee's sakhi), so in comparison, doing a couple Raag Malas a minute is pretty miniscule.
However, just logically speaking. Doing one JapJi Sahib in 5 minutes amounts to reading approximately 1.6 ang every minute (which you agree is possible). Now why is it not possible to read approximately 2.2 angs/minute which is what it would take to read 125 000 Raag Malas in 40 days?
Re: Mundavani
singh5 · 16 Apr 2007
No no, let's not fudge the math here.
I'm saying 1.6 ang per minute for 12.5 hours. That leaves 11.5 hours to sleep, eat, use the bathroom, do nitnem, etc.
You are suggesting 2.2 Angs a minute NON STOP 24 HOURS A DAY for 40 Days! No time for nitnem, bathing, eating, sleeping, washroom.
So you'd have to be faster and also NEVER STOP. That is clearly impossible.
Re: Mundavani
Khalsaspirit · 16 Apr 2007
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Khalsa jio,
Bhai or Bibi CSJ jio, do not get scared of so easily from those who are arguing bhatt bani and bhagat bani. See that is the problem why issue of ragmala did not resolved until today because Sant corporation is tried to scare general Sikhs that if you let it happen "they" (defination of "they" is the killing part) will do this and that to SGGS. Sant Corp is doing this without any knowledge of what they are talking about and as usal our general Sikhs gets convinced. In fact do you know Giani Gurdit Singh ji also wrote book on Bhatt Bani and Bhagat Bani and they clearly proved it is a Gurbani for those who do not believe in those banis.
That is why we keep insisting to our brothers and sisters that please come out from the web of Sant corporation and please be a reader your self. Be a judge youself. That is but Guru Sahib's philosphy to make you a SAMPOORAN MAN by directing you to Akal Purakh. And with Guru Sahib's kirpa khalsa tradition is still existing so do not even see to those sects to discourge your self who is arguing bhatt bani or bhagat bani. At a proper time those will be answered as Nakli Nirankaris were. Lets stay focus on this issue. We are 100% agree with you
Quote"I think keep it orignal no addition or subtacation".
That is what we are trying to say Keep SGGS as intact as it was when given the GurGaddi by Sahib-a-kamal Guru Gobind Singh ji.
In LAREEDAR saroop from IK Onkar to Tan Man Theevay Hariaa.
Guru mehar Karay
Panth will be on same page one day.
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki Fateh
[%sig%]
Re: Mundavani
CSJ · 16 Apr 2007
There were 2500 old swaroops in darbar sahibs before blue star. They all had raagmala in them. This movement was started mainly by Gian soba singh. There is record in darbar sahib that he came there ask for mafi because of his deed he had worms on his toung. Also i was puuting link of katha about raagmal seem like admi. dont want to put it on please tell me why is that because all the proofs are given in that katha. If we can read this Mundavani book why we dont want to listen to this katha.
Admin Note: This is a debate, you are free to listen to the Katha and write the points you like but we dont' see any point in allowing posts with long lists of files people can listen too.
[%sig%]
Re: Mundavani
Hardeep Singh · 16 Apr 2007
Singh5 and Khalsafore done great seva. Excellent. Bhai Sahib singh5 how did raagmala, ratanmala and other kutchi baanis get into Guru Granth Sahib? So did some next man just put them in?
[%sig%]
Re: Mundavani
singh5 · 16 Apr 2007
Really CSJ? Your lack of any coherent knowledge or research shines forth again. NONE of the saroops in Darbar Sahib had Ragmala eh? Where did you find this brilliant research point? Or are you just making it up on the spot? This is dishonest behaviour.
The Sikh Reference Library had MANY saroops without Ragmala. There are pictures and mentions of these Birs in the Book Mundavani. In fact even today, at Patna Sahib and Hazoor Sahib there are Birs without Ragmala.
As for Sobha Singh: there is no record of him asking for any Maafi. Hundreds of Gursikhs after him have not believed in Ragmala and have not died horrible deaths.
All you're doing is talking CSJ. Please do some real research and present some facts. Scare tactics, thoughts off the top of your head and your speculation just won't cut it. In fact, when you make up facts, it's frankly dishonest.
Hardeep Singh,
You asked why these kachi banis got in. The answer is that well-meaning people thought it would be nice to add things to the bir after the bani. They didn't add the kachi bani into the body of Guru Granth Sahib, only after. They thought it was a seva I guess.
Re: Mundavani
CSJ · 16 Apr 2007
I am not making this up it is in the katha by Bhai Harjinder Singh (Damdami Taksal wale). I belive taksaal has more knowledge than any writter.
[%sig%]
Re: Mundavani
Khalsaspirit · 16 Apr 2007
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Bhai or bibi CSJ jio,
Although we gave answer on what ever question you brought up. Now before we proceed further can we ask for your academic education because first we thought you are a concerned Sikh about Gurbani but seems it’s changing because this is important to further the discussion with you? Although being a Sikh we should not ask you on this public forum because its like showing our self as superior than the one in front (adds to ego) which certainly is not our attention but seems like you are getting the answers you going low n low by your self and ruining the rule of discussion even admin have to get involve. From khalsaspirit.com we like to keep this discussion open with you.
Now you end up with certain website links but ah mere Guru kay piyare that stuff even would not justify the topic. Further more
Quote "There is record in darbar sahib that he came there ask for mafi because of his deed he had worms on his toung".
My dear there is no record for this fake story. Now again that is the problem these stories were so scary 100 years ago even well educated man can believe that because they scared of from worms in tong when they imagine this picture in their minds. That is where this Sant Corporation succeeded and number of fake stories developed with time. Now the Sant corp. never let you go away from their influence so they scare you further no to listen some one else etc. etc.
Bhai or Bibi CSJ jio, for instance lets say that story was real. And that Singh worm in his tong because he condemned ragmala. And as per SANT Corp this was Guru da bhana happened that he had worm in his mouth.
Now my dear Guru da Bhana always remains same for whatever Guru decided to. For example Guru Ki rehat was Guru Ka Bhana and remained same through out last 3 centuries. We follow or not is different story.
Recently Giani Gurdit Singh ji did Akal Chalana (passed away) who according you might did more sin that that Singh mentioned in that fake story. Now listen fact carefully you were here we were here and whole panth was here. Then according to all those junky stories made/spreaded by Sant Corporation did not hold on Giani Gurdit Singh In fact he left the swaas very calmly. So if that junky story Guru Sahib did some thing who did not read ragmala then why Giani Gurdit Singh ji passed away with very calm who actually proved with the facts that ragmala is not Gurbani and actual meaning of Mundavani not fake stories, right left wordings etc etc.
and million others passed away. And this is better of if you do not open up discussion on this because we have the true scary death stories for those who read ragamala and to be honest with you these are not relevent to prove whether it Gurbani as these Sants Corps does to do opposite.
So khalsa jio jagooy (please wake up). Come out this sick and tired web of Sant corp. Be a Sikh of Guru. Now again if you do not want to listen it is up to you.
Guru Mehar Karay,
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
[%sig%]
Re: Mundavani
Gursimran Singh · 16 Apr 2007
"So you'd have to be faster and also NEVER STOP. That is clearly impossible."
Dhan Dhan Baba Deep Singh Jee fighting with his sees in his hand, was that also "clearly impossible"? How about Bhai Randheer Singh Jee going 40 days without food? Do you also think that was "clearly impossible"?
I am sure you do believe in the case of Baba Deep Singh Jee and of Bhai Randheer Singh Jee (at least I would hope so). I am sure you too do have a doubt in your mind, however small it may be, that this sakhi is in fact believeable. However, the fact of the matter is that you are unwilling to acknowledge this sakhi (which is really very small, and much more believable, compared to the other two above sakhis...just ask the readers) because you already have a preconceived notion that Raag Mala is not bani and you do not want to hear or believe in anything that might show otherwise.
Re: Mundavani
singh5 · 16 Apr 2007
Gursimran Singh,
In the very story you posted, it says,
>>>>>>>>>>>
Sant Jee told him he wasn't to leave for 40 days. Sant Jee put him in a room and said food will be made and given to you here, and whether it takes you 18 hours a day or 20 hours a day, do sava lakh paat of Raag Mala. After 40 days, then come out. So after those 40 days, that smagam came up again in Lahore. Sant jee told him that they'll give you time on stage this time.
>>>>>>>>>>>
The writer of the story is not thinking himself of what a miracle this will be. He clearly has not done the math and says it'll take "18 hours a day or 20 hours a day". He thinks this will be enough. The math says that he has to do 2.17 Ramgalas a minute non-stop for 40 days straight. Nothing else. No nitnem, nothing.
If the story had a source, and then it acknowledged the miracle that just took place and went something like, "Bhai Jeeta Singh asked, "how will this be possible with such little time???" and Sant jee said "Guru Sahib will do kirpa!" Then I might accept that the writer had considered the problem in the story. Sadly, this is just a case of making up the story without thinking what it really means. For future editions perhaps a conversation like the one I propose above might be added to increase the authenticity?
The other stories with miracles note that a miracle has taken place. It's verified and has a source. This story has no source and the clear miracle that needs to take place is overlooked and ignored. The writer erroneously thinks it'll take 18-20 hours when that just won't do.
I'd be curious to know if there even EXISTED a Singh called "Bhai Jeeta Singh". If he was such a great Ragi, his recordings must exist? There are katha recordings of Baba Gurbachan Singh so why not Bhai Jeeta Singh? Are there any pictures or references? Where does this particular story come from?
But this still is no proof for the authenticity of Ragmala.
Re: Mundavani
Gursimran Singh · 16 Apr 2007
Singh5,
I really do not have the time nor the desire to go back and forth over any of this, so if you want, you can listen to the katha from the following link:
http://www.gurmatveechar.com/katha.php
If you go to Giani Takhur Singh Jee's Japji Sahib Viakhya, it begins in the last 1-2 minutes of part 22 and goes into the first couple minutes of part 23.
I will say though, you are REALLY stretching with your reasoning as to why the sakhi is not believeable. Acknowledging the miracle for it to be believeable? The "writer" having to have considered the problem first? Having open dialogue in order for YOU to believe it? Give me a break (or maybe it was my fault and you would have felt otherwise had I told you who/where the sakhi came from). Regardless, I'm sure you can ask around and find some Singhs that have known other Singhs that could read all of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee in 10-12 hours. I know I've heard of Singhs being able to do so. It's really not as miraculous as you're trying to make it out to be.
And if you have the sharda, anything and everything is possible without there having to be a questioning of how something will be done. That [i]is[/i] what sharda is all about.
Re: Mundavani
singh5 · 16 Apr 2007
With a story that requires a Singh to do Ragmala every 28 seconds for 40 days non-stop, I really don't think I am the one doing the stretching.
I'm still looking for some kind of pictures or kirtan of Bhai Jeeta Singh. Seeing as he was a Ragi of such a high caliber, they must exist right?
But the final point is, even if we assume this story to be true, it still is not proof of the authenticity of Ragmala.
Re: Mundavani
Khalsaspirit · 16 Apr 2007
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Gursimran Singh jio,
I asked you before please provide some facts if you can even for this fake story. We told you before how these fakes were developed by Sant Corp and scare the people like you. Why do not you ask the website you are referring to or the person referring to provide some kind of facts on this Raagi.
We can tell you this story will be more polished in years to come with more butter and cream under the name of miracles which impress the general Sikhs so that they bring out more money from there pockets and that is these so called parchariks love to obtain as they have no education to earn for living so they depends on these fake stories. And many people love to hear these stories like most kids love comic stories.
So please do not degrade the level of discussion here buy this book and read it if possible buy some for those so called parchariks of Guru ghar whose work is to create more n more duvida (doubt) in General Sikh population so that there shop can earn more money than others. So far none of the post came here from you talked about the subject just right and left fake stories from the sources who do not even know what there formation source is.
Anyway you are bringing good entertainment here.
Guru Mehar karay
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
[%sig%]
Re: Mundavani
confused · 16 Apr 2007
i noticed that gursimran singh talked about preconceived notion on raagmala but i also believe that you do too...im pretty much torn in the middle of raagmala debate but the one thing that always hangs over my shoulder is for the pro-raagmala people - who is the author of raagmala if it is bani? and for the anti-raagmala people i was wondering how kachi bani may have been added to SGGSJ
Re: Mundavani
jassmannn · 17 Apr 2007
Now I now this point can be disputed about raag mala, and as much as the scholars like to think they have found an answer, it's not that simple, else there would not be a debate.
Anyone who reads the bani, say for example Sukhmani Sahib, and the many many references to Brahim Giani, Sant and Sadh, you would know they they are here to guide us. Not scholars, or lectureres, or philosophers.
Now I know many people have qualms abouts sants and whatever, so you should look at the Jeevan, even test them if you want, but I suppose some people are just not destined for it.
But anyway as I say, I'm not a philosopher, and neither can I prove any of the points that I make, But I think if you spent a little less time studying sikhi in a book written by a profesor to find the truth, and read more bani, that is where you would actually be able to tell the difference between Kachi bani or not.
It's not an easy task, but if you endeavour, I'm sure it will pay off.
Re: Mundavani
singh5 · 17 Apr 2007
confused,
The same people that added all the other kachi bani you can see in the above pictures added ragmala. Why? Probably because they thought it was good literature or sounded nice. We can't know for sure.
jassmann,
Who is a brahmgyani? No one has a measuring instrument. Singhs like Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh did not believe in Ragmala and so this isn't an argument supported just by scholars.
Sometimes I wonder if you actually close your eyes and refuse to look at the evidence in front of you. I have yet to find any useful points from pro-Ragmala supporters. Just tell me which Guru Sahib wrote it and give some proof.
Re: Mundavani
CSJ · 17 Apr 2007
Bhai Khalsaspirit
"Now before we proceed further can we ask for your academic education because first we thought you are a concerned Sikh about Gurbani but seems it’s changing "
Why it is important to know my education in this discussion. Any way I am design enginner and I am amritdhari since childhood. I have GGS ji da parkash at home. I think who ever do more simran and seva is more respectable than any thing else. Also I am not saying I do lots of simran etc so dont get me wrong. I have meat lots of saints and prof. etc. My belive is no body should change anything I dont care about avastha of that person. I think bani should be read as it is even without adding bindi etc. because we dont know more than guru sahib. I dont belong to any jathebandi so I dont have to defend thier belive. I just support what I think is right.
That is why I think if you have doubts read it for yourself for few days and try. dont go by books. I what you said about going low and low. I am giving taksaals view on this and the link was katha bo raagmaala by taksali singh. So if it dont match your view does not mean it is low.
I respect all jathebandis but I dont have to agree with everything they say.
[%sig%]
[u]:Unless someone has some FACTS to add to this discussion, it is CLOSED.[/u]