Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

should this shoabth be sung???

should this shoabth be sung???

sikhi · 24 Feb 2006

sang ji i have learned a new shobath from an old tape , well two , and i have a question about both of them! well the first one...agam agochara tera anth na paya, you see its not in the amrit kirtan can i still do this shoabth at a samagam? and the second one is acttually ardaas, its tu takut tum pay ardaas ji-ee pind sab teri raas.. i mean its not in the amrit kirtan. it is a ardaas shobath thing. like its in the tune of the shoabth. Do you think it is okay for me to do this in a samagam, or is it wrong to sing the ardaas like that. To me, when i sing it you feel for rus. but i am not sure if it si okay. can someone give me some advice?

Re: should this shoabth be sung???

, · 25 Feb 2006

Just because a shabad isn't in amrit kirtan doesn't mean you can't sing it. If it is in Guru Granth Sahib, then of course you can. Both shabads are totally fine.

Re: should this shoabth be sung???

sikhi · 25 Feb 2006

thanks for the reply!

Re: should this shoabth be sung???

Lionking (LK) · 26 Feb 2006

Also a Side note, as long as the Shabads can be found in Guru Granth Sahib Ji, Sri Dasam Granth, Bhai Nand Lala Ji's rehitname, and BHai gurdas Ji they are safe =) No problemo with any of the above mentioend shabads =)

Re: should this shoabth be sung???

Manvir Singh Khalsa · 27 Feb 2006

Agree with LionKing. It mentions that in SRM.

Re: should this shoabth be sung???

jee · 27 Feb 2006

vjkk, vjkf what's SRM? vjkk, vjkf

Re: should this shoabth be sung???

fff · 27 Feb 2006

what about bhai gurdaas SINGH? [%sig%]

Re: should this shoabth be sung???

LK · 27 Feb 2006

SRM = Sikh Rehit Maryada, AKA Panth Parvan Rehit Maryada There is no mention of Bhai Gurdas Singhs poetry to be allowed to be sung (also known as the 41 vaar of Bhai Gurdas, however it is erroneous to refer to it as the 41 vaar of BHai Gurdas, since the first Bhai Gurdas didn't write the 41th, and the second Bhai Gurdas, i.e Bhai Gurdas Singh didn't write the first 40). Considering that Bhai Gurdas SINGH lived during the 1760's, i.e. quite a time after Guru Sahib, it would be like singing the composition of Bhai Banda SIngh Bahadur (if he wrote any poetry to begin with) or Bhai Veer Singh ji (who live a lot later, but still a very Gurmukh pyaarey) My conclusion: Bhai Gurdas Singhs composition (which includes pivoh pahul khandey dhar & Vaho Vaho Gobind Singh) should be treated like any other Singh's poetry, i.e. like some Gurmukh on this phorum writing a poem. Is it right for us to sing Bhai Veer Singh Ji's poetry in Guru Sahib Darbar? Although Bhai Veer Singh ji was,without any doubt a mahaaaan Gurmukh, I do not believe that his poety should be read in Darbar, and nor do I think he intended it to either. Same way, I find no reason why Bhai Gurdas the second (AKA BHai Gurdas Singh)'s composition should be sung in the Darbar (royal court) of the greatest poets that have laid their feet on this planet. Bhull chukk maaf