Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

PETA

PETA

S Singh · 24 Feb 2006

Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa waheguru jee kee Fateh. Please take some time to visit the following site www.peta.org It is a site which exposes the kind of cruelty and brutality that is inflicted on animals by large corporations and the factory farm industry. It also contains some very graphic pictures and videos of animal abuse. Animals feel just as much pain as humans do (as one can see from the videos), and no one has the right to inflict such painful cruelty on Gods creatures. I believe that the people who inflict such pain on Gods creatures will be answerable to Dharm Rai. If possible for those Veers and Bhains who work, please also donate some money to the folks at PETA as they are doing alot of good work in trying to help Gods creatures from the people who inflict so much pain on them. If you are unable to donate, then please just spread awareness to the general public about the cruelty inflicted on Animals. We need to be the voice for those who don’t have one. Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh.

Re: PETA

Sherbahadar Singh · 24 Feb 2006

WJKK, WJKF Veer S Singh Ji, I agree with your sentiments towards the cruelty and brutality inflicted upon millions and millions of animals daily and I agree with you that we need to spread public awareness regarding this type of barbarity that ever persists in our so-called "modern" society. However, I do not agree with helping PETA not because of PETA's message, but their methods of delivery. A gora friend of mine stopped his membership with PETA several years ago because he was disgusted with how PETA heavily utilized members of the sex trade industry to convey their message. I am not going to get into detail but if you researched using google, you'd find out what I'm talking about and I'm pretty sure you would be quite disturbed. For example, PETA's own integrity has come under question time and time again. How does it make sense to protest an animal circus by painting women (barely wearing anything) like a tiger and putting them in a cage beside the circus entrance? Don't these people have any sense about what they're doing? There are parents with children going to the circus. Their lack of sensitivity really sickens me and they've got a very long history of doing these kinds of neo-hippiesh things. Methods like this are the kinds they use to denounce animal cruelty. The kind of vegetarianism PETA advocates ("veganism") is beyond that of Sikhism even. According to them, NO animal products (including milk) should be consumed and we should all consume soy milk and a whole bunch of other stipulations. I don't think many Sikhs would agree with that. Other organizations like the WWF, WSPA, various Humane Societies and other Animal Societies do not resort to these types of narrow-minded methods and in my opinion, they are better to help. WJKK, WJKF

Re: PETA

S Singh · 24 Feb 2006

PETA are a waste of time. Recently their media star Maneka Gandhi got clips of Nihang on horses banned in the Rang De Basanti film. She takes animal protection to far. She will drive past poor people dying at the road side but if her or her stooges see an injured dog they go out their way to save it.

Re: PETA

S Singh · 24 Feb 2006

Vaheguru Jee Kaa Khalsa Vaheguru Jee Kee Fateh I understand what you are saying. As a Punjabi, I can understand that some of their methods may seem a little too vulgar for our Punjabi culture. But you have to also understand is what they did at the circus was intended for Goras. This type of stunt may not shock Goras as it does us. Their stunts are for the audience they are doing it for. In a way, the circus incident seems like a bit poetic justice. Anyway, I am not condoning some of their actions. I didn’t even know they did all of this. But the fact that they are doing so much for animals is worthy of praise and admiration. Although you may not agree with one or two stunts PETA did, but please do visit their website just to get general knowledge at the kind of cruelty that is inflicted on animals. That website has opened my eyes on the kind of stuff that happens to animals. If you feel that PETA is not for you, then please visit and support other animal rights organizations such as WSPA.org.uk they are also doing some excellent work in protecting animals from cruelty and abuse. Vaheguru Jee Kaa Khalsa Vaheguru Jee Kee Fateh [%sig%]

Re: PETA

Janwar · 24 Feb 2006

Sherbahadar Singh, What PETA did at the circus was just a publicity stunt. They do these stunts to make people aware of what PETA is and does. I know it may seem a little too extreme for us Sikhs, but they do have the best interest of the Animals at heart when doing these stunts. They are probably one of the leading organizations out their helping animals today. Please take a look at the following video http://www.petatv.com/tvpopup/video.asp?video=training_tragedy&Player=wm&speed=_med After watching this, how could it not enrage any kind hearted person out their? The stunt they pulled at the circus was just to embarrass the circus owners at the kind of treatment they inflict on Animals. Instead of denouncing them, we should support them! At least they are doing something, while all we are doing is just criticizing them. All we seem to do is just TALK TALK and TALK, while those out there who are really doing something for these poor defenseless animals are being criticized by those who just TALK! [%sig%]

Re: PETA

S Singh · 24 Feb 2006

BTW, I am a different S Singh from the third poster who seems to be against PETA.

Re: PETA

Nav Singh · 25 Feb 2006

Hey, I understand if the that PETA's methods can be "in your face" and shocking...BUT they do get people to think about these issues. I don't endorse their methods but animal cruelty needs to be clamped down on.

Re: PETA

Sherbahadar Singh · 25 Feb 2006

WJKK, WJKF I think you guys don't have the slightest clue to what end PETA goes to make their mark. In my first post, I asked you to do some research about them and I refrained myself from using the language required to talk about PETA's methods, but now I won't hold back. In my eyes, PETA is nothing more (right now, at least) than a single minded organization that sexually exploits women ever increasingly to get their message across. I honestly haven't seen any other organization that goes the extra mile like PETA when I say this. They are single minded because all they care is about animal rights at the expense of everything else (literally). Please read the links below to understand my perspective better. As a warning, the sites contains sexually suggestive images so please be careful. Other things that PETA does are just damn stupid. Several years ago, in downtown Toronto (I was at home watching the news when this happened), a couple was having sex in public daylight in the middle of some grass pasture near a very busy subway entrance in a sleeping bag to make their point that "vegetarians have better sex". I was like "What the F***?". Next day I went to school, a very violent altercation was narrowly avoided between me and some goras (I went to a school with like 98% gorey, rest Chinese and Indians, I was the only visible Sikh) who knew I was vegetarian and were making very offensive comments. Also, last year, while I was walking in downtown to go for a job interview (around Janruary), from a distance, I could see a crowd of guys assembled. At first I thought somebody had slipped and fallen on the ground as it was very icy. When I got somewhat closer (but still quite some distance away), was a women wearing a bra and panties with made out of lettuce and wearing rabbit ears handing out samples of "Not Dogs", (vegetarian hot-dogs) in frigid cold temperature. There are LOADS of other sites detailing PETA perverse tactics to get their message across. And also, these are NOT one-time experimental methods for PETA; they routinely exploit women to meet their ends and are now doing it more than ever. I don't mean to offend anyone, but I've got several questions for the guys that support PETA. First, do you honestly think any of our Gurus would support these methods to stop people from abusing animals? What if these women that PETA exploits were your sisters, how would you feel then? Again, I'm not flaming anyone, I'm just trying to create awareness of the issue at stake. Please do more research regarding PETA and its tactics before you start supporting them financially or otherwise. There are MANY other animal rights organizations that don't rely on such low-minded tactics and I believe you should support them. As Sikhs, we need to avoid hypocritical organizations with potential double standards and conflicts of interest. I urge you to look at alternative organizations. WJKK, WJKF

Re: PETA

khalistani · 25 Feb 2006

these people need to concentrate on the millions of humans dying around the world also we use animals for many purposes,, and have done so LOONG into our past for milk, for skin, for TABLA, for KIRPAN PUCHES, we use em for many things so did purtaan singhs if we need an animal for a good reason, no harm in having to use it obviusly we aint gonna kill for no reason but survivial is always first we dont eat meat because of spirtual reasons thas it and the fact we dont need to, we can consume plants but dont become hypocrits guru je drank milk guru je had leather dont forget all tha bhula chuka maf

Re: PETA

S Singh · 26 Feb 2006

I wonder if PETA have educated Maneka Gandhi abouting keeping Great Danes type dogs confined in small houses. They should practice what they preach. These PETA wale have got several sponsors to pull out the Quila Raipur Games becasue they claim animals are ill treated (oxe being whipped to run faster). I have not seen them stopping horse races where horses are whipped.

Re: PETA

S Singh (original poster) · 26 Feb 2006

S Singh, Do you even know the kind of treatment that is inflicted on the oxe at Qila Raipur games? they not only whip them, but the whip is tipped with a sharp nail which is hammered into the whip. So when the race is on, the guy stabs that nail repeatedly on the oxe making him run faster because it's in so much pain. For God sake, how would YOU like it buddy if some one were to stab you in the back with a sharp nail? would you still be defending these inhumane games which torture the hell out of these oxe?

Re: PETA

Janwar · 26 Feb 2006

Khalistani and others what do you mean that they should concentrate on the millions of human beings around the world? So animals should be ignored? what are you doing to help the millions of humans around the world to have the audacity to point a finger at PETA which actually WALKS the WALK? All I see is people here who criticise PETA are the ones who in their air conditioned houses will probably never even pick up a finger to help any human let alone an animal. I want to see some of you going to africa or India or some other 3rd world nation to help out humans since you seem to be so obsessed with helping out poor humans. Then please lead by example, and if you cant then dont critise those who are actually out there helping God's creatures. I always notice people giving out Salahas(advice) that "you should do this, or you should do that". But I say to you guys, why dont you guys follow your own Salaha (walk the walk!) then tell others what to do or what not to do! LEAD BY EXAMPLE! dont just give Salahas to those who are actually helping. Khalistani and S Singh, you both say that you want humans to be helped instead. Then please follow your own Salaha by going to Africa this year where millions of poor Africans are starving. If you can do this, then you have the right to pass judgement on those who are actually WALKING the WALK and not just TALKING the TALK.

Re: PETA

S Singh · 27 Feb 2006

S Singh, >>Do you even know the kind of treatment that is inflicted on the oxe at Qila Raipur games? they not only whip them, but the whip is tipped with a sharp nail which is hammered into the whip. So when the race is on, the guy stabs that nail repeatedly on the oxe making him run faster because it's in so much pain. For God sake, how would YOU like it buddy if some one were to stab you in the back with a sharp nail? would you still be defending these inhumane games which torture the hell out of these oxe Yes sure. Have you seen this or is it a rumour your PETA wale have spread ? Despite the efforts of PETA we still had the games. Guess what ? I saw non of these nail whips you talk about. Looks like someone has been getting confused at PETA with their own vulgar activities involving whips etc.

Re: PETA

S Singh(original poster) · 27 Feb 2006

S Singh, It is NOT a rumour I heard. I come from Punjab(born there) and saw this first hand. The whip being tiped by a nail is common knowledge in Punjab. If you do not even know this much (which is common knowledge in Punjab) I am assuming that you are a western born and bred. My suggestion to you to please go to Punjab and see the games first hand and see the reality of this barbarity which in inflicted on those oxe. In India many animals are abused. For example, snake charmers (sapairaas) who keep snakes pull the teeth of the snake out with a plier. In UP you will come accross some who make bears dance. If you were to see this in person you would realise the kind of cruelty that is inflicted on those bears. I understand that most of you live in nice comfortable air conditioned houses in the west and may not realise the rest of the world is not as so cushi wushi as you may have seen on discovery channal. The ground reality is much more harsh. Welcome to reality my friends...

Re: PETA

S Singh · 27 Feb 2006

It is a rumour ! Maybe in your pind they were into torture. Not all Punjabis are like this. I also come from Punjab and my family used to keep specailly bred racing Oxe for games (they are slightly smaller in stature compared to farm Oxe). They were never used for general farm work. They were fed the best grain, looked after and checked by vets in Patiala and were treated as part of the family. We never used nail tipped whips. We had trained hunting dogs as well and they were fed the best and allowed to hunt. So please take your PETA inspired hate elsewhere. I am not going to buy into it. I suggest you and your city based PETA wale go to the race track in Delhi or Mumbaiand see how race horses are kept and treated. Ups we cant be having that as your rich PETA sahibs like Maneka Gandhi would not want to upset the rich racing crowd. We must target the poor who take pleasure in racing oxe. Who treats horses better than Nihang Singh ? So what was with PETA getting parts of the Aamir Khan film censored. Nihang have been doing sewa of horses for hundreds of years. Way before the jumped up PETA crowd got involved. Next we will have these PETA badmash telling the Nihang they cant do xyz during the Holla Mohalla celebrations with their horses and elephants. Look we will carry on treating our animals as we have done for centuries. We do not need PETA wale telling us how to do what comes naturally to us. We are bought up with animals and know how to look after them. Guess what in our village we have Cock fighting, it is another great country past time and nothing you or PETA say can change this. We also do shikar with hunting dogs. When are PETA going to address real problems like the explosion in the monkey population and the growing population of the blue bulls (nilla ghai). Oh we must not worry about that as it is the ordinary farmers who suffer, We must not cull the nilla ghai as it only destroys the crops of the humble farmer. Guess what budy I am fed up to the back teeth of the PETA type city foke who do not know a thing about rural life. If they want monkeys and nilla ghai tell them to take them to the city as farmers have had enough of them destroying their crops. Go to Chhaat Bir Zoo near Chandigarh to see how animals are treated badly....ups we better not do that because the zoo is named after Nehru and it could tarnish Maneka Gandhis link with the Gandhis.

Re: PETA

S Singh(original poster) · 27 Feb 2006

Well well well... Now the reality has come out (aslihat baar nikal he ahi!). So the reason you defend torturerers of animals is becuase your family are also into these barbaric games. Wah! kia Khandani pesha hai! to torture animals seems to be a way of life for you. I am really surprised how you even deny these tortures which happens to be common knowledbe for those from Punjab. Suger-coating turture will not make it any less torture my friend. So the oxe is fed and treated is like 'family' as you claim. But on the day of the race that animals goes through the worst torture imaginable with a nail being stabbed in it's back repeatedly. You call that oxe 'being treated like family'? with family like this, who needs enemies! [%sig%]

Re: PETA

Guroo Guroo · 27 Feb 2006

Panjabis seem to struggle to see Waheguru in Baby Girls!! God help us when coming to see God in animals.

Re: PETA

S Singh · 27 Feb 2006

You really need to get your facts right. Oxe racing is an ancient sport. It is not cruel like dog fighting or say cockeral fighting. You keep saying the torture is common knowledge. It is not common knowledge in our family and the animals have never been touched with these nail whips you mention. I have never seen such a whip let alone used one so please get your facts right. We use a short stick during races but it certainly has no nails in it. In fact it it far less painful than the whips horse jockeys use. We had several ox who lived to ages of 23. With your limited knowledge of livestock you probably do not know this but 23 for ox is a very good age. The lifespan of your ordinary working ox is a lot lower so I guess I can confidently say that our ox get the best of everything foodwise and healthcare wise. Oh they are only raced for a about 3 seasons then we keep them for the pleasure of it and they are not made to work in fields. We have 2 people who are charged with looking after the ox. It is their sole duty to look after our ox. We have an open enclosure of about an acre where they are allowed to roam freely. Where is the torture ? Racing Oxen is not indicative of torture. Do you think a tortured animal would live that long ? I think it is disgusting when people buy large dogs like great danes and keep them confined to small houses in Delhi. How come you PETA fanatics do not address this problem. Is it because your "jathedar" are guilty of such practices. Come on get your PETA wale to have a go at the Nihangs and see what reaction you get. Your post has so touched me that I am going to organise the worlds first Ox Derby at the large annual livestock mela near Rothak. Oh you PETA wala are invited to come and enjoy the races it will be a change for some of your socialites to get away and see something different to horse racing.

Re: PETA

kds · 28 Feb 2006

keeping an ox is also inhumane.ox is castarated version of bull.isn,t castration cruel