Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Baba Shri Chand

Baba Shri Chand

P.S.Sandhu · 23 Feb 2006

Dear Sangat. I want to know the history of Baba Shri Chand, ( the eldest son of Guru Nanak Dev ji) Pls I request veer, Kulbir Singh, Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi and other intellectuals in this forum to respond. I am also posting what I read from the wesite of Gobind Sadan, a self proclaimed saint spreading the message of social harmony and ambience....pls go throu this too and let me know what they spreading about sikh history is right ?? ************* http://www.gobindsadan.org/sirichand/editor/ ***************************

Re: Baba Shri Chand

Sri Chand · 23 Feb 2006

theres a book on ebay on Baba sri Chand http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=6607007102&rd=1&sspagename=STRK%3AMESE%3AIT&rd=1 [%sig%]

Re: Baba Shri Chand

LionKing (LK) · 23 Feb 2006

ouch. Baba Siri Chand, always a controversial character in our history. Go to his dera, to learn about him and the practisis on his dera, and you will find out a lot from them automatically :)

Re: Baba Shri Chand

Prabhjoyt Singh · 23 Feb 2006

just a question might sound abit silly but why was Baba Sri Chand a greyish blue colour? http://images.google.co.uk/imgres?imgurl=http://www.sikh-heritage.co.uk/personalities/baba%2520srichand/SriChand.jpg&imgrefurl=http://www.sikh-heritage.co.uk/personalities/baba%2520srichand/babasrichand.htm&h=347&w=259&sz=29&tbnid=xmLrsYSaskUYDM:&tbnh=116&tbnw=86&hl=en&start=2&prev=/images%3Fq%3Dbaba%2Bsri%2Bchand%26svnum%3D10%26hl%3Den%26lr%3D%26sa%3DG

Re: Baba Shri Chand

Lionking (LK) · 23 Feb 2006

Something that remeinds me of the greyish blueish color is that hindu gods are often previewed as blueish greyish

Re: Baba Shri Chand

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 23 Feb 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI fateh. The Undenaible FACT that we have to keep constantly in MIND is that GURU NANAK JI SAHIB decided that His SON baba sri Chand Ji was NOT FIT or CAPABLE enough to inherit His GURGADHEE and NANAK JYOT. Secondly it is not that Guru ji Didnt give his sons EQUAL OPPORTUNITY - Guur Nanak Ji is JAGAT GURU..everyone of us are HIS CHILDREN...not less and not more than Baba Sri Chand Ji. Guru Ji gave every one of His children and Sikhs equal chances at proving themsleves WORTHY..and ONLY Bhai Lehana Ji PASSED all tests with Flying Colours....and as a result Guru Ji bestowed the Nanak JYOT and His Gurgadhee to Bhai lehana Ji and made him "MY ANGAD"..MY OWN LIMB...What greater HONOUR can anyone have than be MADE GURU JI's' OWN LIMB..a PART of His BODY/JYOT by His OWN CHOICE. Baba sri Chand was Guru Ji's own BLOOD LINE ( not by choice but by waheguur's hukm as it is with all of us...we cannot choose our own fathers, mothers brothers and sisters...BUT we CAN SELECT others as our own ..and make them even MORE than our "own". Just as Guru nanak ji chose Bhai lehana Ji to be His LIMB... we are also given thsi opportunity...when we Chhak Khande Batte dee PAHUL...we MAKE the DECISION - FREE CHOICE - to Choose GURU GOBIND SINGH JI (NANAK JYOT) as our FATHER ( leaving aside the natural father over which we had no choice at all)..and OUR MOTHER - MATA SAHIB KAUR JI....and our PIND - SRI KESHGARRH SAHIB ANANDPUR SAHIB. Guru Ji makes us His LIMB.. The rest of all this stuff is part of our "Sikh history"....some may be true..most of it is mythical made up stuff ( Ishar Singh Nara is in most cases MORE of a Bippar than the Bippars themsleves... he bends over backwards to prove that Sikhs are HINDUS.... (while Mahan Kosh Writer Kahn Singh nabha had to write a Book "HUM HINDU NAHIN"..to counter such influences as by Nanar Ji) and THAT Bipparness is ONE reason why Baba Sri Chand is shown BLUE in colour... becuse he is supposed to be SHIV JI BHAGWAAN....KRISHAN BHAGWAAN etc and as we all know all those Bhagwaans are always BLUE/GREY in colour. ( Here please note that DAS may be "biased" as well because i am more anti-bippar than any other anti-bippars themselves !!..especailly in cases of following stuff like Shudh Gheej yots, coconuts, red cloths, water pitchers, conches, aartees, blue colured bhagwaan pictures, sangrands, pooranmashis, teerath yatras and stuff) Just in case anyone is doubtful that we still have people like Nara Ji among us..we recently ahd such a one as Akal takhat jathedar..Poorna Singh who declared that Sikh GURUS are the Progeny of Ram chander' sons LUV and KUSH...and to rub salt into us...IF not for the FACT that Ram Chander had ONLY one REAL SON - blood son - the OTHER one was MANUFACTURED out of GRASS and WEEDS by a RISHI in the Forest...you see, Mata sita had left her son with the Rishi to BABYSIT..and the Rishi got into meditation and LOST the child...and when he realised his carelessness..what the HECK..he made ANOTHER SIMILAR BABY BOY out of some weeds and grass...but it so happend that Mata sita had found her boy on the way back home....and saw another with the Rishi..and took that home as well....and so Ram ended up with TWO sons..and the ONE born out of WEEDS is "supposed" to be OUR GURU's ANCESTOR..so you can judge for yourself the "stage of sikhi" of such people like poorna singh and ishar singh nara. My advise for what its worth..read the book but take it all with a Pinch (kilo) of SALT. Check everything agaisnt what is said in GURBANI..especialy Bani of GURU NANAK JI, Guru Angad ji and Guru Amardass ji..those GURUS bore the Brunt of the actions of these "blood sons" of Gurus who DID NOT get Gurgadhi. Jarnail Singh

Re: Baba Shri Chand

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 23 Feb 2006

NOTE THE JANEAU ON BABA JI'S BODY...AND ON THOSE OF HIS SIKHS..IN THE PHOTOS. GURU NANAK JI SAHIB TOTALLY REJECTED THE JANEAU...AND WROTE GURBANI EXPLAINING WHY...

Re: Baba Shri Chand

Singh · 24 Feb 2006

Guru Nanak dev ji rejected his lifestyle and instead accepted the lifestyle of bhai Lehna, that is why he was the next Guru.

Re: Baba Shri Chand

Harcharan Singh · 24 Feb 2006

I beleive the blue colour represents the rubbing of ash on the body. This has always been a common feature of the Udasis, alongside unkept hair (dreadlocks). Just because Guru Ji did not give the gurgaddi to Baba Sri Chand does not mean he was bad. Guru Tegh Bahadur Ji did not get the Gurgaddi first time either, does not mean he was bad, Guru Ji did mahaan tapasya for years. Baba Sri Chand brough the 6 schools of knowldge and made them bow to Guru Ramdaas Ji, after accepting Guru Ramdaas Ji as his superior and his master. This made Guru Ramdaas Ji Raj Yogi, only Krishna has been known to have held this honour in the past. Baba Sri Chand then is said to have devoted his life to spreading the Sikh message (in the Udassi way). And it is thanks to Baba Sri Chand Ji that so many ayurvedic and yoga disciplines have survived today, which if learnt and practised can bring priceless mental and health benefits. These systems are thousands of years old and they are products of immense wisdom and evolution. But obviously without the ultimate benefit, derived from our mahaan Guru Ji, the spiritual, mental and physical well being is of no avail. Sat Sri Akaal

Re: Baba Shri Chand

Singh · 24 Feb 2006

Baba Sri Chand Jee was a Great Gursikh, and Udasi are Sikhs.

Re: Baba Shri Chand

.... · 24 Feb 2006

Jarnail Singh, im not too sure about Baba Sri Chand being Sikh but just wanted to mention even Baba Budha Ji did not get Gurgadii, & there is no doubt he was an amazing Gursikh, so im not sure how well your argument holds about Baba Sri chand not getting Gurgaddi means he was bad/not Sikh.

Re: Baba Shri Chand

RightOn · 24 Feb 2006

Very nice reply Gyani Ji :-) Keep up the good work!

Re: Baba Shri Chand

Lionking (LK) · 24 Feb 2006

Just because Guru Ji did not give the gurgaddi to Baba Sri Chand does not mean he was bad. Guru Tegh Bahadur Ji did not get the Gurgaddi first time either, does not mean he was bad, Guru Ji did mahaan tapasya for years ************ Can you really compare baba Siri Chand ji to Guru Tegh Bahadur sahib jee? Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib ji was to be given Gurgaddi in due tme - there was still loads to learn before it was his turn. ***** Baba Sri Chand brough the 6 schools of knowldge and made them bow to Guru Ramdaas Ji, after accepting Guru Ramdaas Ji as his superior and his master. This made Guru Ramdaas Ji Raj Yogi, only Krishna has been known to have held this honour in the past. ****** Why do they not folow the litmus test of Gurbani, and do all sort of manmat stuff going against Gurbani? The very Gurbani you revere as sacred, and thus emphasize raag on, is the same bani that they do not follow.. ************ Baba Sri Chand then is said to have devoted his life to spreading the Sikh message (in the Udassi way). ************ Is there a Sikh-way of spreading message of Sikhi, and an Udasi way? Please support your response with Gurbani, since you seem to imply theres several ways (I thought it was only through Naam, Bani, and Kirtan, but I might be wrong) ****** Author: .... Date: 02-24-06 09:14 Jarnail Singh, im not too sure about Baba Sri Chand being Sikh but just wanted to mention even Baba Budha Ji did not get Gurgadii, & there is no doubt he was an amazing Gursikh, so im not sure how well your argument holds about Baba Sri chand not getting Gurgaddi means he was bad/not Sikh. ****** Baba Buddha ji didnot get GUrgaddi, but he did get loads of other sevas since he obeyed Guru Sahibs HUkam. He did not become a Guru but he did fulfill other functions important at the time. What contributions has Baba Siri Chand Ji made to Sikhi? I recommend everyone to check out the udasi Deras, and only then respond as only then can you find out what they really preach and do.

Re: Baba Shri Chand

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 24 Feb 2006

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Veer Ji Lion King has adequately answered all the queries..Thank You veer Ji. In addition to his reccommendation to go visit Udasi DERA first and get firsthand info on what they really do... Can you people please also "persuade" these UDASI DERAS and web masters of sites like Gobind Sadan..to do "EQUAL PROMOTION" of Sikhs like Baba Budha Ji, Bhai Gurdass Ji....and a few THOUSAND OTHERS...on the same equal basis they promote Baba sri Chand Ji ?? You should be asking them..."Are Sikhs like baba Budha Ji/Bhai gurdass ji..BAD ??...instead of asking me whether i think baba sri chand ji is ?bad/good ??. And to Veer Harcharan Singh ji who declares that GURU RAMDASS JI became "RAJ YOGI"..due to the fact that Baba Sri Chand Ji made 6 schools of thought bow at His Charan....I beg to Differ... Dhan Dhan Dhan Guru Ramdass ji is RAJ YOGI and MUCH MUCH MORE...because GURU NANAK JI bestowed NANAK JYOT on HIM.....to even think that all His GLORY was due to baba sri Chand bowing to Him with his 6 schools of thought is an insult to the Glory of nanak Jyot. This is Not the Only "insult" the admirers of baba sri Chand throw at our GURU SAHIBAANS... I have come across GUTKAS printed by DERAS like nanaksar and others, who DECLARE that GURU ARJUN JI was 'STUCK" ( as in Writer's block) at Ashtpadi 16 of Sri Sukhmani Sahib..and couldnt write a line more..UNTIL..lo and behold Baba SRI CHAND JI came along and..Completed the Sukhamni Sahib for Guru Ji...." This is the Worst and outright LIE propogated by these udasi followers. The GURU that was bestowed the Title BANI KA BOHITHA by none other than Guru Amardass ji...and who wrote More Bani than any other GURU is "stuck" in Sukhmani Sahib ?? What a GROSS LIE....in Baba Sri Chand's name !!! The WHOLE underlying current of such "thought" is that the BIPPAR just cannot rest without proving that the GURUS were somehow "incomplete" without HIS intervention...just see how Bhgawaans like Krishan and Ram chander..are NOT BHAGWAANS..until...and until..they have SERVED the BIppar "rishis", learned meditators in the forests..etc etc by JHARRO MARRING, bringing water, and other seva in the Rishi Ashram....so we have books like gurbilas patshahi chhevin where bippars "teach" and "show" Guru Ji where to asthapan ("Guru") Granth Ji, ..etc etc as IF GURU JI doesnt know and has to be showed.... Why is it so difficult to follow GURBANI in GURU GRANTH JI ? Why must we go outside our GURU SAHIBAANS to look for "good/bad Sikhs" ?? Baba sri Chand Ji had NO CHOICE except to BOW to GURU RAMDASS JI..since He ahd missed the Chance to BOW to GURU NANAK JI/GURU ANGAD JI/GURU AMARDASS JI....IF he had "not bowed" he wouldnt be worth two hoots to Siksh to day just like the Prithiyas , the Dhirmallias, the Raam Rayias, and all those "other Blood relatives" of our GURUS. Bowing to GURU RAMDASS ji makes him..Better late than never....good or bad...Guru ji knows !!! Jarnail Singh

Re: Baba Shri Chand

P.S.Sandhu · 24 Feb 2006

Dear Sangat, I am still waiting the right answer. pls give supportive answers with reference to sikh history and sikh scriptures. thanks for the reply indeed and bringing the topic under discussion. may waheguru be with all of us. Fateh.

Re: Baba Shri Chand

P.S.Sandhu · 24 Feb 2006

My dear sikh brothers, Here is what "The Sikhs in History" by Dr. Sangat Singh says about the topic under discussion: Guru Angad was spiritual successor of Guru Nanak and completely identified himself with the founder-guru as part and parcel of his ideology. His importance lay in the fact that he re-emphasized in totality Guru Nanak's mission. Guru Nanak had dwelt on multiple strands. Guru Angad did n't fall into the trap of over-emphasising some aspects and under-emphasising others. He squarely met the threat posed by Baba Sri Chand, eldest son of Guru Nanak who founded the sect of Udasis-imbued in deep ascetic traditions of the Hindu social order. That caused first schism in the followers of Guru Nanak, thou of minor order. Guru Angad emphasised the term manmukh-self -centred or ego-oriented for such persons. He steered Sikhism clear from asceticism by reiterating Guru Nanak's message in down to earth manner. Guru Angad after 12 1/2 years (Sep 1539-March 1552) found that his end was drawing near. He chose his devot disciple Amar Das who had a rigorous training for about 8 years to succeed him. He was also told to hold his congregation at Goindwal, away from Khadur to avoid conflict with Guru Angad's sons who were not found up to the mark. The period of Guru Amar Das(Mrch 1552-Aug 1574) was quite eventful in further development of Sikhism. In words of Kalsahar, the leader of Bhatts, Guru Amar Das was essentially devoted to naam, which brought hi spiritual illumination and realisation, as it had done so to several rishis and bhaktas. He was a worthy successor of Guru Nanak and Guru Angad. Guru Angad's son Datu was resentful at his being bypassed. Baba Sri Chand contended that Guru Angad, a nominee of Guru Nanak had no right to pass on the succession and for the last time made an attempt, a feeble one, to claim it to himself. The Sikh movement had so much bypassed the Udasis that Guru Amar Dad was able to put a final seal of separation of the two.

Re: Baba Shri Chand

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 25 Feb 2006

From the ongoing active "promotion" of Baba sri Chand....akhand paaths and what not on his "gurpurab" ??? birthday etc are part of this programme..means another schism in Sikhi is being promoted. And the very fact that it is Gobind Sadan that is doing this is a channan munara as to the actual motive behind this GURMATT and Sikhi ...has Nothing to do with Bedis, Baba sri Chand, Dattus, Dassus, Prithiyas, Meeanas and Dhirmallias, Ram Raiyaas, Sodhis, whatever..they all tried to set up RIVAL GADHEES to bring down Guru Nanak's Gadhi, with everything at their command. They have FAILED..before and will FAIL NOW. It is Sikhi's "big heartedness" that we respect baba Sri Chand Ji as "Baba"....otherwise this Title is ONLY fit for SAHIBZADEHS of GURU GOBIND SINGH JI who rightfully earned it 100%. The other Sahibzadehs of Guru Hargobind Ji like baba gurditta Ji and others who stayed on the right PATH of SIKHI and Gurmatt is also OK. This is ONE reason why the "sons" of Guru Angad ji...Dattu and Dassu are NOT given it...one of them KICKED GURU AMARDASS JI in Full Darbar !!!..I beleive the son of Guru Amardass ji "MOHAN" is also mistakenly given this title of baba as the Shaabds relating to Mohan Ji have been WRONGLY interpreted ( in connection with the Pothis of Goindwaal) These POTHIS have now been proven to have been produced by the ANTI-GURU Forces in an effrot to SABOTAGE Sikhi-Gurmatt of Nanak jyot. a person having such "pothis" couldnt be at all a "baba" Lets TRUST in the GURU JI's Actions in REJECTING their BLOOD RELATIVES and SONS. We have no reason at all to go "looking" for them as we have GURU GRANTH JI..Pio Daddeh Da Khazanah... Let them remain just as historical figures..like many others...before and after them.... Jarnail Singh.

Re: Baba Shri Chand

for Mr Arshi · 25 Feb 2006

The story that you r presenting , that you read in the gutka of sukhmani sahib , you have completely modified it and maybe even you yourself forgot it . guru ji went to baba sri chand to teach nimrata to his sikhs . and baba sri chand didn't completed sukhmani sahib or anything like tht . he just changed bhi to bhe in 16 th astpadi and that also to obey the hukam of guru ji not according to his own will . baba sri chand was spellbound with the nimrata of guru ji .

Re: Baba Shri Chand

Lionking (LK) · 26 Feb 2006

Panga Man said it all =)

Re: Baba Shri Chand

Harcharan Singh · 26 Feb 2006

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh, Veers LionKing/Jarnail Singh Jeeo, Forgive me if my message was not clear of offended: - I did not intend to compare Guru Ji, I was simply using this as an example to illustrate that those not chosen for the Gur-gaddi were not automatically bad people. Lion Ji's example is more appropriate, Baba Budda Ji. - Lion King Ji, I was not aware that to respect our Guru's one had to give up their ownlife style? Millions of hindus and many Muslims have respect for our Guru's, and even show devotion towards them, I didn't we had a monopoly on them I personally feel very happy when non-Sikhs hold such high reverence for Guru Sahiban, whilst practicing their own faith. Their was no need for the raag dig, it is out of context. My Hukmi Kirtan posts are intended for siblings who are Khalsa, not for other faiths/sects. - When mentioned spreading of Sikhi in the Udassi way, I simply meant that Udassi's were travelling physicians, chemists, yogis, giving millions of people the benefit of their priceless knowledge. This is the single element I respect of Udassis. In addition, Udassis did give the populace discourses from Gurbani, they excepted Guru Nanak Dev Ji as a supreme Guru and Sru Guru Granth Sahib as the greatest spiritual text, although they also preach vedic traditions. This is what I meant by the Udaasi way. Udassi's remain unattached, which is not a Sikh trait, but that is their faith. If they chose to spread the truth of gurbani to other yogis and people in the far reaches of India over the last 500 years, I do not see this as a bad thing. I don't see why we always have to write off anyone who is not a Sikh. Our Guru's did not ex-communicate Udassis, they allowed them to live alongside us. I can not comment on todays Udassis, as I do have not had interaction, but I can comment on todays Gurdwarai and holders of authority, they also do not represent what our Guru's intended, I can beleive the same may apply to todays udassis to. Also, this thread seems to have become very defensive, no one is saying halleluja, praise and bow to the udassis or Baba Sri Chand. It was simply a historical question, not another passing final judgement and creating informal hukumnamas to disassocatiate with everyone that is not Sikh! It's a big world, learn to live with one another and take the best form one another. Udassis have contributed hugely in ayurvedic and yogic knowledge, give them credit for that. No one is saying let's learn Sikhi off them.

Re: Baba Shri Chand

Gurpreet Sumra · 26 Feb 2006

What is the source that Guru saab went to Sri Chand? To respect someone because he is the son of Guru, is not Gurmat. A Kirtaniya was telling a story that Sri chand is tha ansh bansh of Guru Nanak Sahib. My question is that are we not ansh bansh of Guru Nanak Sahib? A lot of Sikhs only respect Sri Chand beacuse he is son of Guru Nanak saab . It was because of Sri Chand that Guru Angad Dev ji was forced to move from Kartapur to Khadur Sahib. Sri Chand saying kud kabad about Guru Ram Das saab's beard should not elope from Sikh's mind. Sri chand change bhi to bhe is a lie. Nanaksariye in their Gutka has written that Guru Angas Sahib could not recite after 16th astpadi. Guru Angad sahib,Guru Amardas,Guru Ram Das and Guru Arjan Dev ji has leprosy on their feet. Sri chand recited the slok of 17th astpadi "aad sach jugad sach hai bhi sach Nanak hosi bhi sach" After putting a sihari with bhabha Guru Saab's kod eloped and Guru saab started reciting bani. Now this is the height of insult of Guru Saab.Was these Sant babe sitting there or this incident that is the imagination of their sick mind broadcasted again.Or Sri Chand gave Darshan and told this story. So these Udasis were influenced by Hinduism and Gurdwaras came under their control and they wrote lot of anti Guru and anti Sikh literature. So just that Sri Chand is the ansh bansh is only blnd faith, Guru's real ansh bansh are Sikhs for whom Guru Saab sacrificed their own sons "in putran ke sees par var diye sut char char muye to kya huya jeevat kai hajar" So just to give some high status to someone just because he is the son of Guru saab is not correct. [%sig%]

Re: Baba Shri Chand

Lionking (LK) · 26 Feb 2006

Author: for Mr Arshi Date: 02-25-06 19:45 The story that you r presenting , that you read in the gutka of sukhmani sahib , you have completely modified it and maybe even you yourself forgot it . guru ji went to baba sri chand to teach nimrata to his sikhs . and baba sri chand didn't completed sukhmani sahib or anything like tht . he just changed bhi to bhe in 16 th astpadi and that also to obey the hukam of guru ji not according to his own will . baba sri chand was spellbound with the nimrata of guru ji . *************************** Veer jeeyo, Guru Ji sacrifised Dhurkibani to teach nimarta to Sikhs? This is nimarta: [gurbani]jo hmrI ibiD hoqI myry siqgurw sw ibiD qum hir jwxhu Awpy ] hm rulqy iPrqy koeI bwq n pUCqw gur siqgur sMig kIry hm Qwpy ] DMnu DMnu gurU nwnk jn kyrw ijqu imilAY cUky siB sog sMqwpy ]4]5]11]49] [/gurbani] My condition, O my True Guru - that condition, O Lord, is known only to You. I was rolling around in the dirt, and no one cared for me at all. In the Company of the Guru, the True Guru, I, the worm, have been raised up and exalted. Blessed, blessed is the Guru of servant Nanak; meeting Him, all my sorrows and troubles have come to an end. ||4||5||11||49|| Also, in that case why wasn't Baba Siri Chands name written like, BHagat Fareed JI, Bhagat Kabir ji etc Dhur Ki Bani aay, it's not anything ANYONE has a write to change a single kanna or bindi, let alown 'bhi' to 'bhe' Dear Harcharan Singh Veer jeeyo **************** - Lion King Ji, I was not aware that to respect our Guru's one had to give up their ownlife style? Millions of hindus and many Muslims have respect for our Guru's, and even show devotion towards them, I didn't we had a monopoly on them ***************** I agree =) ********* I personally feel very happy when non-Sikhs hold such high reverence for Guru Sahiban, whilst practicing their own faith. Their was no need for the raag dig, it is out of context. My Hukmi Kirtan posts are intended for siblings who are Khalsa, not for other faiths/sects. ********* I apologize. (considering I'ma raag-fan myself, so please do to misunderstand:) ) ******** - When mentioned spreading of Sikhi in the Udassi way, I simply meant that Udassi's were travelling physicians, chemists, yogis, giving millions of people the benefit of their priceless knowledge. This is the single element I respect of Udassis. In addition, Udassis did give the populace discourses from Gurbani, they excepted Guru Nanak Dev Ji as a supreme Guru and Sru Guru Granth Sahib as the greatest spiritual text, although they also preach vedic traditions. ******** I do not agree, since the two are contradictory, one cannot concemn worshipping of idols, yet idol worship yourself. If they are preaching out of Gurbani - then how can the select things that suite them ro preach, and those they don't liek they just ignore? ********* This is what I meant by the Udaasi way. Udassi's remain unattached, which is not a Sikh trait, but that is their faith. If they chose to spread the truth of gurbani to other yogis and people in the far reaches of India over the last 500 years, I do not see this as a bad thing. ********* I agree, but considering that they are spreading a "hinduized" version of Gurbani - that disturbs me. If they are preaching Gurmat and Gurbani, then go ahead w/o any bahman-bia, then I would be the first one to have massive respect for them, but this is ntot he case. ****** I don't see why we always have to write off anyone who is not a Sikh. ****** Agree with you =), personally have massive respct for Hindu and Muslim sevadars of Guru Ji's time, and even modern day Hindus and Muslims who ahve done good stuff ******* Our Guru's did not ex-communicate Udassis, they allowed them to live alongside us. I can not comment on todays Udassis, as I do have not had interaction, but I can comment on todays Gurdwarai and holders of authority, they also do not represent what our Guru's intended, I can beleive the same may apply to todays udassis to. ******** 1- Guru Nanak Dev JI had the power to do anything. If he wanted he coudl have put an end to Muslim dharm,Hindu Dharm, Udasi marg. He did not do so. Just because he did not ex-communicate Udasis doesn't mean he ever accepted them as a part of his 'Gadi-rah'. Guru Sahib openly spoke against ascetics, celibacy, idol wroship and what not, yet we are expected to believe that he accepted udasis because his son founded the marg? 2- As for todays Gurdwara olders- Although they might not be following Gurmat 100%, they are not going so far that they blend themselves into hind-dharm (most atleast), and if they are it simply means we as Sikhs shpuld be vigalante. ********* Also, this thread seems to have become very defensive, no one is saying halleluja, praise and bow to the udassis or Baba Sri Chand. It was simply a historical question, not another passing final judgement and creating informal hukumnamas to disassocatiate with everyone that is not Sikh! It's a big world, learn to live with one another and take the best form one another. ********* No-one ever said that you should disassociate with anyone. Stay in this world, and live life of Pyaar and Compassion. Live in this pond but stay as a lotus. As a matter of fact it is encouraged that yo go and check what other people do. Go and check what Nimaleys do, go check what Udasis do, etc - no-one's telling anyoen to close their mind, all we're saying is that the Udasi Marg has not done much good to Sikh -dharm, but it indeed has brought a lot fo sir-dhardi (although it's good they took care of Gurdwara, they also brought in Jyots and what not) ******** Udassis have contributed hugely in ayurvedic and yogic knowledge, give them credit for that. No one is saying let's learn Sikhi off them. ******** No-one's saying anything about them not contributing to the ayurvedic and yogic knowledge. I'm sure they have, and mubarak to them for that. No-one saying they are bad people who should go to hell, all we're saying is that they have very little to do with Sikhi, are we wrong in that? Bhull chukk maaf