Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..

Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..

Kaljug Jeev · 18 Feb 2006

waheguroo ji ka khalsa waheguroo ji ki fateh...i have a question..my friend and thier family is having an akhand path and they are told by someone to do the puratan way..which is while the whole akahnd path is been recited someone does japji sahib da path..it this a puratan maryada..and is ok to do..and why do they do this if its ok to do so?...plz enlighten me.. bhul chuk maaf.. waheguroo ji ka khalsa waheguroo ji ki fateh!

Re: Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..

akj 4neva and neva · 19 Feb 2006

yes it is....this is because if the main akand paath is stopped then bani is still being recited so the akand doesnt break as such........hope that makes sense

Re: Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..

Gurpreet Sumra · 19 Feb 2006

A well known Santji writes in his book that with Akhand paath japji is must and as many number of japji as there are number of akhand paaths. Saadh sangat ji aakho satnam shri waheguruuuu!!!!!!!!

Re: Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..

.... · 19 Feb 2006

iv never been to an akhand path where japji sahib was not being recited as well

Re: Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..

LionKing (LK) · 19 Feb 2006

According to Panth Parvan Rehit Maryada, which has been implimented by Guru Panth, it is prohibited to read other paath (c) Placing a pitcher, ceremonial clarified butted fed lamp, coconut, etc. around , during the course of the uninterrupted or any other reading of Guru Granth Sahib, or reading of other Scriptural texts side by side with or in the course of such reading is contrary to the gurmat (Guru's way). It is Manmat, according to Panth Parvan Rehit Maryada. Thus, do tell the family in question not to do anything going against the way of the Guru...

Re: Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..

DasnDas* · 19 Feb 2006

vjkk, vjkf I have never seen or heard of Japji Sahib going on at an Akhand Path. Even when AKJ Singhs and Singhnian/Bibi Jees come to our house for duties of reading they don't read it. (I believe/I think) even the ones the have the most strict rehat that come don't read it. vjkk, vjkf

Re: Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 19 Feb 2006

IT is NOT "puratan" or any other Maryada. IN Fact as Lion King Ji has quoted this Practice is BANNED in the Panthic Rehat Maryada. The "reasons" to explain it are as illogical as the "purratan".."Akhand bani" , "IF" Akahnd paath gets interrupted...( Koi inhhan nu puchhey ki JE Japji Sahib gets interrupted..THEN WHAT ??)..DONT we DO ARDASS that the Akahnd Path shouldnt get interrupted ?? so whats the use of that ardass..its just for show or what ?? ) etc reasons given for it. Just stick to the CORRECT Maryada...of the Guru Khalsa panth..perform the Path YOURSELVES ( at least one paathi from family !!), listen as much as possible, and dont let the "purattan thugghs" trick you into placing gharreh of pani, red clothes, conches, havan samgree etc etc...those are for their own "kharchas" Jarnail Singh. BTW I NEVER attend an Akahnd paath if i know such pakhand is being carried on

Re: Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..

Kaljug Jeev · 19 Feb 2006

waheguroo ji ka khalsa waheguroo ji ki fateh...phenjis/veerjis....the guy who told them to do so is a taksali singh..but hes humble and cardikala..the thing is..i to nvr went to an akhand path where japji sahib path is recited...so wht u suggest??..oh and yea..on march 12 theres a wedding here in our local gurdwara..the thing is i have to do lavan kirtan ..i dont know its not a gursikhs wedding.is it like ok for me the lavan...was just curious...bhul chuk maaff...and thanks for the reply sangat jio.. waheguroo ji ka khalsa waheguroo ji ki fateh

Re: Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..

... · 19 Feb 2006

The maryada of reading Japji Sahib with akhand paath sahib is quite old and was used in almost all the Jathas. I'm not sure why this is. I don't think the Japji Sahib reader can focus very well and I don't buy into the keeping the akhand paath sahib unbroken argument. My only understanding is that it could be good to train new paathis how to focus and for sitting. I personally don't understand it but at the same time, I definitely wouldn't boycott and paath where this is happening. That's not the right approach. I also don't see anything wrong with jots (not for spiritual reason but for atmosphere and as a light). I also think that jal that is placed near akhand paath sahib will definitely get some of the vibration. As for doing laavan kirtan at non-rehitvan marriage: I don't think that a rehitvaan Sikh should do this seva. Once Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh and the Jatha had just returned from a Samagam and it was night time. Someone came and said there was an Anand Kaaraj in the morning and no one was coming to do the kirtan for laavan. Bhai Sahib immediately told the Jatha that they should do this seva. They picked up the vaja and jori and walked all night to go to the village. They arrived and found out that the couple were not amritdhari and did not wish to become so. Bhai Sahib immediately turned right around with the Jatha and went home.

Re: Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..

Gurpreet Sumra · 19 Feb 2006

Well known santji writes water in amritsar sarovar has become amrit, same way during akhand paath the water in pot becomes amrit. Saadh sangat ji aakho Satnam shri waheguru!!!

Re: Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..

Kaljug Jeev · 19 Feb 2006

waheguroo ji ka khalsa waheguroo ji ki fateh..if i dont do the lavan path..is it ok for me to sit on guru maharaj tabia to read from maharaj?cause then there wouldnt be any ppl..just for my info..sorry.. waheguroo ji ka khalsa waheguroo ji ki fateh

Re:

... · 19 Feb 2006

kaljugi jeev, all we can do is try our best to follow Gurmat. The Gurmat answer to your question is that we shouldn't attend the marriages of non-amritdharis.

Re: Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..

Kaljug Jeev · 19 Feb 2006

o waheguroo..ok..ill try my best to stay away and attend the khand path..lol..well thanks alot..really helped..and i think i will ask the veerji on the japji sahib thing...and let u guys know whats the reason..if u guys one..thanks alot..

Re: Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..

Kharag Singh · 20 Feb 2006

Author: ... Date: 02-19-06 21:06 kaljugi jeev, all we can do is try our best to follow Gurmat. The Gurmat answer to your question is that we shouldn't attend the marriages of non-amritdharis. ___________________________________________________________ If you dont attend the wedding then how can you expect to keep Guru Granth Sahib there while your at home content with the fact that you didnt attend a "manmukhs" wedding? So what next, stop all non amritdharis getting married altogether? Then maybe even stop all non amritdharis coming to the Gurdwara altogether. This extremism is going to push people further away from Sikhi then closer.

Re: Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..

Singh · 20 Feb 2006

this is shoddy ill thoght out dera maryada. Like most deras they cannot explain why they do and just say it is prataan. There is no evidence to suggest this practice is prataan, just like there is evidence to suggest these deras are prataan.

Re: Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..

Joka · 20 Feb 2006

LOL well done guys! Thank God this sikh isnt going to this akhand path!!! Who knows what may have happened to him had he gone .... maybe he would have listened to some gurbani!! Noooooooooooooo Im so glad we have people within our own panth who discourage others from going to akhand paths and listening to gurbani!! Thank you! ..... And just in case your wondering, at this 'manmat akhand path' the japji sahib is not real out loud. the pathi singhs do it quietly. Tut tut tut singhs doing more path!! How dare they! Next time i see a singh doing his rehras sahib in the corner of a darbar while akhand path is going, ill make sure i give him a clip round the ear! How dare he do path!!! If you dont personaly do it fine, but to say dont go to such programmes is a joke!! I mean come on ... its japji sahib!!! How can doing extra path quietly ever be bad?! How can involving people who otherwsie may or may not have spent that time reading gurbani sitting next to guru ji and doing gurbani be a bad thing!? Chalo, apni apni marji karo! I just hope you do ardas for all the 'pappi's' who dared to do 2 hours of japji sahib rouls!!! Ina paap!!!! Vaheguru!!!! tut tut tut .....

Re: Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..

Gurpreet Sumra · 20 Feb 2006

Read as much bani as one wants.It is good and beneficial.But when Akhand Paath is going on then as per Panth parvant Sikh Rehat Maryada, it says that a Sikh should do the paath hmself, in case if he can't do it then someone else can do it but he should listen to Akhand paath. I think it definitely makes sense.If bani is being read out and you ar3 not listening to it just ignoring it and doing akal ustat,japji saab,rehras saab(they are bani too) then don't you think there is no point of that akhand paath that is going on.Only Paathi is doing it. Whole Guru Granth Sahib is to be read and understood not just some banis otherwise these Akhand paaths just become mantar ratans by paathis. In fact they have become, people book akhand paath in Gurudwaras and nobody is sitting in hall no.1 and it is a social gathering in a langar hall. Otherwise there is no other reason, if you want to ignore rest of bani, nobody is stopping you, go ahead.

Re: Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..

really Mr joka · 20 Feb 2006

Mr Joka jee, no-one said to him not to go and listen to bani. people just said it is not the right maryada, and it is not prataan. So do not be such a joka urself!

Re: Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..

singh · 20 Feb 2006

just a thought... to all of the people invoking the PANTHIC REHIT MARYADA... do all of you actually believe it to be the maryada? is it OK to eat meat? - the maryada says yes it is OK so long as it is not slaughtered in the muslim way. what are the five kakkars? - i bet cha some of you dont agree... what is included in nitnem? - again, i bet most of you like MORE paath in your daily diet than what is written in the maryada so many different issues to think about, these are just a few. but i bet most of you dont agree on all of it. i suggest if you are going to invoke the PANTHIC REHIT MARYADA, you agree with ALL OF IT. fateh jio.

Re: Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..

yes · 20 Feb 2006

>this is shoddy ill thoght out dera maryada. Like most deras they cannot explain why they do and just say it is prataan. There is no evidence to suggest this practice is prataan, just like there is evidence to suggest these deras are prataan< "These deras" provide, and are still providing some of the best paatis, katha vachaks etc. in the panth. Go to 'these deras' and try to tell me otherwise. Speak with someone who has spent a few years at 'these deras' and visit 'these deras' urself instead of sitting in a far off land trying to take shot at 'THESE DERAS'.

Re: Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..

wow · 21 Feb 2006

do not throw the babay out with the bath water. just because the Sikh rehat maryada is not perfect it does not mean we wholly reject and accept the sant samaj mish mash marydada. I think that does not condemn eating meat. Very political, slag off SRM on stages, but in the sant samaj one is the same.

Re: Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..

shota singh · 21 Feb 2006

the PANTHIC REHAT MARYADA ####HAS##### been adhered to by these akj. the only point of contension, is not eating ANY meat!! the basic required minimum bani quoted in the maryada IS completed AND surpassed with further baani. the kakaar, is KEPT! even though considered a bodypart and the actual kakar the keski item. the KES HAS NOT BEEN SHED. therefore the pathic maryada HAS been followed. SO the panthic maryada IS followed to the letter!!! so of course it can be 'invoked'. ...a few things for you to think about!!! Gurfateh Singh jee

Re: Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..

manmati · 21 Feb 2006

gurfateh jio.......frankly speaking i didnt know tat our sikhs are so eerkhaloo tat they cant seee someone doing more baanis.........dun gimme the reason that its not panthic parvaan rehat maryada..........cos its gona get very detail........lets get to the basics jio.......wat was guru nanak's teachings?.....naaam japna.....wandkey chakna....n kirt karni............so is it wrong to do more baani???.......as for maryada is concern i'm a harcore taksaal maryada follower.........but i dun get into the nitty gritty things like panthic parvaan or not parvaan..........tats ur own whether u believe in other maryada...but as far as naam is concern i think we are al wrong now........cos guru arjan dev ji says....aap jap avreh naam japavaho........so by telling letting go all our hatred for another maryada........or another jatha.......i think (asi zeher khol rehey ha).......tats all jio......bhulan chukan di maafi jee...........fateh parvaan kareo ji...........waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh..

Re: Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..

Singh 24/7 · 21 Feb 2006

Mr manmati, you admit you are a hardcore taksali follower, This has nothing to do with jathas. it is common sense, only one paath should be going on at one time. How can you listen to two paaths? It is not a ritual, that just in case some one stopped, then jap ji sahib is happening. Whot sense is that? If you have a break in an akhand path, then by doing japji sahib how are you stopping it? You should ensure there is no break in the first place. Plus it is not only deras that create paathis and kathavacaks. Sikh missionary, AKJ, and many other groups also create paathis and high quality kathavacaks aswell. Sant singh Maskin, Jasvir Singh Khannewale, etc are no dera wale Singhs.

Re: Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..

singh · 21 Feb 2006

shota singh, the quesiton was not whether you mechanically follow the rehit, but if you believe in it. would you eat with someone/ at someone's house - who followed only the PANTHIC REHIT MARYADA? do you believe that people who follow the PANTHIC REHIT MARYADA are full sikhs? more for you to think about. fateh jio,

Re: Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..

Joka · 21 Feb 2006

"no-one said to him not to go and listen to bani. people just said it is not the right maryada, and it is not prataan. " "" BTW I NEVER attend an Akahnd paath if i know such pakhand is being carried on"" What does this mean then einstein? It gives an example of a person who will not attend an akhand path because extra bani is being read does it not? And also hands up how many of you gys when having an akhnad path listen to all of it yourselves? Have you guys sat there for the duration? Do you do the whole akhand path yourselves? According to the 'maryada' if one books an akhand path he should either do it or listen to it himself. So is that what you guys do?

Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..

Forgiveness! · 21 Feb 2006

The reason we do Jap Ji Sahib While Akhand Paath is being done is to ask forgiveness for any mistakes that are made. The same way people will say Waheguru if they make a mistake while doing paath!

Re: Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..

avidya · 21 Feb 2006

Gurfateh Dear Vijaydeep Singh ji Why do you feel chalisa and sampat path are no longer logical?

Re: Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..

24/7 · 21 Feb 2006

so joka, take one line from such a long thread. get a life, you are missing the whole point. to forgiveness what about all the mistakes you make in jap ji sahib, will you get someone else to do a mool manter next to for that. Then another guy doing gurmantar for all the mistakes in mool manter. As vijaydeep said: Two Bani read simulatainusly are insults to Bani as Bani was sent by akal to let us understand but both being sung simulatinuly fails the purpose. cool!

Re: Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..

Joka · 21 Feb 2006

Ermmm i have a life otherwise i would not be here! And who says the path is done out loud? Iv already said it is done quietly!! Please do forgive us maha papi's that we read extra gurbani quietly!! And also please do answer my question as to how many of you follow panthic rehat maryada and listen to THE akhand path or do THE akhand path yourselves! how many of you guys sit there for the duration and listen or read it all. U criticise people for spending 2 hours each reading japji sahib in hazoori of guru ji, and talk about listening to the path. well come on you super sikhs, lets hear how many of u DO listen to the akhand path?

Re: Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..

Admin · 21 Feb 2006

topic closed.