has any1 gt bhai sahib bhai randir singhs recording
akaaaaaaaaal · 16 Feb 2006
wjkk wjkf has any1 gt bhai sahibs recordin???
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
akaaaaaaaaal · 16 Feb 2006
wjkk wjkf has any1 gt bhai sahibs recordin???singh · 16 Feb 2006
People have them but are keeping them gupt, I wonder wayRashpal Singh · 16 Feb 2006
VaheguruJiKaKhalsa VaheguruJiKiFateh There are recording of Bhai Randhir Singh around. You have to ask some of the Puraatan Singhs in India for them, also according to Giani Amolak Singh one of Bhai Sahibs speeches was recorded on Guru Gobind Singh Ji's Gurpurab by the 'All India Radio station' in 1950's. I have tried to get in contact with them several times but haven't received any reply. VaheguruJiKaKhalsa VaheguruJiKiFateh [%sig%]sikh · 16 Feb 2006
it amazes me that people do this. bhai sahib is not guru ji, guru ji spread and gave us bani, naam. why keep them gupt? what on earth are these people thinking keeping bani gupt. more power to the people who call the jatha a cult when u hear these sorts of things.Jagjit Matharu · 16 Feb 2006
Those people are very selfish! Or they are lying.JJSingh · 16 Feb 2006
No they aren't available. 'singh' jee if you know that people are keeping them gupt, you also probably now who those people are? Why don't you go ask them?Confused Khalsa · 16 Feb 2006
many people do this with keertan, rather than give out keertan from "rare" keertanis they keep it for themselves, i really cant understand the logic behind this - surely it would be best to put it on the web so that as many people as possible can benefit from it? I know of two singhs who do this all the time, its very frustrating!MOW! · 16 Feb 2006
yes they do exist when we went to amritsar we asked baba raam singh's wife and she said she used to have a few tapes but people have come round and taken them and not given them back! also pooranji said he used to have a tape where bhai sahib does a single line of the shabad for the entire tape but he doesnt know where it is now.34 · 16 Feb 2006
There are a few Bhai Randhir Singh Ji's tapes. But can't be given out, simply because there too prestige, am sorry! There's a recording of Bhai Sahib Ji on Guru Gobind Singh Ji's gurpurb. Giani Amolak Singh Ji and Bhai Jeevan Singh are on it aswell. 'Jap Man Gobind Aekae Awar Nahee Ko Maerae' is on the tape, and is one of the most beautiful shabads out of the set i have. I may put 1 of the shabads on the Internet, I'll see. But the Puratan Singh who give me this priceless gift, told me not to distribute it to just anyone, only people who will respect. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Ji was a Brahm Giani, and this tape proves it, if I put it up, it wil go on 'www.i-kirtan.com', because this is a good kirtan site, Bhul Chuk Marf.Balpreet Singh · 16 Feb 2006
34, I'm not sure who gave you this tape or if you really have it. But I wonder, Bhai Sahib didn't do kirtan privately and restrict who could hear it? At any rate, if you do have it, I would ask you to please share it. If you have some genuine concerns then please email me at the above address.JJSingh · 16 Feb 2006
Wow '34', that means you must be Brahm giani too, because according to sukhmani sahib: breham giaanee kee gath breham giaanee jaanai || Only the God-conscious being can know the state of the God-conscious being. Also you got the shabad wrong, its actually jap man gobi(n)dh eaekai avar nehee ko laekhai sa(n)th laag manehi shhaadd dhubidhhaa kee kureeaa ||1|| Bhul Chuk maaf ji!Singh · 16 Feb 2006
So, is it better for the tape to sit in some box for a hundred years, or is it better for the Sangat to get 'Darshan' of the Shabads. which they are longing to hear. Please use common sense, Gurbani should not be 'hogged' by people, but rather distributed freely to all people to listen to. We all believe in sharing, don't we?L Singh · 16 Feb 2006
34 Jee, please share your tapes with the sangat worldwide. I respect your sentiments, but please understand that bhai Sahib belonged to the entire panth and not just a select few. 34 Jee, we are all your brothers and sisters, so please be generous enough to share it with us.R Singh · 16 Feb 2006
gur fateh 34 singh ji, it would be amazing if you would put up even one shabdh! you are considering puting one up, but please do uplpoad it to ikirtan.com thank you34 · 16 Feb 2006
i will give it to L Singh, becuase he has asked politley, I will contact you.oh my · 16 Feb 2006
vjkk, vjkf 34 jee, everyone here said it nicely and humbly...:)...thank you for being generous and putting it up. vjkk, vjkfunreal · 16 Feb 2006
Dear '34', Is that what you were waiting for? Someone to ask you politely? If there is seva you are able to provide, do you only do it if someone asks you politely? Is that what you want, people to put their hands together and beg you to share the recording? ....a recording you should be sharing with your brothers and sisters with no hesitation. Please take a look at what you've posted and how it makes you sound. I hope it is only a case of misunderstanding which happens easily on the net. regards, unreal 34 wrote: > i will give it to L Singh, becuase he has asked politley, I > will contact you. [%sig%]Kaur anon · 16 Feb 2006
Fateh ji yes bhai sahib !! Please put the kirtan up !!!! Bhai sahib was well before my time and it was his autobiography that got me into sikhi in the 1st place, his book and his pyar for sikhi just drove me to tears and changed me completely. It would so wonderful and amazing to hear his kirtan !!!! It would be such a HUGE seva !! :) Fateh jisimple singhani · 16 Feb 2006
i agree with balpreet singh! Its seva it distribute these tapes and you shouldn't keep them to yoursleves. bhull chuk maaf wjkk wjkfconfused · 16 Feb 2006
to here puraatan style like his that i've heard soo much about and the keertan that the jatha was started on would be an honourDalvir Singh · 16 Feb 2006
wjkk wjkf 34 jio, thank you for sharing with us that you have some tapes of Bhai Sahib ji. But as everyone here has said, would you please share these priceless tracks with us. We all long to hear this great Brahm Giani's voice as he recites Guru Ji's Bani. I know that all of us will respect these recordings with utmost respect. We all look forward, 34 jio, to hearing these tracks. Please, could you put them up?:) Dalvir Singh wjkk wjkfnobody · 16 Feb 2006
From what i remember, bhai sahib refused to let people record his keertan because he said that you are not listening to keertan when you play back, only a mere sound. Its not the same and therefore didnt let people record him. There was a singh who bought new equipment and asked to record. He was refused but tries neway! Suprisingly, this equiptment all broke down and burned out! As it was not meant to be. I personally dont think there are recordings out there, if there are, be nice to hear, keertan frm the older days! :) nothin more! just to hear the keertan from Gursikhs with such a jeevan, u can tell the differance! SImply as that person has kamai to back up and inspire others!singh · 17 Feb 2006
upload the audio, its not right to keep it to yourself, if you dont upload it then just shutup.Jagjit Singh · 17 Feb 2006
waheguru ji kakhalsa, waheguru ji kefateh Pyare jio, Bani does not belong to us. We have no right over it. That is why it is against Gurmat to sell it. One of the key aims of AKJ has always been Niskam seva and taking bani to people all over the world. No keertan is ever sold on any sites, it is all shared, because ultimately it belongs to the Guru, Panth and humanity. Whether people have keertan of bhai sahib, or any other keertani, whether it is articles, lectures, photos, or anything. None of this belongs to us. It belongs to the Panth. So many people withhold things. This is a great disservice to the Panth. Withholding anything just feeds our ego and pride that we have something no one else haves. Whether you have keertan of bhai sahib or not. It matters not. For me listening to keertan from Bhai sahib Randhir Singh is no different to listening to it from the likes of Bhai Jeevan Singh ji. Ultimatley bani is bani, and the jeevans are all high. But I would say, because I know how hard it was to get info to write books like Kurbani and jeevans of Gursikhs, from people. These things inspire people, and spread them virtues of the jeevan wale Gursikhs. Those who with hold things are doing a great disserve to the sangat and blessings that they have had, and lack Panthic dard, especially when it comes to withholding info on jeevans of Gursikhs. So all those Uk Gursikhs and there are many, who have literally suitcases full of old tapes and spools. You know who you are, because this is not the first time this conversation has happened. They need to question themselves, and see of what value are all them gems doing lying there in suitcases on top of wardrobes for years. They should all be on websites, with open access for any searcher and lover of Sikhi and bani. waheguru ji ke khalsa wahguru ji ke fatehSingh · 17 Feb 2006
I belive it should be shared, you can get Sant Ishar Singh Rara sahib Wela tapes, Sant Ishar Singh nanaksar's tapes, Sant Kartar Singh and Sant Gurbachan Singh tapes. People still learn from these tapes. Bhai Sahib did not do kirtan locked up in a room, so why keep the tapes locaked up from the sangat. People part of AKJ need to Speak with these people and get them to share the tapes. As no other Jatha as this problem.L Singh · 17 Feb 2006
34 Jee, you can contact me through my email if you like.34 · 17 Feb 2006
to Jagjit Singh, if we have no right over Gurbani, and it does'nt belong to us, why don't AKJ lot do ragmala, you guys are cutting shabad from Guru Granth Sahib Ji??? if you can give me answer, I swear I will put the tape on the Internet, promise. bhul chuk marf.... · 17 Feb 2006
34, I don't care if you have 1 tape of Bhai Sahib or 101 tapes of Bhai Sahib, when someone attacks a principle, nothing else matters. You asked why AKJ "lot" don't read ragmala and are "cutting shabad" from Guru Sahib. My answer is that ragmala isn't bani. It is the song sung by a Kanjari (prostitute) while dancing to attract a handsome Brahmin. Why are you "lot" reading this? That's my question. If extra material (which came before ragmala in the sequence after Mundavani) like "jit dar lakh Mohamadan", etc. can be removed because it's FAKE, then why not this? If you have the tape (which I highly doubt), then no one should have to beg you to put it online. Bhai Sahib didn't read ragmala and wrote against it. The others on teh tape, like Giani Amolak Singh and Bhai Jeevan Singh also never read ragmala. If you are so emphatic on the issue, then maybe you shouldn't listen to it either. On one hand you're saying Bhai Sahib is a Brahmgyani and on the other you're bringing up ragmala? Give me a break. Guru Gobind Singh jee wrote to Aurangzeb that his oaths and pledges mean nothing. I have a feeling your "promise" to put the "tape" on the internet may just fall into this category as well. I request the sangat to not beg 34 for the tape. If someone accepts the Sangat's request and gives it, then that is great. If someone refuses the Sangat's requests then he himself is guilty and will face the consequences. Sangat should not beg for anything.R Singh · 17 Feb 2006
I cant think why 34 would lie about having this tape. if you do have it then it would be a great sevaa putting it up on the net. so will you able to upload the kirtan anytime soon? another thing is that tapes have a short lifespan so someone really should put it on cd and digitise the audio so it wont be lost in the future. if youre not able to convert formats then maybe you could send it to Lsingh or anyone else who can convert audio. if you have any queries please contact me via email... you are lucky to have these tapes so please do this sevaa of putting up the kirtan. you can also send copies to me and i will be able to upload quickly. waheguroo ji kaa khaalsaa! waheguroo jee kee fateh!Bhagwant Singh Virk · 17 Feb 2006
Bhai Sahib 34 Ji I can not understand what the issue about Ragmala has to do with putting someone's (in this case Bhai Randhir Singh's) recordings of Gurbani Kirtan on the internet. In essence it is two different issues and should not be linked. Bhai Sahib 34 Ji as you can see from other posts, the general sangat would be very grateful to you for relesing these tapes - and if necessary allowing those that have the technical skills to work on the recordings inorder for them to have the best possible sound quality. If you decide to upload them please let the sangat know accordingly by maybe posting a link on this thread WJK,WJF Bhagwant Singh [%sig%]Singh · 17 Feb 2006
please do some research on raagmala, then you will realise no one is cutting anything. However the Panth did remove rattan mala and other compositions before hand. I think you have no tape and this whole thread is nothing but a wind up!gsingh · 17 Feb 2006
sangat is gurus roop, you can't refuse them. Why not do some sewa and put it on www.ikirtan.com , i can't understand why people are scared or something to share these things. im sure you don't realise how much the sangat will appreciate it and of course you will get the reward for putting it up. so this is a reques.t [%sig%]LionKing (LK) · 17 Feb 2006
ehm. People saying we should keep Gurbani to ourself etc. Read the Shabad yourself!, Listen tothe Shabad yourself - SIngh it yourself. If you're truely out for the Shabad you don't need someone "big" to sing it for you.Kulwinder Singh · 17 Feb 2006
Dear All., Don’t fall in the trap of anybody, if 34 or anybody have something to share then they can share if they don’t want to then it is up to them, people want to make you lose the focus from real issue and want to start conflict among Sikhs, People who do want to create problems within Sikhism are our real hardcore enemies. So please beware of these dangerous elements. I feel that this recording do not exist at least with this person and this individual is just trying to make Sikhs lose energy by fighting among themselves. Best Regards Kulwinder Singh [%sig%]JJSingh · 17 Feb 2006
I personally dont think there are any recordings of Bhai Sahib. If they were don't you think they would be around by now. It would be great if there were some recordings, but i highly doubt it. Bhai Sahib was always in favour of Live recordings, as recordings never have the same effect, no matter how good the recording is. As someone mentioned before, there was a time that some singh insisted on recording, against Bhai Sahib's wishes and his equipment all fused so that he couldn't record it. I also heard about another time when someone was recording and after when they heard the recording, all except Bhai Sahibs recording was there. As we all know Bhai Sahib had a lot of kamai, which is clearly evident in his writings and jeevan. If he ever thought or wished something, how could it never be that it did not happen? If he wished for his recordings not be done, then I doubt there is any. '34' please stop trying to mislead the sangat. If you do have then please care to share it with us!JJSingh · 17 Feb 2006
Sorry I meant 'Live Kirtan' not Live recordings.bani guru · 17 Feb 2006
bani guru guru hai bani vich bani amrit saray gur bani khehay sevak jan manay parthak guru nis thatary. this raagmala business has been goin on for centuries, even when brham giani sant baba isher singh ji rara sahib wale ,brham giani sant baba attar singh mastuanay wale were bout these highly spiritual beings use to read it and so do there jathe, even till now. now if they are at such a high level and they were not condemed so why are we doing it now ,have we gone higher then them. now also why if we dont believe in raagmala do we still do matha tek...... are we just.... kidding our selfs? what happend to II sat gur mara poora II and also are we saying that our guru is a fake! with out reading raagmala during a akhand path is an incomplete akhand path you must read this if you want guru jis blessing. you cannot pick and choose which bania you likeand diss like and have any of you ever read it and studied it first before slandering it. and 1 last thing i just wanted to say during guru jis life time there were so many people that wanted there scriptures to be written in the guru granth sahib but guru only accepted those who were addiquate? the only person that can take raagmala out is the person that put it in.......... giani amolak singh ji was not against it please get your facts right!!!!!! [%sig%]... · 17 Feb 2006
bani guru, This thread isn't about ragmala but your post deserves a reply. I don't think Baba Attar Singh believed in Ragmala. He was a member of Panch Khalsa which was very against ragmala. Highly spiritual Gursikhs like Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh wrote against ragmala. Why do we matha tek to the bir if it has ragmala? It also has the table of contents. It also has a place of publishing. Some birs also have a stamp that says "Chatter Singh Jivan Singh" or "SGPC" are you kidding yourself? And as for Guru Sahib having put it in: that's exactly the point. He didn't. The same way people added Rattan Mala, "Jit dar Lakh Muhammadan", "siahi ki bidh" and other stuff after ragmala, and it was removed, same way ragmala should be. After all, this extra stuff came before ragmala in the old saroops. If the stuff before ragmala was cut out, why not ragmala? Giani Amolak Singh did not believe in Ragmala. There's no doubt about that. Same with Bhai Jeevan Singh.member · 18 Feb 2006
Jagjit Singh stated 'So all those Uk Gursikhs and there are many, who have literally suitcases full of old tapes and spools. You know who you are, because this is not the first time this conversation has happened.' My father has collected many excellent kirtan audio and video tapes over 25+ years. These include many videos of Sant Jarnail Singh's speeches and we may even have a recording of the first main trip from the UK to Hemkunt Sahib at the start of the 80's. However, I do not have the resources to upload these on the net. If you can put me in touch with a trustworthy person in West Lonson who has the relevant kit to clean these up and upload then I am willing to allow them access to these tapes. Inderjit SSingh · 18 Feb 2006
You know in the Harmander Sahib prantan Guru Granth Sahib, is their raag mala and ratan mala in there?... · 18 Feb 2006
The saroop parkaash on the upper level at Sri Darbar Sahib is old but it's not puraatan. It was written by a Gursikh who's name I forget now, but it is not considered a historical saroop.. · 18 Feb 2006
vjkk, vjkf I thought that's the saroop written/compile by the Guru's and Bhagats (the bigg one on the upper level. vjkk, vjkf... · 18 Feb 2006
No, the saroop on the upper level is very beautiful and written with a lot of care, but it is not considered historical. If it was the original saroop then it would solve a lot of problems.. · 18 Feb 2006
vjkk, vjkf what happend to the original saroop? vjkk, vjkfwahegurooo · 19 Feb 2006
wjkk wjkf Yh sum ppl say dat the world aint ready 4 bhai sahibs keertan"!!!Singh · 19 Feb 2006
"Yh sum ppl say dat the world aint ready 4 bhai sahibs keertan"!!!" Why is this? Bhai Sahib use to keep his keertan darbars open.wahegurooo · 21 Feb 2006
butin dem days rainsbhais use 2 b propa chardi kala every1 use 2 b in darbar sahib u wud nt c any 1 in langar halls lyk now. you'll c ppl socialising and i askd bhai shangara singh bwt bhai sahibs keertan he sed no1 cud eva do keertan lyk da but in dem days did dey use 2 do simran wif da shabad?? cuz in da 60s recordins dey did do simran and bhai sahib went 2 sach kand in 1961! so itz reli confusin plz explain wjkk wjkf