Bhog?
KhalsaSingh1699 · 12 Feb 2006
I just had a question about "bhog".. Should we really call it bhog? I was under the impression that bhog is a hindu ceremony where they put it their parshad on the murtis mouth and then mix it back in with the rest of it and give it out or use the jhoota of their guru (this sounds funny but it has happened... i remember i was at a friends just to view how their program went down and their guru drank some water and spit it back into a bowl and it was distributed to the "sangat"..of course I did not drink it :/). Do we not just give it to panj and then distribute it? I don't see the jhoota part anywhere. This may sound like a really silly question but I've had differing opinions on it. Thanks.
Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa! Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh!
Re: Bhog?
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 13 Feb 2006
Bhog just means "USE"....anything that we USE can be said to be BHOGGED by us...
We BHOG our umur..Lami umar bhogee....meaning lived a LONG life !!!
Bhog is also for SEX in marriage..as well as outside marriage
Bhog is also for Consumption...eating..etc.
The TUK Bhog lavoh har rai from guru Arjun Ji that the Taksalis and others use when they Present Karrah parshaad/Langgar to GURU Ji for Kirapn Bhet is a WRONG interpretation of the Entire SHABAD..they take LITERAL Menaing of the words...Our GURU is SHABAD GURU... we seek His APPROVAL..PARWAAN HOVEH..no way is this GYAAN GURU going to eat the parshaad and give us SEET (polite word for JHOOTH) parshaad..THAT PAKHAND is doen by the DEHDHAREE gurus like radhasoamis etc.
Jarnail singh
Re: Bhog?
Gurpreet Sumra · 13 Feb 2006
A very well known Santji in his book writes that karah parshad was made and it was weighed and then after ardaas and bhog it was weighed again and was found to be 250 grams less.Guru Granth Sahib ji ne bhog laataa
Saadh Sangat ji aakho Satnaaaam shri waheguruuuuuuuuu!!!!!!!
Re: Bhog?
KhalsaSingh1699 · 13 Feb 2006
Thanks for the replies. I do not know if I agree with Gurpreet the only reason being I do not see how the Guru Granth Sahib could consume the parshad (this is making it an idol). Guru Panth ( the panj pyaarey) is our physical form of the Guru and Guru Granth Sahib Ji is the spiritual Guru. The reason we put a chandoa and stuff is because we are symbolizing that we value words and gyan so much. I may be wrong but that is what I have always bee taught. But your story is interesting and if it is true it is totally fantastic.
Re: Bhog?
Confused Khalsa · 16 Feb 2006
agreed with "........"
many thinks in Sikhi, some people will say "how can that be.."
if its done with love and humility, (and is in line with Gurmat) then it CAN be :)
Guru Ji is so beant, just look at the Sakhi (Story) of Bhagat Dhana Ji
Re: Bhog?
Kookar Tere Darbaar · 16 Feb 2006
Humility alone is useless without knowing HOW TO USE IT.
Sikhi = humility (shardaa) + KNOWLEDGE
If you are doing something then KNOW WHY YOU ARE DOING IT
[gurbani]gurmuiK igAwnu iqsu sBu ikCu sUJY AigAwnI AMDu kmweI hy ]2][/gurbani]
"The Gurmukh attains spiritual wisdom, and understands everything. The ignorant ones act blindly. ||2||"
1047
And if we are going to justify BLIND FAITH or BLIND RITUALISM with Bhagat Dhanna jee's Sakhi then I say PLEASE READ GURBANI AND READ THE SAKHI rather than rely on MISLED PARCHAARIKS who like to dramatise Sakhis and twist the facts to please the public.
(By the way if someone in response to my post is going to quote the episode of Bhagat Dhanna ji quoted in Bhai Gurdas ji's Vars then please realise NUMBER ONE SOURCE is GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI. Secondly - Bhai Gurdas Ji is not stating the episode he has recorded is the ACTUAL STORY (because any educated sikh who reads gurbani will know what truly happened from Guru ARjan ji's explanation. INSTEAD Bhai Gurdas ji is RECORDING the version of the story which PEOPLE AT THE TIME believed to be true story of bhagat dhanna but there was no written record of this story. So Bhai Sahib did this to show what the people at the time thought. however any person who reads gurbani will KNOW this as guru arjan ji REFUTES the fact that bhagat dhanna ji met vaheguru through "BLIND FAITH" in a STONE! - please read Panthic Weekly, someone wrote an article about this bhagat dhanna ji).
Re: Bhog?
Gurpreet Sumra · 16 Feb 2006
well said kookar guru ke darbar
Read Bhagat Dhanna ji's bani in SGGS ji, you will never find anywhere that he was a pathar pujari, rather bhagat dhanna ji's bani is saying against pathar puja.Immediately followed by it is Guru Arjan Dev ji's bani
"Gobind gobind gobind sang namdeo man lina__---------
-----------------------------------
eh bidh sun ke jattdo phir bhagti laga
mile parthak gosain dhanna vadbhaga"
In this Guru Arjan Dev ji explains all bhagats from Namdev to bhagat sain ji and then tells that after hearing about these bhagats Dhanaa ji started bhagti. None of above mentioned bhagats were pathar pujak, so how can bhagat dhanna ji be one.
It seems that such a story was prevalent at Guru Saab's time that's why
Guru Arjan Dev ji wrote his bani to dispel any misconceptions that Dhanaa ji was pathar Pujak.
[%sig%]
Re: Bhog?
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 16 Feb 2006
so agyani su jio,
how long do YOU wait before YOU weigh the karrah parshad ??..or are you jsut makhee te makhee maree janeh..baba nand singh ji weighed it baba nand singh ji weighed it ?
WHY did he Weigh it in the first place ?? to "SHOW" his shardhaa is greater than su Ji ?? To me it shows haumaii..Guru Ji or his Bhagats NEVER CHALLENGED anyone over "shardha"..people like manna su dhanwanta su and
daljeet su of chicago DO CHALLENGE and now even GO TO COURT and SUE..to PROVE they are CORRECT and their others are WRONG ??
BUT please JUST give me YOUR ANSWER..how long do you wait each time you do ardass ?? How many times has YOUR parshaad weighed LESS ? I will GIVE YOU MY HEAD..or are you willing to Give me YOURS ?? (lets have your real name first just to start off )
Just for your info.I have NEVER weighed my parshad and have no intention of doing so..and dont beleive in such "shardha"..GURU JI doesnt NEED this.
Jarnail SINGH.
Re: Bhog?
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 17 Feb 2006
Author: Gurpreet Sumra
Date: 02-13-06 19:47
A very well known Santji in his book writes that karah parshad was made and it was weighed and then after ardaas and bhog it was weighed again and was found to be 250 grams less.Guru Granth Sahib ji ne bhog laataa
Saadh Sangat ji aakho Satnaaaam shri waheguruuuuuuuuu!!!!!!!
<<<<<<<<<<<<<<
veer ji,
how heavy was the original ?? I mean 250 GM out of 1 Kilo is 1/4.....and that is heavy !! or was it 250 Gm out of 10Kilo..or 100 kilos because Nanaksar has a LOT of devotees....so they must make a LOT of karrah parshaad there !! i also heard NOW they DONT make Karrah Parshaad or Langgar because Sukka Parshaad is more economical ( the devotees can return the extra so that the shop people can repackage it once more..recycling..
How much does the WATER that leaves as STEAM weigh ?? as karrah parshaad cools down..steam does escape.. was that taken into account ?? or was the Parshaad weighed piping hot ?
I also heard some sant ji saying..DONT BHET KIRPAN to piping hot parshaad..GURU JI's TONGUE will get BURNT...cool it all down first !! I didnt know Guru Ji's "tongue" is the KIRPAN !!!..and He tastes the parshaad when we BHET the Kirpan.....so Guru Ji doesnt NEED hands to hold the parshaad..but just tastes it with his tongue ( G***S )
I dont know whether it is my "shardha" or something..i cant take such tales sitting down...or I would place a weighing scale in our gurdwara ( btw no gurdwara of any denomination has any such weighing scales..probabaly have to wait too long and the sangats as you know are pretty much in a hurry... Please do let me know if ANY Gurdwara WAITS for Guru Ji to EAT before they wand the Parshaad...just in case some other "SU" like me with no shardha wants to weigh it...
Jarnail singh
Re: Bhog?
Gurpreet Sumra · 17 Feb 2006
Another well known Santji writes in his book that he put a jug of water on his head while taking bath and Guru granth sahib ji came in his thoughts and rumale got wet.
Saadh Sangat ji aakho Satnam shri Waheguruuuuuuu!!!!!!
Re: Bhog?
Gurpreet Sumra · 17 Feb 2006
Prabh ka simran saadh ke sang
Sarab nidhan nanak har rang
You get to recite akaal purakhs name in the sangat of gurmukh(saadh sangat),in akaal purakh’s love you get all treasures.
Sun meeta nanak binvaanta saadh jana ki acharaj katha
Prof Sahib Singh: Saadh : jis ne apne man nu saadh leya hai, vas vich kita hai,Gurmukh
So whole astpadi is talking about Gurmukhs, not person who writes Saadh or Sant with his name.That person can be anyone.Also Saadh is used for Sangat many a times in Gurbani.
Sant, where it is used in singular is Akaal Purakh and where plural, it is used for Sikhs or Saadh Sangat.At the end of the Ashtpadee Guru Sahib is praising lord or Akaal Purakh not anybody else.
These Saadh and Sants have done a great disservice to Sikhs by betraying Guru Granth sahib ji’s Bani. They use these lines without telling the entire message of Sukhmani Sahib. They just use these lines to declare their santhood. Sikhs should read Gurbani and try to find what it means.
Where sant sajan, sant sangat, sant jana etc is used it is used for Sikhs or Saadh sangat.
If we try to read Gurbani and understand(try to) we can easily find where it is used for guru, sangat, akal purakh.
Satguru Saadh na sewaya har bhagat naa bhai(422, for Guru)
Sun sun maha tripat man pawe saadh amrit bani(611, for Guru)
Amrit bachan saadh ki bani
Saadh dhur much mastal layi,nanak udhare har gun sarnayi(744,for Guru)
Kumbh bina jal na tikawe saadh bina aise abgat jaawe
Ghundi bin kya gaanth chadaiye saadh bina taise abgat jaiye
Ghod bina kaise aswaar saadh bin nahi darbaar(872, Guru)
Satgur ki ahima satgur jane jo kich kare so apan bhaane
Saadh dhur jaache jan tere Nanak sad kurbana hai(1075, for Guru)
Sant Sajjan bhaye sarse pure gur te jaani(922, for Sikhs or sangat)
Amrit gun sant bolte sun griha pilaawo
Jab bhagat kare sant mandli tin mil har gaawo
Karo namaskar bhagat jan dhur much laawo(813, sangat)
Santaan seti rang na laaye sakat sang vikaram kamaye(105, for sangat)
Aayo sajan sant meet pyare mil gaawo gun agam apaare(104 for sangat)
Santoh sang baise gun gaayi(194, for sangat)
Santoh har har har aaradho(627 for sangat)
Sant mile kich suniye kahiye mile asant mast kar rahiye(870, for gurmukhs)
Sant triptaase har har dhraaye(394, for sangat)
So in gurbani, there is nothing about these sants, or saadhs. For about 250 years there was no sant and then they started flourishing like mushrooms.Bhagat word has also been used in Gurbani a lot but none of the Sants , Babas have used it. They have betrayed Guru sahib’s teachings by declaring them sant and telling fairy tales to people and not telling them the truth. They did everything that is against Gurmat and that is why today Sikhs don’t want to listen to Gurbani because Sant ji is much better then Guru Sahib because Guru Sahib tells you truth and harsh realities and Sant ji gives you fairy tales and darshan of Sri Chand , Guru Nanak devji to Guru Gobind Singh ji.
A very recent Sant Maan Singh Pehowa, when someone asked him that don’t recite Kachi bani he said what is kachi bani, sikh said that is not in Guru Granth Sahib then he says:
4 sahibzaadeyan de naam SGGS ch nahi hain oh kachhe ne, bol WAHGURU!!
5 pyareyyan de naam SGGS ch nahi ne oh kachhe ne, bol WAHEGURU!
40 muktyaan de naam SGGS ch nahin ne oh kache ne , bol WAHEGURU!!
And made a mockery of all Sikhs and went away.
[%sig%]
Re: Bhog?
loooooooooool · 17 Feb 2006
A very recent Sant Maan Singh Pehowa, when someone asked him that don’t recite Kachi bani he said what is kachi bani, sikh said that is not in Guru Granth Sahib then he says:
4 sahibzaadeyan de naam SGGS ch nahi hain oh kachhe ne, bol WAHGURU!!
5 pyareyyan de naam SGGS ch nahi ne oh kachhe ne, bol WAHEGURU!
40 muktyaan de naam SGGS ch nahin ne oh kache ne , bol WAHEGURU!!
And made a mockery of all Sikhs and went away.
____________________________________________________________
how is this making a mockery of sikhs? I dont get it....maybe a bhai sahib can explain this as only bhai sahib from the pakand kirtan jatha knws all...
Re: Bhog?
Gurpreet Sumra · 17 Feb 2006
Kuch guruaan nu chad ke baki de naam SGGS ch nahi ne, oh kache ne
Saadh Sangat ji aakho Satnam shri waheguruuuuuuu!!!!!!
Re: Bhog?
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 17 Feb 2006
The Most hyped words these days are "Company of the HOLY".....and the first thing they jump on is to quote Sukhmani Sahib Ji....
WELL, there was NO SHORTAGE of such "Company of the HOLY" in Guru nanak ji's Time....wasnt the SIDHS gathered "Company of the Holy"...wasnt the huge groups of Nangeh Sadhs, Yogis, Jatta jUUT sadhus,..and what not "Company of the HOLY"....today these have changed into DERA....of so an so SANT.."Company of the HOLY"....NO WAY. IF these Companies were NOT HOLY then they are NOT HOLY NOW.
Guru Ji put us on the Right PATH.
The BIGGEST SAADH/SANT is sitting right there DEEP DOWN INSIDE OF US...Guru Amardass Ji says in no unclear terms that this Human Body is the HARMANDIR Waheguru Sajj for HIS OWN SPECIAL ABODE....we are just mere TENANTS....temporary kirayehdaar....and the real owner is Waheguru.
So "SAADH KE SAANG" is in the Company of the SAADH inside of YOU. Meaning if "Naam Simran" is just at the tip of the tongue...muh jabani..and DOESNT REACH DEEP DOWN..SAADH KE SAANG..the SAADH is NOT involved in your Naam simran..it is all in vain...a sort of watering the plant top soil..but never reaching the ROOTS..where it matters most.
Naam Simran SAADH KE SAANG will seep right down deep down..and Bring out the Real Beauty from inside you....inner beauty will shine...your Face will have RADIANCE..the Halo.
IN an Ordinary "saddh sangat"...in the Gurdwara in the August Presence of Sahensha Guur Granth Ji Sahib....it is MUCH EASIER to touch Base with the SAADH Inside of all of us. THATS all to it.
ALl the other hyping about "company of the Holy" ( meaning the frauds who have names and titles of sant saadh so and so etc" is all BOMBED OUT and of no consequence at all....SUKHMANI SAHIB is NOT about these FRAUDS..danke dee chot te..Touch Base with YOUR OWN SAADH/SANT INSIDE YOU ..in the company of the ordinary Gurdwra saadh sangat.. and dont worry about anything...
Jarnail Singh
Bundha Ji.. Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh.
What i dont get is NO ONE ever doubted that GURU NANAK JYOT in Physical Form ever "ate" or Not. They were human in form and obvioulsy ATE.
WHY are the so called Sants you mentioned all so HYPED up about "FEEDING" the SHABAD JYOT...Nanak Jyot in Shaabd Form that is Guru Garanth JI ?? There is NO Need to feed this JYOT...and it doesnt need feeding to survive.
And then their haumaii gets the better of them and they go on to "PROVE" i am better than you..see i can weigh this and show you...wah wah sant honn taan aeisseh. BUT the funny thing is I DONT SEE their Modern day Gadhi-daar SANTS showing this power ?? perhaps they dont have it..where can I SEE one ??
YES I am pretty sure GURU GOBIND SINGH JI is watching..i am GLAD he is...and I WONT be sorry when i go to Him...He taught me to write what i write..SHUBH KARMAN te na DAROON...Nischay kar aapnee jeet karoon..no frauds can frighten me.
Jarnail singh
Re: Bhog?
KhalsaSingh1699 · 20 Feb 2006
Sorry about my question and reply. I did not mean to spark controversy (if i did bhul chuk maaf). I guess I have been society has brainwashed us to be scientific thinker and not always think with out inner souls. For me something has to be physically felt, which is something I am getting over still. I think its beautiful that out of sharda and innocence we do so many things just for the love of the guru and naam. Thanks for all the replies.
Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa! Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh!