Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Gristi Jeevan vs. Living Alone

Gristi Jeevan vs. Living Alone

Independence · 26 Nov 2003

A Gristi jeevan is like living a world of responsibility. Is it important to live a gristi jeevan? What if one day i decide to live alone, and try doing bhagti or alot of paath, would i be able to do that for the rest of my life if i wanted? Or is it important to lead a gristi jeevan. p.s. isn't bhagti greater?

Re: Gristi Jeevan vs. Living Alone

SinghJee · 26 Nov 2003

Yes, Bhagti is greater than anything - Without a doubt, However, Bhagti is so much more developed when living a gristhee jeevan, If all we did was bhagti, We wouldn't be able to learn how to control our krodh, haumai, kaam, etc. etc. in real life situations When living a gristhee jeevan, our bhagti is more developed because we are able to learn how to accept guru sahib's will more easily, If we lived alone, we would be isolated and thus unable to learn how to cope with other people, with annoyances, etc. Basically, all of the Guru Sahibs had wives (except guru harkrishan sahib jee) They preached to live a life with a wife, All major Gursikhs atleast within the past century have had wives, (Bhindrwale sants, prominent Akj Gursikhs, etc.) This should be good enough reason to believe that bhagti is very possible and even more fruitful in gristi.

Re: Gristi Jeevan vs. Living Alone

Independence · 26 Nov 2003

oh i c thanks But do we really need to apply bhagti in this situations in kaljug. If our most important task is to meet god, why can't we just do bhagti?/

Re: Gristi Jeevan vs. Living Alone

gtk · 26 Nov 2003

if i was a chammar, then took amrit would i have trouble finding a wife if i believe in keski rehet?? if i wud what should i do?dating is wrong right? so that means i am meant to overcome my 5 evils without greest jeevan. is this possible? coming from the background i came is it possible to follow the pathway of a householders life as prescribed by guru ji?

Re: Gristi Jeevan vs. Living Alone

jagjit singh · 26 Nov 2003

waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh pyare jio, Buddhists have a similar mentality, and do alot of Bhagti. But Guru ji rejected this philosophy. To do bhagti in this life is beneficial to yourself only, and running away in to caves, or mountains, or even being hermits in your own homes in birmingham, bradford or southall, is only of value to that person. In fact it is very selfish in nature, something completely adverse to sikhi. Taoism does the same, and many monks spend years living in caves in Mount Woo-dang, studying kung fu and meditation. But of what value is that saint warrior if throughout his life he never mingles in society. Of what value is his kung fu, but only to himself, and his handful of chosen chelas. Guru Ji created a khalsa who does not run away from the ills of society, but confronts them. The Khalsa Akal Purkh ki fauj should be working tirelessly on educational, humanitarian, political and social projects, as Guru Ji did himself. I do feel we as the sikh community have created a rut of nothing more than endless akhand paths which no one listens to, and endless langars, feeding the wealthy. Similar gristi jeevan is essential, without it one will always be limited in spirituality. That is what Bhai Rama Singh told us, he always encouraged Gristi jeevan, eventhough he himself was unable to follow such a path. Sikhism is becoming too sant-ified, and forgeting its responsibilities in this world. Sahib Guru NanaK dev ji stated truth is high, but higher is truthful living, similarly we can see bhagti is high, but higher is bhagti in a gristi jeevan (worldly context). Ask any mother to do bhagti, then ask her to do bhagti with a young child in the house. That takes real dedication. waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: Gristi Jeevan vs. Living Alone

jagjit singh · 26 Nov 2003

Vaheguru jee ka Khalsa Vaheguru jee kee fateh! pyare jio, what has coming from a chammer background got to do with anything. Are you not a khalsa? There are alot of gursikhs from previous low castes in jatha in India. One bibi, I know, is the only Amritdahree bibi who presents on national TV, on Doordarshan. She wears a keskee. There are many others. I met her there, she was interviewing on sikhi parchaar. After she asked me some questions, she also discussed caste. Later she told me she was from a chammer background, but got educated and came into sikhi, and was very happy. I said Guru jee, helps all, especially those who walk towards him. If you really a chaamer, forget about it, and have a khalsa mentality. If you cannot find a resta, talk to India Singhs, there are many bibian out there. In phagwara area, where I am from, most of the families of jatha are married out of caste. it is actively encouraged. Caste should never be an issue, if you have complete faith in Guru ji. Guru Ji will always find you the perfect sanjogi. waheguru ji kekhalsa waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: Gristi Jeevan vs. Living Alone

Independence · 27 Nov 2003

What about Bhagat Kabir and Bhagat Fareed? Are you saying they were selfish people? If Bhagti is good and transform people into pure, and if its the only reason we're here, then why not bhagti? Why Gristi jeevan stil?

Re: Gristi Jeevan vs. Living Alone

warrior*princess · 27 Nov 2003

errm whats a chammer? Or im not understanding its purnounciation.

Re: Gristi Jeevan vs. Living Alone

Kulbir Singh · 27 Nov 2003

Princess bhain jeeo, Chamaar is a sub-caste that belongs to the lowest hierarchy of caste system in Hindus – Shudras. People doing leather related work were classified as chamaars by the ancient Hindus. Great saint, Bhagat Ravidaas jee was from a Chamaar background and he never was ashamed of it. He boldly mentioned “chamaar” with his name e.g. “Keh Ravidaas Chamaara” or “Kaho Ravidaas, Khalaas Chamaara”. Folk tales have been very cruel to Chamaars. They stereo-type them as malicious and deceiving people. Loona the evil stepmother of Pooran Bhagat, a famous Punjabi folktale character, was from a chamaar background. Qaadir Yaar in Kissa Pooran Bhagat, wrongfully writes that chamaars are very beautiful people by looks but are not trustworthy. Such wrong notions were rife in those days. Other writers and even Rishis (Hindu Saints) like Mannu, who wrote Mannu Simriti, had very bad things to say about Chamaars and other low caste people. Contrary to popular opinion of those times, Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee Maharaaj embraced all low castes and lifted them to the same level as other castes. Guru Sahib preached that the caste background does not make anyone good or bad. It is individual's deeds that make a person good or bad. This is the reason why Guru Sahib and Sikh Panth always faced stiff opposition from the Brahmins. One of the reasons why institution of langar was started was to bring equality in Sikhs of all backgrounds. Previously, low castes were treated very badly in Punjab and are still treated bad in some states of India. But under the influence of Sikhi, things are much better in Punjab. At our gurdwaras, throughout the world, no distinction is made between castes, when serving langar etc. It is true that caste system is not recognized in Sikh faith, but still we have some Hindu influence on us and we have not ridden ourselves of caste system. There are still traces of caste system in Sikhs. Guru Sahib will do kirpa and Sikh panth will become a casteless faith. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Gristi Jeevan vs. Living Alone

Khalsa Soulja · 27 Nov 2003

if u are living a household life, then the very act of having a child involves kaam, wot r we ment 2 do about that? no1s given me a really good reason for this............kaam is kaam.........yet household living is said to be better?

Re: Gristi Jeevan vs. Living Alone

KaurS · 27 Nov 2003

Khalsa Soulja, Everyone has Kaam. Kaam is wrong, but we all have it. Deal with it. Gristhee jeevan provides a decent/acceptable opportunity to channel our Kaam energy because we have been blessed with Anand Karaj from our Guru Sahib. I myself used to believe that Kaam is wrong no matter what in every situation, but you have to understand that it's always present, releasing it with a spouse in a controlled, respectful way is not manmat. Show me one Gursikh who has said this.

Re: Gristi Jeevan vs. Living Alone

warrior*princess · 27 Nov 2003

Thank you veer jee for that detailed explanation :)

Re: Gristi Jeevan vs. Living Alone

gtk · 27 Nov 2003

bhai jagjit singh thank u very much i am glad to hear jaat paat isnt practiced amongst the jatha singhs in india when it comes to marriage. However what if i want a wife from here in the uk? bhai kulbir singh thank u for your input on the matter too.

Re: Gristi Jeevan vs. Living Alone

tohada daas · 28 Nov 2003

thanx bhai jagjit singh ji, kulbir singh ji and khalsaSoulja ji

Re: Gristi Jeevan vs. Living Alone

Mr. Singh · 28 Nov 2003

>>>>>>>>>>wot r we ment 2 do about that? no1s given me a really good reason for this............kaam is kaam.........yet household living is said to be better?>>>>>>>>> Kaam, krodh, lobh, moh and ahankar never go away. They don't disappear. It's just that with bhagti Singhs/Kaurs are able to bring the 5 evils under total control. It is not wrong to do kaam in marriage it's just that with bhagti both husband and wife develop greater mat and gain more and more control over the 5 evils. In marriage act of kaam is done so that we may have sikhs in the future. In my understanding the 5 evils pull our mind away from "antar dhian" and pull it into the maya outside. With paath and naam simran we "antar gath tirath maal nhao" (Japji Sahib) "we draw our attention inwards and scrub ourselves clean" (very literal translation). Can someone please verify the translation. Also, this is just what I think...I haven't verified my understanding on the matter with Singhs yet.

Re: Gristi Jeevan vs. Living Alone

Jagjit singh · 28 Nov 2003

Quote "bhai jagjit singh thank u very much i am glad to hear jaat paat isnt practiced amongst the jatha singhs in india when it comes to marriage. However what if i want a wife from here in the uk? " waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, The jatha openly discourages flirting, dating or any other such practice. If youth, or parents of youth are finding difficulty, in finding restas, then they should approach senior Gursikhs, for example Committee members, such as Onkar Singh, Satnam Singh. I, myself also now have seva in the committee. We are often approached by families who need spouses for thier sons and daughters. We can then suggest families for your parents to consider. We will just make suggestions, and it for both families then to see if there is a suitable match. I, myself will only get involved if the youth, is of good gursikhi, and not someone who has little interest. Also if caste is an issue, then do not approach me, as i will never ask any family what there caste is. I believe that is an offensive question. There are currently more bibian than Singhs in Uk in this situation, and finding a suitable resta is not hard, as long as the person is not unneccessarily picky, such as nose should be like this or that. If that is the case there is nothing we can do. Youth should just concentrate on their abyass, and let maharaj provide their sanjogi in their own time. That is what happened to me and we are quite welcome to help anyone who is finding it difficult. waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh