Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

keshadari prof who smokes

keshadari prof who smokes

gabroo khalistan dah · 26 Nov 2003

at my universtiy there is a keshadhari prof. who smokes i find this disturbing b/c he's a prof in position 2 do good but he does what? makes the image of the pug into a smoker he could be a nirankari has that look but not sure

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

Independence · 26 Nov 2003

oh well who cares not like he's amritdhari anyways:)

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

Kaur · 26 Nov 2003

No! We should care! He might look Amritdhari. It's important for Gursikhs and ALL kesdharees since people might think them to be gursikhs, to act/look noble, If we don't, the wrong impression is created so easily.

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

kookar raam ko · 26 Nov 2003

Maybe you can try explaining to him that it is giving a bad image to other sikhs wearing dastaars.

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

de · 26 Nov 2003

society cares but not the soul Don't impress others, one day they will learn the truth

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

gabroo khalistan dah · 26 Nov 2003

no man, he's b'n talkd 2 and juss says ****admin cut**** its depressing

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

Trying to be Gursikh · 26 Nov 2003

I know how upset and angry you feel. I have to see a pugwala with a full dara smoke everday at work and I feel like smashing his teeth evertime he smiles. Veerji, from my experience someone who does not want to listen, won't listen. You just waste time on them. People who have fundamentally no understanding of Sikhi don't want to change. He's trying to be in the in crowd, by turning his back on other things. He probably thinks he is a rebel, "I live my own version of Sikhi", but whats the point? If you dont what to live this way then dont. I bet if he told his old man what he gets up to, his father would give the money for him to change his roop. Sometimes you feel like you are fighting a lost cause, I think only people who help themselves get somewhere in life. Basically stuff him, we can gain direction from his stupidity and better ourselves.

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

my thoughts... · 26 Nov 2003

There are way too many keshadari people out there who indirectly misrepresent Sikhs just because they keep kes and wear a dastaar. I get annoyed by this also, however, you can't change everyone, and you can't force someone to change either. So the best solution, I think, is to make sure that, we, as Sikhs, don't misrepresent ourselves and make sure that we correct our own faults before we go out and start pointing out faults in other people. Also, educate people about Sikhi, personally, on several occasions people have come up to me and asked me about Sikhi. They almost always make reference to a non-Gursikh doing something that a Gursikh wouldn't/shouldn't do, so I always make sure that I differeniate between a 'punjabi' and a Sikh so that the other person knows how to identify a Sikh from a regular punjabi. Also, I don't think keshadari people care if they are misrepresenting Gursikhs, even if they are told, some might, if they are wanting to change.

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

bm · 26 Nov 2003

is he a kenyan trim singh?

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

gabroo khalistan dah · 27 Nov 2003

no clue veergi, looks kenyan, if he trims, and smokes i'm sure he's not a singh but loox like it trying 2 be gur-sikh i under stand whre ur commin from ;)

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

Trying to be Gursikh · 27 Nov 2003

Gabroo Khalistan Dah, Let's try and lead our lives by becoming good examples of GurSikhs ourseleves. That's what I am going to try to do. Lead by example.

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

Singhnee · 27 Nov 2003

i was just thinking, that i doubt i'd be able to control myself...maybe the punch might make an impact on their polluted brain.

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

Kulbir Singh · 27 Nov 2003

It is my advice that you talk to this Sikh professor who smokes. Let him know how bad it is for a Sikh to smoke. But one thing I want to mention is that only approach him if you have solid knowledge of Sikhi and if you yourself are in Sikhi saroop and do not take intoxicants. Many times, we see people in Sikhi form doing wrong activities but we ignore them. When we see Sikh wearing baseball caps, we should tell them with pyaar that it is not according to Sikhi to wear a cap. We need to bring awareness in our society, about such anti-Gurmat things. Let us not think that we are alone when asking a Sikh doing anti-Gurmat activity to stop. Guru Sahib is with us and if we all politely and with pyaar do parchaar of Sikhi, it will definitely help. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

gabroo khalistan dah · 27 Nov 2003

i guess i can't approach him i'mma monah but ppl have tried 2 approach hi, he juss brushes them off

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

sukhdev · 28 Nov 2003

what uni does he teach at, im sure we can get local gurdwaras to act and send out letters, if that isnt enough send his bio or post it here, and we can send it to punjabi newspapers.

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

Kulbir Singh · 28 Nov 2003

This is an excellent idea by Veer Sukhdev. If this professor does not stop smoking, he should be exposed in a Punjabi newspaper. This will surely deter him. We can't let one person give bad name to Sikhi. He should be stopped, before he spoils more people.

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

gabroo khalistan dah · 29 Nov 2003

hmmmm is'nt that illeagle

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

R. Dorothy Wayneright · 29 Nov 2003

This person has chosen he wants to smoke, why do the actions of others bother you so much? What if some white american came up to you and said, "Look friend, I like you, and want to be your friend, but you give a bad image of Americans. Your image sends the message that all Americans wear turbans like that guy Osama Bin Laden and that we mainstream americans support terrorism. I want you to stop wearing your turban and shave your beard so you can represent mainstream America. If you don't we will have to start a campaign of harassment by putting your picture in the newspaper and send people to physically harass you until you change your way and get rid of the turban and beard." How would that fell? Chances are you wouldn't like it would you? So why are you doing the same thing to this adult who has chosen that he wants to smoke?

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

gabroo khalistan dah · 29 Nov 2003

hmm i like sukhdevs idea but i think publically defaming some1 is illeagle, but its worth a shotttt he's over every turban wearing, open dhari person out htere

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

warrior*princess · 29 Nov 2003

Dear R. Dorothy Wayneright, Your example is very extreme, because we do not want that Singh to adopt a completely different lifestyle. He already has a certain amount of love for Sikhi due to the way he is, but has lost the right way of living or discipline in keeping the reht/ code of conduct of a Sikh. Therefore your scenario is totally injust and goes against someones religion, so it was not a good argument to use. In the end by pursuing the idea mentioned of publicising his actions, it will help his jeevan/ life more than anything and will make other people think twice about their actions in public or life in general. A Sikh never likes to see injustice or baistee done of Sikhi. This kind of inner strength may not be understood by everyone.

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

sukhdev · 30 Nov 2003

can u please post a link or bio, and i will get it out and will ask the legal team or lawyers, on what they think. we are not sayin hes a rapist, all we are sayin is that he smokes.gabroo khalistan dah wrote: > at my universtiy there is a keshadhari prof. who smokes > > i find this disturbing b/c he's a prof in position 2 do good > > but he does what? makes the image of the pug into a smoker > > he could be a nirankari has that look but not sure

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

R. Dorothy Wayneright · 30 Nov 2003

>Your example is very extreme, because we do not want that Singh to adopt a >completely different lifestyle. He already has a certain amount of love for >Sikhi due to the way he is, but has lost the right way of living or discipline in >keeping the reht/ code of conduct of a Sikh. How do you know he has a love for Sikhi? Maybe he has a love for Punjabi Culture and wears a turban/beard because for that reason? >Therefore your scenario is totally injust and goes against someones religion, >so it was not a good argument to use. I don't see anything wrong with my "scenario." It is almost exactly the same as your "problem" with this fellow. Lets take a look okay? * The accuser claims that he really likes the other but feels he is doing something unacceptable that needs to be stopped. * The accuser feels that the other is misrepresenting him and people like him. * The accuser is ready to take action against the person based on the sole reason that he doesn't like what the other is doing. They should pretty similar to me. Or maybe it doesn't sound similar to you because this time YOU are the accuser? >In the end by pursuing the idea mentioned of publicising his actions, it will >help his jeevan/ life more than anything and will make other people think >twice about their actions in public or life in general. Who are you to make this decision for him? Did I miss something? Did god came down and hand you the right to make these kinds of decisions while I was sleeping? If he wants to smoke, that's his prerogative. How about you concern yourself with your own life instead of harassing someone else because they don't live by the same religious standards as yourself. > A Sikh never likes to see injustice or baistee done of Sikhi. Care to explain how he is doing "baistee" of Sikhi? Is he making any claims against the sanctity of Sikhi? Is he disrespecting any writings/figures you feel are holy? As I said before, did it even cross your mind that he is NOT a Sikh, but rather has a turban/beard because he is Punjabi? > This kind of inner strength may not be understood by everyone. It sounds more like bullying some poor fellow than inner strength. May I suggest you grow up a little?

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

Balpreet Singh · 01 Dec 2003

Dorothy, This person is a keshdhaaree dastaar wearing individual at a prominent position. People seeing him smoking may take the idea that Sikhs can smoke and this is ok. Of course no one can force him to stop smoking, but I see nothing wrong in talking to him about this. Ask him if he knows that he's damaging the Sikh appearance by doing this (dastaar/kesh are Sikh identity, not punjabi). In fact, maybe by talking to him, he may stop this deadly habit and it would in fact be a favour to him. I don't see what objection you or anyone could have to this. In the end, if he refuses to stop smoking, there is nothing anyone can do to force him. But it's at least our responsibility to raise our concerns with him.

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

Jugraj Singh · 01 Dec 2003

Punjabi Culture does not promote wearing of dastaar. I was in PUnjab last year... very hard to find dastaar vale people. In any case the image of a Sikh is being polluted. He is doing it unintentionally i'm sure and did not forsee the consequences of his actions but still what he's doing is wrong and making Singhs look bad. It'd be like someone with a dastaar walking into a strip club or a bar or something. Guru sahib will teach him in his own way, but we should try to speak to him calmly and reasonably about this. I was discussinga similar issue with a friend of mine yesterday. He said that back in the day in Punjab if they saw a pug wala guy with a bidi (cigarette) in his hand he would get jumped. Or atleast a few galan. It should be like that now too but extended to sharab de bottle and sadly cough syrup.

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

R. Dorothy Wayneright · 01 Dec 2003

__Balpreet Singh said:__ >Of course no one can force him to stop smoking, but I see nothing wrong >in talking to him about this. Ask him if he knows that he's damaging the >Sikh appearance by doing this (dastaar/kesh are Sikh identity, not punjabi). Yeah, of course only Sikhs wear turbans... oh wait, what about religious muslim elders that wear the kalansuwa? Or how about the Afghan turban popularized recently by the Taliban? Lest we forget we also have the Persian/Iranian dulband. We also can't ignore the kings and royalty of antiquity that showed their power and status from India to Turkey with fancy turbans. What about the pseudo-turban (kaffiyeh) worn by Palestinians? Sikhs were not the first to wear the turban, nor do they have a monopoly on turban wearing. May I suggest you do a little bit of research on what you wear on your head before you go making silly claims such as turbans belong to Sikhs. >In fact, maybe by talking to him, he may stop this deadly habit and it would in >fact be a favour to him. I don't see what objection you or anyone could have to >this. In the end, if he refuses to stop smoking, there is nothing anyone can do >to force him. But it's at least our responsibility to raise our concerns with him. Oh, you think a 40-50 year old college professor does not know the risks involved with smoking? You think you are going to bring to him some new enlightening research that will suddenly make him see the errors of his ways and he will immediately stop smoking and thank you profusely for correcting the errors of his ways? Do you actually think this is the first time some overzealous youths will accost him for smoking? Please. Don't be so naive. __Jugraj Singh said:__ >In any case the image of a Sikh is being polluted. How is the image of a Sikh being polluted? Is he making claims he is an ideal sikh? Is he giving others guidance of how to live according to Sikhi? Is he the chair person of a some kind of Sikh club? If he is not, what is it to you what he chooses to do with his body? __More importantly, what gives you the right to tell him what he can or can not do to his body? Who gave you this authority?__ >He is doing it unintentionally >i'm sure and did not forsee the consequences of his actions but still what he's doing >is wrong and making Singhs look bad. Right, a 40-50 year old __college professor__ didn't see the consequences of his actions. Did you ever consider that maybe he enjoys smoking? >I was discussinga similar issue with a friend of mine yesterday. He said that back >in the day in Punjab if they saw a pug wala guy with a bidi (cigarette) in his hand >he would get jumped. Or atleast a few galan. You are really showing the maturity of you and your friends by bragging about this. So if someone is doing something you don't like you should beat them up? What if I say I don't like your beard, and I think you should shave everyday, do I get to beat you up too if you don't do it? Or wait, does that only work when YOU are the one in power? Perhaps instead of spending this much time worrying about what others are doing, perhaps you should spend this time worry about yourself? Doesn't your religion teach you that kahrod (anger) is a bad thing? Well you all sure seem to have a lot of it. Maybe you should work on yourself a little before you go attack someone else (who is not even claiming to be a Sikh as far as I can tell, unlike yourselves)?

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

Gaiani · 01 Dec 2003

I was just wondering dorothy y r u so worryed then about us and what we say when we feel our image is threatened, ur be hypocritical. and accornding to ur logical thaqt means just because he doesnt say ne thing about sikhi but is wrecking our image but u think its not because he doesnt openly claim to be a sikh. then i have ask about kobe bryant, if he is innocent then why does he always get booed and called a raper everytime lakers play away from home? then y were innocent people who whear turbans targer after 9/11 beacause osama wore a turban? was it not generalization by americans to think all turbanned people are terrorists? perhaps u shud mind ur own bizness and stay out of ours, since that is what u are telling us to do, u do it first.

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

RoopKaur Khalsa · 01 Dec 2003

i think the above post was in most cases right but the last part was a bit too rude. Instead of getting all bent out of shape that some one is offering a different view on the issue, we should concentrate on explaining why this view is wrong. I think the problem here is that Ms Dorothy does not understand how serious snoking is in the sikh culrute, and is basing her comments on a western perspective. In sikhi smoking is on the same level as committing adultery and it is one of the four bujjar kurehits, which means that if a person does smoke, he is no longer a sikh. I cannot think of any western anology right now that could describe how seriuos smoking is, but I think ms dorothy should try to get out of the western way of thinking, which accepts smoking as normal, and try to understand this from a religious perspective. Also, the question of a turban, it is not a question of who has a right to wear it or not, the real issue here is that a sikh cannot not wear the turban, they have to wear it. I dont think there is any other religion in the word which makes it mandatory to wear a turban. It is not a neccassarily a queation of who has the right to wear a turban, it is a question of neccessity. By the way, the solotion you proposed, which was cutting the hair and shaving your head, thats as bad as smoking and the person that did that would also no longer be a sikh. "You are really showing the maturity of you and your friends by bragging about this. So if someone is doing something you don't like you should beat them up? What if I say I don't like your beard, and I think you should shave everyday, do I get to beat you up too if you don't do it?" how would a christian person like it if thier cross was somehow being insulted in front of everyone? what if some one was burning the prophet muhamads koran in front of a devout muslim, would he jsut sit there. NO. Likewise, how can sikhs just sit there when their guru ji;s image is being wrecked?

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

Bikramjitsingh · 01 Dec 2003

Dorothy for someone who keeps calling others naive you are the most ignorant person here. Your said >>How do you know he has a love for Sikhi? Maybe he has a love for Punjabi Culture and wears a turban/beard because for that reason?<< How thick are you ? If a Sikh wears a turban it is because it is a part of his religion. Turban wearing is not a part of Punjabi culture, if it was then Hindus and Muslims from Punjab would still be wearing it when they are abroad. Muslims especially wear their salwar kameez dress so why don't they wear a Turban if it is a part of Punjabi culture. Get some knowledge before you attempt to teach us GurFateh Bikramjit

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

Balpreet Singh · 01 Dec 2003

Dorothy, If you re-read my post, you'll see that no where did I say only Sikhs wear a turban. I've had enough experience with dirty debaters to know how they like to put words in people's mouths and then attack those very words. It's not a very healthy technique and I'd encourage you to refrain in the future (see, I've got advice fore everybody, not just the professor :-) ). I had said that a dastaar and kesh are Sikh identity. I don’t' know of any other group that wears a Sikh-style dastaar. Afghans don't wear a Sikh-style dastaar, it's a totally different type of turban. For definition of a dastaar/Sikh-style turban, please do look it up on earlier discussions on this board. As for not knowing the risks: if everyone followed the course of action you suggest, the world would be a very cold and harsh place indeed. No one bothering to say anything to help anyone else, minding their own business, etc. Perhaps speaking to another Sikh would give this professor the motivation to give up this bad habit. Perhaps he needs some support/motivation. If he does not and wants to continue smoking, like I said, there's nothing that can be done to help him. But I still think speaking with him is a good idea and might give him motivation. Dorothy, your posts are filled with a lot of irrational anger and are generally quite offensive. Even if something you say might have some value, the way you present yourself can only result in a reader taking offence. I believe you were thrown off the www.sikhsangat.com message board for this very attitude.

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

R. Dorothy Wayneright · 01 Dec 2003

__RoopKaur Khalsa said:__ >how would a christian person like it if thier cross was somehow being insulted >in front of everyone? what if some one was burning the prophet muhamads koran >in front of a devout muslim, would he jsut sit there. NO. Likewise, how can sikhs >just sit there when their guru ji;s image is being wrecked? I am a scientist and hold quite a fondness in my heart for the likes of Sir Issac Newton, Gottfried Wilhelm von Leibniz, and Leonhard Euler. If someone was insulting them, and their work in Physics or the Mathematics, I would not get mad at all. Why? Because the merit of their work can stand on its own without my need to defend it. In the end, the person making baseless claims will look like the fool at his own expense. I don't see why this is any different for a Sikh, Christian, or Muslim. Let the validity of your faith stand up on its own. __Bikramjitsingh said:__ >How thick are you ? If a Sikh wears a turban it is because it is a part of his >religion. Turban wearing is not a part of Punjabi culture, if it was then Hindus >and Muslims from Punjab would still be wearing it when they are abroad. Muslims >especially wear their salwar kameez dress so why don't they wear a Turban if it >is a part of Punjabi culture. Get some knowledge before you attempt to teach us In case you did not read what I wrote before, I will say it again, with emphasis this time: "We also can't ignore the kings and royalty of __antiquity__ that showed their power and status from India to Turkey with fancy turbans." So yes, Hindus and Muslims of antiquity DID wear wear turbans as a show of power and status. I never made the claim that they do this today. Also, I would challenge this claim that the turban is not a part of Punjabi culture. People were living, and wearing turbans in the land that is today Punjab long before the Sikh religion came about. So we are supposed to ignore the fact that the turban was part of the identify of the people of Punjab before Sikhi just because Sikhi later came and adopted that as one of their symbols? That seems silly to me. Like I said before, people of antiquity in that region wore turbans before Sikhs, and it is silly to assume that that that cultural link between kings of antiquity and the power and status they held does not still exist in the minds of many. __Balpreet Singh said:__ >I've had enough experience with dirty debaters to know how they like to put words >in people's mouths and then attack those very words. It's not a very healthy >technique and I'd encourage you to refrain in the future (see, I've got advice >fore everybody, not just the professor :-) ). I see what you mean, you think I was using a straw-man argument? After re-reading what was written I can see how that may seem true. But you must understand there is a language barrier here. I assumed daster and turban were interchangeable, after re-reading the discussion thus far I see that they are not. My apologies if you thought I was using a straw-man, I really wasn't, it was simply a problem of a language barrier. Please correct me if I am wrong in the future. >I had said that a dastaar and kesh are Sikh identity. I don’t' know of any other >group that wears a Sikh-style dastaar. Afghans don't wear a Sikh-style dastaar, >it's a totally different type of turban. For definition of a dastaar/Sikh-style >turban, please do look it up on earlier discussions on this board. This is very much true... to you. If you looked at different types of turbans you would be able to tell the difference. But if you take the average American (or Canadian) they would not know their were different styles of turbans much less know that different ethnic groups/religions wore turbans. So my point still stands. To any non-sikh looking at this professor, and that is the crux of this discussion, what a non-sikh would think of a man that wore a turban and smoked; a non-sikh would probably think that person is a Muslim and would not think of the Sikh religion any less. When it comes down to it for about two years the media has been feeding the images of people the likes of Osama Bin Laden and various other Islamic Clerics that wear turbans and have beards to mainstream America. Now sure, in America the majority of the people that wear turbans and grow beards are Sikhs, but that is not what is perceived by many Americans (as you can see with the misdirected hate crimes against Sikhs). Is it fair? No. But the situation still remains the same, anyone with a turban and beard in America is thought of as a Muslim. So I still don't see how this hurts the Sikh image at all. >As for not knowing the risks: if everyone followed the course of action you suggest, >the world would be a very cold and harsh place indeed. No one bothering to say >anything to help anyone else, minding their own business, etc. Perhaps speaking to >another Sikh would give this professor the motivation to give up this bad habit. >Perhaps he needs some support/motivation. If he does not and wants to continue smoking, >like I said, there's nothing that can be done to help him. But I still think speaking >with him is a good idea and might give him motivation. Like I said before, I really doubt you will tell this man anything that he has not heard before. After-all he is what? 40-50 years old? I think it's a pretty big leap of faith to assume that no one has told him the dangers of smoking. >Dorothy, your posts are filled with a lot of irrational anger and are generally >quite offensive. Even if something you say might have some value, the way you present >yourself can only result in a reader taking offence. I am sorry you feel my posts are filled with irrational anger. Because I can assure you they are not, perhaps you can point out some examples of this irrational anger that you see so I can a look at what people find offensive (because I can not see it) and perhaps change my posting style.

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

Balpreet Singh · 02 Dec 2003

Dorothy, Your argument is then premised on the belief that a Canadian/American who sees a Sikh can't tell the difference between a Sikh and a Muslim, and because of this, it doesn't matter anyways. Fact of the matter is that in Canada, I'm quite certain most people know the difference between a Sikh and Muslim. A Sikh looks considerably different and people in Canada can indeed identify the two as different. So a smoking Sikh would indeed be confusing to an observer and reflect badly on the Sikh image. Speaking, as a Sikh, to this professor, not necessarily about the health problems involved with smoking, but the effect it has on Sikh image is something that is still worth doing. Sometimes people don't understand the effect they have on others and someone gently pointing it out can change things. There are many examples of people changing like this. And I ask again....what's the harm? As for your posting style, please do re-read your posts and notice that they are quite confrontational. Comments like "May I suggest you grow up a little" and "Please. Don't be so naive. " generally aren't condusive to a positive exchange.

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

anonymous · 02 Dec 2003

What about keshdhari men who drink? There are more keshdhari men who drink then there are ones who smoke. So why not go and start campaigns against them? Are these people not misrepresenting Sikhi as well? Is smoking in Sikhi worse than drinking? At my university there is a keshdhari professor who drinks with his colleagues. Should we start a name and shame campaign against him as well? Publish his details in some newspaper? What do you all think?

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

warrior*princess · 02 Dec 2003

Thank you for the support Veer Bhai Balpreet Singh jee... But you know what :D Im starting to believe Dorothy is my BEST Friend! :D ----------------------------- gourree || Gauree: ni(n)dho ni(n)dho mo ko log ni(n)dho || Slander me, slander me - go ahead, people, and slander me. ni(n)dhaa jan ko kharee piaaree || Slander is pleasing to the Lord's humble servant. ni(n)dhaa baap ni(n)dhaa mehathaaree ||1|| rehaao || Slander is my father, slander is my mother. ||1||Pause|| ni(n)dhaa hoe th baiku(n)t(h) jaaeeai || If I am slandered, I go to heaven; naam padhaarathh manehi basaaeeai || the wealth of the Naam, the Name of the Lord, abides within my mind. ridhai sudhh jo ni(n)dhaa hoe || If my heart is pure, and I am slandered, hamarae kaparae ni(n)dhak dhhoe ||1|| then the slanderer washes my clothes. ||1|| ni(n)dhaa karai s hamaraa meeth || ONE WHO SLANDERS ME IS MY FRIEND; ni(n)dhak maahi hamaaraa cheeth || the slanderer is in my thoughts. ni(n)dhak so jo ni(n)dhaa horai || The slanderer is the one who prevents me from being slandered. hamaraa jeevan ni(n)dhak lorai ||2|| The slanderer wishes me long life. ||2|| ni(n)dhaa hamaree praem piaar || I have love and affection for the slanderer. ni(n)dhaa hamaraa karai oudhhaar || Slander is my salvation. jan kabeer ko ni(n)dhaa saar || Slander is the best thing for servant Kabeer. ni(n)dhak ddoobaa ham outharae paar ||3||20||71|| The slanderer is drowned, while I am carried across. ||3||20||71|| This Shabad is by Bhagat Kabeer Ji in Raag Gauree on Pannaa 339 Guru Granth Sahib jee. ------------------------------------

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

kinetikman · 02 Dec 2003

If someone said dont wear a turban because you are misrepresenting the america, i would tell that person to ***admin cut*** themself. We are lucky to live in a democratic country where people are free to do as they please within the law. If the prof doesn't listen, what can you do? Perhaps Hand out pamplets about Sikhs and what they say about tabacco.

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

Trying to be Gursikh · 02 Dec 2003

Only a Sikh would understand the pain you feel when you see another Sikh in the Gurus Roop smoking. You can't explain it to non-Sikhs, they won't understand. I know because my colleagues at work think I am the stuck up, backward one and the Pugwalla who smokes at work is the chilled out, fun guy. The Sikh roop is the roop of the Guru. It's a gift. The Sikh is representing the Guru's image. It's not a violation of human rights. If a Sikh wants to smoke he/she has the option of cutting their hair and must take the responsibility not to be in Guruji's Roop.

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

gabroo khalistan dah · 02 Dec 2003

trying to be a gursikh is rite

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

... · 02 Dec 2003

Quick Question: Why is everyone assuming that R Dorothy Waynewright is non-Sikh? Just because he/she is using a Western name? From what he/she has written, I havent been able to find any proof of what religious/racial/cultural group this person is representing. Only a name. And on the internet, names mean nothing. I may be wrong, but this may be a case of dont judge a book by its cover (further proving what R. Dorothy Waynewright is trying to impress on you.) WJKK WJKF

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

_* · 02 Dec 2003

trying to be a gursikh, there is a difference between what you feel and what you can do.

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

** · 02 Dec 2003

DHANAASAREE, FIFTH MEHL: The Lord saves His Saints. One who wishes misfortune upon the Lord’s slaves, shall be destroyed by the Lord eventually. || 1 || Pause || He Himself is the help and support of His humble servants; He defeats the slanderers, and chases them away. Wandering around aimlessly, they die out there; they never return to their homes again. || 1 || Nanak seeks the Sanctuary of the Destroyer of pain; he sings the Glorious Praises of the infinite Lord forever. The faces of the slanderers are blackened in the courts of this world, and the world beyond. || 2 || 15 ||

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

Trying to be Gursikh · 03 Dec 2003

"trying to be a gursikh, there is a difference between what you feel and what you can do." The honest truth is that to this pugwalla who smokes I am just a nagger. I am like an old broken record. I will say the same things again and again, in the hope that one day it will hit him. To him I am a pain in the backside. I might be fighting a losing battle, but I will continue expressing my opion to him It's not bible bashing, at the end of the day we as GurSikhs know that Kesh dhaan, Sikhi Dhaan, Bibek Dhaan are gifts from the Akal Purakh. We ask for these dhaans in our Ardas everyday. We know full well the 500 years of history inorder for us to be able to exist as Sikhs. So when we see a brother/sister abusing the God given gift that all Sikhs do benti for, when we see a brother/sister abusing the the 500 years of struggle for existance. We must do what it takes to educate them and stop them from doing this. It is our obiligation to the Guruji. Same as if they want to carry on living this way, they have an obligation to Guruji to remove themselves from the Sikh identity. Yes, I am highly embarrased of this pugwalla who smokes, I am embarrased when I see a Sikh drunk. It's not my ego talking, I am not saying I am perfect in anyway, it's my love for Guruji talking. We stand out big time, our actions stand out, our deeds stand out, our principles stand out and therefore our beliefs stand out. We are so different from the crowd such that our bad deeds also stand out, our bad actions stand out. The Guruji made us like this. By standing out, we think before we act. I don't think we will achieve anything by slander though. BUt I do suggest not to sit back and just hope he will change, because he won't.

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

Go Get Him! · 04 Dec 2003

So what have people decided to do about this guy? Do keep us informed.

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 05 Dec 2003

rite NOW is an extreemly bz time, i got exams, but as soon as tey're over i'll try 2 locate some info, and even get a sikh friend 2 talk 2 him as its pointless for me as a monah 2 say ne thing

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

Just realize · 05 Dec 2003

Just realize that a) a person who only wears a turban does not represent sikhism b) a person who has taken amrit does c) It is not right for us to pick out flaws on people d) if the person is not amritdhari or is following that way of life, let them be and if possible, make a difference in their lives

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

R. Dorothy Wayneright · 05 Dec 2003

__Balpreet Singh said:__ >Your argument is then premised on the belief that a Canadian/American who sees a Sikh >can't tell the difference between a Sikh and a Muslim, and because of this, it >doesn't matter anyways. Part of it is. >Fact of the matter is that in Canada, I'm quite certain most people know the >difference between a Sikh and Muslim. A Sikh looks considerably different >and people in Canada can indeed identify the two as different. So a smoking >Sikh would indeed be confusing to an observer and reflect badly on the Sikh image. 1) I don't think that is the case. I think most people can not tell the difference. I have trouble telling the difference and I actually know there is a difference. Perhaps the reason you think it is so obvious to tell the difference is because you are one of them. Think about it this way, many White Americans say that all Asian people look the same. But ask a Chinese person or a Japanese person and they will say, "of course we are not all the same, we all look very different." So to you there may be differences, but to everyone else they are not so apparent. 2) Even if they could tell a difference, how do the actions of one "bad" person negatively reflect on everyone else? >Speaking, as a Sikh, to this professor, not necessarily about the health problems >involved with smoking, but the effect it has on Sikh image is something that >is still worth doing. Sometimes people don't understand the effect they have >on others and someone gently pointing it out can change things. There are >many examples of people changing like this. And I ask again....what's the harm? Oh there is no harm in asking him or politely asking him. But people in this thread are talking about slandering him in newspapers and flyers and someone even mentioned punching this fellow. __anonymous said:__ >What about keshdhari men who drink? There are more keshdhari men who drink >then there are ones who smoke. So why not go and start campaigns against them? >Are these people not misrepresenting Sikhi as well? Is smoking in Sikhi worse >than drinking? This person inadvertently raises a good point, why the double standard? __Trying to be Gursikh said: >Only a Sikh would understand the pain you feel when you see another Sikh in the >Gurus Roop smoking. You can't explain it to non-Sikhs, they won't understand. >I know because my colleagues at work think I am the stuck up, backward one and >the Pugwalla who smokes at work is the chilled out, fun guy. "Only a American would understand the pain you feel when you see another American with a turban and beard and refusing to shave. You can't explain it to non-americans, they won't understand." >It's not a violation of human rights. If a Sikh wants to smoke he/she has the >option of cutting their hair and must take the responsibility not to be in Guruji's Roop. Why can't he keep his turban and beard and still smoke? >The honest truth is that to this pugwalla who smokes I am just a nagger. I am >like an old broken record. I will say the same things again and again, in >the hope that one day it will hit him. To him I am a pain in the backside. I might >be fighting a losing battle, but I will continue expressing my opion to him You know, to me, YOU are the one giving Sikhs a bad image. You have one person who quietly smokes and don't bother anyone. Then there is you, you harass people that smoke and constantly preach to this person about the evil he is doing. To me, you are the person giving Sikhs a bad image because to me you come off as someone that can't see beyond there own small little world view of things and can't accept that other people live there lives differently and THAT IS OKAY. >It's not bible bashing, From what you have described it sure does sound like it. >Yes, I am highly embarrased of this pugwalla who smokes, I am embarrased when I see a Sikh drunk. Why? You are not doing it. No sane person would see that as a negative reflection on you. Why does it bother you so much? If I see a scientist drunk or blathering about something, it doesn't embarrass me. It doesn't negatively reflect on all scientists, nor would any sane person think that all scientists do is get drunk and blather non-sense. The point I am trying to get across here is this: In American the reason we can all peacefully live together and coexists is because the West believes that you have the freedom to to pursue your own happyness. The reason Sikhs can peacefully coexist with other ethnicity is because of this! Now you want to deny this person the same thing that allows you to pursue your own happiness (for you: being able to practice your religion)? If this person finds happiness in smoking, who are you to deny it to him? What gives you the right to even try and change his ways? He has every right to smoke as you do to wear a turban and beard.

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

my thoughts... · 05 Dec 2003

Well Gabroo jeeo, what better time then now to start keeping your kes. It is obvious from all your posts that you have strong opinions for Sikhi even though you are a mona. It is sort of like carrying around ammunition without a gun to fire it with. Your feelings/thoughts and opinions will hold more weight if you become a Sikh. This is your chance, maybe you may not be the right person for telling this prof. that he is making Sikhs look bad, however, you would if you could, but you can become that person. Maybe its time to start practicing your thoughts on your self, start keeping kes and set an example of what a good Sikh is suppose to be like, as you said in your earlier posts that talking to this prof. won't/might not change his mind, however, watching you change, and then you going up and talking to him might wake up his sleeping soul and then he will be embarassed enough to change. Also, I'm not sure about you, but I always picture a Gabroo Khalistan Dah as a tyar-bar-tyar Singh. I know Khalistan could use a Singh with strong feelings for Sikhi like yourself.

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

resham singh U of Windsor · 05 Dec 2003

gabroo khalistan what is the school you go to, and what is the professors name and department. u dont have to do anyhting, just post that much info. you have singhs that want to do somethign positive and encourage him to stop, so just simply post the information up and we can get people from that area to talk to him, u never know maybe ppl actaully know him. so once again i request that you post the information, and this topic should end, the only next post should be yours telling the information, and another post will come from us, telling you what was done and the outcome. so please gabroo lets put an end to this distubing topic by you posting some information. thanvaad wjkk wjkf

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

Khalsa · 06 Dec 2003

Gabroo jee....why dont you just get the profs email address...and send him this URL , and let him read these messages himself. At this point I dont think a newpaper publishing of the man is necessarry. We should first Exhuast all means necessry before going to more drastic measures. Let him see how much his actions hurt Gursikhs. smoking is a disgusting habit anyways. most smokers themselves WANT to quit. they think it everytime they have a cigg.....

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

Darshan Singh · 07 Dec 2003

Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa, Vaheguroo Jee Kee Fateh!!! Dorothy, you say: Perhaps the reason you think it is so obvious to tell the difference is because you are one of them. Think about it this way, many White Americans say that all Asian people look the same. But ask a Chinese person or a Japanese person and they will say, "of course we are not all the same, we all look very different." So to you there may be differences, but to everyone else they are not so apparent. Dorothy, I was born in Vancouver, B.C. which has quite a diverse population, several different ethnic groups. I can say that I have always been able to figure out if a person is Japanese or Chinese. As a matter of fact its so natural for me I don't even have to think about it. I believe myself to be a reasonable, average person who lives in a very diverse city and I believe that any reasonable person would be able to diffrentiate between a turbanned sikh as opposed to a turbanned muslim. I believe Veer Balpreet Singh is partially correct for stating that the average Canadian/American could identify a Sikh as opposed to a turbanned muslim. He is PARTIALLY correct because this becomes an issue of regions. In the Lower Mainland in BC I would believe this statement to be 100 percent correct because of the number of turbanned Sikhs living in this area. Toronto, Montreal etc. is a similar situation. However I don't believe the average Canadian from Red Deer, Alberta would be able to tell the difference, as they are not in contact with turbanned Sikhs as much. So if this professor is teaching out of a region which doesn't have as much knowledge of the Sikh religion he wouldn't be doing as much damage. However if even one person feels that the image of a Sikh is being tarnished (especially a non-sikh who has no knowledge of Sikhism) then the professor is absolutely out of place in doing what he is doing. Dorothy, you always say: If I see a scientist drunk or blathering about something, it doesn't embarrass me. It doesn't negatively reflect on all scientists, nor would any sane person think that all scientists do is get drunk and blather non-sense. For certain groups of people there are certain things that promote or harm the image of people in the group and their beliefs. For example, corporate America suffers from a wide-ranging loss of confidence in the minds of the American public because of insider-trading in companies such as Enron and Worldcom. However, many members of corporate America do not participate in such dishonest activities. The moral of the story? The actions of a few have sullied the repuation of many who did not deserve it. I am not sure what a scientist could do to ruin the reputation of other scientists, however I believe you, as a scientist, would feel that the pristine reputation of scientists is being ruined by a small minority. Why was there post 9/11 backlash on turbanned Sikhs? Misconceptions against minorities were caused by the actions of a few lunatics. Obviously smoking is not in the same universe as a terrorist attack, however for a Sikh it is a serious offense. For this professor to be dirtying the name of practicing keshdharis/amritdharis it is promoting a misconception, the misconception that Sikhs are permitted to smoke. Similarly to how 9/11 promoted the misconception that all people who wear turbans are terrorists. For the general public to think less of a Sikhs moral and ethical guidelines based on the actions of a small minority is a great injustice to Sikhs who are devoted to Sikhism and their communities. Dorothy, I'm not sure what ethnicity you are. Perhaps if you have been the target of racial stereotypes you would have a better perspective of where I am coming from. Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa, Vaheguroo Jee Kee Fateh!!! Daas, Darshan Singh

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 07 Dec 2003

thank my my thoughts i appreciate ur kindness honestly :d resham singh i goto u of calgary, no clue what he's a prof off tho yah i will khalsa, tha's a briliant idea the pug to the western world represents sikhs, and a sikh with a kothi (ciggertte) in his mouth is disgusting cause the sikh is the roop ofo gur sahib and the roop of guru sahib deserves respect not mutliation with a cigerette :@

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

warrior*princess · 07 Dec 2003

when is Dorothy going to stop arguing with everyone, she's only putting her ego on display...also, she is only proving the fact how scientists believe less in God and more on their manmukh theories, rather than understanding the truth. Dorothy mentions happiness in america, yeah plastic makeovers, people walking around with hardly any clothes on or respect for themselves, crimes, increase of rapes, drug consumption... Dorothy we are not in la la land, this is Kalyug....everyone wants to help that Man who should not be smoking. If you don't want to be a part of that, then i believe you are actually wasting your time with pathetic debates that you are basing your reasoning on. You should use up your time with more important things that will help you, like Naam. You can't stop us from choosing the way we make decisions or live our lives either, so who are you to speak.. sounds like there is a hypocrite on the loose!

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

Trying to be Gursikh · 08 Dec 2003

Is Dorothy the keshadari professor? I wonder....??

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

Anonymous · 09 Dec 2003

[quote]Obviously smoking is not in the same universe as a terrorist attack, however for a Sikh it is a serious offense. For this professor to be dirtying the name of practicing keshdharis/amritdharis it is promoting a misconception, the misconception that Sikhs are permitted to smoke. [/quote] How come nobody answered my question? Why is smoking considered worse than drinking? There are countless keshdhari men out there who drink like fish. So arent these men dirtying the name of practicing keshdhari/amritdhari men by promoting the misconception that Sikhs are allowed to drink? Yet none of you is aiming a name and shame campaign against them? So why the hypocricy? Could somebody please answer my question? Thank-you. P.S. Most of us know innumerable numbers of keshdhari men who drink, many of them in our own immediate and extended families - perhaps people could start off talking to people within our own families or communities, rather than aiming name and shame campaigns against complete strangers. The chances of sucess with these people are a lot higher. Just a thought. Please stop the hypocricy!

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

warrior*princess · 09 Dec 2003

To Anonymous, the original thread does not concern a drinker, so there is no hypocrisy here. Maybe you are angry about something. The first post was made because someone is concerned about some Singh...they requested a reply to something in particular, so its the sangats duty to respond to that issue only. No one is stopping you from asking advise on stopping someone from drinking.

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

Anonymous · 09 Dec 2003

Warrior princess, mine was a simple question. It seems judging from your post that you are the one who is angry about something. I never mentioned anger, you did. Please let us know what it is, so that perhaps we can help you. My dear, Im afraid it is hypocrisy of the worst sort. The fact that you cannot se the hypocrisy in my exmple speaks volumes of your inability to understand simple English. Once again, in simple English, Im asking you (or anybody on this thread who cares to answer) how is drinking worse than smoking? If drinking is not worse than smoking, and does just as much damage to the Sikh image, then why not launch name and shame campaigns against those men who drink within our own families and communities as well? Instead of starting some smear campaign against some man you dont know and have never seen, why not start within our own families and communities by exposing those who are bringing into disrepute Sikh identity by drinking? It is interesting how we're not willing to do anything about what is going on in our own backyards but are willing to do channel our engergies into thinking of ways of publicly naming and shaming some man whom we have never seen.

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

H2O · 09 Dec 2003

Smoking is a bujjer kurreht. Drinking is not, even though it is bad and people that drink alcohol are given laanth by gurbani.

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 09 Dec 2003

is'nt ne type of intoxicant a bhujjer khurait? or is it specifically smoking

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

Trying to be Gursikh · 09 Dec 2003

I actually agree with anonoymous. I think we have created a drinking culture by turning a blind eye to alcohol. Regardless of what level of a kurheit it is, it is a problem in our families. Sikhs are known as being the heavy drinkers and well we know how non-Sikhs long to be invited to a mainstream Sikh wedding for the booze. In my opinion alcohol causes more problems in families and society than smoking.

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

warrior*princess · 09 Dec 2003

alcohol is a bujjar kureht

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

my thoughts... · 09 Dec 2003

Veer 'Trying to be Gursikh,' Alcohol is a big problem in punjabi culture. Yes, lots of of kesadhari people are heavy drinkers which in turn misrepresents Sikh, since these people have the same phyiscal appearance as Sikhs. However, if a person calls himself Sikh, meaning that he has taken amrit and wears the 5 k's, and then drinks, this person is not a Sikh anymore. Any type of intoxicant is strictly prohibited in Sikhi, as it is a bujjar kurehit. Therefore, it would be wrong to say that "..Sikhs are known as being the heavy drinkers...." I didn't mean to nit-pick at your post, but I felt that statement needed to be corrected.

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

warrior*princess · 09 Dec 2003

Of course alcohol problems are just as bad as smoking, who said they werent. As for the publicising issue, i'll explain... The only reason why everyone wants to take a bigger step in sorting out this Singh is because some requested and started a topic on at their own will. This Singh is already publicising himself. He doesn't seem to have any worries that a GurSikh passing by him may see his actions. In regards to other people, their actions are not on question in this post. Families who have such problems inside their households are already taking steps to sort problems out and its not easy. As for this Singh, i think its important to make a one big blatant attempt for a Sikh to tell him what he is doing is wrong in terms of gurmat. And then, if cannot still see sense, then his wife should be immediately informed of his actions. Things can be taken from there on, if she agrees to publicise him then its her decision and choice.

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

eeeee · 10 Dec 2003

all drugs are bujjar kurehits

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

R. Dorothy Wayneright · 10 Dec 2003

__Darshan Singh said:__ >Why was there post 9/11 backlash on turbanned Sikhs? Misconceptions against >minorities were caused by the actions of a few lunatics. Obviously smoking is >not in the same universe as a terrorist attack, however for a Sikh it is a >serious offense. For this professor to be dirtying the name of practicing >keshdharis/amritdharis it is promoting a misconception, the misconception >that Sikhs are permitted to smoke. Okay, even though I don't think that most people would actually know this person is a Sikh, lets just assume that they do, for the sake of the argument. MAYBE in collectivistic cultures like Punjab/India, yes someone sees a Sikh smoking they would think that all Sikhs are allowed to smoke; but last time I checked in the West's individualistic cultures, what one person does does not reflect on the group, but only reflects on that person. So even if we assume that the person knows what Sikhs are and even then that non-Sikh wouldn't have a bad image of Sikhs because of the individualistic culture they grew up in! >Dorothy, I'm not sure what ethnicity you are. Perhaps if you have been the target >of racial stereotypes you would have a better perspective of where I am coming from. 1) Why do you assume that? 2) What does racial stereotyping have anything to do with this? __warrior*princess said: >when is Dorothy going to stop arguing with everyone, she's only putting her ego on display... Please explain how I am putting my ego on display. >also, she is only proving the fact how scientists believe less in God Why do you assume that just because I am a scientist that I don't believe in a god? >and more on their manmukh theories, rather than understanding the truth. "manmukh theories"? Oh you mean things like the American Constitution and rights enumerated in it like freedom of religion and freedom to pursue happiness that allow American Sikhs to live there lives without fear that the government will come knocking on there door and force them to convert to Christianity? Yes, terrible "manmukh theories" they are. I should jump on the chance to accept your version of the "truth" were I can harass anyone that I think doesn't represent me correctly. >Dorothy mentions happiness in america, yeah plastic makeovers, people walking >around with hardly any clothes on or respect for themselves, How do you correlate less clothing with lack of respect for ones self? I have seen plenty of farmers in Punjab working in there fields with just there Kashare (umm, they are like shorts) on and Kirpans on. So you are telling me that those Sikhs don't have respect for themselves either? >crimes, increase of rapes, drug consumption... Which are all punished under the law. >You can't stop us from choosing the way we make decisions or live our lives >either, so who are you to speak.. sounds like there is a hypocrite on the loose! I am not forcing you to make any decision. I am not going to slander you for any decision you make. I am not threatening to physically harm you for any decision you make. I am simply questioning your actions. How this that hypercritical? >This Singh is already publicising himself. Really? More than most drinkers? I think parties and the like where most people get drunk are publicized a bit more than when someone decided to take a little break and go out and smoke. >He doesn't seem to have any worries that a GurSikh passing by him may see his actions. Why should he be concerned with what someone else thinks of him? He isn't allowed to be the master of his own life anymore? Should YOU be concerned with what a White American may think of you when they walk by? >In regards to other people, their actions are not on question in this post. >Families who have such problems inside their households are already taking steps >to sort problems out and its not easy. So it is hard for family members to stop another family member from drinking but it is easier for strangers to stop someone from smoking? Does this make sense to you? Anonymous raises a good question, why doesn't anyone here want to start campaigns against the drinkers?

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

warrior*princess · 10 Dec 2003

Dorothy you have tried your hardest to mock what you could of my posting but u refused to read the solution to the matter that i proposed. No one is here for a slander match or arguement. So u def wont be hearing from me again my best friend.

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

Anonymous · 10 Dec 2003

Why dont you just admit that you dont have answers to Dorothy's points, warrior princess? Anyway, I am thinking of creating an internet site where I can post the pictures of keshdhari men who drink, and in doing so, give all practicing keshdhari Sikhs a bad name. If people would be willing to provide pictures of their own keshdhari family members (fathers, grandfathers, uncles) who drink, then I can publish them on the site with a little blurb underneath their names citing their profession and age. Maybe we can even post addresses and telephone numbers, so that the morality police can go round to their houses and beat them into good behaviour. I think that people would agree that before we go around sticking our noses in other people's business, we should attempt to sort out our own. Gurfateh

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

Jagroop Singh · 10 Dec 2003

Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh! I am going to talk from what i believe to be the Gurmat perspective; may the GurSikhs forgive me for my mistakes and point out any wrong words or concepts. When a person keeps the Guru-given form, they are basically unifying (whether intentionally/unintentionally) their physical, mental and spiritual form with Siree Guru Gobind Singh Ji. After taking Amrit (i.e. becoming a Guru ka Sikh) that person's Mun and Tun have been handed over to Guru Sahib; they have surrendered... furthermore, they positively aspire to lose all sense of self and merge into the Universal Self. To see a Keshdahari person who APPEARS to be a GurSikh smoking, drinking, committing breaches etc. hurts the heart of a GurSikh...in fact if it does not hurt the heart of a GurSikh then they should seriously question how much they love Guru Sahib. For a GurSikh the external form is sacred, so naturally it hurts. Those GurSikhs who with love in their heart ask these Keshadhari people to refrain are doing them and the Panth a service. They are actually doing their NATION a service (Sikhs have been recognised as a fully fledged nation: House of Lords Judgment, UK...not too soon either!). Let's look at it in another way - Guru Sahib gave the Khalsa a distinct NATIONAL UNIFORM - a uniform is a public statement which declares what we can expect from a member of that Nation...it is also a device which ensures that those who do not action what they 'seem' to represent are being devious and hence should be reprimanded. Let's scale it down more and show how even at much lower institutional levels, what we may consider to be a 'minor issue' can actually be very serious. A policeman/woman will uphold the law and a fireman/woman will put out a fire; they are easily identified and hence are approachable for those citizens who require their help... Now what if you were to see a policeman/woman who beat a black man senseless or used the law as a means to capitalise upon his/her corruptive practises...they are betraying the very trust we place in them and furthermore bring disrepute to their colleagues and office. In the same way on a NATIONAL LEVEL s/he who keep Guru Sahib's form does the same...it is therefore natural and right for the GurSikhs to be positively responsive. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ "...but last time I checked in the West's individualistic cultures, what one person does does not reflect on the group, but only reflects on that person". ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Please do not take offence, but this statement is unbelievably naive e.g. In the UK and America and in fact across the West, police departments spend hundreds of millions of pounds/dollars to limit the damage that cases of corruption/racial discrimination create. Whether compensation is paid-out, or recruitment drives are organised, challenging bad publicity is a major concern for them and a massive financial drain....why is this? BECAUSE STEREOTYPES CAN AND DO STICK...ESPECIALLY IF THE ARE NOT OPENLY CHALLENGED!!! Let's move on to some other general issues concerning Guru Sahib's form and the implications that can arise when this form is abused... FACT 1 I have been called Bin Laden/Terrorist many times by many people since September 11th. I can't remember ever being called ANY names before then. >Therefore, the interactions that people have with information sources such as the media can shape their attitudes and behaviours towards communities; especially when these communities are as VISIBLY DISTINCT AS GURSIKHS. This problem is greater in the information saturated world we live in today...but i digress - please forgive me. FACT 2 >I am told by many non-Sikhs that they have been to a 'Sikh wedding' and that 'it was the best in the world...lots of booze etc.' >Therefore many people's experiences with other peoples, races, religious communities, whether rightly or wrongly, shape their GENERAL ATTITUDES. To argue with this would be even more naive...you wouldn't believe the amount of time I (as I am sure many others) have spent correcting thsoe who have unfortunately been 'misinformed'! Guru Sahib intends us to be walking, talking, actioning examples of Him...24/7/365. He claims that he resides in the Khalsa. No where is this more evident than in The Form He has blessed us fools with. For those who have faith in His words, it is therefore impossible to stand by as someone puts a cigarette in HIS MOUTH...it is that literal...that real...and that serious. Dear R. Dorothy Wayneright, even if you cannot accept, tolerate or relate to someone's perspective atleast accept that the reasons they hold it may be beyond those who do not experience the very thing that MOTIVATES their beliefs and attitudes...in this case, it is Guru Sahib's Form. Perhaps YOU would have to BE the police officer who sees a colleague beat the living daylights out of an innocent person...perhaps then you would step forward and show him/her the errors of their ways. Perhaps until you wear The Uniform of The Guru's Police Officers, you will not be able to understand why s/he wishes to walk forward and openly challenge wrongdoing...in this case the PHYSICAL FORM OF GURU SAHIB. Bhul chuk maaf karna. Vahiguru ji ka ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh!

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

Trying to be Gursikh · 11 Dec 2003

Well written Jagroop Singh ji. I Thanks for your posting.

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

... · 11 Dec 2003

I do agree that if this prof who smokes is someone who calls himself/herself a Sikh then that is wrong. What I dont understand is why people think that a dastaar and beard is the guru given uniform. (i.e. for sikhs only) In every religion, any religious man has always had long hair (Moses, Jesus, Joshua, Gurus, SAMPSON). And if you look at other religious traditions today, we are not the only ones who believe in covering our hair (for example the Muslims and Sikhs) to some extent.

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 12 Dec 2003

k ..., this dude name is singh, he obviously is'nt keep his kesh because moses jesus , jashua or sampson kept it he knows better then 2 smoke with a dastaar, general public are gonna think its permissible in sikhi...which it sure aint... sorry guys i'll get info school is over got exams juss tied up

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

Singhnee · 13 Dec 2003

The point is that a Keshdari professor smoking is giving a bad name to Sikhs. Just as how some saardars are known to drink a lot. This is the wrong image that these so called SIKHS protray. Its our duty as Khalsa Panth to stop this from happening. If Guru Gobind Singh jee was here himself and seen this Professor, he would have gone straight up to him and told him what he is doing is wrong. So Gabroo Khalistan Dah veerji you should go to your professor and explain to him that he is commiting a sin. Its our duty as a Khalsa Panth to do parchaar and bring more people into sikhi, and fix mistakes that are against Gurmat.

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 14 Dec 2003

singhnee ji, i can't cause i'm a monah(non-sikh) it won't look 2 good. Its really sad tho :( some singhs have talked 2 him in the past he juss says f' off

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

Singhnee · 14 Dec 2003

Gabroo Khalistan Dah veerji why not become a Sikh then? By becoming a Sikh you could do so much parchaar, and help those kinds of people like your professor to come into Sikhi and follow Guru Sahib jees Rehit.

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

Boston Singh · 15 Dec 2003

Publicly exposing someone in the paper is the wrong course of action. Someone needs to sit down with him and first explain the disadvantages of smoking, and then explain that Sikhs are not supposed to smoke. by Pubically exposing him, you are adding fire to the flame and will cause long term damage. If that is the case, you may as well resort to violence, which also causes problems. Things must be dealt with in a proper manner for the maximum results.

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 15 Dec 2003

i want 2, dunno what holds me back :( its wierd

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

Just a suggestion · 15 Dec 2003

Gabroo Ji, you have great knowledge of sikhism now.. please take amrit jeo, and become a khalsa.....!!!!!!!!!!!! *daas

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

Singhnee · 16 Dec 2003

I agree with 'Just a Suggestion' by reading some of your posts on various sites, you have knowledge of sikhism, and know what is right from wrong. Please do take amrit and become part of the Khalsa Panth, start by keeping kesh and reciting 7 banis.

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

warrior*princess · 16 Dec 2003

Dear GABROO KHALISTAN DAH jee Guru jee has been waiting for you many many days and time... ..........and he still is! :))))

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

my thoughts... · 16 Dec 2003

Gabroo ji, I think, the sangat is speaking from their hearts. It is time for you to start walking on the path of Gurmat. You should accept the sangats request.

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

Just Do It! · 16 Dec 2003

Yes Gabroo, it does not matter if you are ready or not to take amrit, just do it!

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 16 Dec 2003

mannnnnnnnn ya'll so kinddddddddddd i'm honestly feeling dis wierd emptness lately guilt about meat, guilt about everything ur rite its time it is a paap for me 2 not obey the sangat

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

Singhnee · 16 Dec 2003

Yes!! Gabroo jee with folded hands the sangat is requesting for you to become a Khalsa, child of Guru Gobind Singh jee. Please accept this, and make Guru Sahib jee very happy. The Sangat here can help you with any problems you may have or questions that are holding you back. Please Veerji Take Amrit :)

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

Admin · 16 Dec 2003

Ok, I think we've pretty much exhausted this topic and so we'll close it up. Thank you for all the suggestions. And also, the Admins also encourage veer Gabroo Khalistan Dah to start keepign kes and rehit of Guru Sahib. It would be amazing to have you as fellow Singh in the Khalsa.

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

VaheGuroo · 16 Dec 2003

VahegurooJiKaKhalsaVahegurooJiKeFateh Bhai Sahib Gabroo Khalistan Dah Ji, sur nar mun jan amrit khojadhae s amrit gur thae paaeiaa || The angelic beings and the silent sages search for the Ambrosial Nectar; this Amrit is obtained from the Guru. You found Satguru Ji already he is there within the panj pyiaraa also Guru Gobind Singh Ji is standing there watching you become his Khalsa Fauj, Receive Naam this is the only use in life, the only wealth and heeraa (diamond). naam thath kal mehi punehacharanaa || In this Dark Age of Kali Yuga, only the Naam, shall be of any real use to you. naam binaa kaisae paar outharai || just so, without the Naam, the Name of the Lord, how can anyone be carried across? Akal Purakh Ji has forever waited for you; you have been through lakh chouraaseeh (8.4 million life forms), so many faults we made in our past jeevan (lifes). NOW Vaheguru Ji has given you this human body, it is so hard to achieve this. lakh chouraaseeh bhramathiaa dhulabh janam paaeioue || Through 8.4 million incarnations you have wandered, to obtain this rare and precious human life. Akal Purakh made you a Sikh, now make the most of this life become a Khalsa, a Gursikh from there by doing Naam Bhagti become a supreme Gurmukh as, kal mehi guramukh outharas paar ||7|| In this Dark Age of Kali Yuga, only the Gurmukhs cross over. ||7|| No matter what as Satguru Ji says they whom haven’t merged with Vaheguru Ji’s Jot, reached SaachKhand they must proceed to Narak (hell), before that, you shall be judged by Dharam Rai (Angel of justice) and your judgement won’t be a good one. You don’t receive any honer. Jamkaal runs so fast at you after your death to smash your head with a heavy club. theerath barath naem keeeae thae sabhai rasaathal jaa(n)hi ||233|| no matter what pilgrimages, fasts and rituals they follow, they will all go to hell. ||233|| naam lagae sae oobarae bin naavai jam pur jaa(n)hi || Those who are attached to the Naam, the Name of the Lord, are saved; without the Name, they must go to the City of Death. The Gursikhs who do Naam Bhagti and become Gurmukh obtain high honer in Vaheguru Ji’s Darbar (court) Dharam Rai bows to their honourable lotus feet and Jamkaal pays respect from a distance because of their fear from you. Gods, Goddess, angelic beings, angels, furista (white angels), Shaheeds, Bhagats, slaves and more, they shall all greatly honer you. You shall also receive the robes of honer. path naam paavehi ghar sidhaavehi jhol amrit pee raso || Through the Naam, you shall obtain honor, and come home. Eagerly drink in the Ambrosial Amrit. kahu naanak praanee guramukh shhoottai saachae thae path paavai ||5||2|| Says Nanak, when the mortal becomes Gurmukh, he is saved and honored by the True Lord. ||5||2|| gur dheebaan kavaae painaaeeou || In the Guru's Court, He has blessed me with the Robe of Honor. abinaasee purakh paaeiaa paramaesar bahu sobh khand brehamandaa hae ||3|| They have found the Imperishable Supreme Being, the Transcendent Lord God, and they receive great honor throughout all the worlds and realms. ||3|| Bhai Sahib Ji it is true you do have great knowledge of sikhi, Amrit Shaklaoo!! Sahib Ji!! Become a ShaktiShali Sooraa, turn from Sunmukh to Gurmukh. Do sikhi parchaar, by receiving Naam Dhir you will do a mass of Naam Bhagti and the sangat shall fall at your feet. Achieve VAHEGURU JI’S DARSHAN the greatest thing ever. We all need Khalsa Raj, now as said before by all the sangat become a Khalsa. ho kharree nihaalee pandh math moo(n) sajan aaveae || I stand by the side of the road, waiting for You; O my Friend, I hope that You will come. I'm not sure if you have Bhai Sahib Ji but you should read the posts in the topic NAAM, it might give you more interest in taking Amrit. Also there are loads of inspirational books written by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Ji and one by Bhai Sahib Rama Singh Ji. Bhul chuk maaf karnaa, and to you admin I think this is the last post. VahegurooJiKaKhalsaVahegurooJiKeFateh

Re: keshadari prof who smokes

do it bro! · 16 Dec 2003

"it is a paap for me 2 not obey the sangat" Gabroo veerji, it IS Gursangat;) I would listen to them if I were you!! hehe. Seriously though veerji, give your 'sees' to Guru Jee, we need a brother like you in the khalsa panth:)