listening 2 non sikhs kirtan
indy · 24 Jan 2006
What are the sangats views on listening 2 non sikhs kirtan such as nuserat ali fateh khan????? DEGH TEGH..............................
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
indy · 24 Jan 2006
What are the sangats views on listening 2 non sikhs kirtan such as nuserat ali fateh khan????? DEGH TEGH..............................ao · 24 Jan 2006
dont lisenp.s · 24 Jan 2006
reason, mr ao ?ao · 24 Jan 2006
no ras mr p.sDhanwant · 24 Jan 2006
nusrat wicked....one of the best vocalist in d whole world.he believed in Guru Nanak dev ji's ideology.why shudnt u listen.or wud rather hav mans lisnin to dirty hip hop songs???Think b4 u speak. [%sig%]Gandalf · 24 Jan 2006
I say it is fine. You take what you will out of the kirtan. If your mind is closed to getting anything at all out of kirtan by a non-sikh, non-amritdhari, etc etc....you will get absolutely nothing out of it. Too bad for you. And who is anyone to say how much ras another person has. This is how I see it: What is more important?? The message, the messenger, or how the message is delivered?Harcharan Singh · 24 Jan 2006
More importantly, how about listening to Kirtan that is not sung as Guru Ji has ordered? At least NFA Khan appreciates the divinity of and sings in Guru Ji's gifted raags (which is the real reason why Khans songs are deemed as magical). He sings out of his passion and love for God, as Sufi's always have, but has also taken huge advantage of what Sikhs have deemed pointless or cumbersome, Guru Ji's unquestionably clear instructions on how to sing to God. If they can't achieve ras singing to the one God using Guru Ji's musical instructions, then I'm not sure what chance the rest of us have who listen to and perform bollywood, bhangra, classical and folk kirtan. It's up to the individual whether they want to listen to Sufi's, if Sikhs had appreciated and valued Guru Arjun Dev ji's hard work and gift to us, we wouldn't have to listen to anyone else to see what our Guru's divine gift is capable of achieving. Gurbani does tell us that apart from praising God, all other songs are false. It's up to you to decide whether Sikhism has the monopoly on singing Gods praises. Sanson Ki Mala Pe Simaroon Mein Pi Ka Naam I pray the name of God on a rosary of breaths Is an example of Nusrut Ji's devotional Sufi songs. I would say that the foremost task is for Sikhs to learn what Guru Ji's kirtan really is, and for us to revive it. In learning, I don't see anything wrong with listening to great singers or musicians if it is directly related to improving your Kirtan. Once you have learnt how to compose in Guru Ji's hukmi raag and with Guru Kirpa, play a saaj that Guru Ji divinely designed for us, we have no need to ever listen to anyone again. We have more than a lifetimes worth of Gurbani to read and compose kirtan from, and follow Guru Jis hukum to sing Waheguru Ji's kirtan night and day in our own homes with our own families and friends, and spread Guru Ji's word as was shown to us by Guru Nanak Dev ji and millions of Guru Jis disciples thereafter... Ultimately we will be able to pay the correct respect and show our complete allegiance and devotion to Guru Ji by singing Kirtan in Guru Ji's hazoori (Gurdwara), instead of performing for the sangat (instead of for Guru). And instead of going to the Gurdwara because so and so jathaa or latest popstar kirtani is down (who actually listens to and sings in the style of the latest bollywood or bhangra tunes...), or alternatively go down the Gurdwara to listen to so and so classical Kirtani (really meaning, one who does kirtan to 60s bollywood tunes or Punjabi folk tunes).no1 · 24 Jan 2006
listen you dont have to be a sikh to do kirtan. all you need is pyaar for guru ji.. · 25 Jan 2006
erm that doesnt rele work, coz if u did have pyaar for guruji, then you would adopt the sikh path.its quite simple releasdf · 25 Jan 2006
<> siqgur pRswid ] ik oa(n)kaar sathigur prasaadh || One Universal Creator God. By The Grace Of The True Guru: rwgu Awsw Gru 8 ky kwPI mhlw 4 ] raag aasaa ghar 8 kae kaafee mehalaa 4 || Raag Aasaa, Eighth House, Kaafee, Fourth Mehl: AwieAw mrxu Durwhu haumY roeIAY ] aaeiaa maran dhhuraahu houmai roeeai || Death is ordained from the very beginning, and yet ego makes us cry. gurmuiK nwmu iDAwie AsiQru hoeIAY ]1] guramukh naam dhhiaae asathhir hoeeai ||1|| Meditating on the Naam, as Gurmukh, one becomes stable and steady. ||1|| gur pUry swbwis clxu jwixAw ] gur poorae saabaas chalan jaaniaa || Blessed is the Perfect Guru, through whom the way of Death is known. lwhw nwmu su swru sbid smwixAw ]1] rhwau ] laahaa naam s saar sabadh samaaniaa ||1|| rehaao || The sublime people earn the profit of the Naam, the Name of the Lord; they are absorbed in the Word of the Shabad. ||1||Pause|| pUrib ilKy fyh is Awey mwieAw ] poorab likhae ddaeh s aaeae maaeiaa || The days of one's life are pre-ordained; they will come to their end, O mother. clxu Aju ik kil@ Durhu PurmwieAw ]2] chalan aj k kalih dhhurahu furamaaeiaa ||2|| One must depart, today or tomorrow, according to the Lord's Primal Order. ||2|| ibrQw jnmu iqnw ijn@I nwmu ivswirAw ] birathhaa janam thinaa jinhee naam visaariaa || Useless are the lives of those, who have forgotten the Naam. jUAY Kylxu jig ik iehu mnu hwirAw ]3] jooai khaelan jag k eihu man haariaa ||3|| They play the game of chance in this world, and lose their mind. ||3|| jIvix mrix suKu hoie ijn@w guru pwieAw ] jeevan maran sukh hoe jinhaa gur paaeiaa || Those who have found the Guru are at peace, in life and in death. nwnk scy sic sic smwieAw ]4]12]64] naanak sachae sach sach samaaeiaa ||4||12||64|| O Nanak, the true ones are truly absorbed into the True Lord. ||4||12||64||singh · 25 Jan 2006
listen to keertan by a jeevan wale Gursikh like Bhai Jeevan singh, Bhai Rajinder Singh Singapore, Bhai Harpreet Singh, Bhai Joginder Singh talwara, and then compare that to Nasrat fateh Ali khan. There is no comparision. You cannot pretend to have a jeevan, and you cannot pretend the Ras of Amrit in the keertan.Dhan Teri Sikhi · 25 Jan 2006
Mr Ao. I was at Slough many years ago when Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan did keertan, It was amaaaaaaazing.. Ive got the video and watch that occasionally to see the way Nusrat Jee sang Gurbani with so much pyaaar. Sikhi is universal… Gurbani says koee gaavai ko sunai har naamaa chith laae || Whoever sings or listens to the Lord's Name with conscious awareness kahu kabeer sa(n)saa nehee a(n)th param gath paae ||4||1||4||55|| - says Kabeer, without a doubt, in the end, he obtains the highest status. ||4||1||4||55|| Anyone can sing or listen to Gurbani.. There is no reference to only Sikhs can.. There is reference to Whoever Bhul Chuk Maaf.====. · 25 Jan 2006
singh - I notice you have only mentioned the name of Singhs within AKJ slightly biased... lolsafety s · 25 Jan 2006
does no one think that Bibi Ashupreet jatha have sooooooo much pyar and rass in their kirtan yet they are not even sikhMehtab Singh · 25 Jan 2006
hmmm...whats next? [i]Can we buy Gurbani cassettes/CDs from shops run by non-Sikhs?[/i] please!!!!!ao · 25 Jan 2006
theres a big difference between selling kirtan and doing kirtan and i dnt think tht bibiconfused · 25 Jan 2006
quite frankly i dont believe people who sell their keertan have gursikhi jeevan because look what they do anyone can get a job so they cant use that profession excuse on usDhan Teri Sikhi · 25 Jan 2006
Safety S Just to clarify Bibi Ashupreet Kaur and the sisters are Sikh and in fact Amritdhari and have been initiated into the Khalsa Panth.no1 · 25 Jan 2006
who are we to judge anyones sikhi? first we need to sort out our OWN.......... · 25 Jan 2006
rass in keertan is a very subjective thing talk to the very gurmukh singhs, the keertan they enjoy most, will most likely not be the kahn rass we enjoy.Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 25 Jan 2006
What is IMPORTANT is NAAM JAAPP. Gurbani is the vehicle..the important thing we must do is Naam japp.... "Kirtan" if not leading to Naam japp and Vichaar is just kaan rass....melodious voice etc. IN Gurbani Guur Ji tells of this Kaan Rog....and the Hiran Deer dies of this rog....the Fish dies of the Tongue taste rog, the Elephant dies of the Kaam rog, the Patanga dies of the Drishtee seeing rog...ONLY the SATGUR - WAHEGURU is WITHOUT ROG...Harcharan Singh · 26 Jan 2006
If "Kirtan" is done according to how our Guru Ji ordered then we can attain Guru's Ji's naam, ras, anand, kirpa... Real kirtan is a very high form of simran, kathaa and vichaar all rolled into one, that it why the hukum of which raag to render the each shabad in is given 1st and foremost in the Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. When we do Kirtan for our Guru, we meditate carefully on a given shabad, we repeat the words again and again, we feel the words and understand the meaning through repitiion, mediaition and Guru Ji's given melody. We perform Waheguru's praise in teh highest form known. Repeating Waheguru's name 24 hours a day on each and every breath, the benefit entailed goes without saying. It keeps our mind attuned to the true master and his hukums, and thus reflects on all our actions and thoughts. Kirtan is the IMPORTANT way Guru Nanak Dev Ji spread the truth around the world, please do not undermine it. Kirtan and Mardana's divine music (made divine by instruction from Guru Nanak Dev Ji), is how Guru Ji spoke to people of many lands, faiths and languages. Where ever our Guru's went, their darbaar was never without kirtan. Page 214, Line 10 ਨਾਨਕੁ ਕਹੈ ਸੁਨਿ ਰੇ ਮਨਾ ਕਰਿ ਕੀਰਤਨੁ ਹੋਇ ਉਧਾਰੁ ॥੪॥੧॥੧੫੮॥ नानकु कहै सुनि रे मना करि कीरतनु होइ उधारु ॥४॥१॥१५८॥ naanak kahai sun ray manaa kar keertan ho-ay uDhaar. ||4||1||158|| Says Nanak, listen, people: sing the Kirtan of the Lord's Praises, and you shall be saved. ||4||1||158|| Guru Arjan Dev Page 297, Line 10 ਮੀਚੁ ਹੁਟੈ ਜਮ ਤੇ ਛੁਟੈ ਹਰਿ ਕੀਰਤਨ ਪਰਵੇਸ ॥ मीचु हुटै जम ते छुटै हरि कीरतन परवेस ॥ meech hutai jam tay chhutai har keertan parvays. death is overcome, and one escapes the Messenger of Death, by absorption in the Kirtan of the Lord's Praises. Guru Arjan Dev Page 108, Line 1 ਹਰਿ ਕੀਰਤਨੁ ਗਾਵਹੁ ਦਿਨੁ ਰਾਤੀ ਸਫਲ ਏਹਾ ਹੈ ਕਾਰੀ ਜੀਉ ॥੩॥ हरि कीरतनु गावहु दिनु राती सफल एहा है कारी जीउ ॥३॥ har keertan gaavhu din raatee safal ayhaa hai kaaree jee-o. ||3|| So sing the Kirtan of the Lord's Praises, day and night. This is the most fruitful occupation. ||3|| Guru Arjan Dev Page 145, Line 12 ਕਲਿ ਕੀਰਤਿ ਪਰਗਟੁ ਚਾਨਣੁ ਸੰਸਾਰਿ ॥ कलि कीरति परगटु चानणु संसारि ॥ kal keerat pargat chaanan sansaar. In this Dark Age of Kali Yuga, the Kirtan of the Lord's Praise has appeared as a Light in the world. Guru Amar Das Page 213, Line 8 ਨਾਨਕ ਸੁਖੁ ਪਾਇਆ ਹਰਿ ਕੀਰਤਨਿ ਮਿਟਿਓ ਸਗਲ ਕਲੇਸਾ ॥੪॥੧੫॥੧੫੩॥ नानक सुखु पाइआ हरि कीरतनि मिटिओ सगल कलेसा ॥४॥१५॥१५३॥ naanak sukh paa-i-aa har keertan miti-o sagal kalaysaa. ||4||15||153|| Nanak has found the peace of the Kirtan of the Lord's Praises. All his sorrows have been dispelled. ||4||15||153|| Guru Arjan Dev Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki FatehProfessor Mohinder Pal Singh · 27 Jan 2006
Listening Gurbani, through a non-Sikh kirtan is not a crime, but we are of the firm opinion that there are no much vibrations contained in their voice. Their kirtan can not be piercing to the heart, may be acceptable to the brain. They can make Posse and musical instruments can add to help to come out with good presentation. Time pass and for telling each other looks nice. When, their (non-sikh) lust for money or publicity in a different circle attracts them, such singers adopt this method, otherwise, if they have a little courtsey and love for Guru Sahiban, they should openly embrace the Sikhism. Sikhi is love affair with Guru Sahiban and not a business. Professor Mohinder Pal Singh [address removed]LionKing (LK) · 27 Jan 2006
When, their (non-sikh) lust for money or publicity in a different circle attracts them, such singers adopt this method, otherwise, if they have a little courtsey and love for Guru Sahiban, they should openly embrace the Sikhism. Sikhi is love affair with Guru Sahiban and not a business. ********** Although Guru Sahib gave Bhai Mardana some guidelines of what to do and what not to - did he say - "you are fool because you have been circumsized" "you cannot do your namaz 5x a day" Did Guru Arjan Dev ji or any Guru for tha matter put such a demand on a muslim that went straight against their religion? Guru Nanak Patshah did give some conditions, but kes ni kataney, Amrit vele othna (can't remember last one), but nothing that went straight against their religion such as" don't do namaz" etc Yes Sikhi is a love affair with Guru Sahib - but Sikhs don't have monopoly over Guru Sahib. You can follow the Guru, and his prem da marag, just lika Sata Balwand, Bhai Buddhu Shah - http://allaboutsikhs.com/youth/gstories045.htm WE have become very narrowminded and asked everyone who wants to listen or do Kirtan to accept Sikhi - let them do whatever they want to. If they have suchi preet they will do what the Guru commands them sehaje ehaje, we are in no position to impose our views on someone who wants to enjoy the Guru's word, because frankly - we don't have monopoly over Guru ji or his Bani. bhull chukk maafKulbir Singh · 27 Jan 2006
Lionking, What kind of love is it if one does not follow the hukams of Pyaray Guru Sahib? You write that Sikhi is a love affair with Guru Sahib can a patit person really be a lover of Guru Sahib? What is the measure of love or can someone be a lover of Guru Sahib if he cuts hair thus blatantly disobeys the basic hukam of Guru Sahib? As for listening to kirtan by non-Sikhs, there is no one stopping you from listening to kirtan by non-Sikhs but I doubt that kirtan performed by a non-Sikh could bless the listeners with Hari Rass. When a true devotee of Guru Sahib sings from his or her heart, such kirtan pierces the hearts of all listeners. A person who is singing for the sake of money can rarely move hearts. Kirtan is not just singing of Gurbani in Raags. Ingredients of Kirtan are at least three – Gurbani, Raagi and Raag-vidiya. Only singing of Gurbani can be classified as Hari-Kirtan. All other kind of devotional singing is below this level. In sangat, only a devotee can sing Kirtan. Non-Sikhs and patits are not allowed to do kirtan in sangat and rightfully they have been banned from Siri Darbar Sahib Amritsar Sahib. Finally, kirtan should be sung in sur and taal. One does not have to sing in pakkay raag to derive rass from it. Simple and loving reets are fine to sing. Kulbir SinghProfessor Mohinder Pal Singh · 27 Jan 2006
Dear Kulbir Singh jeo, You are the leading Singh of this Phorem. Please read once again, I said, if they have a little courtsey, they should embrace the Sikhism. I did not say that they should remain patit and should recite Kirtan, hence, the second portion questioning to me, is null and void. Rather I agree with you, that they should be with Sikhi. There is no measurement of Love affairs with Guru Sahiban, but one thing, the way of life - Achar/Vihar - will start indicating and death will decide how the man lived. We are talking about "listening 2 non sikhs kirtan", and not the details of love. Perhaps, we are on the same line, as regard to the high level respects for our Guru Sahiban, but presentations are separate. Rass or non-Rass, Raag, style etc. it is different topic, not connected to my letter. Hari Kirtan, Paakey Raag, Sur Taal, I have no where mentioned in my letter, perhaps, you have referred to somebody else. Dear Lion King, Thank you very much for your compliments:- You have written - "You are fool, because you have circumsized". OK, dear, very nice of you and your language. It is difficult to go with the Fanatics. So,I accept defeated from you and you are the winner. Otherwise also, you are Lion King - Lion plus King - so, you are No.1, but in Jungle. Quoting Bhai Mardana, Satta, Balwanda and others, is not going to help, this is merely quoting, the need is of living in a practical way of life. This is your life, you live the way you want to live. You said, Sehje Sehje doing, Please see that death may not snatch before coming on the path of Sikhism Sehje Sehje, important is that. We are the disciple of same Guru Nanak Patshah. MATT SAH AWEI KE NAWEI RAAM Professor Mohinder Pal Singh [address removed]Harcharan Singh · 27 Jan 2006
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh, Veer Kulbir Singh Ji, I was wondering when someone was going to say this: "One does not have to sing in pakkay raag to derive rass from it. Simple and loving reets are fine to sing. " Could you please point me towards where this indication/maryada exists in our history? This comment has no basis at all. You yourself said a few lines earlier: "Ingredients of Kirtan are at least three – Gurbani, Raagi and Raag-vidiya. Only singing of Gurbani can be classified as Hari-Kirtan" And then you say one does not have to sing in pakka raag, contradition I think. The whole Guru Granth Sahib has been structured around raag, I'm sure you know this better than any of us, what do you think the point of this was? To give us Sikhs an option when it came to the style of praising Waheguru? Do you think Guru Arjun Dev ji has given raag such prominence because Guru Ji needed a hobby? There is absolutely no arguement/discussion when it comes to kirtan. See how each shabad starts - RAMKALI - mahalla 3 - Anand. This is how our Guru's and early Sikhs recited Anand Sahib, the one and only source that matters tells us this is black and white. I can't understand how you can contradict this. You make such a fuss about Keski, amrit from Panj etc quoting common sense, why can you not see the common sense in our Guru's blatently giving us instruction in how to render/recite each shabad in Sri Guru Granth Sahib (Jap Ji Sahib aside)? Guru Ji has given us the key to experiencing HAR RAS, to sing Guru's shabad, with devotion and love, in the PRESCRIBED format. It is the raag that creates the true and correct emotion. The emotion, the feeling that Guru Ji has ordered you to feel when experiencing the said shabad. With all due respect, I think you should learn a little more about the purpose and power of Raag, these are not ay raag, these are raags either divinely invented or chosen by our Guru's, like I said, nothing in teh Guru Granth Sahib is their as an option. I am sure you will agree that everything in Gurbani is HUKUM, there are no 2 ways about it. Non-raag kirtan consists of bollywood (old and new), bhangra/folk (old and new) and even pop music today. This is a fact. All these kirtani do not compose non-raag, they simply copy tunes from where they have heard or seen them. I find it insulting for someone to knowingly use a tune from an unholy source to replace my Guru's created hukmi raag. There are many people/Sikhs who do not know about raag and perform kirtan how they have been taught etc, they are not to blame, it is our culture which is to blame. Before the British Raj, kirtan was done in raag using Guru Ji's saaj. Going back even 70-80 years, kirtan was still done in raag in most places. The British took away the power of Guru's sangeet and instruments and replaced them with a sub-standard European instrument that is not capable of perfoming raag. It has been designed for western scales. People like yourself who have so much giaan and pyaar for Guru Ji should be trying to revive real kirtan, not belittle it by saying it is not compulsory. If Guru's thought it was compulsory, no one has the right to make it optional! The word Raagi means he who does kirtan in Raag. It is a joke, that so many people are refered to as Raagi's, who have no interest in or understanding of Raag. As a fighter of so many Sikh issues, I implore you to learn about and fight for this issue to. Guru Nanak Dev Ji spoke to the whole world through Kirtan, which was done in raag, using an instrument, the rabaab, that could play raag. This is how Guru Ji blended the ultimate truth with emotion to speak to peoples minds and SOULS. Just because groups such as Namdhari who you may not be a big fan of have preserved Guru's Kirtan maryada, does not mean that it does not belong to all Sikhs, and does not mean that we should not also strive to preserve it. Namdhari do Naam Simran also, does that mean we should stop? Who are we to decide what tune is a simple loving reet? Who makes that decision? Is Michael Jacksons tune "you are not alone" a simple loving reet? Because kirtan is being done to it today? Our Guru's have already decided what "reet" we should perform Kirtan in/to, we do not need to reinvent the wheel, not do we have the capacity to. And for your information, Bhai Balpreet Singh Ji whom you attended 2005 Khalsa Camp with in the UK, said in one of his workshops that RAAG IS COMPULSORY. Sat Sri Akaal Harcharan SinghHarcharan Singh · 27 Jan 2006
Veer Kulbir Ji, Another point about people who do not perform according to Guru Ji's asoole is changing the chorus or stress point of the Shabad. A prime example is Lakh Kushiyaan. People normally give high charava to the singer to sing this on birthdays, weddings, passing exams, new businessm new house.....etc I was just thinking about this, and even thought of the above example to use, when what do you know, I decide to have a quick look at my e-mail on Sikhnet and WAHEGURU, Veer Amardeep Singh Ji's thoughts on this exact topic and example have been posted there! Dhanvaad mere pyaare Guru Maharaaj. Please read this excellently explained article: Lakh Kushiyan...Significance of the Rahao 01/27/2006 Flow and Pause in Gurbani & Keertan It is important to understand a few terminologies before we proceed further. Rahau - While reading through a Shabad in Guru Granth Sahib, we find that one line has a word RAHAU written at the end. Except for Raag Tukhari, we find the mention of Rahau in nearly all the other Bani. Depending on the type of Shabad (Chaupada - 4 liner, Ashtpadi - 8 liner, etc.) it has that many defined lines. Somewhere in the middle, or in the beginning of the Shabad one line has the word Rahau mentioned, with the numeral 1. The word rahau means WAIT.... PAUSE....in Punjabi "Therau". Gurus have clearly indicated that while reading the Shabad, take a PAUSE on this line. Why Pause? Because the line with RAHAU has the central theme of the Shabad. This is the line in which Guru is conveying the topic discussed in the Shabad and it contains the Gurmat Vichar, the RIGHT THOUGHT. Therefore we are required to pause on this line and contemplate the message. The other lines in the Shabad are used to explain/extrapolate the contents of the Central Theme given in the line of Rahau. These other lines (the non-Rahau lines) talk about prevalent practices, arguments, reasoning, intention, etc. and are used for strengthening/explaining the Central Theme. The point to note is that the numbering of lines is meanigful: the numbering conveys a definitive message. The message here is: Wait/Pause and contemplate on the message. In this line the Guru is telling us the theme of the Shabad. The number 1 of Rahau indicates ,read this line carefully. Now read the other (non-Rahau Line) line, and correlate it to the message in Rahau. Now proceed to other (Non-Rahau) line thereby keep proceeding with all the other lines in a sequential manner. At times, if rarely, we find more than one rahau in a Shabad. All the Rahaus in that Shabad (usually 2,3 or 4) convey the same central theme: reflect on truth. Gurus thought it appropriate to explain the same central theme in different combination of words and therefore gave more than one Rahau. Asthai - In Keertan (or any music) we find one line keeps getting repeated time and again. This common line, which is repeated each time after a different line, is known as Asthai in Indian Classical Music, or Chorus in the Western Music. Antra - In Keertan (or any music) after singing the Asthai (the repetitive line) a different line is sung, and upon its completion the Asthai is sung again and then a second different line is sung, followed by Asthai. This changing line is known as Antra in Indian Classical Music. The purpose of Keertan is to deliver the Gurus’ message sweetly to the listener. As Rahau has the central theme of the Shabad and contains the spiritual message, its usage, as an Asthai is repeated time and again after every Antra, which helps in the message getting drilled into the listener’s mind. The result is that the Guru’s message gets delivered many times while the Shabad is being sung. This increases the probability of retention of the central theme (Gurmat Vichar) by the listener’s mind. Let me take a very popular Shabad from Siri Raag, Page 44, which is sung by Raagis during a happy occasion in the family. Most of the Sikhs will remember the shabad by its popularly known line: Lakh khushiya patshahiya jey satgur nadar karey ......... It’s commonly found that Raagis make the above line as the Asthai while singing the shabad because of the word Khushiya (Happiness). This line is the second non-Rahau line in the Shabad and gets commonly used as the Asthai while singing. The English translation of the Shabad is: SRI RAAG, MEHLA V: All happiness is achieved only by Thy Grace. The precious gift of this human life becomes fruitful when one chants the True Word. One who has such destiny written on his forehead enters the Mansion of the Lord’s Presence through the Guru. || 1 || O my mind, focus your consciousness on the One. Without the One, all involvlements are worthless; emotional attachment to a mirage is verily false. || 1 || Pause || Hundreds of thousands of princely pleasures are yours to enjoy if the True Guru bestows His Glance of Grace. If He bestows the Name of the Lord, even for a moment, my mind and body are soothed. Those who have such pre-ordained destiny hold tight to the Feet of the True Guru. || 2 || Blessed is that moment, and fruitful is that time, when one is in love with the True Lord. Suffering and sorrow do not touch those who have the Support of the Name of the Lord. Grasping him by the arm, the Guru lifts them up and out, and carries them across to the other side. || 3 || Embellished and immaculate is that place where the Saints gather together. He alone finds shelter who has met the Perfect Guru. Nanak builds his house upon that site where there is no death, no birth, and no old age. || 4 || 6 || 76 || If we were to sing this Shabad in proper Keertan singing style by making Rahau (Mere man eikas sio chit laaye/eikas bin sabh dhund hai/sabh mithiya moh maye) as Asthai for repetition, then upon reaching second Antra, the message that will get repetitively get delivered to the mind will be that we need to first make an effort to get our mind to focus on One God, give up attachment to Maya and emotional entanglements. If we succeed in achieving this state of mind, then (as stated in the second Non-Rahau line) thousands of Pleasures will be attained (only if) if His Grace falls upon us. Note that the CONDITION (Rahau line to be used as Asthai) is that we make the effort to rid our mind of attachment/Maya, then the RESULT (Non-Rahau line to be used as Antra) is - if Satguru deems it worth then he provides hundreds of pleasures to the devotee. Unfortunately, this Shabad is commonly sung by Raagis by making the non-Rahau Line No.2 as the Asthai (Lakh khushiya patshahiya jey satgur nadar karey....), which gets repeated many a times during the Shabad singing. Now see the change in deliverability of the message to our mind. We are seeking from our Guru thousands of pleasures, by His Grace and, upon getting them, we will then strive towards ridding our mind of attachment/Maya! Note that by using the non-Rahau line as Asthai, the CONDITION has changed to: if Satguru deems it worth, then He provides hundreds of pleasures to us and the RESULT (Rahau line being used as Antra) is that we will make the effort to rid our mind of attachment/Maya! By using the non-Rahau line in this Shabad as Asthai, our mind is subconsciously being told to live on HOPE, rather than make the EFFORT, which is the reverse of what the Guru is telling us in this Shabad, viz.- Devotee first makes the EFFORT and then HOPE should arise for His Grace. Interesting....isn’t it? We tend to ignore the finer details of Gurus’ message, which is so clear.................Probably that’s the reason why Sikhs of today lack the spirit/spiritual discipline for which our forefathers were known. I hope people will start making an effort of getting the Sikhs in their immediate contact to understand the importance of Rahau in Keertan singing, and strive towards singing Keertan in the correct manner. Those who are active in Gurudwara Management/teaching Keertan should make it a point to teach to the youth only those Shabads in which Rahau is made the Asthai. For a teacher to correct what he has already learnt in so many years is a tough proposition, but he can definitely make an effort to select those Shabads from his Keertan bank for teaching the youth/children, in which the Rahau is made the Asthai. In this way, we may be able to slowly steer in the direction of true deliverance. Guru Ang Sang Amardeep SinghProfessor Mohinder Pal Singh · 28 Jan 2006
listening 2 non sikhs kirtan Author: indy Date: 01-24-06 03:40 What are the sangats views on listening 2 non sikhs kirtan such as nuserat ali fateh khan????? DEGH TEGH.............................. Here is the copy of the subject matter in question and it is addressed to the Sangats views. Please read once again. It questions to (a) listening (b) Kirtan and (c) from non-sikh......such as means plus others like Nuserat ali fateh khan????? But in this phorem, there are only two or three piyare singhs, whose job is to go on condemning, by involving the subject with so many other topics, and go on answering to added-topics and not to the desired topics. The reply to the question is ignored and set aside. Always, they want to show their supremacy. Indy is asking the views and not condemning each other. Reply to his question and there is no need to reply to others. Other day, Princess, Manjit Kaur Sidhu and Dhillon UK wala and many more were condemned badly. It looks like, as if, there are two three people, who have all and all the knowledge to condemn others, and not to reply on the questioned topics. They should not think, they are Braham Gyani, they are Bharam Gyani. And they should not forget to what Guru Sahiban say: HAUMEI DEERAGH ROG HAI DAROO BHEE ISS MAHEIN and further : KIRPA KARE JE AAPNEE TA GUR KA SABAD KAMAEI Chance for Kirpa is possible, if we do not condemn His children. You are condemning to the children of His, which indirectly indicates, condemning Him. Because you are not on the line of Sabad Kamaei - (Ninda Bhalee Kissi Ki Nahe, Man Mukh Mughad Karann. Mooh Kaale Tinna Nindka............. AAGE SAMAJH CHALO NAND LALLA PACHHE JO BEETEE SO BEETEE. Hope this phorem is meant for positive views, as captioned at the top of the website. Professor Mohinder Pal Singh [address removed]LionKing (LK) · 28 Jan 2006
Dear Lion King, Thank you very much for your compliments:- You have written - "You are fool, because you have circumsized". OK, dear, very nice of you and your language. It is difficult to go with the Fanatics. So,I accept defeated from you and you are the winner. Otherwise also, you are Lion King - Lion plus King - so, you are No.1, but in Jungle . *********** Uhm you took my post out of context- read my post again - ***** Although Guru Sahib gave Bhai Mardana some guidelines of what to do and what not to - did he say - "you are fool because you have been circumsized" ***** I was saying that Guru Nanak Dev ji did nto say to Bhai Mardana that he is a fool because he followed Muslim mat and circumsized. Lol this had nothing to do with you personally. I was giving examples of how tolerant and pyaar parey our Guru Ji is. I was never beign fanatic and saying anything to you about it lol. If saying that Mone and non-sikhs can have love for Guru Ji makes me a fanatic, then okay, I'm fanatic Again i sincerely bleive that Guru Ji did not object anyone following their religion yet listening to devotionl praises of the lord as prescribed by Guru Sahib. For all that matters is that you have love and raag. For me that's it. If a Gora has immense love for God and Sings a Shabad with pure love pure maryada - then I think that's a lot better than a Sikh just singing it beign forced by his mum or something. Nowhere in Sikh hisotry do we find that Guru Gobind Singh ji forced Buddhu Shah to take Khande Batte di Pahul. Where do we see tha Bhai Gani Khan and the other muslim pir were told to take Amrit, Sai Mia Mir Ji whoma lot of peopel claim became a Sikh - his decendants and Bhai Mardana's decendants are still MUSLIM - how coudl they be MUSLIMS if they had officially become Sikhs. We can see that the decendants of Prof Sahib Singh (the scholar) are SIKHS, because he converted [I'm using his example because I know his decendants]. When he converted from hinduism suddenly his whole family became Sikhs. There are decendants of Baba Deep Singh Ji, Baba Buddha Ji who are Sikhs - they clearly adopted Sikhi and Sikhdharm - but were never forced to. In a SImilar fashion, Guru Sahib did not force BHai Mardana or Bhai Satta Balwand of Bhai Buddhu Shah, Bhai Gani Khan or any devote to stop practising their religion and that can be seen today. This is a clear evidence they were still muslims, still did their namaz, still had their "sunat", yet they were never banned from doing Kirtan in Guru ji's Darbar. They were never stopped to Sing the Guru's and Vaheguru's Praises - why have we become so narrow minded. History tells us that Guru Sahib had several hindu poets, several Muslim Darbar Sahib vich Kirtan Karan Vale Raagi, - he did not distinguish which religion someone belonged to. Again if Buddhu Shah could sacrifise his army yet still didn't convert, if Bhai mMrdana was told to do Kirtan, Bhai Satta and Balwand, Bhai Gani Khan, Sia Mia Mir Ji, all whom modern day Sikhs have started claiming converted - have their decendants as MUSLIM SUFIS!!! If Guru Nanak Dev Ji said Na Koi Hindu na Koi Musalman, it wasn't just directed to them it was directed at all. Guru Ji looks for love, not labels. Guru ji saw love in Bhai Mardana, Bhai Satta and Bhai Balwant, Bhai Buddhu Shah, Sia Mia MIr Ji, they were Guru Sahib's darbaris - yet they did not convert - WHY have we become so intolerant to non-sikhs? Panth has made a decision that only a Sikhs are allowed to do Kirtan in the Darbar of the Guru. That's fair enough. Why is that so? Because lately there's been cases of peopel claiming to be decendants of Bhai mardana washed their mouths after doing Kirtan saying that they have read the bani of Kafirs. This is preuly disrespectful to Gurbani - thus they were banned. But when there was that innocent pure love, Guru ji had his arms open for them. When they started disrespecting Bani, they were banned, if they respect for Bani Guru Sahib did give an example by opening his arms for them. My conclusion for above mentioned pro & cons arguments - If a Non Sikh does Kirtan with pyaar and maryada then i see no reason why they shouldn't be allowed. In Darbar Sahibs they are until Panth sees that yes there are non-sikhs who can do Kirtan with pyaar and MARYADA, banned. BUt outside darbar Sahib i see no reason why if you have a track by a non-sikh who does Kirtan with devotion and maryada I d't see why not. We should stop jumping on non-sikhs who seem to have an interest in the Guru and Sikhi. We have seen how tolerant and loving our Guru's were, they did not force anyone but accepted anyone with open arms - why cam't we? Bhull chukk maafKaur · 28 Jan 2006
Harcharan Singh, when and where has Nusrat sung title raags from the Guru Granth Sahib in the same shabad?Harcharan Singh · 28 Jan 2006
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh, Bhen ji, I never said that Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan sang shabads from Gurbani in title raag, I said : "At least NFA Khan appreciates the divinity of and sings in Guru Ji's gifted raags (which is the real reason why Khans songs are deemed as magical)." Meaning Nusrat Ji sang in Guru Ji's raags, not sung Gurbani Kirtan. This is not to say he may not have, I am not an expert on Nusrat Ji, but have heard he has done some Sikh dharmak quawilies, not sure if they were historical or Gurbani though. Anyway, the question was about raag, as an example, Nusrat Ji has sung the following quawalis in Guru Ji's given raag: TRADITIONAL SUFI QAWWALI' VOLUME 2 1. Manqabat in Raga Bhairavi Maulah ali maula ali (Raag Bhairav - Expressing man’s state of hell) 2. Ghazal in Raga Kedar Khabren rasid im shabd ke nigar khahi amad (Raag Kedara - expressing love) 3. Song in Raga Bilawal Main jagi piya ke sangh (Bilaaval - Expressing beautification of soul, happiness). Here is an example of feedback from someone who has listened to Nusrat Ji's devotional songs, this is the magic of raag, especially Guru Ji's raag when someone knows how to use it: Haq Ali Ali takes up a whole side, he flips it and goes classical for some time, also the back and forth leading to the crescendo and then the chorus is truly amazing. Qwaali becomes about the sound, words are repeated in song until they lose their outward meaning and a deeper truth is revealed. This recording is filled with an amazing energy that perhaps could not be caught in any studio. There are instances of microphone feedback which only show the trance that the musicians got into, their total oblivion. This tape can bring you to tears before you know it. This is devotional music which can be felt through the cassette, a devotion to the mysteries and the sadness and the lack of comprehension of life, a devotion to God and to brotherhood, and it can be felt without any knowledge of Urdu. So, the point is that, we, the Sikh Panth have lost this indescribable and divine tool given to us by our Guru's, and people like Nusrat Ji, Ravi Shankar, and may other musicians and singers have seen the power in these raags and have created some of the most famous songs in the worlds and become legends. The point of stating this is not the fame is good or the objective, the point is the one thing that has captured the imagination, hearts and souls of millions of people (which people think is the genius of these artists) is in fact the divine genius of our pyaare Guru sahibaan, their cherished and so kindly gifted raag, which elevated Waheguru's worship through Sikh Kirtan to the highest level ever known. And we today have decided that it is "optional" or not all that. Pure hypocrisy, to rant and rave about all other types of Bibeki and Maryada which are 100% clear in Gurbani, but yet ignore the one maryada that is "ABSOLUTELY" clear, how to recite gurbani in it's most beatiful form - Guru Ji's Raag Kirtan. All my attempts to gain support on this subject from the influential people on this forum seem to fall on deaf ears. It's a shame how these people quickly identify faults in other peoples interpretations and understanding of Sikhi, yet are completely blind or purposefully ignorent to their own weaknesses. No matter, there are plenty of more Sikhs in the world. Guru Ji's hukum will be and are being revived right now. The days of manmat Kirtan are numbered, Guru's kirtan is returning. Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh. Harcharan SinghProfessor Mohinder Pal Singh · 28 Jan 2006
Dear Lion King Gone are the days of those muslims, to whom Guru Sahiban embraced. Let us be careful, if we want to survive as a Gursikh, and our generations. We have to be far sighted like Guru Gobind Singh Ji. I too can quote, hundred citations of history and details of present-day situation, including Nine Eleven but sorry, I do not find any logic to remain in this argument. Better give reply to original question of Indy. Chapter is closed with you. Professor Mohinder Pal Singh [address removed]Kulbir Singh · 28 Jan 2006
Veer Harcharan Singh jeeo, ---------------- Veer Kulbir Singh Ji, I was wondering when someone was going to say this: "One does not have to sing in pakkay raag to derive rass from it. Simple and loving reets are fine to sing. " Could you please point me towards where this indication/maryada exists in our history? This comment has no basis at all. You yourself said a few lines earlier: "Ingredients of Kirtan are at least three – Gurbani, Raagi and Raag-vidiya. Only singing of Gurbani can be classified as Hari-Kirtan" And then you say one does not have to sing in pakka raag, contradition I think. ------------- What I meant by “Pakkay Raag” was the complicated alaap they do in kirtan and “Sa re ga ma pa dha nee saa” they say in Kirtan. This is what I meant by Pakkay Raag. In my opinion, kirtan reet should be such that sangat should be able to sing along with it. Don’t start a debate on Raags now. I am not against Raag kirtan and it’s good to hear Raag kirtan when sung by a Jeevan-waalay Gursikh. I personally have never heard a pure Raag kirtan from a person who is a Naam Rassiya, gets up at amritvela etc. The last Naam Rassiya Raag Kirtaniya was probably Baba Shaam Singh jee of Darbar Sahib. --------------- There is absolutely no arguement/discussion when it comes to kirtan. See how each shabad starts - RAMKALI - mahalla 3 - Anand. This is how our Guru's and early Sikhs recited Anand Sahib, the one and only source that matters tells us this is black and white. I can't understand how you can contradict this. ---------- I don’t think one can really recite Siri Anand Sahib in Raag Ramkali. Raag is there to tell that when this baani was first sung, it was sung in Raag Ramkali. It does not mean that one cannot simply do paath of this baani, nor does it mean that one is not allowed to sing in any other Raag, this baani. If Guru Sahib had meant that a certain pankiti of Siri Anand Sahib can only be uttered Raag Ramkali, then no one can do paath as paath is not sung but uttered. ------------- Guru Ji has given us the key to experiencing HAR RAS, to sing Guru's shabad, with devotion and love, in the PRESCRIBED format. ----------- Name one famous Naam Rassiya Mahapurash who sang only in prescribed Raags (in modern times). ---------- Non-raag kirtan consists of bollywood (old and new), bhangra/folk (old and new) and even pop music today. This is a fact. All these kirtani do not compose non-raag, they simply copy tunes from where they have heard or seen them. I find it insulting for someone to knowingly use a tune from an unholy source to replace my Guru's created hukmi raag. ----------- Here I have to agree with you. There should be a stop to these Bollywood Raagis and Kirtanis. A very famous AKJ Kirtani from UK once went to Chicago to attend the AKJ Samagam. I too was there. Prior to my amritdhari jeevan, I used to listen to filmy songs very keenly and had a mastery in this field. This kirtaniya, was blatantly singing Bollywood tunes in kirtan. I could not restrain myself and with folded hands I did benti to him, after his kirtan, to avoid doing kirtan in Filmy tunes. He got irritated and advised me to not watch too many movies and listen to songs. I told him that I don’t watch movies or listen to songs but he never admitted his mistake and to this day, continues to sing Filmy tunes of 50s, 60s, and 80s. ----------- People like yourself who have so much giaan and pyaar for Guru Ji should be trying to revive real kirtan, not belittle it by saying it is not compulsory. If Guru's thought it was compulsory, no one has the right to make it optional! ------------- I have been thinking about it and we Singhs have not yet decided on adopting a strict Raag Maryada. Perhaps in days to come, it will happen. -------------- Just because groups such as Namdhari who you may not be a big fan of have preserved Guru's Kirtan maryada, does not mean that it does not belong to all Sikhs, and does not mean that we should not also strive to preserve it. Namdhari do Naam Simran also, does that mean we should stop? ------------ I don’t believe Naamdhari style Kirtan is Gurmat Sangeet. These Kukaas have learned kirtan from Muslim Ustaads and are now preaching that their sangeet is Gurmat Sangeet. --------- And for your information, Bhai Balpreet Singh Ji whom you attended 2005 Khalsa Camp with in the UK, said in one of his workshops that RAAG IS COMPULSORY. ---------- This is what I just said in one of the previous paragraphs. Many Singhs from our Jatha are in favour of Raag Kirtan. I am in the middle somewhere. Hopefully, soon we will get a resolution on this. Kulbir SinghHarcharan Singh · 29 Jan 2006
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh, Respected Veer Kulbir Ji, Firstly, thank you for responding, and I am hugely encouraged and pleased to know that you have some respect for Guru Ji's kirtan, but I do believe that there is still scope for learning, but I pray Guru ji bless you with kirpa on this subject also. ---------------- Veer Kulbir Singh Ji, I was wondering when someone was going to say this: "One does not have to sing in pakkay raag to derive rass from it. Simple and loving reets are fine to sing. " Could you please point me towards where this indication/maryada exists in our history? This comment has no basis at all. You yourself said a few lines earlier: "Ingredients of Kirtan are at least three – Gurbani, Raagi and Raag-vidiya. Only singing of Gurbani can be classified as Hari-Kirtan" And then you say one does not have to sing in pakka raag, contradition I think. ------------- What I meant by “Pakkay Raag” was the complicated alaap they do in kirtan and “Sa re ga ma pa dha nee saa” they say in Kirtan. This is what I meant by Pakkay Raag. In my opinion, kirtan reet should be such that sangat should be able to sing along with it. Don’t start a debate on Raags now. I am not against Raag kirtan and it’s good to hear Raag kirtan when sung by a Jeevan-waalay Gursikh. I personally have never heard a pure Raag kirtan from a person who is a Naam Rassiya, gets up at amritvela etc. The last Naam Rassiya Raag Kirtaniya was probably Baba Shaam Singh jee of Darbar Sahib. ----- ------------- --------- Veerji, pakaa raag means only 1 thing, to sing in the title raag. What many so called famous kirtani/raagi do today is mix raags, basically manmat, thinking that they can improve on Guru Ji's ordained hukumi raag. The alaap style that you mentioned is Indian Classical music, there are some raagis that do this, but not all. They do this because they have received training from classical music garanaas. An alaap is a very important learning, teaching and evidence element. It should be done at the beginning of the shabad, not part way through, it is normally done to the announcing of the title raag and reciting mool or gurmantar at the start of the raag. The alaap shows evidence of the raag being sung, it uses the wadi, samwadi, niyas, anuwadi and vivadi, the key sur that define the raag, each sur plays an individual and key element in the composition. I totally agree that kirtan should be simple to sing, and if raagis oeby gurmat sangeet rules, then it is very simple, please listen to Prof Surinder Singh Ji's album "Mere Mun", to see how simple, beautiful and empowering real kirtan is, as well as how it should be presented. Anyone can sing along with it. The point that you have mentioned is all the more reason for real gurmat sangeet to be revived, there is a lot of classical music based influence today, we need to correct this. Please don't dictate what should be debated or not, this is a forum and so it's purpose is debate, it is strange to hear a comment like this from yourself, as you debate on nearly everything else. I will debate and correct people until I am blue in the face if they dare to change or twist my Guru's hukum. Yes, Baba Shaam Singh was a legend, for me more so, because he treasured Guru Arjun Dev Ji's gift, the Saranda, and only ever did kirtan with this, solo many times. He was the perfect raagi, Guru's instruments, Guru's melody and Guru's shabad. Again, instruments are a whole other issue which people know about, but brush under the carpet because they don't like change, or like the fact that they have never used common sense to question why they chucked away Guru's instruments and are using the Gorais sub-standard intruments. As for Gursikhs who are Raagis and only perform in raag, they are not many but they exist, Bhai Balbir Singh Ji is the most famous at present, he has never sold out, he performs strictly in Guru's raag, and his kirtan is uncomparable to any present day kirtan singer. Prof Surinder Singh Ji has dedicated his life to researching and reviving gurmat sangeet - real Sikh kirtan, not the classical based raag that some are claiming as puraatan today. Prof Ji's love for Guru is amazing, and if you ever have the good fortune to see them do kirtan for Guru Ji, you will understand how simple, beautiful and powerful Guru Ji's kirtan is, and how it should be presented. There are many other Gursikh babai who have dedicated their life to reviving kirtan, but they are on a much smaller scale, but if you are not interested in Guru's kirtan, then obviously you will not know about them. It's a shame you have never heard proper kirtan, but with his kirpa you will soon. Please listen to Bhai Balbir Singh Ji's kirtan on: http://www.ikirtan.com/index.php?q=f&f=%2FBhai_Balbir_Singh_Jee%2F31_Raags http://www.ikirtan.com/index.php?q=f&f=%2FBhai_Balbir_Singh_Jee%2F31_Raag http://www.ikirtan.com/index.php?q=f&f=%2FBhai_Balbir_Singh_Jee Also, try and purchase Prof Surinder Singh Ji's album "mere mun", it comes with a priceless book which explains the meaning and emotion and technicalaties of every raag in the Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, Prof has sung a shabad in every raag of Guru's. It is very damming to say the last naam rasiya kirtani was Bhai Shaam Singh. You forget Baba Ram Singh Ji who revived Sikhi, a large part of which was due to his kirtan propogation. There have also been thousands of others, not every one can become a Darbaari Raagi and be immortalised in annals of history. My grandfather for one is NITNEMI is for 40 years and sings strictly in raag. --------------- There is absolutely no arguement/discussion when it comes to kirtan. See how each shabad starts - RAMKALI - mahalla 3 - Anand. This is how our Guru's and early Sikhs recited Anand Sahib, the one and only source that matters tells us this is black and white. I can't understand how you can contradict this. ---------- I don’t think one can really recite Siri Anand Sahib in Raag Ramkali. Raag is there to tell that when this baani was first sung, it was sung in Raag Ramkali. It does not mean that one cannot simply do paath of this baani, nor does it mean that one is not allowed to sing in any other Raag, this baani. If Guru Sahib had meant that a certain pankiti of Siri Anand Sahib can only be uttered Raag Ramkali, then no one can do paath as paath is not sung but uttered. ---------- ------ ----- I know that Anand Sahib Ji can be and is recited by people in Ramkali, and true Gursikh Kirtani can do this.. I never said that you can't simply do paath of this baani. Again yo belittle and put your own spin on the reason that Raag has been specified before every paath (par Japji) in Gurbani. Title raag is not a historical reference, it is a hukum - clear and in black and white. I honestly can't understand why you don't see that, that is a very defensive attitude, to say it can be sing in any raag is blasphemous, who are you to decide this? Guru Ji has stated clearly what raag it is to be sung in, if you tried to reading my posts carefuly you would understand why. It is so you will FEEL the meaning of the shabad. If you change the raag, you change the feeling and thus understanding of the shabad. Please read my other posts on this forum, it's not so hard to understand. Reading paath and singing paath, reading for learning and doing kathaa, kirtan for connecting to Waheguru, to express our love for him, to give ourself to him, to prove our dedicationa and loyalty to him, to listen to his hukum, to vichaar, to simmer, to naam paap.... Simran, paath and kirtan are all equally important, and inmany ways overlap in the benefit derived. ------------- Guru Ji has given us the key to experiencing HAR RAS, to sing Guru's shabad, with devotion and love, in the PRESCRIBED format. ----------- Name one famous Naam Rassiya Mahapurash who sang only in prescribed Raags (in modern times). ------ --------- ----- That is the only real arguement/justification that people have. To be honest my knowledge is limited, different times, conditions etc create and shape us. Post the British raaj - kirtan was obliterated in a number of ways, very cleverly. There are many people researching this, so we will have some answers soon. But the British did push to force Christianity on Punjab in a big way, but it failed, so the next thing they did was shape Sikhi to suit them. Harmoniums were introduced, Guru's saaj were displaced made unfashionable and so with them was raag. Gorai had a huge influence on Sikh kirtan, they introduced microphones, grammophones, speakers, radio, media etc... and opened up doors for the modern world, which will always attempt disolve the puratan world. Baba Ram Singh Ji is the last mahapursh I know of that performed raag kirtan. Post this I am not sure. But due to Sikh knowledge, maryada and history being diltued, I beleive Gursikh like Baba Atter Singh Ji, Isher Singh Ji, Nand Singh Ji, Jarnail Singh Ji, Randhir Singh Ji etc.. used what was available to them, in the time and tuff circumstances in which they lived, which is fine. That is not to say that they may not have sung in raag or raag based melodies, I have heard by some people Bhai Randhir Singh sang in raag. But today when we have brought Sikhi back to the mainstream, and have so much knowledge, resource and time, that there is no excuse. This isn't an attack on those who don't or haven't used Guru's Hukmi Raag, it is a request to now embrace and reintroduce Guru Ji's maryada now that we have the time and resource to do so. ---------- Non-raag kirtan consists of bollywood (old and new), bhangra/folk (old and new) and even pop music today. This is a fact. All these kirtani do not compose non-raag, they simply copy tunes from where they have heard or seen them. I find it insulting for someone to knowingly use a tune from an unholy source to replace my Guru's created hukmi raag. ----------- Here I have to agree with you. There should be a stop to these Bollywood Raagis and Kirtanis. A very famous AKJ Kirtani from UK once went to Chicago to attend the AKJ Samagam. I too was there. Prior to my amritdhari jeevan, I used to listen to filmy songs very keenly and had a mastery in this field. This kirtaniya, was blatantly singing Bollywood tunes in kirtan. I could not restrain myself and with folded hands I did benti to him, after his kirtan, to avoid doing kirtan in Filmy tunes. He got irritated and advised me to not watch too many movies and listen to songs. I told him that I don’t watch movies or listen to songs but he never admitted his mistake and to this day, continues to sing Filmy tunes of 50s, 60s, and 80s. -- --- There isn't just one Veer ji, the majority actually operate in this way. If they claim they made the composition, then that shows that they have time on their hands, and if they do, then why not learn and compose in Guru's raag. That arguement falls short. tunes are either inherited or copied form media. If correctly inherited, then that means they are a diluted version of the raag, if thats the case, then why not repair and make the composition 100% Guru's again? ----------- People like yourself who have so much giaan and pyaar for Guru Ji should be trying to revive real kirtan, not belittle it by saying it is not compulsory. If Guru's thought it was compulsory, no one has the right to make it optional! ------------- I have been thinking about it and we Singhs have not yet decided on adopting a strict Raag Maryada. Perhaps in days to come, it will happen. --- ------- --- Waheguru thwanu kirpa devai, athe gurmat de toore te faisle benown nu himmat devai. I do have much respect for aspect of AKJ, and I hope that the jathaa will take one step closer to Guru ji and adopt this, his most clear maryada. -------------- Just because groups such as Namdhari who you may not be a big fan of have preserved Guru's Kirtan maryada, does not mean that it does not belong to all Sikhs, and does not mean that we should not also strive to preserve it. Namdhari do Naam Simran also, does that mean we should stop? ------------ I don’t believe Naamdhari style Kirtan is Gurmat Sangeet. These Kukaas have learned kirtan from Muslim Ustaads and are now preaching that their sangeet is Gurmat Sangeet. --- --- -- This is a very "hear say" founded opinion. Namdhari have always had and strictly lived by Guru's raag vidya and maryada from the days when it was not optional. It is true to say that Namdhari have learnt how to play Guru's saaj from classical garanai, that is not a bad thing. They have revived Guru's Ji's gifted saaj in a big way, thank you to them for that. That is not to say this had disappeared from the mainstream, but very neary so. Learning how to play Guru Ji's instruments from people who appreciated them and treasured them is no bad thing. Thank yo uto the classical garanaas for preserving our saaj. The time has now come for us to take them back and put them back into the use for which they were invented and given to the world, to perform Guru's kirtan. Gurmat Sangeet - mainly refers to Guru's raag, this has nothing to do with classical houses, they douse them but in a different way, and have become bery famous because of them i.e. ravi shankar. Gurmat Sangeet is Guru's hukmi kirtan and using Guru's saaj to perform it - this is strictly a Sikh keeping. --------- And for your information, Bhai Balpreet Singh Ji whom you attended 2005 Khalsa Camp with in the UK, said in one of his workshops that RAAG IS COMPULSORY. ---------- This is what I just said in one of the previous paragraphs. Many Singhs from our Jatha are in favour of Raag Kirtan. I am in the middle somewhere. Hopefully, soon we will get a resolution on this. ---- Let's hope our enlightened veers in the jathaa can also rub off some off their kirpa on you. Thanks you for discussing. I sincerely hope you will take interest in this important subject and become invloved. Guru's kirtan darbaar are what drew people near the charan of our Guru sahiban and that very same kirtan is what pierced through the maya and straight into their souls, making them Guru's forever. The spear that pierced the soul was Guru's Raag executed Shabad. Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh Harcharan SinghWhatThe... · 29 Jan 2006
"Gone are the days of those muslims, to whom Guru Sahiban embraced. Let us be careful, if we want to survive as a Gursikh, and our generations. We have to be far sighted like Guru Gobind Singh Ji." Gone TOO are those days of those Brahmins, to whom Guru Sahiban embraced. Bahminism has always been the Dusht of the panth since the days of the Gurus and in my opinion, is the even more of a threat today. Let's just not pick on Islam here. jab eih gehai biparan kee reeth || main n karon ein kee pratheeth || Professor Mohinder Pal Singh [address removed] What's unisexastrology all about?ns · 30 Jan 2006
Kulbir Singh Jee mentions: "I personally have never heard a pure Raag kirtan from a person who is a Naam Rassiya, gets up at amritvela etc. The last Naam Rassiya Raag Kirtaniya was probably Baba Shaam Singh jee of Darbar Sahib. " I disagree somewhat there are many that are adopting this method now then before and to take the lead are the likes of Dr. Tejinderpal Singh Ji Doola.. I 've listened to doing keetans for decades however over the last decade or so his style has changed he does more raag kirtan as along with the normal AKJ stylee. This is an excellent discussion point veer Harcharn Singh Jee has raised excellent points. I recently went to a kids youth darbar kirtan in Southall just the weekend gone. Kirtan was done by most youth using string insturments and I would say it was excellent. No doubt this will continue and prosper with Guru Ji';s blessing. I would also menton Bhai Avtar Singh Ji is also a great kirtanea as along with Balbir Singh as mentioned above.Balbir Singh · 31 Jan 2006
Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal! Dear claiming racers! The Guru's message is the universal truth. It is for all human beings. Some people claim they alone are heritable. Please do not give the impression that few have become better imitators because they are singing Gurbani in a special way. Gurbani is the experience of Truth. It is not the repetition of songs on a stage. Balbir Singh [%sig%]Harcharan Singh · 31 Jan 2006
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh Veer Balbir Singh Ji, Please decipher your message and clearly state to whom and to what it is directed. "Please do not give the impression that few have become better imitators because they are singing Gurbani in a special way." Who has given that impression? Gurbani is for everyone, for every single living soul on this planet should they wish to accept it. Who is an imitator? What does this mean? Singing in a special way? That is an extremely diluted way of putting it. I would say singing in the way Guru Maharaj has ORDERED is divine and only those who are blessed do so "vadbhaagee har keertan gaa-ee-ai". Please do darshaan of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, it is clear as day. If you wish to to sing gurbani with an electric guitar and sing it to hip hop tunes, that is entirely your choice, it's a free world. I'm aware Daya Singh Ji's daughter does gurbani to Michael Jackson tunes, may be you would find this more enjoyable than our Guru's divinely inspired and hukmi raag. So please show the same democratic attitude towards those who actually want to follow their Guru's hukum 100% and not pick and choose. Please do not have a problem with people trying to encourage others from doing kirtan in Guru's method rather than a manmat method. "Gurbani is the experience of Truth. It is not the repetition of songs on a stage." The experience of truth you so eliquently point out is experienced when we listen to and accept our Guru's hukum. And actually it is a "repitition of songs" although I find it hugely offensive that you dare call Guru Shabad and kirtan "songs", in a derogotary way. Learn the purpose of Rahao (read my Rahao post) and you may understand why we need to repeat, to contemplate and to put emphasis on, to do arth, vichaar, to simmer. Do you not repeat Gurmanter? Why bother, if saying it once is enough? You repeat to meditate, to absorb, to understand, to feel, to merge. Please think before making such brash statements. Page 213, Line 8 ਨਾਨਕ ਸੁਖੁ ਪਾਇਆ ਹਰਿ ਕੀਰਤਨਿ ਮਿਟਿਓ ਸਗਲ ਕਲੇਸਾ ॥੪॥੧੫॥੧੫੩॥ नानक सुखु पाइआ हरि कीरतनि मिटिओ सगल कलेसा ॥४॥१५॥१५३॥ naanak sukh paa-i-aa har keertan miti-o sagal kalaysaa. ||4||15||153|| Nanak has found the peace of the Kirtan of the Lord's Praises. All his sorrows have been dispelled. ||4||15||153|| Guru Arjan Devuk singh · 31 Jan 2006
Balbir Singh is an excellent Kirtani as is Shamsher Singh Karir, Bhai Hari Singh and Bhai Gurmej Singh. Even some of the more famous tuny kirtanees can perform brilliant raag kirtan ie Nirmal Singh and Harjinder Singh. It is unfortunate that the $$$$ are more important to them than keeping raag maryada intact. The truth hurts. Approach any one of these ragis about why they do not stick to raag kirtan and you'll see the same negative responses time and time again.Balbir Singh · 31 Jan 2006
Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal! Veer Harcharan Singh Ji! You wrote "Please do not have a problem with people trying to encourage others from doing kirtan in Guru's method rather than a manmat method." Exactly this is imitating Gurus, in my view. Do we really know the inner state and consciousness of the Gurus while singing their celestial songs? How was it then possible to find our method Gurmat and other's method of singing Manmat? Have the Gurus ever suggested us to imitate them? Please give references from Gurbani. The Gurus sang whole life but they never named it Gurbani. They praised Gurbani very often. For them Gurbani is 'Hari Naam' and its praise after experiencing it. You wrote further "And actually it is a "repitition of songs" although I find it hugely offensive that you dare call Guru Shabad and kirtan "songs", in a derogotary way." Strange that when you write 'repetition of songs' it is complementary but it is derogatory when I write it is 'repetition of songs'. Please provide one reference where the Gurus have instructed us to copy and sing their hymns. Have you ever thought why one sings songs in praise of mangoes before he has tasted it? There are still some who sing songs in praise of mangoes after they have tasted it. There is a difference. One who knows the taste of mango wants others to taste it. He never wants others to imitate his songs of its praises. Thanks for the great Guru's Vaak. nwnk suKu pwieAw hir kIrqin imitE sgl klysw ]4]15]153] nwnk suKu pweAw hir kIrqin imitAo sgl klysw ]4]15]153] naanak sukh paa-i-aa har keertan miti-o sagal kalaysaa. ||4||15||153|| SGGS Page 213, Line 8 Guru Nanak Ji found peace by singing Hari that dispels all the sorrows. How many times people should repeat the above Guru's Vaak to dispel sorrows and find peace? Please explain. Balbir Singh [%sig%]Harcharan Singh · 31 Jan 2006
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru j iki Fateh, Veer Balbir Singh Ji, With all due respect, please read all the kirtan articles that have been posted and this thread and others and you will find your answers. If you are ignorent to the fact that kirtan was done in Guru Ji's raag before the British presence, then this discussion is futile. Gurmat - Guru inclined - Shabad sung in the method that Guru Ji has clearly stated. Please explain to me why the whole Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj is structured around raag. Why has every shabad been given a raag. Why would our Guru put an "option" in bani, does that mean that everything else in bani is optional? Manmat - self-inclined - Shabad is sung to ones own composition, bhangra music, bollywood music, folk music, classical music or pop music. What is so hard to understand. "Please provide one reference where the Gurus have instructed us to copy and sing their hymns." I am not even going to bother answering that. Re-read your sentence and meditate on it. Then do an ardaas and ask for Guru Ji's forgiveness. I beg you do some research on raag before continuing this discussion. Raag serves a purpose, it creates and invokes an emotion, the exact emotion that is relevant to the theme of the shabad. Is that hard to understand? It's completely logical. "You wrote further "And actually it is a "repitition of songs" although I find it hugely offensive that you dare call Guru Shabad and kirtan "songs", in a derogotary way." Strange that when you write 'repetition of songs' it is complementary but it is derogatory when I write it is 'repetition of songs'." I was quoting your words, hence the use of the quotation marks. You know very well you were belittling kirtan by calling it a "repitition of songs", be man enough to admit. "Please provide one reference where the Gurus have instructed us to copy and sing their hymns." I am not going to even bothering answer that, that is probably the most ridiculous sentance I have ever read (to say it politely). But for your info: Page 108, Line 1 ਹਰਿ ਕੀਰਤਨੁ ਗਾਵਹੁ ਦਿਨੁ ਰਾਤੀ ਸਫਲ ਏਹਾ ਹੈ ਕਾਰੀ ਜੀਉ ॥੩॥ हरि कीरतनु गावहु दिनु राती सफल एहा है कारी जीउ ॥३॥ har keertan gaavhu din raatee safal ayhaa hai kaaree jee-o. ||3|| So sing the Kirtan of the Lord's Praises, day and night. This is the most fruitful occupation. ||3|| Guru Arjan Dev Page 131, Line 13 ਗੁਰਮੁਖਿ ਚਾਲ ਜਿਤੁ ਪਾਰਬ੍ਰਹਮੁ ਧਿਆਏ ਗੁਰਮੁਖਿ ਕੀਰਤਨੁ ਗਾਏ ਜੀਉ ॥੮॥ गुरमुखि चाल जितु पारब्रहमु धिआए गुरमुखि कीरतनु गाए जीउ ॥८॥ gurmukh chaal jit paarbarahm Dhi-aa-ay gurmukh keertan gaa-ay jee-o. ||8|| To live as Gurmukh is the lifestyle by which we come to meditate on the Supreme Lord. The Gurmukh sings the Kirtan of His Praises. ||8|| Guru Arjan Dev "Have you ever thought why one sings songs in praise of mangoes before he has tasted it? There are still some who sing songs in praise of mangoes after they have tasted it. There is a difference. One who knows the taste of mango wants others to taste it. He never wants others to imitate his songs of its praises." So what are you saying, that Sikhs over the last 500 years have been stupid for singing/imitating our Guru's words? Should we be composing our own praises? I am not at all sure what you are talking about. In my understanding - Guru Ji's shabad - Guru Ji's saaj - Guru Ji's raag = Guru Ji's kirtan = my Kirtan. Easy. Don't presume to know who has and who hasn't tasted the ras of Guru Ji's kirtan. If you do a little research, you will understand why Guru Arjun Dev Ji dedicated his life to kirtan and preparing Sri Ad Granth ji in a way by which we could sing Akaal Purkhs praises and feel the anand forever. If you think otherwise, that's your prerogative. Answer to your last question....... as long as it takes. "karmee aapo aapnee kay nayrhai kay door". Sat Sri Akaalsingh · 31 Jan 2006
bhai harcharan singh, u talk of prof surinder singh reviving sikh music which is very comendable. bt with my own ears i have heard him call any person who sings kirtan which is not in title raag a manmukh and a paapi. what sort of "gursikh" would have the nerve to call Sant Attar Singh, Sant Isher Singh, Bhai Randhir Singh manmukhs and paapis. If people want to preach what is gurmat, they should look at themselves first before putting down some of the greatest gursikhs to set foot on this earth in the last 100 years!!Balbir Singh · 31 Jan 2006
Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal! Veer Harcharan Singh Ji! In my view, the Gurus message is universal and for all Jug (ages). There will always be people on earth of different culture, customs, speaking certain languages and interested in particular type of melodies with different music instruments. The Gurus message is open to all. All those who are true seekers long for God's Darshan with the means God has gifted them. Strange the room for Gurus Wisdom is becoming smaller every moment for some Sikh Brahmins these days. It is possible only, I feel, when the true message is misunderstood. One who knows true Simran, he wishes it for everyone. What has moved some Sikh to ban others singing Gurbani with often new restrictions? You wrote "Raag serves a purpose, it creates and invokes an emotion, the exact emotion that is relevant to the theme of the shabad." Surely Raag serves a purpose. For everyone it is different. I know many people who have lost interest in listening the Guru's Hymns from these classical singers. Apart from this, the Gurus have not suggested any technique to realize God, like Keertan done by classical Raagis these days. Rather, Gurbani says "geet naad mukh raag alaapay man nahee har har gaavaa." SGGS Ang 1003 The Gurus have also not instructed us to imitate them by singing in Raags and long Alaaps. The only humble suggestion from them I found is to get One True Naam and its Jap. Simran is the true continuity of Alaap. "o-ankaar ayk Dhun aykai aykai raag alaapai." SGGS Ang 885 You also wrote "You know very well you were belittling kirtan by calling it a "repitition of songs", be man enough to admit." Please do not try to estimate my thankfulness for Hari Naam with God's Grace. And do not waste time in inventing a measuring instrument for it. Thanks for providing the wonderful references from Gurbani about the praise of Hari (Hari-Keertan). My Gurus say that Hari Keertan is to establish within mind. It is not Alaap to sing outwardly. "dayh daras jit man tariptaasai har keertan man thehraa-idaa." SGGS ANG 1076 The True Simran is Hari Keertan. The Alaap from Raggis these days is neither Hari Keertan nor Simran. "hamrai sarvan simran har keertan ha-o har bin reh na saka-o ha-o ik khin." SGGS Ang 369 The Gurus clearly explain what Hari Keertan is. "beej mantar har keertan gaa-o." SGGS Ang 891 I will not ask more questions and bother you not to answer. You also are uncertain when you write "I am not at all sure what you are talking about." Please come to know true Simran. You may not need to understand me anymore. Balbir Singh [%sig%]Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 31 Jan 2006
BEAUTIFUL PICTURE....just like a scene out of the Old Testament..Moses and all that...who painted it and where ?? nay other info on it. please. I am intrigued by the dress of the people... Jarnail singhHarcharan Singh · 01 Feb 2006
Veer Singh Ji, You are right that Prof Ji can be contraversial at times, but he has the utmost respect for the all Mahapursh that you mentioned. Secondly, I have not heard him say that, we only have your word for it. If you heard him say that and it upset you, then you should have confronted Prof ji and asked him why he said it - there and then. Not relay your experience at a later date on a forum where the audience only have your word to go by (please don't take this the wrong way, I am advising you as a brother). Unfortunatley you mis-understand Prof Ji, when he makes comments (not quite as insulting as you have said) he is targeting the gyani/kirtani who know very well that they are sourcing tunes from bhangra/bollywood and are using these with our Guru's sacred shabad. The sangat themselves love this type of kirtan because it is perfomed to tunes that they are familiar with and love back at home, the shabad is therefore not pardhaan. Also, he is saying that if a kirtani wants to dedicate his life to kirtan, and make a living from it, then why not do it according to Guru's rules, they are doing it full time, so learning raag won't take them that long. Today we have all the resources in the world, if Gursikhs weren't able to perform rag in the last century it is understandable times were hard, 1st with the British then with the Indians. I have expressed my opinion/theory on why Mahapursh may or may not have sung in raag, namley, majboori, they could only do what the conditions - political, economic and social - around them allowed to. Here is a post from a Veer on sikh sangat, which also helps understand this, only thing is that there is big difference between classical and gurmat sangeet, classical is way more complex as it is music orientated: -------------------------- to master raag it takes many years. ravi shankar stayed in an ashram for 20 years before he went onto be a professional sitarist. but that has nothing to do with the topic. i have come across some singhs whose parents mastered raag, taking them years...6-7 years. as parchaar began to lack during the british period, singhs became very desperate to do parchaar, hence raag fell because it took too long, and many singhs wanted to go out there to do parchaar, hence the raag format gave way and singhs tried to do keertan (another form of parchaar), as they became so desperate they had to make their own tunes up. hence items such as vajaa all of a sudden became a must have, unlike the taus the vajaa did not need tuning. many of the singhs seeing this thought it was ok to do this kind of stuff, as a result went on to become very famous keertaniye, but without learning how to master raag. even in darbar sahib, some people got to a stage where they would say "satnaam sri waheguru" and sing a shabad in a funky tune. thats until Jathedar Vedanti made it compulsory for every jatha to sing in raag in at least one shabad (back in 2003). even the raag keertan we hear at darbar sahib is not pure raag, its a very watered down format which the indian government has something to do with. its also worth mentioning that during this time, alot of what the Gurus had made (such as schools) were converted to christian missionary buildings which still stand today (cant remember the name, but theres one on amritsar i know that). the british also stopped the supply of materials to make instruments such as Taus, hence from the praatan group of over 30+ doing keertan together, this was eventually reduced to 3 people in a jatha. hence parchaar had to be done fast...and in doing so raag had to be sidelined as during the british raaj, alot of the singhs were subjected to conversion to christianity, hinduism and other cults. but now there are gurmat sangeet acadmies that teach students raag. ----------------------------Harcharan Singh · 01 Feb 2006
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru j ki Fateh, Veer Balbir Ji, You have conveniently picked and chosen specific parts of my response and ignored others, in addition it is evident you didn't listen to my benti and read all other posts on this topic. No matter. ---------- my view, the Gurus message is universal and for all Jug (ages). There will always be people on earth of different culture, customs, speaking certain languages and interested in particular type of melodies with different music instruments. The Gurus message is open to all. All those who are true seekers long for God's Darshan with the means God has gifted them. Strange the room for Gurus Wisdom is becoming smaller every moment for some Sikh Brahmins these days. It is possible only, I feel, when the true message is misunderstood. One who knows true Simran, he wishes it for everyone. What has moved some Sikh to ban others singing Gurbani with often new restrictions? ----------------- I am open minded and agree with much of what you say. Especially the fact that true seekers seek waheguru's darshan with the means gifted to them. My problem is not with them. It is with people who have all the means, but choose only the ones that will please the sangat and increase charavaa rather than please Guru and increase Kirpa. You speak of new restrictions and bans, I am unaware of this. I am simply trying to promote Kirtan in Guru Ji's hukmi raag, if people wish do use kache raag that's fine, their choice. Our Guru's gave us maryada - do find this restrictive and brahminical also? -------------------- You wrote "Raag serves a purpose, it creates and invokes an emotion, the exact emotion that is relevant to the theme of the shabad." Surely Raag serves a purpose. For everyone it is different. I know many people who have lost interest in listening the Guru's Hymns from these classical singers. --------------------- This is where your ignorence and therefore disrespect shows. Raag serves only 1 purpose, to create the correct emotion that is assocaited to the shabad, our Guru has spoken, he has felt, he has experienced, this is what he wants us to understand, not something else. There is a huge difference between a true Raagi and a classical singer. Classical singers (many guised as Raagis), have done as much damage to kirtan as rock star gyanis have. Please listen to my benti and do some research, if you are interested I can send you info, e-mail me, I will happy to help. ---------- Apart from this, the Gurus have not suggested any technique to realize God, like Keertan done by classical Raagis these days. Rather, Gurbani says "geet naad mukh raag alaapay man nahee har har gaavaa." SGGS Ang 1003 The Gurus have also not instructed us to imitate them by singing in Raags and long Alaaps. The only humble suggestion from them I found is to get One True Naam and its Jap. Simran is the true continuity of Alaap. "o-ankaar ayk Dhun aykai aykai raag alaapai." SGGS Ang 885 ---------------- Veer ji thanks for saying this, many people are ignorent of this fact. Gurmat sangeet is not about long alaaps, it is about Shabad. The long alaaps that you may have experienced are from people who have learnt from classical musicians. Long alaaps have no place in gurmat sangeet, this is what I have said, classical has done as much damage as pop. If you could be kind enough to read previous posts the alaap question has already been anwered. The rest of your post on this subject is therefore irrelevant. I doubt very much Guru's sang in long alaaps, so that comment is invalid. As for imitating out Guru's, if you find you don't want to then fine. To me Guru Ji is my ultimate role model, I will try and immitate their puran lifestyle in any way I can, as I am sure most Sikhs do. --------------- You also wrote "You know very well you were belittling kirtan by calling it a "repitition of songs", be man enough to admit." Please do not try to estimate my thankfulness for Hari Naam with God's Grace. And do not waste time in inventing a measuring instrument for it. --------------- Not sure what you mean. --------------- Thanks for providing the wonderful references from Gurbani about the praise of Hari (Hari-Keertan). My Gurus say that Hari Keertan is to establish within mind. It is not Alaap to sing outwardly. "dayh daras jit man tariptaasai har keertan man thehraa-idaa." SGGS ANG 1076 -------------- Yes, same can be said for Naam Abiyaas, yet it doesn't stop Sikhs from expressing their lovely outwardly. You are right ultimately the goal is inward, for everything, but that does not mean to say you cannot express your inward anand outwards. And I do not think My Guru's invented saaj, held kirtan darbaars, composed Gurbani around raag ...because they were bored. Every single last action of Guru's served as a purposeful influence and every single action has a thousand benefits if followed. ------------ The True Simran is Hari Keertan. The Alaap from Raggis these days is neither Hari Keertan nor Simran. "hamrai sarvan simran har keertan ha-o har bin reh na saka-o ha-o ik khin." SGGS Ang 369 The Gurus clearly explain what Hari Keertan is. "beej mantar har keertan gaa-o." SGGS Ang 891 ------------ I agree with you. Many raagi are saaj/alaap pardhaan, and that is wrong, same goes for the majority of gyani/kirtani who do not want to be restricted by raag and want to show of their vocal talents and cool music from the latest films. For your kirtan to be true, your intentions need to be true, your passion needs to be true, your love needs to be true. I agree. Please stop generalising raagi, there are fakes and their are real ones, same as every single other aspect of life. You contradict your own open mindedness when saying "There will always be people on earth of different culture, customs, speaking certain languages and interested in particular type of melodies with different music instruments. The Gurus message is open to all." And then slating raagis (real or false). --------- I will not ask more questions and bother you not to answer. You also are uncertain when you write "I am not at all sure what you are talking about." Please come to know true Simran. You may not need to understand me anymore. ------------ Veer ji, if you have a real desire to learn about this subject then e-mail me and I will be pleased to help. Thanks you for pointing out my lack of kirpa, that is very kind of you, I will try harder understand true simran, and would advise (in all politeness), for you to do the same. Waheguru ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ka Khalsa. Harcharan SinghBalbir Singh · 03 Feb 2006
Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal! Veer Harcharan Singh Ji! It does not surprise me to read your sentences like "I am open minded and agree with much of what you say," "Veer ji thanks for saying this," "You are right ultimately the goal is inward . . ." and "I agree with you." The posts from Balbir Singh are written in mastee. These are not to convince anybody. Some stress explaining how convinced these people are because they have understood their scriptures and misunderstood others. The songs from enlightened persons are not to understand and get convinced by mind. Those are to enliven. The Truth is possible easily with true Simran, the true Gurshabad. Truth is never reached by reproducing someone's behavior or looks. You emphasized strongly writing a post dated 01-31-06 06:28 "I would say singing in the way Guru Maharaj has ORDERED is divine and only those who are blessed do so "vadbhaagee har keertan gaa-ee-ai."" I do not know where Guru Maharaj Ji has ordered to sing in their way or in a special way. The name of the Raag in the beginning of a particular Guru's Baanee is the pure information. It is not a hint to misunderstand as their instruction. The Guru's Hymns became 'Vaikhree Baanee' as blessings for the world in ecstasy. This ecstasy can be reached by the true Simran alone. It cannot be reached by singing their Hymns in their Raags without reaching their state of consciousness. In my understanding A Raag is the combination of particular notes in an ascending and descending order. This gives unaccountable possibilities to sing in different melodies. These melodies can also be harmonious and soothing to the minds of masses too. It is perfectly all right when some people spend valuable lifetimes to learn Raags and prefer to sing Guru's Hymns that way, but please without the feeling of simulating them. Please ponder over this what the Guru says about imitating the enlightened Sat Guru. [gurbani]jy ko kry aus dI rIs isir CweI pweIAw ][/gurbani] "jay ko karay us dee rees sir chhaa-ee paa-ee-aa." If someone simulates Him, receives dust on head. [gurbani]nwnk ApiV koie n skeI pUry siqgur kI vifAweIAw ]34][/gurbani] "naanak aparh ko-ay na sak-ee pooray satgur kee vadi-aa-ee-aa." SGGS Ang 1250-19 Nanak, none can deny the glory of the Perfect True Guru. ************** [gurbani]ijs no swihbu vfw kry soeI vf jwxI ][/gurbani] "jis no saahib vadaa karay so-ee vad jaanee." Whom Sahib makes great is known alone to be great. [gurbani]ijsu swihb BwvY iqsu bKis ley so swihb min BwxI ][/gurbani] "jis saahib bhaavai tis bakhas la-ay so saahib man bhaanee." Who is pleased to Sahib, he is bestowed. He is liked by Sahib. [gurbani]jy ko Es dI rIs kry so mUV AjwxI ][/gurbani] "jay ko os dee rees karay so moorh ajaarnee." SGGS 302-17 One who simulates him he is harebrained, ignorant. ************** [gurbani]gur prswid sdw min visAw siB kwj svwrxhwrw ][/gurbani] "gur parsaad sadaa man vasi-aa sabh kaaj savaaranhaaraa." Guru's Prasaad resides always in mind resolving all affairs. [gurbani]Enw kI rIs kry su ivgucY ijn hir pRBu hY rKvwrw ]5] [/gurbani] "onaa kee rees karay so viguchai jin har parabh hai rakhvaaraa." SGGS Ang 638-3 Simulating them, he gets destroyed whom Hari Lord is the savior. ************** [gurbani]Duir Bgq jnw kau bKisAw hir AMimRq Bgiq BMfwrw ][/gurbani] "Dhur bhagat janaa ka-o bakhsi-aa har amrit bhagat bhandaaraa." From the beginning worshipers are bestowed. A Bhagat is the treasure of Hari Amrit. [gurbani]mUrKu hovY su aun kI rIs kry iqsu hliq pliq muhu kwrw ]2][/gurbani] "moorakh hovai so un kee rees karay tis halat palat muhu kaaraa." SGGS Ang 733-16 Who becomes stupid he simulates them. His face is blackened now and every moment. ************** [gurbani]ijin qU syivAw iqin suKu pwieAw horu iqs dI rIs kry ikAw koeI ][/gurbani] "jin too sayvi-aa tin sukh paa-i-aa hor tis dee rees karay ki-aa ko-ee." SGGS 549-14 Whom you serve he gets solace moreover who can simulate him. Dear Harcharan Singh Ji! In my view one may use his talent to sing in Raags with the attitude "singing in the way Guru Maharaj has ORDERED." He should not wonder why he is receiving strange results, the Gurus have mentioned. Please let the rest of the world sing also as God want them all to rhyme. Love. Balbir Singh [%sig%]Harcharan Singh · 04 Feb 2006
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh, Veer Balbir Singh Ji, I agree with everthing you say bar these points: 1 - You seem to be under the impression that someone who who invests time in learning their Guru's raag to perform kirtan the way that their Guru's did is not capable of, or somehow does not have enough time to realise true simran? Could there be a remote possiblity that the love and clarity gained through simran may be the reason why some people would want to learn about and revive their Guru's kirtan, and feel the anand that their Guru's felt? I am not sure why you keep identfying this distinctoin, I have already agreed that without naam, all tasks are futile, including kirtan. Please stop patronising and judging by implying I should do more simran and forget about Guru's raag. As advised before, reflect on your self, not others. 2 - You may think that there is content in the Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji that is there for information only, I certainly don't. Every single word bani and serves a purpose. Why would I want to do kirtan different to my Guru, why would I want to reinvent the wheel, what makes me think that my rendition or composition will be better than Guru's or that I can achieve the same anand from Kirtn that Guru's did without using there divinely inspired and gifted Guru Raag? I do not think the Guru's would have wasted precious space in Maharaj to put simple or optional historical information - Maharaaj is Shabad - the word of God, the ultimate truth, the source of naam. If you are happy to listen to kirtan done to bollywood music, then thats fine, I am not judging you. I am simply expressing my opinion and understanding as you are yours. This is a Sikh website, so I am trying to encourage sangat to do kirtan to Sikh music (Guru's Raag), why do seem to have a problem with that? 3 - You say: "In my understanding A Raag is the combination of particular notes in an ascending and descending order. This gives unaccountable possibilities to sing in different melodies. These melodies can also be harmonious and soothing to the minds of masses too. It is perfectly all right when some people spend valuable lifetimes to learn Raags and prefer to sing Guru's Hymns that way, but please without the feeling of simulating them." It does not take a lifetime to learn raag, this is a myth. You obviously haven't done any research as requested nor read my posts, so it useless to carry on this discussion, as you do not still understand the principles or reasons for raag. It is not a simple ascending and descending scale. That is like saying Guru Ji's bani is simply a collection of Gurmukhi characters. And it does not simply a harmonios soothing melody. Each raag for each specific shabad serves a very important purpose, it invokes the exact emotion, passion, mood that is relevant to the shabad, not all shabads have the same direction although they all lead to the same goal. Gurbani helps us in every single aspect of life, every problem, every sorrow, every happiness, every confusion, every question, it is for this reason, and to understand the essance of the shabad that Guru Ji has given us this priceless tool for aiding our understanding and expressing our emotions to our Guru. You seem to be simply justifying your lifestyle or view point. You said earlier "One who knows the taste of mango wants others to taste it. He never wants others to imitate his songs of its praises." This line sums it all up. If you want to know what anand Guru's raag gives, take some time to learn it try it out, until then, with all due respect, stop pretending to understand all belittle it. As for Guru Ji not wanting us imitate them, I think you are wrong. Our Guru's lead an exemplery life, because they were imbued with Akaal Purkhs essence and to show us how to live our lives, this is why they refrained from miracles. Secondly, if we accept your understanding, that they didn't want us to imitate them, then I would still imitate them. We all imitate, that is how nature works, you are a product of imitating throughout your whole life. You did not recieve special divine enlightenment on how to speak, read, write, dress, bathe, interact with people, do your Dastaar, you did this all though imitation. It is how nature works. If I choose to imitate my Guru and encourage others to do so, please donot have a problem with this, on the contrary, encourage me, there is no one on this planet who would be better to imitate. The kirtani you speak of who sing in their own chosen melodies have imitated Hans Raj Hans, Asha Bhosle or Ravi Shankar, fine, their choice. I choose to imitate my Masters, Guru Sahibaan. Waheguru ji ka Khasla Waheguru ji ka Fateh. Harcharan SinghBalbir Singh · 04 Feb 2006
Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal! Veer Harcharan Singh Ji! You have often expressed a wish stating "You obviously haven't done any research as requested nor read my posts," " . . . in addition it is evident you didn't listen to my benti and read all other posts on this topic. No matter.", "I beg you do some research on raag before continuing this discussion.", "This is where your ignorence and therefore disrespect shows." And "Veer ji, if you have a real desire to learn about this subject then e-mail me and I will be pleased to help." Veer Ji! Thanks for your offer. I have gone through those posts. Still, I have not become a classical Raagee nor I got the wish to become one. Please excuse me for this. It looks like you know Simran and its Raag too when you write "I have already agreed that without naam, all tasks are futile, including kirtan." Please explain in which Raag the Simran is performed. I will be grateful. You have proudly admitted that you imitate the Gurus walking their path. It is your personal matter. I listen Gurdev singing [gurbani]mn ry gur kI kwr kmwie ][/gurbani] "man ray gur kee kaar kamaa-ay." O mind, earn the act of Guru's know-how. [gurbani]gur kY BwxY jy clih qw Anidnu rwcih hir nwie ]1] rhwau ][/gurbani] "gur kai bhaanai jay chaleh taa an-din raacheh har naa-ay. ||1|| rahaa-o." SGGS Ang 66-3 One who walks according to Guru's know-how then day and night Hari creates Naam. One who walks also according to the true Gurus's know-how then he receives honor in the Lord's court. [gurbani]siqgur kY BwxY BI clih qw drgh pwvih mwxu ][/gurbani] "satgur kai bhaanai bhee chaleh taa dargeh paavahi maan." Guru Nanak Ji says when Naam is not awakened, for those wearing, eating is worthless. [gurbani]nwnk ij nwmu n cyqnI iqn iDgu pYnxu iDgu Kwxu ]1][/gurbani] "naanak je naam na chaytnee tin Dhig painan Dhig khaan. ||1||" SGGS Ang 646-15 It is wonderful listening Gurdev while singing. I do not know why Gurdev never sings that the Keertan styles, also classical Raags developed in the year 2006 will give honor to a Raagee in the Lord's court. ************** Veer Ji! In my view, the music is pleasant for ears and mind. All types of notes are worldly but one. This is Truth and received as Gur Prasaad. This cannot be learned from music teachers. The Gurus have not taught Raags to Sikhs. This is the reason why the Gurus have not written any book on music. God and the Gurus wisdom are all about Truth. It is recognized by Simran. Here are few great, wonderful and truthful Shabads from the Gurus about Raag. [gurbani]gwvih rwg Bwiq bhu bolih iehu mnUAw KylY Kyl ][/gurbani] "gaavahi raag bhaat baho boleh ih manoo-aa khaylai khayl." Sings Raag, speaks in many ways this mind plays games. [gurbani]jovih kUp isMcn kau bsuDw auiT bYl gey cir byl ]2][/gurbani] "joveh koop sinchan ka-o basuDhaa uth bail ga-ay char bayl. ||2||" SGGS Ang 368-4 He is busy lifting water from well to irrigate fields. Get up. Oxen have eaten the crop. ************** True Gurmukh does not relish tastes of food and Raags. Gurmukh discards those. [gurbani]gurmuiK rwg suAwd An iqAwgy ][/gurbani] "gurmukh raag su-aad an ti-aagay." [gurbani]gurmuiK iehu mnu BgqI jwgy ][/gurbani] "gurmukh ih man bhagtee jaagay." SGGS Ang 415-15 Gurmukh! In such mind worship awakens. ************** [gurbani]Bgiq nwrdI irdY n AweI kwiC kUiC qnu dInw ][/gurbani] "bhagat naardee ridai na aa-ee kaachh koochh tan deenaa." Worship naardee is not entered heart. Through various ways body is craving. [gurbani]rwg rwgnI ifMB hoie bYTw auin hir pih ikAw lInw ]3][/gurbani] "raag raagnee dinbh ho-ay baithaa un har peh ki-aa leenaa. ||3||" SGGS Ang 654-19 He sits embedded with Raag and Raagnee. What has he to do with Hari? ************** [gurbani]gIq rwg Gn qwl is kUry ][/gurbani] "geet raag ghan taal se kooray." Geet, Raag, Ghan, and Taal are illusions. [gurbani]iqRhu gux aupjY ibnsY dUry ][/gurbani] Those give birth to three GurNs which die and remain at distance (from Truth). ************** [gurbani]rwg nwd Coif hir syvIAY qw drgh pweIAY mwnu ] [/gurbani] "raag naad chhod har sayvee-ai taa dargeh paa-ee-ai maan." Discard Raag and Naad, serve Hari then honor is received in Lord's palace. [gurbani]nwnk gurmuiK bRhmu bIcwrIAY cUkY min AiBmwnu ]2][/gurbani] "naanak gurmukh barahm beechaaree-ai chookai man abhimaan." SGGS 849-6 Nanak! Gurmukh contemplates Brahm. Mind gets rid of egotism. Dear Harcharan Singh Ji! Gurdev is not trying to convince anybody. Gurdev is just singing. It is our luck what we perceive. Nobody should worry about his earnings after reading my posts. God has assigned His Karams and Bhogs to all His creatures. Please ponder over this. There are many references from Guru's Baanee about Raag. Why Raagees never sing those? Love. Balbir Singh [%sig%]Harcharan Singh · 05 Feb 2006
Veer ji, We are going around in circles. I am honestly unsure as to what you are trying to prove? 1 - Classical raagi is completely different to a Sikh Raagi, stop confusing the 2. 2 - Please stop saying you have read my posts, if you had, you wouldn't keep on repeating the same incorrect quotes like you have above. 3 - I am glad you are not becoming a classical raagi, because the panth already has those (and these are who are probably refering to), we need Sikh Raagis. 4 - You can perform simran with or without raag, most of the gurmanter simran melodies we still here today that have been handed down generation to generation are actually still in raag, i.e. waaa-heeee-guruuu waheguru waaa-hee-guruuu... Depends on what mood your in. Or you don't have to do simran to raag at all. Do you profess to know how to do simran, I personally thing there are many ways to do simran, slow, fast, quiet, loud, swas swas, to raag, Gurmanter, Moolmanter, to shabad....is naam not contained in all these ways? Or alternativley, as the type of music isn't apparantly important you can also do simran to Michael Jackson, hip hop, bhangra tunes etc.. as people are starting to today, your choice, what ever makes you happy. All music is raag, it all creates emotions, passions, it can be used for good or for bad as you well know, same as knowledge, relgion, high position in society, fighting knowledge, a positiojn of trust, food etc... Veer ji, it is you that needs to do vichaar on the tuks that you have so selectively chosen, and are using immaturely to discredit Guru Ji's given raag. Guru Ji is talking of the many classical raagis that were prevalent at the times of the Mughals, and who's sole purpose was entertainment, fame, wealth, pride etc... and possibly those that started to become manmukh on not render shabad pardhaan kirtan, those who put music first. To prove my point let me elaborate on what would be in your eyes a negaitve comment on raag: ਕੋਈ ਗਾਵੈ ਰਾਗੀ ਨਾਦੀ ਬੇਦੀ ਬਹੁ ਭਾਤਿ ਕਰਿ ਨਹੀ ਹਰਿ ਹਰਿ ਭੀਜੈ ਰਾਮ ਰਾਜੇ ॥ कोई गावै रागी नादी बेदी बहु भाति करि नही हरि हरि भीजै राम राजे ॥ ko-ee gaavai raagee naadee baydee baho bhaat kar nahee har har bheejai raam raajay. Some sing of the Lord, through musical Ragas and the sound current of the Naad, through the Vedas, and in so many ways. But the Lord, Har, Har, is not pleased by these, O Lord King. ਜਿਨਾ ਅੰਤਰਿ ਕਪਟੁ ਵਿਕਾਰੁ ਹੈ ਤਿਨਾ ਰੋਇ ਕਿਆ ਕੀਜੈ ॥ जिना अंतरि कपटु विकारु है तिना रोइ किआ कीजै ॥ jinaa antar kapat vikaar hai tinaa ro-ay ki-aa keejai. Those who are filled with fraud and corruption within - what good does it do for them to cry out? You, as you have above, would have only shown and focused on the 1st line, completely missing Guru Ji's point, which is, without tryin to be being Gur-Mukh, all the best attempts and practices to praise Waheguru are futile. I have already stated, that without love for waheguru, kirtan is useless, so I don't why you keep on at this point. You are also trying to compare kirtan against simran, this is nonsensical, it is not a competition. Guru Ji has emphasised the importance of both. The same way you have probably spent hours searching out negative things to say about raag, which are actually talking about the people using them, you should spend some time to search what Guru Ji says about the importance of kirtan. There is no confusion, kirtan is mandatory. Guru Ji has kindly given us the ultimate tool to do kirtan, at the beggining of each shabad - the hukmi raag, without love of Waheguru, all is futile - meditation, kirtan and reading gurbani. It does not take a nuclear-physicist to add 1 and 1 to make 2. Love for Waheguru + Sri Guru Granth Sahib (Title Raag + Shabad) = Guru Ji's hukmi Kirtan. If you have a different formula, thats fine it's a free world and you are an individual able tomake your own choices. Where is the confusion? You also say Guru have not taught raag? Well actually they did, Guru Nanak Dev Ji first of all taught Bhai Mardada Gurmat Raag, Bhai Mardana who was already a raagi, but Guru Ji replaced his wordly raags with divine ones and ones which expressed the correct feeling and emotion of the shabad that Guru Ji was about to sing. Also, why was all kirtan done in raag prior to British rule? Economic sanctions, conversion, caste division, religious restriction, partition, irresponsible SGPC, Harmonium, radio, media, amplifier, speakers, cinema, music as entertainment (bhangra- bollywood), westernising sangat are some of the reasons Guru ji's raag declined. The same reason the following - shaster vidya, sarbloh bibek, laridaar saroop/gurmukhi, rehit, bana, nishkaam seva, suchma, correct history... to name but few, declined, is the same reason Guru Ji's raag declined. Many things we are supposed to do as Khalsa, as Sikh tradition, that are not specifically instructed in Gurbani, does not make them worthless. The funny thing is that pardaareth raag is one of the things that Guru Ji has clearly instructed in baani. If you think it is their for "information only", then thats yuor choice. Page 178, Line 6 ਕਰਿ ਕੀਰਤਨੁ ਮਨ ਸੀਤਲ ਭਏ ॥ करि कीरतनु मन सीतल भए ॥ kar keertan man seetal bha-ay. Singing the Kirtan of His Praises, my mind has become peaceful; Guru Arjan Dev Page 208, Line 18 ਜਾ ਕੈ ਹੀਐ ਪ੍ਰਗਟੁ ਪ੍ਰਭੁ ਹੋਆ ਅਨਦਿਨੁ ਕੀਰਤਨੁ ਰਸਨ ਰਮੋਰੀ ॥੩॥ जा कै हीऐ प्रगटु प्रभु होआ अनदिनु कीरतनु रसन रमोरी ॥३॥ jaa kai hee-ai pargat parabh ho-aa an-din keertan rasan ramoree. ||3|| Those whose hearts are illuminated by God, sing the Kirtan of His Praises night and day with their tongues. ||3|| Guru Arjan Dev Page 199, Line 3 ਹਰਿ ਕੀਰਤਨ ਮਹਿ ਏਹੁ ਮਨੁ ਜਾਗੈ ॥੧॥ ਰਹਾਉ ॥ हरि कीरतन महि एहु मनु जागै ॥१॥ रहाउ ॥ har keertan meh ayhu man jaagai. ||1|| rahaa-o. Let your mind remain awake and aware, singing the Kirtan of the Lord's Praises. ||1||Pause|| Guru Arjan Dev Hun babeya, chuti deh deh. Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki FatehBalbir Singh · 05 Feb 2006
Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal! Veer Harcharan Singh Ji! Thanks for Satsangs and the great references from Gurdev. There is a difference. Gurdev sings [gurbani]hir kIrqn mih eyhu mnu jwgY ]1] rhwau ][/gurbani] "har keertan meh ayhu man jaagai. ||1|| rahaa-o." In Hari Keertan this mind awekens. You understand it [gurbani]rwg kIrqn mih eyhu mnu jwgY[/gurbani] "rag keertan meh ayhu man jaagai." In Raag Keertan this mind awakens. One, who has realized the Truth of Hari, sings Hari Keertan. ************** Your name is addressed to write these posts. The messages are not alone for you. The name Balbir Singh is used to spread love at the conclusion. The messages are from Praymeshwar. Love. Balbir Singh [%sig%]Angad Singh · 05 Feb 2006
ask your self a few questions.. who was bhai mardana.. why do we have bhagats bani in the Shri Guru Granth Sahib Why did Balvand and Satta ..sons of bhai mardana do kirtan in guru ram das ji's court why did guru gobind singh ji employ muslims in his court to sing kirtan.. kirtan is praises of god..you cant say its copyright protected thus u cant sing it.. guru ang sang!... · 05 Feb 2006
Angad Singh, Bhai Mardana was a Sikh. Are you suggesting that after travelling so many year with Guru Nanak he still believed in Mohammed as his prophet? He was certainly a Sikh. Satta and Balwand were not the sons of Bhai Mardana. But at any rate, they too were Sikhs. Hence their praising the Gurus. If they were Muslims, they could not do this. It would be blasphemy. Unless you're suggesting they were just "making it up" as part of their "employment". Read their life stories they were Sikhs. Re. the Bhagats, this discussion is very old. They were Sikhs and not anything else. They clearly weren't devout Hindus and Muslims. Who told you Guru Gobind Singh employed Muslims to sing kirtan? Do you have any proof for this ?LionKing (LK) · 06 Feb 2006
Bhai Mardana was a Sikh. Are you suggesting that after travelling so many year with Guru Nanak he still believed in Mohammed as his prophet? He was certainly a Sikh. Satta and Balwand were not the sons of Bhai Mardana. But at any rate, they too were Sikhs. Hence their praising the Gurus. If they were Muslims, they could not do this. It would be blasphemy. Unless you're suggesting they were just "making it up" as part of their "employment". Read their life stories they were Sikhs. ************************ Did Guru Sahib EVER stop Bhai Mardana from reading Namaz? Did they condem him for being circumsized? ******** Who told you Guru Gobind Singh employed Muslims to sing kirtan? Do you have any proof for this ? ********* I do not know of Guru Gobind Singh Ji, but Guru Arjan Dev ji definetly had two muslim saints doing Kirtan - Bhai Satta Bhai Balwand, who did Kirtan in Guru Sahib's deevan. a Shabad composed by them (which is actually dhurkibani) can be found in Guru Sahib. Guru Gobind Singh ji DID on the other hand have - Bhai Gani Khan (and the other saint whose name I always forget), who helped Guru Sahib get from one place to another. The Guru issued a Hukamnama for these. THeir decendants still have the Hukamnama, and although have faith for Guru ji are STILL MUSLIMS. Something worth mentioning is that many have given generous offers to buy this hukamnama from them - however they refuse totally sayign thta it's a gift that the Guru has given to them, and isn't some cheap thing that can be sold- it is ANMOL (beyond value) - yet we Sikhs tend to be the ones selling our heritage off. Puting bathroom tiles on our Gurdwara, not allowing anything to stay genuine from the time of the Guru - Down with the Thanda buraj at Sirhand! Down with Bebe Nanaki's Haveli! Up with marbled Gurdware!!! (a bit off topic) Bhai Buddhu Shah - send soldiers to Guru Gobind Singh Ji - Guru ji never asked any of these sevadars to convert - what a shame that we tend to force people to convert before even allowing them to smell the supreme bliss given by reading/singing/listening to kirtan bhull chukk maaf..Harcharan Singh · 06 Feb 2006
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh, Veer Balbir Singh Jeo, "Gurdev sings hir kIrqn mih eyhu mnu jwgY ]1] rhwau ] "har keertan meh ayhu man jaagai. ||1|| rahaa-o." In Hari Keertan this mind awekens. You understand it rwg kIrqn mih eyhu mnu jwgY "rag keertan meh ayhu man jaagai." In Raag Keertan this mind awakens." At last we are getting somewhere now. Hari Kirtan - kirtan with Waheguru in heart, in mind and in speach. There are many ways of performing kirtan, kirtan is not Sikh invention, Muslims (Sufi's) and Hindus have been performing kirtan for an age now. What is the difference between our Kirtan and theirs? Guru Ji has given us bani and structured it in with Kirtan in mind. Hence giving us tools and choruses and stress points and taals.... You now very well how important Kirtan is in Sikhi, there are hundreds of references to it's importance in bani. All this discussion has been about to put it in to one line is: Do you want to kirtan in Guru's way or do you want to do kirtan in your way? There is no arguement or contraversy, it is an individuals choice. Akaal Purkh di kirpa de naal, it won't be a choice for long when it comes to Gurdwarai. Efforts are being and will continue to be made to re-introduce compulsory Guru Ji's Pardaareth Raag Kirtan back in to Guru Ji's ghar. So please, let us leave it at this, you do kirtan your way, and let those of us who wish to, do Kirtan in our Guru's way. Dhanvaadh. Sat Sri Akaalummm · 06 Feb 2006
Veer Harcharan singh, even though I agree with the raag concept, one thing that annoyed me and still does to this day, is the lack of respect prof surinder singh had for the printed shabad, I distinctly remember at one of his group performance's the shabad printout lay in the feet of the musicians (i call them that), for me have all the raag you want, have the best instruments to sing with but once you cross the line of putting the printed shabad on the floor in your feet, forget it, raag or no raag, satkar is not there, no satkar no pyaar, in other words just musicians, and yes I went and mentioned this to the professor and he just blanked me as though it didn't matter and wasn't a big deal, I never bothered with this man again and still won't. So before you go around telling sangat about this man's pyaar etc, I will also point out the truth. Nothing more than a musician. Bhul Chuk maf kara....Balbir Singh · 06 Feb 2006
Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal! Dear All! Gurdev begins Baanee with JAP. It becomes Simran of God's Name also known as Shabad or Mantar. God's Wisdom is visualized by human beings through Jap and Simran received from the Sat Guru. The true Hari Keertan begins. The expression of Hari's praise is a unique art of the individual. He conveys Truth singing or in silence. The rest of the world may analyze and call it classical or primitive, it does not matter. There are many who learn to express God in a special way prejudicing their method to be the best. Truth is not learnt. The Gurus transfers truth through Jap. True Sikhs then live whole life singing praise of Hari. In Kaljug, Raagees learn singing to earn truth of Maya. They have nothing to do with Jap and its truth. I wish I could hear once THEIR praise for Hari from these imitators. The Guru's Baanee refers such Raagees with these Hymns. [gurbani]gwvih gIqy cIiq AnIqy ][/gurbani] "gaavahi geetay cheet aneetay." Sing songs with wicked consciousness. [gurbani]rwg suxwie khwvih bIqy ][/gurbani] "raag sunaa-ay kahaaveh beetay." Sings Raags, call him divine. [gurbani]ibnu nwvY min JUTu AnIqy ]1][/gurbani] "bin naavai man jhooth aneetay. ||1||" SGGS Ang 414-15 Without Naam mind is false and wicked. This may not be the case of Harcharan Singh Ji. I do not know why he is canvassing for Raag Keertan in a way like it is a technique to realize truth. The Gurus have nowhere suggested the importance of Keertan to begin with it to realize God. Please be sure. I am not criticizing Raagees because they are earning their life and fame by singing. It is surprising. Everybody is born with the seed of complete God's Wisdom. The Rare seed becomes a tree and gives fruits. Love. Balbir Singh [%sig%]Harcharan Singh · 06 Feb 2006
Balbir Singh, Your words speak for themself. You are a politician. You select tuks, quote and interpret them out of context with rest of the shabad. You talk with politeness and of love on one hand, whilst calling raagi's imitators (generalizing), trying to prove the uselessness of kirtan while actually having zero understanding of it or it's anand, you are insulting millions of Gur-Sikh who have follwed in the footsteps of their Guru's by calling them by saying that they do not express their love in a "unique" fashion. But most upsettingly, you are a judgmental, twisted, confused individual. Japping naam is just as useless as dong Guru's raag kirtan if you can not get rid of your pride and of being judgemental. Where do you get off quoting: "gaavahi geetay cheet aneetay." Sing songs with wicked consciousness. "raag sunaa-ay kahaaveh beetay." Sings Raags, call him divine. "bin naavai man jhooth aneetay. ||1||" SGGS Ang 414-15 Without Naam mind is false and wicked. Who are you to say who this refers and who it doesn't refer to. How dare you generalise all raagi's into this category? You say: In Kaljug, Raagees learn singing to earn truth of Maya. They have nothing to do with Jap and its truth. I wish I could hear once THEIR praise for Hari from these imitators. The Guru's Baanee refers such Raagees with these Hymns. and then say I am not criticizing Raagees because they are earning their life and fame by singing. Your talking nonsense and contradicting yourself. I am sorry if I sound upset and possibly rude, I am no saint, but you seemed to be either bored or have possibly had a bad experience trying to learn kirtan, either, stop wasting your time condeming raagis, they are not all bad. And for your information, many raagis do not earn their money from singing, they do kirtan (like every Gur-Sikh does) in their own time, after work. This discussion is not about people who make money. Lastly you said "I do not know why he is canvassing for Raag Keertan in a way like it is a technique to realize truth." You call it raag kirtan, to me it is simply Guru's kirtan. How do you think Guru Nanak Dev Ji drew people to realise the "truth"? Why do think Bhai Mardana was with Guru Ji for so many years? Why do think our Guru's held a Kirtan darbaar where ever they were? Why do you think the Sri Guru Granth Sahib is structured around raag? Why did our Guru's invent the most beautiful sounding instruments in the world? Why do our Guru's say (please make sure you read everything): Page 363, Line 3 ਕਰਣੀ ਕੀਰਤਿ ਨਾਮੁ ਵਸਾਈ ॥ करणी कीरति नामु वसाई ॥ karnee keerat naam vasaa-ee. Singing the Kirtan of the Lord's Praises, the Naam abides within the mind. Guru Amar Das Page 400, Line 18 ਸੂਖ ਸਹਜ ਆਨਦੁ ਘਣਾ ਹਰਿ ਕੀਰਤਨੁ ਗਾਉ ॥ सूख सहज आनदु घणा हरि कीरतनु गाउ ॥ sookh sahj aanad ghanaa har keertan gaa-o. Peace, celestial poise and absolute bliss are obtained, singing the Kirtan of the Lord's Praises. Guru Arjan Dev Page 446, Line 2 ਗੁਰ ਸਬਦੁ ਕਮਾਇਆ ਅਉਖਧੁ ਹਰਿ ਪਾਇਆ ਹਰਿ ਕੀਰਤਿ ਹਰਿ ਸਾਂਤਿ ਪਾਇ ਜੀਉ ॥ गुर सबदु कमाइआ अउखधु हरि पाइआ हरि कीरति हरि सांति पाइ जीउ ॥ gur sabad kamaa-i-aa a-ukhaDh har paa-i-aa har keerat har saaNt paa-ay jee-o. Acting in accordance with the Word of the Guru's Shabad, the medicine of the Lord's Name is obtained. Singing the Kirtan of the Lord's Praises, divine peace is obtained. Guru Ram Das Page 453, Line 15 ਮਿਟੇ ਦੂਖ ਕਲਿਆਣ ਕੀਰਤਨ ਬਹੁੜਿ ਜੋਨਿ ਨ ਪਾਵਾ ॥ मिटे दूख कलिआण कीरतन बहुड़ि जोनि न पावा ॥ mitay dookh kali-aan keertan bahurh jon na paavaa. Suffering departs, and there is peace; singing the Kirtan of the Lord's Praises, one is not consigned to reincarnation again. Guru Arjan Dev Page 454, Line 18 ਕਰਿ ਕੀਰਤਿ ਗੋਵਿੰਦ ਗੁਣੀਐ ਸਗਲ ਪ੍ਰਾਛਤ ਦੁਖ ਹਰੇ ॥ करि कीरति गोविंद गुणीऐ सगल प्राछत दुख हरे ॥ kar keerat govind gunee-ai sagal paraachhat dukh haray. Sing the Kirtan, the Praises of the Lord of the Universe, and all sins and sorrows shall depart. Guru Arjan Dev Page 498, Line 7 ਸਾਧਸੰਗਿ ਨਾਨਕ ਬੁਧਿ ਪਾਈ ਹਰਿ ਕੀਰਤਨੁ ਆਧਾਰੋ ॥ साधसंगि नानक बुधि पाई हरि कीरतनु आधारो ॥ saaDhsang naanak buDh paa-ee har keertan aaDhaaro. In the Saadh Sangat, the Company of the Holy, Nanak has obtained understanding; singing the Kirtan of the Lord's Praises is his only support. Guru Arjan Dev Page 498, Line 13 ਜਪ ਤਪ ਸੰਜਮ ਕਰਮ ਧਰਮ ਹਰਿ ਕੀਰਤਨੁ ਜਨਿ ਗਾਇਓ ॥ जप तप संजम करम धरम हरि कीरतनु जनि गाइओ ॥ jap tap sanjam karam Dharam har keertan jan gaa-i-o. The Lord's servant sings the Kirtan of His Praises as his worship, deep meditation, self-discipline and religious observances. Guru Arjan Dev Page 502, Line 8 ਗੁਰ ਗਿਆਨ ਕੀਰਤਨ ਗੋਬਿੰਦ ਰਮਣੰ ਕਾਟੀਐ ਜਮ ਜਾਲ ॥੨॥ गुर गिआन कीरतन गोबिंद रमणं काटीऐ जम जाल ॥२॥ gur gi-aan keertan gobind ramnaN kaatee-ai jam jaal. ||2|| Through the Guru's spiritual wisdom, we sing the Kirtan of the Praises of the Lord of the Universe, and the noose of death is cut away. ||2|| Guru Arjan Dev Page 502, Line 8 ਗੁਰ ਗਿਆਨ ਕੀਰਤਨ ਗੋਬਿੰਦ ਰਮਣੰ ਕਾਟੀਐ ਜਮ ਜਾਲ ॥੨॥ गुर गिआन कीरतन गोबिंद रमणं काटीऐ जम जाल ॥२॥ gur gi-aan keertan gobind ramnaN kaatee-ai jam jaal. ||2|| Through the Guru's spiritual wisdom, we sing the Kirtan of the Praises of the Lord of the Universe, and the noose of death is cut away. ||2|| Guru Arjan Dev - view Shabad/Paurhi/Salok Page 506, Line 18 ਮਨ ਰੇ ਹਰਿ ਕੀਰਤਿ ਤਰੁ ਤਾਰੀ ॥ मन रे हरि कीरति तरु तारी ॥ man ray har keerat tar taaree. O my mind, the Kirtan of the Lord's Praise is a boat to carry you across. Guru Ram Das Page 592, Line 8 ਜਿਨ ਕੰਉ ਸਤਿਗੁਰੁ ਭੇਟਿਆ ਸੇ ਹਰਿ ਕੀਰਤਿ ਸਦਾ ਕਮਾਹਿ ॥ जिन कंउ सतिगुरु भेटिआ से हरि कीरति सदा कमाहि ॥ jin kaN-u satgur bhayti-aa say har keerat sadaa kamaahi. Those who meet the True Guru, ever sing the Kirtan of the Lord's Praises. Guru Amar Das Page 613, Line 6 ਪੇਖਿ ਨਿਕਟਿ ਕਰਿ ਸੇਵਾ ਸਤਿਗੁਰ ਹਰਿ ਕੀਰਤਨਿ ਹੀ ਤ੍ਰਿਪਤਾਵੈ ॥ ਰਹਾਉ ॥ पेखि निकटि करि सेवा सतिगुर हरि कीरतनि ही त्रिपतावै ॥ रहाउ ॥ paykh nikat kar sayvaa satgur har keertan hee tariptaavai. rahaa-o. Beholding the Lord near at hand, he serves the True Guru, and he is satisfied through the Kirtan of the Lord's Praises. ||Pause|| Guru Arjan Dev I am trying to promote kirtan. Guru Ji's kirtan. Stop having an issue with that and implying all raagi's/kirtanis have evil minds, you have implied I possibly have, thank you for that - it doesn't bother me what you think, you are not Dharam Raj, my Guru can see what my mind and intentions. If kirtan is not for you fine or didn't work out for you, fine, I'm sorry. But stop trying to drag eveyone else away by changing the subject to the importance of simran, that is not the discussion. You are patronising and judging people by implying kirtan or raag is pointless, how do you know who does naam simran or not? I know, and so does the sangat, how important naam japna is. It's not a competition. People don't have to decide between the two, we have been ordered to do both, the two can be one and the same or different. AGAIN, the real question is simply, Guru's raag or kachaa raag. All music is raag - rang - colour - emotion. We all choose which we want to listen to. Your choice. Be happy, and let us be happy. Wahehuru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh Harcharan SinghBalbir Singh · 06 Feb 2006
Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal! Veer Harcharan Singh Ji! Thanks for giving me so many titles. I hope you have become little poorer by losing few defective words from your treasure. I felt up to now that you were doing Alaap and singing in a particular Raag. What happened suddenly? You started missing soft notes of your Bhairavee. Nothing else is important to look at while doing true Hari Keertan. You may first come to know him. We can then compete who finds more deficiencies in Balbir Singh. ************** It is great to get busy with Guru's Shabads any way through anybody. The references from the Guru's Baanee you have provided can bring anyone in exaltation of truth but not the translations. Why have you consulted the borrowed translations? Can't you express the taste of Truth yourself? When a person becomes humble requesting Gurdev for the taste of Truth, he is immediately transformed into the Gur Sikh. I remember someone's proud of being an imitator again. To become an imitator one needs the original God who can be imitated. The duality remains from the eyes of an imitator. God's view is ONE. The unique ONE is without imitators. ************** In the universe there is only one celebrity. He is God. The more one recognizes HIM the more he comes to know Hari Keerat. The translation you have provided of Hari Keerat is not the Raag Keertan, singing of notes. Also, the true praise of the Guru, Wahe Guru, is possible only after receiving the True Shabad Guru. Similarly the praise of Hari, Hari Keertan, is possible only after receiving the True Hari Naam. God cannot be tasted by imitating. Blessed are those who have forgotten imitating God. There is nobody left to imitate. Love. Balbir Singh [%sig%]Harcharan Singh · 07 Feb 2006
Pray Truth for Veer Balbir Singh Ji and say Satsriakal! Veer ji, Thanks for giving me so many titles. I hope you have become little poorer by losing few defective words from your treasure. ----------- The words were not defective, they were factual, and do some times need to be used. I am none the poorer, saying twisted was probably undeserved, so, Maafi Chonda for that. I felt up to now that you were doing Alaap and singing in a particular Raag. What happened suddenly? You started missing soft notes of your Bhairavee. ------------ Looking up a few words associated with raag and using them completely out of context (again), is doing not doing your objectiveless mission any favours. Nothing else is important to look at while doing true Hari Keertan. You may first come to know him. We can then compete who finds more deficiencies in Balbir Singh. ------------ Veerji, that must mean that you have come to know him very well, as you have found so many deficencies in me, kirtani and raagis, who all apparently have wicked/false minds and consciousness. It is great to get busy with Guru's Shabads any way through anybody. The references from the Guru's Baanee you have provided can bring anyone in exaltation of truth but not the translations. Why have you consulted the borrowed translations? Can't you express the taste of Truth yourself? ------------- Veerji, how did you 1st translate, did you have a "unique" mystical experience and all (Gurmukhi, santhiaa, veechar, aarth, parchaar) was revealed to you? Did you never consult anyone for explanation, translation, did you never seek any Gur-sikhs help? When a person becomes humble requesting Gurdev for the taste of Truth, he is immediately transformed into the Gur Sikh. ---------------- Yes. Let's pray that this happens to us both. I remember someone's proud of being an imitator again. To become an imitator one needs the original God who can be imitated. The duality remains from the eyes of an imitator. God's view is ONE. The unique ONE is without imitators. ----------------- Thanks for your judgemental comments again. I was not aware you had the monopoly on the original God. And, you 1st say "To become an imitator one needs the original God who can be imitated" and then say "The unique ONE is without imitators" Make up your mind Veer ji, and with all due respect, stop chasing your tail. In the universe there is only one celebrity. He is God. The more one recognizes HIM the more he comes to know Hari Keerat. The translation you have provided of Hari Keerat is not the Raag Keertan, singing of notes. Also, the true praise of the Guru, Wahe Guru, is possible only after receiving the True Shabad Guru. Similarly the praise of Hari, Hari Keertan, is possible only after receiving the True Hari Naam. God cannot be tasted by imitating. Blessed are those who have forgotten imitating God. There is nobody left to imitate. -------------------- You seem to have a chip on your shoulder with Guru Ji's raag, your choice. What you state is your singular opinion, thats all. Again you are repeating yourself, and talking about kirtan being useless without naam, NO ONE IS DISAGREEING, we have agreed and established that. You cannot redeem your slandering, judgemental, unresearched, pointless argument by repeatedly stating the obvious as if IT is the subject in question. Who is trying to imitate God? You've really left the track and wondered off into the woods! Do you not wear 5 kakaar, do you not wear a Daari and Dastaar, do you not do your NITNEM, do you not mathaa tek to Guru Ji, do you not speak Punjabi, do you not do ardaas, do you not try and do parchaar, do you not balaa Fateh???? If you don't, only then can you claim not to be an imitator. Sat Sri AkaalBalbir Singh · 07 Feb 2006
Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal! Veer Harcharan Singh Ji! You complained ": . . as you have found so many deficencies in me, kirtani and raagis, who all apparently have wicked/false minds and consciousness." God spoke through the Gurus. They recognized God and His creation too. Raagees, Naadees etc. are also God's creatures. All the references provided by me are from Gurdev. I only requested all to be little attentive. Please listen what Guru Nanak Ji is singing. [gurbani]rwig nwid mnu dUjY Bwie ][/gurbani] "raag naad man doojai bhaa-ay." Raag and Naad are mind's duality, brother. [gurbani]AMqir kptu mhw duKu pwie ][/gurbani] "antar kapat mahaa dukh paa-ay." Inside deception receives big sufferings. The Gurus never suggested us to repeat their Hymns and sing those in Raags. Please provide an instruction from Gurbaanee for singing in a particular Raags. They suggested only one way to achieve consciousness. That is receiving Naam meeting the Sat Guru. [gurbani]siqguru BytY soJI pwie ][/gurbani] "satgur bhaytai sojhee paa-ay." Meeting Sat Guru consciousness is achieved. [gurbani]scY nwim rhY ilv lwie ]4][/gurbani] "sachai naam rahai liv laa-ay. ||4||" SGGS Ang 1342-7 Live remaining tuned with true Naam. ************** I found many references from the Guru's Baanee about worldly business carried by different professional people. Sansaar and its Maya are also Godly. And so is everything of it. Maya is also endless like God. Still true values are precious as those are stable. Maya and its values are ever changing. Gurdev sings [gurbani]sBnw rwgW ivic so Blw BweI ijqu visAw min Awie ][/gurbani] "sabhnaa raagaaN vich so bhalaa bhaa-ee jit vasi-aa man aa-ay." From all Raags one is ideal, brother! That resides within mind. [gurbani]rwgu nwdu sBu scu hY kImiq khI n jwie ][/gurbani] "raag naad sabh sach hai keemat kahee na jaa-ay." Raag, Naad is all true their value cannot be said. [gurbani]rwgY nwdY bwhrw ienI hukmu n bUiJAw jwie ][/gurbani] "raagai naadai baahraa inee hukam na boojhi-aa jaa-ay." Raags and Naads are outwardly, from these, Hukam is not recognized. [gurbani]nwnk hukmY bUJY iqnw rwis hoie siqgur qy soJI pwie ][/gurbani] "naanak hukmai boojhai tinaa raas ho-ay satgur tay sojhee paa-ay." Nanak! Who recognize Hukam they get treasure, consciousness is received through Sat Guru. [gurbani]sBu ikCu iqs qy hoieAw ijau iqsY dI rjwie ]24][/gurbani] "sabh kichh tis tay ho-i-aa ji-o tisai dee rajaa-ay. ||24||" SGGS Ang 1423-19 All happens per HIS Will and HIS Accordance. ************** The topic here is not Balbir Singh. Please do not waste life analyzing a marionette. Love. Balbir Singh [%sig%]Harmanjit singh · 07 Feb 2006
Keertan is keertan whether sung by Sikh or Non sikh. It is the same bani of guruji. Bhai Chaman lal sung Keertan so many years and people enjoyed it when he do keertan. I do remember my father told me that some one Non Sikh was doing PAATH OF SUKHMANI SAHIB every day with devotion and one day Guru Arjan Dev ji appered to him and asked him to start keertan. The person said that I never sung and I don't know about keertan. Guruji said you just start I will sit on your tong.( Rasna te birajman) He started keertan and my father told me that they never heared keertan after him. My fathre just passed away few months back son not able to tell his name. For Guruji everyone is same,it is we people who are going against his wishes to accept that Manas ke jat sabe eko pehchanbo. Harmanjit singh [%sig%]Harcharan Singh · 08 Feb 2006
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh, Veer Ji, You say: "The Gurus never suggested us to repeat their Hymns and sing those in Raags. Please provide an instruction from Gurbaanee for singing in a particular Raags." Ok, in that case you must be suggesting we make our own hymns (kachi bani) and sing in kache raag, if we wish to sing our love to Waheguru. Our Guru's sang their predecesors hymns, so why can't we. Do you understand the concept of role models? Veer ji, if the format of the Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji isn't enough instruction for you I don't know what is, our Guru's expected us to have some common sense. I have already explained your misinterpretation of these quotes. You conveniantly ignore them and keep repeating yourself again. Jup So Dar So Purakh Sohila Siree Raag Raag Maajh Raag Gauree Raag Aasaa Raag Goojaree Raag Dayv-Gandhaaree Raag Bihaagra Raag Wadahans Raag Sorat'h Raag Dhanaasaree Raag Jaitsree Raag Todee Raag Bairaaree Raag Tilang Raag Soohee Raag Bilaaval Raag Gond Raag Raamkalee Raag Nat Naaraayan Raag Maale Gaaura Raag Maaroo Raag Tukhaari Raag Kaydaaraa Raag Bhairao Raag Basant Raag Saarang Raag Malaar Raag Kaanraa Raag Kalyaan Raag Prabhaatee Raag Jaijaavantee Shalok Sehskritee, First Mehl & Fifth Mehl Fifth Mehl, Gaat'haa Phunhay, Fifth Mehl Chaubolas, Fifth Mehl Shaloks of Devotee Kabeer Jee Shaloks of Shaykh Fareed Jee Swaiyas from the Mouth of the Great Fifth Mehl Shaloks in addition to the Vaars Shalok, Ninth Mehl Mundaavanee, Fifth Mehl & Raag Maalaa At no point have I suggested that learning raag is going to give you mukti. Raag is a divine tool, which helps us to express our love to Akaal Purkh in kirtan format recommended by our Guru's as evidenced above. "The topic here is not Balbir Singh. Please do not waste life analyzing a marionette." The topic here is also not people who wish to make use of their Guru's divinely gifted raags in order to follow Guru Ji's hundreds of hukums in Gurbani instructing us to sing Hari Kirtan. The pot calling the kettle black. Could you please summarise in 2 sentances, clearly, concisely and to the point, without trying to be philosophical, what exatly you have been trying to say? My point has been simply this: I believe Kirtan should be done in Guru Ji's raag, because what musical accompyment and composition could be better than Guru Ji's? Sat Sri AkaalBalbir Singh · 08 Feb 2006
Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal! Veer Harcharan Singh Ji! The art of singing is a natural gift from God. This does not degrade other human beings. Singing is also not a reason to feel privileged to meet Truth of God before others. Any singer, who feels that by learning Raags and singing the Guru's Baanee is a faster track, has gone astray. Such singers learn Raags with an illusion of ego. At least they earn means of living, name and fame if they miss God. It is the resolute adherence of ego's own ideas and desires. It never allows a person to the wisdom of true Naam. Gurbaanee says [gurbani]scw AlK AByau hiT n pqIjeI ][/gurbani] "sachaa alakh abhay-o hath na pateeja-ee." The True, Unseen, Without Happenings is not reached by bullheadedness. [gurbani]ieik gwvih rwg prIAw rwig n BIjeI ][/gurbani] "ik gaavahi raag paree-aa raag na bheej-ee." One sings Raags, by sheltering Raag one is not submitted. This is why the Gurus never promoted Keertan as the first step to the Truth. Rather they make us aware where Raags and Naads may lead a singer to. For singers also, as for every Jeev, the first and most important step is Jap of true Naam. Every Jeev is born with an ability, a capability and an art of living. This ripens with true Simran received from the Sat Guru. God is not to be sung alone by classical singers. God is activated in all movements of the cosmos. Everyone may enliven Him completely. Simran is the first step put forward with God's Grace. Love. Balbir Singh [%sig%]priceless · 08 Feb 2006
bai balbir sieha, manu lagda hei ke tu na kedna naa khedan dena, bas khuti ch ... ... ... vali gal farri hoyee hei. naach na janei aangan dheda vali gal siyaaniyaa vali gal nahi hei jei kuch hasal karna hei merei baiji. Jis tara guru sihab ne gayiya te gaun vaste hukum likh ditta, Guru dee alahi bani dei kirtan da asli anand iss to ziada hor kivei mil sakda hei guru da hukum manan valei sikh nu. mere varga bandar moorkh kiya jane adrak daa suwad hath naa pujei thoo kouri valiyaan galaan cho kuch nahi labnaa, guru dei pai poorniyaa te chalan de kosis karo baiji. man rae gur ki kaar kamaei, gur kai bhaanai jae chalehi ta anadin raachehi har naei ho guramukh kaar kamaavaa jei gur samajhaeai [%sig%]Balbir Singh · 08 Feb 2006
Satsriakal to all and Priceless Ji! Zaraa eh ta dasso tuhaanoo GuraaN ne kithay te kidda samjhaayaa ke sab sikhaaN noo Guru di baanee, jo sri guru granth sahib ji vich darz hai, dohraanee hai. Kirpaa karoo ji guru ji da koee vaak te sunaa-o ji. Dhanvaad. Balbir SinghHarcharan Singh · 09 Feb 2006
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh, Veer Balbir Singh ji..... You are repeating the same point in 10 different ways, a point which enlightens no one, as it has already been stated numerous times previously and never needed to be stated in the 1st place as it was commonsensical to start with. For the umpteenth time, WE ALREADY KNOW KIRTAN, RAAG OR NOT, HAS NO VALUE UNLESS ONE MEDITATES ON AKAAL PURKH. Now please stop using this same point againa and again to justify your own personal problem with the singing of Kirtan in Guru Ji's method. Next: "The art of singing is a natural gift from God. This does not degrade other human beings. ------- There is a difference between singing and Hari Kirtan, please stop confusing the 2. Singing is also not a reason to feel privileged to meet Truth of God before others." ------ ay satgur boli-aa mai pichhai keertan kari-ahu nirbaan jee-o. Finally, the True Guru said, "When I am gone, sing Kirtan in Praise of the Lord, in Nirvaanaa". It is not for us to feel priviledged or JUDGE others, it for us to follow our Guru's hukum only. "Any singer, who feels that by learning Raags and singing the Guru's Baanee is a faster track, has gone astray. Such singers learn Raags with an illusion of ego. At least they earn means of living, name and fame if they miss God." -------- 2 points: 1 - Any Guru da Sikh who takes their faith seriously and puts in the effort to learn and perform kirtan (raag or non raag depending on resources) out of their love for Waheguru IS ON A FAST TRACK. You have this sordid idea in your mind that one can either choose simran or kirtan in life?? It may come as a huge surprise to you, but a person can actually do both, and nearly all, do both! aas pi-aas raman har keertan ayhu padaarath bhaagvant lahai. ||1|| Hope and desire to sing the Kirtan of the Lord's Praises - this is the treasure of the most fortunate devotees. 2 - You keep on stereo-typing Gur-sikhs who learn and sing Guru da kirtan, by implying that they do it for money and fame. Shame on you for again being so judgemental. The huge majority of Gur-sikh learn raag kirtan to follow Guru Ji's hukum and do not make any money, they do kirtan out of pure love and it forms part of their maryada and riaz: How would you like it if I kept classing you in this category: urjhi-o kanak kaamnee kay ras nah keerat parabh gaa-ee. ||1|| rahaa-o. I am entangled in the love of gold and women, and I have not sung the Kirtan of God's Praises. "It is the resolute adherence of ego's own ideas and desires. It never allows a person to the wisdom of true Naam." ----------- Well actually: sukh-daata dukh bhanjanhaaraa gaa-o keertan pooran gi-aan. Sing the Kirtan, the Praises of the Lord, the Giver of peace, the Destroyer of pain; He shall bless you with perfect spiritual wisdom. This is why the Gurus never promoted Keertan as the first step to the Truth. Rather they make us aware where Raags and Naads may lead a singer to. ------- You are really digging your hole deeper..... mahaa anand keertan har sunee-aa. ||3|| Listening to the Kirtan of the Lord's Praises, I am in absolute ecstasy. ||3|| Guru Arjan Dev AND aas pi-aas raman har keertan ayhu padaarath bhaagvant lahai. ||1|| Hope and desire to sing the Kirtan of the Lord's Praises - this is the treasure of the most fortunate devotees. ||1|| AND kathaa keertan raag naad Dhun ih bani-o su-aa-o. This is my life's purpose, to sing the Kirtan of the Lord's Praises, and listen to the vibrations of the sound current of the Naad. For singers also, as for every Jeev, the first and most important step is Jap of true Naam. -------- sarab Dharam maano tih kee-ay jih parabh keerat gaa-ee. ||2|| Understand, that whoever sings the Kirtan of God's Praises, has performed all religious rituals. ||2|| Every Jeev is born with an ability, a capability and an art of living. This ripens with true Simran received from the Sat Guru. ------------ vadai bhaag parabh keertan gaa-i-aa. By great good fortune, one sings the Kirtan of God's Praises. God is not to be sung alone by classical singers. God is activated in all movements of the cosmos. --------- Veer ji, why do you keep refering to classical singers, please stop doing this. This discussion is about Guru Ji ga Pardaareth Raag Kirtan. Not entertaining classical singers, which seems to be your only experience of kirtan, I would advise you to get out more. And lastly I would do vichaar on this, Guru Ji's hukum: ramnaN kayvlaN keeratanaN suDharmaN dayh Dhaarnah. To sing the Kirtan of God's Praises is the righteous duty incurred by taking birth in this human body. And then do an ardaas, ask for his forgivenss, put your personal experiences/prejudices aside and try doing kirtan and realising the true ANAND, which is gained in singing your love to your holy master. If you can get over the problem you seem to have with imitating people, then may be the next step could be performing kirtan in Guru Ji's hukmi raag, and realising the ultimate anand in kirtan. You can bring no arguement to this most commonsencial point: Performing kirtan with a desire for naam, using Guru Ji's divine saaj (designed for the sole purpose of helping Sikhs perform kirtan to the most beautiful sounds in teh world), using Guru Ji's hukmi raah (to ensure we do not become engrossed in haumai by doing kirtan to our composed tunes or copying the tunes learnt from watching filthy bollywood or bhangra videos) as well as ensuring that the emotion we create represents the true meaning of the shabad and not our personal interpretation i.e. jumping around to Lakh Kushiyan Pathshayiyan, when Guru Ji has stressed the reason for this shabad is mere mun. Again please do not misinterprate/mis-apply gurbani to suit your lack of experience of Guru Kirtan Anand. The raag, naad and songs Guru Ji talks of the many tuks you have quoted refer to classical singers, egotistical singers and those who do it for fame and wealth. NOT TO THOSE WHO SIMPLY WANT TO EXPRESS THEIR PYAAR TO WAHEGURU. If we were to apply your logic, then it could be said that you fall into this category: ਕਹਾ ਭਯੋ ਜੋ ਦੋਉ ਲੋਚਨ ਮੂੰਦ ਕੈ ਬੈਠਿ ਰਹਿਓ ਬਕ ਧਿਆਨ ਲਗਾਇਓ ॥ Of what use it is if one sits and meditates like a crane with his eyes closed. ਨ੍ਹਾਤ ਫਿਰਿਓ ਲੀਏ ਸਾਤ ਸਮੁਦ੍ਰਨਿ ਲੋਕ ਗਯੋ ਪਰਲੋਕ ਗਵਾਇਓ ॥ If he takes bath at holy places upto the seventh sea, he loses this world and also the next world. ਬਾਸ ਕੀਓ ਬਿਖਿਆਨ ਸੋ ਬੈਠ ਕੈ ਐਸੇ ਹੀ ਐਸੇ ਸੁ ਬੈਸ ਬਿਤਾਇਓ ॥ He spends his life in such performing evil actions and wastes his life in such pursuits. I, unlike you, am not suggesting that all who meditate are fake. I am simply using this as an example of how you are using Guru Ji's bani which was aimed at entertainers/fakers, to attack everyone who is trying with an honest intention to follow their Guru Ji's hukum. I pray you will now not repeat your naam jap Vs kirtan posts, stop stereo-typing all raag/kirtani, and accept the fact that most kirtani/raagi find the desire to do kirtan through Waheguru's kirpa and that they are naam jappan wala Gur-Sikh. This post has never been about performers/entertainers. WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA WAHEGURU JI KI FATEHsingh · 09 Feb 2006
1 question to bhai harcharan singh. Do u believe anyone who does kirtan in non-title raag is going against Guruji?? Do u believe every kirtani who doesnt sing in title raag performs bollywood and filmy tunes??Balbir Singh · 09 Feb 2006
Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal! Veer Harcharan Singh Ji! It is nice to hear these words "WE ALREADY KNOW KIRTAN, RAAG OR NOT, HAS NO VALUE UNLESS ONE MEDITATES ON AKAAL PURKH." At least you pretended to understand when you wrote "There is a difference between singing and Hari Kirtan, please stop confusing the 2." I am not sure if you have truly understood Guru's Vaaks. All the references you have provided from Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji are not complete. You have avoided the most important portions of Guru's Shabads. Let us go through some of those. You referred to Baba Sunder Ji's wonderful Shabad [gurbani]AMqy siqguru boilAw mY ipCY kIrqnu kirAhu inrbwxu jIau ][/gurbani] "antay satgur boli-aa mai pichhai keertan kari-ahu nirbaan jee-o." SGGS Ang 923-15 At the end Sat Guru spoke "I after that did Keertan without sound Jee-o" BaarN [gurbani]bwxu[/gurbani] is sound produced through the mouth. And NirbaarN means 'without sound'. Nirbaarn does not mean 'nirvaanaa' as you have mentioned. With true Simran, one steeps into silence. May I ask why have you overseen the next line [gurbani]kyso gopwl pMifq sidAhu hir hir kQw pVih purwxu jIau ][/gurbani] "kayso gopaal pandit sadi-ahu har har kathaa parheh puraan jee-o." Kayshav, Gopal and Pandit said Hari Hari Kathaa and read Puraarn Jee-o. The above great Shabad from Baba Sunder Ji mentions basic requirements in the beginning to achieve the NirbaarN Pad. These are [gurbani]gur sbid smwvey Avru n jwxY koie jIau ][/gurbani] "gur sabad samaav-ay avar na jaanai ko-ay jee-o." Gur Shabad merges. Any other is not known Jee-o. [gurbani]Avro n jwxih sbid gur kY eyku nwmu iDAwvhy ][/gurbani] "avro na jaaneh sabad gur kai ayk naam Dhi-aavhay." Nothing else knows than Gur Shabad, contemplates one Naam. Veer Ji, please ponder over it. How does one get time to show his talent for singing when he is all the time contemplating one Gurshabad? ************** You seem to get bored when you write sentences like "You are repeating the same point in 10 different ways, a point which enlightens no one, as it has already been stated numerous times previously and never needed to be stated in the 1st place as it was commonsensical to start with." And "Now please stop using this same point againa and again to justify your own personal problem with the singing of Kirtan in Guru Ji's method." Gurdev started with JAP. Today also HE is giving uninterruptedly the message of JAP. Have you ever wondered why? I have only tried to bring everybody's attention toward it. ************** You wrote "How would you like it if I kept classing you in this category" and mentioned Guru Teg Bahadur Ji's Vaak [gurbani]auriJE knk kwmnI ky rs nh kIriq pRB gweI ]1] rhwau ][/gurbani] "urjhi-o kanak kaamnee kay ras nah keerat parabh gaa-ee. ||1|| rahaa-o" SGGS Ang 718-6 Got entangled in taste of attractive wishes, did not sing celebrity of God. Guru Teg Bahadur Ji sang this Vaak about Him. The line just before this is [gurbani]khau khw ApnI ADmweI ][/gurbani] "kaha-o kahaa apnee aDhmaa-ee." I say where is my own half mother (deficiency)? Veer Ji. These words are from Gurdev for Him. Please do not crown those on me. ************** It does not interest me who sings the Guru's Hymns and how. He may be a Raagee, Naadee, Vedee, Paapee or Pathee. Most important is that Gurdev's messages reach me every time and remember me of Simran. ************** All the references you have provided from Gurbaanee are about praise (Keertan) and celebrity (Keerat) of Hari (Prabhu). Those do not suggest taking a music instrument (vaajaa) in hand and start tuning the throat with it. Strange you could not provide one reference from Gurdev where They suggested us to imitate them or repeat their Hymns to reach God. Instead you go on blowing horn "The huge majority of Gur-sikh learn raag kirtan to follow Guru Ji's hukum and do not make any money, they do kirtan out of pure love and it forms part of their maryada and riaz": These are characteristics of Maya. We leave it up to one. He remains a part of Maya. Better surrender all to God and come to know HIM as Sat Guru. Love. Balbir Singh [%sig%]Harcharan Singh · 09 Feb 2006
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh, Veer Singh Ji, I believe it is not for me to judge anyone. I can say, that Guru ji has organised the whole Sri Guru Granth Sahib according to the "mood" of the shabad. They have done this for a reason, and not "some historical reference" as some people believe, every single word represents divine truth, iand has a purpose, it is all Guru di Bani. Veer ji, if you read my earlier posts on this thread, I have already given my understanding as to Gur-Sikhh who may or may not have sung in Guru Ji's pardaarath raag. Our culture and knowledge suffered a great set back during the British Raj, in all spheres, this is known only to well. Mahapurkh like Baba Attar Singh Ji, Baba Nand Singh Ji, Baba Isher Singh Ji Rarawale, I believe sung Kirtan in the way they were taught or they had heard, whatever was resource was available. There is a big difference between the above mentioned Mahapurkh and todays most popular kirtan singers who blatently catch the crowds attention with their well rehearsed bollywood and bhangra tunes. There are many kirtani/gursikh who do not know any better, and learn and perform kirtan with love in their heart to any melody they may have heard shabad sung in, and not even know it's source, I do not think these people are doing anything worng, if they do not know about Guru Ji's raag, it's purpose, it's anand or have no resource, that is no fault of their own. I do have a problem with people who know this knowledge and can make the change, but don't because: It's not cool; the charava won't be as much; their jathaa doesn't do raag, which means it probably isn't important; they are to lazy to learn; they prefer their filmy/pop tunes; they choose to be ignorent; they don't think they have time to learn raag; they don't do kirtan themselves, so don't advocate it...etc In todays age, we have every resource we need. There is no excuse for us. Guru Ji has clearly given us instruction as to which raag the shabad should be sung in, unless we have tried to follow this instruction how could anyone (like people currently posting on this thread) possibly know the bliss to be gained from singing the said shabad in Guru Ji's prescribed format? Guru Ram Daas Ji says: ਸਭਨਾ ਰਾਗਾਂ ਵਿਚਿ ਸੋ ਭਲਾ ਭਾਈ ਜਿਤੁ ਵਸਿਆ ਮਨਿ ਆਇ ॥ सभना रागां विचि सो भला भाई जितु वसिआ मनि आइ ॥ sabhnaa raagaaN vich so bhalaa bhaa-ee jit vasi-aa man aa-ay. Among all Ragas, that one is sublime, O Siblings of Destiny, by which the Lord comes to abide in the mind. ਰਾਗੁ ਨਾਦੁ ਸਭੁ ਸਚੁ ਹੈ ਕੀਮਤਿ ਕਹੀ ਨ ਜਾਇ ॥ रागु नादु सभु सचु है कीमति कही न जाइ ॥ raag naad sabh sach hai keemat kahee na jaa-ay. Those Ragas which are in the Sound-current of the Naad are totally true; their value cannot be expressed. ਰਾਗੈ ਨਾਦੈ ਬਾਹਰਾ ਇਨੀ ਹੁਕਮੁ ਨ ਬੂਝਿਆ ਜਾਇ ॥ रागै नादै बाहरा इनी हुकमु न बूझिआ जाइ ॥ raagai naadai baahraa inee hukam na boojhi-aa jaa-ay. Those Ragas which are not in the Sound-current of the Naad - by these, the Lord's Will cannot be understood. ਨਾਨਕ ਹੁਕਮੈ ਬੂਝੈ ਤਿਨਾ ਰਾਸਿ ਹੋਇ ਸਤਿਗੁਰ ਤੇ ਸੋਝੀ ਪਾਇ ॥ नानक हुकमै बूझै तिना रासि होइ सतिगुर ते सोझी पाइ ॥ naanak hukmai boojhai tinaa raas ho-ay satgur tay sojhee paa-ay. O Nanak, they alone are right, who understand the Will of the True Guru. ਸਭੁ ਕਿਛੁ ਤਿਸ ਤੇ ਹੋਇਆ ਜਿਉ ਤਿਸੈ ਦੀ ਰਜਾਇ ॥੨੪॥ सभु किछु तिस ते होइआ जिउ तिसै दी रजाइ ॥२४॥ sabh kichh tis tay ho-i-aa ji-o tisai dee rajaa-ay. ||24|| Everything happens as He wills. ||24|| It is no coincidence that Guru Ramdaas Ji Maharajs son, Guru Arjun Dev Ji when compiling the Sri Ad Granth Ji, took their fathers hukum literally by organising all the shabad according to correct "naad", so that all Sikhs for all time would be able to understand the shabad not just through intellect, but through emotion. If we try and understand purely through intellect, we see the problem it causes, many different interpretations, but if we try and understand the shabad in the highest form, as our Gurus showed us, through kirtan, using our Guru Ji's Pardaareth raag, we cannot misinterpret the feelings our Guru's expressed when singing their shabad, we can feel exactly what they felt. Veer Singh Ji, Guru Ji clearly says that the ragaswhich are not in naad, will not allow you understand Akaal Purkhs hukum, Guru Ji is talking of speaking to your aathma, Guru Ji's raag provokes the emotion which speaks to your soul, whilst the holy words of the shabad speak to your mind, there must be a balance of both. If music was not important, why is kirtan mentioned so many times in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, why did our Guru's all do kirtan, why spend precious time learning/inventing raag and the perfect instruments to execute the divine raags? Every day you do your NITNEM, do ever make the connection between Ramkali and the Anand Sahib? Guru Amardaas Ji Maharaaj tells us clearly: ਰਾਮਕਲੀ ਮਹਲਾ ੩ ਅਨੰਦੁ रामकली महला ३ अनंदु raamkalee mehlaa 3 anand Raamkalee, Third Mehl, Anand ~ The Song Of Bliss: ੴ ਸਤਿਗੁਰ ਪ੍ਰਸਾਦਿ ॥ ੴ सतिगुर प्रसादि ॥ ik-oNkaar satgur parsaad. One Universal Creator God. By The Grace Of The True Guru: ਅਨੰਦੁ ਭਇਆ ਮੇਰੀ ਮਾਏ ਸਤਿਗੁਰੂ ਮੈ ਪਾਇਆ ॥ अनंदु भइआ मेरी माए सतिगुरू मै पाइआ ॥ anand bha-i-aa mayree maa-ay satguroo mai paa-i-aa. I am in ecstasy, O my mother, for I have found my True Guru. ਸਤਿਗੁਰੁ ਤ ਪਾਇਆ ਸਹਜ ਸੇਤੀ ਮਨਿ ਵਜੀਆ ਵਾਧਾਈਆ ॥ सतिगुरु त पाइआ सहज सेती मनि वजीआ वाधाईआ ॥ satgur ta paa-i-aa sahj saytee man vajee-aa vaaDhaa-ee-aa. I have found the True Guru, with intuitive ease, and my mind vibrates with the music of bliss. ਰਾਗ ਰਤਨ ਪਰਵਾਰ ਪਰੀਆ ਸਬਦ ਗਾਵਣ ਆਈਆ ॥ राग रतन परवार परीआ सबद गावण आईआ ॥ raag ratan parvaar paree-aa sabad gaavan aa-ee-aa. The jewelled melodies and their related celestial harmonies have come to sing the Word of the Shabad. ਸਬਦੋ ਤ ਗਾਵਹੁ ਹਰੀ ਕੇਰਾ ਮਨਿ ਜਿਨੀ ਵਸਾਇਆ ॥ सबदो त गावहु हरी केरा मनि जिनी वसाइआ ॥ sabdo ta gaavhu haree kayraa man jinee vasaa-i-aa. The Lord dwells within the minds of those who sing the Shabad. ਕਹੈ ਨਾਨਕੁ ਅਨੰਦੁ ਹੋਆ ਸਤਿਗੁਰੂ ਮੈ ਪਾਇਆ ॥੧॥ कहै नानकु अनंदु होआ सतिगुरू मै पाइआ ॥१॥ kahai naanak anand ho-aa satguroo mai paa-i-aa. ||1|| Says Nanak, I am in ecstasy, for I have found my True Guru. ||1|| Ramkali is the raag that evokes a very high state of happiness, this is clearly reflected in Guru Ji's words. If we use a sad tune to this raag, would this make sense? If we used a happy tune, or exciting bhangra tune? A fast beat, pulsating, loud tune??? So many interpretations of what this shabad is saying, but to save us the trouble of misunderstanding it, and to truley listen to what our Guru said and HOW he said it, Guru Ji has given us his divine raag, which tells us the tone of his voice, the level of happiness, the state of bliss Guru ji was feeling. I don't beleive anyone can replicate this except Guru Ji, and when Guru Ji speaks to us in the way we have been told to listen we can feel as well as understand what they are saying to us. For those who think that there is no encouragement of or explanation of raag in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, you are wrong. This is just one example of Guru Ji explaining the emotion that is created from singing kirtan in the said raag, in this case raag Sorath: ਰਾਗੁ ਸੋਰਠਿ ਵਾਰ ਮਹਲੇ ੪ ਕੀ रागु सोरठि वार महले ४ की raag sorath vaar mahlay 4 kee Vaar Of Raag Sorat'h, Fourth Mehl: ੴ ਸਤਿਗੁਰ ਪ੍ਰਸਾਦਿ ॥ ੴ सतिगुर प्रसादि ॥ ik-oNkaar satgur parsaad. One Universal Creator God. By The Grace Of The True Guru: ਸਲੋਕੁ ਮਃ ੧ ॥ सलोकु मः १ ॥ salok mehlaa 1. Shalok, First Mehl: ਸੋਰਠਿ ਸਦਾ ਸੁਹਾਵਣੀ ਜੇ ਸਚਾ ਮਨਿ ਹੋਇ ॥ सोरठि सदा सुहावणी जे सचा मनि होइ ॥ sorath sadaa suhaavanee jay sachaa man ho-ay. Sorat'h is always beautiful, if it brings the True Lord to dwell in the mind of the soul-bride. And ਸੋਰਠਿ ਸੋ ਰਸੁ ਪੀਜੀਐ ਕਬਹੂ ਨ ਫੀਕਾ ਹੋਇ ॥ सोरठि सो रसु पीजीऐ कबहू न फीका होइ ॥ sorath so ras peejee-ai kabhoo na feekaa ho-ay. In Raga Sorat'h, drink in this sublime essence, which never loses its taste. ਨਾਨਕ ਰਾਮ ਨਾਮ ਗੁਨ ਗਾਈਅਹਿ ਦਰਗਹ ਨਿਰਮਲ ਸੋਇ ॥੫॥ नानक राम नाम गुन गाईअहि दरगह निरमल सोइ ॥५॥ naanak raam naam gun gaa-ee-ah dargeh nirmal so-ay. ||5|| O Nanak, singing the Glorious Praises of the Lord's Name, one's reputation is immaculate in the Court of the Lord. ||5|| Hope my limited explanation helps.. Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh Harcharan SinghBalbir Singh · 09 Feb 2006
Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal! Veer Harcharan Singh Ji! Thanks for giving again a possibility to read Guru's wonderful Vaaks. Please do not raise the impression that I am against singing Hari Keertan. May it be in Raags from a professional or one who does not know anything about musical notes. From your post one may feel that he is left behind because he does not know anything about Raags. Those also sound like invitation to join a Sangeet Maha Vidyalaya as everyone can learn Raags. Your canvassing for singing Guru's Shabads in classical Raags makes one think that Raags are of prime importance. Is it not that Simran is for everyone? Many people listen to Raagees in Gurudwaras. Do they realize truth at the same time? Or Raagees have realized truth earlier during the rehearsal at home. It is only true Simran that gives the true experience of Truth to all. Be sure one has not come to receive it if this has not happened. I want to clear my point here. Music of any kind is a sensual matter. The joy of music is the joy of mind. Many musicians swear that they feel transcended from their music. But their transcended state is momentary. They seek soon next attempt to reach that state again. All sensual pleasures act and react with mind similarly. Ananda reached through Simran is beyond sensual pleasure. It establishes the state further through Simran. Ananda is also transcended next with Simran. Naam accompanies one till merging in God. Where as music and Raags accompany un to the mind through senses. Gurus did not sing. Through Gurus the Truth sang. This ego less state was reached by Simran. Some are trying to sing the borrowed truth using the same notes to achieve that state. There is a difference. Gurus were aware of this situation among others. That is why they sang many Shabads on Raags and imitating them. Few of those have been referred already. It is Simran that makes the dumb speak and the blinds see. It is the Simran that makes ego vanish and recognize God's Will. God becomes the Singer, Raags and the Audience. There is nobody else existing. It is the matter of receiving true Naam alone with God's Grace. All the parameters of the worldly intelligence fail. I suggest a pause to this Satsang and thank you for giving a great company. Love. Balbir Singh [%sig%]priceless · 09 Feb 2006
bai balbir singhji >Zaraa eh ta dasso tuhaanoo GuraaN ne kithay te kidda >samjhaayaa ke sab sikhaaN noo Guru di baanee, jo sri guru > >granth sahib ji vich darz hai, dohraanee hai. > >Kirpaa karoo ji guru ji da koee vaak te sunaa-o ji. das, bahut moorakh hei. tuch jehi kosis kar riha haan guru di bani nu samjhan di. Sunoji baiji, guru saab kendei han Naam guruparsad hei te Guru Gurbani hei so naam Guru Gurbani dee bakhsis naal hee milega " -satgur bani purakh purakhotam bani sio chit lavaigo =satguru di bani duara sareshat purakh parmatma milda hei, iss karkei too gurbani naal apna dhiaan jor. Gurmat anusar rab nu yad karan dei do zaroori ang han, pehla gurbani te dooja naam jo gurbani(Guru) to milda hei dekho guru ji ki kendei han " -gurbani varati jag antar is bani te har naam paaeidhaa ( Guru Amar Daas Ji Raag Maaroo 1066 ) =gurbani da iss sarei jagat ch vartara hei, te is bani duara parmatma da naam milda hei -gurbani chahu kundi suneeai saachai naam samaaeidhaa (Guru Amar Daas Ji Raag Maaroo 1065 ) =Gurbani is dunia de choh kunda ch sundi hei, te is bani naal assi parmatna dei naam vich sama jaande haan -eh bani jo jehu janai tis antar ravai har nama (Guru Amar Daas Ji Raag Bilaaval 797) =jis ne gurbani naal dilon saajh paa layee, ohde andar parmatma da naam sada vasiya renda hei -jan nanak bolae gun banie gurabani har naam samaaeiaa =nanak jan gurbani gaunda hei te is gurbani naal parmatma de naam ch samaunda hei -gurabaanee har alakh lakhaaeiaa =gurbani dura, naa bujhan vala parmatma bujgiya gia " gurmat anusar Guru roopi gurbani daa tin taraa naal darshan hunda hei sab to uttam - Gavnaa (Kirtan) te Jaa phir Sun-na te jaa phir parna Guru sab ne sari gurbani gaa ke uchari te hukum kita -bani guru guru hei bani vich bani amrit sarei te phir eh vee hukum kitta ke -prabh bani sabad subhakhia, gavahu sunahu parahu nit bhai gur poorai too rakhia Gaaun( gurbani kirtan ) dee mahtata sab to ziada hei Guru da phurman hei ki -gurbani sakhee anand gaavai -gur ki bani anadin gaavai sehajae bhagat karavania - avahu sikh satguru ke piario gavau sachi bani || bani t gavau guru kaeri baniaa sir bani || jin ko nadar karam hovai hiradai thina samani || pivahu amrit sada rehu har rang japihu sarig pani || kehai nanak sada gavau eh sachi bani || meri benti hei kie jo veer guru sab dei hukum anusar ragaan ch gurbani gaaun jaa gawaun da uprala kar rahei han jaa karnaa chahundei, oh dhanta dei yog han, ohna da virodh karkei mamukh na bano kiyoo ki satguru bachan kamavanei sacha ehi bichar bhulaa maaf karniya ji. changa baiji. [%sig%]Harcharan Singh · 10 Feb 2006
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh, Veer Balbir Singh Ji, You say: "It is nice to hear these words "WE ALREADY KNOW KIRTAN, RAAG OR NOT, HAS NO VALUE UNLESS ONE MEDITATES ON AKAAL PURKH." At least you pretended to understand when you wrote "There is a difference between singing and Hari Kirtan, please stop confusing the 2." ----- Thank you again for your kind words, I am now pretentious on top of everything else. Dhan-vaadh. "BaarN bwxu is sound produced through the mouth. And NirbaarN means 'without sound'. Nirbaarn does not mean 'nirvaanaa' as you have mentioned." ------------- What do you think Nirvana means? Buddha Ji reached the state of supreme realisation and peace, this is Nirvana. Though expressing our love to Akaal Purkh and meditating and doing vichaar on his shabad (Kirtan), we experience realisation - which occurs inside of us, so how is it different? "Veer Ji, please ponder over it. How does one get time to show his talent for singing when he is all the time contemplating one Gurshabad" ------------- THANK YOU VEER JI. You've tripped over your own shoe laces again. You should ask yourself how our Guru Sahiban and great Gur-Sikh such as Baba Ram Singh Ji, Baba Nand Singh Ji, Baba Isher Singh Ji got time to devote their life to kirtan (Singing Gods praises using their divine talent) and spreading the message of Guru Nanak Dev Ji. Do you propose you have reached a higher state than them? How does your comment fit with the many Gurbani quotes I have given on Guru Ji telling us the neccesstiy of Kirtan in our lives? Who is trying to show their talent in singing? Are you talking about the pop star gianis who do not want to be restricted to the emotional boundries of raag or the classical musicians/singers, BOTH of which have nothing to do with topic, but you feel the need to keep bringing up, because your arguement has no direction and substance? "You seem to get bored when you write sentences like "You are repeating the same point in 10 different ways, a point which enlightens no one, as it has already been stated numerous times previously and never needed to be stated in the 1st place as it was commonsensical to start with." And "Now please stop using this same point againa and again to justify your own personal problem with the singing of Kirtan in Guru Ji's method." Gurdev started with JAP. Today also HE is giving uninterruptedly the message of JAP. Have you ever wondered why? I have only tried to bring everybody's attention toward it. ---------- Veer ji, yes I agree. But you seem to think that their is not enough space for Jap and kirtan in the world, although there was for Guru Sahiban and the millions of Gursikh that followed them? As well as their being numerous hukums to sing Kirtan in Gurbani? "You wrote "How would you like it if I kept classing you in this category" and mentioned Guru Teg Bahadur Ji's Vaak auriJE knk kwmnI ky rs nh kIriq pRB gweI ]1] rhwau ] "urjhi-o kanak kaamnee kay ras nah keerat parabh gaa-ee. ||1|| rahaa-o" SGGS Ang 718-6 Got entangled in taste of attractive wishes, did not sing celebrity of God. Guru Teg Bahadur Ji sang this Vaak about Him. The line just before this is khau khw ApnI ADmweI ] "kaha-o kahaa apnee aDhmaa-ee." I say where is my own half mother (deficiency)? Veer Ji. These words are from Gurdev for Him. Please do not crown those on me." ------------ Veer ji, Guru Ji tells us we all have the 5 chhor inside of us and maya outside of us. It is in Guru's divine way to show us the path using themselves as an example. Are you saying the above cannot possibly apply to you? You cannot possibly get entangled in maya? It does not interest me who sings the Guru's Hymns and how. He may be a Raagee, Naadee, Vedee, Paapee or Pathee. Most important is that Gurdev's messages reach me every time and remember me of Simran. ------------- Nice of you to mention those who devote their lives to praising Waheguru in the same sentance as paapi, this has been your game throughout your posts. I'm glad that you are finally stating that this is simply YOUR opinion. I do ardaas that Guru Ji's message does continue to reach you, and you do immerse yourself in naam simran and that if Waheguru does kirpa, you taste the anand of praising him with your heart and soul, as our Guru's did and asked us to do. All the references you have provided from Gurbaanee are about praise (Keertan) and celebrity (Keerat) of Hari (Prabhu). Those do not suggest taking a music instrument (vaajaa) in hand and start tuning the throat with it. -------- Oh dear, run out of attacks on kirtan and so now we move on to Guru Ji's saaj, and again we start from square 1. Vajaa has nothing to do with Pardaareth Kirtan. It is a sub-standard Austrian instrument designed for western scales, our beautiful Guru Sahibaan have given us the tools/saaj that we need to do their kirtan and raag justice. Another topic for you to go and research (not just a quick half-hearted internet search this time I hope, as you did with raag). Do you not think our Guru's practiced singing, exercising their voices? Do you not think they wanted their praises to Waheguru to sound beautiful as humanly possible? Do you not think that the growing sangats were pulled in by the divine voices and divine shabad that Guru Ji did Kirtan with? What do you think Sikh means? Pupil. to learn, disciple - you said earlier, how can we have time to sing> A pupil makes time, when their teacher is speaking to them and teaching them, the pupil doesn't question, the pupil learns. A Sikh is a pupil until their last breath. Look up history and then tell me whty Guru Arjun Dev Ji created the most beautiful instrument in the world - the Saranda - then look at your question again. Strange you could not provide one reference from Gurdev where They suggested us to imitate them or repeat their Hymns to reach God. ----- Did our Guru's have such haumai that they called themself perfect? Think! So what hyms do you suggest that our Guru's were refering to when they have given us so many instructions about kirtan? Kachee Bani or Gur-Bani? Again, why is the Sri Guru Granth Sahib organised in raag, why not in author format? Why did our Guru's imitate their predecesors by doing kirtan in the same way the Guru's before them did it? Why did Guru Arjun Dev Ji record the method in which his 4 earlier Guru's did their kirtan, for fun? Instead you go on blowing horn "The huge majority of Gur-sikh learn raag kirtan to follow Guru Ji's hukum and do not make any money, they do kirtan out of pure love and it forms part of their maryada and riaz": -------- I do not blow a horn, Bajai (the real meaning of the word) are not allowed whilst doing kirtan because they require the use of your mouth, meaning that one cannot sing bani - Shabad is not pardhaan. Your point was what? These are characteristics of Maya. We leave it up to one. He remains a part of Maya. Better surrender all to God and come to know HIM as Sat Guru. ------- Ah, again thanks for pointing out my Maya characteritics, your critism cannot hurt me, I am a lowly and ignorent person already. Please be careful you do not drop to my level by continuing to judge me. ----------------------------------------------- Dhan Dhan Guru Maharaaj Arjun Dev Ji ------------------------------------------------Balbir Singh · 10 Feb 2006
Satsriakal to all and Priceless Ji! Bahut Bahut Dhanvaad. Gurbaanee sunaa-orN daa. Enha vich kerra vaak dasdaa hai ki Guru-aN dee Baanee dohraa-o jaa onhaN dee rees karo. Tusee likhia "Gurmat anusar rab nu yad karan dei do zaroori ang han, pehla gurbani te dooja naam" Kirpa karo ji. Eh vee das da-o Gurdev nay ayasaa kithay likhia hai. Mainoo taa Gurdev nay ayko Naam dasyaa hai Jee. Antay tusee likhia "meri benti hei kie jo veer guru sab dei hukum anusar ragaan ch gurbani gaaun jaa gawaun da uprala kar rahei han jaa karnaa chahundei, oh dhanta dei yog han, ohna da virodh karkei mamukh na bano" Mayraa dhanvaad te saaryaaN noo hai jee jo Gurbaanee sunaa-onday han atay guruaaN de dittay bachan 'simran' dee yaad karaa-onday han. Ki tusee sirf gaaun vaalayaaN da dhavaad karday ho jee. Satsriakal. Balbir SinghHarcharan Singh · 10 Feb 2006
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh Veer Balbir Singh Ji, Thanks for giving again a possibility to read Guru's wonderful Vaaks. --------- Thank you for giving me the opportunity to find them. Please do not raise the impression that I am against singing Hari Keertan. May it be in Raags from a professional or one who does not know anything about musical notes. ---------- I don't need to give this impression, you do this perfectly well your self: "Veer Ji, please ponder over it. How does one get time to show his talent for singing when he is all the time contemplating one Gurshabad?" "Singing is also not a reason to feel privileged to meet Truth of God before others." "Any singer, who feels that by learning Raags and singing the Guru's Baanee is a faster track, has gone astray. Such singers learn Raags with an illusion of ego. At least they earn means of living, name and fame if they miss God." "The Gurus never suggested us to repeat their Hymns and sing those in Raags. Please provide an instruction from Gurbaanee for singing in a particular Raags. " " Kaljug, Raagees learn singing to earn truth of Maya. They have nothing to do with Jap and its truth. I wish I could hear once THEIR praise for Hari from these imitators." There is plenty more, but I that should suffice for know. From your post one may feel that he is left behind because he does not know anything about Raags. Those also sound like invitation to join a Sangeet Maha Vidyalaya as everyone can learn Raags. Your canvassing for singing Guru's Shabads in classical Raags makes one think that Raags are of prime importance. Is it not that Simran is for everyone? --------- Is the next step - fed of judging me you will now theorise that I have a hidden agenda? Let me give you a good accusation for next time, you can call me an agent of the Indian Government, pathetic. Yes, I feel people are missing out if they are not doing kirtan, in Guru Ji's hukmi raag, tha same way you feel people are missing out if they do not do simran. I have asked you before to stop classifying and portraying Guru Ji's divine gifts as "classical raag", this temr is commonly understood as cultural and entertainment based, Guru Ji's raag as found in Gurbani are not for entertainment as you keep seeming to think they are. Yes simran is for everyone, for the millionth time, who said it wasn't? And it is also of prime importance - to have gurmanter on our breath every second of the day. Please please stop using this as excuse to pull people away from Guru Ji's hukum to sing Kirtan for our supreme Pithaa. Many people listen to Raagees in Gurudwaras. Do they realize truth at the same time? Or Raagees have realized truth earlier during the rehearsal at home. ------ again you judge, generalise and stereotype, what concern is this of yours anyway. I am not antarjami, I can cannot read every single Gur-Sikh and Raagis mind in the world. I thought people were unique and responsible for their own actions and it was for Dharam Raj to judge? I can tell you this, when you listen to kirtan being perfomed in the Pardaareth raag, by a true sevak, you can feel the meaning, even if you can't understand all the words. You then feel the "kitch" to go and and learn the meaning of the shabad, at which point you are blown away. For those fortunate who can understand the shabad properly as well, they will certainly be in external and internal ecstacy. This is how Guru Nanak Dev Ji spread the truth in so many foreign countries where people so spoke so many differetn languages, accompynied by Bhai Mardana Ji. It is only true Simran that gives the true experience of Truth to all. Be sure one has not come to receive it if this has not happened. ------------- Yes, but who says that kirtan is not also a form of simran, you are repeating Guru shabad again and again, meditating on the words, doing vichaar..how can one not realise Waheguru like this: ਸਬਦੋ ਤ ਗਾਵਹੁ ਹਰੀ ਕੇਰਾ ਮਨਿ ਜਿਨੀ ਵਸਾਇਆ ॥ सबदो त गावहु हरी केरा मनि जिनी वसाइआ ॥ sabdo ta gaavhu haree kayraa man jinee vasaa-i-aa. The Lord dwells within the minds of those who sing the Shabad. I want to clear my point here. ------ Waheguru Music of any kind is a sensual matter. The joy of music is the joy of mind. Many musicians swear that they feel transcended from their music. But their transcended state is momentary. They seek soon next attempt to reach that state again. All sensual pleasures act and react with mind similarly. Ananda reached through Simran is beyond sensual pleasure. It establishes the state further through Simran. Ananda is also transcended next with Simran. Naam accompanies one till merging in God. Where as music and Raags accompany un to the mind through senses. ---------- Who is talking about instrumentals or music/raag alone here, not anyone on this thread. The discussion is about KIRTAN, not music - Kirtan = Shabad Guru + Guru Raag + Guru Mukh ... and to make it perfect.... Guru Saaj Bhai Sahib, try listening to Guru Raam Daas Ji and singing Anand Sahib Ji in Ramkali and you will experience a new Anand. ਸਬਦੋ ਤ ਗਾਵਹੁ ਹਰੀ ਕੇਰਾ ਮਨਿ ਜਿਨੀ ਵਸਾਇਆ ॥ सबदो त गावहु हरी केरा मनि जिनी वसाइआ ॥ sabdo ta gaavhu haree kayraa man jinee vasaa-i-aa. The Lord dwells within the minds of those who sing the Shabad. ਕਹੈ ਨਾਨਕੁ ਅਨੰਦੁ ਹੋਆ ਸਤਿਗੁਰੂ ਮੈ ਪਾਇਆ ॥੧॥ कहै नानकु अनंदु होआ सतिगुरू मै पाइआ ॥१॥ kahai naanak anand ho-aa satguroo mai paa-i-aa. ||1|| Says Nanak, I am in ecstasy, for I have found my True Guru. ||1|| Gurus did not sing. Through Gurus the Truth sang. This ego less state was reached by Simran. -------- Ok, I can agree with that...... Some are trying to sing the borrowed truth using the same notes to achieve that state. --------- Gurus were aware of this situation among others. That is why they sang many Shabads on Raags and imitating them. Few of those have been referred already. ----------- Then why did they bother to sing in raag and base the whole bani around raag, as well as provide refernces as to the emotion of raag? It is Simran that makes the dumb speak and the blinds see. It is the Simran that makes ego vanish and recognize God's Will. God becomes the Singer, Raags and the Audience. There is nobody else existing. -------- Veer ji, without Shabad Guru and it's propogation you would not even know this. Shabad Guru is Pardhaan. I suggest a pause to this Satsang and thank you for giving a great company. ------- Good idea. Thank you for giving me and the sangat the opportunity to learn more about the purpose and bliss of Kirtan as well as that of simran. I do ardaas that you will come to realise both in your jeevan Waheguru j ika Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh Harcharan SinghBalbir Singh · 10 Feb 2006
Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal! Veer Harcharan Singh Ji! God sang Truth through Guru Ramdas Ji in these words. [gurbani]rwgY nwdY bwhrw ienI hukmu n bUiJAw jwie ][/gurbani] "raagai naadai baahraa inee hukam na boojhi-aa jaa-ay." Raags and Naads are outwardly, from these, Hukam is not recognized. I find Gurdev's Vaak wonderful and true. In This Vaak, also nowhere else Gurdev has asked anyone to stop singing. ************** You asked "So what hyms do you suggest that our Guru's were refering to when they have given us so many instructions about kirtan? Kachee Bani or Gur-Bani?" All is kachee Baanee without being blessed with true Simran. Only through Simran one realizes the wisdom of Gurus Baanee. Without Hari Simran there is no experience of Hari. Listen. Guru's Baanee is saying something about Gauree and Sorath. [gurbani]gauVI BI soriT BI ][/gurbani] "ga-orhee bhee sorath bhee." Gauree also and Sorath too [gurbani]ry jIA inlj lwj quoih nwhI ][/gurbani] "ray jee-a nilaj laaj tohi naahee." O! Jeev shameless, are you not ashamed? [gurbani]hir qij kq kwhU ky jWhI ]1] rhwau ][/gurbani] "har taj kat kaahoo kay jaaNhee. ||1|| rahaa-o." SGGS Ang 330-16 Forsaking Hari where and to whom you go. You may please convince God that Raagees know true Simran and sing Hari Keertan as its result. Truth is experienced alone through Simran. True values of Sorath are also realized after mind has come to know the truth of Naam. [gurbani]soriT sdw suhwvxI jy scw min hoie ][/gurbani] "sorath sadaa suhaavanee jay sachaa man ho-ay." SGGS Ang 642-11 Sorath is ever soothing when truth dwells mind. Truth dwells mind only after one receives Simran. Guru Nanak Ji sings further. [gurbani]soriT qwim suhwvxI jw hir nwmu FMFoly ][/gurbani] "sorath taam suhaavanee jaa har naam dhandholay." Sorath is generally soothing when Hari Naam is sought. [gurbani]gur purKu mnwvY Awpxw gurmqI hir hir boly ][/gurbani] "gur purakh manaavai aapnaa gurmatee har har bolay." SGGS Ang 642-14 Own Gur Purakh is harmonized, Gurmatee speaks Hari Hari. I feel Gurdev suggests speaking Hari Hari. Gurdev is not asking us to repeat His complete Hymn. In my view, Simran is not repeating five particular Baanees and reading, reciting or singing of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. I hope you are wise who knows true Simran and let God sing Sorath through his voice. Love. Balbir Singh [%sig%]Kulbir Singh · 10 Feb 2006
Balbir Singh jee, ------------- Enha vich kerra vaak dasdaa hai ki Guru-aN dee Baanee dohraa-o jaa onhaN dee rees karo. ----------- Are you suggesting that there is no vaak that tells us to sing Guru jee’s baani? I have done a shallow reading of your posts and it seems as if you are advocating that all we need to do is Japp Naam and there is no need to recite Gurbani. Please correct me if my interpretation is wrong. In Siri Anand Sahib, Siri Guru jee has cleared instructed us to sing Guru’s baani: “Baani ta Gavo Guru keri, Baaniya sirr Baani||” (Sing Guru’s Baani that is greatest of all other baanis). Kulbir Singhsingh · 10 Feb 2006
bhai harcharan singh, u say its not ur duty to judge neone, yet u say u feel those who are trained in raag vidiya and choose not to make a difference are wrong, and u list ur reasons why. how bout singhs who have raag vidiya yet do nishkam kirtan through there love for guru ji albeit not in title raag?Harcharan Singh · 10 Feb 2006
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh, Veer Singh Ji, It's a shame you have not acknowledged the rest of the post which I wrote for you, but only my issue with kachei raag. I said it is not for me to judge anyone because you question was simply asking to me categorise non-Guru Raag Kirtani. I do not pertain to know all people in this categoty, nor their intentions. All I say is that where do we draw the limit for what kind of music we use, who decides this, us mortals? How would you feel if you heard kirtan done to drum and bass or ragae music, would you be joyfull at the ever growing diversity within sikhi? My view is simple: I respect my Guru's kirtan, and I don't see why everyone else shouldn't. I can't understand why people would want to ignore and not learn about this treasure Maharaj has given us, and try to experience kirtan as Guru ji did and has allowed us to by telling us how. Gur-Sikh who never had these resources don't count in this discussion, we can only make the best of our environment, and that is what they did, and they are great for it. But can we say that for todays kirtan singers, are they are making the best use of available resources as our Guru's did and millions of Sikh after them did? I am judging no one, only trying to highlight the case for Guru Ji's pardaareth raag, and hopefully inspire a few people to learn, experience and teach, so that Guru Ji's kirtan can return to our Gur-Ghar the world over once again. Last thing Veer Ji, you mention Nishkaam kirtan, I cannot understand this concept being applied to people who seek to use their own melodies and ignore our Guru's kirtan framework, Nishkaam means selflesss, my chosen melody does note equate to selfless. If we do Kirtan using purely Guru's gifts and none of our own, then we can say nishkaam. Unless Guru's gifts are not available to us, then we use gurmat and do the best we can - that would be nishkaam. Satnaam Harcharan SinghBalbir Singh · 10 Feb 2006
Satsriakal to all and Kulbir Singh Ji! Welcome back to this topic. Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji remembers us to do NAAM JAP again and again. Reading, reciting, listening, discussing or singing Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji has one purpose. He remembers us to come back to Simran. Strange that people are using Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji for their source of earnings, politics, fame and to carry on many businesses around and near by. I hope you will stay and help reaching a conclusion of an important point you have raised. Please explain what is Baanee? Balbir Singhsingh · 10 Feb 2006
------------------------------------------------------------ I respect my Guru's kirtan, and I don't see why everyone else shouldn't. ----------------------------------------------------------- doesnt that imply anyone who sings in non-title raag is disrespecting Guru ji? And listening to mere mun by prof surinder singh the other day like u suggested, 1 thought arose. Why if we should only use our guru's saaj, are performers using flutes and sintoors which were not used in guru's darbar?? And Prof Surinder Singh claims he is spreading gurmat by spreading the message of title raag, yet Naamdharis are his best perofrmers and perform with him in Guru;s hazoori......interesting.Kulbir Singh · 10 Feb 2006
Balbir Singh, ------------- Reading, reciting, listening, discussing or singing Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji has one purpose. He remembers us to come back to Simran. ------------- I agree that Naam is the main purpose but it seems like you are undermining kirtan of Gurbani. Please clearly spell out what your belief is. ----------- Strange that people are using Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji for their source of earnings, politics, fame and to carry on many businesses around and near by. ------------ Yes people are using Gurbani for their selfish needs but this is not the topic on hand. ---------- Please explain what is Baanee? -------- The word baani has many meanings. While it simply means sound, it also means “ghaarat” or build-up as in the case of “Karam Khand kee Baani Zor||”. Baani also means Naam Gurmantr in some places in Gurbani and it also means Gurbani itself in many places. Baani also means "dohi" as in the case of "Babur baani phir gayee, koir na roti khaaye". There maybe more meanings of this word. This is what I could come up with quickly. In one of your posts you wrote the following: “Enha vich kerra vaak dasdaa hai ki Guru-aN dee Baanee dohraa-o jaa onhaN dee rees karo.” What I understand from this is that you are not in favour of singing and reciting Gurbani of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. You challenged sangat to produce one hukam that says that “Guru-an dee baanee dohraa-o jaa ohnHan dee rees karo”. I have presented one Vaak in my previous post that clearly says that we should sing “Guru kee baani”. What do you have to say in respond to this? Please clearly state your position. Are you saying that no Vaak of Guru Sahib instructs us to sing or recite Gurbani? Please be clear and frank. Then we will proceed further. Kulbir Singhsingh-2 · 10 Feb 2006
1. raag fanaticism so every shabad must be sung in the raag in which it written? so many questions arise - -what about the bani that is not in raag? -what about doing just paat of bani without music and instruments should that be banned? -what about doing keertan in the correct raag but at the wrong time of the day for the raag eg. doing anand sahib in ramkali in the evening after rehras when ramkali is a morning raag? or indeed rehras itself in the evening with raag asa being a morning raag? wasnt guru sahib aware of the raag time restrctions? maybe the gurus' didnt follow time restrictions? -therefore what about the possibility that the guru's version of any particular raag doesnt correspond to the one in nothern indian sangeet? who was there to witness what the guru's meant by raag asa, sri raag, etc? -what about some places in bani that have additional information of dhuni's like for example in asa ki vaar it states tunday as rajay ki dhuni? what dhuni is this? no one knows what it means - so should we stop doing asa ki vaar altogether because we are supposedly going against guru's hukam by not doing it in the way it was meant to be done? these are just some of the issues that crop up when people start insisting that all keertan must be done in raag and only that raag which the shabad is in in gurbani. this is not to say that raag should not be encouraged. every keertani must be capable of following darbar sahib maryada ie. first shabad in raag of the chounkee and then after that ragee should be free to do keertan of choice. this is maryada followed by hazoori jathay and should be encouraged. insisting on anything above and beyond this is however going against settled panthic maryada. 2. bollywood criticism as to the filmi tunes bollywoodism etc criticism, this is such a general criticism and made so often by raag fundementalists and others that people have started to believe in its truth. its misguided and must be challenged. first, the gurus only created one raag all the other raags were already established in nothern indian music. the gurus used the music of the time and place in which they lived (ie. khusro nothern indian classsical music) to convey their message. many religious sects in india criticised and continue to criticise the impact of music on society because they say it is dangerous and leads to kaam. music has throughout the ages has been associated with romance and relationships. infact raag mala is believed by many on this site to be part of a kaam poem. also in the indian context music was associated with dancing women and brothels etc. that is why many sects within india discouraged people from it generally and would at any rate not propogate their religious message through it for the negative connotations that went with it. mainstream sects within islam agree with this interpretation. but guru sahiban understood the power of music and argued that its not the music itself which is bad it is the use to which it put that defines whether its good or bad. they harnest the powerful energy of music to convey their message. so now, should we be stuck with nothern indian music and instruments pre 17th century for the rest of time or are we allowed to change with time? our guru's never invented a new form of music. the raags and tunes used - with exceptions - were of the time and place ie. khusro northern indian music. that khusro lineage continues to this day in keertan as much as it does in general indian music. many bollywood songs are too sung in one raag or another. they are afterall based on the same musical tradition as keertan. should we stop doing keertan in raag altogether because these films have songs in them in the same raags as we have for gurbani? or maybe alternatively we should want to ban bollywood films as they supposedly use "our" raags for their songs? see how mad this sounds. gurus never created a seperate musical tradition so how can you now seek to differentiate? [%sig%]LionKing (LK) · 10 Feb 2006
Author: singh Date: 02-10-06 13:35 ------------------------------------------------------------ I respect my Guru's kirtan, and I don't see why everyone else shouldn't. ----------------------------------------------------------- doesnt that imply anyone who sings in non-title raag is disrespecting Guru ji? And listening to mere mun by prof surinder singh the other day like u suggested, 1 thought arose. Why if we should only use our guru's saaj, are performers using flutes and sintoors which were not used in guru's darbar?? And Prof Surinder Singh claims he is spreading gurmat by spreading the message of title raag, yet Naamdharis are his best perofrmers and perform with him in Guru;s hazoori......interesting. ******************** Harcharan Singh ji earlier on answered that - Naamdhari's preform because they are the best he could find. If there's Sikhs who know their raags, and is able to teach, he would be happy to have them join.... As for disrespectng Guru Ji by not reading in non-title raag- is it disrespectful to do padh-ched of Gurbani, then why isn't it wrong to recite it the way Guru Sahib asked us to recited it?Balbir Singh · 10 Feb 2006
Satsriakal to all and Kulbir Singh Ji! Thanks for your response. The word Baanee does not have many meanings as you have tried to explain. Baanee is the sound expression. Baanee always has particular impacts. Baanee is never the written or printed matter. Anything written or printed does not produce a sound. Gurbaanee is the sound originated and transferred through the Guru. I feel, Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji is misinterpreted and misunderstood since the wisdom of true Simran eloped. Truth is that The Gurus sang the praise of Hari and wrote their Hymns for the mankind to receive once the true impulses and search for the first step. True Simran is only transferred. Its wisdom is never achieved by reading, discussing or using similar practices. You have provided the wonderful Vaak from Gurdev [gurbani]bwxI q gwvhu gurU kyrI bwxIAw isir bwxI ][/gurbani] "banee ta gaavhu guroo kayree baanee-aa sir banee." SGGS Ang 920-5 Baanee is to sing which Guru performs, that Baanee is exalted. Your translation "Sing Guru’s Baani that is greatest of all other baanis" is suggesting singing the written or printed Hymns from Gurdev. This is not correct, in my experience. The Gurus have sung many times that by reading, reciting, discussing or singing any scripture Truth is not realized. Strange many have understood it to reject other scriptures but not the one that is in my possession. Sikhs are supposed to receive Simran from Panj Pyaras. Please ask them how did they transfer it to the Guru if one is not satisfied with the results. I have expressed the truth as I have enlivened it. From my side there is no need to discuss it further. Wishing you all the same True Naam, I remain. Balbir Singh [%sig%]Kulwinder Singh · 10 Feb 2006
Long debate of the topic “listening 2 non Sikhs kirtan” No shortage of arguments on both sides. But question for me is Those who think “listening 2 non Sikhs kirtan” is wrong or allowing non Sikhs to do kirtan in Gurudawars (apart from Golden Temple) . is some how wrong. These people should think. Are they people saying our Guru Ji is narrow minded ? ( many Sikhs rather make Guru Sahib narrow minded like themselves then accept others ). Do you know for sure one who appear to be Pura Sikh is a Sikh for sure. Past and present history have shown us otherwise. Praising of Guru Sahib or GOD is monopoly of Sikhs in Gurudawaras ? I can list many So called Sikhs who have harm the penth and I can list many who have served the Penth even when their declared faith have been something other then Sikhism( I am talking about past and present times). Bhagat Namdev Ji when kicked by the Brahmins out side the temple went at the back of temple and did kirtan by clapping his Kharava ( Shoes), What they think of that ? Yes when you are doing simran of Shabads you are doing kirtan even when you are own you own or in a sangat. By no mean I am saying do not learn Rag or make more efforts in learning music, But rather then shutting down the doors and portraying Guru Sahib as narrow minded why not accept Guru Granth Sahib as they are , why give our own Man made argument why not listen to Guru Sahib. We are very good at picking and choosing what we like from Guru Sahib, Bottom line is we think we know better then Guru Granth Sahib, and we think Guru Sahib is not 100% present Guru and not capable of guiding us, only then we can take refuge in instructions of our mind other wise why else we would over rule Guru Sahib. Doing kirtan in rag is highly desirable as desirable as being a good Gurusikh, but don’t try to force in a way that we kick , restrict and object others love towards Guru Sahib or GOD. Sikhs need to accept Guru Granth Sahib as their Guru in full authority e.g. Only Guru Sahib’s decisions count and what ever do not sync with Guru Granth’s Philosophy should not be applied in designing the practices. GOD And Guru Sahib are most kind, loving, compassionate, supportive, father- mother - brother and friend like, Please do not portray them in any negative form. Our Guru Sahib even when kicked in the congregation did not showed his hostility towards the offender, contrary to that ask the kicker if his bones actually hurt the kicker in his act. That is how humble our Guru Sahib ji are, If Guru Sahib wanted all he has to do is give one gesture to his Sikhs and they would have burnt the offender alive, but our Guru Sahib Ji’s have shown us the path of kindness even to those who insult Guru Sahib. These lessons are the most precious lessons for Sikhs in particular and for humanity as whole, If Sikhs fail to make this world aware of this compassionate and Loving Guru and Guru’s most kind Philosophy this world will still find out about this kindness but by acting as loud speakers of Guru Sahib we can save the world of some harsh times ahead. There are also arguments about people who take money , how come they can have ras in the Kirtan ? Big question : The whole setup of Gurudawars in India including Golden Temple have ragis and Kirtanees on wages, do you think not even one person get rass from visting and listening to Kirtan in any of these gurudawars ? Some time we just get focused on so much of what we want rather then what is real world is, Even Guru Sahib’s time Guru Sahib use to finically look after the people who provided the services like that. The whole episode of the Sata and Balwanda happened and Sikhs as whole were encouraged by Guru Sahib to do Kirtan by themselves, which most of us do not do that, and the time has made some traditions which have served us well, e.g. we have paid kirtanees who are treated as employees and get payment but no special status is given to them as kind of middle man with GOD or any thing even near to that. If we can not provide as community some kind of structure where we provide a good finical support to these Kirtanees while they are in their working life and beyond that we should just shut up and stop criticising those who execute their paid work with the dedication and guideline we provide as community. I personally love the Jetha;s kirtan style and sing along is my cup of tea but I do understand that another large majority love listening to Kirtan performed by professional Kirtanees and Many of them I like listening too. I still get very powerful vibes while listening to Mohinder Kapoor’s Deho Shiva ber moha ehie from Nanak Naam Jahaz hai. Or listening to Mohamd Rafi ‘s Miter Pyaria noo. Gurubani is so Sweet and powerful I do not know anybody who is not impressed by Guru’s blessing. The Question is how come inclusive Guru’s Sikhs want Sikhism to be exclusive ? Moving away from Guru Granth Sahib is surely not the path of Guru Sahib. [%sig%]Harcharan Singh · 11 Feb 2006
Waheguru i ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh, Veer (?) Singh Ji, You are intent on making me stereo-type and generalise against people who perforn non Guru pardaareth raag Kirtan, when I have already addressed this issue, please read my posts. I feel upset "in this day and age" when kirtan singers sit in Guru Ji's hazoori and do kirtan not as Guru Ji has requested. at the start of the shabad. That is my opinion. I have my justifaction for when this happened due to politcal, social, cultural and economic circumstances in teh past, but I don't see any justification today. There is a hukamnanam (forgive me I can't recall the source) that instructs we should not use bajai (wind intstuments - not harmoniums) because they do not allow us to the sing the shabad, which is actually the reason for kirtan, instruments come second (be it an important second). I have stated what kirtan means to me, not given a hukumnama on what it should be. Shabad should be pardhaan, the shabad inludes the Guru Ji's raag. Instruments are accompyments, and should ideally be in harmony with the kirtan. Harmoniums are not, they are not designed for hukmi kirtan, they do not have shruti - microtones - as our voice does, they therefore create imbalance. My big issue is following Guru Ji's hukmi raag, because that is what Guru Ji has asked us to do at the start of each shabad. It would be beautiful if we could use Guru Ji's instruments as well, but it is not ompulsory or as important. That is down to the individual, whether they treasure their Guru's divine gifts, or think that some one today has bettered Guru's Ji saaj. To date, no instrument can complete technically against our Guru's saaj. Lastly, as of late, Professor Ji now only uses his students to perform kirtan in Guru Ji's , no longer Namdhaari. So that shouldn't be an issue for you anymore. Sat Sri AkaalHarcharan Singh · 11 Feb 2006
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh, Veer Singh (?) Singh Two, 1. raag fanaticism so every shabad must be sung in the raag in which it written? so many questions arise - =========== -what about the bani that is not in raag? Japji was a divine revalation and forms the nucleaus of the Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Why is this a question or problem, do you not trust your Guru, if you have such a big issue, follow the raag hukum where it is stated , and don't where it is not. As for Dasam Granth, once you understand the meaning of Guru's raags and baani, you can apply the relevant Guru Raag to teh relevant baani. -what about doing just paat of bani without music and instruments should that be banned? ============= There is kirtan (expression of devotion and love) and there is education. Education requires reading the bani, learnt santhia, doing vichaar, arth and listening to kathaa. -what about doing keertan in the correct raag but at the wrong time of the day for the raag eg. doing anand sahib in ramkali in the evening after rehras when ramkali is a morning raag? or indeed rehras itself in the evening with raag asa being a morning raag? wasnt guru sahib aware of the raag time restrctions? maybe the gurus' didnt follow time restrictions? ============ Thanks for highlighting this. Classical/Vedic kirtan tradition follows timescales for raags, Gurmat Sangeet does not. Are your moods restricted to times of day, are yo only happy in the morning, sad in teh afternoon, lonely in the evening etc, hopefully not. Sikhs do not beleive in "holy days" or "holy times", God is not so limited as to only be accessed at set times, dates. We congregate on Gurpurb to be with sadh sangat, learn history, do kirtan, commerate an event etc, not because it is a "holy day". Same goes for time. Amritvela is the exception, because Guru Ji has told us and explained the reason for it's importance. The world sleeps, maya sleeps, the 5 chhor are weak, it is just us and Akaal Purkh, no disctractions, this is therefore the best time to contemplate him and perform our NITNEM. This does not mean we can't rememver him or can't do our NITNEM any other time of alongside. Only "Classical" raagis who use vedic education promote time restricted raag, time restraints go against common sense and Sikhi. -therefore what about the possibility that the guru's version of any particular raag doesnt correspond to the one in nothern indian sangeet? who was there to witness what the guru's meant by raag asa, sri raag, etc? ============ Guru's raag didn't disappear as long ago as you think. It is only in the last 100 years that they have declined (during British occupation - surprise). The raag knowledge is plentiful, Indian Music has capitalised on our Guru's raags, and as per Indian tradition, failed to mention Sikhi in history when it comes to our Guru's contribution. It was our Guru's that saved, rejuvenated, added, beautified and made divine raag kirtan. There is not any big arguement over the rules and meanings of raag, all major sources have agreement on their use, there would no benefit for anyone to dilute them, as they would no longer retain their power. They can be used for bad as well as good, same as Gurbani can (by misinterpreting by fake babai), or shaster vidya can, or food can (glutony), the list goes on. If we support and contribute to those that are now making a gigantic effort to research and preserve Sikh Kirtan, instead of wasting time like this wouldn't it be a better use of our time? Lastly, you will know what the raag means when you do kirtan, the merger of Guru's words and the music will evoke the correct undertstanding feeling, our efforts to describe the feelings will only always be half hearted, best to try and see for yourself. -what about some places in bani that have additional information of dhuni's like for example in asa ki vaar it states tunday as rajay ki dhuni? what dhuni is this? no one knows what it means - so should we stop doing asa ki vaar altogether because we are supposedly going against guru's hukam by not doing it in the way it was meant to be done? =========== Poeple do know what it means, I am not able to tell yuo form the top of my head, but people who have dedicated their life to researching Sikh Kirtan like Professor Ji can tell you. If you are really interested you can e-mail him. My knowledge is very limited. these are just some of the issues that crop up when people start insisting that all keertan must be done in raag and only that raag which the shabad is in in gurbani. this is not to say that raag should not be encouraged. every keertani must be capable of following darbar sahib maryada ie. first shabad in raag of the chounkee and then after that ragee should be free to do keertan of choice. this is maryada followed by hazoori jathay and should be encouraged. insisting on anything above and beyond this is however going against settled panthic maryada. ========== Veerji, the maryada states: b) Kirtan means singing the scriptural compositions in traditional musical measures. Traditional is how it was done for 400 years before the Angreji Raj, not in the last 30 years with filmi influence. Let me say something else, the highest maryada is Sri Guru Granth Sahib, if it ever comes to choosing between Guru Ji and anyone else, the choice will always be clear. Have you ever heard Kirtan done by 15-20 Gur-Sikh Raagis, this is how it used to be done at Darbaar Sahib before SGPC took, over. Imagine what what that must have been like. 2. bollywood criticism as to the filmi tunes bollywoodism etc criticism, this is such a general criticism and made so often by raag fundementalists and others that people have started to believe in its truth. its misguided and must be challenged. first, the gurus only created one raag all the other raags were already established in nothern indian music. =========== What is your basis for saying this? You should do proper research before misconstruing Sikh History. Although you have made this brash statment, I won't put you on the spot by asking you to tell me who invented the other 58 raags (or did you think that there were only 31?) Our Guru's created 34 of Gurbani's raags, many of which are misharat (mixed raags), creating new and more specific emotions relavant to the said shabad. Raags have actually been used for thousands of years, and in those millenia were soley used for devotional worship. It was only when the Mughals came that raag was finally abused and used for entertainment. Our Guru's rescued, perfected and took ownership of this divine kirtan tool. the gurus used the music of the time and place in which they lived (ie. khusro nothern indian classsical music) to convey their message. many religious sects in india criticised and continue to criticise the impact of music on society because they say it is dangerous and leads to kaam. ========= Our Guru's were not limited by culture. They invented 34 raags and applied correct usage to the rest. The have been immortalised in Bani, ignore them at your own loss. Khusro only refers to a specic time period, raags have been used for thousands of years. Our Guru's applied raags for divine use, for which they were orinially used. Amir Khusro was known for perfomring in the Kings courts, our Guru's and their Sikhs perfomed in Gods court. It is the common ISLAMIC perception that music is evil, not a Sikh, Vedic or Indian one. This point you have stated is irrelevant. Our Guru's and Sikhs thereafter have used Kirtan/music as the highest from of art known to man, to express their emotions, longings, questions,happiness, sadness to Akaal Purkh. music has throughout the ages has been associated with romance and relationships. infact raag mala is believed by many on this site to be part of a kaam poem. also in the indian context music was associated with dancing women and brothels etc. that is why many sects within india discouraged people from it generally and would at any rate not propogate their religious message through it for the negative connotations that went with it. mainstream sects within islam agree with this interpretation. but guru sahiban understood the power of music and argued that its not the music itself which is bad it is the use to which it put that defines whether its good or bad. they harnest the powerful energy of music to convey their message. ============ Sorry, I see your above message was not finished. As pointed out above, it was only after the Mughal inception that music and dancing (south Indian), were used as forms of entertainment, where before hand they have been forms of artistic worship ofr thousands of years. I am glad you realise that our Guru's harnessed the power of music and gave us a pure unadulterated basis to do kirtan. It is compulsory, as it is for anything else i.e. seva, to do kirtan with Guru in mind, otherwise this gift can be misused. Question always comes down to this: Do you want to kirtan in Guru's method or in your own? Sat Sri Akaal I am glad you recognise the fact that so now, should we be stuck with nothern indian music and instruments pre 17th century for the rest of time or are we allowed to change with time? our guru's never invented a new form of music. the raags and tunes used - with exceptions - were of the time and place ie. khusro northern indian music. that khusro lineage continues to this day in keertan as much as it does in general indian music. many bollywood songs are too sung in one raag or another. they are afterall based on the same musical tradition as keertan. should we stop doing keertan in raag altogether because these films have songs in them in the same raags as we have for gurbani? or maybe alternatively we should want to ban bollywood films as they supposedly use "our" raags for their songs? see how mad this sounds. gurus never created a seperate musical tradition so how can you now seek to differentiate?LionKing (LK) · 11 Feb 2006
Although you have made this brash statment, I won't put you on the spot by asking you to tell me who invented the other 58 raags (or did you think that there were only 31?) Our Guru's created 34 of Gurbani's raags, many of which are misharat (mixed raags), creating new and more specific emotions relavant to the said shabad. *************** Would this be "partaals"? What emotion exactly does this make, i.e. a mixture of two emotions, .e.g. Love and separation or?singh-2 · 11 Feb 2006
harcharan singh, >>>Veer Singh (?) Singh Two,<<< singh is a different poster to me. >>>As for Dasam Granth, once you understand the meaning of Guru's raags and baani, you can apply the relevant Guru Raag to teh relevant baani.<<< so where there is no raag prefixed to a particular shabad, every individual is left to chose which raag to apply once they have "understood the meanings" of the bani in question? in other words they can chose whatever they feel like based on their understanding? >>>Classical/Vedic kirtan tradition follows timescales for raags, Gurmat Sangeet does not. <<< how did you come to this conclusion? i agree with you that it is nonsense to say that a certain collection of notes should only be played at a particular time. however, there are many classical raagi's like bhai avtar singh who stick to time limitations so why are they wrong? have you any historical evidence of gurmat maryada stating time to be irrelevant in gurmat sangeet other than it merely goes against your common sense as you stated? >>>Poeple do know what it means [tunay as rajay kee dhuni], I am not able to tell yuo form the top of my head, but people who have dedicated their life to researching Sikh Kirtan like Professor Ji can tell you. If you are really interested you can e-mail him. My knowledge is very limited<<< which people would these be? please do reveal. as far as i'm aware nobody in the world of gurmat sangeet knows what it means. but maybe your professor knows. >>>Let me say something else, the highest maryada is Sri Guru Granth Sahib, if it ever comes to choosing between Guru Ji and anyone else, the choice will always be clear.<<< is that why the professor does keertan with naamdhari's? has he made his choice? it is one thing to learn any vidiya from someone who rejects guru granth sahib as guru if no one else is available to teach it but to do keertan with them? keertan is done to the guru who are these naamdhari's doing keertan to? >>>Our Guru's created 34 of Gurbani's raags, many of which are misharat (mixed raags), creating new and more specific emotions relavant to the said shabad.<<< but are these so called raags settled? if you look within different raag books different authors have different interpretations. who is right? sometimes it maybe no more than educated guess work. it reinforces my point that what collection of notes guru sahib did the shabad in or had in mind for a particular shabad may only be known to guru sahib. for example you stated in one of your earlier posts that anand sahib should only be done in raag ramkali. however, some would claim that anand sahib is not infact in raag ramkali but in the raag "ramkali-anand" whatever that maybe. how are we to decide whether that is right and what that raag maybe other than any persons own idea? >>>Question always comes down to this: Do you want to kirtan in Guru's method or in your own?<<< the whole point of this debate is to determine whether there is a method and to determine what that is. i personally dont think there is enough evidence left to prescribe a defined method over and beyond settled panthic maryada. if you feel you know what gurmat sangeet is and wish to do your keertan in it then good for you. no one is stopping you. the problem only arises when you start insisting everyone goes along with your ideas of gurmat sangeet.raag-online · 12 Feb 2006
As is often the case the topic has gone slightly of track.... From personal experience I never knew the difference between raag keertan and non raag keertan but once the difference has been experienced you begin to understand with guru's grace why Guru Granth sahib Ji was compiled in such a way. The emotions felt when listening to non raag keertan are as powerful as when listening to raag keertan however I have come to understand that it is not the same. Raag keertan allows you to feel the emotions relating to that particular shabad not just the general emotion of pyar that we have for all of Guru Ji's bani. Although this understanding can only be experienced it can never be explained. Therefore rather than discussing the differences and the issues we should go out and experience keertan and see what Guru ji blesses us with. Also I do not think that any keertan which is not in raag is wrong I think when keertan is sung and heard with pyar it can only be a possitive thing.Harcharan Singh · 12 Feb 2006
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki Fateh, Veer (? means I don't know how to address you fully as Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj has asked all his Khalsa to do) Singh Two, >>>As for Dasam Granth, once you understand the meaning of Guru's raags and baani, you can apply the relevant Guru Raag to teh relevant baani.<<< so where there is no raag prefixed to a particular shabad, every individual is left to chose which raag to apply once they have "understood the meanings" of the bani in question? in other words they can chose whatever they feel like based on their understanding? ----------------- Bhai Sahib, Dasam Granth is a contentious subject, and not really relevant in my opinion. I don't want to start a discussion on this, but Guru Ji said Guru Manyo Granth - they were refering to Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, not Dasam Granth. My personal belief is that Guru's close Sikhs compliled Guru Ji's personal works and thoughts after Guru Ji's Joti Jot, Guru Ji did not create or intend his personal works to be worshipped, hence raag issue. We as a panth however have taken the decision to include Guru Ji's bani in our NITNEM, I am happy with that. Dasam Granth Sahib is bani for me. >>>Classical/Vedic kirtan tradition follows timescales for raags, Gurmat Sangeet does not. <<< how did you come to this conclusion? i agree with you that it is nonsense to say that a certain collection of notes should only be played at a particular time. however, there are many classical raagi's like bhai avtar singh who stick to time limitations so why are they wrong? have you any historical evidence of gurmat maryada stating time to be irrelevant in gurmat sangeet other than it merely goes against your common sense as you stated? --------------- I don't agree with Bhai Avtar Singhs stance on this. I have already provided my reasons clearly for this. People are not happy, sad, lonely, angry at certain times of the day, Sikhi is always in line with common sense, I would like some to prove through Gurbani that a certain shabad is restricted to a certain time of day. Time restrictions and raag is an ancient Vedic/Hindu thinking, a thousand years before our Guru's. It is based on this hindu school of music that Bhai Avtar states his thoughts. His claims of lineage mean nothing, hard evidence, common sense and gurbani should always prevail. Bhai Balbir Singh Ji's opinion means more, as he had 100% respect for Guru Ji's kirtan, and has never sung out of raag (been offered plenty to do so). Bhai Sahib, also completely disagrees with time limits, their is not even 1 decent arguement in gurbani context for this. If we are hurting or happy, do we have to wait for a certain time of day before we do that relevant shabad to soothe us? >>>Poeple do know what it means [tunay as rajay kee dhuni], I am not able to tell yuo form the top of my head, but people who have dedicated their life to researching Sikh Kirtan like Professor Ji can tell you. If you are really interested you can e-mail him. My knowledge is very limited<<< which people would these be? please do reveal. as far as i'm aware nobody in the world of gurmat sangeet knows what it means. but maybe your professor knows. ------------ I will get back to you on this. >>>Let me say something else, the highest maryada is Sri Guru Granth Sahib, if it ever comes to choosing between Guru Ji and anyone else, the choice will always be clear.<<< is that why the professor does keertan with naamdhari's? has he made his choice? it is one thing to learn any vidiya from someone who rejects guru granth sahib as guru if no one else is available to teach it but to do keertan with them? keertan is done to the guru who are these naamdhari's doing keertan to? ------------------ I am not sure why you seem to be obsessed with Professor. I don't need to defend him, his efforts and the outcome of them speak for themself, there are over 600 Gur-Sikh students learning their Guru's kirtan from all over the wordl and growing. Namdhari or not, that is a personal choice, worry about yourself not others, please don't start a discussion on Namdharis. They do the same kirtan, written by the same Guru's, and ultimately beleive in Waheguru and naam japna. It is not the fault of todays generation namdhari that they are born into their version of history. If we are to spread Guru Ji's true history and try and help those that have veered of the path, this is not going to be done through exclusion, isolating people, constantly critising and damming people, it is going to be through Guru's love and education, like that shown by Baba Nand Singh Ji. There is a lot we can learn and benefit from if we could bring Namdhari back into the mainstream, but to persuade them that their 120 year old version of history is wrong is not a task that is going to be accomplished by hate. I have already told you, Prof no longer does kirtan with Namdharis, this should not be an issue for people like you anymore. >>>Our Guru's created 34 of Gurbani's raags, many of which are misharat (mixed raags), creating new and more specific emotions relavant to the said shabad.<<< but are these so called raags settled? if you look within different raag books different authors have different interpretations. who is right? sometimes it maybe no more than educated guess work. it reinforces my point that what collection of notes guru sahib did the shabad in or had in mind for a particular shabad may only be known to guru sahib. for example you stated in one of your earlier posts that anand sahib should only be done in raag ramkali. however, some would claim that anand sahib is not infact in raag ramkali but in the raag "ramkali-anand" whatever that maybe. how are we to decide whether that is right and what that raag maybe other than any persons own idea? ---------- Please provide 2 well recognised gurmat sources that conflict on the aroh and avroh of any Gurbani raag. Over 90% of raagis agree on the raag asule. I do not know enough to answer your ramkali example, but lets say you were right, what is your stance exactly. That we shouldn't make an effort to research, revive and preserve our Guru's kirtan? Many people argue over our Guru's maryada also, so what is your stance their, we can't be 100% sure, so let's forget it altogether? Nothing is possible with Guru's kirpa, if Guru Ji gave us a gift, and we lost it, with ardaas and benti, why could not help us to find it again? >>>Question always comes down to this: Do you want to kirtan in Guru's method or in your own?<<< the whole point of this debate is to determine whether there is a method and to determine what that is. i personally dont think there is enough evidence left to prescribe a defined method over and beyond settled panthic maryada. if you feel you know what gurmat sangeet is and wish to do your keertan in it then good for you. no one is stopping you. the problem only arises when you start insisting everyone goes along with your ideas of gurmat sangeet. ---------------- Veer ji, they are not my ideas. All the raagis I have met (independant) do not argue over the meanings or rules of the raag. That is an excellent start and does away with your doubt. The world is not going to change with my tiny insistence, I am only promoting and talking about what my Guru has shown me, I am sorry if you find that offensive, but your doubts will not stop me talking or researching or promoting. My Guru's preservation in every way is more important than your doubts.KhalsaSingh · 12 Feb 2006
Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa! Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh! In my opinion it is not wrong to listen to a non-sikh do kirtan. The message of the Guru Granth Sahib is universal and meant for all of humanity. Many non-sikhs respect our philosophies and this is acceptable. You do not have to convert to a religion to respect a philosophy. If the message of the Guru was not universal Guru Ji would not have to travel all over the world to deliver his message. The Guru's message is Gods word and not only Sikhs believe in God so I think its futile to claim that only Sikhs can do kirtan and recite the praisies of God. I am sorry if I offended anyone. Also, on the topic of Raags (I am a raag fanatic and find so get so much ras out of them as bani is put on a throne), If these are truly God's words and there are headings for raags, in my opinion kirtan should be done in proper raags. Just to let you all know raag is not difficult to learn unless you wish to perfect it and sing it like Baba Shaam Singh but no one even reaches the level of Bhai Harpreet Singh (Truthfully he is not even close to puratan kirtanees but he is still awesome and I am grateful to him). But truly, it is not difficult. Any tune is put in a raag. If you think AKJ tunes are easy they are also in raag SO is it really hard to learn raag? NO! This bothers me because people use it as an excuse just because they don't think it is important. And I personally get more ras out of raag but especially when a message is delivered with it such as Gurbani. Raag highlights and uplifts bani. Also, if Guru Ji gave us an art form for bani then why should we not learn it instead of putting bani to tunes that are filmy? If we follow guru maryada then we should also follow kirtan maryada. By the way I am not AKJ, Taksali, Nanaksaree or anything I am just Guru's sikhs so please do not think I am attacking any specific group. Also, just to let you know chainay were really used in houses where girls used to dance (girls were heavily exploited) and for me they ruin kirtan as they are just noise of metal clanking together. Sorry If I offended anyone just putting in my two cents. [%sig%]wory · 13 Feb 2006
is that last point true about the chainey?oh know i also learned that the harmonium was also played in brothels.Harcharan Singh · 13 Feb 2006
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh, Veer Babbar-Shere Maharaj, Partaal implies a complex is to be used on the pakawaj/jora, all as is common today, tabla. As for the misharat raag, you are correct to say that they bring together the emotions of 2 raags, although the emotion is predominantly of the first raag mentioned, the slight difference pertains to the twist the second raag contributes. Professors 59 raag CD set comes with priceless gem of a book, which explains all the raags and the mixed raags, and gives an example of each and every raag in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Maharaj in the form of wonderfully and correctly composed kirtan. The book also states all the rules for each raag. I would suggest you invest in this as you seem to have a genuine interest in Guru Ji's raag kirtan. The big thing that is confusing the panth with regards to hukmi raag kirtan is the difference between "Terminology" and "Musicology". Many raagis learn and follow the rules of raag, and perform kirtan simply as a technical exercise, which doesn't go down to well with sangat, as the raagi is predominantly concentrating on the alaap, aroh, avroh and surs. This is not kirtan. and it's a shame that this is the the experience the large part of the panth get of raag kirtan. The missing element is musicology, this is applied by understanding the meaning of the raag, drawing deep on our personal experiences and applying them to understand and reflect the correct feeling of the shabad. This is where the athmaa comes into affect (understanding and showing the correct emotion). One of the previous posters is correct where he has said that even non-raag kirtan can be powerful and the love for Guru can show, but the simple difference is still this, that the emotion that those veers are feeling or applying is not the one that our Guru has asked us to feel. I will give you an example of misharat: Raag Gauri Sorath - This raag takes the elements of Gauri where the listener is encouraged to strive harder to achieve an objective and is combined with Sorath, where a strong belief is conveyed and continuously repeated. The message is so powerful that even the most unresponsive listener will be attracted. Here is an example from Bhagat Kabir Ji, note the power of the message resides in the rahao (the chorus), if we were to take any other line of the shabad as the chorus, the whole message, emotion and aim of the shabad would be changed, this is what many kirtani do today perfect example as always is Lakh Kushiyan: ਗਉੜੀ ਭੀ ਸੋਰਠਿ ਭੀ ॥ गउड़ी भी सोरठि भी ॥ ga-orhee bhee sorath bhee. Gauree And Also Sorat'h: ਰੇ ਜੀਅ ਨਿਲਜ ਲਾਜ ਤਹਿ ਨਾਹੀ ॥ रे जीअ निलज लाज तोहि नाही ॥ ray jee-a nilaj laaj tohi naahee. O shameless being, don't you feel ashamed? ਹਰਿ ਤਜਿ ਕਤ ਕਾਹੂ ਕੇ ਜਾਂਹੀ ॥੧॥ ਰਹਾਉ ॥ हरि तजि कत काहू के जांही ॥१॥ रहाउ ॥ har taj kat kaahoo kay jaaNhee. ||1|| rahaa-o. You have forsaken the Lord - now where will you go? Unto whom will you turn? ||1||Rahao|| ਜਾ ਕੋ ਠਾਕੁਰੁ ਊਚਾ ਹੋਈ ॥ जा को ठाकुरु ऊचा होई ॥ jaa ko thaakur oochaa ho-ee. One whose Lord and Master is the highest and most exalted - ਸੋ ਜਨੁ ਪਰ ਘਰ ਜਾਤ ਨ ਸੋਹੀ ॥੧॥ सो जनु पर घर जात न सोही ॥१॥ so jan par ghar jaat na sohee. ||1|| it is not proper for him to go to the house of another. ||1|| ਸੋ ਸਾਹਿਬੁ ਰਹਿਆ ਭਰਪੂਰਿ ॥ सो साहिबु रहिआ भरपूरि ॥ so saahib rahi-aa bharpoor. That Lord and Master is pervading everywhere. ਸਦਾ ਸੰਗਿ ਨਾਹੀ ਹਰਿ ਦੂਰਿ ॥੨॥ सदा संगि नाही हरि दूरि ॥२॥ sadaa sang naahee har door. ||2|| The Lord is always with us; He is never far away. ||2|| ਕਵਲਾ ਚਰਨ ਸਰਨ ਹੈ ਜਾ ਕੇ ॥ कवला चरन सरन है जा के ॥ kavlaa charan saran hai jaa kay. Even Maya takes to the Sanctuary of His Lotus Feet. ਕਹੁ ਜਨ ਕਾ ਨਾਹੀ ਘਰ ਤਾ ਕੇ ॥੩॥ कहु जन का नाही घर ता के ॥३॥ kaho jan kaa naahee ghar taa kay. ||3|| Tell me, what is there which is not in His home? ||3|| ਸਭੁ ਕੋਊ ਕਹੈ ਜਾਸੁ ਕੀ ਬਾਤਾ ॥ सभु कोऊ कहै जासु की बाता ॥ sabh ko-oo kahai jaas kee baataa. Everyone speaks of Him; He is All-powerful. ਸੋ ਸੰਮ੍ਰਥੁ ਨਿਜ ਪਤਿ ਹੈ ਦਾਤਾ ॥੪॥ सो सम्रथु निज पति है दाता ॥४॥ so samrath nij pat hai daataa. ||4|| He is His Own Master; He is the Giver. ||4|| ਕਹੈ ਕਬੀਰੁ ਪੂਰਨ ਜਗ ਸੋਈ ॥ कहै कबीरु पूरन जग सोई ॥ kahai kabeer pooran jag so-ee. Says Kabeer, he alone is perfect in this world, ਜਾ ਕੇ ਹਿਰਦੈ ਅਵਰੁ ਨ ਹੋਈ ॥੫॥੩੮॥ जा के हिरदै अवरु न होई ॥५॥३८॥ jaa kay hirdai avar na ho-ee. ||5||38|| in whose heart there is none other than the Lord. ||5||38|| Sat Sri AkaalKhalsaSingh1699 · 13 Feb 2006
The harmonium was also used in brothels.. but the thing is that the harmonium was common throughout classical music all over india whereas chainey were specific to dancing houses.. those cymbal things were used throughout classical music as well including at the harimandir sahib by some raagis.. I am not saying the harmonium is ok (in my opinion it is not) but) but at the end it just comes down to doing the shabad in gurmat raag. Sorry about the chainey part I shouldnt have added it. Whether it was used in brothels or not is still irrelevant because raags were also sung in brothels so I shouldn't tell anyone chainey are necessarily wrong. I personally do not like them and they give me a headache when people keep going off beat and keep hitting them together like theres no tommorrow (keep in mind some people play them well). And in my opinion gurmat raag and chainey just do not come together.. it ruins the art as well as the Bani for me.. but if it floats your boat whatever as long as you get ras and bani out of it.Harcharan Singh · 13 Feb 2006
Apologies Veer Lion-King Ji, My 1st line must have totally confused: Partaal implies a complex is to be used on the pakawaj/jora, all as is common today, tabla. It should have read: Partaal implies a complex TAAL is to be used on the pakawaj/jora, OR as is in common use today, THE tabla. DhanvaadhHarcharan Singh · 13 Feb 2006
Musical Framework of Guru Granth Sahib Amardeep Singh* Gurbani Keertan today has been commercialized to such an extent that, barring a few, most singers are only concerned with making quick money. Their limitations to experiment within the prescribed vastness of Guru Granth Sahib is camouflaged in the excuse that the Sangat does not prefer to listen to Keertan in Raags as prescribed by the Gurus and thus it is easier to convey the message of Gurbani in catchy tunes. This shallow argument poses questions, like: "What does Guru Granth Sahib, our eternal Guru command us on the subject of Keertan? Why is it that the Gurus chose raags to classify Gurbani? What is the relation between Shabad and raag? Do we need the aid of experimental music to propagate the message of Guru Granth Sahib? Have our Keertanias experimented with the vastness of raags and taals as prescribed by Gurus? What impact will experimentation have on the future generation of Sikhs? Hymns in Guru Granth Sahib are in poetical-metric forms; associated with them raags and ghars (beats/taals). Does this mean that Gurus have left no scope for experimentation with the music to accompany the Shabads? The indication of raag and ghar (beat) with every Shabad implies that Gurus had a definite motive behind fixing a framework. This framework was not set to limit the ability of the human mind to experiment with music but to act as an aid in spiritual development. A simple mathematical permutation and combination on notes of any raag will indicate that each raag offers thousands of tunes to experiment with. Complementary: Poetry (the form in which Gurbani is written) and music (raags) are two sides of the same coin. They are independent and yet complement each other. Music versifies and provides melody, uniformity and cadence to poetry. The factor that binds music and poetry is their metrical-form (ghar or beat). Music (Raag) is based on sound (swar - notes) and a combination of notes produce distinct musical effects. Poetry is determined by Word (Shabad), which communicates a message to the mind. Music (Raag) on the other hand conveys a feeling to the heart and is therefore universal. Spirituality, after all, is striking the right balance between mind and heart. Therefore, when the poetic Gurbani is complemented with raag (music) and bound by ghar (beat), the resulting effect on mind and heart can become a catalyst for spiritual transformation. The raag conveys a feeling and Shabad a message. Every raag is capable of touching the heart with feelings like joy, sorrow, detachment, etc. Upon studying the structure of Guru Granth Sahib it can be seen that Shabads relating to common themes are generally placed under each raag. When the broad themes of Shabads are overlaid with feelings conveyed by these raags, there emerges a reason behind grouping of Shabads under a broad classification of thirty-one raags. Common Themes of Shabads placed under Raags of Guru Granth Sahib 1. Soohi - Being away from home. The soul being away from the House of Lord and the joy of meeting the true ‘husband.’ 2. Bilaaval - beautification of soul, happiness. 3. Gaund - Separation, union, surprise. 4. Sri - Maya and detachment 5. Maajh - yearning to merge with Lord, giving up of negative values. 6. Gauri - Principles, serious, thoughtfulness, composed 7. Aasa - Hope 8. Gujri - Prayer (Pooja) 9. Devgandhari - Merging with spouse, self - realization 10. Bihaagra - Yearning due to separation of soul and happiness due to meeting the Lord. 11. Sorath - Merits of God 12. Dhanasari - Mixed theme 13. Jaitsree - Stability 14. Todi - Maya, separation 15. Bairagi - motivation to sing praises of Lord 16. Tilang - many words from the vocabulary of Islamic origin are used, sadness, beautification. 17. Raamkali - to give up the life of a wandering Jogi. 18. Nat Narayan - Joy of meeting the Lord 19. Maali Gaura - Happiness 20. Maaru - Bravery, profound philosophy. 21. Tukhari - Separation and union with Lord 22. Kedara - Love 23. Bhairav - Man’s state of hell 24. Basant - Happiness 25. Sarang - Thirst to meet God 26. Malaar - State of separated and united soul 27. Jaijawanti - Vairaag (Detachment) 28. Kalyaan - Bhakti (Prayer) Ras 29. Vadhans - Vairaag (Detachment) 30. Prabhati - Bhakti (Prayer) 31. Kaanra - Bhakti (Prayer) Feelings communicated by the music of Raags: 1. Soohi - joy and separation 2. Bilaaval - happiness 3. Gaund - strangeness, surprise, beauty 4. Sri - satisfaction and balance 5. Maajh - separation, beautification 6. Gauri - seriousness 7. Aasa - making effort 8. Gujri - satisfaction, softness of heart, sadness 9. Devgandhari - no specific feeling but the Raag has a softness 10. Bihaagra - beautification 11. Sorath - motivation 12. Dhanasari - inspiration, motivation 13. Jaitsree - softness, satisfaction, sadness 14, Todi - this being a flexible Raag it is apt for communicating many feelings 15. Bhairaavi - sadness, (Gurus have, however, used it for the message of Bhakti) 16. Tilang - this is a favourite Raag of Sufi Muslims. It denotes feeling of beautification and yearning. 17. Raamkali - calmness 18. Nat Narayan - happiness 19. Maali Gaura - happiness 20. Maaru - giving up of cowardice 21. Tukhari - beautification 22. Kedara - love and beautification 23. Bhairav - seriousness, brings stability of mind 24. Basant - happiness 25. Sarang - sadness 26. Malaar - separation 27. Jaijawanti – Victory (Detachment indicates a victory of spiritual plane) 28. Kalyaan - Bhakti Ras 29. Vadhans - vairaag, loss (that is why Alahniya is sung in this Raag when someone passes away) 30. Prabhati - Bhakti and seriousness 31. Kaanra - Bhakti and seriousness It’s clear that the Gurus used raags to increase the delivery power of shabad to our mind by invoking complementary feelings in our hearts through usage of the prescribed raags. Another interesting aspect of raag and Gurbani classification is understood by studying daily time-cycles. A raag has a preferred timing associated with it. There are some morning raags, evening raags, afternoon raags, etc. The timings of raags also complement the changes in human moods and heart during a twenty-four hour time cycle. Upon classification of thirty-one main raags used in Guru Granth Sahib based on the prescribed raag timings, we find that no raags fall under the time zone 12 AM - 3 AM. It is interesting that the Gurus chose not to use any raag with a time cycle of 12AM – 3 AM, because one would normally sleep between 10PM - 4AM. Timings of Raags: 6 AM - 9AM: Bhairaagi, Devgandhari 9 AM - 12 PM: Saarang, Suhi, Bilaaval, Gujri, Gond, Todi 12 PM - 3 PM: Vadhans, Maru, Dhanasari 3 PM - 6 PM: Maanjh, Gauri, Tilang, Tukhari 6 PM - 9 PM: Sri, Basant, Maali Gaura, Jaitsree, Kedara, Kalyaan 9 PM - 12 AM: Bihaagra, Nat Narayan, Sorath, Malaar, Kaanra, Jaijawanti 12 AM - 3 AM: No Raags from Guru Granth Sahib 3AM - 6AM: Aasa, Raamkali, Bhairav, Parbhati Some raags also have seasons associated with them as seasons also denote feelings. Seasonality of Raags: 1. Basant raag can be sung at any time in Basant season. Shabads with the theme of happiness are clustered under this raag in Guru Granth Sahib. 2. Malaar raag can be sung at any time in the rainy season. Shabads with the theme of separation are clustered under this raag in Guru Granth Sahib. The Gurus have also indicated the beats associated with the poetry of every Shabad. In Guru Granth Sahib seventeen ghars (taal - beat) are mentioned. These seventeen ghars denote the following beats: GHAR 1 - DADRA TAAL (There are 1 Taalis and the Beat has 6 Maatraas) GHAR 2 - RUPAK TAAL (There are 2 Taalis and the Beat has 7 Maatraas) GHAR 3 - TEEN TAAL (There 3 Taalis and the Beat has 16 Maatraas) GHAR 4 - CHAAR TAAL (There are 4 Taalis and the Beat has 12 Maatraas) GHAR 5 - PUNJ TAAL (There are 5 Taalis and the Beat has 15 Maatraas) GHAR 6 - KHUT TAAL (There are 6 Taalis and the Beat has 18 Maatraas) GHAR 7 - MUT TAAL (There are 7 Taalis and the Beat has 21 Maatraas) GHAR 8 - ASHT MANGAL TAAL (There are 8 Taalis and the Beat has 22 Maatraas) GHAR 9 - MOHINI TAAL (There are 9 Taalis and the Beat has 23 Maatraas) GHAR 10 - BRAHAM TAAL (There are 10 Taalis and the Beat has 28 Maatraas) GHAR 11 - RUDRA TAAL (There are 11 Taalis and the Beat has 32 Maatraas) GHAR 12 - VISHNU TAAL (There are 12 Taalis and the Beat has 36 Maatraas) GHAR 13 - MUCHKUND TAAL (There are 13 Taalis and the Beat has 34 Maatraas) GHAR 14 - MAHASHANI TAAL (There are 14 Taalis and the Beat has 42 Maatraas) GHAR 15 - MISHR BARAN TAAL (There are 15 Taalis and the Beat has 47 Maatraas) GHAR 16 - KUL TAAL (There are 16 Taalis and the Beat has 42 Maatraas) GHAR 17 - CHRCHARI TAAL (There are 17 Taalis and the Beat has 40 Maatraas) Within the rules of Indian Classical Music, uncountable raags can be created. In fact, any form of music (non-Indian and non-classical) can be classified under some form of raag. Hence it is a misconception that raags are something highly classical and beyond the realm of the common man’s understanding. In fact, any form of music can be classified into a raag. But in Guru Granth Sahib, the Gurus have gone into depths of poetry, music and metrical forms to lay the framework that is best suited to convey the feeling and message of the Shabad simultaneously to the human mind and heart. When each of the prescribed raags offers uncountable permutations and combinations of musical compositions, then why is it that modern Keertanias are not experimenting within the prescribed framework of the Gurus? Are they camouflaging their limitations in the excuse that Sangat prefers only catchy tunes? Gurbani says: "Among all raags, that one is sublime, O Siblings of Destiny, by which God comes to abide in the mind." (Page 1423) Clearly, only that raag is prescribed by which a feeling of spirituality is aroused. The Gurus have not prescribed catchy musical tunes that may dominate the Shabad. The essence of Keertan lies in effective delivery of the inherent message of the Shabad, using raag and taal as a medium. The medium must not dominate the essence. This is where our modern day keertanias are making the mistake of experimenting beyond the prescribed framework of Guru Granth Sahib and singing shabads in catchy tunes. At the end it’s the tune that remains in the mind and not the message. Music is twice blessed, yet one must guard against misuse of its inherent power. For while it can be effectively used for constructive Keertan by operating within the prescribed framework of Guru Granth Sahib, on the other hand it can also be used for arousing destructive feelings by use of catchy tunes. (as explained earlier, any form of music can be classified into a raag). It is interesting to note that the main object that has caused the current day deterioration in quality of Keertan is the most widely used musical instrument called ‘Harmonium’. But harmonium is not an Indian instrument. Over one hundred years ago, Europeans brought the harmonica to India. The air box of this European instrument was experimented by Indian musicians to develop a new instrument that was named harmonium. This instrument is not best suited for Indian classical music. According to Indian classical music, the human ear can recognize twenty-two musical notes in an octave. The harmonium only offers twelve discrete keys in an octave. Only string instruments offer the ability to play all twenty-two notes in an octave, by pressing the string at midpoints. It is for this reason that earlier Indian Music was always played with the accompaniment of only string instruments. In fact if one sees the old pictures of Harmandir Sahib, one only finds string instruments being used by the Keertanias. Instruments: Although the harmonium offered a compromise to Indian classical music and should never have been used in the Indian system, it gained rapid acceptance because it was very easy to learn and use. Learning a string instrument requires close to four to five years professional training but the harmonium can be learnt in less than two months. This was a great blessing to aspiring Sikhs who also wanted to be able to do Keertan. While there is no harm in using a harmonium ,and we must also accept its contribution in making it easier for the masses to learn Keertan, thereby helping them start their spiritual journey. However it also caused the biggest deterioration in the tradition of Keertan singing. The professional Keertanias were now finding it hard to keep pace with the rapid generation of new breed of amateur Keertanias, who did not go through the years of rigorous training, using the string instruments. Materialistic desires lead them to shorten their classical training period by quickly moving to the harmonium. Over generations this trend lead to complete elimination of string instruments from the Gurudwaras. Lack of dedication that crept in because of the ability to learn Keertan in just two months also lead Keertanias to soon start doing Keertan in catchy filmy tunes. Arguably, our modern day Keertanias should be given a one hundred percent score for having the ability to experiment with music. But unfortunately, this experimentation with catchy tunes is causing more harm than good to Keertan tradition as they have stopped experimenting within the prescribed framework of Guru Granth Sahib. An instrument that was supposed to attract Sikhs to Gurbani has now become the very reason for the downfall in present day standards of Keertan. It would have been fine for the harmonium to be adopted, but not at the expense of compromising on string instruments. The harmonium should have acted as a stepping-stone for budding Sikh Keertanias to quickly acquire musical sense and move forward to experimenting within the prescribed framework of Guru Granth Sahib. Instead they have chosen the short cut. The reason for citing the above example is to show the long term pitfalls associated with un-checked experimentation. Modern day experimentalist keertanias need to be cautious and introspect. The first question that needs to be answered is: What is attracting the youth to this new style of Keertan? In all probability, it is the music that is attracting them because Keertan is being done in a modern day, highly dramatized form. Haunting: I have heard a shabad "Mittar Pyarae Noon…" in which thunder, lightning and sounds of wild animals complement the shabad to project the scene of Machiwara jungle. The only reason one would get attracted to such style of Keertan is because of music. Like any MTV Top of the Charts, such music can’t last long in the minds of the youth, nor can the message get effectively delivered to their mind. On the other hand, maybe the youth is getting attracted to this style of Keertan because effective English/local language translations are being provided. If that is the case, then the translations can also be provided while doing Keertan in the prescribed framework of Guru Granth Sahib. After all, there are thousands of tunes that can be created from each of the prescribed raags and these tunes need not be highly classical in order to cater to popular tastes of the youth. Even the Gurus did not allow the dominance of classical music over the Shabad. Our Gurus support forwardness, but where should we draw the line? Who knows, next there could be an experiment with Jaap Sahib being sung in the Rap style! Will Jaap Sahib in Rap style lead to feelings of spirituality? The future of Keertan lies in the hands of present day Keertanias. They definitely need to look at ways of improvising and attracting the youth, but not at the cost of further deterioration of Keertan. Our Keertanias should first make the effort to acquire full knowledge of the musical framework of Guru Granth Sahib and then adapt from within it, to attract the youth - not on a short-term basis but on a long-term basis. I believe that if our Keertanias make an earnest efforts to implement the commands of Guru Granth Sahib in their singing style, then the ‘pied pipers’ of pop music will not need to walk the streets to attract the youth, they will automatically get attracted to the Gurudwara.Harcharan Singh · 13 Feb 2006
Flow and Pause in Gurbani & Keertan Amardeep Singh, It is important to understand a few terminologies before we proceed further. Rahau - While reading through a Shabad in Guru Granth Sahib, we find that one line has a word RAHAU written at the end. Except for Raag Tukhari, we find the mention of Rahau in nearly all the other Bani. Depending on the type of Shabad (Chaupada - 4 liner, Ashtpadi - 8 liner, etc.) it has that many defined lines. Somewhere in the middle, or in the beginning of the Shabad one line has the word Rahau mentioned, with the numeral 1. The word rahau means WAIT.... PAUSE....in Punjabi "Therau". Gurus have clearly indicated that while reading the Shabad, take a PAUSE on this line. Why Pause? Because the line with RAHAU has the central theme of the Shabad. This is the line in which Guru is conveying the topic discussed in the Shabad and it contains the Gurmat Vichar, the RIGHT THOUGHT. Therefore we are required to pause on this line and contemplate the message. The other lines in the Shabad are used to explain/extrapolate the contents of the Central Theme given in the line of Rahau. These other lines (the non-Rahau lines) talk about prevalent practices, arguments, reasoning, intention, etc. and are used for strengthening/explaining the Central Theme. The point to note is that the numbering of lines is meanigful: the numbering conveys a definitive message. The message here is: Wait/Pause and contemplate on the message. In this line the Guru is telling us the theme of the Shabad. The number 1 of Rahau indicates ,read this line carefully. Now read the other (non-Rahau Line) line, and correlate it to the message in Rahau. Now proceed to other (Non-Rahau) line thereby keep proceeding with all the other lines in a sequential manner. At times, if rarely, we find more than one rahau in a Shabad. All the Rahaus in that Shabad (usually 2,3 or 4) convey the same central theme: reflect on truth. Gurus thought it appropriate to explain the same central theme in different combination of words and therefore gave more than one Rahau. Asthai - In Keertan (or any music) we find one line keeps getting repeated time and again. This common line, which is repeated each time after a different line, is known as Asthai in Indian Classical Music, or Chorus in the Western Music. Antra - In Keertan (or any music) after singing the Asthai (the repetitive line) a different line is sung, and upon its completion the Asthai is sung again and then a second different line is sung, followed by Asthai. This changing line is known as Antra in Indian Classical Music. The purpose of Keertan is to deliver the Gurus’ message sweetly to the listener. As Rahau has the central theme of the Shabad and contains the spiritual message, its usage, as an Asthai is repeated time and again after every Antra, which helps in the message getting drilled into the listener’s mind. The result is that the Guru’s message gets delivered many times while the Shabad is being sung. This increases the probability of retention of the central theme (Gurmat Vichar) by the listener’s mind. Let me take a very popular Shabad from Siri Raag, Page 44, which is sung by Raagis during a happy occasion in the family. Most of the Sikhs will remember the shabad by its popularly known line: Lakh khushiya patshahiya jey satgur nadar karey .......... It’s commonly found that Raagis make the above line as the Asthai while singing the shabad because of the word Khushiya (Happiness). This line is the second non-Rahau line in the Shabad and gets commonly used as the Asthai while singing. The English translation of the Shabad is: SRI RAAG, MEHLA V: All happiness is achieved only by Thy Grace. The precious gift of this human life becomes fruitful when one chants the True Word. One who has such destiny written on his forehead enters the Mansion of the Lord’s Presence through the Guru. || 1 || O my mind, focus your consciousness on the One. Without the One, all involvlements are worthless; emotional attachment to a mirage is verily false. || 1 || Pause || Hundreds of thousands of princely pleasures are yours to enjoy if the True Guru bestows His Glance of Grace. If He bestows the Name of the Lord, even for a moment, my mind and body are soothed. Those who have such pre-ordained destiny hold tight to the Feet of the True Guru. || 2 || Blessed is that moment, and fruitful is that time, when one is in love with the True Lord. Suffering and sorrow do not touch those who have the Support of the Name of the Lord. Grasping him by the arm, the Guru lifts them up and out, and carries them across to the other side. || 3 || Embellished and immaculate is that place where the Saints gather together. He alone finds shelter who has met the Perfect Guru. Nanak builds his house upon that site where there is no death, no birth, and no old age. || 4 || 6 || 76 || If we were to sing this Shabad in proper Keertan singing style by making Rahau (Mere man eikas sio chit laaye/eikas bin sabh dhund hai/sabh mithiya moh maye) as Asthai for repetition, then upon reaching second Antra, the message that will get repetitively get delivered to the mind will be that we need to first make an effort to get our mind to focus on One God, give up attachment to Maya and emotional entanglements. If we succeed in achieving this state of mind, then (as stated in the second Non-Rahau line) thousands of Pleasures will be attained (only if) if His Grace falls upon us. Note that the CONDITION (Rahau line to be used as Asthai) is that we make the effort to rid our mind of attachment/Maya, then the RESULT (Non-Rahau line to be used as Antra) is - if Satguru deems it worth then he provides hundreds of pleasures to the devotee. Unfortunately, this Shabad is commonly sung by Raagis by making the non-Rahau Line No.2 as the Asthai (Lakh khushiya patshahiya jey satgur nadar karey....), which gets repeated many a times during the Shabad singing. Now see the change in deliverability of the message to our mind. We are seeking from our Guru thousands of pleasures, by His Grace and, upon getting them, we will then strive towards ridding our mind of attachment/Maya! Note that by using the non-Rahau line as Asthai, the CONDITION has changed to: if Satguru deems it worth, then He provides hundreds of pleasures to us and the RESULT (Rahau line being used as Antra) is that we will make the effort to rid our mind of attachment/Maya! By using the non-Rahau line in this Shabad as Asthai, our mind is subconsciously being told to live on HOPE, rather than make the EFFORT, which is the reverse of what the Guru is telling us in this Shabad, viz.- Devotee first makes the EFFORT and then HOPE should arise for His Grace. Interesting....isn’t it? We tend to ignore the finer details of Gurus’ message, which is so clear.................Probably that’s the reason why Sikhs of today lack the spirit/spiritual discipline for which our forefathers were known. I hope people will start making an effort of getting the Sikhs in their immediate contact to understand the importance of Rahau in Keertan singing, and strive towards singing Keertan in the correct manner. Those who are active in Gurudwara Management/teaching Keertan should make it a point to teach to the youth only those Shabads in which Rahau is made the Asthai. For a teacher to correct what he has already learnt in so many years is a tough proposition, but he can definitely make an effort to select those Shabads from his Keertan bank for teaching the youth/children, in which the Rahau is made the Asthai. In this way, we may be able to slowly steer in the direction of true deliverance.amarjeet singh · 16 Feb 2006
this thread has gone compleltely of subject were talkin about how none sikhs shudnt do kirtanLionKing (LK) · 17 Feb 2006
Or how they could do Kirtan, and are and were fully welcome to do so, as well as other sevas.sk · 18 Feb 2006
Harcharan Singh ji, you have not mentioned raag maalkons; is it a raag in Guru Granth Sahib ji? I have not yet come across a shabad in the amrit keertan that has a shabad in that raag.Harcharan Singh · 19 Feb 2006
Dear sk Ji, I have not come across raag maalkons in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Maharaj. Sat-naamLionKing (LK) · 19 Feb 2006
How are shabards in Siri Raag catagorized? I've seen in Siri Raag (the only Raag I've read :P) that In the beginning, it starts with Gurus chronlogically, but then it goes back and fourth, some Shabad by Mhala Tija, Some by Mahal Chautha etc :s Could someone please clearify why this is`?