Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

RSS/Rulda Expose - PW Part III Added - Sant Samaj

RSS/Rulda Expose - PW Part III Added - Sant Samaj

Panthic Weekly Reader · 23 Jan 2006

I noticed that Part III of the expose with Rulda Singh has been added to The Panthic Weekly. http://www.panthic.org/news/125/ARTICLE/2195/2006-01-22.html I'm not sure what to think of this issue. It has focussed on Sant Samaj and even implicated Baba Takhur Singh. I have heard these types of allegations before but this is the first time they have been solidly put foward.

Re: RSS/Rulda Expose - PW Part III Added - Sant Samaj

Niranjan Singh · 23 Jan 2006

I don't think Panthic Weekly implicated anyone in the articles, they just presented what Rulda says, now it is up to the Sangat to figure out whether Rulda is telling the truth or not. What Rulda says also matches what some news papers reported several years ago, so definately there is something going on. I think RSS has succeedeed in their plans and have bought out our "leadership", now the next generation must decide whether to accept such leaders or reject them...

Re: RSS/Rulda Expose - PW Part III Added - Sant Samaj

newbie · 24 Jan 2006

This is good journalism. They have presented the tape and tracked it with news reports. It is for each person to make thier own conclusions. Everyone knows Sant Samaj is totally dodgy. Taksal should never have got involved with them.

Re: RSS/Rulda Expose - PW Part III Added - Sant Samaj

... · 24 Jan 2006

This article does not show anything bad about Sants. The Sants and Taksaal were negotiating with RSS to free Sikh youth from jails. RSS agreed to move forward with this, but Badal blocked this. Where engaging the RSS can do something positive for the Panth, then there's no harm in any meeting. The real panthic.org exclusive would be if they can show the Sants took steps to hurt the Panth. Neither the article nor the Rulda audio show this.

Re: RSS/Rulda Expose - PW Part III Added - Sant Samaj

Wake up to Reality · 24 Jan 2006

well Mokham Singh of Damdami Taksal was present at all meeting the RSS had with the Sant Samaj. He was also chosen to represent the Sant Samaj during the meetings and coordinated with the RSS for further meetings. Mokham Singh will represent Sant Samaj: http://www.panthic.org/data/audio/2005-01-15/Rulda_5member_cmt_kohli_mohkamsingh_reps.mp3 You can hear the views of Mokham Singh regarding Shaheed Singhs who gave everything for the Chardhi Kala of the Khalsa Panth. You can also hear what he suggests to Rulda Singh regarding the death penalty of Bhai Davinderpal Singh Bhullar. Listen closely to the language that Mokham Singh uses for our beloved Shaheeds. Mokham Singhs thoughts regardingh Shaheeds and Davinderpal Singh Bhullar: http://www.panthic.org/data/audio/2005-01-15/Rulda_mohkamsingh_re_bhullar.mp3 The Sant Samaj chose this man as their representative. He calls Shaheed Singhs dogs and says they died a dogs death. This tells you something about how Panthic they are and where they stand.

Re: RSS/Rulda Expose - PW Part III Added - Sant Samaj

singh · 25 Jan 2006

I think there is far more to this than meets the eye. Rulda singh cannot be so stupid to allow this to come out without some hidden purpose. Currently this damages Rulda the most, and finally puts a face to the RSS. Any sikh leaders with any shred of decency would never engage such people. The ones who have, were descredited before even this came out. They are just more discredited now.

Re: RSS/Rulda Expose - PW Part III Added - Sant Samaj

Frank the Man · 25 Jan 2006

It begs the question: Where did they get this tape? How do we really know this is Rulda speaking? Why would he want to share this info? What he is saying could be be merely lies, how are we supposed to know, there is really no proof. They are just allegations, he could be just making it up to cause trouble, which the RSS is well known for. To "Wake up to reality" maybe you should take a dose of your own name. Do you really trust Rulda and that what he is saying is the truth? He has his own agenda which will come out sooner or later. Panthic Weekly does not seem to have published the accused persons version of the events, very shaddy journalism.

Re: RSS/Rulda Expose - PW Part III Added - Sant Samaj

Defender Of The Panth · 25 Jan 2006

the people who have been mentioned by Rulda were suspected of collabarating with RSS, other anti Sikh forces, and government agencies long before these recordings came out. The recordings just make the case against them even stronger If you knew anything about the past 21 years of Sikh History then you would see that these people have never stood with the Khalsa Panth. And if the people mentioned in Rulda Singhs recordings beleive what he says is false then it is up to them to send out a clarification saying so.

Re: RSS/Rulda Expose - PW Part III Added - Sant Samaj

M S Nijjar · 25 Jan 2006

I agree the jounalism is very shady...... .....Also, Rulda wouldn't just allow this kind of information to leak out so easily, it seems to me it has been released on purpose just to cause further devisions in the Panth. Look, the people who don't know about the RSS, don't care anyway, people who do, know they are bad and upto no good, therefore it's not like RSS are going to make proper Singhs like them in anyway so they just release these tapes so that Singhs are discredited and therefore divisions created in the Panth!!! I also question the sources from where these tapes were obtained, and think such garbage should never be shown anyway unless it is 110% credible. There are many Panthic Leaders who have been basically "dissed" in there by being shown as RSS agents basically, inluding Sant Baba Thakur Singh Jee!!! Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa, Vaheguroo Jee Kee Phateh!!!

Re: RSS/Rulda Expose - PW Part III Added - Sant Samaj

M S Nijjar · 25 Jan 2006

These issues cause major conflicts, divisions and problems in the Guroo Pyaree Khalsa Panth and should NEVER be released unless the facts are 110% credible and true!!! O and like to add: THAN THAN MAHAPURKH BRAHMGIANI 108 SANT BABA THAKUR SINGH JEE MUKH SEWADAAR DAMDAMI TAKSAAL!!!!! Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa, Vaheguroo Jee Kee Phateh!!!

Re: RSS/Rulda Expose - PW Part III Added - Sant Samaj

G Singh · 25 Jan 2006

these people never stofdd for the panth for the last 21 years? are you serious? Baba Hari Singh Randhavaywale never stood for the panth? Go to india and look at the schools he has set up, look at the prachar he does. Even if you think baba takhur singh made a mistake by what was said on Sant Gyanee Jarnail Singh Jee, how can you say he hasn't stood with the panth? Why dont you go help out shaheed families like he did, why don't you give up your wealth for shaheed families. Learn about Baba Takhur Singh Jees full story before making such accusations. Even if you dont agree with one thing baba jee did in their whole life, why would you discredit the countless number of other things they did before leaving this world. THe amount of seva done by baba jee is something normal sikhs can only dream of. Half of us would be fortunate to do that much seva is 100 lives.

Re: RSS/Rulda Expose - PW Part III Added - Sant Samaj

Niranjan Singh · 25 Jan 2006

Frank the Man said : "Where did they get this tape? How do we really know this is Rulda speaking? Why would he want to share this info? " The following articel will answer your questions Frank Ji : http://www.panthic.org/news/125/ARTICLE/2160/2006-01-08.html Read : Paragrahps numbered 9 and 10.

Re: RSS/Rulda Expose - PW Part III Added - Sant Samaj

singh · 25 Jan 2006

Mokham Singh being linked to RSS is not a big story in the eyes of most taksalis i think, taksal being one an insititution that has done amazing seva and parchar for the panth, is obviously gona be the victim of government and rss inflitration, Mokham Singh is one of those people.

Re: RSS/Rulda Expose - PW Part III Added - Sant Samaj

The Truth Hurts · 25 Jan 2006

Baba Takhur Singh who you claim is a Brahm Giyani lied to the entire Khalsa Panth in the Hazoori of Dhan Dhan Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji for the past 21 years. Him saying that Shaheed Sant Jarnail Singh Ji Bhindranwale is alive was the biggest gaddari wether you wanna beleive it or not. These statements made in the precense of Dhan Dhan Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji hurt the Sikh Independence movement in a major way. The Damdami Taksal comes out now and says yes Sant Ji was Shaheed all long. So this means that Takhur Singh was not telling the truth, does it not?

Re: RSS/Rulda Expose - PW Part III Added - Sant Samaj

naklisingh · 25 Jan 2006

Dhan Guru ke Piyare!

Re: RSS/Rulda Expose - PW Part III Added - Sant Samaj

Parminder Singh · 26 Jan 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheugur Ji Ki Fateh All knows that what Damdami Taksal served for the panth and what its current position. Doing seva of the panth is very good, but it does not mean that u have got right to HARM the panth or do anything u want. Some time ago, KPS Gill also got the saroopa in Damdami Taksal by Baba Thakur and everybody knows who is KPS Gill. Regarding Rulda's voice authenticity, first of all it is clear that whose tape is this. At that time when he was being trapped, he was showing pictures and documents with whom he has met, like all Nakli Khalistanis, Sant Samaj, Sikh Leaders, and many other high profile peoples. One questions arises here, why didnt he named, Simranjit Singh Mann, Ratinder Singh, or Tapoban Saheb, and many other gursikhs, because he has not met with these peoples, so he didnt named them. For more truth, anybody can contact, the chief of Rashtriya Sikh Sangat and President of BJP NRI wing, Mr. Rulda Singh, on these numbers: 098140-96087 and 0175-235587. Even though if anybody is not satisfied, he can contact Gurcharan Singh Gill, Rashtriya Sikh Sangat President at 094140-23297 n 0141-3092759. For more authenticity, anybody can contact Avinash Jaiswal, Incharge of RSS on behalf of Rashtriya Sikh Sangat at 093131-06523. Know about Bhai Mohkam Singh of Damdami Taksal. Again if anybody is having some doubth or not satisfied, then he can contact him and asked him how many singhs he got released after meeting with RSS; can he named those singhs: at 098554-20126. For more authenticity u can contact Editor chief of Indian Awareness, Sr. Sr. Sarabjeet Singh at -011-25114073, 98111-02260, [address removed]. For reality of these above pathic traitors and sant samaj, u can contact Navkiran Singh JI, the famous advocte from Chandigarh at: 0172-2746122 098144-11494. Now fo the authenticity of the tapes that have been given by Panthic Weekly, has anybody taken pain to conclude how these people have got those tapes, how they trapped, Rulda Singh, what were conditions at that time. Simply sitting outside India gives u picture that this is going something like a fairy tale story or some James Bond Movie. So, do ardaas for those gursikhs who are working behind Panthic Weekly and a group of Singhs are on special duty who are watching activities of RSS since 1990 and wait for some more thundering news in the upcoming weeks. Bhul Chuk Maaf Panth De Kukkar.....

Re: RSS/Rulda Expose - PW Part III Added - Sant Samaj

naklisingh · 26 Jan 2006

Is it true that Rulda is from taksaal?

Re: RSS/Rulda Expose - PW Part III Added - Sant Samaj

Niranjan Singh · 26 Jan 2006

>>> Is it true that Rulda is from taksaal? YES [url]http://www.panthic.org/news/125/ARTICLE/2155/2006-01-08.html[/url] Audio : While reading a document that questions how he is a RSS Sikh and a Taksal member. Rulda Singh responds that he received training from the Damdami Taksal from 1978-1983 [i]“For a total of 5 years. O.P. Gupta, a manager for National Bank of Punjab met him in 1978 and for five years kept working to get him to join the RSS.” [/i] External Reference: [i]“He claims to have received religious education from Damdami Taksal when Sant Kartar Singh was its chief and Sant Bhinderanwale was one of its students.” (RSS Had Secret Meetings With Sikh Hardliners, March 14, 2005, Tribune India)[/i] Audio : Rulda speaks of his relationship with Sant Ji in the Damdami Taksal. [%sig%]

Re: RSS/Rulda Expose - PW Part III Added - Sant Samaj

naklisingh · 27 Jan 2006

When I think of this these things comes into my mind:- (1)Taksaali Singhs are chardi kala singhs and they are targeted everywhere. or (2)Taksaal is full of Brahmanvaad that it is so easy to infiltrate taksaal or (3)For 21 years the Damdami Taksaal has defamed the name of the great Shaeed Jarnail Singh ji Bhindranwale. Rss knows Taksaal has nothing left in them. or (4)Taksaal is too busy with their own politics. Well let's see how Jatha Reacts to it, RSS next goal is Jatha, there is not a single city left where jatha is united. These are the two Jathebandis panth is focused on because it is hard to find Gursikhs in other Jathebandis. Let's blame RSS for everything and Sit back and watch because we are chardikala gurmukhs doing simran everyday and taking care of our families, just pray to Guruji and he will help us. Let's just do kirtan, simran and play gatka and wear new domalla and chola and start calling your freind gurmukh so you would get the same response back! [%sig%]

Re: RSS/Rulda Expose - PW Part III Added - Sant Samaj

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 28 Jan 2006

Sant Samaaj and Taksaal are cooperating in the so called Vishav Sikh Samelan....read the Open Letter on the vishavsamelan thread...

Re: RSS/Rulda Expose - PW Part III Added - Sant Samaj

singh · 31 Jan 2006

Who is Bhai Ranjit Singh?

Re: RSS/Rulda Expose - PW Part III Added - Sant Samaj

singh · 31 Jan 2006

It is not a question of fully accepting everything that RSS or Rulda say. If Mokham singh and co deny this then they should make a statement to Panthic weekly. Sant samaj has been mixed up with RSS for years. The biggest mistake taksal made was getting mixed up with sant samaj aswell.

Re: RSS/Rulda Expose - PW Part III Added - Sant Samaj

M S Nijjar · 01 Feb 2006

In the coming Sundays issue, the paper will be getting the official reaction from organisations and the indviduals that have been mentioned in the last few issues and by Rulda. Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa, Vaheguroo Jee Kee Phateh!!!

Re: RSS/Rulda Expose - PW Part III Added - Sant Samaj

Bijla Singh · 03 Feb 2006

I think many people are getting confused over what the actual truth is and what is presented. First of all, what Panthic Weekly (PW) has presented is not their own opinions but rulda's statements which could be false. I do not care about the present state of taksal but I do respect puratan taksal (pre 84) very much so here are some questions for everyone to ponder upon. ------------------------ ****External Reference: “He claims to have received religious education from Damdami Taksal when Sant Kartar Singh was its chief and Sant Bhinderanwale was one of its students.” (RSS Had Secret Meetings With Sikh Hardliners, March 14, 2005, Tribune India)**** ------------------------ Now compare the above reference with rulda's statement: ------------------------ ****While reading a document that questions how he is a RSS Sikh and a Taksal member. Rulda Singh responds that he received training from the Damdami Taksal from 1978-1983**** ------------------------ According to rulda he joined taksal in 78, one year after the death of Sant Kartar Singh Ji. Then how could he receive training from Sant Ji? Obviously either tribune or rulda is lying. time will tell the truth. Now the next statement rulda makes is the following: ------------------------ ****For a total of 5 years. O.P. Gupta, a manager for National Bank of Punjab met him in 1978 and for five years kept working to get him to join the RSS**** ------------------------ He clearly says that from 78-83 gupta tried to get him to join RSS which means while rulda was a student of taksal he was NOT a member of the RSS. he joined afterwards though he doesn't specify when. Thre are two possibilities: 1) Either he received training from Sant Kartar Singh Ji - Tribune or 2) He joined taksal in 78 - Rulda's own statement It is up to you to decide which one to believe in but here are some more questions to think about: 1) Assuming rulda is from taksal and joined rss later on, is it really the fault of Taksal or Sant Ji? Anyone from any jatha could join anti-panthic groups. The fault is of the individual not of the jatha. 2) what year did rulda join rss? did he join rss before coming to taksal or after he left taksal or maybe during the time he was a student of taksal? Assuming he joined rss before coming to taksal (contrary his own statement) did Sant Ji know about this and still let him join? The list of questions goes on but one thing is clear that neither Sant Ji nor Taksal is to be blamed for the misdeeds of rulda. PW is no way states that rss or its members (rulda in this case) had good relations with Taksal in late 70s. Sant Ji stood against anti-panthic groups and there is no way he could've had good relations with rss. PW clearly states that the official statements of the other side will be published so no need to jump to conclusions right away. Just because something gets printed on PW doesn't mean it is the absolute truth because they are simply presenting the information they have obtained and the allegations rulda has made. We have to decide with some rationality whether what rulda says is true or not. ------------------------ ****Some time ago, KPS Gill also got the saroopa in Damdami Taksal by Baba Thakur and everybody knows who is KPS Gill. **** ------------------------ Parminder Singh Ji, can you provide some evidence on this? The article on khalsa alliance website clarifies this point. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh [%sig%]