Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

How would you answer?

How would you answer?

Bhopinder Singh · 22 Jan 2006

Lets say you go for a trip to India .You are a amritdhari rehitvaan singh and you are asked by a Punjab Police official . Your views about Khalistan. Even though you have never been involved in any sought of millitancy,but there is no assurance of safety (Duniavi Worldly) at the same time their is no fear like the days of active freedom struggle. My thanks in advance. [%sig%]

Re: How would you answer?

priceless · 22 Jan 2006

ehde vich puchhan vali gal ki hei bha bhopinder singh sacha amritdhari rehitvaan singh sach bolan to darega nahi par pakhandi (shaid mei vee unna vichoon hee haan) ik dam jan gan man goun lag peiga. Par, koi siddha saadha sikh jis nu apnei guru tei poora bharosa hei zaroor datt jeiga chahe kehen nu bebeiki naa hove. asal vich satgur bachan kamavanei ta uss velei hee saabat hundei han jei saamney pattaa hovei taa vee een nahi manee jaei, naahi taa sab dhong hee hei. sach gal taa eh hai kei bahutei bebeiki kahaoun valei eho jihe hee mildei han. gustakhi maaf sach bolan dee par sach eh hee hei. Hain Viralae Naahee Ghanae Fail Fakarr sansaar [%sig%]

Re: How would you answer?

True Story · 22 Jan 2006

True Story, my 2 bros are monas.. they went to the place in the wagha border where they have like police marching. The Pakistanis were saying 'Pakistan Zindibad', the Hindustanis were saying 'Hindustan Zindibad'.. My bros said 'Khalistan Zindibad'... 2 Police guards came up to them, and they still said Khalistan Zindibad.. They were 8,7 at the time and they know what happended during the late 80s/golden temple attack and such.. If an amrithdari guy couldn't express his views, and if your talking about an adult male.. then i dunno.

Re: How would you answer?

Swinder Singh · 23 Jan 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI Fateh Mr.Simarnjeet Singh here in India is openly advocating for the independent sikh state. Then there is no point for you to hold on your views on the subject. Air your views in a decent manner, with proper reasoning the need for khalistan. Gur Fateh ji

Re: How would you answer?

Kulbir Singh · 23 Jan 2006

It all depends on the Singh's mauj. I don't think a Singh is obligated to answer every question that a manmukh police wala asks him. What is the point in answering this question? Veer Bhopinder Singh jeeo, I give you another scenario. Say you know where a certain Singh is hiding. Police is looking for this Singh. They ask you about his whereabouts. Would you tell them the truth and disclose his whereabouts? Or would you just keep quiet and exercise your right to stay silent? Or perhaps diplomatically dodge the question? Whether you believe in Khalistan as a country of 12 zilas (districts) or in Khalsa Raj including whole of Hindustan and much more, there is no need to disclose your "Dil dee gal" to a manmukh policewala. Having said that, at times when the Baaghi (rebel) instinct of Khalsa takes over him, he (or she) may openly defy the police and say whatever he pleases. It all depends on the circumstances and the avastha or mauj of Khalsa at a given time. Kulbir Singh

Re: How would you answer?

Harjinder Singh · 23 Jan 2006

In my humble opinion, it all depends on your love and bharosa for Guru Sahib. Those who have true faith will not change their stand with circumstances. In other words, our submission can only be tested in such a situation where we have death as only choice for keeping our faith. Guru Sahib gave us the birth in his house taking our head. So it’s clear what is price we've to pay for keeping Sikhi. I totally agree with priceless ji here. I have personally experienced this lot. I have seen those who seemed to us very loose in rehat but proved their love to guru sahib by giving head. On the other hand, most of the people showing their outward rehat and judging others, failed in such a test every time and all they worried was safety of their own life and forgot at all when they gave their head to Guru Sahib. I believe that all those who have taken birth in the house of Guru Sahib by taking Khandey dee pahul are equal brother and sisters and are legally married to Waheguru/Guru. Those, who have the love still in their heart, will have to get married to legalize their marriage bond with guru Sahib by going through the same enlistment procedure. We should not judge anyone's rehat other than if it is a bajjar kurehit because only that proves the divorce. That does not mean rehat is not necessary. The more we keep it, the better it makes our ability/state to reach the complete submission and merge with our lord. But it is my understanding that keeping rehat is like a wife keeps her virginity for her husband only and no one else. So all what matters is if the husband accepts her love and embrace her. She does not need to prove it to any body else. Likewise, a Sikh (wife) keeps his rehat for his guru (husband). If we can understand this, I believe that most of mess-up situation in Guru Khalsa Panth will be over. Let us all believe in each other and help each other to uplift. Although each of us has to separately please our husband for ourselves but we have one thing in common which is our husband is one. That is what make all of us become the one Panth because we are on one path. Let us not go into checking the virginity of each other because that is the job of our husband. Our job is to achieve his happiness and help each other for the same. But that is only possible if we recognize each other with equal respect and do not doubt the integrity of each other’s relation with Guru Sahib. Bhul chuk maaf [%sig%]

Re: How would you answer?

Bhopinder Singh · 23 Jan 2006

Veer Kulbir singh ji If you read my question carefully I made the parameters very clear ie no threat to the life or property of third person.Clearly under the cicumstances you mauj thing seems more of something else which is against the instruction of panj and is also a lie.I cant understand how your question is related to the given senario,unless you did say so in some past situation ,even then you were free to write what you want on this forum. Having said that I respectfully and humbly am trying to answer your question Although I was never involved in any sought of millitant activity ,but the situation of those days was such that any sikh was picked up for questioning as we lived in Punjad till 1990 and you do know many people in your surroundings. This did happen to me .Yes when thay came to ask I ran away and for 3 days nothing was known about me .SHO Joshi requested my father that if he could arrange our meeting just for 1 miute he would let me go.My father a devout rehitvaan singh all his life came to my place of hididng and narrated to me the whole incident ,I refused to go which then ment absconding .While leaving me their my father did tell me that since that was my decesion I should keep going forward and never turn my back or get daag for the entire family which clearly ment shahdee.Fortunately the lies of the police fell apart and I was left also it is never like I ask you ,you tell me thing ,if they asked you about some singh. I wrote this to tell you about how rehitvaan singh behave under such situations ( my father) although I myself was more scared of the torture ,to be honest and I will not lie about that. ________________________________________________________ Whether you believe in Khalistan as a country of 12 zilas (districts) or in Khalsa Raj including whole of Hindustan and much more, _________________________________________________________ Nowhere did I ask about your defination of Khalistan or gave mine so let us leave it . [%sig%]

Re: How would you answer?

Kulbir Singh · 23 Jan 2006

Veer Bhopinder Singh jeeo, You asked what a Singh would do if asked about his opinion on Khalistan. My response is that a Singh is not obligated to answer to the Policewala. It does not matter whether the singh is facing any pressure or not. A Singh has the right not respond to this query by a Sarkari Manmukhi Policewala. I had no hidden agenda when I wrote that scenario in my previous post. My only aim was to bring forth a situation in which a Singh must keep quiet and not disclose the whereabouts of the fugitive Singh to the police. Telling the truth in this matter would be disastrous. Kulbir Singh

Re: How would you answer?

Kulbir Singh · 23 Jan 2006

Veer Harjinder Singh jeeo, ----- I totally agree with priceless ji here. I have personally experienced this lot. I have seen those who seemed to us very loose in rehat but proved their love to guru sahib by giving head. On the other hand, most of the people showing their outward rehat and judging others, failed in such a test every time and all they worried was safety of their own life and forgot at all when they gave their head to Guru Sahib. ------ Veer jeeo, what are you trying to say above? Are you suggesting that keeping less rehit is better than keeping more rehit or are you suggesting that it does not matter whether we keep rehit or not and keeping more rehit does not affect one’s spirituality for the good? Reading your paragraph a gullible Sikh will come to the conclusion that it does not matter whether he keeps Bibek or not. I know that your intention is not to discourage people from keeping rehit but what you are trying to say is that along with keeping rehit one should also do sewa of Panth and be of strong determination. Veer jeeo, I totally agree with you if this is what you are trying to say. We must keep rehit and we must strive to bring chardi kala in Panth by doing the required sewa of Panth. This is the reason why I started that thread of "What sewa is of utmost importance for Panth now". I personally feel that this is the time for doing sewa of Parchaar and to bring awareness of basics of Sikhi in people. Of course other sewas can be done as well and there is no stopping anyone from that. -------------- I believe that all those who have taken birth in the house of Guru Sahib by taking Khandey dee pahul are equal brother and sisters and are legally married to Waheguru/Guru. Those, who have the love still in their heart, will have to get married to legalize their marriage bond with guru Sahib by going through the same enlistment procedure. We should not judge anyone's rehat other than if it is a bajjar kurehit because only that proves the divorce. --------- In the above paragraph I get the impression that the only rehit we should judge is the Bajjar Kurehit. Gurbani instructs us to discern Manmukhs from Gurmukhs. One of the rehit of Khalsa is to keep Bibek. Bibek means eating from the hands of tyaar bar tyaar Khalsa. For tyar bar tyaari the least one should look at is Bajjar Kurehits, Punj Kakaari rehit, basic nitnem, and daswandh. In addition to these, Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee used to also look at whether a person is Bibeki or not before eating from such person’s hands. Please refer to Jail Chithian (Multan Jail part of it). ---------- That does not mean rehat is not necessary. The more we keep it, the better it makes our ability/state to reach the complete submission and merge with our lord. --------- I don’t think the outer rehit i.e. kakaars, bajjar kurehits, daswandh etc. are optional. One must keep all these rehits. One does not have a choice between picking and choosing rehits. ------------ But it is my understanding that keeping rehat is like a wife keeps her virginity for her husband only and no one else. So all what matters is if the husband accepts her love and embrace her. She does not need to prove it to any body else. Likewise, a Sikh (wife) keeps his rehat for his guru (husband). If we can understand this, I believe that most of mess-up situation in Guru Khalsa Panth will be over. Let us all believe in each other and help each other to uplift. Although each of us has to separately please our husband for ourselves but we have one thing in common which is our husband is one. That is what make all of us become the one Panth because we are on one path. Let us not go into checking the virginity of each other because that is the job of our husband. Our job is to achieve his happiness and help each other for the same. But that is only possible if we recognize each other with equal respect and do not doubt the integrity of each other’s relation with Guru Sahib. ---------- The question of checking your fellow gursikh’s rehit arises only when an important sewa comes up. When doing sewa in langar, proper sudhaayee should be done before giving this sewa to individuals. Same thing for Siri Akhand Paath Sahib and not to mention the Amrit Sinchaar Sewa. Only those individuals who keep the basic rehit should be allowed to do these sewas. This may not be a popular thing to say but this is what my meagre understanding is at this time after reading life and books of Gursikhs like Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee. In normal dealings, I totally agree with you that we should not judge one’s rehit. It is not our business to judge what others are doing. Only when there is a question of maryada, we have to do sudhaayee of each other. Kulbir Singh

Re: How would you answer?

Kulbir Singh · 23 Jan 2006

----- If you read my question carefully I made the parameters very clear ie no threat to the life or property of third person.Clearly under the cicumstances you mauj thing seems more of something else which is against the instruction of panj and is also a lie. -------- Veer Bhopinder Singh jeeo, I forgot to answer this part of your post. I don’t understand how, not answering to policewala’s unreasonable question amounts to going against the hukam of Punj and how is a lie? It’s my “dil dee gal”. Why should I disclose it to Policemen? During the initial questioning of Bhai Sahib, he too refused to answer the questions of policemen. Please refer to Jail Chithian for more details. Not answering such unreasonable question of Policewalay is not against Gurmat. Having said that, I should make it clear that I personally have never been asked such a question by anyone. Kulbir Singh

Re: How would you answer?

Shaktishali Sha Soora · 23 Jan 2006

VahegurooJekaKhalsaVahegurooJekeFateh Punjab Police official: What are your views on Khalistan? Gursikh: Well Khalistan is the savior of the world, the cure of Manmukhs and the instrument of defeat for the wicked. It is basically the light in this dark house. That is what Khalistan is and something like that should be kept personal. Guru Gobind Singh Jee didn’t ever discuss Khalistan with the Muslims or Hindus but with the Sikh. For example, when a Gursikh attains a spiritual experience, that experience is meant to be left a secret between Vaheguru Jee and the Gursikh, since if it was told to another it would have a negative effect on the Gursikh. Similarly a Manmukh isn’t meant to know about the existence of Khalistan that resides in a Khalsa’s heart, as Khalistan is the end of the Manmukh Kind. VahegurooJekaKhalsaVahegurooJekeFateh [%sig%]

Re: How would you answer?

Bhopinder Singh · 23 Jan 2006

Whether you believe in Khalistan as a country of 12 zilas (districts) or in Khalsa Raj including whole of Hindustan and much more __________________________________________________________ Veer Kulbir singh ji Same line is common for every sarkari sikh,I think most of us can remmember this line being towed from GOI to every chamcha sikh opposing soverign sikh state. ___________________________________________________________ that a Singh is not obligated to answer to the Policewala. __________________________________________________________ You say that in defiance or as a rebel Since you chose to mix the whole issue ,which made me think you might have done the opposite in past.Rest Guru sahib knows .I still think your insertion of whereabout of another sikh was not appropriate.

Re: How would you answer?

Kulbir Singh · 23 Jan 2006

Veer Bhopinder Singh jeeo, You are very well aware of my views on Khalistan. You should be the last person on Earth whom I should be explaining my position on a sovereign Sikh state. Having said that, I am a firm believer and I think I conveyed to you orally too that at all those places where Guru Sahib Takhats are situated, Khalsa Raj will come. Takhat Patna Sahib and Takhat Hazur Sahib will be centres of Sikhi around those areas. All those places where Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee did his Udaasis (travelled to) will be under Khalsa Raj. To believe in such Khalsa Raj as stated in paragraph 2 above does not mean that you don't support a sovereign Sikh state in Punjab state. You should not jump to conclusions so fast. Kulbir Singh

Re: How would you answer?

Bhopinder Singh · 23 Jan 2006

Shaktishali Sha Soora ji As always your answers are more mystic ,please spare us this time.I am least interested in your visions and so are many on this phorum.Instead of this hotch-potch isn't it more suitable to say ,I support it from my heart ,rest is upto waheguru ji . Will that make you loose your nam kamai BOL SO DHARMIADE MON KAT DHARI RAM Why guru Teg Bahadur ji gave his sees to manmukh Aurangjeb .He could have said the same since he was manmukh to,I dont need to go there.

Re: How would you answer?

Shaktishali Sha Soora · 23 Jan 2006

VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh Bhai Sahib Bhopinder Singh Jeeo. jis a(n)dhar thaath paraaee hovai this dhaa kadhae n hovee bhalaa || One whose heart is filled with jealousy of others, never comes to any good. Even we're manmukhs if we don't completely devote our lives to Guru Jee, a Sikh is a Manmukh if he indulges in worldliness or commits a sin. Basically anyone is a Manmukh if they don't devote their lives only to Vaheguru Jee while rejecting all else. Furthermore, what I've said in my post only refers to the Khalsa, which are only a few in this world even though there's so many Sikhs. 'I support it from my heart ,rest is upto waheguru ji .' Oh yeh, and that is a good line, thanks Veer Jee. Finally, what visions are you talking about? VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh

Re: How would you answer?

Bhopinder Singh · 23 Jan 2006

Shaktishali Sha Soora ji jis a(n)dhar thaath paraaee hovai this dhaa kadhae n hovee bhalaa || One whose heart is filled with jealousy of others, never comes to any good ___________________________________________________________ Totally out of context .What makes you think I an jealous of you,for Gods sake I dont even know who you are. ____________________________________________________________ Even we're manmukhs if we don't completely devote our lives to Guru Jee, a Sikh is a Manmukh if he indulges in worldliness or commits a sin. Basically anyone is a Manmukh if they don't devote their lives only to Vaheguru Jee while rejecting all else _______________________________________________________ Again why do you always want to preach.It seems like you are full of knowledge.I know that stuff come to the point.

Re: How would you answer?

Shaktishali Sha Soora · 23 Jan 2006

VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVaheguroojekeFateh guramukh bhagath ghatt chaanan hoe || The Gurmukh has the light of devotional worship within his heart. Bhai Sahib Jeeo, just as the Naam has been implanted inside of a Sikh when taken Amrit so is spiritual wisdom whereas Manmukhs, which are caught in the illusion of Maya are implanted with false and a cursed seed. The Khalsa and manmukhs are two factions of the opposite, as the Khalsa is covered with goodness whereas the Manmukh is covered with badness even though they both contain the same light of Vaheguru Jee. Similarly, Gurbani states many times that the thoughts of the both of these are completely different due to the fact that the demons have corrupted the mind of the Manmukh and so he only thinks of enjoying his/her life whereas the Khalsa only finds comfort in devotion to Guru Jee. Hence, Khalistan is only about devotion to Guru Jee – understand this. guramukh bhagath jug chaarae hoee || To live as Gurmukh is devotional worship, throughout the four ages. Therefore, how can a Manmukh ever understand the concept of Khalistan - they hate everything about it so what’s the use in telling them, when at the end of it they would have the urge to thrash you. ‘Why guru Teg Bahadur ji gave his sees to manmukh Aurangjeb .He could have said the same since he was manmukh to,I dont need to go there.’ The Khalsa shall always have love for a Manmukh but the love back from the Manmukh shall never be received due to their hatred for goodness. Finally, there are only a few you can express your view on Khalistan with – choose wisely because if you don’t you just may regret it. Kirpa karka forgive me if I’ve offended you in any way, as I do not mean to argue with another light. parr parr pa(n)ddith vaadh vakhaanehi bin boojhae sukh n hoee || Reading and studying, the religious scholars argue and debate; but without understanding, there is no peace. VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVaheguroojekeFateh [%sig%]

Re: How would you answer?

................... · 23 Jan 2006

////// I totally agree with priceless ji here. I have personally experienced this lot. I have seen those who seemed to us very loose in rehat but proved their love to guru sahib by giving head. On the other hand, most of the people showing their outward rehat and judging others, failed in such a test every time and all they worried was safety of their own life and forgot at all when they gave their head to Guru Sahib. ////// Veer Harjinder singh jeeo, Muaaf karna your above comments are irritating and irresponsible. I am wondering if you are trying to mislead innocent sikhs on a special purpose or you really don't have enough knowledge of Gurmat. How could a Guru pyaara condemn Guru jee's rehat by using this kind of poor examples? In above statement you tried your best to prove that a manmukh is much better than a rehatvaan Gursikh. Firstly, you must know Gursikhs keep rehat to obey Guru's hukam not for showing. secondly, one who keeps rehat, cannot forget his Guru and the price of Amrit because One tries his best to fulfill his promise of obeying Guru jee's all hukams, which promise was made at the time of taking Amrit. On other hand, One who does not keep rehat, is totally ignorant, selfish and a big lier because that One, by not keeping rehat and by criticising Guru jee's rehat and rehatvaan Gursikhs, is showing his back to Guru jee and knowingly ignoring and breaking that promise of obeying all hukams of Guru jee in price of which hukams one had got that precious Daat of Amrit. How a person, who can not sacrifice his worldly desires but will sacrifice Guru jee's hukam of keeping rehat, could sacrifice his life for Guru jee? This is funny. Think again with cool mind and do ardaas to get sojhee of Gurmat. Thirdly, there is nothing wrong, if a person seeks safety because if asking for safety was wrong then Why Dasmesh jee had wrote "Choupaee Sahib"? Read " Chaupaee Sahib" with consentration and try to understand what Guru jee is asking for through this Bani. Bhul chuk dee muaafee jee. I could not understand if there is any spiritual or worldly benifit of this thread for khalsa panth. This kind of topics are only to spread hatred towards rehatvaan Gursikhs and Guru jee's rehat, which should be totally ignored because this kind of people have nothing to do with spirituality and are stuck with their own ego. This forum is to discuss Gurmat and other sikh issues to help each other to walk on Gurmat path to reach our distination(Sachkhand). [gurbani]gurisK mIq clhu gur cwlI ][/gurbani] gurasikh meeth chalahu gur chaalee || O Sikhs of the Guru, O friends, walk on the Guru's Path. [gurbani] jo guru khY soeI Bl mwnhu hir hir kQw inrwlI ]1] rhwau ] [/gurbani]jo gur kehai soee bhal maanahu har har kathhaa niraalee ||1|| rehaao || Whatever the Guru says, accept that as good; the sermon of the Lord, Har, Har, is unique and wonderful. ||1||Pause|| [gurbani]rihq ibnw nih isK khwvY, rihq ibnw dir cotw KwvY[/gurbani] [%sig%]

Re: How would you answer?

Bhopinder Singh · 26 Jan 2006

How a person, who can not sacrifice his worldly desires but will sacrifice Guru jee's hukam of keeping rehat, could sacrifice his life for Guru jee? This is funny. Think again with cool mind and do ardaas to get sojhee of Gurmat. ___________________________________________________________ ................... ji First of all ,if you think of yourself as a defender of rehit have the sincerity and courage to write your name.Any written dacument loses its essence or importance without a name and becomes a mischief. If you focus on your above lines .In reality this did happen there were many people like that for each rehitvaan singh I can name 1000 non rehitvaan singhs giving their heads to guru sahib during the freedom struggle and you wont have more than 20 singhs rehitvaan but,my count of thousand wont stop . Not even once the author has tried to belittle rehit or deny its importance infact and I quote "That does not mean rehat is not necessary. The more we keep it, the better it makes our ability/state to reach the complete submission and merge with our lord". I know your diversions so I repeat NO ONE CAN DARE BELITTLE REHIT AS IT IS BEYOUND THAT.Which means nobody can touch it. Dass was only 15 years old in 1984 during militaryoperation and the call of Sant Jarnail singh to come out after the military assault on Darbar sahib . I still remmember a trolly full of villagers machine gunned by the indian army they just started from homes and i myself pulled their bodies out with many, not even one had kakkars.They just told their families its call from guru ji and knew the odds of reaching their were none but ,still the love for guru was overwhelming and I think you would have thought otherwise since the odds were such why? here i go ___________________________________________________________ Thirdly, there is nothing wrong, if a person seeks safety because if asking for safety was wrong then Why Dasmesh jee had wrote "Choupaee Sahib"? Read " Chaupaee Sahib" with consentration and try to understand what Guru jee is asking for through this Bani. __________________________________________________________ What are you talking about ?I should rather say how dare you judge that guru ji is asking for safety?Read this please Shastran se at he ran bheeetar joojh marooo to sach patijay this is whish of Dashmesh ji .He is doing benti for that to Akal Purakh and more Akal USTAT JI KAHO KAL TE BHAAJ KE BACHIAT TE KAHO KUNT KAHAA BHAJ JAI HAI AGE HOO KALL KHADA AS GAJAT CHAGAT HAI TEH TE NAS JAIE HAI never could he ask of safety you are talking about inother words what you have deduced is not safety but,cowardice it is crystal clear. Safety from Kaam and four other vikars that make one coward and ask for protection. Khalsa is in the protection of akal the fearless and theirfore fearless but,offcourse Khalsa .As all others do ask safety and are given by Akal inthe form of Khalsa . A rehitvaan singh will ask for the battle with evil not seeing the odds of making sense or not like Garja singh and Bota singh SHAHEED .Did you see their odds.

Re: How would you answer?

Kulbir Singh · 26 Jan 2006

--------- If you focus on your above lines .In reality this did happen there were many people like that for each rehitvaan singh I can name 1000 non rehitvaan singhs giving their heads to guru sahib during the freedom struggle and you wont have more than 20 singhs rehitvaan but,my count of thousand wont stop . ---------- Veer Bhopinder Singh jeeo, Pray, tell me what conclusion you are drawing from this statement? Are you saying that keeping rehit is not good? Or are you saying that ones who don't keep rehit are better than rehitvaan Singhs? Or are you saying that rehitvaan Singhs did not contribute in this movement? What do you want to say here? By giving the example that you can name 1000 non-rehitvaan Singhs giving heads to Guru Sahib and only 20 rehitvaan Singhs giving head, you are glorifying non-rehitvaan Singhs. Having said that, I should mention that your statement is not correct. As a percentage, rehitvaan Singhs (sarlbohi) suffered way more than non-rehitvaans. The movement was started by Sarblohis and Sarblohis were not spared in this movement. Only few of the Sarblohi Singhs were not touched by the police. Most of them suffered severely in the hands of police. Go to India and speak to Sarblohi Singhs who were of age of maturity in the 80s and you will find that a vast majority of them suffered. Also, compare the percentage of Ghaddaars (traitors). How many Sarblohis were traitors and how many non-sarblohis were traitors? What about the leadership? All the traitor Akalis are non-sarblohis. All sellouts are non-Sarblohis. Pretty much 99.999% of all traitors were and are non-sarblohis. You say that non-rehitvaans gave heads to Guru Sahib. As for giving head to Guru Sahib, the only way to do this is by offering your head to Punj Pyaray. Unless one gives head to Punj Pyaray, no one can offer head to Guru Sahib. We read history and see that Bhai Dalla jee helped Guru Sahib greatly but when he asked for space in the charan of Guru Sahib in Sach Khand, Guru Sahib replied saying that only if one takes amrit one can get space in Sach Khand. Guru Sahib offered Bhai Dalla Raaj Bhaag but did not agree to give him a spot in Sach Khand. Without amrit nothing is right. One can make emotional statements but everything has to be tested against maryada and Gurmat. Amrit is a must and Rehit is a must for amrit. Without amrit one cannot get acceptance and without rehit one's amrit does not stay. I do understand your emotions and realize the sympathy and love you have for everyone who gave their lives for the Sikh cause. I too have the respect and admiration for these individuals. But by the same token, we should not realise that it's not dying in the battlefield that will give us place in Guru Sahib's charan but winning the inner battle will enable us to claim place in Guru Sahib's charan. Lakh Soortan Sangram, rann meh chhutay praan || What is needed is to control the 5 vices, and other evils of our mind. We must tame the mind through Gurmat Naam and strict Rehit discipline that Guru Sahib has blessed us with. Only then we can get khushi of Guru Sahib. Fateh will surely come to Khala but it will come only when we become Khalsa of Guru Sahib. If we don't become Khalsa, how will Fateh come? A Khalsa is such who is tyaar bar tyaar in Rehit and Naam Abhyaas. A Khalsa should have many qualities but one quality that he must have is Naam Abhyaas - Paath and Rehit. Vijay will come with kirpa and kirpa will come if we obey hukams and keep rehit and japp Naam. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: How would you answer?

............. · 27 Jan 2006

///// First of all ,if you think of yourself as a defender of rehit have the sincerity and courage to write your name.Any written dacument loses its essence or importance without a name and becomes a mischief. ///// This is funny statement. Who is serious, the one, who defends Guru's Rehat or the one who is trying his best to condemn Guru's rehat using baseless examples? Name does not make any difference for discussing Gurmat. The thing is to adopt and preach Gurmat or to preach against Gurmat to satisfy our ego. ///// there were many people like that for each rehitvaan singh I can name 1000 non rehitvaan singhs giving their heads to guru sahib during the freedom struggle and you wont have more than 20 singhs rehitvaan but,my count of thousand wont stop. ///// Wah Wah! you are saying non-Amritdharies and non-rehatvaans are better than rehatvaans. So, you are trying to prove that there is no need to be Gursikhs. Fight in a battle field and that's all. According to your philosophy, there is no need of Khande-battay-dee pahul, no need to keep kes, no need to keep rehat and ultimatly no need to listen to/follow Guru Sahiban. There are millions who have died while fighting in battlefield why only thousands? In Asa dee Vaar, Guru Sahib Says: [gurbani] lK sUrqx sMgrwm rx mih Cutih prwx ][/gurbani] lakh soorathan sa(n)garaam ran mehi shhuttehi paraan || hundreds of thousands of courageous actions and giving up the breath of life on the field of battle. About giving heads to Guru Sahib jee, Kulbir Singh jee has said it all in light of Gurmat. There is nothing more I can add to that. A rehatvaan single khalsa is better than sawaa lakh manmukhs. Sikhi is not about quantity it is all about quality. ///// Not even once the author has tried to belittle rehit or deny its importance infact and I quote "That does not mean rehat is not necessary. The more we keep it, the better it makes our ability/state to reach the complete submission and merge with our lord". ///// What's the point of argument then. You are trying not only in this thread but in many others on this forum to belittle Guru jee's rehat by using even baseless points. The recent example is your above quoted statement about non-rehatvaans giving their heads..... You are condemning it and then denying your actions at same time. This is not Gursikh's achaar. A true sikh should take a stand according to Gurmat without worrying of the consequences. Playing around with Gurmat to kill time is not bravery. ///// Dass was only 15 years old in 1984 during militaryoperation and the call of Sant Jarnail singh to come out after the military assault on Darbar sahib . I still remmember a trolly full of villagers machine gunned by the indian army they just started from homes and i myself pulled their bodies out with many, not even one had kakkars.They just told their families its call from guru ji and knew the odds of reaching their were none but ,still the love for guru was overwhelming and I think you would have thought otherwise since the odds were such why? here i go ////// What are you trying to prove here. NOTHING. According to your policy, those who were in India at the time of 1984 attack and are still alive, did not get shaheed and came to foreign countries are loosers [gurbani](BgOVy)[/gurbani] of khalsa panth. You were there, so what about you? Did you take another birth or you are writing from heaven? ___________________________________________________________ Thirdly, there is nothing wrong, if a person seeks safety because if asking for safety was wrong then Why Dasmesh jee had wrote "Choupaee Sahib"? Read " Chaupaee Sahib" with consentration and try to understand what Guru jee is asking for through this Bani. __________________________________________________________ ///// What are you talking about ?I should rather say how dare you judge that guru ji is asking for safety?Read this please Shastran se at he ran bheeetar joojh marooo to sach patijay this is whish of Dashmesh ji .He is doing benti for that to Akal Purakh and more Akal USTAT JI KAHO KAL TE BHAAJ KE BACHIAT TE KAHO KUNT KAHAA BHAJ JAI HAI AGE HOO KALL KHADA AS GAJAT CHAGAT HAI TEH TE NAS JAIE HAI never could he ask of safety you are talking about inother words what you have deduced is not safety but,cowardice it is crystal clear. Safety from Kaam and four other vikars that make one coward and ask for protection. Khalsa is in the protection of akal the fearless and theirfore fearless but,offcourse Khalsa .As all others do ask safety and are given by Akal inthe form of Khalsa . //// In other words you are challeging Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee in your above comments about asking about safety. Here you go: [gurbani]pwÚ10kibXobwcbynqI]cOpeI] hmrIkrohwQdYr`Cw]pUrnhoieicqkIie`Cw] qvcrnnmnrhYhmwrw]ApnwjwnkropRiqpwrw]1] hmrydustsBYqumGwvhu]AwpuhwQdYmoihbcwvhu] suKIbsYmoropirvwrw]syvkis`KsBYkrqwrw]2] mor`CwinjkrdYkirXY]sBbYrnkoAwjsMGirXY] pUrnhoiehmwrIAwsw]qorBjnkIrhYipAwsw]3] qumihCwifkoeIAvrniDXwaUN]jobrchoNsuqumqypwaUN] syvkis`KhmwryqwrIAih]cuincuinsqRhmwrymwrIAih]4] AwphwQdYmuJYaubirXY]mrnkwlkwqRwsinvirXY] hUjosdwhmwryp`Cw]sRIAisDujjUkirXhur`Cw]5] rwiKlyhumuihrwKnhwry]swihbsMqshwieipXwry] dInbMDudustnkyhMqw]qumhopurIcqurdskMqw]6] kwlpwiebRhmwbpuDrw]kwlpwieisvjUAvqrw] kwlpwiekribsnupRkwsw]sklkwlkwkIAwqmwsw]7] jvnkwljogIisvkIE]bydrwjbRhmwjUQIE] jvnkwlsBloksvwrw]nmskwrhYqwihhmwrw]8] jvnkwlsBjgqbnwXo]dyvdYqj`CnaupjwXo] AwidAMiqeykYAvqwrw]soeIgurUsmiJXhuhmwrw]9] nmskwriqshIkohmwrI]sklpRjwijnAwpsvwrI] isvknkoisvgunsuKdIE]s`qRünkoplmobDkIE]10] GtGtkyAMqrkIjwnq]BlyburykIpIrpCwnq] cItIqykuMcrAsQUlw]sBprik®pwidRsitkrPUlw]11] sMqnduKpweyqyduKI]suKpweyswDnkysuKI] eykeykkIpIrpCwnYN]GtGtkyptptkIjwnYN]12] jbaudkrKkrwkrqwrw]pRjwDrqqbdyhApwrw] jbAwkrKkrqhokbhUM]qummYimlqdyhDrsBhUM]13] jyqybdnisRsitsBDwrY]AwpuAwpnIbUJaucwrY] qumsBhIqyrhqinrwlm]jwnqbydBydArAwlm]14] inrMkwrinRibkwrinrlµB]AwidAnIlAnwidAsMB] qwkwmUVHaucwrqBydw]jwkOByvnpwvqbydw]15] qwkOkirpwhnAnumwnq]mhwmUVHkCuBydnjwnq] mhwdyvkOkhqsdwisv]inrMkwrkwcInqnihiBv]16] AwpuAwpnIbuiDhYjyqI]brnqiBMniBMnquihqyqI] qumrwlKwnjwiepswrw]ikhibiDsjwpRQmsMswrw]17] eykYrUpAnUpsrUpw]rMkBXorwvkhIBUpw] AMfjjyrjsyqjkInI]auqBujKwinbhurricdInI]18] khUMPUlrwjwhÍYbYTw]khUMismitiBÎosMkriekYTw] sgrIisRsitidKwieAcMBv]AwidjugwidsrUpsuXMBv]19] Abr`CwmyrIqumkro]is`KaubwirAis`KsMGro] duStijqyauTvqauqpwqw]sklmlyCkrorxGwqw]20] jyAisDujqvsrnIpry]iqnkyduStduiKqhÍYmry] purKjvnpgpryiqhwry]iqnkyqumsMktsBtwry]21] jokilkoiekbwriDAYhY]qwkykwlinkitnihAYhY] r`CwhoieqwihsBkwlw]dustAirsttryNqqkwlw]22] ik®pwidRsitqnjwihinhirho]qwkyqwpqnkmohirho] ir`iDis`iDGrmosBhoeI]duStCwhCÍYskYnkoeI]23] eykbwrijnqumYsMBwrw]kwlPwsqyqwihaubwrw] ijnnrnwmiqhwrokhw]dwirddustdoKqyrhw]24] KVgkyqmYsrixiqhwrI]AwphwQdYlyhuaubwrI] srbTOrmohohushweI]dustdoKqylyhubcweI]25] sÍYXw] pWieghyjbqyqumryqbqykoaUAWKqrynhINAwnÎo] rwmrhImpurwnkurwnAnykkhYNmqeyknmwnÎo] isMimRiqswsqRbydsBYbhuBydkhYNhmeyknjwnÎo] sRIAispwnik®pwqumrIkirmYnkhÎosBqoihbKwnÎo] dohrw] sglduAwrkauCwifkYgihEquhwroduAwr] bWihghykIlwjAsgoibMddwsquhwr] [/gurbani] Read "Chaupaee Sahib" with full consentration, so, you would know what Guru jee is saying in this Gurbani. All Guru jee has asked is for safety and to ruin HIS enemies in "Chaupaee Sahib" and you think you are more intelligent than Guru jee by condemning demand of safety. ////// A rehitvaan singh will ask for the battle with evil not seeing the odds of making sense or not like Garja singh and Bota singh SHAHEED .Did you see their odds. ///// Your answer is in "Chaupaee Sahib". What are your views about Dasmesh jee after reading above Gurbani?

Re: How would you answer?

Bhopinder Singh · 28 Jan 2006

............. ji What can I say since I dont know who you are on the other hand you can see all my posts and even refer to them but ,I am used to such things since the death of Major Baldev Singh Ghuman the killers left a note owning the killing but their was no name except INA ,it was later established that the killer was Pappu cat and the letters were planed by GOI. Nowhere did I say I am or was millitant at the same time your praise of Punjab police seems intelligent .I lived in Punjab till 1990 as a sikh ,If the Indians didn't kill me bad for them .I still am talking about Khalistan not caring for odds or being assumed stupid by others else I could have posed as a very strict gursikh but out of sheer cowardice left the struglle for which so many men gave their heads.

Re: How would you answer?

Bhopinder Singh · 28 Jan 2006

................. ji I do not think Choupai Sahib is for physical safety because Guru Sahib seek att hee ran mei tab joojh maro so can never ever not even in dream would seek his physical safety. When sikhi is born by giving physical head so physical safety is not even a valid question. guru welcomes only who do not want physical safety jo to prem khelan ka chao sir dhar tali gali meri aao only thing guru sahib want is dolan te rakhon prabhu so that all the life live like a dead body jeevtiya mar rahiye and att hee ran mei tab joojh maro Choupai Sahib, please do not intrepret it to cover our own coerdice ================== Paatchahi 10, Kabieyo Baatj Benti Tjawpaai Style of poetry, humble request, by the 10th Guru. Hamrie karo’ haath dai ratja, Poeran hoje tjit kie itja. Tav tjarnan man rahai hamara, Apna djaan karo’ pratipara Please, be my support and protect me to fulfill my desire that my mind may stay attached to Your feet. Take me as your own and protect me. Hamre doest sabhai toem ghawhoe, Aap haath dai mohi batjawhoe. Soekhie basai moro pariwara, Sewak siekh sabhai kartara. Please, protect with Your hands and save me and finish ememies sex, anger, greed. attachment and ego (all real enemies). May my family (Khalsa Panth) be ever in peace and all these, servants and devotees of the Lord. Mo’ ratjha nidj kardai kanjai, Sab bairan ko aadj sanghrijai. Poeran hoje hamarie aasha, To’r bhadjan kie rahai pij aasa Be my support, and always protect me. Destroy all the enemies(ex, anger, greed, attachment, and ego), today. My wish of Your worship get fulfilled and thirst for Your worship get satiated (Quenched). Toemehie tjhaad kojie awar na dhijawaun, djo bar tjahon so toem te pawoen. Sewak sikh hamare taarijahi, tjoen tjoen satra hamare maanahi. I may not leave You and worship anyone else, That, I may get from You the boons I seek. The devotees Sikhs (disciples) that belong (Love) to You cross over the world-ocean . Pick up my foes and destroy them. (Sex, anger, greed, attachment, ego are the real enemies). Aap haath dai moedjhai oebarjijai, maran kaal ka traas niewarijai. Hoe djo sadaa hamaare patjhaa, srie asidhoedj karijo ratjhaa. Please, extend Your hand (help) and save me. Eradicate the fear of the time of death. May You ever be on my side – my support. My Lord, protect me! Raakh lehoe moehi raakh na haare, saahib sant sahaaje pijaare. Din bandh doestan ke hantaa, toem ho poerie tjatoer das kantaa. My savior Lord, protect me, Helper of the Saints, my dear God, Friend of the humble, destroyer of the wicked, You are the Master of the whole world. Kaal paajie Bramha bap dharaa, kaal paajie siewdjoe awtaara. Kaal paajie kar Biesan prakaasa, sakal kaal ka kiejaa tamaasa. By the Will of God, Brahma (the creator god) came into being. By the Will of God, Shiva (the destroyer god) was born. By the Will of God, Vishnu (the sustainer god) appeared. This all is the play of the Will of God. Djawan kaal djogie siew kiejo, beed raadj bramhajoe thiejo. Djawan kaal sab lok sawaara, namaskaar hai taahi hamaara. The Will of God that created Shiva the great Yogi, God Who created Brahma the physician. The Will of God that created the universe, I bow to that Lord! Djawan kaal sabh djagat banaayo, dew dait djatjhan oepdjaayo. Aad ant ekai awtaara, soye goeroe samdjhihoe hamaara. The Lord who created whole of the world, He Who created gods, demons and demi-gods, One Who is the Prime-Being, from the beginning to the end, Undestand that He is my Guru. Namaskaar tis hie ko hamaarie, sakal pradjaa djien aap sawaarie. Siwkan ko siwgoen soekh diejo, sattroen ko pal mo badh kieo. I bow to Him, To Him Who takes care of His all the beings (His Creation), He bestows on His devotees the god-like qualities and comforts. And, He destroys the enemies (Shortcomings) in a moment. Ghat ghat ke antar kie djaanat, bhale boere kie pier patjhaanat. lijietie te koentjarasthoela, sab par knpa drisht kar phoelaa. God knows the mind of everyone. He understands the pain equally of good or bad people. From an ant to a heavy elephant, He is pleased to look at everyone with His Kindness. Santan doekh paaje te doekhie, soekh paaje saadhoen ke soekhie. Ek ek kie pier patjhaanai, ghat ghat ke pat pat kie djaanai. If the saints are in pain, He feels it. When the saints are in comfort (Happy), He is comfortable (Happy). He understans the discomfort of everyone. God knows the state of every depth of each heart. Djab oedkarakh karaa kartaara, pradjaa dharat tab deeh apaara. Djab akarakh karat ho kabahoen, toem mai mielat deeh dhar sabahoen. When the Lord expands His Creation, Then, many types of living beings get created. When You dissolve (Destroy) everything, Then, all the living beings get absorbed back into You. Djete badan srist sab dhaarai, Aap apanie boedjh oetjaarai. Toem sab hie te rehat nieraalam, djaanat beed bheed ar aalam. All the living beings that get created, Each one praises You according to its understanding. But, You stay detached from everything. This is known to the Vedas, persons with deep knowledge, and to the scholars. Nirankaar nribikaar nirlambh, aad aniel anaad asaambh. Ta ka moerh oetjaarat bheda, djaa ko bhew na paawat beda. You are without a form, Pure-Being, and Self-Sufficient (Non-Dependant). You are Primal-Being, free from color (Unattached, Pure-Being), without a beginning, and without being born (Self-Created). And the fools talk of His mystries, Whose secret even the Vedas could not find. Ta kau kar paahan anoemaanat, mahaa moerh katjh bheed na djaanat. Mahadew kau kahat sada siew, nirankaar ka tj ienat nahi bhiw. They make a stone idol and take it as God. These unwise people do not know the difference between an idol and God. They call god Shiva the Immortal: God. He does not know the Truth about the Formless God. Aapoe apenie boedh hai djatie, barnat bhin bhin toehi tetie. Toemhra lakha na djaaye pasaara, kih bidh sadjaa pratham sansaara. According to the individual wisdom, They describe God differently. It is not possible to know the extent of Your Creation, That how the universe was created to start with. Ekai roep anoep saroepa, rank bhayo raw kahie bhoepa. Andadj djeradj setadj kienie, oetbhoedj khaan bahoer ratj dienie. You have one Form, but You adopt other unique forms as well. Sometimes You become a pauper, sometimes rich, and sometimes a King. He set up the methods of birth through eggs, placenta (womb), and sweat (dirt), And from the earth (way the plants produce), through these four methods the Lord brought about the Creation. Kahoen phoel rodja hai baitha, kahoen simit bhyo sankar ikaitha. Sagarie srisat diekhaji atjambhaw, aad djoegaad saroep soeyambhaw. At times He becomes a King sitting on the lotus: Brahma (The god of creation), At times He becomes Shiva (god of death), collects (destroys) His Creation and gathers it. He shows whole of the universe as His wonderful play, He Who has been since the time immemorial, since before the time-periods (Ages), and Who is Self-Created. Ah ratjha merie toem karo, sikh oebaar asikh sangharo. Doesht djiete oetwat oetpaata, sakal rnaletjh karo rann ghaata. Please, protect me now. Those who follow You (Khalsa Panth) save, and those who do not, destroy them. All the evil persons who come into being, Fight with (take care) and destroy all such bad people. Dje asidhoedj taw sarni parc, tien ke doesht doekhhit hwai mare. Poerakh djawan pag parc tihaare, tien ke toem sankat sab taare. O God, those who seek Your refuge, Their enemies die miserably. Those who surrender at Your feet, You remove all their afflictions - sufferings. Djo kal ko ik baar dhiyai hai, take kaal nikat nahi aihai. Ratjha hoje taahi sabh kaala, doest arist taren tatkaala. Those who ponder on God even once, Death does not go near them. (They stop fearing death). They always get Your protection. Their enemies and sufferings go away at once. Kripa drist tan djah nihariho, ta ke taap tanak mo hariho. Ridhe sidh ghar mo sabh hoojie, doesht thhaah tjhawai sakai na koie. Those to whom You see (consider) with mercy, In a moment You remove all their sufferings. Miracles descend at their homes: in their minds (Get the Blessings of God). And the evil persons cannot go near their shadows even. Ek baar djin toemai sambhaara, kaaiphaas te taah oebaara. Djin nar naam tihaaro kaha, daarit doest dokh te rahaa. Whosoever recites Your Name even once, You save him from the noose of death. Anyone who recited Your Name, He got saved from the poverty and wants, evil ones, and from those who bothered him. Kharag ket mai saran tihaarie, aap haath dai lehoe oebaarie. Sarab thaur mo hohoe sahaajie, doest dokh te lehoe batjaajie. Bearer of flag with the symbol of Sword (Protector: God), I have sought Your shelter. Please, help and save me from the fear of dhust and dhokhis and Kindly help the khalsa path everywhere and Save from the evils, and from those who bother. ============================= SO in essence, Choupai Sahib is a prayer to kept the fear of death finshed. Further, where ever it seems guru sahib want the physical protection as well, it is always for the entire Khalsa Path and never ever for the personal physical safety. aapna sir taa har velei hajar hona chaheeda hai so that jeevtei mar rahie. and when time comes att hee ran mei tab joojh maro Dharam sir detiyaan baajh nahi rehnaa [%sig%]