Re: ratoval shasters are graet!!!
Harcharan Singh · 21 Jan 2006
Mow Ji,
How can carbon steel be sarbloh? Carbon steel swords are exactly that - carbon (coals) added into melted steel. This is how the Japanese made the best swords in the world, with the added benefit of the number of times the steel was folded.
Does this mean that the "jatha" Singhs are not making Sarbloh kirpans?
Satnaam
Harcharan Singh
Re: ratoval shasters are graet!!!
I want a good kirpan · 21 Jan 2006
R these going to be available at the keertan darbar tonight at seven kings gurdwara, goodmayes?
thank you
Re: ratoval shasters are graet!!!
Harcharan Singh · 22 Jan 2006
Thank you for your kind comments Mow Ji.
With Waheguru's kirpa, I am generally in Chardi Kalaa. Please don't let yourself worry about my emotional balance.
I was under the impression this forum was to discuss Sikhi, I would go to a "Joke" forum if I wanted to have a laugh.
I was simply pointing out that the commonly understood translation of sarbloh (Iron) was not in line with your comment about the sword being a good quality carbon steel.
Iron is a pure element. Every atom in a chunk of iron is an iron atom. Iron is not as strong as people think.
Steel is better. To make steel, they melt down iron and mix in small amounts of other elements. There are different types of steel based on what they mix in and how much. Each type of steel has different advantages, such as stength, durability, chemical reactivity, and many other qualities. Typical elements that are added to iron to make steel include Carbon, Manganese, Silicon, Chromium, and Molybdenum. But most of the atoms of steel are still iron, because they only usually add in a small percent of other elements.
I was not discussing nor stating my opinion on sarbloh in any other context.
WROUGHT IRON: .00% to .04% (4 pts.) carbon, 3% silica.
Characteristics: soft, malleable, welds easily, resists burning in the forge, resists rust, when bent tends to stay bent.
STEEL: .04% (4 pts.) to 2.25% (225 pts.) carbon. Most modern steel runs from 20 point "mild steel" to 150 point "tool steel". Steel has a low silica content and usually various trace metals. In the period we are dealing with these trace metals were accidental. In the modern period they are intentional, creating various alloys for different purposes. Intentional or accidental, they will affect the performance of the steel, and ores containing different elements were used for different tools or weapons. Trial and error works even when you don't know why something works.
Characteristics: harder, less malleable, difficult to weld, easy to burn in the forge, rusts, tends towards springiness, shatters when over-hardened, cracks when worked at wrong temperature - all in proportion to its carbon content.
CAST IRON: Up to 8% impurities including 3.5% to 4.25% carbon, plus phosphorus, silica etc.
Characteristics: hard, brittle, non-malleable, casts in liquid form, heat resistant, withstands compression, rusts, doesn't weld at all. Cast iron is produced (in useable quantities) by high heat blast furnaces.
So here is the basic problem: wrought iron, available in classical and early medieval Europe, makes dandy door hinges but lousy swords. It won't hold an edge, it bends and deforms; it's actually worse than bronze. Cast iron, available in Asia because of the design of their smelting furnaces and the use of coal, won't work very well either. It is much too brittle. Only steel achieves the required balance of qualities, but there is no easy and sure way to smelt it in quantity.
Different weapons require different quanities of carbon. From my understanding quality swords carbon conteny varies from 30 to 90 points of carbon to steel.
My understanding is similar to "unreals" i.e. quality swords have high carbon content.
Guru Kirpa.
<<(()) ; - ) >>>
Harcharan Singh
Re: ratoval shasters are graet!!!
Charan Dhoori · 22 Jan 2006
MOW Bhai Sahib do you to pre-order the Kirpans or can you go the Rathowal and buy a Siri Sahib on the spot?
In regards with steel and sarbloh... a POSSIBLE solution for the pro-steal and pro-sarbloh people could be having a sarbloh (iron) kirpan with steel plating? What you think?
Re: ratoval shasters are graet!!!
LionKing (LK) · 22 Jan 2006
i read your posts and they always seem so negative you sound really miserable! why dont you just smile and be happy :)
*******
May'be cause we see them as negative. I.e Bhaji pumps comments about raag-kirtan, something some of us others arn't concerned about and naturally might see the posts as negative - I usually tend to see them knowledgable and informative.
Re: ratoval shasters are graet!!!
amarjeet singh · 24 Jan 2006
get sarbloh kirpans by buying propa sarbloh nd give it 2 some1 2 make