Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Groups

Groups

a question · 24 Apr 2003

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh Why is it that now a days we classify people, as they like to classify themselves? For example, my friend is "akj," and she is proud of the "AKJS." Its like your making cults of the religion of Sikhism. The term Akj is the equivelant of Akhand Keertan Jatha; I can understand that. But, seriously whats up with "akj amrit." Is it not understood that amrit is all of one kind?. Aren't we all just the same?-I mean, if we have all taken amrit, then doesn't that make us a Sikh and or Khalsa?

Re: Groups

ha · 24 Apr 2003

Amrit is the same. There is only one amrit, naam amrit. It's inside us. Gurbaanee tells us this. However, the method of partaking khanday dee pahul differs within the panth. This is unfortunate. It would be politically correct to say it's all the same, but that isn't the case. There are differences and the effect on the individual could aslo be different. I remember a few years back, someone I know wanted to take khanday dee pahul at Ross Street Gurdvara in Vancouver. The granthee there was going to be leading the panj. He had just recently been thrown out of the panth by the Akaal Takht. It was also known locally that he indulged in some other nasty, non-sikh habits, that would disqualify him even as a sikh. So would taking pahul from those panj have the same effect? Would Guru Saahib perform his miracle there? Was it valid? I personally wouldn't question anyones 'amrit' (except in extreme cases like that) as it is guru saahibs kirpaa but there are differences.

Re: Groups

khalsa · 24 Apr 2003

You are right. There truely is only ONE amrit. That Amrit is given to you by Guru Sahib through Panj pyaarey. As long as the panj and amrit sinchaar is following rehit and gurmat then you cant go wrong. Its a shame ppl have labeled "akj amrit", instead of AMRIT. There is only ONE amrit. and there is only ONE khalsa rehit. Guru sahib knows the rest....

Re: Groups

Khalsa Soulja · 24 Apr 2003

when u take the so called "akj amrit" the panj will tell you the kakkar is keski rather than kes. all amrit is the same, it is termed akj amrit because you take it from singhs who believe a particular set of things, just like taksaali amrit, where they say no meat, but no keski, or "normal" amrit as by sgpc maryada, where u are free to do only 5 banis a day, no keski, even eat meat if u want.

Re: Groups

sangh · 24 Apr 2003

Take amrit love life...As Sant Baba Jaranil Singh Khalsa Bhinderwale Dadmami Taksal (The 13th Jathedar..who's on vacational leave) stated, the whole process of wondering "WHO'S AMRIT SHOULD I TAKE?!?!" is interily man matt as amrit can only be given by punj pyare.

Re: Groups

aq · 24 Apr 2003

wjkk wjkf Amrit is one- this concept is understood by many. But, why the different rehat maryadas? Of course, people have a different perspective of seeing things, but shouldn't we just follow the rehit maryada issued by the Akal Takht at this point?

Re: Groups

khalsa · 25 Apr 2003

If i were to follow the marayda issued by Akaal Takht..then i would be a bujjar krathi...ie NO amrit left in me (no more amritdari) Eating meat = no more amrit

Re: Groups

aq · 25 Apr 2003

Are you saying you eat meat? No rehit maryada allows anybody to eat meat and of course it is a bujjar kurehit.

Re: Groups

R2D2 · 25 Apr 2003

amrit is one. Rehat's are many. AKJ amrit or any OTHER jatha's amrit is not superior.

Re: Groups

Kulbir Singh · 25 Apr 2003

First of all, there is only one amrit. There is either real amrit or fake amrit. If proper maryada is not followed, the Khalsas doing sewa are not keeping rehit, are not naam abhyaasi, or if there is not Laridaar saroop of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee present during amrit sinchaar, then such amrit does not seem to be real amrit. The question is not of AKJ Amrit or Taksaal Amrit. Whether it is Taksalis who do amrit sinchaar or Jatha Singhs, if proper maryada is followed, then that is the true amrit. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Groups

Singhnee · 25 Apr 2003

Waheguru jee kaa khalsa!! Waheguru jee kee fateh!! Amrit is ONE, there's no dout about it. I took Amrit from taksaal in 1985 and then went to India and got pesh at Akaal Takhat Sahib because I took off my siri Sahib in plane. Both times Two pyaaras out of punj gave me Amrit. Is't the manyaada of Amrit to take amrit from punj??? And my saroop was same like muslim bibi. No dastaar, wearing salwaar suit and gutt behind. We all know Guru Sahib made khalsa's appearence Niaara. I took Amrit and people were questioning if I was muslim. I think the main reason for problems our panth having today is that we are not following what our Guru Sahib told us to do. "JAB LAGG KHALSA REHAY NIAARA, TAB LAGG TEJ DEEO MAI(n) SAARA" Bibies from all religions before sikhi were wearing salwaar-kameez, saari or ghaghra and having gutt or jooRa behind. Then what's niaarapan after having Amrit??? Rehatnaamas says Amrit panchan to(n) laina. How many are there who took amrit from punj??? There are punj pyaaray who prepare amrit but only two or sometimes only one pyaara gives amrit to abhilaakhies. How you can say you took amrit from punj then. Finally, in 1995 Guru Sahib did kirpa and I got amrit from punj pyaaray in the presence of REAL GURU SAHIB SIRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE NOT MAN MADE PADD SHADE SAROOP. belive me there's a big defferece when you take amrit from rehatvaan punj pyaaray in presence of aslee saroop of Guru sahib jee(LaRidaar Saroop). So amrit is one but it all depends on maryaada the punj follow. Waheguru jee kaa khalsa!! Waheguru jee kee fateh!!

Re: Groups

Sawa Lakh · 25 Apr 2003

>>>>>>>>>REAL GURU SAHIB SIRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE NOT MAN MADE PADD SHADE SAROOP>>>>>>>>> I totally agree with "Singhnee" who are we to carry out this manmat of making the saroop padched. Guru sahib did what he did for a reason and we go around changing that because we are too lazy to learn how to do paath properly and don't want to spend time with santhiya. it is very sad. Yes and I also got peshed at an amrit sanchar where there was no larivaar saroop and then i got peshed at one where there was larivaar saroop. I also felt an incredibly huge difference. big difference ... ofcourse there would be i mean guru sahib was not present at the amrit sanchar with pad ched saroop. I think the reason the panth is in such pathetic shape is directly caused by this dhil in panth. And the worst part is that people who carry out this manmat will yell and scream at others for doing parkash of larivaar saroop... when they are the ones who went against guru sahib's hukam in the first place and decided they know more bout welfare and parchaar of sikhi then guru sahib does. Rest guru sahib knows. as you can tell i feel very strongly about this issue. bhul chuk maaf