Re: Marrying an amritdhari?
Sher Khalsa · 17 Jan 2006
no u wouldnt
Re: Marrying an amritdhari?
Shaktishali Sha Soora · 18 Jan 2006
VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKEFateh
If you're saying that the female could be brought to your family first after marriage and then she'll take amrit. That is a wrong move. I completely understand her point of view but if she really wants to make a change and undergo the life of a Khalsa then she’ll have to abide by the Gurbani line stated below:
jo tho praem khaelan kaa chaao ||
If you desire to play this game of love with Me,
isru Dir qlI glI myrI Awau ]
sir dhhar thalee galee maeree aao ||
then step onto My Path with your head in hand.
iequ mwrig pYru DrIjY ]
eith maarag pair dhhareejai ||
When you place your feet on this Path,
isru dIjY kwix n kIjY ]20]
sir dheejai kaan n keejai ||20||
give Me your head, and do not pay any attention to public opinion. ||20||
Whenever it comes to religion public opinion will come in the way to destroy the religion within a person, as even relatives and family have lost love for their own if that person is religious.
bhaaee ba(n)dhhee haeth chukaaeiaa ||
There is no love, even among brothers and relatives.
Moreover, if you did make that move you would loose your own Amrit, as already stated by so many on this phorum Amrit Sanskaar comes first before Anand Sanskaar, as Anand Sanskaar is the second step after both the individuals have given their head to Guru Jee in Amrit Sanskaar. After this is done the individuals are then going to give their life to Guru Jee together through anything into the full practice of rehit – this is performed in Anand Sanskaar.
The Anand Sanskaar isn’t one bit valid or even lucid without taking Amri Sanskaar at first. In the past Anand Sanskaar wasn’t ever performed for a non-amritdaree as it was compulsory for that individual to be initiated in Amrit Sanskaar first.
saadhh sa(n)gath gur shabadh sun kapatt sanaeh karan baethaalae||
Even listening to the word of the Guru in the holy congregation those who do not keep any discipline, move around like ghosts.
Finally, this discipline mentioned in Gurbani is to abide by the rehit, which is received by Panj Piarey in Amrit Sanskaar but not even this, as discipline is also a act of humbleness which is to listen to the Saadh Sangat in advice concerning Sikhi.
Guru Gobind Singh Jee would most defiantly advise this move to be taken, as even he took amrit himself to stabilize the foundation of a Khalsa, so that every Sikh may also take Amrit as the first step.
If the bibi does have strength in Sikhi and does only care about Sikhi then she will, with her head up high take Amrit first without doubts of the concern of a Manmukh, as then will she be untouchable and will not waver one single morsel at all after the Anand Sanskaar. In order to be accepted by Guru Jee sacrifices have to be made, as this is the natural law in Sikhi; Vaheguru Jee tests a Sikh more then anyone else but don’t take this as a bad thing but as the true and strong love that Vaheguru Jee has for his Sikh.
VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKEFateh
Re: Marrying an amritdhari?
Shaktishali Sha Soora · 18 Jan 2006
VahegurooJekaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh
Bhai Sahib 'sumone' Jeeo the amrit taken from the AKJ has nothing to do with the name but the rehits and the Kakaars given in there, as even Guru Gobind Singh Jee commanded Bhai Rama Singh Jee to take amrit from the Panj Piarey that give Keski and not Kes as a kakaar. If Guru Gobind Singh Jee said this that means there's a massive significance in this Amrit than any other.
This is the truth whether you want to believe it or not. I personally think that any other Amrit besides AKJ daa isn't Amrit Sanskaar.
VahegurooJekaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh
Re: Marrying an amritdhari?
Harcharan Singh · 18 Jan 2006
Can I just say that I thought Akaal Takht maryada was the authority on the Sikh code of conduct and not AKJ? Even Damdami Taksaal and Budda Daals maryada is in line with Akaal Takht on the kesh issue.
Personally I don't see the problem, Kesh is compulsory no matter what.
In history, Sikh women have or haven't worn keski's its a personal choice.
There is no way that Sikhs are ever going to unite or achieve anything as long as they keep on insisting themselves better than others.
If the Bibi has taken Guru Ji's amrit from the Panj Pyare and has recieved gurmanter and moolmanter, then she is Guru Ji's Khalsa.
As for the naam dhri problem, either ask her to recieve AKJ pesh or do your naam dhri separately, no big deal. You can still do simran and kirtan together, and all other aspects of life should be fine.
Without keski, she can do Kirtan with you in sangat also, as long as it is not AKJ, there are many other Khalsa sangats that you can attend and be part of. Just because you have taken amrit from AKJ does not mean that you have signed your life to them. Of course you have taken vows, and must now adhere to them, but that is directed towards yo only.
You should only bear allegiance to Guru Gobind Singh Ji and his Khalsa. If you wish to be in the company of a particular jathaa that is your choice, it is not necessary, as long as you are keeping Khalsa sangat.
Sat Sri Akaal
Harcharan Singh
Re: Marrying an amritdhari?
akj is akj is akj · 18 Jan 2006
hmmmmm
i think he means any amrit sanchaar which doesnt give the correct rehit isnt an amrit sanchaar,
like giving kes as the 5th kakaar or allowing 3 bani nitnem, or not giving naam drir.
which is still pretty similar to saying only akj is propa :-)
but akj are pretty great
Re: Marrying an amritdhari?
Shaktishali Sha Soora · 18 Jan 2006
VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVaheguroojekEFateh
Thank YOU, Bhai Sahib 'akj is akj is akj' you're completely right. If the Kakaar isn't held within the Amrit Sanskaar how can it be the true Amrit, as only, whenever Guru Gobind Singh Jee says to take amrit he expected the Amrit to be like the first time but the rehits given in the Amrit Sanchaar were changed by the Goraa in the past.
Thats why Bhai Sahib 'Lol' Jeeo I wrote that post in the beginning because the Amrit the bibi has taken isn't the true amrit.
KESKI IS THE KAKAAR, five banis have to read at amritvela and one has to jap naam, Sarbloh bebek and the rest.
VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVaheguroojekEFateh
Re: Marrying an amritdhari?
amrit is amrit · 18 Jan 2006
so were people like Jarnail Singh Khalsa Bhindrawale , Baba Thakur Singh, not Gursikhs?
akj has only been around since bhai randir singh from what i no but my knowledge is limited
why such a fuss over akj being best n others not?
i'm not an amritari but i'm sure if the Gurus are looking down they must b finking what a idiot.. just becuz one has taken akj amrit does not make him better what are the 5 sins? i'm sure ego is one of them??
Re: Marrying an amritdhari?
Shaktishali Sha Soora · 19 Jan 2006
VahegurooJekaKhalsaVahegurooJekEFAteh
Bhai Sahib 'amrit is amrit' Jeeo if Guru Jee really thinks where all idiots then why did Guru Jee, not tell but command Bhai Rama Singh Jee to take Amrit from the Panj Piarey that give out Keski as a Kakaar and not Kes.
After this post lets just drop this old debate.
VahegurooJekaKhalsaVahegurooJekEFAteh
Re: Marrying an amritdhari?
Shaktishali Sha Soora · 19 Jan 2006
VaheguroojekaKhalsaVaheguroojeKeFateh
Bhai Sahib '88' Jeeo forgive me, as I wasn't thinking about any ones feelings and to whoever elses feelings I've hurt I'm sorry. Be good my children, lol.
VaheguroojekaKhalsaVaheguroojeKeFateh
5 Kakaar
Harcharan Singh · 20 Jan 2006
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh
Could an educated Sikh please shed some light on the following specific question:
Are there any references to the Panj Kakaar in the following texts, and if so what do they say:
1. Gurdas, Bhai, Varan
2. Jaggi, Rattan Singh, ed., Bansavalinama
3. Kuir Singh, Gurbilas Patshahi 10
4. Bhangu, Ratan Singh, Prachin Panth Prakash.
5. Santokh Singh, Bhai, Sri Gur Pratap Suraj Granth
6. Bhalla, Sarup Das, Mahima Prakash
7. Gian Singh, Giani, Panth Prakash, Patiala
8. Sukha Singh, Gurbilas Dasvin Patshahi, Patiala
Satnaam
Harcharan Singh
Re: Marrying an amritdhari?
Kookar TERE Darbaar · 20 Jan 2006
Don't want to sound rude or anything, but hasn't this topic gone "off-track"?
Poor guy was asking for guidance and instead we have ended up in an argument amongst ourselves. Some of the replies sound like that they haven't even read Ksingh's original post and what is situation is.
Just food for thought. Hope no-one takes offense.
To ksingh bhaji:
Bhai Sahib the girl is Amritdhari so great! You get along with her and to the sounds of it you she will be a good prospective "Jeevan-Saathi" (life companion) and provide you with Sangat in this journey of becoming ek man ek chit (One) with Waheguru.
In regards to Keski. Sadly, generally in the Panjabi community, ladies who Keski and adorn themselves in the Khalsa's image are seen in odd way. Just recently I went to some relatives house and one the old ladies (from India) said [i]"O my God! You see ladies at the Gurdwara who have taken Amrit and they tie their Joora at the top of their head and wear Paghs (turbans).... I think they are trying to look like the men. It looks silly and ridiculous and there's no need."[/i]
I felt insulted and annoyed at this elderly bibi's comment. However, it was good that I didn't have to reply to her. Instead my dad, who is cuts his hair and is a mona, he replied. Waheguru! He said, [i]"What you said is TOTALLY WRONG. THey are following rehat. You shouldn't insult the Khalsa and Guru Gobind Singh jee. Those women who wear Keski and Dastaar deserve respect and look more Amritdhari and Guru's daughters than normal ladies." [/i]
Sat Naam. The elderly Bibi ended in apologising for what she said and said she didn't know that it was Rehat. And once she realised that I wanted to marry a SinghNee who tied a Keski she felt even more worse. Poor lady. But at least she found out about Rehat and realised that ladies who adorn themself in Khalsa image deserve respect and support.
Bhai Sahib please search for "Interview with Bibi Amarjeet Kaur" (Shaheed Bhai Fauja Singh's wife). Before Bibi jee married Bhai Fauja Singh jee, she didn't wear a Keski. She only started wearing it just before they got married.
I suggest that if both of you agree. Your wife can start to wear Keski just before you get married... perhaps start from the Engagement day (if that's before the wedding). And in regards to Naam DriR she can always go pesh to Panj Piyare whenever the next Amrit Sanchaar is.
Last point, it would be easier for both of you if she starts wearing Keski before you get married. Starting marriage and then trying to fulfil these promises sometimes lead to unfulfilled promises. And God knows, but she could say I have change of heart.
Note: For those reputing Amritdhari should wear Keski (turban) as part of Rehat and thats it not in line with Sri Akal Takhat Sahib Maryda, please read this:
[URL=http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=56430&t=56430]The Sikh Rehat Maryada & Wearing Keski[/URL]
Re: Marrying an amritdhari?
Dhiyalang Saroopae · 20 Jan 2006
* Bhai Sahib 'amrit is amrit' Jeeo if Guru Jee really thinks where all idiots then why did Guru Jee, not tell but command Bhai Rama Singh Jee to take Amrit from the Panj Piarey that give out Keski as a Kakaar and not Kes. *
Veerji, Baba Harnaam Singh Jee of Rampur Kherae is also known to have darshan of Guru Gobind Singh Jee numerous times. Yet there is no mention of Keski being the Kakaar by him...and FYI his Rehit was more in line with DDT.
You're basically saying that because someone's Panj don't label Keski as the Kakaar that they're Amrit is invalid? So basically all the countless Gursikhs that are not part of AKJ are in fact fooling themselves? I think your views are extremely narrow when it comes to this issue. I understand you have beliefs, but you're basically insulting everyone who does not believe Keski as a Kakaar and saying that their Amrit Sanchar ceremony was nothing but a farce!
It's a good thing that I don't judge myself according to what AKJ thinks, or I might start thinking that Sikhi is AKJ and AKJ is Sikhi. When we both know that's not the case.
vaheguroojeekakhalsavaheguroojeekeefateh!
Re: Marrying an amritdhari?
Shaktishali Sha Soora · 20 Jan 2006
VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVaheguroojeKeFateh
Nice post Bhai Sahib 'Dhiyalang Saroopae' Jee and again sorry for the insults Veer Jee. I admit I was wrong, as I hope you and the rest that were hurt can forgive me.
VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVaheguroojeKeFateh
Re: Marrying an amritdhari?
harpreet singh · 21 Jan 2006
took a lot of guts to admit ur mistake shaktishali sha soora
good man
Re: Marrying an amritdhari?
Dhiyalang Saroopae · 21 Jan 2006
Nice post Bhai Sahib 'Dhiyalang Saroopae' Jee and again sorry for the insults Veer Jee. I admit I was wrong, as I hope you and the rest that were hurt can forgive me.
thank you for showing the humility that you have. Hopefully, Guru Sahib blesses me with the same humility...
PYAAR NAAL...
wahegurujeekakhalsa
wahegurujeekeefateh
Re: Marrying an amritdhari?
Gurukaiashq · 22 Jan 2006
Gurfateh
Marry her and have a happy Gursikh life, always do ardaas for Gursikhi Jeevan Jaach...it will go a long way.
"NANAK AMRIT EK HAEEE"